Zevachim 62

Today's is and we are about 15 lines from the bottom of the is going to continue to discuss the we learned in aid when the came from in the beginning of so they rebuilt the mikdash one of the things they rebuilt was the misbeh says the rebuild the with the exact dimensions that had had in the times of rather they added four to the and four to the gamma. So this is the third time that we had this gamma here in Rashi again says the gamma is like an end so like an L. So they added four amas to the dar side four amas to the side. Rashi tells us the rest of the story. The misbayak in the times of Malik was 28 amus by 28 amus being that they added four am to dim and four to so it comes out that the misbeh during bayeni was 32 am by 32 my time why did they do that because there wasn't enough space they felt that misbeh wouldn't be big enough all the carbonas that they were going to have to bring during bay on msbak That's 28 by 28. You saw in the previous daffin would result in a muk of 20 by 20. They felt the muk of 20 x 20 is not enough. They wanted it to be 24 by 24. The four extra that they added went straight to the bottom line. It went straight to the muk. And as a result, those four extra would allow them to facilitate the additional carbon that were going to be brought during heard said. And he told him, by it says you know how many there were during they were literally that are mentioned in the where promises of that Israel will be so plentiful literally like the grains of sand on the beaches of the world it became true that's how many Jews there were during bas and for that was 28 by 28 hours a that was 20 by 20 was enough. The second Bik says in the beginning of Ezra that when Cyrus the great gives the Jews permission to leave B and Persia to go up to and to rebuild the second base. So how many Jews heeded his call? It was 42,360 Jews. Was it not enough? So where were the more during bay was only 42,360. said, "How could you tell me that you needed a bigger a bigger told him over there?" And during it was the miraculous that had come down from the Gomorrah said remained until the times of mana. But you had this a shamayan and being that there was an asel shay it allowed the fire to consume the im much quicker as a result the turnover was faster you didn't need such a large you didn't have this you didn't have the it's for that reason that you needed a larger when they added this extension to the dur one of the things they did was they added these were holes on the top of that they used. They used to think meaning what happened before they added the before they added the there was a bar on the floor of the right next to the and they would pour the on the on the wall of the misb it would come down the wall eventually would go down into this bar this drain there was shin on the bottom of the ground and somehow that's how the may and the yen would leave the muk mikdash when they added this extension to the basan mikdash they didn't put a bar next to the mb but rather they put in the misbeh why would they have done that? What was the before and after? Meaning before during the thought was don't put the y and the in the msbak but let it just flow along the wall of the misb. Now they wanted to go into they thought that the had to be which sounds like it's with it's one solid piece of you can't have any there can't be any holes. Then they thought it over and they said you know what you find you find a concept of just like the maybe the it gets consumed by the itself. You don't put the on the itself actually consumes it. So too they thought the should be consumed by the misbeh as well. Thus they wanted it swallowed by the actual so now that they realize that doesn't mean to the contrary there's in it. So what does mean it means it should be attached to the ground itself and it shouldn't be built on arches or on top of tunnels. So it had to be built on top of solid ground either way. So the first base mikdash was 28 am by 28 am. Second B mikdash they added four Amish tora four amus to Dim as a result it was 32 A by 32 A why the change said they actually needed more space during bay sheni during bay even though there were much less Jews during bay sheni than the war during bayan but at the same time during bayish you had the which was some supernatural fire it had descended literally in the times of the again in the times This was some supernatural fire and it helped the consume theim much quicker during in heaven and therefore you had to make up for it by there being more space but says I realize I made a mistake and Rashid tells us a little bit of the rest of the story top line in Rashid was sick and he forgot his learning and then slowly slowly his came back to him and that's why you find very often in sh that he would say something and then he would remember oops I made a mistake and this is an example of that. So first thought that was the reason for the difference in size between the two but then he afterwards that's not the reason it's really based on a says the were involved in the construction of the second base they were meaning they realized how big the misbeh was supposed to be. The reason they made it four larger is because really it was supposed to be four armors larger as if to say who said the only thing he didn't understand was he made a mistake here too. He didn't know how big the was really supposed to be. He thought 28x 28. That's why he built it with those dimensions. But in reality it was supposed to be 32x 32. The knew that and that's why they built it a little bit bigger. But the says this is one of the important that repeat themselves that we know everything that was built in the mikd it was all done. So what do you mean didn't realize what the real size of the was supposed to be. It's not a question of you don't sit down with a and figure out how big the is supposed to be. It's something that's supposed to be done. Let me explain a little differently. It's really based on a say the compar just like the bias was 60 long after sold to the was able to be up to 60 long that the could be as big as the mik itself and just like the mik is 60 long the technically could be 60 long as well didn't know