0:00 / 0:00
Weekly Update: Nachum Segal and Malcolm Hoenlein Discuss the Latest News
4 views
Nachum Segal welcomed Malcolm Hoenlein of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations to this morning's JM in the AM for the Weekly Update. They discussed the latest news concerning Israel and the Jewish community around the world.
Categories:Music
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Malcolm Homeline is with us. Conference
of presidents of major American Jewish
organizations. We call this the weekly
update here at JM in the AM. Mr.
Homeline, welcome back to JM in the A.M.
>> Thank you. Good to be with you as
always.
>> That was quite a preamble I gave. Huh?
>> Yes. I'm just sitting here shaking
wondering what's coming next.
>> Well, you have no need to shake. You're
not going to have trouble responding to
this. The reason I would think you might
be and others might be upset that I'm
bringing it up is that I'm bringing it
up at all. Uh and that is of course a
leader in the Satmer community has
actually tossed out the idea of um
continuing to fight the yeshiva draft
law
um with complaints against Israel by
filing complaints against Israel at the
International Court, the infamous I will
use that word international court. And
sadly, Mr. Homeline. I start by asking
you your reaction to this news story.
>> Well, we just saw the story and uh the
fact that um
um somebody from America
and uh people whose positions are are
well known uh coming out of elements of
the community. Um, I mean, we don't have
all the details yet, but the idea that
even the intervention, let alone the
idea of going to a place as hostile to
Israel as and I would say to Jews, the
as the International Court of Justice is
the ICJ, which we are fighting on on so
many fronts.
I I think that um I I don't know whether
it's a publicity stunt, whether they
that the the association, but you know,
with all the animosities and the
divisions that we see in Israel, this is
going to only exacerbate
um this even more. Um they're supposedly
collecting reports, a group in the
United States working to collect reports
of police brutality and pass them on to
US members of Congress to at a time when
we're you know fighting against the
internal enemies uh through DSA and all
of those affiliated groups.
Uh and he met and the GRBA's involvement
in this has to be clarified. We can't
just go based upon the news reports. Um
I think that this is a very disturbing
development.
>> I mean we should mention that just based
on what you've told us about what what
um
leaders and rabbis who are in Israel,
the way they view the situation, I I
think you'd agree that you'd be
surprised if they did not either come
out against it or remain neutral on the
issue. Would that be accurate?
>> Certainly. I think they would come out
about going to the International Court
of Justice and um I think anybody would
say knows what the possible
ramifications of that would be and and
the embarrassments that there are people
who appear to be immune to it and maybe
it's because we've let the boundaries
you know be eroded of what would be
acceptable and unacceptable in general.
>> Yeah. But I think you've brought up
something I never considered and I'm so
glad you did because I have to think
about this now. And that is the other
boundaries, the geographic boundaries.
In other words, I you may be hitting on
something really important that
leadership outside of Israel who feel
even more disconnected from the whole
situation there, whatever the situation
means, government, uh, political life in
general, those who really are completely
separated by 6,000 miles from the
situation in Israel, they're the ones,
as we see from this story, who are
inclined to go ahead and file this
complaint at an international court.
Maybe you're suggesting that somebody
who's in Israel, especially somebody
among leadership, great philanthropists,
etc., they would never think of doing it
because they see up close and personal
what happens um in terms of the court's
reaction when a complaint is in fact
filed there. Could that be one of the
differences, the distance that this
Jewish leader uh has between him and his
community and Israel?
Well, I don't know how I wouldn't define
a Jewish leader yet. I think what we um
we often had the problems that come from
within the community and um we'd have to
hear fully their views. But everything
that even the public statements
um uh are disturbing and unfortunately
too many people are more interested in
the publicity than thinking through the
ramifications and is true in regard to
many issues that confront us. But a time
when the divisions are so deep in
Israel,
>> I mean, you have to use your brains and
and uh and and your heart
>> to to derive it at approaches that make
sense, not just common sense, that make
sense
>> and that we don't know all the details.
I think we have to know much more but
it's certainly very disturbing and in
Israel will become you know just a
political football in this in the in the
heightened uh climate before the
elections.
