Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
You
see your
tomorrow
[Music]
walking the Hashem, we are here at the
beginning at the beginning of a siren
and we're about to learn Torah. There's
nothing more gishmack and there's no
bigger kadeshm
than sitting and learning in the midst
of a war. Now, this is a war. It's a
quite a serious war.
Somebody was telling me today that
imagine we were going for a minute. It's
like the lack of security that a bomb
can come through the window. They they
have nothing to hold on to. They have
nothing to hold on. They don't have any
sense of
they don't have any sense of we can dav
Hashem. Hashem's our father. He He
controls every single till, every single
rocket. He's going to make sure he goes
to the right place. They have any sense
of that. Imagine the the sense of panic
they must be feeling in a war.
We we have who speaks out that there's
and hashem has a address for every
rocket and it will not go anywhere
except for where he wants.
There's a gar which says
someone has a headache you should learn
to actually goes through a whole list of
things. If you have a pain here
I haven't seen inside. Somebody told me
it's I'm going to believe him. He says
I've had a headache and I learned and it
didn't go away. What does the Quran
mean?
What's what's the meaning of this?
says,
"You have a headache. What are you going
to do? You going to go to bed?" Hey, a
toss and turn. Yeah, sometimes going to
bed helps. Lots of times it doesn't. You
wake up with a in a worse mood. No,
sometimes it does. Don't get me wrong.
Stomach is the same thing, by the way.
Stomach is the same thing.
Says,
"If you anyway got a headache, you might
as well go learn to
where you going to lose out."
So the art people it's a time of war
okay don't go to work don't go to learn
just freeze freeze it's paralyzed I said
you're paralyzed and they get really
scared you could just learn from the co
mistakes making lockdowns and everything
the amount of people who suffered from
mental health
physical health from being stuck at home
for so long of course within reason you
have to you know you have to be careful
and follow the the the basic guidelines
which are given not to be stupid but to
freeze all day always through all the
wars Eden carried on as Rab Poston said
the show must go on
but I want to say that it's it's it's
the next stage it's not just that we've
got nothing else to do so let's learn
that's that's not you know we're bored
we could play chess so we can learn so
we're learning so we're sadik
It's a little bit more than that.
The nephe at the beginning of his safer
speaks out the power of a ye the extreme
power of a ye and he says every time a
ye does a mitzvah
he's he's changing things up in sham we
have a without sh with the mitzvah we
were given we can change things it's
amazing we can we bring down
with a same thing happens you bring kil
kulum you bring destructive
powers down
the quot something it's just it's very
very powerful to hear
we know the mdish got destroyed and the
simple way of understanding it is yes
misbehaved the gummor discusses why it
got destroyed
but
quotes a medish
and the medish says like this. Look in
source number one.
Source number one. Yeah, I changed my
mind. I do it often.
Um, he quotes a long medus. I don't want
to go into it. The med starts off in
source number five, but I don't want to
go through it inside.
Now at the time of the
then they said to the
this Russia tit
the who came to to to destroy the base
of mikdosh different times they're going
to say you see I destroyed the base of
mikdosh
yeah the the the going to say I
destroyed the base of mikdosh
isn't isn't that isn't that
andem turned around and said a line.
This line goes like this.
This is in source number one and big
you say that you can fight with me.
If from shmayim it wasn't sent
you have killed a dead lion.
You have you are grounding ground flour.
You are burning something that is
burned. You're burning a beauty that is
burnt. A a city that is burnt.
says the med
titus doesn't have a k to burn the base
of mikdash titus doesn't have a kak to
destroy the b mikdash he is destroying a
destroyed building
he gives it through mashim it's like
grounding ground wheat what you're doing
you're doing absolutely nothing cuz it's
ground doesn't become fine and there's a
certain level it will get to and there's
nothing you can do about that if you
shoot an animal which is dead you shoot
a dead lion doesn't become more geted it
just stays dead.
