Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
What your TEEN really needs from you
1,603 views
Rabbi Shais Taub at the Evergreen Estates Women's Day of Learning addresses the topic of what our teens really need most from us today. #jewishparenting
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay
good to be here
as uh mrs pepsner mentioned
this started what night you said 19
years ago so
it started as a birthday party birthday
celebration
appropriate to the nine days so what
kind of a celebration can we do
for the nine days we can learn tiger
it's always a good thing to learn
and it started as an
and then i guess other topics as well
were added
so i know that there was a poster that
went out with the topics on it
if people saw the topics or i could talk
about whatever i want
solve the topic but that's why you're
here okay
but uh before we get into the topic i
just want to mention
something about meshia
we all know about the incredible
love that our matriarch
rahul has for all of the jewish people
who
are her children she is the archetypical
yiddish
and that she was made sinnefish not to
be buried in madison
which is the second holiest spot in the
world
by choice to be there on the side of the
road where her children will be brought
into gulas we're all uh
familiar with the words of the
of the navi who says
that a voice is heard in rama
but now rafa is crying for her children
and the simple meaning of the verse
is that when the eden were brought into
gallus the first time in the bubble
so they they came by the way where rahul
is buried and she was able to be
mothered off
on them to shorten the galas
and she continues to be motivated after
him and on her children in valles
but that that that's the simple meaning
and the simple meaning
on its own is already very very moving
especially i guess if you're jewish
mothers you can relate you relate to the
muscle
i mean more than i to me
i've never been a jewish mother um
i was raised by a jewish mother married
to a jewish mother
merit hashem i'm raising some jewish
mothers but i've never been a jewish
mother so you could relate to this
more than i can but the love
and the compassion the rahmanis
that a mother has on children it's a
special thing
that that's
okay so that's a simple chat that i'm
going to tell you what the owl ship says
he reads the he reads the pastic a
little bit differently
and it's based on dickbook
and grammar technically
the word shouldn't be me it should be
because vacca actually means she makes
others cry if it means
she cries it should be rocho she's
crying
but means she's making people cry
i gotta be attentive to the zoom people
to admit them when they come in
okay
who's she making cries
she's making her children cry why is she
making your children cry
so the al-sha says a martial like this
he says there was a woman
her child was sick and she brought the
child to the doctor
and the doctor said that he may not live
through the
day so she brought the child home and it
was uh
ed of shabbos came friday night
they lit candles but then uh the candles
go out and it's dark and you can't
re-light them so it's dark in the house
it's friday night it's dark
and she can't see anything and she has
her sick
child with her and she can't see the
child because it's dark and she can't
turn on the lights
and she wants to check on the child so
how's she supposed to check on the child
so it's a known thing that
when a child especially a baby hears
crying
they start to cry you ever had a chain
reaction at three in the morning
the toddler wakes up with a nightmare
then the baby wakes up
and then the ten-year-old and then
before you know it there's eight people
standing in your room
you ever had this before you can relate
to this okay the trailer yeah the domino
effect right
because when a baby hears crying they
start to cry
so what does this mother do she wants to
know if her baby's okay she wants to
check on her baby she can't turn on the
light so
means that this mother is
crying to get the baby to cry back
so she cries a little bit at first
she doesn't hear anything so she cries a
little bit louder she doesn't hear
anything
and then she cries really really loud
she doesn't hear anything
says
these are three types of tears each one
more intense than the other one
is the most intense one bitter bitter
tears
she doesn't hear an answer so it says
that awful
she refuses to be consulted she's
inconsolable
alba now for her children nano because
they are not
because they are not they're not what so
according to the owl
they're not crying she's crying to hear
if the baby cries the baby's not crying
so she she's inconsolable about the fact
that she doesn't hear crying
back
salship explains
also
she cries every day
that her children should cry back
and if they don't cry back she's
inconsolable
that they're not crying
the way she checks in on us the way she
makes sure we're still alive
is that we're still crying
so you think to yourself two thousand
years even in goalless
how much more do we have left to cry
you have to think about the fact we have
we have a we have a mother ruffle
and she has the compassion that a mother
has on a child
we are her children and she's checking
on us to make sure that we're still
alive
imagine hearing imagine you're the child
we are we don't have to imagine we are
we are the children
and someone who loves you like only a
mother could love you
like ruffle loves her children someone
who is maestro nefesh
in this world and in the next world it
was my sign fish in this world
she was making that fish in the next
world she doesn't she doesn't get to be
buried in the second holiest spot in the
world
all for what like a true jewish mother
she's nice and that is for her children
so you think about who are her children
you you are her children
so you think about a person okay she's
an alamo emmaus you never met mama
okay it doesn't matter the point is
she's your mother she knows you you
might not know her she knows you she has
compassion on you
she's worried about you she's she's
deeply concerned about you and she's
checking in on you to make sure you're
still alive
and how does she check in she calls out
with a cry
to see if she'll get a response
just like that that's it very good
couldn't have time did better
count of time did better
