Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay, good morning everyone.
We're continuing in
we're up to
these are different cantens of leather.
You
fix them, you establish them and you
made them a base.
You could use them for
sackloth or
that you fix them to be situated
without leaning.
Why?
[snorts]
because they were not made to be a
receptacle
by and
if you make it
uh have a base, you could use it for
because
inherently they're receptacles. The only
problem is they can't sit. So if you
give them a base, so now they could sit
as opposed to a box or a piece of sack.
They're not meant to be receptacle. So
you could do whatever you want. You
could paint them a receptacle. You could
make a base. You could tar them. But
they were not made to be a receptacle of
liquids. [snorts] Says the
writing
them in you making them a base.
I have to say I was bothered by that.
Why do you need to make a base for them?
Didn't we learn yesterday that if they
were made originally to be a receptacle,
even if they can't have a bay, even if
they can't stand on their own, then you
could use them for. So why does say you
fix them? You don't have to fix them.
They were made that way to begin with.
The answer is that their their status as
receptacle is not
unless you make a base.
If there's no water, there's no
interior.
Think what that means is it's it's just
like a if it doesn't have liquid in it.
So then it's not even a receptor. It
just like folds in a blob one on top of
each other. Meaning one on top of each
other. No, the the entire receptacle
collapses.
Something that's made to be receptacle.
You don't have to make a base. So why do
you have to make a base for this leather
canteen? Because without liquid in it,
it's not a receptacle. It has no it has
no form to it. [snorts] So therefore you
need to be making it.
[snorts]
That's interesting.
>> [snorts]
>> And therefore, Rabenion Abash says,
um, in my time when I was in Israel,
when dinosaurs roame the earth and you
wanted milk. Yeah. They had milk bags.
Remember milk bags?
And you you cut off you snip off the
corner. Could you use that as a for if
you designate it? No. Says for the
reason the says that without a liquid in
it, it has no form. So therefore, it's
not a clea. [snorts]
But on the other hand,
a sack and a koopa, even if you fix it,
it doesn't help.
It's not made at all to
to accept liquids.
Okay. The continues.
Let's say you have a felt hat.
Let's say you have a felt hat and it's
so stiff, no water is going to come out.
It's not used to hold liquids.
So, could you use a hat for
you know the blazer silver wore a very
distinguished shiny top hat in which he
would store his lunch that he would take
with him
um wherever he would go.
And in fact the story goes that he once
visited Rutderman and he took off his
hat and
he put down his lunch and you know the
rebbitson served him lunch and he said
I'm sorry I don't eat outside of my
house. So Robbitson said that's
wonderful I don't allow outside food on
my table you know. So but anyway let's
say he would have washed with that top
hat. Um
let's say he would have washed with that
top hatord
seems to be saying [snorts] it's not
because travelers
are frequently drink from it.
It's not like sak
and
[snorts]
uh it's not like let's see a sack vupa.
So
um
it
nevertheless
because travelers do drink from it says
um
[clears throat]
you know capion a hat
or a yarmaka
or even even a leather yarmaka.
Maybe that's where the minhug came from.
Some people wear leather yarmas in case
you're stuck without.
But usually they're pretty flat. I don't
know. I don't know if they could hold
3.3
uh ounces. Anyway,
the
he says, "Come on, a hat is not meant
for as a receptacle."
And the straight up argues on
you should wash without a [snorts]
he also writes you should wrap your
hands in a towel
if you're not in a great
Even travelers today will not drink out
of their hat.
Here
we have the famous
a that was made that it cannot stand
without leaning
and is only used when it's leaned.
Let's say I what I think of is a test
tube. A test tube, you know, it can't it
can't be positioned unless you put it in
the what is it called?
>> Holder.
>> Holder. Excellent. The holder. So if you
uh that would be a cle even though I
don't know if a test tube could hold 3.3
ounces.
Any uh chemists here? Scientists?
>> Different sizes.
Okay.
Different sizes.
A cleave full of holes
on the bottom with a narrow opening.
A little physics over here. What you do
is if you have a clea with holes on the
bottom, if you put your finger on the
narrow opening on top, it creates some
kind of pressure cavity and now the the
liquid doesn't go out of the holes on
the bottom.
Yeah. Does that make uh does that make
sense?
So you have this cle it's full of holes
on the bottom, a narrow opening on top,
and you put your finger on top of it,
the water doesn't go out. And when you
remove your finger, the may goes out.
You're allowed to use it for even though
it doesn't contain anything
since it is designated and it is made to
be receptical in this fashion
cle. It's called a cle. [snorts]
Let's see the
a clea that was made initially to use
only if it leans or this other that's
from the unqualified language of it
implies
doesn't matter if it's small holes or
big holes
since when you put your finger on it the
water doesn't go out
cleave
I don't understand this. How can
something that requires you to put your
finger on it?
Without your finger, it can't contain
anything. So now it needs my finger. So
how could that be a clay?
But because that's how it's made. It's
levers.
Our lever. It says on the bottom. It has
two openings, one above and one below.
One wide opening below.
When you remove your finger, the water
comes gushing out.
from the that's quoted by the it's only
if the holes that the water comes out
are very fine.
It's only if it comes out slowly with
delays.
Are we talking about a syringe?
>> No, we're not talking about a syringe,
but the syringe has the same a syringe
would be a good example of something
that has that phenomenon that when you
close the smaller hole, nothing will
come out of the it will create the
pressure cavity and will come out of the
nothing will come out of the bigger
hole.
It it's it's
>> like just making the opening of sink.
Isn't that what he's talking about? Like
you have a lever on your sink. You want
to make you open, close, open, close.
That's what he's referring to.
>> It's the same concept as the other
thing. You're opening, closing, you're
putting your finger in and out.
>> Yeah. But I mean, he does say
Sounds like your finger is literally
closing some kind of hole.
>> That's true. But in the the lever case,
it's just a separate case. Like somebody
comes up into a sink, he doesn't have a
cup. So like, ah, can I use my lever on
the sink? Open and close it because the
water is stored under the sink. So like
maybe I can use it as my own. So he's
come to tell us that the lever is not
going to work.
>> Mhm. I just Okay, I hear. But I don't
think that in the lever
the way it opened is by pulling some
kind of thing. It sounds like you
physically your finger was I mean he
says
by the lever case you're saying that the
more advanced lever cases our sinks. In
other words, you open the faucet
mean it's in a receptacle basically and
there's a hole so it can't really
contain. But the reason why it's
contained is because instead of your
finger, but the the manual lever is
sealed shut. And then I open it and it
comes out of the comes out of the
reservoir. It comes out of the water
tank.
So you're saying according to the
according to the Mishna's in the opening
of the sink should be good for for but
the Rambam quoted by the Taz would say
no that's not good. The hole is too big.
Maybe we'll see tomorrow the Okay,
recording stop.