What does this mean? This means like
this
is trying to bring out his point that
when a ye does a mitzvah
when a ye does learns
he gives
it gives in
for whatever we need for whatever we
have
it takes away something that we need
something that we have so they did a
they didn't deserve the B mikdash
anymore. The B mikdash in Shayim
was gone.
Titus only has a kayak to take down the
B mikdash because the B mikdash was not
there in Sham. The Kak to keep the B
mikdash. The spiritual B mikdash was
gone.
And therefore Tetus could come along and
burn it. But Tetus doesn't have a K to
burn the B mikdash. He has no K
whatsoever to burn the B mikdash. If
there's no shim, if we're not to it, if
we don't have the mitzvah which give us
the merit for it, we don't then tas can
destroy it. Nothing can be destroyed.
Nothing could be could be created
without our mitzvah
and filler.
Right?
So this this this gives us an
understanding
that no rocket
can have a k unless the decides it
should have a k. No pilot can be shot
down unless unless gives them a k. Where
does it where do we get the kus to stop
a rocket fall? Where do we get the kus
to stop a pilot being shot down? from
learning Tyra, from doing mitzvah, from
davening. That's what gives us the k
mikdash can only be destroyed if it was
already destroyed. You cannot destroy a
b mikdash which has which has sh. So if
we learn and we dav and we do mitzvah
properly, it gives us a kus. So let's
this is why it's an amazing kdish hashem
that we're here today giving a sh when
there's a sire because this is what
saves us because you have to follow the
guidel
[Music]
it's just the sources he's just quoting
the sources which he he made these notes
I don't think so I think the nephe
quotes lots of different quotes um you
want to read it you want to know what
he's talking about. So he just quoted
one bit um which said
so it brings the whole metric
okay let's start discussing some hilus
last year we discussed the different
stages of creating sitsus let's go back
there I asked my friend to get me wool
unfortunately he hasn't managed so you
know the next time you see a sheep will
come wool wool from a sheep
machine. Yeah, there's a process.
Take a piece of wool. It's dirty, right?
Sheep. They're not very clean. It's got
all different garbage. It's It's rough.
And they used to comb it to get all the
garbage out.
Impurities. Impurities.
They used to comb it.
Following that, I guess they cleaned it.
You guess you got to have it clean. If
you wanted to get it into a thread, it's
all soft and everything, they had to
kind of pull it.
That's called, right? So, the first
stage is nippets. Nippets is combing to
get all the garbage out. And then
there's
with you end up with a thread, not just
fluff, a thread.
Now, for titis, there's an extra ding
called shazira. You take a thread and
another thread and you put them
together. If you look at your titsus,
you'll notice that there's more than one
put together,
right? That's what you see. It's called
shazer. It's been shaz.
Um after that, you have your tits ready
to go inside your bag. Okay.
Shaz the Rambam holds you only need you
should do it for the mitzv by nothing
else
all other say no you need to all the way
through that means
and then you have a begged let's take a
begged
see if we can get it out
slap it up here's your beard right so
you got your hole
So what you need to do is you need to
put your tits through the hole. So you
take a thread four fourin four threads
you put it through that putting it
through is making the titus. Now we're
starting to create the tits
hanging it on the garment. And then what
do you do? You need to make a knot. It's
the next stage. After that one one round
one
ring that's all that's needed and then
another kashir that is tits the rest
what we do is do our bon very nice
things but mida that's all we need to do
okay so starts with nipp which according
to most most most you do not need lash
so we're going to leave that it's a it's
a nice thing to have lash for that Okay.
That means you're doing it for no other
reason except for the mitzvah of not for
style, not cuz you're bored.
Following that is shaz when you wrap
them together. I think we do four and
it's different in hogam how you do
shazer but it has to be more than one
right you take two put it around
together you end up with something like
this. This is a very thick synthesis.
After that you need to do ta. You put it
through the hole. You make a knot. You
make one round. You make another knot.
And hey presto, you ended up with a pair
of tits. Right? We do more than that,
but that is the main thing you need lash
for.
Okay, that is the basics of having
forus.