okay
so let's talk about the topic speaking
of
parental compassion
speaking of parental compassion
what was the first topic
why your kids need you yeah i think it
was more specific than that
teenagers yeah
who do we have to work harder to have
compassion on among all our children
than our teams
sail outside
the rolling guys
yeah you know there were once there were
three simple yidden
and uh it was pashas vallero
in show they heard the korea about uh
the al-qaeda but of roma vino brought
gitzhak to the arcade
so there was a few posture to eden
and uh after the korea they were they
were talking to each other they were
simple jews
so they were they were saying how how
old was yitzchak
by the akedah so one of them said well
he says he was a a nar he was a boy was
he was a kid he was probably
nine or ten the other one says no no but
then
he carried the wood so he must have been
strong must have been an adult
i bet he was like 30. and the other one
said no
no he wasn't 30 he wasn't nine he was
probably
in between he was like a teenager they
said no
he wasn't a teenager so why why wasn't
you talking a teenager
he says because then to sheffield
wouldn't be a sacrifice
okay so let's
why is it easy to have compassion on a
baby
and it's not easy to have compassion on
it
babies don't talk back yeah okay
you don't have expectations we don't
have expectations
compassion
you know the difference between
dean and rashmi
what's the difference between cassette
or what we call khasid
they're moving bringing in more chairs
so let's give them a second
so hassan would be
that a guy walks down the street
handing out hundred dollar bills
whoever he sees he just hands them a
hundred dollar bill
rich poor whoever doesn't matter
not even call a patient young anybody
that doesn't have they don't even have
to ask he just walks down the street
he's handing hundred dollar bills to
everyone that's called
din or guru
as he walks down the street and he's not
handing out anything
rafa is compassion
walks down the street
he sees people who don't look like like
they need the help
but then he sees somebody who looks like
they need the help
and he takes the hundreds that he was
gonna you know that the balcasa gives to
everybody
he takes all those hundreds and he gives
it to the guy who needs the help
what's the difference has it is i give
indiscriminately
i mean is almost like a redundancy
repetitive redundancy
because by definition has it is
the giver i'm giving because because i'm
about hazel so i give
then is i don't give a tantam i i
withhold
me as i give and that's why it's because
it's a blend of hassan and din
but i give judiciously din is judgment i
give judiciously i give with a judgment
what's the judgment
i look who needs it the most
so hassan is giving to everyone
indiscriminately
rachel is who needs it most
so i asked the question why do babies
get more compassion from us than
teenagers
it's f it's funny if you think about it
because
who needs more compassion
the person who's in the most amount of
pain
everyone's familiar with the expression
claim the kid that claimed that sores
grace a kid degreases right
but in our selfishness we think that
that's only talking about
the tsar gilbane but our own as parents
stop a second remember when you were a
teenager wasn't that long ago
remember when you were a teenager
grayson torres is the source of the
child
it's not just art saurus
what
so you don't have compassion on today's
teenagers
that's exactly what i'm talking about
you know what so you're saying that you
didn't speak to our parents the way our
teams speak to us
that's good you're making
means let them talk however they want
means
for a second just for a second can you
stop thinking about yourself
you're a jewish mother
think about mama raw think about your
selflessness
stop thinking about yourself stop
thinking about the fact that these kids
are disrespectful stop thinking about
the fact they don't do what they're told
let's just be empathetic for a moment a
little compassion
a teen is in a lot of pain
yes i know we were also in pain but
again you're minimizing you're
rationalizing
don't rationalize you know what it means
to rationalize
rational lies we don't want to hear
don't do the rational
lies write it down
it's rational it makes sense you're
right you're right
it's not going to help us this is not
helpful
stop a second and start to feel with
your heart don't be so
motivated don't just think in your brain
feel in your heart
teens are in pain all teens are in pain
because
it's nice to hinder the head they're not
children anymore they're not adults
it's awkward adolescence is an awkward
face
then if you have a child who's a little
bit sensitive
a little bit sensitive anyone has
sensitive children
they're all sensitive
that's why we are but but i said let's
stop thinking about ourselves for a
minute like
like a little selflessness for a second
four thousand years ago she was
maybachter
and she's still waiting by the side of
the road
so mama had also selfless 4 000 years
okay we could be selfless for four
minutes
i know we're also in pain i know we also
have our problems
i understand but when we talk about the
relationship between a parent and a
child
it's a clear one-way direction it's a
clear
one-way street we are the givers our
children are the recipients
we are there to provide for them not
just food and clothing and scarlet
and and camps we provide them with
emotional support
they do not owe it to us to provide us
with emotional support
is there a key of the aim yes there is
and we'll talk about maybe what that
means but that does not mean that they
are responsible
for your emotional well-being or to not
be let's predict because they need to
make sure that your feelings
are protected it's a one-way street we
take care of them
we are there to provide them with their
emotional needs they are not there to
provide us with our emotional needs
in fact it's probably one of the worst
forms of abuse because it's so insidious
because if you beat your kids or you
abuse them otherwise
it's more obvious that it's abusive but
enmeshment
where a parent uses a child to meet
their own emotional needs
doesn't look so terrible it's actually
one of the most destructive things that
a parent can do to a child
so no our children are not there to meet
