0:00 / 0:00
When a Telephone Appears on a Remote Island, Regular Logic Keeps You Trapped
1,056 views
Torah Ohr Beshalach Vayaar Yisroel #4 - The Parable of People Growing Up in a Dark Pit Who Split Into Believers and Not-Believers For Source Sheets: https://www.theyeshiva.net/jewish/7354 Dedicated by Susan Goldberg, in honor of the blessed memory of Aryeh Lev ben Zev Wolf and Yocheved bat Matityahu Goldczer, may their neshamahs have an Aliyah This class was presented on Wednesday Parshas Yisro, 17 Shevat, 5780, February 12, 2020 at the Ohr Chaim Shul, Monsey, NY
Categories:Torah
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
the yeshiva dotnet okay good morning
everybody welcome we want to especially
welcome the Ukrainian guests the guests
from Ukraine are gracing us this morning
samatha Bayes column 1 or page 123 the
word startzville okay in the middle of
the page
he said via a minibar violence taqueria
buy a minibar via who are valued ella
ella Almeida Scottish ain't a Negro
Muslim Willa shyest Bipin acidic a
mimouna 5i you know assertion and by
amino Basha
so yes the muna should come before year
answer is it's very different the Year
represents a certain distance but also a
closeness because if I'm in awe of
something I have to appreciate it on
some level there has to be some sense
some experience that's why every year is
the same letters like every year we have
to see you have to see there's some of
the some appreciation it's not AHA
that's year it's a sense of or majesty
but there's a certain element of Riya
she says there's year by year US Army's
in Hawaii Adele eSATA almond is Galya
the world that's manifested it's
revealed of I am in Obadiah he has to
repeat Hawaii because if it would save
same Hawaii you would be missing the
point where minnow bhava is a via de la
Isla
Alma discuss a nine a domicile
it's the world it's the reality that's
not seeing by Yi Rou year Oasis ryomou
Sigma Saga
comprehended grasp like lajas cigarette
well I shared my penis unit so even year
is not available there came the proper
the experience of it can only be through
what we call a muna
well offensive Haggadah laggy beaver
brain mish - er the opening wish - sure
we identify her Shama three terms
okay look Avram it's a gak of a kala God
Allah give Ivana which comes from Ashura
been in safe Eduardo martially it's upon
him like Assad but an interesting thing
is a devolve is only by the third if you
if you if if you wanna Volvos you want
the prefix of evolved like and in
English and so huh god oh okay
huh God though Vera get over her now and
aunt she says shall the Ospina schneider
sort of Leah still evolved for him to be
Noah Noah is that which is odd the new
dish is called forest ik - first ik
right neither is that which triggers are
mo an experience of here no it is
awesome awesome the first is we have of
once involve a penis I'm shocked I'm oh
my little not the Leah's penis later
for me to experience on or it has to be
of or first because the valve is is the
letter that represents how chakra
communication from a higher place to a
lower place to the point that I could
see and therefore I can be in orbit or
could only come from a certain closeness
an appreciation a sensitivity the purse
to people could seek it could meet the
same reality and meet the same person
one is not affected because they don't
they don't have the tools to appreciate
it in their world it doesn't mean much
the fact that one person experiences
euro are talking a year is voiceless a
year of all of the grandness of it where
I feel inadequate not an adequate in a
negative way in a positive way because
it's so it's so big I'm coming face to
face with something so so infinite this
is a closeness you have to be able to
have a sensitivity for this some people
can just ignore it and miss it
so sometimes in you know people say oh
that's oh that's that's a greatness you
don't get lost in anything that's not a
compliment certain situations not to get
lost is a very big compliment but in
other situations okay
unfortunately you just you missed it you
know there's no his spotless by you you
don't get in this ball from anything so
when you get hurt a lot of times people
decide that I'm gonna get into small
from anything cuz they don't want to be
enraptured what's the word in raptures
huh
yeah enraptured nobody's gonna
enraptured me it could be expressed in
you his spineless comes from the word
Pola something affects you his spineless
means vos rest in a spa right something
is is piling you from the word Pola it's
affected something the person remains
cerebral I remain in my own my own orbit
I mean I'll look into I'll observe you
but it's from a very distant deep
distance year is a fairy is a deep
experience F elitsa he loses himself
there's a certain boy she's there she
says that comes that night and he always
needs evolve
Frosch m to be able to be known as
Weaver it has to go through the volver
noida which was I'm sure come on Milo
LaMotta Valliere OS of ayah then there
is a violin o V amino is that which year