>> Yeah, no question about it. Um all
right, let's go to Iran for a second.
The president of the United States
essentially extended a deadline this
week. He had said that uh he was going
to pummel Iran, worst attack since World
War II, etc., etc. and then of course
backed off um gave them more time and
insisted to the public that they are
begging him for some type of deal. They
went ahead and denied it. So where do we
stand now? I mean is there a hard is
there a new hard deadline or really
these deadlines are completely
meaningless?
>> The deadline for the
>> United States
>> for the Iranians to do what they haven't
done till now.
>> Correct.
And the message that could be sent is
one is a reverse one that if you given
the perverse thinking of of many of the
Iranian leadership or the perception
that is created and I met this week with
people from the region let's say from
even hostile parts of the region and you
know they they talk about the how
especially let's say in Iran after what
happened in January that we've lost
we're losing the people and the
confidence of the people in these
countries who were all gung-ho, you
know, and to remember the president
saying that that, you know, we would be
with them just as American presidents in
the past said it to the Iranian people,
but also to others. I mean, there is
today a really serious development which
has been being built up to for a while.
I mentioned it a couple weeks ago about
the when there were indications of it,
but now it looks like today even there
could be a signing in Riyad between
Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey of a
new defense pact.
This is a gamecher.
Now, I don't believe that Turkey is
going to send, you know, airplanes to
bomb the Houthis to defend Saudi Arabia.
But Saudi Arabia, with all the billions,
hundreds of billions more that they've
spent on weapons, never proved that they
were able to to execute and to properly
provide and to take on the Houthies, for
instance. They did participate in with
the United States in some attacks on
Iraq when the militias Iranianbacked
militias in Iraq. They have participated
in other things uh other activities and
I think behind the scenes they play um
more constructive role than than what
they do publicly. But this I think is
the the core of what could be a big game
changer in the region for Israel for uh
and for others. Uh you know the UAE and
Saudi Arabia despite some of the you
know messages sent that things are
warming up. It's not true. The the
hostility seems to continue and the
hostile relationship it's not as open as
it was but it's still there. But when
you take Pakistan, a nuclear power, you
take Saudi Arabia with its resources and
Turkey with the largest air force in and
the army in I think in NATO, I think
it's the largest or second largest.
And you know, Saudi Arabia has never
proven that they were able to use the
weaponry to full in effect that they
were able to purchase. Turkey uh took on
the Kurds and now they signed a pack
that removes a major uh challenge to
them. Their focus today is almost solely
on Israel and the taking over Syria
which they control 5% today. Israel
controls 1% or less. Yet you don't hear
about the Turkey uh role aggressiveness
and and attempts of dominance in Syria
and elsewhere.
And then you you put the three together,
Saudi Arabia,
Pakistan and Turkey. And Turkey with its
huge population, Pakistan huge
population.
And you think about the announced plans
to build the railroads bypassing Israel
and to create perhaps economic
uh coalitions as well. It has a lot of
possible ramifications. And what's the
US relationship now with Saudi Arabia?
We we had always been under the
impression that it was a very good one.
Uh is this a is this a move that the US
would approve of or are they wary of
Saudi Arabia now they've entered into an
agreement with Pakistan and Turkey?
So, so the United States has u one
government relationship certainly Saudi
Arabia and we know that the seen reports
just last week of the call from the
crown prince of Saudi Arabia to the
president as being a major factor in um
the decision to hold off on the on the
bombing the um the relationship between
Erdogan and the president the president
of Turkey and the president of the
United states is very warm. You see how
he praises him a strong man etc. without
going into the fact that he's a Muslim
Brotherhood advocate and unfortunately
there are people close to the president
uh including some who serve in the
region who are advocating this
relationship and this the the you know
Qatar and Turkey are working together.
They are the I think the the front for
the Muslim Brotherhood in the region. uh
they work together on on a lot of the
stuff including about uh Syria etc. and
the uh they provide the the funding
Turkeykey's economy is in ruins. Um but
remember it's a huge country that can
turn Europe on fire overnight. They say
if you know Turkey gets a cold, Germany
gets pneumonia,
>> right?
