0:00 / 0:00
Zionism #34- Satmar Zealotry if ideological isn't Torah sanctioned, rather another unhealthy "ism"
82 views
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
so we're here
finishing off the Monica letter that we
started probably two to three months ago
and uh in Mr Shem my tomorrow we will
finish it
and
um
and then start learning a minor next
week
this is the point where the bio was
talking to this
[Music]
who had all kinds of kindness arguments
and complaints against labovitch and
against
and slowly but surely dispels each and
every one in a very methodical logical
way
and although on some of the points you
know one can argue with the eczema
Indian with the the issue itself but not
with the way
were spinning it I think that's what's
very more important than
then the issues itself whether they are
good the sarsa in this or not zionists
and whether you know all of those things
I think he I mean I think he he
presented a very very logical solid
argument to many of things with proofs
from foreign and everything else but
nevertheless
you know
[Music]
um
Tita is is open to
argumentation in a respectful way
difference of opinion but the the the
real issue that that Rabbi wants to kind
of knock out from these um from from the
the the sadness the the approach
that they have towards scientists and I
think if that's all we walk away with
then we have accomplished that we
shouldn't have a sinner
a hatred towards a yeet
you can hate their shita but not hate
the individual
and unfortunately
the the the the the the attitude of of
some of these people that are that abuse
writing to is that they mix the two
together not only do they
say and believe that the shita is at the
courses is evil and bad but they say the
individual is evil and bad and to that
he quotes hit the river and the outer
lab and others for him not just khabots
for him it's one going back way before
Chabad way before cities
that you have to separate the two yes
the sins will be eradicated from the
Earth but not the sinners
and this is necessary
and to remember and and even though many
times it's very difficult it's very
difficult
to
differentiate to to to separate the
person from the ACT
because it's they're so closely related
even in in in the sweater including
The Miser of the other the act of man
on one hand is completely separate from
who man is right
who the man is their mind their mind and
their heart
their actions their behavior
so the behavior are you going to say
their behavior is who they are no
but nevertheless
their behavior touches a place within
the soul that's even deeper than Seiko
lamidos and by the way that was the
Tanya that we learned over Shabbos
chapter 4 and Tanya well to them but
says an amazing thing there that
delivers him the tools and instruments
or what he calls the garments the
levusim of thought speech and action are
more united touched deeper within the
nephesh than the circular meters
and if we have to put you know translate
that into
Daily Language and conversation Hillel
it means that behavior
of how you behave with your thoughts and
how you behave with your speech and how
you behave without with your action
touches deeper God than my mind and my
heart
and that's that's a that's a very
revolutionary statement but that's what
he says in chapter four and Tanya if you
didn't pick that up I really urge you to
reread it and read lessons in Tanya
which should clarify that for you with
good explanations especially the last
volume the last new addition that's uh
on the apps of lessons and Tanya they
rewrote it in a in a much better way
so so how do you reconcile the two
the answer is
that the answer is that true behavior is
not man it's not it's not man but
Behavior touches a chord that's deeper
than man I.E is God
so if we if we if we if we follow this
line of thinking Jameson what we
understand from this is that the way you
behave
is whether you're godly or not godly
instead of y'all says
without saying the words that I just
said he sang to the sacrament the way
you're applying your hatred towards the
zionists is not God it's not the
approach of Jewish of Judaism of theta
in other words the message is right the
deliverer and the way you're delivering
it is awful
because the message of whether it's a
Zionist or a heretic kaifer or someone
in that category in those categories
are wrong yeah that's what the title
says as we discussed the whole time but
the question is the application and
abuel says that the rabbit taught us
that ever taught us to approach everyone
regardless whether they learned in
Yeshiva or they were in a Buddhist camp
or they didn't know anything regardless
approach if they're a yeet approach them
that they're a yeed and just focus on
their Yiddish guide and their pristine
the Shama