our emotional needs
we are there to meet their emotional
needs
let's think compassionately for a moment
our teens are in pain and if
i want to tell you something if you
can't entertain that for even a moment
please eva mitchell
do not tell your teenage children to do
anything ever again
because it's an avedo of putting a
stumbling block before the blind
you hear what i'm saying no
i'll spell it you mean physically you
don't hear it or you don't understand
put in here
there was no such thing as teenagers in
the olden days that was right
they're annoying walk away they're not
going to help but they don't get it
that's it's in the omni letter so your
hand up before captain it's in the book
it's one of the letters that made it in
the book
i have no idea could you please repeat
it again
you know what my channel is my letters
and i'll come back
rabbi taub rabbi tao
yeah i'm trying to i'm trying to process
what you just said it's pretty
big the concept could you repeat it
again i'm going to repeat it
there's like there's like 150 people
here so i gotta wait till they get quiet
thank you people on the zoo
i said you need to be a little bit
empathetic
toward our teens who are in pain
and if you can't
try to put yourself into
a mode of compassion for them
then please do yourself a favor
and with sadly
no leaf means there's a prohibition
don't put a stumbling block before the
blind
that means to cause someone to do an
evader
to set somebody up to fail morally
if you don't have compassion for your
team if you can't
feel their pain then i'm asking you
please don't ever tell them to do
anything because you're setting them up
to fail
and there are much worse consequences of
their failure
than the fact that it will annoy you you
are actually causing them to be over and
keep it away
so it's safer and better you should be
mindful because the din
is that a parent who is michael al-qaeda
then your kids off the hook if you
insist on it they're not
so i'm telling you something if you
don't have compassion on them
please do not be over on leaf naive
by causing them to fail and i'm going to
explain to you why if you don't care for
them and you don't have compassion and
you're not sensitive to their pain
why you are setting up to fail when you
tell them to do things
it is partial human psychology
people don't care what you know until
they know that you care
if you do not establish compassion first
nobody cares what you have to say
you mentioned the amy letters which i
don't want to talk i did that for eight
years thank god i stopped
but what if everyone who ever read those
letters notice
what's the first thing i did in every
letter religiously
what compassion how did that show
validation
now why do you do that why did you do
the validation
you have to why do you have to because
do you hear what you're saying they
cannot hear
you can write the same exact answer it
could be two
three pages of very sound reasoning
but if you don't first validate and i
mean specific validation not just
general like oh you sound like a nice
person
specific value where you say back to
them things that show that you were
listening reflective listening
if you don't first do that
your whole answer is worthless and
that's when you're giving advice that
they asked for
how much more so if you're trying to
tell them what to do
and they didn't ask for it that if they
don't
feel validated if they don't feel that
there's a connection a thread of
compassion
coming from you to them they can't
listen
now you're going to say well it's their
problem
whether or not we love them or care for
them or like them
and you can have that attitude we can
see how it plays out in fact
it's not a theory we do see how it plays
out because we can see
for ourselves the results of parents who
stand
on that holy war that jihad
of cuba david and they insist it's not
my problem my kid doesn't feel hurt it's
not my problem my kid doesn't feel
validated
i told him what to do he doesn't listen
it's his problem and you can
you know there's an expression you want
to be right or you want to be happy
you say it a lot in marriage you can
apply it to parenting as well
you want to be right okay you're right
you're right your kid's wrong
where does that get you where does that
get you
so i'm saying the most compassionate
person that the archetype of compassion
when we're trying to think of a muscle
to embody compassion what do we think of
a jewish mother so i'm not even telling
you to do something that's unnatural to
you i'm saying tap
into your innate rahmanis
and i'm asking you again what i asked
you five minutes ago how come it's so
much easier to have compassion
on a baby than it is to have compassion
on a team
should be it should be the
opposite because compassion goes by
who's in the most pain
a baby's pain they're teething that's
the most pain they have teething
a teenager has real pain
they have a big enough brain to start
thinking philosophically they're like
staying up at night wondering about life
they start having deep questions they're
socially awkward
they're constantly all day forced to be
in a peer group
not of their own choosing so they're
always jockeying for social position
they're being graded absolutely
literally graded constantly because
they're in school
constantly being evaluated and judged
and told whether they're good or not
good
intense pressure they don't know who
they are they don't have an identity yet
it's very stressful being a team so i
ask you another question why is it so
much easier
to have compassion on a baby that have
compassion on a team when the teen is
the one who really needs that compassion
more than the baby
that's part of my argument i'm saying
if i if i listen to the people on the
zoom
i'm going to get a room full of 150
women talking
because while i'm leaning in and
listening to the zoom they're going to
start breaking out and decide
conversations i can't really
what are we saying back there there's an
interesting conversation going on
oh when it gets to that point where the
kid starts acting out then you know
they're in pain
yeah i'm asking how to figure it out
five years beforehand
you know what what i want to encourage
everyone to do
write down questions on these pages i
would love
to have this be more interactive but i
see what's happening over here
