When Can We make A Zimun? - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

okay first of all helping you roll well and I am a little hoarse but otherwise I'm okay oh so there's a Shem and I wanted to discuss in Indian today that's nagae all the time I think especially now that our boys are home the question is when can a person make a zine one and when could a person make a second zi money a typical case someone answered to one group can you make a second Zeeman if you want to create a Zemon you want to give someone to eat something so you could answer what's the lockers of Zeeman of three Zeeman of ten and as we see some fascinating Shiloh's as well but basically the common denominator is you want to make a seaman of three or a Zemon of ten sort of a practical guide of how to proceed so I think it's important to realize and I first be marked them someone asked me a very innocent question what's the big deal about Elka's 'man you can't go wrong it's a few years issuer's a bison valve invention and then you Seamus Emma vary from yatra delhomme is a pasta Cantillon can't go wrong with that we said it in hollow last week and Navarre Columbus Allah he is not even a broker and even if you say para la que nous but it's still not Gemma Malthus so why the need first-year say it if you want don't say it if you want you really can't go wrong but that's absolutely not true and especially that you Amy Eden not learned long ago learned the seventh Paragon Brock is the bulk of it is Hill choice Zeman Chicana of devotes no less than 10 C Mon him cook asada Calif total swimming race all including similar age all about Zeman so obviously it's a lot more than a few years words plus and this is important the gomorian Brock has man Hamid Bay's tells a story a 3 mm that ate together and they were in doubt if they should make a bro a Zemon so what do they do they didn't make a zine one but then they were they should have she did make Z money after benching a whole needs are what's the big deal obviously Zeeman is a big deal and don't forget as the Morrises umbrella staff member in the beginning of relationship flow you learn how to 'man from tube silken the plastic in partisan okey shame I am a corrupt hover Gardella like a no or the pasta can tell and God bless them eat the M is my active and the mere fact that the chimera marshals of plastic in the Taira leads some Gedaliah PI scheme to conclude that Zeeman is a fee of their eisah it's based on a there's a fascinating lavash in cuffs addict a CVS about an antagonist suffix of herself McIver if he has a fee of Zeeman or not we don't know his status and lavash says a body's Mikoyan sway could arise Alejandra because in ich in la muralla from the beginning also holds demons ERISA but the mr. Bruin cuffs are dick base your olive and Sherrod see and cook topic scientist ayan cook Sadiq test test is of the opinion that Zeeman is their opponent Roy sheet as he says holds their opponent has in his rights I don't know what he means right if she dies but the truth is a practical Africa Mina where the Zeman's the rights of the rebel on is can you be macabre of omitsu boy then I raise my mitts with the bench because he's not a goggle dear I see yet until he brings him onon so because a niche that holds us their eyes up with not allow of them it's a boy to bench and talk to the orchestra venue an olive pave of Records the meaning of the stapler who did not allow mammoths avoid the bench as the Masami the mini golem we'd have to give it a little bit savoy so I could say bi them over lawyer Eden it seems that many go item is to assume like mr. Brewer says Zeman's their opponent and a cotton I'm sorry a bomb it Savoy could bench but rabbi say even if it's only me there are born on do you see a hole sugar once you ate with an oil you can't leave you can't lose the seamen will learn today you'll add a create a Zemon obviously it's a lot more than a few years words but there's also the flip side there's a fascinating finish of their mom and cook pate receives a lien that has a shiloh about adding Lvov in a certain case so their mothers you know you should do put it into a Rockman can't go wrong but says the machina says there are more but no you can't do that you can't just say all the other if you're in doubt because since there is Seamus Hashem it might be a brothel of atala fragged the machina from Valhalla vittala and all of you have it is no broker of course the shame of shame but there's no broker says the big day yes a tremendous you soit the bargain of Rama's right Rama rest is knows bracha I say my share you let us say it Fela with shame a shame you later Sarah shadow night you out some finesse hashem elokenu with shame Michelle Sonnenberg tomorrow boss says if you allowed to say a Trina why not Yaffe avoid says the big day yes - our a beautiful year soit Tefila never backfires but feel as its feel like cleaner cleaner but if we say something in the context of Abraha even if there's no shimmer Malthus even with just a like a know that could be a brothel about Allah and one of his rallies Raisa Pella is our Gomorrah and Broca's the amore discusses there I'm Maria Mater Suffolk if they should make zine one frag Dybbuk there should just say it was Custer delt what are you losing says the big day yes yeah from this we see a Zemon that was not required if it has a Latino could be a brothel of Attalla so we have two precedents that even if it's not a typical broker if there's Seamus gem it could be a brothel Vitolo yalla yalla is one and Xiwen is to serve I said we have based on a big data that a Zemon of 10 that was unnecessary could result in a brothel about Allah I should mention the prima Gotham and cooked South exam Basin hecho la from also is nighter that an unnecessary Zima with a Latino could sour and become a brothel of a taller so as is often the case there's no room for ignorant Zeeman is not just Yiddish words it's a fee of grammar the rights of the rabble on you can't just skip as Iman and you can't say it unless you're