We got a little bit into can you use a
machine for lashma
right meaning to have it you need to
need should be you right otherwise what
does it you I'm doing this and then you
give it to someone else to do right of
course that's not the mitz cuz he's
doing it so if I make get a machine to
do it I can say I'm doing this but then
machine's doing it so what does it make
a difference what you say no one really
cares what you say cuz the machine did
it not
So could you do a machine? No. What do
we think?
Is a machine okay or not okay?
You already know that you eat machine.
Machine matzah. I eat machine matzah. We
know that matzah has to be made lash.
Matzah must be made lash. But I along
with uh there's quite min mostly don't
have. Yeah, thank you.
mostly do not have mash first night. I
do along with lots of other
goritz from gates gates
[Music]
used to have there's a lot of problems.
So how can you get away with it?
So I asked this turb gurvitz the rashiva
of gates said and I said to him how is
it possible to eat machine mats on the
first night when you need lashar and he
said to me like this there's a garra
that says if somebody has a huge body of
water and it's held with a dam and he
picks up the dam and what happens all
the water goes flying out and it goes
and ruins a whole load of fields are you
or are you potter
right what do you do there. It's
grammar. No, you couldn't. Nothing could
have happened if you didn't do it.
Nothing could have happened if you
didn't do it. What do you mean? If you
didn't understand, it wouldn't have
happened. Grammar lots of times is if
you didn't do it, it wouldn't have
happened. Okay, that's right. But there
is a concept which Robert Poston is
saying which is called grammar. Grammar
means that you caused it. It wasn't like
a for sure, you caused it. Indirect
direct, right? It's a person say it's
indirect.
You think it's direct? It's a
[Music]
English. True. It's a it's a it's a it's
a optical illusion. Why say optical
illusion? Because it's not indirect.
It's direct. If you if you it doesn't
matter how many gears or how many ropes
and pulleys you have. If you if it
couldn't have happened without you, it's
all you.
Oh, look look look I I'm going to I'm
going to argue with you on one point and
that is sometimes grammar happens even
uh with
without you it wouldn't have happened
but because you did it it's going to
happen and you're not you're putter so
then that has to be measured if it's
measured then uh then if it has to be
measured there's such a thing as
measuring example if I take a tiny uh
dental string and I hang a kum kum from
the roof and then I say everybody Please
be careful. Excuse me. You You'll meet
people in life that are like that by you
know that like they'll they'll put like
their bike in the middle of the entrance
and they'll say, "What do you want? I'm
trying to sleep here." You know,
something like that. You know, and
they're like, "It's your fault." You
know, so it's like
I Okay. Okay. I hear what you're saying.
It's miserable. A person wants to tell
his grammar lisa. It's not. Why is it
not? What? Yeah. He wants a tiny more
than that. The water is is pressed
against the dam. It's pressed against
the dam. By you pulling it up, you are
causing not even causing you are making
it's your kayak. It's what we call
kerition. You are making it go into
hashem. You are making it go into the
fields. It's the dam the whole time
that's stopping it the entire time. by
you taking away that's enough called
your
says if you press the button it's true
that what's happening what damages the
field after he pulled the dam is not him
but we say it's yours because it was
pushing against the dam and you pulled
it off
even though it's it's happening 5
minutes later think about it yeah you're
in the countryside and there it's on top
of a mountain it's on top of a hill and
you pulled out this dam even though 5
minutes later it's trickling ling down
and ruin the guy's field. It's all you.
You're all you initiated it, right? So,
we consider it all yours. So, you're
saying there's a difference.