and and if you focus on that you'll have
mercy on them and and including you have
mercy on the software who hates Jews
you'll have mercy on them too
you understand
you know people make this is just for
another moment people make this mistake
that if I see them like this and Jews
Like This who who have this
understanding and this attitude of when
it comes to our own
they don't have the same feelings and if
you find anyone like that they're not
connected
that they're not on the right page
there's no different and I and I saw
this and and I think you saw it with the
red but really you look there's
thousands of clips of people going by
the rib take a look how he doesn't have
any difference of an attitude towards a
guy who comes with a strimel and
appeared from Renee broccoli or she'll
like him with all of his stuff
or a guy who comes and brings him you
know books and and even sometimes at the
courtship books and things like that
when he needed to make a point that you
know this is a yoshka book and don't
give it to me they threw it away or when
the litter came from today Brock and he
and he was a sincere but nevertheless he
communicated a message of of antagonism
against Lubavitch that ever let him have
it the devil wasn't a pushover
give this guy Judaism we're not
pushovers they were pushovers we better
go back to school grade school and learn
all of days again
the Commodities that it's a gamara good
morning
says every Jew must have
ashwini's of gaiva every two including
assadic
why because if you make yourself into a
coupon an addresses which means a um
if you step over you know when you come
into the door you step over the what's
it called whatever it's called
right you step over
threshold threshold thank you doormat
doormat thank you
no
we don't that's not that's not Yiddish
kite but at the same time
how do you apply that
so the it all boils down to the
application the behavior The Miser and
if you and if you apply it properly with
love and real genuine concern for
another person including including the
guy who was who is
arguing to complaining against the
Babbage with all this with the same
attitude
then then you're I'll tell you the Jew
you really irritated you and if not
nothing may you know you know you're
just operating on your own you want to
operate your own sometimes you get it
right and sometimes you get it wrong but
if you go to the Messiah and you go with
the attitude
and you see Taco just remind myself
right
they're all they love their Remy but
they fought and they died
there's a room for a beard and not a
beard and we're both the same
you know
um
over the weekend in Miami I saw someone
came in from New Yorkers beard was all
grown out of big beards he comes from a
real about the Trump for whatever reason
he didn't have a beard he's like 55
years old almost 60. so I say to him so
and so hey
he said I'll tell you I'll tell you what
happened
I was sitting in 770 with you know for
bringing and there was an older house up
there
and he turned to me says all you have to
do is not touch not do anything
if you don't touch trim shave whatever
it grows
it says you don't have to do anything
most of the things you have to buy
Trillium you have to put on them azuzah
you have to be proactive your beard just
keep your hands off your face and your
beard grows
and you know what he told me it hit him
for some reason when I and others his
friends in yeshivi learned the Le papaji
Yeshiva I'm sure his friends came with
him about not having a beard as a
barbecue family from a spitz kebab
trust me his family was very unhappy I'm
sure they didn't have a beard right
nothing changed him he sits by if I
bring him and one guy says to him all
you have to do is just keep your hands
off and not touch it doesn't say more
and he told me it just clicked and
decided I'm not touching my beard and
he's letters and he lets us and he let
his facial hair grow and he has this big
beard
it's all in how you say things it's all
in the other the other when our hazal
say the opposite slow is the key to
relationships and the key to to growth
it's kipshota it's
so that's what we're on now this section
the last part of the the letter when
Abdul says on page the left we went last
time versus
and and and we insert the doctors here
with us and he gave us the dogma of the
doctor the doctor tells a patient you're
not well you have to eat your Kippur
patient says I'll die first before he
killed Kipper I haven't ate Yom Kippur
65 years of my life if I have to eat
them keep her I might as well die
you know the title says you're going
against Hashem
very nice that you have this feeling and
you'll get a big star for it we'll give
you a big medal for wanting to die
rather than eating your Kipper but what
a doctor tells you that if you don't
even careful you're going to become sick