which we ear can't touch my eyes
physical or spiritual can't see it in
the sense that I can really grasp it
it's Alma discuss here it's a
concealed reality here he says way I
mean above I am the fascinating thing is
that moisture comes in the second you
could say they had year from my show so
it's a very interesting posit right they
feared God and they believed in God and
in my show we say it every day so we
don't realize every it's not it's not
it's not a regular possum
they feared God but they believed in God
and in motion moisture Zaza Majorca
suddenly he gets his on a Munna and
wasn't me they believed in motion what
does it mean my shaft day right they see
motion they seemed I didn't have to
believe that moisture is out there they
saw it it says in the filter the
mistletoe says on the posix well well
well Allah made shakaal misha mom in
Benicia ke loom i'm and ameesha olive
oil um and the opposite that's who the
mistletoe says which is an extraordinary
madras of the castle this is the
mistletoe which means it's one of the
earliest texts of terrorism alpha in the
turmoil the mad rush on choice so the
mistletoe says that this plastic teaches
you that if somebody believes in motion
psyche believes in our sham and if not
not I'll go for Shila what is it what
does what does attacker mean which
brings up another question what do you
need moisture what is the real role of
moisture to the point that it says that
the ultimate Davichi is mr. Aiman
curious yam service finally at the
conclusion of it all when it hit the
crescendo and finally the whole godless
monster ahem is over cause till Korea's
yam soup there was still you know
reservoir she says they still had such
tremendous fear of the Egyptians they
even thought that after Korea I am
something gonna come up on the other
side the sea will wash them ashore on
the other side that's what it says
clearly that's why if I yari sauce
Messiah mace else were so young and at
that moment the highlight of it is you
could save a amino Basha
amid emotion uber militia after after
Basia
now most obviously as avidly not much
separate moisture as outdated with the
word half days especially this he says
of emotion of the moisture openness
darvis Cassius Moshe represents what's
called das das is discussions connection
the post excessive variations we learned
many times valorum your desk over Adam
new hava and they had children cayenne
and ever so yada says adam new have of
attire she became pregnant and she gave
birth yada is a euphemism for a
connection for intimacy Adam Yodas have
right each lawyer da is an expression
man did not know her you dog doesn't
mean knowledge cerebral knowledge I know
about you das represents his Cassius
connection which means on every level it
could be physical like hard them Yoda's
how he didn't only know her but he
connected with her but wherever that
whenever you talk about das on every
level it's always his conscious
conscious means the connection between
between the two it's not just knowledge
as detached knowledge I know what the
computer has information I also have
information was it's animal or Safra
bouquets filled you know the bookcase
has the most knowledge it's filled with
knowledge the camera has an expression
with some it's animal the sufferer it's
our Emily swaram the more says about
somebody who's a bookcase filled with
big books so it's a very interesting way
of describing somebody in other words
he's full of information yeah like they
say about a computer right it's full of
information but it's clueless it has it
knows everything but it knows when
somebody once said people who know the
price of everything and the value of
nothing so das is not just knowledge
knowledge is information das is the hiss
cos the internalization of the knowledge
because knowledge without internal
frankly is useless I mean it's useful
for for sometimes certain
accomplishments or certain creations but
in terms of the human advancement a
person could know everything but they
know nothing they didn't get it you know
so das is what other meu discover it
what you would call intellectual
intimacy because that's what yoga means
intimacy intellectual intimacy what mean
intellectual intimacy just like this
physical really so I really get it I
understand it that's what his conscious
means and that changes everything
everybody knows you could know
information and you may believe the
information it's not like you're
questioning it but there's no das and as
long as there's no das the effects won't
be the same because it's still like
aloof it's it's it's cerebral so it says
in swandam of kabbalah and synthesis in
kenya so there's a whole discussion on
the american base moshe represents das
mauritius - ah das what Scott Marsh is
das he motioned me shiver I am the
camera says in suka at the end of suka
that there were seven shepherds by the
Jewish people in Zohar there also
discussed of the seven or spigen of
circus
they're called Shiva Roy they're defined
as the Shepherd's mush of course the
PASOK says about him a moisture higher