sure plus I guess an added incentive they avoid rahama in the beginning of Catholic days in the new print a match in sama he says Dimona Sheva do libraries borough chambers Amanat Oh mushrooms as there we get out each other ready ooh miss vada me a fraud the hider is lloyd with a sharp right Olaf alright al chef a diverse I like it says God oh gosh I'm et under I'm emotionally active so with fur yield with fearsome I am a novice a sham demons an opportunity of adding a little more sheva so replace a we realize now semen is more than meets the eye let's apply this Lamesa a practical guide can a seaman be set on that so first of all let's talk about a common Shila you have two boys at home and about to bench without a seaman and the third brother comes can I just call him and take him to join us can they reek you recruited for a seaman what does he have to eat the same Schuyler iniciativa this is even more common Evo flea will be safely go to camp this year it happens all the time you have nine and someone just come you have to just comes so I won this mention we discussed this it was share 663 but briefly there was a call of the light pasta calcium then a Shiva there's no fee of Zeeman which we as we discussed does not make sense if we have booked a meeting together and there I'm talking terms and there is some connection why can't there be a Zima the olden days the bottom eight quickly they came they left they were hit and run there was not much food in the first place there was no pious but today burnish a man I tell you I fed very well they make a massive so to speak out of a meal if you ate together in a camp or you see Livadia make Zima but the question is if you're missing one can you recruit someone and join me if you have seven can you recruit three to make a seaman of Asura so this is a good Marlin broca's at MEMS I rather and small eight together and they basically finished but they don't have a seaman just then if see me came along and started quickly eating so Ravan noticed that he was eating quickly goes what are you rushing even if you eat you can't be part of our zealand because we finished eating it's too late small hurry dad and suppose as I say I take exception if they would bring us a dessert would you be able to eat it yeah and we're not stuffed when I hold masculine Gaza right so since you could eat I mean you still could eat we did not finish the meal if so we can ask ruff see me to join so this Kimura is telling us tremendous it is even the tail end of a meal when you're ready finished eating if you could still physically eat more you didn't finish and the third person can be recruited given to eat will soon see what foods and join the Zeeman and twice's of honored points out even though Rav initiative did not seem to agree but Rob eventually agreed to swirl so tasteless says wall agree la loca if to finished eating but they still could eat more they could make a Zemon by giving the third person to eat but twice it is one exception if the meal officially ended because they said hovel on the network let's bench ah that's a problem because once you said let's bench you can't eat anymore even if you see hungry have London a roof is a silica so tasteless reasons if you said have on veneer of the two people Roberts will cannot eat so then you can't join with ruff see me because you finished eating so we see to our locusts from this story number one you could recruit someone even the tail end of a meal and two plus one equals Eamon it's the good news but have long vanilla and you'll soon see how long deliver cos live to Africa if you said if you got my my cranium if you filled up a case even though grab that you don't music i sir tool but let's see how it seven and you want to make ten but once you filled up the kyster bench or you use my Mac rhenium the meal is over but what's more than this the ROG will fail because I in Simmons involve based on the Gemara says that if there's a third person suck the rajma and I quote the lotion value of him there's a field leaping lloyd given food to complete the Zeeman in other words it's not just the hectare to recruit someone else it's a field now the Embassy's why is it a picture dish when you have nine people for darvany what do you do with that Center so if you have three two people want to get a third if you have seven people and you can add up to three additional people why not do that and this is all quoted in chiffon our cooks have excited gimel Alif if they didn't set have long veneer off they could recruit one more 4 3 3 4 10 and hi-yah them leading lady the muhabba used the lotion of the rush of the Razvi now I should mention the mr. Brewer see if cotton Dalit says loved Africa fear Mitzvah but I'm its Estella Mitzvah in regard them and see if cotton olive says if you don't want to they don't have to but they're not doing correct correctly but what to me was surprising but you see that zine one is much more than meets the eye the bath has an interesting suggestion let's say the two people already said have longer never it's too late says the bath it's never too late you could go wash make another might see eat bread and then bench with this third person have one vanilla is all indication that you finish the meal and you can't eat without a new bra so the back reasons so make a new block on create the three of Zeeman kill apply you know but as the le rob assess and there her sofa and see if outlet quotes it that's already a feeler gasm to eat again just to make a Zemon Ashokan says Lajamanu ma'sha'allah - lastly skåne so the mr. burr does not even quote this bath but to me it was inspiring how the bath longed to make a Zemon you said how long whenever you can't eat any further with the original brach allah so eat again again that's not the a logical a miser but it's an incredible insight of how Zeeman is indispensable it's not just ya know maybe so you got to know when to say it and when it works when is it too late to say z1 so the Gemara says as long as the two people or the seven