and it's picklefish you have a tighter
obligation to eat onion Kipper you know
why because that's the rocks in Hashem
because the doctor of wrapping it up is
giving that kayak and if he acts like a
doctor Appiah Shem then that means
that's what God says you my friend have
to eat this Yom Kippur
and your feelings you keep to under your
Talus when you make a husband of what's
going on
and like I told you the hustle who told
me in 1980s based on was it was a
Russian gee that came there to throw
what's his name
so he told me that he never wrote him a
letter and that ever wrote Rabbi
so-and-so when he went into the first
time after he came from Russia so he
said to the dead but the Russian didn't
exceeded me and they spoke openly they
said whatever what do you what do you
like what are you lying for I'm a rabbi
I'm no great man I'm a regular eat
and he said to them
I don't feel all these accolades and did
upset them and he repeated to me and I
repeated to you
feeling isn't it Kane moose feeling is
five words feeling isn't necessary you
feel you don't feel too bad if I'm
writing to you this is who you are then
I wouldn't say these words I'm
paraphrasing if I addressed you in a
certain way that's the way it is
so you do feel it you don't feel it no
and and this is one of the Geniuses not
not Geniuses wrong word one of the the
goggles of the rabbit the way you see
the way he he all of these you know
take a look just take a look you know
with the the that business the day Lynn
with with the Entourage and all that
stuff that ever spoke to you and look at
look at the clips
so Earthly so down to earth so
one-on-one to me it reminds me also when
I met the option of it ebb and by the
gun I felt like it was my best friend
even though he's this Avid Hashem the
Sadiq this epic yeah but his his
attitude and the way it was like I'm
talking with you guys now you know we
know each other we talked it
foreign
was trying to communicate in between the
lines in this entire letter is to the
satmer change your Paradise have a
paradigm shift and change your attitude
towards another Jew any Jew and
including yourself
including your own kids if you come down
and you say you're not doing it my way
or the highway
that's not Yiddish kite
that's not good it doesn't mean it
doesn't mean to say if the kid wants to
let's say smoke a shop it's the front of
your face to come to the table without a
yamaka you know listen
you know we always say like this what if
a non-religious person you met a month
on 47th through the Fifth Avenue
Manhattan or you met him race wherever
you met him right
and you invite him for a Shabbos
and he comes to you and he doesn't put
on a yamaka or a woman comes and she's
not so newer you're gonna throw him out
of the house
you're not gonna you're not gonna make
Kiddush you're not going to give them
color you're not going to say it but
I'll tell you you're not going to sing a
Megan you're not gonna right you are aha
so for them you have love
but for your own son or daughter or
friend who who was raised a certain way
and and and and doesn't follow yet or
right now that him you hate and who you
want to throw out and hanging
is that right is that right
at the same time negotiate a way that
there could be respect and and decency
in the house give them a room for
himself and I know parents will do that
if a son or a daughter is not you know
keeping Shoppers properly whatever the
case you know they say in your room
that's your room but outside you know
let's keep it civil and we keep it from
home I don't want to go into that right
now
you wanted to say something Johnny
two questions first of all no one was a
statement
you know why do these type of Jews do
this and this you know they look very
obviously obviously Orthodox and Jewish
why do they do such and such you know in
order and they would bring up some kind
of lesson whatever they don't talk
Russian heart but I'm just saying about
certain so my father would always say to
them don't confuse Judaism which Jews or
Jews with Judaism
it's it's
you know people are people okay
okay
right next thing
next thing
when the Revolution
was talking
about
um very interesting because this job is
we hosted a a couple couple that they
live now in Israel but he used to go
almost every Shabbos and a pair of yoil
every single Shabbos when he was a
buffer like when he was 20. now he's in
his 40s he told me a story about Rubio
he said that
it's actually about his wife he said the
rabbit he was one time in the in in the
supermarket in you know on Kingston
Avenue and
this this woman was there and he didn't
know who she was she you know and she
was backing all her bags and the apples
fell out of her bag
so we went to help her and he didn't
speak any English he was a Russian boy
the crane didn't speak you know any