>> Because of the millions of of Turks that
that are there uh who came as guest
arbiters and were people came out of the
adaturk tradition have been radicalized
in Germany.
>> How many are there? Are there more than
100,000 Turks in Germany?
>> Uh well I would say there are probably
4 million 5 million.
>> Wow.
uh they started with 3 million. I think
it's the number I actually talked to
people this week about it is much larger
and of course they also go to other
parts of of Europe because of the
Shenhen agreement. You don't stop people
at at borders
um
except the East Europeans who don't let
any the migrants in. Right. So, so you
take all of the ramification, we talk
about Turkey alone for an hour. Uh, but
Pakistan is a nuclear power. Remember IQ
Khan, you remember all the background
about them sharing the nuclear selling
the nuclear information.
And while I think I think that there's
still pragmatic people there and people
with whom we could actually do business,
uh I think this will will create a front
and the question is will it counter
Russia and and China? Remember these
countries all flirt with them now.
>> Yeah. American do a lot of business and
sell obviously the oil um China is the
biggest uh consumer of Iranian oil about
80 plus percent but also from others it
might from Saudi Arabia
and um will this be a counter to the
belted road will it do other things what
happens to the IME proposal which is the
Indian uh le proposal to be to to which
involves a bunch of countries as well uh
And and I don't want to see the
bulcanization of the Middle East. I
don't I think this but but I I I this
should be a blaring headline. This story
and I'm sure it will be in Israel once
they get the details. But it's it hasn't
been signed yet. It's supposed to be
signed I think this afternoon
>> according to this was signed 21 minutes
ago.
>> Right. Well, that's this afternoon
there.
>> Yeah. Yeah. I'm saying.
>> Yeah. Right.
>> Um
Yeah. Now,
it's hard to navigate this because now I
think we have no choice but to conclude
that Saudi Arabia is never going to be
part of the Abraham Accords. Am I am I
wrong about that?
>> Well, it will certainly complicate
things more. Uh and as I said and I've
said on this show many and professed
this for a long time that it's we've
been mistaken in how we go about dealing
with Saudi Arabia. We shouldn't be
talking about it. We shouldn't be
begging them to come in. We shouldn't
have to control it. It's in their
interest. But the more you publicly
demand, the harder they become, the
higher the price becomes. And the
domestic resistance increases that we
should moved ahead with others. And
there are others in the region that
would have come into it and will come
into it. Uh and when Saudi Arabia
realizes they're left behind, I can tell
you that the leader of Saudi Arabia, top
leader there, said to me a long time ago
that a lot of our initiatives, including
Naom and other things can't be built
without Israeli technology. We know how
much we need it, but remember that there
are a lot of uh different forces at at
play in Saudi Arabia. I still believe
Saudi Arabia can be a partner. I think
if we if we would deal with Iran, get
rid of that issue and then which would
undermine the Houthi danger and what I
said earlier about their abilities. Uh
look how the Houthies were able to I
mean these peanuts were able to
challenge them and and attack their
their resources and airports fuel
storage and they they you know they
bypassed the restrictions in the straits
of Armuse by by exiting the oil to the
Red Sea across land and then uh to the
boats in the Red Sea. But if they close
Babal and Dab, that would close off
their excess
route for for the oil that they export
>> and and now Saudi Arabia is expecting
Pakistan and Turkey to help them in the
battle against the Houthis. Like how
does this how is this an advantage in
trying to get the Houthis to stop, you
know, stepping
>> first? First of all, it's they shouldn't
even need any help against the Houthis.
Uh but um the Houthis have attacked
others in the region including Israel
including of course working at the
behest of of Iran against others and
shooting at ships American ships and
others in in
the Red Sea. The um so we don't know yet
h how this will play out. Saudi Arabia
has has been sort trying to soften the
edges with everyone and and I understand
they want stability. they they need it.