If you have a D, which means you're
opening a valve when there's water
pressed against the wall? What about
when you open it when it's not pressed
against? That that will probably be
Christian. If it's not pressed against
the wall and it could and could not fall
out then the rain comes and it's not
withheld that's I I would think that
that's not that also
I don't know I don't yeah I can think
yeah you're for sure not question is
where where exactly is that also goes
into like later into AI and stuff where
you have presets and all these sort of
things and are you blamed for something
but at the end of the day if that the
programming whatever the line code says
what they want as much But yeah, it's
the same thing. Yeah. Yeah. Um,
so that's what Grovit says. 5 minutes
later, it's all the way down in the
valley and it's ruining the guy's
vineyard. It's me. What did I do? What
did I do? Says the Gmorra. Because you
pulled it away. Even though it's it's 5
minutes later has no you're already
sleeping. Doesn't make a difference cuz
you pulled it away. It's your it remains
you. So it says it so too if you press a
button of a machine and it's gone for
hours for hours it's it's put it's
needing I don't know what exactly a
machine mount it does it's all
considered you
but it's a big heated debate cuz at the
end of the day the guy 5 miles downream
could say what did you do about your dam
what did you do about your property
lines what about the neighbor this guy
that guy that the water came maybe you
know if you would have done it it should
have been expected that you should have
been able to hold with that that height
or whatever it is. But because you know
there's there's there's there's a lot of
of tightness and it's it's been spoken
about a lot a lot a lot. We're just
bringing it in to understand why sitsas
in any of the good I don't believe they
have machines and that is because
they've worked out very good systems how
to do it by hand. Um hopefully we're
going to go to a factory if they're
still open in the war. Sure they are. um
business as usual and they there's
pictures of it. I don't want to ruin it
for you. I don't want to ruin it. So,
it's basically they have a big wheel
and you have this guy going like this.
Shame it
shites
and he's turning the wheel. By him
turning the wheel turns a different
wheel, turns a different wheel and it's
doing it's strengthening it or it's
doing shazira all with one wheel just
going around. Amazing. Yeah. I've got a
question for you. What happens if you're
turning the wheel? This guy's going like
this. Turning the wheel. Alicia's a
question for you. Turn the wheel. And
then you got this. You do it on the bike
sometimes. Push it really hard and then
you leave go for a minute cuz you want
to scratch your hair. That's right.
Yeah. M like that. Hang on a second.
When it carries on going, is it still
you?
How does it start? M Carell says that.
Listen says even if you leave go and it
carries on going, it's still your it's
moving because of your
that's you know cuz we're probably going
to see that in the factory. So that's
that's fine. Okay, that is we make tits.
Go on. What you saying? No, I'm not
saying okay. Is that a what is the
significance of that? Of what? Spinning
and spinning and spinning so fast that
the thing could run for 5 seconds. 6
seconds. Well, he just wants a break.
That's all. 40 seconds, 2 minutes, 3
minutes, 5 minutes. When at what point
does it become you? At what point does
it become It always will stay you cuz
it's moving because of you.
You can't say that. What happens if it
can still run for like one of those like
what do you call those science
experiments that like it has like the
the the I saw one. It has like a funnel
and it comes down and then it curves so
that the water either goes back or the
balls come flying back and go again.
I'll be honest, I don't I don't know.
You understand what I'm describing to
you? You're you're basically saying if
you start something that can carry him
for let's say an hour, can that still be
considered yours?
I I don't really understand the scenario
properly how how it's set up. It sounds
like it should it sounds like it should
still be yours. And it and it has like
the tracks and it rolls down. It's at a
certain height and it just like it comes
up and it shoot it shoots back into the
the the bowl and it has the funnel and
it goes back and it sound it sounds like
it'll still be his cl cuz he started it.
He let it go. That's what I would think.
Okay. Okay. I want to discuss now
if
ladies can make sitsus. Touched up. We
touched upon it. What is the
significance? There was a time by
October 7
when it was very very in fashion for
everybody to wear tits. I don't know if
it's still in fashion, but um and they
they couldn't get them out quick enough.
Were ladies making tits?
Were they they were so for the and the
people who were making it had
only
they were making for
they were allowing the women. Oh that's
very interesting. Yeah. This where a
person says that when they made the for
the when they're making for the soldiers
they let women or even Ashkanazi women.
No even Ashkanazi women. Yeah. Make it
style. They were making for theim. They
were making for the but the Ashka they
couldn't they weren't making for the
Ashkanaz. What's the problem with women?