Russian and in English very very little
and um he starts to pick up the apples
for her so he
at very little in English and then
she said to him
she said to him oh
um she was okay you don't have to speak
to me in English you can speak to me in
Russian they speak Russian and and then
she said to him
if you're new here right I didn't write
yeah no I'm I'm studying in the Yeshiva
by 770. so she said I want you to come
for Shabbos and he and he said that it
was very you know it was it didn't feel
comfortable because he doesn't know who
these people are he didn't know who
Rubio Khan was he didn't know who the
Robinson was you know but she but
basically when they made that connection
so they exchanged phone numbers and they
were persistent and he used to go every
shot this almost every shop is when he
was a buffer there he became very very
close why I'm telling why am I bringing
this up because what my thing is when
review is talking about
um oh and by the way another thing she
had an amazing Library she had an
amazing Russian life she had Tolstoy she
had all these things he said
unbelievable stuff like he was he didn't
grow up for him he grew up in Ukraine
and you know it was under communism so
he knew about all this stuff and he was
like he couldn't believe she you know
the amazing Library
interview amazing Russian library with
all both but the thing like when review
was bringing this up and he's speaking
specifically about software I'm assuming
because those were the encounters he had
was he referring to also the you know
the the raw types and and the literature
types the Lakewood types
also you know robotics didn't get a very
good act with these places
he keeps mentioning stop for summer but
I thought growing up in in Flatbush and
high in Berlin
it was just as bad okay so base the
answer is yes and no what do I mean the
overall discussions that we've we had
we've learned we've learned here are
true anywhere and everywhere but but you
know the the literature didn't snap them
whatever you you know they were at the
time you know the opponents they weren't
they weren't calling Chabad zionists
because they were more zionistic than
Chabad
so most of this argument here is about
Zionism so in that way I would say no
but the overall issue of looking at a
Jew and not looking down at a Jew that
applies to everyone let us learn now
okay
is
belief in God needs to be positive but
later you're not in a manner of
negativity let's see what he says
he says if I wouldn't be fearful of your
rights I would say
all all complaints against they come
from
it's not really because some think and
make the mistake that according to Allah
you're forbidden to be Makarov to bring
closer the the what they call the wicked
he says hey fellas let me tell you the
reason is the reason for their their
arguments their complaints is something
totally different The Who and that is
in order to bring close the Young
Generation should be strong and Tighter
and the fear of God and be saved from
the from the storm of evil Waters and
this generation
you have to give them something positive
and with great abundance the Hezbollah
to explain to them
what does Godless mean what does mean
you have to explain to them
not only your general Divine Providence
but every detail has to find Providence
have music the concept
the actors Hashem the unity of God
there's nothing else besides God's
and when we permeate in the youth all of
these ideas
dispels much darkness and in a manner
the darkness will automatically be
dispelled because of the light that's
been brought into the room and into
one's life
the light doesn't have to battle with
the darkness
when there's light
involved the darkness is dispelled
automatically um
and since all of these Concepts that we
just mentioned
potatoes are explained very well in
there foreign
in most immaturity of groups
and that they don't learn about cities
and they're missing these ideas
right
because these ideas are explained at
length and kabad cities
with the Youth of these groups
are caught partially in in um
false philosophies
upon him in a very refined way very in
the hottest but foreign and we shouldn't
elaborate them painful things
bikini let's continue we haven't
finished the thought but in the group of
satbers
they don't teach their youth hasidus but
itself
they have to give something to their
youth is it true for a pillow
to they give them a pill to fight the
the wave of heresy what's away to they
came up with a with a solution Allah in
quotes in in quotations
[Applause]
we give our students cities explaining
Divine properties etc etc what do they
give their kindness if you're a kanoi
your ass is a good one right
and by and through in the sacrament by
them educating their own Young
Generation literally to
screaming that's Innovation so when you
