Wrapping Your Hands When You Don't Have Water - Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 163 Seif 1

Okay, good morning. Good morning, friends. We're continuing today's the last day of our campaign. Charity.com/mh26. The rules of someone who doesn't have water and someone who feeds someone else. If you don't have water available, if it's in front of you, meaning in the direction that you're traveling at a distance of more than 4 mil. A mill is 2,000 amount of time it takes to walk 18 minutes. So that's 70 more than 72 minutes. And out of your direction behind you 1 mil 18 minutes, you wash your hands with a with a cloth. Now, what in the world does that mean? How do you wash your hands with a cloth? We'll see. Is this the right ga? And you eat bread. So in other words, you could use this to eat bread or something which is dipped in a liquid or or use a spoon. Fine. Says those who wash their hands with the moisture of the grass when they don't have water, they're sinning. First of all, they're disparaging the secondly. It's meaningless. It's nothing. It's nothing. It's not actual in the when water is not available. When water is available, it's user to use this cloth lest you come to touch. This of we'll see not washing your hands with a cloth, but wrapping your hands in a cloth is only if water is not available. But if water is available, you're now to wrap your hands in a cloth because you may come to touch the food. Who says that? The gar. when you're on you estimate you're not going to find water even at a distance more than four mil he's hungry he wants to eat you a wash through like so what would an example of this be uh I don't know you're in a car they're not going to stop or you're you're in the wilderness or you're on a plane and there's turbulence so they don't let you get up. So what you could do is you could wrap your hands in a cloth. Um now the duru says there are certain circumstances. Let's say a guy he knows he's going to be out on the road. Could he wash his hands for in the morning and have in mind he's going to it will cover his whole day? There is such a there is such an however is better anyway. So if you evaluate you're going to find water right after 4 mil the says now the lion of the it's interesting you usually we say the distance for a minion is here it's he says take of if you're going to find it right after then you are to wait until you get there behind you Then sagi basher mill if you can go out of the way you're going to have to go out of the way then it's enough for a mill meaning the points out the gar says davka you know when you need to go back less than a mill you would have to go backwards less than a mill but for a mill you don't have to go back you do not have to go back for a mill you do have to go forward 4 mil. You even have to go forward slightly more than 4 mil. Backward you don't have to go even 1 mil only less than a mil. Right? That's why wrote this by ahead. That's even beyond formal. It's longer than that because if you're going to find it beyond 4 mil, you do have to you do have to wait. By backward 1 mil, you don't have to. It's only less than >> when there's turbulence on the plane and the mill happens much faster. >> Right. We we'll have to see. Is this a time or is a distance? We didn't see. Okay. There are many stiras in regarding the the Shir 4 mil or 1 mil. Is it time or is it distance? Let's say regarding minion, there's a famous between D minion and D. Right now, we're assuming it's distance. Okay, we'll see. We'll see. So, he says >> is not is not a shear. >> Why not? >> How much more? >> More. >> What does that mean? more means doesn't say. So there's four mil there's more than there's take off right the lion is um take of you have to wait. So there are three there are three levels. There's 4 mil, there's take off 4 mil and there's how much certain things gave a person the to know what they are. There's four, there's take off, and there's okay, right? The same would apply. Let's say you're maybe you won't find water in front of you. A shear of four mil and you're hungry. Okay. Now, map. You could also use a mapa. It's not only if you know that you won't find water. It's also if you're not sure if you're going to find water. So then you could use a map. If you're not sure, I could I can now travel and I might not find water. You could you don't have to try to find it. You could be malle the shion says what about using a spoon. The primagandam says don't be lenient spoon. The says even the if you had garden or orchard watchmen if they're going to have to go find water then they only are to go less than a mill like the distance you'd have to go behind you. and they can't leave their job. So the distance of of mill is if you're headed in that direction. But if you need to be where you are now, so then the shar is always let's say like this, you know, they're they're turning off the water. you know, you get you get one of these notices. They're going to be turning off the water between 11 and 1. And you forgot to uh put away. So, you don't have