people can still eat now it you don't have to eat D it seems chloride and find them afford but it seems Clark there's no fear for the two people to eat with the third person if they still could eat they didn't finish the meal the mr. brewer and the sûreté see in quotes that's the Rambam schita that the two people have to be able to eat a culture a little bit dynamic leave to eat we have leader Casillas okay the Prima Garden has the Suffolk about this and look at our time and cynical topic Zion says I believe you have to have to be able to eat it cuz is war but Neman Eleni know the mr. brewer the same the Rambam that the two people that just finished if they could eat a culture they could complete the Zeeman now again I might be wrong so please correct me but I didn't find the forage but it seems very sensible that the two people don't have to actually eat as long as they are capable physically able to eat you could join it they could join with the third person and that's why I saw the Ark Ashoka in the beginning of course Alex Ayad quoting rush and tour he says it's almost never that you can't make a Zemon out because which two people elaqid don't eat until the busting they can't meet another call shoe so it makes sense meets add the two people or the seven people it's almost always that they could eat a little more and therefore they could create a Zemon the only problem which is most common if the two people said have long than ever or they brought when they filled up the case or they brought my my cranium all that is a form of have long vanilla now I want to mention if you learn the sugar you'll realize this we say a vice invention that's part of benching of course that's a silica this Halawa have a million is not providing on benches they only have two people this is saying let's banish let's bench is enough of a silikal so this is basically as far as the two people or the seven people basically they could always recruit someone else now let's discuss the other office for that additional person that's joining so the question is first of all what did I mean he's supposed to create a Zemon if I only have two people I'm eating breakfast me and my son actually go on the street and and cry out a Drita Drita if I have seven after Golda Street so mr. brewer and see if cotton olive says if you find someone who writes a level it's therapy my am do it what that sounds like is you have two brothers ate at home breakfast and as they're about to bench they didn't say I was on the liver the third brother comes oh that's very good right select oh good start but you have to go looking for a third from the mr. Breuer is not mash miss oh but the mr. Bruin keep coughs a big Zion see if cotton Zion and your olive is mashed my guess if you could get someone else be proactive and get someone else now I must mention you don't have to actually go into the street and recruit a third ORS or eight nine and ten mr. Bruin in chief cotton Zion says if someone's in the house try to get him and of course it has to be reasonable but if you have someone available I'll give you a very simple example to browse I'm about to bench and a third blocker sits down so good wait for him wait till eat the Cazares will soon see and then you could have a Zemon why not create a Zemon the question is this third person what does he have to eat and how much does he have to eat to create the Zeeman so here I'll tell you which is a macabre Jahanara curves a big Zion CVM Oh the Kaabah makes a distinction if you have seven people they want a bench you could get three people give them any food give them a an egg that's a good ice and and then you can make a Zemon for ten the additional three could eat any food but says the Makabe if you're only two and you want to complete a Zemon of three the third person has to actually wash and eat a keziah sub bread now we would think Epica Mostafa ten people's is a shame ahem mr. GRU explains if you don't have a Zemon yet how could you might serve some of the data an egg if you have seven already you just need 10 people early Cadle million any food is good so according to the macabre if you have seven people give three people anything any food to be say cake an egg a vegetable fine but to make a Zemon of three the third has to wash the muhabba it cooks out eggs and gibble says some say bizarreness is good for the third and some say any food but the macabre Baskins don't create such a Zemon that's in doubt if you have a third person willing to wash and eat bread present eight if your own will eat an egg michael type is don't make the semen but mr. Barasa the contrabass says Dominica alone is like the last cheetah if the third person eats any food you could make the semen so to put this practically you have two boys at home there eating breakfast and the bell to bench a third brother comes lava you give them an egg a bowl of cereal let Amita Casillas and you can make a semen what's a bigger fish what we just learned if you have two buckram two boys at home or two boys you see that about the bench they have no semen they should call someone the brother from upstairs whose are you planning on eating in the habit in with the kazars of food create the Zeeman give him an egg and Jessica's is probably egg is a double Casillas but our Casillas and create the Zeeman it's also very Nagaya two people are home and a third person comes to visit P macabre did not just ask the kyboot but create the fever's even someone a family of seven are going to a song salsa and three people came to meet them and walk together oh it's a grand opportunity the three people you have to give them bread with holidays give them a bit of food the cause is a food and then you can make a Z mother like a No even according to the macabre here I must dress the people that you are recruiting to create the Zeeman must eat a Casillas unlike the previous case where the two original people we said have to be able to eat a cultural but here to make a Zemon the additional people have to eat and have Peter Casillas