how to dash in this p the was the but like all there was an element of ambiguity and really it was incumbent upon the to be able to properly decipher what was said he was able to see in high definition but other couldn't and that's why there was always a lack of clarity when it came to so there was a pik that The question was what does that mean? Didn't realize that you're able to build a up to 60. Somehow he thought it was 28 came and they said you could extend it beyond. They decided to extend it four but really if you wanted to you could have extended it even further. One thing is clear in this we'll see more about it in the course of the d and that is that the dimensions of the is not because and the second was 28 in the times of was 32 if you remember in the previous was 5 by 5 was 10 by 10 the was one by one so there's different shim for the I mean these are all technically serving the same thing there. It's the misbeh it's the focal point of the aor of the it's it's used for the but as we'll see in the gor it's a so that the size of the isn't either way so they didn't come up the times of Ezra and they just received permission to rebuild the bdash they have to figure out now where to build everything so it says bias I understand how they knew where to build a Bikdash because they were able to see the surah. What does it mean says Rashi? They were able to see the of the original Bikdash and based on where the of the original Bikdash was, they were just going to build on top of it. So they're able to look underground, look at the foundation of the original Bikdash and based on that they'd be able to figure out where to build. But the MB didn't have a underground. There was no underground foundation to support the MSB. So how they know where the MSB is supposed to be said? What they saw was a built ms miraculously and the who the gar refers to as a was standing on the misbeh and he was bringing. So they knew that where that vision of was that's where you're supposed to build they saw the wherever they went in they smelled the but from that one area they smelled the so they realized that must have been the place where the were burnt that must be the Makham. So you're right. The way they knew it this was supernaturally. Either they knew it because they see they see this this marin of standing and and bringing carbon or they smell the of or they see the of regardless there were three that went up with the yidden from balance. These would be the last three Nim that the yidden would have. And who are they and as a matter of fact discusses we mentioned that brings in the beginning of it talks about the first mto is a little more ambiguous says the it talks about the third mik is there that talks about the second yes it's so they came with from bubble one of them was made that you could extend the like the we had earlier The other one told him where was supposed to be. And the third one said, "Whoa." So it comes out that it's says this is a riot to what I said in that very long. The is the reason we had a very short. the that goes from the top of the bottom of and that is that even the holds and that's why that holds throughout etc etc etc that is but when it comes to which is of course the raita this is of course the raita so the wrer tells the ra that I have no idea where you got this from that even know seemed to learn it in this we heard it from the so what's the question how could later start arguing we literally got a memo from that what happened to maybe we'll speak about that tomorrow but either way those were the three things that the said so there was one said that you could expand the from 28 to 32 really up the 60 Amnest that was the Masagar. The other one told us where the Mak was. They knew where the Makt was. They can base that off the foundation off the but the third one said this of why would it be so relevant they're about to build onto you have to know now right is that you need to know in g but when you're building the second mikd why would it be important probably is because when the yidden built the mikdash it took time and while they were building the b mikdash they able to bring carbon. So it was during that they were building the mikdash that it would have been if you remember the said that the whole and the whole is only when the building otherwise you have the either way there's a that said the same thing that there were three that told us three but this had a little differently I The first one was with regards to the number one you could expand the four and number two where the is the second one not the third one the second one was what was the third one that thera shouldn't be written anymore it should be written we spoke a lot about that in the second bar of the fact that the has to have corners. The fact that has to have a ramp, we know what that is. And that it has to be a perfect square. All those things are but the length the width and the height of the that's like we spoke out before you see there were different sizes of throughout history it says so sometimes when the Torah mentions elements of the it says not so Rashi says for example by the it says by the says by the it says and the face so to speak of the is the ramp of the point is that it says by certain elements wherever it says it's going to be the pictures that were on the side of the according to they should also So the Torah talks about the isb says it's these pictures. is referring to the and it says Hamzbe by the car and if you're going to tell me wherever it says Hambe it means that it's so the should also be now what's the according to it's this according to it's the but the bottom line is these things should also be the B says okay so you're going to tell me that according to those if they were the ones that were the author of this Bryce so they would have added the Gmorra says in the as a matter of fact the says on that day which day referring to a where there was a who was the and he went up to do but the didn't believe in so he may believe he was doing really he poured the water on his feet and they started pelting him with and because of that one of the corners of the broke they bu and they brought salt and they They they