Then while they're oil rich, the the
crown princes try to move the country
for years in a direction of not being
dependent on oil and looking for other
uh sources of income and and uh for
sources of energy as well. They have
huge solar potential. They have other
potential which when you're swimming in
oil, you don't think about, but he does
and he thinks ahead and and he's very
smart and I think committed. uh but but
it's not a monolithic um constituency
that he has to represent. So the the
question is how will Iran interpret
this? How will others do we come
actually to a final line? Is the reason
why we we we backed off again and again
and again which may be justified and I
think President Trump wants to to finish
this this issue. uh you know the debate
of whether we have a shortage of of
ammunition and of uh longrange of
missiles to be able to to to use the
interceptors
is very damaging to America's the
perception of America and to the
security because if the enemies think
that we don't have the ability to resist
>> right
>> and uh and I believe that we could
easily act and decisively and once and
for all there are reports that the
supreme leader is very dangerously ill
right now. Uh we don't even know if he's
alive, but but he but if he's alive,
he's very dangerously ill according to
these reports that came out today and
yesterday, last night. Uh which also
will be uh have an impact both on the
stability region. Nobody has seen him.
Nobody which proves that maybe you don't
need a supreme leader or that he's you
know they can they're just manipulating
it. But all of these are destabilizing
factors that will have impact on on
Israel. It's a time when Israel has to
be unified. This the the increasing
tensions between the parties and the
fact that everything gets politicized.
People have to think beyond this moment
that that will have longerterm
ramifications.
>> Yeah, you could you could have made that
statement in any era. It seems uh that's
what always seems to be the case in the
political situation in Israel. It's
America's one and only Jewish moments in
the morning radio program heard on
listener sponsored digital radio around
the world alamusicle.com on the single
network of course the beloved NSN app
before I get back to the Turkey thing
which I will in a second. So Turkish
population in Germany it's amazing how
accurate you are. I was only I was only
off by like millions and millions.
Here it it says there's 1.4 million with
Turkish citizenship.
3.1 million with a migration background
from Turkey and 7 million in Germany who
identify as ethnic Turks. Wow. I just
got a uh a lesson in uh in world
population. That's pretty amazing. Also,
is Erdogan the deacto leader of this new
alliance? Is that how how it will be
viewed?
>> That that's actually a good question. I
don't think we know the answers because
we don't know that much yet about what
this what the conditions are. But
Erdogan, first of all, Erdogan hasn't
been well and etc. and he's not young
and and I'm sure he's looking at this
for something for the future for his
future um future leadership of his
country. is you know he keeps
imprisoning his opposition and but we
don't hear where the condemnations
nobody taking him to the world court
nobody you know defending the rights of
the people of Turkey to have a choice
when you know the mayor of Istanbul and
Ankor they he puts him in prison as soon
as they represent any kind of a
significant threat so he he's uh and you
know he's he's very involved in inside
Syria not just in Syria and and now they
signing this peace deal with the with
the Kurds, the PKK, even to the point of
of supposed disarmament,
uh is um it takes enables him to focus
on other issues. There are still a lot
of tensions between Turkey and Greece
and people think it's all quiet. It's
not quiet at all. And um and the you
know they and if there's not a decisive
outcome in Iran, that will have an
impact too. They say whether the west
has the commitment and the sustaining
power and the ability to really
pursue its needs and this is an
essential need which is to destroy the
regime in in Iran.
>> I'm trying to find if there's any
reaction yet from Jerusalem. Do you
think the prime minister is going to
make a statement regarding this new
agreement?
>> I think it'll be very hard for him not
to. He may not want he may leave it to
others to do because I don't know that
he'll want to be associated with um with
this because then they'll point to it
and say that uh that Israel's position
is uh is weakened. But um but you know
that Israel and some of the Gulf states
have been holding talks to develop
routes for Gulf oil and natural gas
bypassing the streets of Ramoose and the
Bel and Dab. um according to reports
that had emerged this week and one
immediate uh option would be unloading
oil from tankers
from the western Saudi port of Yanbu
which is um to to the port of a lot and
then it would be transported through
existing pipelines to Ashcolon and
shipped across the Mediterranean to
export. So I mean that would be uh that
would strengthen the relationship
>> but I think you so you have always as
always um the complete competing
scenarios in the region. Um but you know
Hamas has moved its covert activities to
to Turkey from Qatar. So Turkey is not,
you know, playing it. It they charm the
United States and and uh President Trump
has, you know, spoken about President
Erdogan and such long terms as a friend
and has uh um but uh there are people
there who have seem to have ideological
and other interests in pushing this
relationship. It's funny how geopolitics
is. Because of the NATO fear of Russia
and China, Israel is now in a weaker
position.