you look in the mug and a drum as if cotton a it's also lavash Seif cotton Gitmo says the Farish the people that you're adding 1/2 theta cos iose and the husband's very posh it the previous halakha when the two people finished they're not eating anymore they don't have to eat they have to be able to eat so then the ability is enough but you have to eat here it's a fundamentally different I'll offer you want to join some German to join you and say sure Holly Mitchell I know we know the types of the word a fever is the cause is we just had the honor of a pays off pair of tights lamotte's ice stockings because is so this halakha to join to have a third person join or 8 9 and 10 join a million of 10 they not enough they could eat no meat gooey they have to actually eat a cause iose of food the next question is fine you give them an egg or I guess a piece of cake and they made a broker right now okay let's bench that's too late you blew it because DAF Godot make the broth afraid now this third person that ADA Kazan is his claim to fame is he ate with you if he makes the block right now then he's finished so he can't join so that mr. Burriss says if contest valve give him a Casillas tell not to make a brother cry now in fact as it seems from the kid to show Canara actually kitchen is buffet wish ma'am hey you'd the Robster Caernarfon see Fay it seems to also say this the best thing would be given mochas eyes to eat let him listen to the Zeeman answer wait till as honest a coil that completes the Zeeman and then he makes his birdie Foster's our album is here because we should be first that telethon is part of the Zeeman so let him actually partake in the Zima now for a Zemon of ten but the f7u ladder at three people and all they have to eat is a gazelle use of food that we saw but again here - don't make a bra Karina mr. Bruin sieve contest says explicitly if the person you want to add made a brach Raina it's too late we once had a child of someone was they Mahabad someone to eat cake and soda he already made an ala meal here and in fact what are you doing don't make a burner flashes but is it too late because you ready-made analogous here the answer is no as long as he is still connected with the drink with Barnet flash ice even though he officially stopped eating but then again he has a seat Brock Raina that would be enough a big question I wanted to clarify is generally when someone joins all you recruit him he ready finished eating he's not interested in eating he's not gonna have a piece of cake he said I'm not going to wash is it enough to just give him a drink on a hot summer day give him a cup of cold so the seltzer spring water coffee or a tea juice soda so the MS is there are two questions it's drink balsam it's tariff and which drinks so the embassies once the egg is found oh the flavor drinking is also part of a sailor but then again don't forget regarding the Zeeman of three the mahabodhi ask to eat bread okay we're making but don't push it maybe drinks is not enough so this is our Schuyler can you mix are someone that drank as opposed to eating and if yes is it any beverage to listen to a fascinating sodium choices in Broca's Memphis damasco tisha with the gomora says if the third person 8/3 owes 898 of food you might styrofoam sucked Isis who identity steer baklava Sheila so Tice's clearly says to make a Zemon the third or eighth ninth then don't have to eat drinking is also good why because since the ick is bartholomae shall I that's the objective we're trying to get to that stay of equality law but twice is lost chanise if he ate or drank a case of wine cozy ayan mitts tariff because you could say Shalom is shallow now that is very tricky because maybe choiceless Africa is speaking about wine wine besides being very flush if the maurices umbrellas yeah in a solute is Surveyor maybe wine is considered to how new Misha Lloyd who said a cup of soda is good for that we have a base Yosef but listen al that has the plot thickens sup the basin in Simon cooks Alexander muscle Venera even though tasteless says wine loved Africa wine any Mashka is good such minimim water doesn't help but apple cider helps the marshal and he sends you to air VIN the missionary VIN that car vomited base what's going on in let me share with you the beauty of this sucio Tice's the base Yosef seems to hold since the objective is to this third person can say xiaolu Misha Loy any drink is good because Tom Aquila steer bacala Gila but you need a food that's on that hasn't done as nourishment water of all the drinks has no nutritional benefit zero calories and toy and bass Joseph sends you to even have all the days that we see water is not good now look at me he'll Cosima the Gabby Irvin the Mishna says you could make an area of two men with any food except for water and salt because they're not Sun so the base Youssef applies that delicas Eamonn since Zeeman is all about hezonia Sequoyah you need a food that's nourishing the Mishna says an aryan what is that nourishing so the base Yosef seems to say loved Africa wine any beverage except for water and this is gap as Kent in shocked America static Zion Bay's any food pretend that is and for us any food for three even any drink except water comes again the Morgana from I'm gonna rum says I don't agree to this Makabe this is it we find that even water is considered a Fela and he sends you to your they arranged Lambeth festive base Sam I made a nether not to eat he can't eat and he can't even drink water because steais nyan is bacala Sheila says the bargain of rum since the objective is to be able to say chef Colin Lee Mitchell oi why can't water be good and then he says more so since then the car is twice this and traces of Steve bahara Fela what gives you the right to say what is different so now we have I guess I could say he concludes therefore I believe whatever is good not like the chauffeur Nara now I think we should be a little confused the basic says what is not good and sends you to Kosair even the monogram says water