stuffed the hole but they didn't make it because in order to make it you would actually have to replace the Ken and there was no Karen just should have looked like the was how did you know they couldn't make it by just stuffing the hole? How do you know you need the Karen? So the price continues you have to have the Yeah. So he holds the was the and why are Karen why are those things because it says and by the it also says bottom line is in like the garra says yeah you're right wherever it says it's and being that it says by is going to be what is the so we just mention whether it's these pictures on the side of the or whether The car is the but the bry says a whole different definition. It's the area between the corners the is the horns of the misbehan the place where the khan used to walk and it's an widear says well slow downh is that where the khan walked couldn't walk between the and because how you going to get when you have to make a turn you have to go through the cars it's not possible that's what they walked the way you read the price is as follows the is it's two number one it's the area of which is an because the Ken is an why and it's another you have like a little lane where that's for the kahan where they have to go and walk around the but the bottom line is is what's the says the is and the between the says basically respectively had a different definition of what the ku was And they both explained it as being something on the wall of the MSB. Either it's something decorative or it's the and says they're right because when the PK describes the wall of the it says it's clearly describing the wall of the you have to say there were two different one was on the side of the which was either a one was on top. It was like an indentation inside the roof of the misb. The purpose was is that you know it can get slippery on the misb with all the blood and everything else going on. So they shouldn't slip and go off the misb. So it's for that reason they dka made it in that way. Either way just to exhale for a moment before we go v. So we just learned a lot. So uh just a few random thoughts. Number one. So the right at the beginning of the had mentioned that when the yidden came up the extended the was 28 by 28 am but the during was 32 by 32 am they made it bigger why did they make it bigger who was and he was a little bit unsure so first he said I think it's very simple I think the reason they made it bigger is they simply needed more space why would they have needed more space so he said that because maybe there were more people said no you can't say there were more people during during because the describes says it's they were literally and what do you have in the beginning of when the y didn't go up to rebuild the second base 42,360 in the beginning of so there were much more in why would you need the misbeh to be bigger zing You're right. The reason is not because there were more people during bay but during bay you had the shayim that was messiah during bay you did not have the shayim that was messiah so two first of all so the garra says there were a lot more people during bay during bay I'll tell you the medish is in and it's on the so the medish talks about how many there were during the times of the just one excerpt that's relevant to some of the that we learned this week says the message you want to know how many years were living in the times of the BT you can figure it out from the so we're clearly talking about how many carbon did bring the day that he built the base 22,000 may have enough and 120,000 142,000 together how many were involved in the of there were 24 the were brought the so think about how many there were do 22,000* 24 and then do 120,000* 11 that's how many there were so can you imagine how many yidden there were so you want to know says the medish how many yidden were around in the times of do the based on the amount of if it's 22,000 times 24 120,000* 11. So it's a creates an incredible amount of so this is for what it says I'm going to tell you a story assuming this was the last it was the last right before the I want you to give me one look of every single carbon They brought him 600,000 peers of In other words. So he wanted one from every carbon they brought him 1.2 two million. And every one of those had at least 10 people that were said I heard some of them had 40 and some of them had said and not everybody was able to even bring the car. There were people that were there. There were people that were the bottom line is think about how many how many there were. And then the mag continues says one time the went up to be bring the carbon and there was just no room on the to facilitate all the Jews there was they trampled him because they went ahead and they crushed this person continues what was their secret to procreate on on such a level says a man would marry off when he was 12 years old as soon as he was old enough to have children and then his son would get married when he was 12 years old by the time a person turned 26 he was ready regardless you see that how many yidd were during bay 42360 yeah that's when the yidden originally went up But fast forward 420 years later in the times of grief millions and millions of Jews. So I mean you have to understand it's a little bit of a mean is that when the came up originally and they built him as so he comes up to doesn't see any Jews there. He was so upset and that's why he went that he can that the aren't going to get nicer anymore. they were living in there. It was so meager what was going on. But maybe they saw that there were going to be much more than regardless just one as it relates to how many Jews there were in bayan versus how many Jews there were in the times of bay. So then said that maybe it was because of the you had the sh that was there was no during immediately on this sends us to another that we've spoken at many times in the d but always for a different reason and that is a over there says that it when describes see tells the I want you to rebuild the base on miktosh the boy And the word the which is of course from the of is written should be with a hey at the end and it's written as if it would say the says why is it