any bottles of water. You don't have water. So, how far do you have to walk? You have to walk less than a, you know, you have to walk 16 minutes, 17 minutes, not more than that. The share of four mill is only when you're on the road. You're going there anyway. Here also we have a it should say. So again back to our previous dispute. Is this change the ga or does means read that's what it means? First he says and once he should say you know the word and yal are basically the same letters. You could see how they got unscrambled. That seems to indicate you should change the text. And then what in the world does yolot mean? When do you ever use the word yalot? answer and that means what that's trying to say like by was maybe you know he wrapped himself in his cloak >> when when we sent a meal is that is that dare back and you say 163 minutes I'm leaving my house that water it take me another 16 minutes to get back >> it's one it's one way in other words you have to go six you have to go less than a mil to get it even though it's going to take another less than a mil to go back Right. It doesn't have to be what? Mapa is a cloth. It could be anything. It could be a towel. It could be a shirt. It could be it could be um a whatever you want to use, whatever suits your fancy. You have to wrap both hands. Ah, you're only eating with one hand one hand would be enough. I'm not sure which he's referring to. Let's see the meaning how much of the hand do you have to wrap? you have to wrap just the fingers like the or the whole hand you know that's also but what's he referring to um oh let's see the says the says you could use a spoon you mean use a spoon but the left hand, you know, who knows what you could be doing with the left hand while you're using a spoon. So that means the Rama holds you only have to worry about the Ramo who allows the doesn't allow the spoon. The Rama allows the spoon. So once the Ram who allows you to use a spoon is not uh is not concerned for the second hand. The does not allow you to use the spoon is concerned for the second hand. Why? Because if it's wrapped, if one hand is wrapped, you'll remember and you won't come to touch it again. The doesn't say a spoon. Why the wants a spoon? How's a spoon going to help? What about the other hand? The Rama is not worried about the other hand. So the wants to say that there would be enough whether you have to wrap both hands. I would say not that you could say not like the I would say not like the because that's why the Rama holds you could use a spoon. the hold you can't use a spoon because we're worried about the second hand then why didn't the Rama say by the way you only need on one hand if that's what the Ram is getting at what the Ramo is getting at by the way I argue on the holds you need to wrap your hand I hold you could use a spoon what but that's not what he's getting at what he's getting at is you only have to wrap one hand so the Ramos should have set it straight the Ramos should have said I argue on the maba the is worried about two hands I'm only concerned for one hand I would say that maybe even the maba would hold or even the rama would hold if you're wrapping you got to wrap both hands because if you wrap one hand you're inevitably going to use the second hand to eat it's not so easy to eat with a wrapped hand but when it comes to eating a spoon so you know you're supposed to eat the spoon. Why would you why would you go and touch it? Anyway, the is saying an interesting is saying that there's a second over here. First of all, he's saying two. You ready? Number one is the holds you can't use a spoon. Did you pick up on that? Just because the didn't mention you could use a spoon, does that does that mean holds you can't use a spoon? Yes. The says if didn't say you could use a spoon then holds you can't use a spoon is holds you could use a spoon. That's the first of the second of is that why does say you could use a spoon? Why aren't you worried you're going to touch it with the second hand? Oh the holds you're not worried you're going to touch it with the second hand. Oh that's why the holds you can't use a spoon because he's worried you're going to use it touch it with the second hand. So I'm just saying the created a second between the usually we like to say you know we don't like to make too but the but then he ends off saying that uh many questioned Rama's spoon but he's saying that it would come out another whether you But whether you have to wrap both hands. Mhm. He bring again he brings this in the he says according to the it's you have to wash two hands according to look we're you know we we have to take the the the knows how to read the I don't know that I would have got from the that the holds you have to you have to wrap both hands and if he does And the Rama disagrees then why didn't the Rama say anything about that? He did by saying you could use a spoon. That's the way the Rama is saying you only have to be concerned for one hand. That's how the Mishabur is reading the Mabama. Okay, we'll hold it over here. >> Recording stopped.