created it's heresy God forbidden there
because they have to fight against it is
awesome this impacts them that they
should guard their soul because
like an arrow you know the the arrows
the bow and arrow because distance
yourself far away from any new idea
therefore they've been raised this way
to to the canoes with celery canoes or
vasaka and to scream are called over
Hunter should create anything that's new
and an Innovative is create a heresy you
know how to deal with it since they've
become so accustomed to do this and to
be trained this way and live this way
for years in Mahine they don't
distinguish Benjamin between the right
with smile to the left the gamma called
and therefore even things that
explicitlyn
um skip the parentheses shallow your
super dancer that wasn't done in the
previous
dollars on the last line because there
was no need or the idea didn't exist
sorry again they screamed from krita
then we have to oppose it next page
the cell yesterday
this is the libuscus I find Merit and
those that have the argument
that evil chapter 3 was a great scholar
right so so
so they they they they argue looking you
guys are might be big philosophers and
you understand God and you talk about
Divine Providence and actors
and you understand and you're able to
explain well we had a guy named chapter
three and he was also a great lambd and
a great scholar and look what he did
Allah
says after
finding Merit that the satma are just
following are following in the way of of
of of the shop that's V and and don't
want to follow in his way but yes
I I humbly advise them not to not just
to give their youth a negative idea
kanois of which is zealotry to hang on
to and to use as their tool to keep them
strong Jews and strong hasidim
[Music]
it's not only enough to to uh deny the
uh Idol called Baal but you have to also
substitute it and give someone the moon
and Hashem in other words you deny the
idol but what have you given in exchange
discussed this earlier we have to give
them the in exchange the belief of God
and base
even regarding this third idea of
symmetry Kasha
is lacking and missing the positive
aspect of belief in God and
understanding God aside
then it's very possible that zealotry
itself will be transformed from Holiness
to an ideology ADL means ideology well
the Indian show my flag will become a
party line
that's not based on Toyota for us
and then the zealotry itself
become ideological and party like
Vegas like all like all like all other
um ideologies of many parties
in order for me to clarify this I'm I'll
give you two examples look from Olive
one
and cracks off the little between I
wrote earlier the Ayla Manchester United
those amongst the staff who don't want
to listen to what's written clearly
because
it doesn't fit into their zealotry
ideology
this shows them that their zealotry Aina
means Hashem it's not true zealotry of
God
perspective Ella it's kanois have you
said this is their own generated and
decided in zealotry based on their own
decisions
because it's comparable to the love of
religious groups
which is also not true average
Israel based on an ideology
them that human beings you know decided
through their heart that they decided
this is obviously slow to have an orange
that you say there is love for another
person therefore we're going to add an
orange to the Seder that's my own my own
spin in other words I love everybody so
therefore we're going to end you want to
love everyone love everyone what because
I've never spoke about adding an arms to
the Savior but you decide that the way
to to implement well for everybody is to
have an orange that you say there
it's the same thing as creating your own
zealotry ideology and hating Jews
he says
the foundation the primary Foundation
that everything has to be based on is
the player
um
so the fact that we have to be both a
lover of Jews and at the same team Zelda
at the same time zealots who met Nations
it's because Taylor tells us Israel and
regarding obviously
for example avocation
but when I was Israel and the kanois
aren't based on the Toyota
then it's like any other foreign secular
ideology and it's not Jewish
yes
nobody you know nobody has a problem
without me there and made their heads
and we're gonna have they pull kids at
the Obama
which would help medical people that had
to be in the hospital in New York City
they would give us food me
you know
[Music]
the the cup the cover of my book called
satma labavage
hold on
this is the cover of the book do you see
the cover
you have a laborator putting on filling
with a policeman in 770
and then you have the Sacramento the
satinum bus and it says Holland
and what right this bus goes around
helping people for a bit because hold it
and I made this
as the cover
because sophomore emphasizes
hello