because we have noise and because the
room isn't so
controlled as far as sound so anytime
people start talking
i lose the room and it's it's not fair
to people who are
trying to focus and concentrate so
unfortunately i would love this to be
more of a dialogue i would like to be a
free-for-all actually
but i'm gonna say if you have questions
write the questions down we'll get to
the questions
but for now let me just
let me just tell you a few things and uh
without trying to interact too much
unfortunately i would like to do it more
as a dialogue but i just i think the
room is not conducive to it
possibly if the sound doesn't allow for
it does everyone notice that
that that happens as soon as somebody
starts talking everybody else starts
talking and then
what classroom of teenagers that's right
okay
go to the prince
okay
when a baby is born
everybody is so happy everyone's so
proud
baby can't do anything
and we have knackers from this from this
baby
in spite of the fact that they they
really they don't offer anything
they don't have no they don't they don't
they're not making a contribution
it's like i don't even know if i like
you you know maybe grow up learn how to
say a few words i'll take you out for
coffee i'll see if i like it but
babies just lying there what are they
doing
and yet everyone loves the baby and
everyone's proud of them they've knocked
us from the baby
take pictures of the baby he's in this
pose he's in that pose in the same pose
so baby has one pose
but i'll tell you what's right about it
it's actually it's coming from a from a
correct place
it's actually not wrong it's not wrong
that we have so much knockouts from
babies for doing nothing it's actually
right what's wrong is that we stop
what's wrong is that some at some point
would stop
when we have knuckles from a baby who
can't do anything
it's actually the deepest spiritual
truth
which is that the ultimate is from the
nisham
the fact that you're able to talk the
fact that you have certain talents the
fact that you
you know you do things well that's a
circumstance of your goof
of your body and your situation in the
world
but then there's the the shama which
existed long before you were
embodied before you came into the
physical world
and uh and that's there from the very
moment that you're born
and when a baby is born we're keyed into
that to the idea that there's this
this this being this entity called the
nisham but we don't articulate it this
way i don't think parents actually use
these spiritual words some do but
most don't but there's this there's this
feeling where we're
maybe subconsciously heed into the fact
that this
is a heavenly being
this neshama this gift
and because of that we're really really
all intuitively in line with the truth
that our child is intrinsically worthy
unconditionally worthy
infinitely worthy and and that's a deep
spiritual truth because
the neshama where does it come from that
a child
is intrinsically worthy unconditionally
worthy
infinitely worthy that comes from the
neshama because that's what the nisham
is nishama is intrinsically worthy
unconditionally worthy infinitely worthy
let me just explain what those terms
mean intrinsically worthy means its
worth
comes from itself it doesn't have to go
out and acquire something or accomplish
something
in order to have value the value is
built in it's intrinsic
that's the nisham
unconditionally worthy means it cannot
lose its worth
there's no way it cannot be valuable the
neshama is valuable that's what it is in
fact that's what it means it's
intrinsically worthy the two aren't
declined
and then the third thing's infinitely
worthy how worthy is it can you put a
price
tag on the worth of inishama infinitely
worth it there's no amount
so the nishama is intrinsically worthy
unconditionally worthy infinitely worthy
when you look at your baby you see the
shama whether you articulate it this way
or not
and therefore you identify this baby as
being
intrinsically worthy unconditionally
worthy infinitely worth
what happens they start to grow up
and then you get distracted by
the superficial conditions of embodiment
the personality the talents the
challenges
strengths the weaknesses whatever all
this stuff that is
battle that is of this world
that is temporary and you start to value
them
or the opposite based on those things
based on those factors
you know they've done studies that
toddlers have great self-esteem
and generally speaking around five years
old self-esteem plumbings
and the prevailing theory is that it
coincides with school
if when a child starts going to school
all of a sudden they start being
compared to others
and their self-esteem plummets
now if you send your child to school at
five i guess the self-esteem plummets at
five you send them to the
you know the it gets earlier and early
and earlier
i mean i think now they send the kids to
nursery school like two weeks old
you know when the other time is that
we're keyed into the fact that a person
is really a soul
and they get a free pass and everyone
says how beautiful and wonderful they
are
well they die yeah very good so
either the only time you get a break in
this world
is when you just came to the world or
you just left it
babies and dead people get a free pass
everybody else gets mercilessly judged
when our children are babies we're tuned
into the truth that they don't
have to earn our acceptance they have it
unfortunately as they grow up and they
develop personalities
and and they start to do different
things and they start to exhibit
different strengths and different
weaknesses
all of a sudden we throw that out the
window and we start we replace their
true
eternal identity of the shama with this
new
made up identity that has to do with
matters of the body how smart they are
how well behaved they are
how whatever just stuff that
you didn't use as criteria when they
were babies in their friend
so what's the real answer
if the question is how can we tune back
into the fact that your child is
intrinsically worthy unconditionally
worthy infinitely worthy
how how do we do it we have no choice
well how do we do it
that's true what do we have to do we
have to focus
on the soul so with immense apologies i
know
that people don't like the spiritual
talk
i know and by the way where do i get the