ah he was a shepherd so a shepherd
literally that he shepherd the flock but
he's also considered one over the
timeless seven shepherds of the Jewish
people
what's the fault function of a shepherd
the Shepherd has to tend to the sheep
and feed them and nurture them and
protect them and help them survive in a
wilderness where there is often the
hydration and a lack of food and
predators dangerous animals and their
delay is responsible for the sight like
we have in your Marvel becoming you know
you give you its own to the earlier to
the shepherd to watch them much oh
you're right for who are mom cyclic
lawlessness o missis oh goodness Emunah
Vil okay nicker
Raya
mayhem in Zohar Moshe is defined as
Araya merimna ryeom Aminah means the
faithful shepherd mayhem has died Romaic
for Neman like the passage says about my
sermon called bassy naman ho Bala he's
trusted faithful loyal wasn't a loyal
and trusted he's the faithful trusted
Shepherd McCall basing them on who he's
named when you say he's an ish Neman was
meaning that each Neman in Yiddish is
called a boggle I Peter Mensch yeah
these are Finglas of Mughlai Peter
Mensch trustworthy human being in fact
in Zoya there's a whole section and
should say fresh moist these parishes
called Raya mayhem it's called the 7mm
net which according to the Zarya was it
was wisdom that was given over by Moshe
I may know who's called ryeom ahem
so the taxes he's a faithful shepherd
the ballot Anya Titans I am Emma
something else
I'm Roy in them on shiroyama finally
some mom sure cleanest Emunah
Raya man that means he's a separate of a
muna not of course he's a faithful
shepherd ah father Ryan man that means
he Shepherds Emunah Roya he Shepherds
his flock with a Mona Roya
he feeds them he gives them a Shepherd
feeds the flock he brings them to the
right grasses the right pastures in
order to be able to feed so Ryan ma'am
he's the roar of a Munna commercial
castle behold a sea anemone what certain
Emma again not just he's trusted III
like him out I'll show him what's going
on he won't go he doesn't have to go but
the whole base in Yemen who is that
moisture has the power to be able to
give a muna Neman there's a pathogen in
tehilim hooray a Emunah worry am Oona so
the both an attack Caesar am Mona means
hooray from the word Raya
or a and one that means you have to
Shepherd their mana because ammonia on
its own could remain aloof and that's
the function of das in ascaris to be
able to internalize it for who I'm a
habit of Micajah BAE's Javier's amount
so therefore it can connect by the
Jewish people the two states of javea
how valued the law SATA by you and I
value the Leila be a minnow full of a
number now sow that's where the Gomorrah
says in Broca's a two-year mill citrusy
he in lagaa be merciful the Gomorrah
says a messiahs brothers some of you are
learning now says in Paris a curve Moshe
says but after you saw Marsh I'm Willa
Cather Xiaomei must qiyam Lehrer Sasha
melikhaya the letters were called rock
of the DAF kibou and now what does our
sham ask of you already only to fear him
that's all he asks like like what do you
make you know Marcia Malik echo what
does he want from you he's just asking
the year so the Gemara ask some brokers
or to union most of citrusy searches
that means small is your is such a small
thing it's like such a it's it's it's a
it's it's it's insignificant like what
am I asking for you to do already what
I'm asking for you to do were ready give
me $5
what am I asking of you are ready so the
goods much this is what is I'm asking
only leaves are Shambhala Casa so what
does the Gomorrah answer in yeah the
Gaby motionless is what you see for most
it's a small thing so much it's a small
thing so the time the about Latonya asks
and Tanya I don't understand what type
of answer is that he's not talking to
himself he's talking to the Jewish
people
Mattie so Marsh I'm gonna catch a show
me Bach say for you it's a small thing
you're not talking to yourself so talk
to yourself and say what is God asking
of me on the year for me it's a small
thing he's talking to the people and
Bilal it's an interesting statement that
for most of us SM ISM
a clinic like a small thing since
touches here that year is very reserved
aya and why a minibar values at jávea
delaila so here in Mills's sutra say he
for moisture year is a small Indian
because year is Hawaii de la santé
doctor he says Friday penis Moshe miss a
Lulu penis a Via della Ella by Aminu to
be able to experience via menu in a via
delaila
for this one needs moisture phalanx IVA
a Turkish Irish and kinesthetic and
that's why at this point right before
creation so much to give an introduction
the jews were screaming and he was
screaming and he said I shall be lucky
member Adam Tahitian God will combat and
you be silent silence which is Alma
discuss in an almond is scarcely the
relationship is one of silence sticker
attempt a flourish that's what that's
where I'm gonna comes in and Munna is
experienced in silence the hardest thing
to do is to be quiet now to really be