missing it's referring to the five things that mikt had that didn't have to now if you count it it's really between seven. Rashi says that are really one. So that's one. That's all related to the there was no ini there was no ini there was no ini there was no ini and there was no so we've spoken in the past there was no there was no what's a md without so obviously it's levels of there was no if there's no then maybe there was no doesn't that render the exactly what the is so that's that we've spoken about in the past but what we need Now is the soar seems to say there was no and there said that I once saw the this H that came down from and it looked like a dog. It was like and the gummor says that by it looked like a by it looked like a he once spoke out of from the that the garra says that if a has thinking while he does which at first glance seems like such a bizarre he had in mind that will eat the say it's not so bizarre the says that the looked like a maybe that's why he thought of a dog whatever the the punch line is but it's not so bizarre The H of the was shaped like a so says on the one hand who lived during he said that he saw the and it was and here there were five things that were missing during one of the five things that was missing was the so the says in there really was but the was there it was there it looked like a kev but it didn't do anything there was no supernatural powers to this age other than its mere existence but in terms of it having an ability to consume theim quicker than an ordinary could that it didn't though and Rashi says that's an argamar as well when initially thought that the reason would have to be bigger why because there was no that was messiah emphasis on there was but there was no that was going to be that is but I'll tell you something interesting something that we've spoken at once and that is in pares brings begins says the word mishk is bigatri of 410 and it's a rem ofish of so we were going to have a mishk for 410 years continues he says ham mishkun is 415 it's mishkun plus hey but if you add the five letters hey shin cuff It's 415 plus 5 you end up with 420. That's rem to the 420 years that there was written in the hey back of the arithmetic is 479 and it's rem to the 479 years that had a mishk. The mishk was built built the mikt 480 years after built mikt is 480 minus one. There was a mishk for 479 years. So says This is the summation of the in the first for the three periods that the yidden would have mishkone 410k 415 plus the five and 479 that's rem that there was a mishkid or and brings He says it's an unbelievable ramis says but you have to understand one thing why would the terror write 415 as opposed to 420 and now you have to add the five letters why not write a word that means 420 says I think it's a rem to the five things that the gar says in we're missing during during and that's why it's writtener five rem to those either way I saw the on he says that in the word the first was built by is hey that was complete with those five things that were missing during his was complete he had it during I'll tell you something interesting this is the majer he makes a we say in so and then the second that we say it's the emperic is so now it's easy to get confused that and another say every morning in so in you say in every morning It's not but rather what's the difference? He says the is that who wrote the hill brings that from count is count the next 11 were all written by Rabenu said his at the time of Mishkan. At that time there was a tremendous gill of being that there was a tremendous say he saw there was a real mik who wrote it's was written by Ezra Ezra lived in the times of a mikdash but it wasn't a mikto what are the five things that were missing was qualitatively it was it wasn't what it WAS WAS BUTRINA itself So you want to remember which one is which one is which is half of a fell either way. We'll get back some more. Right. So he said the K the those things in the were all as opposed to the length the width the height that's not and that's why you find throughout different periods in history they were of different dimensions said you just have to make sure that if you want to make the really small you could do that but it can't be smaller than the how small was there and said an so they started laughing at it's a it says it was 5 by five one man said 10 by 10 but you can tell me an how can you tell me an laughing at maybe this is in line with maybe it's in that vein people were laughing at him I'm not sure but either way they laughed at was there and he stood up for he Maybe what Rebi means to say it means to say the which was an as we saw in previous maybe that's what he's referring to commented and he said he calls him that's usually something you call a rebi so he calls who was more than rebi he says you know what I mean of course that's what I meant and then he turned to the people that had laughed at him and kai And he told him, look at Rashi. He referred to them as on that note calls these people that laughed in the tells another story where another called somebody was learning with his nephews said the following. Now never married a woman named the real gives so as soon as he says that they jumped up they told him they corrected it's not says you call them you are you have to know what that means the wood that made to put every morning on with on the of the for the carbon. So one of the mitzvah that the ganam had to do when they brought the carbon every morning is they had to take two blocks of wood and they had to put it on the fire and it was incumbent that every single morning there being two zer. So how big were these? So they were an amma long, they were an amma wide and the thickness of the wood was it's like the thing that they would use to smooth a container that has a saw. So if you want to make it smooth on top so they would use kalin. So the thickness of the kali that was used to be a saw that's how thick it had to be. You remember when we say it was an amma it had to be a smaller amma versus a larger. It's not clear what a small is and what a large am is but it had to be says why do you have to be a small the says and we learn from that you have