One could argue that, right?
>> I I don't think this I don't think
Russia and China are in a stronger
position because of it. I don't
>> No, but Israel's weaker. I'm saying
because of American fear of Russia and
China, Israel's now in a weaker position
because this new agreement.
>> I don't think America is afraid of
Russia and China. Russia has proven in
this long war that it has it's this the
the limits of its capabilities. China um
is always uh on the agenda not only
because of potential actions against
Taiwan but because of the belt and road
and its aggressive behavior but it's
it's it's aggression is largely
advancing its meeting its food and
energy needs which is dominant. They
also have big um demographic problems
other things um that the
u but I I don't think Russia and China
you see how limited their involvement in
the Iranian war maybe they provided
Russians provided intelligence you know
guidance for movements of US troops and
other things like that but they did not
get involved they don't can't spare the
equipment and and China uh while it did
get involved more in some of the
shipments of of equipment we found out
about usually after but it's not a major
and decisive role. So I think Russia and
China are more marginal than that and
certainly the fight within NATO NATO is
going through many changes and they are
unifying. The president did force them
to start paying for their own defense
and allocating a bigger percentage but
still comes to like 3 4%.
uh but until now they were just relying
on the US and we carried the burden for
all of that. I think that he did redress
that imbalance and the um uh uh so the
the native threats are are more serious
and the fact that if if Iran is able to
walk away from this and that will have
devastating impact in the region it's
already having it in terms of the
confidence. So one level was on the
people level in Iran and let's say other
countries but also on the political
level that what appears to be
inconsistencies or you know uh and and
the interpretation that we're too weak,
we're too this, we're too that. I don't
believe that that is true. I I think
there are there are shortages of
ammunition. It's true globally and
Israel is moving to become more
independent in that regard also setting
up factories to devel to produce their
own weapons because being reliant on the
global supply and especially when the
United States has other demands like
Ukraine uh makes it very difficult.
>> But it's funny that weapons shortage
even though I know it's in the it's in
the news but it's never the primary
reason. The primary reason everyone
talks about the his hesitation to go
into into action here is because of the
midterms. It's all a political thing and
and if we didn't have these elections
coming up in the United States, a lot of
people suspect that he would have gone
ahead with whatever, you know, threat he
was threatening over last weekend. So,
it's interesting. I mean, there may be
some
>> that is Yes. But I'm I'm citing the
other things how people interpret it.
They don't know about the all of the
election politics in America, right? in
in a lot of these places, they look at
it and say, "Is is America does America
not have the will? Do they have a secret
agreement? Do they do they not have the
weapons to do it?" Very few are going to
say they're worried about the election
in Kansas, the impact of this right now.
That's an American concern and Americans
see it and and we're seeing it more and
the victory of the DSA in the last week,
I think, highlights it even more. I
think only Israel is really focused on
the American midterms in terms of
foreign countries. I mean, but they get
it over there and obviously there's a
lot of people from the United States
that are there. Speaking of which, by
the way, not enough people from the
United States are in Israel right now.
It's August. It's tourist season. I
noticed that American Airlines extended
its suspension suspension. We're talking
about Pesak time is their new deadline.
And hopefully Delta and United are going
to make good on their commitment to be
back before the end of 2026. any you
think it might happen actually?