biggest pushback when i get when i get
spiritual
the froome crowds the froome crows don't
want to hear
if i'll quote secular psychology
everyone off the top good
very good
when i start talking to show
weird this is too lofty for me
that is not practical and they start
making arguments
but but
we'll get back to the cookbook we'll
talk about the football but hold on a
sec
your child is in the shum not your child
has a mishama your child is in the shum
if that's not the foundation of your
opinion of them
please don't even try to
is that okay
yes he had a moment
of uh teenage struggle
right you know about his teenage
struggle let's talk about his life
i mean talk about trauma
his brothers tried to kill him and the
end they didn't kill him what they do
they sold him into slavery i don't know
which is worse
he this teenage kid
who was just told by his family
that we hate you so much we want you
dead
i'm just think relate to it emotionally
for a second
then he he's shipped off to this strange
land
and over there what happens
all of a sudden people start admiring
him
this teenager imagine this thrown away
teenage boy rejected by his family
and then he he shows up in town and all
of a sudden
everyone starts he's jaw-droppingly
beautiful and everyone's giving him
attention
for his body
and uh he has a master
he's a slave so he has a master and his
master's
wife decides that she wants this boy
now he's vulnerable he's emotionally
weak talk about a a kid
who's estranged from his family
he was almost murdered by his family
members
so he's not just physically distant he's
emotionally cut off from them
and now he's getting all the special
attention
and now he has the offer of pleasure
i'm not saying this is what's going
through yes but it's mind i'm not here
to psychologically analyze the obvious
i don't think we're shy after that i'm
asking you as a muscle to try to relate
to it
how you would experience it where you
were completely rejected
by your family and then you were put in
the place of an assailant
where you're getting attention and the
offer of pleasure
immediate gratification and think about
that nassarian for a moment
and you're a teenager
by the way when i when i describe it
like this doesn't sound like a bible
story anymore does it sound like
something that happened
last week in brooklyn
probably happening right now probably
somewhere
a jewish teenager who feels completely
cut off from their family
and who has the messiah being offered
immediate gratification
for something of this world
because they feel cut off from from
spirituality
it's happening right now i'm sure i mean
i know
and uh so we know that he was tested i
mean uh
there's it's a much like us how tested
he was
when he went into the house did he have
intention
to sin or not
he at least uh in his mind he said i'm
gonna give in
again it's far be it for me i'm not here
to
humanize the obvious in ways that are
not
for us to do i'm telling what the gemara
says
so he's he's about to sin at least
according to one opinion
the amounting and he refuses
your mind with a chalice right
that means he was strengthening himself
with every fiber of his being to resist
he was refusing
and what what was the what was the
turning point how did he have the
ability to refuse
very good okay
i've heard this before be a moin he
refuses
he saw the image of his father in front
of him
des moines he refused how the yes of
mattis
of hiv yasip saw the image of his father
in front of him
so one meaning of that is that he was
about to sin and then he saw an image of
his father
and he couldn't do it anymore
he couldn't do it
tell you another meaning
he refused means he saw the image of his
father in front of him
what gave him the strength to refuse
what gave him the strength
to overcome this challenge when he
saw the image that his father
had of him when that became apparent in
front of him
then he was able to overcome when it
flashed before his eyes
how his father viewed him
means his father's vision of him
he was able to overcome
in other words because this teenager
knew
that his father saw greatness in him
his father saw perfection in him
he had the strength to do the right
thing
the image that a parent has of a child
is the most powerful tool that a
child has to stand up to the challenges
of life
the identity that's given to a child by
their parents
not by strangers not by friendly
neighbors or educators or the therapist
it's all good very nice
but the image of the parent that the
parent has of the child
that is what stays with the child that
is what
the child thinks of himself or herself
you can go to therapy for years you
won't get rid of that you'll be able to
overcome it you'll be able to
to circumvent it to get around it but
the opinion that a
parent has of a child that is the
foundation of your entire identity
and if that's your identity then
wherever you go there you are
i'm gonna repeat that wherever you go
there you
are you give your child their sense of
self
every situation they will ever be in
is going to involve their sense of self
so first and foremost before anything
else you give your child
should be a clear sense of self
and if you're a jewish parent i would
presume you would want them to have a
sense of self that's based on tyro
which means my true self
is my soul which is
intrinsically worthy unconditionally
worthy infinitely worse
oh but we tell them that we tell them
that they're
intrinsically worthy unconditionally
where they're infinitely worthy then
what's the point that why be good
it sounds silly but people say that all
the time but if you knew
that you were perfect why would you care
to do anything why would you even try
anymore you just let yourself go no
no it's better we'll tell them
that they we barely tolerate them in
fact we're disgusted with them
we put up with them but if they work
hard enough to prove themselves
maybe they'll earn a place in our family
and among humanity let's go with that
that's a good approach right
sometimes we have to hyperbolize things
in order to understand what they are
sometimes exaggeration is a helpful tool
let but let's do apples to apples i'll
exaggerate both
i'll exaggerate both approaches and you
tell me which one sounds more jewish
one approach of course i'm exaggerating
but for the sake of illustration i'm