quiet he told them to be quiet because
it wasn't easy but them tradition is not
a silences you want me to talk about it
you want me to talk about silence I
don't have a choice ya know the question
is why does the MacLeod come in there
via me no bash em boo boo mush and what
does it come in here yeah yeah yeah some
people think it's a livin Judaism you
say whoever yeah I mean the the the the
Washington's I her desire says is sparse
to say the moisture Michael Donovan
Donna there's a specialist of motion
every day and in MAGIX Robin says in the
solder shame by commercia so then I
could this avid I but even as after what
does it mean obviously moisturize are
they not much as a
as a separate Mateus Marsh is not a
separate mobile home base in Emma no
like um Navi commotion well what what
what is this engine of their mana or
motion self well we learned he came from
different Schmidty
and on the previous mine Mensch mice he
came from all different Schmidt by him
the hinners was to speak not to be quiet
by him he didn't want to speak her alpha
saw him quad Peck fat lush in that sham
said me some Pella other trichinosis
hope came the most have hope
moysha was the whole midsi's of taken
was absurd wasn't it wasn't he was
allergic to it shame not to tell him
that Kay llamosa have hope you don't
have to give up on the world yet enough
to give up on the enough to give up on
the world you could scratch the yet they
didn't have to believe that what does it
even mean by I mean that what they have
to believe it they saw the Marcus they
so curious young self they saw he picked
up his and it says 'not a yourself how
are young enough to believe and it's
after year it's not before and by you
they clearly feared my show so I would
think the proper thing is they were
afraid of mush look at me the man the
man knows how to do a trick or two or
ten or eleven right he has up his sleeve
what else is coming Simba Moshe always
said that it says - Lissa sit was never
as a Moshe I mean it was never such a
moment I mean even in the Haggadah on
peso he's not mentioned you know it's
interesting thing the whole our God
moisture is not mentioned once you would
think that we're telling the story of
Pesach Epis I thank you a credit the man
did it all by the way the APIs are
cyclic or assertive
- Lia not as a zone man but something
the Cockrum you mentioned a rush you
mentioned the time you mentioned para
you mentioned love Anja everybody gets
mentioned from love and Tamara they're
all mentioned very nicely they have
prominence their prominently featured of
the huh God
the Tom the Cheniere de ELISA outs
everybody the plagues just the frogs the
lice even the goats here and the and the
dogs he'd meant much is mentioned once
in the Haggadah not in the huh got this
boss ik when you're reading the Markus
how many markers the were right before
the before the section of the Delano and
he goes through he says this possible
that's wheeze mention in this Bostick
that's it in the text of the Hagaddah
itself outside of terrorism itself by
God is Michelle tis the text of the
Khazar not mentioned once I don't know
figure it out figure it out why do I
choose my she said do it himself
what do you need my shimmer car what's
the real role of my show what's the real
role of mush what is what is the essence
of moisture that's really the question
yet what are you looking at on Conda not
once you won't find his name worship
environment where I seen her his name is
not there no no text no text of the
Haggadah sometimes is different Esaias
but his name is deleted it's an
interesting thing when they made a
garden you would think that was
something I know that but mom are
incidental incidental okay we're talking
in ops are I mentioned I mean the whole
lot god they're really strange when you
look at the text of the Haggadah you
would think you should just tell the
story that they were in exile and they
left right how god is one of the most if
you don't understand the Haggadah I mean
I don't mean to sound irreverent but if
you don't understand the Haggadah like
if you're reading the Hagaddah you would
say and you don't understand you would
say it was composed by the most ad D
personality in history it's like the kid
asked for good question
wani answer then it's okay we were
slaves to party in Egypt and he took us
out okay it's a good beginning
suddenly where were we in Bnei Brak
there was a story they were there a
whole night speaking by the way once
we're talking about Bnei Brak yeah let
me tell you what herbalism been Azaria
said about you seeis mentioning it see
as mister I'm at night
whoa wait ah T could you just get back
to the story no no no no no no by the
way I want to bless a sham for giving us
the Torah and you should know this for
different types of children by the
Jewish people now let's talk about the
different types of children okay now
you've finished by the way y'all call me
Roy - why are we even doing the Seder
tonight I think we should do it unrest
tradition once we're talking about this