>> Well, first of all, I think people
should return their American Airlines
credit cards and start sending a message
to them that this is really irrational
and um it's you know the Israel being um
increasingly isolated because of it. But
yesterday or not yesterday, today is
Friday. So I guess on Wednesday I think
was a record day. I think a hund over a
100,000 people went through Benorian in
the one day. It's a record. And despite
the fact that the tankers are still some
of them are still at Bengorian although
most many have been moved to the Ramon
Air Force Base uh which crowds the
airport and all the reports that you
know it would it would hamper the flow
of people that it is amazing that they
were able to handle a record crowd. They
have archa flying now and of course um
lal and uh others
and and the thing is it's their most
profitable route the for many of these
airlines
Turkish Air had 13 14 flights a day and
they complain about the people who work
there complain about the losing this um
this very profitable route. So the the
um uh but the fact is that you had a
record number of people flying in and
out of Israel. Uh I think tourism August
is is expected to be a good month but we
have to make sure that people go and go
go for the Khagim. Uh it's going to be
beautiful in Israel. The weather
forecast is great and the uh and to plan
winter vacations it's very important
that we have to sustain it. people, you
know, a lot of the smaller businesses
and others have paid a heavy price and
even the hotels, uh, while they they
survive, it's it's, um, it's very costly
to them.
>> Yeah, that's an understatement. Um, all
right. You mentioned, you alluded to it
a moment ago. Let's just go quickly
through this. Um, uh, the current
election season in the United States.
Abdul Elsed defeated Haley Stevens.
They're going for Gary Peter's open seat
in the Michigan Senate race. This is US
Senate, folks. Yeah, you could have
Abdul El Say as a United States senator.
We'll ask Malcolm in a second if it's
likely. In the Michigan 12th, Taib was
renominated. Okay. Can't do much about
an incumbent like that. I was a little
surprised that Cory Bush lost in
Missouri's first to Wesley Bell. I don't
know if you were surprised by that or
not. Apac was obviously a big um factor
in that race. So, what is We'll take
those three unless you know of others.
What's your reaction to those three
results this week?
>> Well, Cy Bush is not a surprise. Cory
Bush lost in the last election and um uh
I think the margin even bigger this
time. The others Elad you have to know
how much money was poured into it from
outside. People regrettably are focusing
just on Apac and the fact that Apac
became a distraction in this election or
a focus of attention
when this is an American group. They
they kept painting it as if it's Israel
manipulating this. Uh it's a the the
pack that got involved. I would wish
they did things more quietly. I think
you know we have to be careful that you
you're inviting this kind of reaction
and that the DSA organizes against it.
uh but they don't organize against all
these other groups and how much foreign
money is channeled through the DSA
according to reports and other uh
sources um uh that we know that have
been operating for a long time. how much
money Qatar swamps all of the money that
we put together or that any AP pack or
any of the pro-Israel packs put together
and that there's nothing illegal and
appropriate for American citizens
whether if they're Greek to be uh
supporters of of candidates that uh um
represent their positions or people from
every uh organization. The question is
the manipulation and the lies,
distortions and the fact that you have
people who who celebrated October 7th
who who you know condemned the the
attacks on 9/11 not from our side from
the other side. People who have
expressed themselves in horrific ways
against the American system and seek to
undermine and imposing the DSA's agenda.
And nobody knows what democratic
socialism is because like vibe it has no
definition in today. Uh you know Israel
used to be a member of the socialist
international because socialism itself
was not anti-democratic. Sweden was a
socialist others were
>> today it obviously has different
connotations and especially here in the
United States. So these the real race in
Michigan will come down to it. I think
Mike Rogers has a good chance of
winning. We need they need to get
support. But the key was their ground uh
effort that they organized. They brought
people in from all over to work the
crowds to to drive people to the polling
booths to to uh facilitate
uh the outcome of of a guy whose views
are so abhorent in so many ways and the
promotion then of uh you know Mr. M from
New York and others and and I think we
should not talk about him. We should
mention his name, but um as that young
woman told me, we should call him the
Grand Muy of New York. But but um uh you
know, we have to learn that we we're
promoting these guys too much. We're
focusing on should focus on the issues
and the substance and what these guys
represent, what their election
represents to the United States. The
American people don't want it. And by
the way, one of the mistakes is people
think blacks don't want to, Hispanics
don't want it, other minority groups,
they do not want. And they're winning
with, as in the case of espionage, 17%
of the voters showing up. 17% which
means 2,000 votes could have turned the
election the other way.