exaggerating
one approach is telling a kid you're
disgusting
you you don't have a place in this
family
we barely put up with you but if you
work really hard
walk on eggshells to satisfy us
then we'll put up with you
that's one albeit exaggerated
version of that of that approach then
the other approach
you are perfect you're intrinsically
good you are god's creation
you have nothing to prove
you are loved you are supported
no matter who you are no matter what you
are you are our gift
we will always be proud of you
you tell me which one sounds more jewish
i hope that's i hope that's not true
and if it is you know every truth has a
little joke
this every joke has a little truth but
it's really every truth has a little
joke if that answer if that joke was a
little bit true
then i say we need a cultural revolution
because if there's any truth to that
joke and i'm hoping it was a joke
we have a big problem we have a big
problem in the froome community
and it's not internet and it's not slias
the big problem that we have
with a bit let me finish it this is all
you need to hear
this is the only sentence you need to
hear today the major problem
in fact the only problem we have today
in the firm community is that children
grow up in our system in our families
and our life's defender
and they leave feeling bad about
themselves that is our only problem
that is our only problem
somebody who gets a jewish upbringing
should come out of it should enter
adulthood saying
you know what there may have been this
there may have been that you know
maybe uh maybe i can't read and write in
english so well but i want to tell you
something
what i can tell you is because of my
upbringing
i feel good i feel
strong i feel like an intrinsically
worthy person
i feel like that the infinite god
cares about me watches over me
and has knocked us from me that's what
every jewish child should grow up and
say about their upbringing
and if one jewish child were out there
saying i grew up in the fruit community
and i feel bad about myself as a
consequence
that would be a hormone the fact that
more than one are saying it
we need a cultural revolution and i'm
appealing to you because you're jewish
mothers and if you don't have compassion
who will
i heard what you said about them about
the the principles
i don't rely on their compassion i rely
on yours
i do not rely on the compassion of
people who
whose job security depends on status quo
i'm appealing to your maternal instincts
we cannot allow another jewish child to
be raised in our community
and think that toyota says that they're
worthless
and if they have abusive parents at
least let them grow up and say
my parents were sick my parents told me
that i'm worthless but
hashem says that i'm infinitely worthy
we need a cultural revolution
and this is the one that could've this
is it
you're worried about permissiveness
you're worried you're gonna you're gonna
it's gonna be half cadence you're gonna
you're gonna
just fan the flames of the chutzpah you
know what
be my guest go continue doing it your
way try the oppressive
approach and see because if the church
didn't come from that i don't know where
it came from
you're taking children you're telling we
don't care about you we don't relate to
you we don't feel your pain we have no
compassion for you
but now here's a thousand different
things that you have to do every day
in order to barely be acceptable in our
eyes and you tell me that's not a
formula for footstool
that's where the look becomes from the
people who feel unworthy
and pressured and and they're lashing
out
if i treated you that way as adults you
lash out
so i just want to try to give this over
we don't have a lot of time i want to
try to stick to the schedule
and there's salmon with pastel over
there so
did you see it by the way it was really
good i mean i didn't eat it yet because
i didn't want to mess it up before
anyone
touched it but someone saved me up make
me a plate no i shouldn't say that in a
room full of jewish mothers would be 50
plates
but in the remaining little time we have
here i want to try to give
you are my ambassadors if you so choose
to be
i want to give you icees i want to give
you a language
for being advocates for the idea that
our children
are perfect and and i want you to tell
your children that
and i want if it comes up in
conversation with your peers to tell
your peers that
and also if it might happen that an
educator a school a principal
might not really realize that your child
has infinite worth
and maybe you could articulately
advocate for your child
and tell the schools
i don't want to get hung up talking
about the schools again
i want to tell you something i want to
tell you something very cynical
institutions have no heart
have no heart an institution is a
machine
no you said isis it's time to have a bet
make tall people short and short people
tall a mice it is one size fits all and
if you don't fit will squish you it will
stretch you and if you can't put up with
that then
throw you out so institutions i don't
have a lot of
i don't have a lot of faith in
institutions but i have faith in people
especially jewish mothers especially
jewish mothers
and i believe that if jewish mothers can
advocate for their children
that we will have a cultural revolution
where people will grow up and say
that growing up from is the most
emotionally
healthy upbringing you could ever dream
for
why don't our children say that we want
them saying that
just
but i'm not worried about the condition
i'm appealing to your maternal instinct
beside your your motherly compassion for
your children
we want our children to grow up and to
say this was the most
beautiful way that i could have ever
wanted to be raised
and the toyota made my upbringing more
supportive
we'll get to this i want to give you
like i said i want to give you issues to
be able to
to talk about this idea
father tells me he's walking by his 18
year old kid's room
kid is home from yeshiva he was supposed
to be working he got fired
or he stopped showing up six or one half
a dozen of the other
whatever it was and he's sleeping all
day
and he's just he just sleeps just in his
room sleeping
and he's got a smartphone doing god
knows what although
we don't have to say god but we know
what and it's
it's not just 24 6 probably 24 7.