is good and sends you to help us Nidoran and to make this a little more exciting how about Elsa Steines you know they eat in a tightness you can even drink water so obviously drinking is what's called water bacala feel so now we're confused debate the basis points you to hook us a ribbon mug around points you tell size tiny so we said we said Titus and the dharam and also what's the Eco Giocondo or has on comes again the big day Yasha of an art since the basically Civ is right what I remember is that right boy let's do this far really water is not a form of a fever there's no Sun I and it was the durian when you made another night think you can't drink water because the net is he wants to call he wants to have some self afflicted pain but sue rain of shape he wants to create a ticklin so he a self-imposed pain so if you want to feel the fast you drink water you won't feel the fast so regarding the durian and I guess we can't regarding Tiny's what is included but says the big day Asia for Zeeman it's all about Sun has an esse coil if so water is not a form of a healer regarding Zeeman now so he postions like the macabre noggin of rome but the voice that we could do better shimmer screen after him come to gain the time of moisture on art and he's a beautiful you soit what's going on here the basis water is not good John McKenna Velma says water is good Shalu since the camera is beautiful Toph you just learned brought it down long ago the famous good macaques mara Canberra's Zeeman we're a Zemon Gotoh does even conclude with the words shall demisch allow you to voice hyena is at the end of Zeeman what does a goat on a Sequoia said the from bad moisture if you olds even goes into lisanna Sequoia so the part of Z Monet's on whatever is not Sun that's why the basically she says what is that good but if you olds even go social column is shallow so the only criterion is chiffon though not as honest a coil she says that's why the pie skin go with the ROM law there are more passkey and Zeeman goes till jacala we shall oi and and and and therefore we could understand rom held like that like that cheetah jaw column is shallow and therefore is the end of Zeeland and therefore water is perfectly acceptable there are more and similar a shift base pass gains Zima goes on a Sequoia therefore lalala water is not good so the mark Shila is what a good for z1 is telling the old child where does even go to but he does admit that there's one major problem because the muhabba past kings that demon goes till Shahana me salary according to his thesis what it should be good but the same Aqaba varias just said that water is that good she says the macabre sheet I can't figure out but luckily my sir Rama is our schita and therefore we go now like the bog on a drum we old water cannot count now um I said the mr. Brewer does quote both days we look at the Lost it's very clear that he pass things like the macabre water is not good I should mention the bob kevoian of an art also discusses this Shila and he says for different reason waters good he says because the fever benching is we are held to be supportive hereafter and basically as he says it water is not sphere there's no three in water so he's coming from a different angle but the assaulter riservato Oviraptor does not include water and that's probably why the mr. brewer because he saw them that much the big day yes yeah he saw the monkey boy him so we could say the following wine is surely loved Africa but any Mashka except for water so now we go a step further which really I found very intriguing what is that good other mask is is good how about typical mask is that are basically water seltzer coffee and tea is it great Mayan soda in other words if you have orange juice 100% pure orange juice that's pure orange juice that's an Oscar apple cider but let's see have soda that's mostly water so let me explain let me share with you what I found the beautiful onion the Mishnah and Broca's says if someone drinks water and in that thirsty there's no brocco why because water has no nutritional benefit and no one having taste if you're thirsty and drink water why they make a broth but take water to get down the pill there's no Brock on the water and that's then even the mug enough rum that holds what is good says they be a local enraged outlet see if tests seep sighing I'm sorry even the mug around those water is good if you're not thirsty you just drinking the water to make a Zemon you don't count because you don't make a Brock on it there's no Brock wine in it and it could cost we're not safer but let's say you enjoy the water I'm gonna Rob says it's good we pass keen it's not good oh now let's say you take a cup of salsa or spring water for soda to swallow a pill so this V once discussed this is a beautiful Indian some say CELTA has taste it's like soda and it's a beverage even if you take me to swallow a pill because seltzer and some say spring water has a taste it's only water that's tasteless and has no nutritional benefit now many places what are you talking about if you don't enjoy the taste of water ice of why it's also better and certainly spring water you know there are some cynics that will swear if you take tap water and put it into the spring water bottle and give it to a quote a discerning taste they'll say oh this is spring water they think they can take a difference but Lamesa is there a difference anyhow but here's what I want to say a finish even if you hold in health as Broca's then you make a bracha on spring water and seltzer even if you're not thirsty because it has a taste that's regarding he'll face Broca's with the deciding factor is hanno so you could say salsa has had no but the gap is even the deciding factor is son salsa is plain water spring water mineral water is playing well who cares it has a taste that you make a Bravo there's no Sun so it comes out that salsa and spring water even if you old you make a broken all situations will not be good for Zealand now someone SP but club soda has salt in it I told