okay you know what okay he's Charlotte
let's sing the song they want to destroy
us in every generation happy you go back
to the story no no no no love and I
Romney was a really really bad guy I'm
gonna start this talking about love and
our army and by the way we have a lot of
Madras am I'm soaking embarrassed
bickering impartial Suki sovereign oh
the Marcos yeah let's do the Marcos
right by the way there's an argument how
many markers the work ha why don't you
just go back to the story why don't you
tell the story Schmoyer Aidan no no no
no no no now we're gonna discuss Diana
okay by the way we didn't mention tastes
of matzah murder
let's do pace of smarts a murder okay
time to drink let's go eat and that's it
no people don't realize this goes huh
you do realize this okay
the text of the Haggadah is one of the
most ambiguous strange ah in other word
it everyone has a fart of art here for
idea of art there but the whole
structure from beginning to end
yeah I'm sorry it's mamas like app you
could you could see how a brain works
yeah the main thing is never to come
back to the story and good for him he
never does he never does know if I were
to ask you to compose a text to read at
a seder yeah about you'd see as much
time what do you think is the natural
thing to do what should you read
you have a story choice Vader by a
beautiful story we read it every year
and career Sapphira exile redemption
emancipation you have a story really
tell it to a kid discuss it you know
that story is not read once in Paris be
Korean parshas key which is key Savoy it
takes took him from there and he starts
darkening it and only after talking
about that
why are you analyzing your family had to
say they understand was a therapy
session that's just no yeah you said
text on Shabbos okay now let's talk
about the different types of kids in the
family does she do privately with your
wife you talk about your kids you ever
thought about this look at the text
you'll see it's a very very it's a
fascinating text there's a pisser he's
trying to say something so I'm just
saying this structure is very important
and the fact what's put in what's not
put in obviously its I'm being humorous
about it but there is a profound
structure to it by not having that
structure that we would expect that
itself is part of the structure right
sometimes that's the best structure so
I'm gonna share two parables two
parables today parable number one there
was a remote location where tribe lived
for many many years disconnected from
the rest of civilization and therefore
disconnected from all the progress and
modern civilization and one day from the
sea was washed ashore a telephone
telephone was washed ashore they never
in a little box they never saw such a
thing they took it out and they brought
the expert
and of course they sew buttons they
started to press zero can I help you sir
right they pressed other numbers
nine-one-one how can I help you and this
was incredible they're hearing voices of
which sounded like human beings which is
of course impossible because they're
here in our remote island so that's not
possible they brought the scientists and
all the Hakka McCallum to analyze the
telephone and they analyzed it for weeks
and months and they looked at it and
they saw it then they scrutinized it and
they reached a conclusion the conclusion
was that when you assemble metals and
crystals and and matter in this
particular fashion right it's a type of
instrument that when you press it it
produces the replica the sound of a
human voice which is an amazing and
amazing thing for that sound as when you
have a violin and you have a court a
string and or a piano and you press the
key and this particular key produces a
particular sound this is unique some
just a sound but it's actually the sound
of human beings in a different language
that they never heard a different thing
they didn't hear this was the conclusion
very logical conclusion Emmis there was
a profound person there in the island
and he said I want to suggest something
maybe you have actually touched on
something that you have never touched on
before maybe this is an ability to
access the reality of people who don't
live here they all started to laugh I
was shooting sedated and you could see
their laughter right I just want you to
put yourself into their shoes crazy
person who has brainwashed you there's
no such a thing obviously it's just
between the lithium and the the
switchboards and the metals
this is the sound that produces yeah we
have to figure out to the other language
okay we have to figure out stuff there's
no question but it's obvious and we'll
prove it to you
the best greatest proof is smash the
phone and the voices stop obviously it's
all in the phone itself yet you smash it
hard enough right
there's no voices anymore obviously of
course ball in the phone there's nothing
outside the phone so what the producers
it's like you break the piano you're
breaking the violin you tear off the
court so there's no sound anymore that's