okay we're talking about an 18 year old
who's not thriving to put it mildly he's
not thriving
he's not yeshiva he's not working so he
doesn't have any self-esteem from that
he's failing in life he's sleeping all
day
now if the child had cancer god forbid
this the discussion i'm about to tell
you would not have even taken place
but because he has emotional cancer so
now
it's a different story okay so what
what's what's the conversation
father walks by the room with the 18
year old boy he tells me the father
tells me this
he walks into the room and he says to
the kid
don't you want better for yourself
i want you to stop for a second
i'm going to hit pause on this story
[Music]
does everyone here you are jewish
mothers
i don't have to teach you this does
everyone instinctively understand
that that those words are a dagger
or a knife
now i also let me say i have compassion
under the father
i understand the father is in pain the
father is frustrated
and the father's afraid i think fear is
the biggest thing we don't talk about
this
but when it comes to the target of
bonding the biggest
component really is the fear fear of
what people will say
fear of what my child's future will be
fear of am i a failure
fear is a big big part of it okay so i
am compassionate
to the father as well and i understand
where it comes from when he when he sees
this 18 year old who's
doing the opposite of thriving and he
says don't even want better for yourself
but at the same time i'm asking you as
jewish mothers take the side of the
child
okay your mothers mothers always take
their children's side
i want to know something do you
understand intuitively
how that is a dagger this 18 year old
who can't even hold down the job that he
was supposed to hold down
it was set up by a favor of a friend of
the father and you know he couldn't even
hold that down he's family in life
don't you even want better for yourself
do you understand what a cruel question
that is
of course he wants better for himself
he's not capable
so the father tells me
child's response
is and it's very telling what the child
response was he says to the father
you're never proud of them see it's
interesting don't you even want better
for yourself the child says you're never
proud of me see child understood what
that what the words really meant don't
you even want better for yourself
really meant i'm so sick looking at you
i'm disgusted
i mean he didn't say those words but the
child heard the translation
he says you're never proud of him
so father tells me i told him that's not
true
remember two summers ago when you were a
counselor
you're all laughing because you know
you're already losing the argument when
you do that
that's like you know you never say you
love me
it's not true two years ago i told you
two years ago
right you're never proud of him never
doesn't mean never never means
not enough you're never proud of me so
he says i was proud of you two years ago
right
which implies the opposite of proud for
the past two years
so the kid says and this just blew me
away the father told me this the kid
said
it's so interesting how sometimes people
are so
capable of articulating their emotional
needs and we don't hear them
like the child said exactly what he
wanted
he made his emotional needs known but
father didn't hear
and he told it to me and then retelling
it back to him i was
able to help him to to hear it but
initially he did it
he says to the child i was proud of you
two years ago and then the child said
again marvelously articulating his
emotional needs the child says
are you proud of me now now
do you understand the courage
of the 18 year old who hasn't gotten out
of bed yet
to say to his father are you proud of me
now
do you understand how vulnerable that
question is
he's begging he's begging for parental
approval and he knows the odds are slim
that he'll get it but he needs a
desperate he knows what his needs are
like
like a person in the desert screaming
water water even though he knows the
odds are no one's going to swoop down
and bring him in water
he says are you proud of me now
says i told him no
now in slow motion replay everyone here
gasps
because you understand that that's
murder
but in a moment again i have compassion
i understand the father in the moment
he didn't understand what was going on
you know
i'm telling you the story not to bash
the guy it happened to him it's so that
we can learn from it so when it happens
to
us on any level not necessarily that
your kid is is failing in life
but listen children articulate their
emotional needs all the time even the
kids who are thriving even the kids who
are getting lots of uh validation who
are who are called successes they also
articulate an emotional need so i i want
to
i want to learn from this story so the
kid says are you proud of him now
the father says no i said to the father
first of all on an emotional level
i'm just so pained to hear that
but let's set that aside
as a religious jew just punish it from a
theological perspective
how did you dare to say those words
because what does being a religious jew
have to do with what i told my kid that
i'm not proud of
he said you don't know
hashem is proud of your child
how dare you not be proud of your child
he says hashtag was proud of my what
does this jump proud of my child
this is for the laboratories here i said
to this father