Oh, this is what we're going to see. Why
should any equality, right? Isn't it
right? Why why are they any different
about the whole social aspect? They were
being lenient when there was a great
need even for the Ashazi.
We had stock at least right away for
this. Yeah. Okay.
So, let's have a look at source number
two. H. It's in the Gammorra.
One, two, three, four, five, six lines
up in the Gumarra. So, on the right is
Tismas. On the left is the Gamarra.
Shuna
Run.
Yeah, it's probably a place ra the son
of ra from says
have you got it
that was written.
Yeah.
It was either by a min someone who's a
what's mean not sure what it means here
to be honest could mean a I'm not sure I
don't there's no rashy I didn't bring
print the rashi let's see if rashi says
that it's not in gith so it won't be in
it um a servant ish a lady the cotton
anus
the yol m or yrol who is a mama Who is
does Yeah. Yeah. Oh, that Yeah, that's a
balm. Yeah. Yeah. Very similar.
So if any of these wrote wrote wrote
it's going to be a possle
you should put it onto
and you should write it says the
whoever has the
mitzvah of writing it
whoever doesn't have the mitzvah of
doesn't have the mitzah
The Gomorra learns that from a Joshua in
order to write
in order to write a safer to write you
have to have the mitzvah of putting on
the if you don't have the mitzvah to put
on fillin you cannot write it.
Okay. So that tells us by fillin this is
a posin we asked the question by titus.
So we know a lady can't write. That's
okay. What about tits? Let's have a look
at this is on the right side
right at the top
from here says aim
a lady cannot tie a lulus
and she cannot make
because she doesn't have a
says we see from this p that if you have
from this dasha if you have the mitzvah,
you can make it. If you don't have the
mitzvah, you can't make it. So, ladies
cannot make sites. Ladies cannot make
it's all a sudden it's gone to all the
mitzvah. It seems like it's it's a it's
a broad concept this it's not by it's
not only by where we've learned it from.
It's also by Titus. It's also by Suk.
It's also by Lulov
says in it does not seem so
he's arguing about
says
how often do you get to learn to in the
time of war? Get involved.
I'm going to do something very cheeky
and say a little story here.
It was in the first world war was a song
called the big I think it was it was the
first world war
somewhere in Eastern Europe I don't know
exactly I think it was on the Ukrainian
broader
and there was a rule at night you were
not allowed to have any lights on why
because the the planes used to go flying
low looking for lights wherever there's
a light that means it's civilization so
you weren't allowed any lights on was
upload burning and of course he covered
the windows and everything and it must
have been that one of the blinds got
pushed aside somehow and the soldiers
who were patrolling was punishable by
death. Means you're a spy. If you leave
a light on it means you're giving the
enemy away. So if you get caught that's
it bullet through your head. So he was
busy learning
schmack narama
and the door bursts open
and they find him learning with a candle
there. They pick him up and they start
taking to the door. I'm going to kill
you. Look, you left the window open.
He says, "Give me one minute. Give me
one minute." He says, "What? Give me one
minute." I'm in the middle of a ram. I
don't know ra Let me finish off the ram
and then you can kill me. just let me
finish off the ram.
In the middle of a war, he was so into
his learning. Let me finish off the ram.
The story carries on. So they said,
"Okay, you'll finish the ram." Say no.
They made sure that the the curtain was
closed and no one could see. And he
starts learning the ram and he getting
old. He's trying to work. And then the
commander came. He said, "Guys, let's
taxi outside. We have to go right now."
They left him.
He left King
was the tlic. So middle of middle of a
war toy let's get involved.
So Tyus started off with Raben what does
Rabut say that just like we learn by
fillin that if a lady who doesn't have
the mitzvah
she doesn't need to put it on she can't
write it. Somebody who's not in the
mitzvah cannot make it. So she can't and
she can't make senses turns around says
it doesn't seem so why
from the fact that we ple we make a
beginning of
[Music]
[Applause]
it says B is
talking to B is and the Gar there learns
out B is not can't make
says the M you see from that
I isha is kasha I isha can make tits
only a guy do we learn out they can't
but we don't say a lady can't so says to
cannot be correct
brings another that a lady who makes a
suka
from Nami sukas gambach gambach stands
for noshim I know what's bass don't
remember
is it kash it's kasha what's what's base
um goshim
races
Okay. So this is this Joshua is only by
right and he has a he has a ray
because we have a Joshua which says
double bene form and the gammor are only
bene are not
ladies. So let's recap two
First is
when it says
would seem to imply that also women
don't have to wear isn't that
last two lines. No. So he says
that's make but we didn't make that.