him good you made it to a mission er the two things that I've knows on is my mmm Ella so if your assumption is right the club soda is water with salt with sodium it doesn't count now if this is true which I think it is we could advance that say this one step further you give someone a cup of diet soda that has big bold letters zero calories you could also that also doesn't work because if there's no calories there's no nutritional benefit so in regarding health as Broca's of course diet soda maker bracha in all situations as a taste but regarding semen celsa spring water them and even diet soda does not count the next question is how about coffee and tea there is some ingredients to it okay it's not a keziah sort of tea but maybe it's considered a tea anemic serious now myself since this is very Nagaya tea coffee soda powder drink we called used to called kool-aid that's equally maíam but there's some food stuff to it so i looked into this and i want to share with you what I found there Hashanah coughs at exile Ian hey postions like the Mahabharata Magana from what is not good and therefore he says but any drink that has a Shiva's sauce is good therefore if you drink Miami sooo kaanum improved water can my Seltzer lemonade I mean a Clausen now Enoch fuss and cooked I see this red curve above all of salahuddin is a wheat drink I'm not sure what it was but that's where we drink humid styrofoam to the Zeeman selves up lemonade and make awesome now this is very understandable because lemonade and my cousin has some ingredients that are severe according to their - coffee tea presumably is also good maybe better because it's a cost of a drink but the pellet to me was his first example of salsa Celsus claim what we said so maybe there are hishaku knelt since it's miss sook on its prepared it's better but the MS is I I seem to remember I verified this with people then a mulligan sight in the word salsa was a word used for carbonated beverage soda was called salsa because they had the combination so it's more likely there are consultants Elsa is our soda ah damaged things beautifully Seltzer is soda lemonade make fussin are all good for Zeeland okay now we have to add even though there's no cause iose of ingredients but this cup of soda became so it's a good science of soda or a vase of soda I should say and you allow to air them to Zima according to this a tea or coffee it could be even better besides being some emotions it's also hardship it's not for shooting its assets for sure the only drawback with coffee and tea is if you don't have if you don't make a broth crema on hot drinks like the mr. Brewers sack and you can't be counted as even the aleph is you have to make a profit right now so he'll drink it quickly or your wait till it cools off but Laharl a Turkish Olson coffee tea soda juice is good I looked a little further there's a marsh AG and Gaelic base seaman cook pay he was asked about if someone drinks soda vasa he writes does he count to the Zeeman so the car shark says no because soda Vasa is plain water regular water doesn't count he says if it cut if it's playing water it's not song but then he adds a listen to this he says when can you count something to z1 when there's some ingredients in it and then he quotes the or - that lemonade and make awesome is good so suck the Marchand okay I'll accept there - but soda Vasa is plain water and can't count I was once again confused if he accepts the oarfish ocean that lemonade is good why isn't soda good Oh so here again I'll tell you something that I verified that so the Vasa is not the soda of today so the Vasa was Elsa in fact in its role today soda is Elsa the marsh AG seems to agree to the artist also that lemonade make Fossum and soda of today is good his soda Vasa is like we just like he himself says Mayan seltzer so it comes out a little funny there Herschel consents Elsa but he means our soda the Mossad says soda Vasa but he means seltzer but I think what my son Shalimar you throw seltzer doesn't work it's a cream I am and as a diet soda shouldn't work but regular soda and lemonade and coffee and tea should be good then I saw the merits they succeed the schinsky in the 207 hvala he was asked if you commit sour some of the drinks coffee and tea the bulk of his chuhwa is that there's no there is a Brock Rainer on coffee and tea not like that no like the mr. Brewers sock but then he says but wait a minute isn't coffee and tea aquarium so he says a very unique reasoning he says if you cook vegetables with water the broccoli is very pure dama make washes she says coffee and tea are like vegetables cooked in water maybe she make out dama on coffee or tea he says it's not the Minich but he says that coffee and tea is like a food like like a vegetable soup a Nevada it's counted into Zima so I think we're comfortable to say water sells spring water diet soda does not work - it started for Zeeman but coffee and tea cider apple juice and even soda although it's a cream I am but we saw Marcia Erica shokhin and Moritz and other place kill the aura let's see an obscene Amish allah mohamet base he says only drinks myths TV which would be something like orange juice or cider that's pure juice counts but anything that's coffee and tea is it grammarian okay that's what he says but as we show mo spice Kim seemed to be Mako and I think we could say that especially as we said earlier if the market of rum holds even what is good so we're not say makan that but definitely if you have a drink that has something to it that we could count now you might say if I character but then again macabre says for a seeming of three you have to eat bread so why use a drink okay but weep askin for a Zemon of three you could count other beverages and the miser the sock Leonora anti-sea says char Mashka cuts me Maya so soda tea and coffee is not my the only thing I must mention again if you use a hot drink make sure you end up with a burner for so it's either you go the sheet is your maker hot or your drink slowly one last group of