what it is it's just the phone itself
and they defined him as a senile old
over bottleneck old man who does not who
cannot anymore lead the community that's
the end of the story the fool on the
hill yeah what would it take for them to
consider what he say what would it take
for huh
can I could convey logically consider
what he's saying they would have to go
back to iron we know we the brilliant
people of 20/20 living everybody with
the hundred phones right it's obvious
it's not obvious of course they're right
they're dead wrong but they're dead
right
made in China huh ah
[Music]
Moisture Boehner didn't live in yes he
lived in iron you'd have to go back to
iron and that's the most difficult thing
to do I in uproots every yesh it's the
source of everything
you have to be able to go back to the
source to be able to come back and look
at it from a completely different
perspective if you study a little bit
about scientific developments in history
you'll see many of them when they were
first suggested by people those people
were not just laughed at but sometimes
killed the cynicism was beyond there was
a doctor there was a in Vienna there was
a time in the 1800's where thousands of
women were dying after childbirth and
they searched everything to figure it
out
and they couldn't figure it out women
would die the doctors were tend to them
then they would go in and they give help
the new women give birth and there a few
days later the women were dying the
numbers were staggering they searched
everything there was a doctor his name
was uh
Semmelweis and he he had observer he
said that they're going from the dead
patients to the living patients and the
hands the hands are not being washed but
nobody saw germs was nobody as germs
thank you who was at the telephone he
was locked up in a mental asylum in a
mental institution where he was beaten
to death today the world has him to
thank for doctors going over to the sink
and washing their hands but he himself
he was this is not a this is not he was
locked up in the basement and I'm sure
goddamn house huh 25 years later they
started to look back and they saw it
saved it saved hundreds of thousands
ultimately millions of people mothers
young mothers a few years ago the same
thing happened with ulcers yeah ah
same thing with ulcers happen what's the
reason for this there
there's a reason for this and the reason
is a person this is the thing as a
telephone if you read people who love to
deny that there's anything outside of
the body there's nothing outside of the
body consciousness is a derivative of
the body they'll always tell you look
the stupid idea that is a sold is this
there's something out something there's
something beyond the body itself look a
guy's in a bad mood you give him a
medication you shift the chemical he's
in a good mood this whole idea happiness
depression it's all it's buttons in the
body it's it's depressing zero you press
nine you press one one and look when you
break the telephone there's no voices
you break the body there's nothing here
isn't that the best proof in the world
cavaldi to proof here's the key things
get proven based on paradigms I know a
professor in McGill University a
neuroscientist his name is Yaakov Brower
so he he was once giving a lecture on
neuroscience and they had a skeleton in
the room they had a skull and he took
his son with him from his house just you
know to play in the university instead
of Maximus sugar the the boy I know his
summer he brings the son in six years
old suddenly he sees a skeleton not easy
for a six-year-old so he looks at it and
he goes over this father and he says
right Tati this is not a real it's not a
real body of a person first of all it's
white second of all there's an arm
missing and there's a leg missing and
also do screws everywhere for sure it's
not a real skeleton and his father
nodded of course it was a real skeleton
but the boy to deal with his fear
decided it's not and he brought proof
two screws inside and it's white and
there's an arm and leg missing obviously
it's not a real skeleton great proofs no
a real skeleton doesn't have screws in
it and that's it then you're fine
when I'm living in a certain modality I
have proof for it - it's great proof you
break the telephone there's no voices
what happened to all those people you
break the body there's nothing else
there's no consciousness you change the
chemical you shift it and everything
changes obviously it's just a piano it's
just a machine it's a functioning
machine that's it there's electricity
that we call life but there's nothing
else that's it there's not even
something called I there's no I uh
violin doesn't have an i it's a
wonderful instrument but there's no I a
colorful doesn't have identity telephone
doesn't go to therapy maybe today yeah
but the people make it Meshuga
in LA it's Shia but is most it's rubbish
it's rubbish these are all
fundamentalist philosophical abstract
religious indoctrination you understand
the mercial you understand the name show
here is parable number two as a power