Yeah.
But it doesn't say not ladies. The
doesn't say not ladies. Women doesn't
say
it says but is we learned
and yed means not go. It doesn't mean
not not ladies. But then you would have
the same thing with
follow that same path.
Yeah. It's not in the same
it doesn't doesn't say it doesn't
mention doesn't mention
all we learn out from whoever has the
mitzvah can make it that's what we learn
out okay two
says ladies cannot make any mitzvah
which are not that's what it sounds like
and then we have another which is who
says what what it says leave it by
there's
Dasha that says go can't make senses. It
doesn't say ladies can't make senses.
Okay. Okay.
There is another shitta.
I don't think we should do it inside.
The other is that when it says den it
says ben
ben means ben.
So even though it doesn't say it in the
the Gomorrah it says double ben is speak
to the ben is the children ben the sons
of isra it says the sons of isra doesn't
says b doesn't say the daughters so
ladies cannot make sus that's the third
it's maram brought over here in source
number four
um yeah it's okay and and anytime he
says that anytime the word bene is not
referring to Jewish people but he's
referring to the men of Israel so this
is Uh this is a very good question when
it says Ben is it only referring to men
whenever it says it. It's a good
question gets busy with it. Um it's it's
spoken about
anywhere in Jewish literature when using
the term Israel. Does it only mean does
it mean the Jewish people or does it
only mean men of Israel?
That is a very good question. It's
spoken about but I don't want to get
into it. It's a it's a schmoo for
itself. It's a it's a it's a big topic
and we're not going to get into it.
Okay.
So, we have three
Three Now, I want to give you
a interesting scenario which I came
across.
How long ago was it? Maybe a year ago.
Longer than a year ago. Now, um I had
operation on my shoulder. I used to get
dislocated very often. So for 4 weeks I
had to have my arm it was held like this
and I couldn't use it at all. Couldn't
put on my fill in.
So at the beginning when I was still
very uh much in pain and I wasn't going
out and I asked my wife to help me to
put on fillin. She wasn't very good at
it because she's never put on fillain
before but she was very nice and she
used to help me put on fillin. Could she
do that?
You helping you put on your own so she
pulls it over here and she puts the
filling on me. Is that okay? Sure she
can. What do you think, Lawrence?
Just tying them. What do you say? She's
tying them.
She's just tying them. She's just tying
them. She's just tying them. Yeah. Oh,
okay. Let's have a look in source number
four.
Let's have a look in source number four.
four lines down
in middle of the line.
So, right
which a lady is not could go in like
she cannot tie the second and she cannot
um prepare the
You're implying that it has ritual
significance 100% because we have so of
course it's got significance
says there have been a time he has a
this time we've saw before the
whoever has a mitzvah of putting on has
a mitzvah of but if you don't have the
mitz of you don't know
there was a story in a place called this
is where the rash was born Yeah. Yes.
Interesting. Isa with a lady.
She was rogel. She used to fix tits and
make tits likeis
and she used to make the gadim. She used
to do do the things. She was the tits
maker. You bought titsus and you have
the strings. You wanted someone to do
it. You gave it to this lady and she
made it. Raben raan said the pusle stood
up. I'm sure he said the what this
lady's doing
from this which we saw before in
says
the
there was a story with a lady. She was
married to
shares
and she used to tie the villain on his
hand
as the girls is how can you tell me if a
lady isn't in the in the mitzvah she
can't do it she can't prepare it we see
this story
they used to help her husband put on the
so it means that that God's moment is
understanding
that if you're not in the mitzvah, you
can't put it on.