questions I want to mention when someone answered when could he answer a second time I'll tell you about the bare moisture that Bettina Robin hang the gimel cinnamon LOM agimo has the following Shila he says it was there are two boys that they ate with their father I think was supper and then the father went to the shear so the boy stopped there Sudha and they answered the Zeeman of the father the father went to learn the grandfather joined them and and then they weren't gonna make another Zeeman after they were late so they made a seaman the father came home from the devasena rush it was a true story and he found out what happened he goes you can't I heard from the Rob they've seen a Robin this year you can't join a second Zeeland you ready answer to me you can answer for Sadie so who's right when can you answer a second time so again replace ice in seaman is not just a few years words it's a field which could turn into a brothel of Attalla we have to learn the circuit properly so I'm gonna use one muscle to make it easy and the word the name moving I don't like using the name move ain't because move ain't dies room and fell to evil but this is a happy story a typical case two people ate and they want the magazine man so they recruited moving they gave Wu Vayne a Casillas and he answered good now Ruben is sitting there and two other people start eating no people can they also recruit Reuven give him a Casillas and it can answer twice so it's Laura why not you could say kedusha as much as you use I ought to say why can you make wits are after two Z moons but the fundamental philic is kedusha is a den of minion so answer a second time but Z moon is totally in Aquila how could you answer a second time oh I understand so what's the problem Reuven eat another cuz I use so we could say yes if Wu vain want answered once and now he wants to answer a second time as long as the Erica's alias he's fight the answer and that's the sheet of the tour in the end of simin race very brief they yes the rush can answer a second time and his answer was yes sucked the bath mama shalva case he answered to group number one he can answer the group number two why why not then the back had an important point that we must clarify says the bath the Gemara has the following Shila that sometimes para Zeeman mean i you you can't answer a second time now i'll redo the lotion up of the circle American cooks are begin well hey I'm actually I'll tell you the story into chef Canora and again we'll use Ruane as an example there were three groups that ate separately and they all had a moving can move in to be very lot of miles moving and they all answered the three groups made a zine one but the three routines are slow it is they're very very much in common and they join together on the eighth and the complete completed their meal can the three rulings now that they're together and they ate together a cos I assume what can they make a zine one so the muhabba based on a gomorian learn to come or you'll see two kumara that's perhaps Zeeman mean i you these three rulings or all augustine ones they ready made a seaman so the box is asking himself so one second so how could I say you could Rubin could answer once and a second time the camera says part of Zimmerman are you sucked the back let's push it in the case that the the three routines they all answered Zeeman to a group and there's no new people it's the same old three rulings you people are ugly zealand but our case moving answered to plane in our mighty now Shimon a lady came along a nuclear I knew here they could answer so the critical factory is there a new Mathias a new group of two then moving to the answer to 1/2 a second and even a third sister back but if there's no bulk if there's no basis of new here it's the same moving moving I'm moving that got together that's part of Cosima now let me give you one example and then we'll apply this Lamesa that will click crystallize this holy site imagine the same case you have three routines part of three groups same story and make it very simple but they didn't eat with their groups they ate a Casillas just to make a Zemon so you have three rulings they're very similar as you could see they all later cos is an egg and they made three Z ones then they got the gun this is a we're still hungry all that is a cause is they sat down and he washed can I make it seem at the end of the meal says the car for Jaime's you've gotten club of absolutely why not I've already answered they answered as a third person but now they're making a new Zeeman a new akela they're not just continuing they're making a new a healer the point is you need a new Messiah to answer a second time so to apply this Lamesa let me tell you the following beautiful Shiloh consider you have six people that ate together to have to go so moving is always doing a mitzvah rule vain answers to them and they go now you have three people left and one of them doesn't want to bench doesn't want to answer can Reuben answer to this other group of three says the Yoruba and Lucius throw the cup of crimes it's got enough quotes this absolutely.i why Tarek's is beautiful because the three that remaining didn't then make semen yet there are new people so they have a fear demon so Ruben can answer to them first group of two and then to the group of three they want you to see me with the two if is only five and groove ain't answered to the bulk of them so the whole group is a group at third but since you have a surviving group of three after ooh lenient said they create the fear so we rank an answer to one group and to a second group but wait we haven't seen anything yet I'll show you a cons let's say the initial group was eight okay two people had to go so good old move ain't answered then two new people had to bench good old blue veins a lot of answer because they were FD finished the first group there were five remain is okay so we make an answer to the second group now he's left with three more Ruben could answer a third time as long as you have