>> Yeah.
>> So again, reminding everybody to
register and to turn out. By the way,
the I mean, you're right that that it's
much tighter than it was because the
projected
uh a couple months ago the projected
Elsa Rogers election was like Elsa by 60
points. Now it's basically a 20 point
difference, but it is narrowing. So, I
don't know. I mean, I you know, I I
don't know if Rogers could pull this
off, but um it's uh it's not it's at the
moment it's not very at least according
to the polls. I know that polls aren't
always accurate, etc., But somebody's
betting markets are accurate and nobody
has it as a close race right now. So
we'll see what happens on that. Also,
>> they do say it's a close race.
>> How close? Which which poll has been the
closest that you've seen? How many
points?
>> Four points.
>> Really?
>> For for Rogers. Yeah,
>> cuz the betting sites are like
are like, you know, they're not
recommending that uh that the Rogers
will win. It's interesting. Well, we
know that the betting sites are often
manipulated and you know, and I wouldn't
I certainly hope people don't just base
their votes on that. Um, and and you saw
that Cy Bush betting everything on on
the Israel issue. She lost.
>> Uh, I mean, she ran hard against Apac
and so do others, but that is having an
impact.
>> Yeah. Look, there's a lot of time left
in this race. I agree with you. There's
a lot of time to go. Yeah. But these
things are having an impact and an
erosionary impact that people demonize
um a pack. uh and and while the the
other side can pour in billions over
years to to influence our campuses and
our every institution, our cultural
institutions, the the debate in America.
Um the fact that Americans putting
together funds to to
involve themselves in a domestic
election
is it's certainly an imbalance.
>> I hear that. But the other thing and I
mean the the only other thing is uh I I
think the difference between what you
described as you know trying to keep
people's mouths shut with the Apac thing
as compared to other like when it comes
to the prime minister of Israel I agree
with you that sometimes things are
better not said and there are many
situations we could you know tell people
it's just better to remain silent on the
Apac thing it's hard to maintain silence
when these days every email press well
not press release but every email
announcement private conversation
becomes exposed lose by somebody either
in the organization or someone
affiliated with them and it's really
hard to keep any strategy under wraps in
that situation.
>> Yes. and people infiltrate these
organizations are paid by outsiders to
do that and uh but the question is you
know it's a question of approach and how
you structure it and um and I mean it's
obviously well-intentioned and it's it's
meant to impact it to counter uh the
influx of of money but when it becomes
the issue
>> not the substance the issues don't no
longer relevant the issue becomes quote
apac and you know and painting it as
they successfully They have in some
cases in the most nefarious way and and
um anti-American way and and yet they
haven't taken on Qatari hundreds of
billions hundreds of billions still
investing in it. The fact that that
China the fact that Turkey the fact that
all these others are are pouring money
in today China even more than Qatar and
the campuses and and the Qataris say
they're going to focus on Hollywood.
They're going after every source
including all the manipulation of of the
online the bots that come out and and
here now the latest report they they
traced a lot of the bots that were
producing the pro uh mayor uh
reporting and stuff I mean support
turned out to be bots traced to city
hall and uh if that's true then that
tells you a lot and uh it's so much is
manipulated that we don't know we can't
see it it's almost impossible to trace
everything, but they're clearly using
it. We know that many of the things
going to one day at the White House, I
think 80% of the anti-Israel messages
were bots from overseas
and it's automated and you know, so
we're creating bots too to give out the
the right information to counter it
because I think ultimately the truth is
our strongest weapon. We have to sustain
that that we that our credibility
remains intact.
>> Wow. Unbelievable. machines are going to
end up fighting the battle for everybody
on both sides.
>> Pretty remarkable. Uh thank you so much.
Have a wonderful Shabas. We'll speak
again next week.
>> God willing. Be well. Malcolm Homeline,
Conference of Presidents of Major
American Jewish Organizations, weekly
update here on a Friday of Shabas at JM
Eminem.