That's what it says over there. So, my
wife putting on my for me, I don't know
how correct it was. We're going to have
to see says that God's no she wasn't
tying it.
She was helping him. the actual tie the
the last pull that made it tight. He
must have done it. But she she helped a
bit. But to do the actual tying, not
that couldn't be. Why? Because she's not
in the midst. She can't do it.
Different.
It's not forbidden for a lady to do only
preparation.
Means preparing it. Um making it. Ah I
see. Yeah. Yeah.
preparing the object. I see here like
writing
preparing
and tying the before you do
the forz
she's allowed to do it.
Okay.
He says this is the end of the
these are golden words
the din would be the same with doing the
let's think for a second we need to
think for a second
we've said that it's questionable
if ladies can make
what about
that means when we have ta when you're
putting it in the pegged. That's making
the tits. You put it through, you make
the knot, you do the the the you put it
around once, and you do another knot.
That's making tits. What about when I'm
doing
is that called making tits? Was that
like before I put it on a garment? What
about this is tits? Nothing yet.
To sites, I'm taking wool and I'm making
it into a thread. Now I'm saying because
I know what the end result is. But is
that called making tas? Am I making tas
when I'm making a thread?
It's not only
it can't it is it could be used for this
multi-purpose. It could be multi-purpose
but I'm saying it's titas. I'm saying
this for tits but but that's not I'm not
making the tits. Now am I creating the
tits?
Now go says that even though we're
learning out that a lady cannot make
tits, she can still do spinning the
titas that she's allowed to do. Why?
Because that's not really part of making
tits. Let's recap and discuss. We have
three.
One is a lady cannot do any mitzvah
which is not
that means al that means titas that
means fillin all across the board.
Why? Because we have a special Joshin
and we learn that out to everywhere. So
says Rabin. We have the next which says
what that's only said by fillin leave it
by fillin ISA
learns out means only are not going not
going. It doesn't say not ladies. So he
says of course ladies can make tits.
This is a lot a lot of restraint. uh we
saw inas we saw in it's a lot of
and then we have a third that he doesn't
say that that what we see back to fillin
if you not in the mitzvah you can't make
it he doesn't say that he says there's
another special it says b is means the
boys the men and it doesn't mean the
ladies which means according to that
rish can can you make a lulf can a lady
prepare the lulaf of course you
cuz he's not learning it like which is
like whenever you don't you're not you
can't make it three
seems to say let's read it out I didn't
print it
this is in simle
is which makes it possible.
So speak to come to exclude
a lady is cautious to make it. This is
the the one that the go after says the
are those
that they say that you need men to do it
and it's good to do this. So I guess
that's why they let for the apparently
when they were doing the when they
making the for the let ladies do it for
the Ashkanazim they said better I passed
it was my place to pass. Mhm. They asked
me, I said, I personally would say to
all the women coming, let the men put
the strings through the hole, let them
tie the first knot and then then it's
all right. Let the women continue.
That's great. They said
like we just said here that the the the
boss is is make the the revol was was
not here. Oh, this is what they said.
And I I I'm I'm afraid I'm embarrassed
to say this on film, but I saw it
myself. There were 80% of the volunteers
were women. And the few men that showed
up, their figures were so uh what's the
word? Inept. It took them, let's say,
two times as long, three times as long,
maybe even four times as long to make a
pairus. And they needed a rush. So they
took all the I'm going to call them
coolers, but whatever. All the different
they didn't listen to me. And they just
had the women do it
because of the the situation
situation. So then they turned it into a
and they just had the women.
Interesting. What do you think about
why? Well, what do you think? So for the
and I would think it's okay. It sounds
like it's okay from the I didn't I
didn't look into it especially for but
um it's it is written that even for
Ashkanaz it's okay.
Yeah. So if you tell them for for
Ashkanazim if the if a man starts off
and he puts it through and does the
first and the first ring around and the
second and it's fine.
Yeah.
Thank you very much.
Heat. Heat.
[Music]
Oh my