a remaining surviving group of three moving can answer to ten to two more and then two three it's update and raise Apella the bargain I from says if Ruben answer to a group of five including himself he can answer a second time but seven and eight he creates a second time Jacques de la vache shrugs seven or eight is loved Africa because if he began with eight he can answer three times but seven I can only answer second time so came out to me a little of a finish that really the mocking Rama should have said six or eight six he can answer a second time and eight it can answer a third time and Lucius errotica wonders why I'm not gonna roam hopped on seven right now carry seven is like six he can answer twice eight he could answer a third time but what's interesting is let's say he had a Zemon of were all together five people so that is the fair in a locker room ain't answered once he can answer a second time because they they were you ate sapporo seaman mean I sucked the Evan Orissa on the back of the ship honor and the fascination morale of sitcom a quote passing this if the two people a war they created a new field and then Rubin can answer to the second group even though they park a seminar you the mr. brewer in Civ cotton seaman race if cotton test does not agree and I understand why because l'm I see you were you're it's a seaman no appeal doesn't make a new fee of Zeeman it's you allowed to answer but once you were Yates with the first seaman is up the Mishnah Brugha once they were you eight sir eating more does not help question tricky question you have a group of three two people one a continue eating and one has to go so long as that I'm going to stop but decide to be a nice guy and the to stop for him now he left and you have two people and good old Ruane came out of nowhere and wants to join can moving join to these two people and voice it's possibly device the answer is no that's part of Zima the two people the ball cavalry answered and that's the ferry to rob and Simon race if they said the seller the bear Mauritius question talk we understand once they answered the anakov answered to the father pair of Zima they can answer to this ADA the Big Finish that the bargain of rum and semi rage mr. Brewer quotes this is when you answer all ten answered to a of ten and then they went back to eating they can make another Zeeman of three i what do you mean you already answered so this noggin aromas big finish that if you answered a Zemon you were you AIT's a Zemon if you answer just to make la que no they have colbert source finish area you want necessarily rights Azima you were you late to say much them so you were not you ate Susie Mellen the three people that answered for the ten well your eats a shame a sham they can make a Zemon of three now of course what you could do is answer to the Zeeman of us are and have a mind to be AIT's a Zemon also then you can't make another semen and then we leave you with three interesting questions it's really one leads to the other you had a three people or 10 people that had a sea of Zima they were so apps might they just bench without Zima can you make semen after benching especially now we're learning to send Mitzvah cuz over there i satura bottom so the macabre in the beginning of cotati Daleks says it doesn't make sense Zeeman isn't a Hanukkah benching after you benched it's too late okay good next question it happens quite often you had a minion of ten but the person was absent-minded the measurement in the varkala me shallow and then i'm said promise ie no and then so this is the shuffle north in cook Sadek base at the end once you will bench with Zeeman you can't make another one of Lak know your Yeats azima I want on the cane with a Fallon now listen to the third Shila three people ate together on Shabbos were young teeth and they all three forgot to say yalla via voice or would say when it's Moroccan so all of the bench over says the macabre and cooked a festive tests they all have to bench over but they don't make another Zeeman cozy when you were eight sir especially if you all the benching also you were you ate the bench and you see mystic in a scar but without that you were your it's avenging he oats is even benching after bench over but what's beautiful today says sofa and mem Halen battalion says is match from Russian assassin are then let's say they were really forgetful not only forgot to say y'all of the other you would say but they forgot to make a Zemon and then a cop they made two mistakes it's possible that they could bench over and now make a Zemon but Larry this is totally in the old Schuyler if you old without a scorer Yates just you're missing a scorer I'm not so sure they could make a Zemon again but let's cause all we learned today resurrection demon is a lot more than Yiddish words some say it's the riser as at least the Rabanne on it's a field you try to create an opportunity if there's no fear of and you say it it's a brothel of Attalla if you have two instead of three or seven instead of ten give someone to eat ideally bread but a locker any food is good if you already said have long vanilla or you got my refraining or you got got got ready to bench and you clearly has a fat ass it's too late but if you didn't say that yet a cause is is enough loved Africa eating drinking any drink we said except for water cells spring water or diets or any water any drink that Surveyor soda juice coffee and tea if there's a bra crater that is you could answer a second time if there's a new Messiah you could even answer up to three times or more as long as there's a bulb Messiah when do we say Perkins Zimmerman are you when the person actually the bulk made us even if you have eight people then the our event could bench make three times even six people you can make two simens and as we said if you forgot to make a Zemon or you forgot to Lak know it's too late and if you bench with algae olive oil you have to be benching but a Zemon is not repeated thank you all for listening and the wonderful week