to make sure that the aren't going to protrude beyond the it sounds like the is that the shouldn't protrude beyond the going to tell me that the means the of the but why does it have to be a small ammo let it be a regular And the won't protrude beyond because the was a regular just didn't understand why this it has to be an either way more about the ramp was on the side of the so like this itself during it was 32 long but whereas the mb was a perfect square The wasn't how wide was it? It was 16. So what it means is referring to the carbon and the carbon like all were brought which means the side of the side of the but we learn from here could also mean the thigh of a person in this case a foot or the bottom of the person that the Mak the face of the misbeh should bear and the feet of the misbeh should be biten and that's how you know that the ramp which is referred to as the pa that's the top that's the way you ascend the misb was on the dam side whereas the yer the feet were on the northern side were on the sen side but the gumar saysen just because the feet were bit how do you know that means the head has to be dark if a person lies down says face is is going to be on one side and his feet are going to be on the other side. If he's lying darens, his face is going to be dar and his feet are going to be tough or vice versa, right? It's going to be they're going to be on opposite sides. But if a person stands or if a person sits up for example, so his and his punim can both be on the same side. So just because you know that the yerk is unsuffen, how does that imply that the pun is in? If this person is lying down, then by definition, if his feet are here, then his head must be there. Well, who said he's lying down? It was understood that if the is compared to a person, it's a person lying down. Maybe it's a person standing or a person sitting up. He told him, it says, and ravu is a play on words. It's like someone that's lying down. But the says, that's not what means. Ravu doesn't mean lying down. Ravu means that it has to be a square. It doesn't say but according to you if what the Tyra means to say is not that should be squared but it's like a person lying down so that you know if the the feet up it's softened that means the head the ramp has to be it should have said a different word it should have said and you're right it says the used this word and rava has a double meaning it means number one it should be squared from the fact that didn't say but at the same time it's also mashma like a person lying down so if you know that the were in soften and you were comparing it to a person lying. That means the head has to be that's how you know that the ramp was on the dam side of the there was a that knew that the kebab was on the side from somewhere else not from but soften like a person lying down which implies that the end but rather the time went. So when you went up the you were supposed to go up facing and we learned from there called we learned from there two things. Number one any turn that the coyan made in the mikdash but certainly on the itself had to be a right turn. It also had to be misre. The only way to make that work that the coen would always be facing mis and would always be turning right. It's much easier if you're looking at a a picture, but the only way to make that work is if the Kum was in Dar. So if the Kevish was on the Dharm side of the Misbeh, you're going to have to be facing Misro going to the right. Otherwise, if the K is on Sen and you're facing Misro, you're going to end up going left. The only way you're going to be going right by facing Misro is if the Kev is on D. But the Gmorra says, what do you see in that Pik that you have to go to the right? All the says doesn't say anything about making writers. So the says I know that from somewhere that was this big mikvah that built. So it was very decorative. It stood on 12 buck. Three of them were facing and we learn from here. So how do you know that? So Rashi says because if you look at the four directions that were mentioned by the it's counterclockwise. If you're walking counterclockwise and looking at the thing, as you walk, you're going to be walking to the right and you're going to be walking mis. So, we see from here, we see from here. So, I know they had to be facing mis and I know they always have to make right turns because you're facing the thing walking counterclockwise, which means you're walking to your right. No, but the gar says where do you see that in this? Because it says three would soften, three were the just describing the says why does it say the word so many times it's coming to teach me this idea of just one last before we end the d and that is that the mentioned olive. So the yidden when they come to build the second mikt they want to know where to build the ba mikt. So thear says itself they knew where to build. He knew where to build the bias. Why? Because they were able to see based on where the mik had previously been. That's because they were able to see from the from the foundation and based on that they would know exactly where the banto was supposed to be built. It sounds like when the came up during bay shi they saw the bias the foundation of bas was still there you say in alar's bubble right we're mourning that's what alar's bubble is and then at the end of the we say that we remember who destroyed dest they literally tore out the even the B mikdash was destroyed. Now pis this is referring to the first basar morning the second mikdash they were mourning the first mikd so doesn't it say clearly but the truth is it's a because what does the say referring to didn't destroy the first basd destroyed the second mikdash so the truth is this is actually referring to the second ban it's parak in the of kanso theor says And he said that was and then he throws it. I saw they bring in the sh that says that the hum discusses who was worse the lived in or the yidden that lived in lived in. So one terrorist the Gumra says the Yidden during Bas got to Bdish back we the Yidden who lived in Bay never got to Bdish back right the Gmorra has a discussion over there has a similar discussion and says I'll tell you were never destroyed