pole from the Hasidim of the middle ear
Eber who was the son of the ballot Anya
there was a poet's an overlord you know
they used to do this he had a drew
didn't pay rent you know how all the
stories go took him and his family and
threw them into a pit it was a big
elaborate cave dark no opening on top
there was a little tiny lid they would
throw down food and water every day it
was miserable but so is life and that's
what they had so that's where they lived
and another family was throwing and
another family was throwing in tragic as
it was this was their life children get
older they had to get married their new
generations were born
kids who were born in the pit started to
grow up the old men and women died and
so life went on for many generations the
original people who were throwing in
were gone now was only the new
generations who came later but the
tradition was so powerful and so clear
that this is my life this is a fake life
this is a horrible life this is a tragic
life there's a whole world out there
with the sunrises and sunsets every day
with our oceans and rivers and lakes and
canals and people and animals and
mammals and birds and reptiles and
bushes and trees and sunlight and a Sun
and a moon and darkness and vegetation
and climate etc anyway after a long time
at shammed hakama had a brilliant man
stood up and said let's face it you have
been sold you have been sold a bowl of
cholent this is a ridiculous ridiculous
tradition there's no world out there
this is life this is reality this is
some good fantasize er who needed
something to look forward to because
this is a boring dead place you live and
die he needed to create some action and
tell my goodnight stories to the kids so
he made up in his imagination a world
that doesn't exist and he was so
convincing the two groups split there
was now fifty-fifty the believers and
the atheists the believers said there's
a world out there the atheist said
there's no and they used to argue all
day and this is what gave them action
and they made us a room against them of
course they said you're up of course him
and your coy rib and they said it's the
other way around you're a bunch of crazy
nut jobs they stopped speaking to each
other but then they got together again
because they only had one little pit to
live in and they were bringing food this
food coming in this food coming in yeah
of course it's part of the process it's
called the laws of nature food comes in
water comes in yeah there happens to be
a
some flow of water that comes the ghost
comes down you know this was back back
back back back
bye he I am you know the end of the
story but yeah yo him somebody fell in
they look happy
may a fiber yellow dasa we did this guy
come from this is where I came from with
where've you been
what are you doing here this is what
we're doing here we're living in the
world we're living life he says this is
the world there's all other words that
what other world he told them about
where he comes from that's the end of
the story that's the end of the most and
I want you to think about one question
this side that was in the cave the group
that was in there and believed as an
outside world versus the other group
that was in the cave and didn't believe
there's an outside world are they closer
in terms of their perception of reality
to the one who fell into the cave and
said there's an outside world you would
say they're much closer right
huh-huh really in facts but in
perception of reality are they really
closer in others who's more similar to
each other the two groups who are
arguing or the guy who fell a felon from
the outside world who's really more
similar to each other the two groups are
more similar to each other right even
though they're arguing with each other
the two groups are arguing with each
other they're ready to kill each other
but they're much closer you know why
because they live in the same world they
live in the same paradigm you understand
the two groups are really more or less
the same okay yeah you this your brain
works like this my brain works like this
you know mycav Russa is a better Canada
arguer you know
you see the two groups are more or less
the same even those who are saying the
truth what's really different being them
in the other group they happen to have
Mazel
but it's puzzle and if I was if if I was
sitting in your chair and if I grew up
with you in the house
yeah and if it would be a little more
cynical by nature right and the people
would sell me lies more often and if my
imagination was less fertile it's
circumstantial I say this you say this
he comes from there it's reality so you
can have a believer and not believer
they're more or less the same because
they're operating in the same reality he
happens to have Mazel he's saying the
right thing with em these are the two
mashallah that I'm gonna ask you to
think about today this class is brought
to you by the achieve Annette please
help us continue the classes make even a
small contribution at triple w dot they
ueshiba net slash donate