i said then this this child who you used
to have knocked us from when he was a
baby when he was a toddler
before he let you down what did you
teach him
when he was a little when he was a
little child and he was a toddler what
did you teach him
how does every laboratory teach their
kids when they're little
hmm 12 took
they will inherit the land forever
nate sir matoy my sayordai
the branch of my planting the work of my
hands
heir to be proud of
hashem says he is proud of jews
not because of anything they did to make
him proud
because of what hashem did in making
them
i see you other least part of the looks
at every single jew
and hashem is proud now is there another
thing
yeah that's another thing there's a
second thing called i'm proud of your
actions
as well i'm also proud of your actions
but that's secondary first and foremost
the foundation is i'm proud of
you not because of anything you did
or can do or will do but because of who
you are unconditionally unchanging
hashem is proud of every single
one of your children not because of
anything they did
but because of who they are when were
you on the same page with hashem
when your child was an incident then you
were on the same page with hashem
and you knew to just look at this baby
and say
i have unconditional pride
and then they grew up and the
unconditional pride was removed
and replaced with judgment
and rejection
it's not jewish you want to do it
do it don't do it in the name of what if
the kid said why if the father said yes
first of all
first of all if the father would have
meditated on a daily basis on his
children's neshama
he wouldn't have come to the point where
he'd be placed in that awkward position
of being asked that question
it's your question what would you do
it's rather like
if you get to a point where a wife has
to ask her husband do you even love me
at that point at best it's good
best case scenario it's going to be
awesome the point is preventative
medicine
so that nobody should ever have to ask a
spouse do you love me
and no jewish child should ever have to
ask a parent
are you proud of me
if your child had to come to you and
tell you that they had tattered shoes
they didn't have a bed to sleep in it
that they haven't eaten in two days
would you feel
would that not shock you that you're not
providing for your child of course it
would
so what about a child who's emotionally
starving who hasn't been given
validation
today why aren't we horrified by that
and i want to reiterate what i said
earlier it's not just to make your kid
feel good right now
it is investing in their future because
everything you teach them about
who they are and about their intrinsic
value and intrinsic worth
that's the self concept they're gonna
bring with them to every experience that
they have in their lives when they're
married and they decide what kind of
treatment they're worthy of from their
spouse
it'll be based on how you treated them
and what you taught them about
how much worse they have when they go
out in the workplace
and they deal with office politics their
level of self-esteem and self-respect
that'll be based on what you taught them
about their level of value
we have the most powerful tool
that no educator no rabbi no therapist
nobody has we
i'm talking about parents
we have the ability to teach our
children who they really
are
and that is the greatest gift you can
give your child
everything else is bonus
then when a child is in a test
like yes they'll be able to be a mawing
to refuse
because the ace of madison because he'll
see in front of his own eyes
what his parent but his loving
compassionate parent thinks of him
or her and understand what he or she is
really capable of
not because of guilt not because of
pressure
but because you taught them who they are
the foundation of jewish education
is not all of base it's not maidani it
comes before that
foundation of jewish education is you
are a jew
and you are therefore infinitely
precious and beloved
before everything else
we all know about unconditional love now
20 years ago if i would
be you know if this was this is the 19th
year
right so if i were here for the first
year of it and i told everyone here
about unconditional love a bunch of from
people talking about unconditional love
i would get scoffed at i promise you
because 19 years ago unconditional love
you know it's kind of like
new age right what is that but today
everyone understands come on
unconditional love you got to love your
kid unconditionally so i'm here to push
the envelope i'm here to say
that it's not enough that we have
unconditional love for our children
that we all know
we have to have unconditional pride
unconditional drive just like when they
were babies
you didn't just love them you were proud
what were you proud of
intuitively i'm telling you you were
keyed into their neshama you were proud
of their soul
why did you stop to whatever extent that
you stopped we
all stopped to some level why did we
stop
so get back to it get back to it
get back to seeing your child is in the
shama get back to unconditional pride
get back to the messaging that lets our
children know
that they were given the gift to be
raised in a family and a community
that makes them strong and confident
that that enables them to take on the
world to risk to resist challenges
to accomplish anything
okay pesto salmon awaits we're gonna
take a break