they were destroyed as it says that's the Roman Empire that destroyed the secondar's bubble that's the garra says that is saying about so from this year to this they see clearly that although it says but that was referring to that was by had this that's why the said I know how they were able to find them as but it's to say that the says that this was also referring to Alar's was allian said to me that even destroyed the first bas but he left the and then later would come and would play a role in and they would destroy the first the says that there were four periods in history where chaped with the one of them was Adam this guy doesn't with the with the mash and arom which is that of the first mikdash were intact and as a result the yidden knew where to build the base of mikdash but they didn't know where to build was the misbeh so the garra says they found the e because they smelled the so they knew that must be where the misbeh was alternatively because they saw the he was finally So just two more the very last the last places. So over there brings this over there says the same thing that is and and apparently that's a real thing is it's just that ordinary we don't see it. They were able to see on the mil that's to the that's how they knew exactly what is what exactly is being says that is being so go up to they become who is the that's sounds interesting brings this brings very small to one line. Apparently there was a mic not to say and says that's not a good mic. You're supposed to say you say by you say by all that feels discuss the way we have it in our period mean period means the carbon has been washed in fire. So we're asking please Hashem accept our and accept our we don't have anymore. So brings and what exactly is means the third that he brings is that you have to know where to put the where to put the period. It's not rebuild period. Oh, and now accept it's return and bring back the carbonus then it's first he says is that maybe it's not such a maybe simply means it means but maybe that's what it means as well but then he says another you know what is means it's referring to the you know what the is means means it's referring to the carbon that the sar brings. And what's this carbon that brings? The carbon that brings iso of that's is the of themselves of the we'reing every single day that should be. So either just is another way of saying or is going back on what you said previously. You have to know where to put the don't have. We're not asking we don't have or which is the he says that's the one with that's the says that's the you're supposed to have. So what do you have when you say that's what you're supposed to have the is the last one and that is you're supposed to put the after you're not supposed to put the after we have time just one final and that is we mentioned so what does it mean they was never burnt on the what does it mean so then asks writer and he says we don't mean we mean but you're himself was never burnt. The truth is there's and is discussing the rain for a long time and something very bad's happening. So the there was a whole procedure that the yidden had to do a whole what you were supposed to follow and it says that the yidden would go into the and they would bring the ta the bema we spoke about the beamer earlier in the week. would bring the beimma into the and they would put apher they would put ashes on top of the beimma and then they would take ashes and they would put it on the head of every person says why why did they do it so one man says the reason they did it was to show we're worthless we're literally like like said one said the reason is I want you to remember I want you to remember what's the difference. It could be now offer. Could you put offer let's say as opposed to apher? Could it be like dirt? Something else that has no value or does it have to be ashes? If you're remembering a said it has to be if it's just something that's not so you could be offer or it could be or upper with an says that if the idea over here is to remember listen to say so it has to be it has to be from burnt human bones to Remember that's what says except the whole idea is according to remember and the idea of is so let's take it to the finish line it has to be the right type of it has to be what's going on over here was the never He wasn't touched. He was never touched. What does it mean? Of course, it means says right here in says, "And besides now, besides that, it just seems like a very interesting that you're gonna have to find apher ashes of a of a burnt human being. It's a very very bigish that that's what the that was what was supposed to be done but the bottom line is says it in both places but it's I had what's says that the way to remember is by taking the ashes of human bones and flesh that's what you're that's what you're supposed to take what's going on over here is like this that there's a rea so we've gone through a lot of rea olive recently because it talks about the the so the rebels is describing the and it says over there the word. And then he prepared fire and he prepared. And then took and he put him on top of the and on top of the and he literally tied him down as if he was as if he was about to be. And then the gets dramatic. He takes AND THEN LIKE AND FINALLY he hears the boss and everything stops. But says the Asian says it says there was fire. If you look at the puzzle doesn't say anything about fire. Here it says there was fire. He says, "You know what thehat must be must be because the Gmorra says that when the would prepare a carbon, so you would have to first put and then put the had to be an he was an if he was an so first there had to be if the says there were then by definition there must have been as well. That means there was fire. That's how the but the bottom line is is that contrary to conventual wisdom was lying on fire. Now it's true never burnt them but that was but something happened to he was lying on fire. How did something not happen to say you could understand when they talk about you have it right here in it's in other places in what means it means the apher the little part of that was burnt there was apher and that apher is the That's makas.