Va'etchanan Part 1 Weekly Torah Portion according to the Kli Yakar Deuteronomy 3 verse 23 5776

good evening everybody we're impartial Kanade is found Deuteronomy chapter 3 verse 23 I'll read in English and Hebrew I am Florida Shem at that time safe I'll read the next sentence too but really we're going to concentrate the whole show on that statement my lord Asham Elohim you have begun to show your servant your greatness and your strong hand what power is there in the heavens or on earth that can perform according to your deeds and according to your mighty acts please let me cross and see the good land that is on the other side of the Jordan this good mountain and the Lebanon so our first verse in Hebrew the f9l Hashem baita he lay more so the clear car begins by explaining look at Rashi he is a real problem with Rashi parish Rashi our appreciation with Siddiqui little ism of Marseille moto beam even though there is that what say the right you know they have the ability for to be keen to hang or depend on their good actions and it seems from what we're reading at the moment that we're talking about the past nevertheless a new boxing PE Montes keenham nevertheless they don't ask for something except for a free gift meaning you would think from the first reading of Rashi that we're talking about past merits I'll read the Rashi Rashi beans by saying ain't diamond bakoma comme le Lucien Malaspina the forms of the word he known in every place the spirit appears in Scripture always means a free gift requesting a free gift of appreciation Hamlet Siddiqui little over mark cimetidine even though the righteous could make their requests depending on good deeds as I said we think it means past tense we'll see a different you of the clea car and he the the arch girl says for example they could be justified in requesting things as a reward that they deserve which gives the impression which all my past tense ami bacha me at the month of allah - payment but they don't seek for michelle except for a free gift and then he brings a proof Leticia on Marlo because God said to Moses the penalty at Bashar come I will show favorite to whom I shall show favor to our local ocean beneath Hannah and that's why Moses said the word that cannot it's interesting because the sister coming says the reason is bothered Rashi is because the normal language one would use would be that pal al that I pray so what Iman or right at Kanaan it's a language of pain or he knew something free a free gift and the the proof that Rashi uses is right I will show favoritism and will show favor and that implies again past merits if I deserve it great and if I don't deserve it then you'll show this then you'll show me grace because of what I've done in the past so the clear car has another take in other words what the clean he doesn't admit when I say disagrees with Rashi there's a nuance that he wants to build a bottle so we read the first part of the Clea car and he says kashaf said what's the difficulty about this Rashi may - Peppa may hate it a softer Python where would it ever come upon our minds or anybody's mind she even though Massa McCullum's who are assume that then Siddiqui would hang and request something based on their past experiences why don't you okay that's all true he's not gonna go there surprisingly enough but he strengthens the question and when he strengthens the question through this next statement you understand where he's gone with it hello Leo love anal or other shoe covetous particle he called mr. Shah the boy said Amen die hey chief cow Moo Bob Calgary Charlotte why the tag mulu he ally aloud Benesh kawarazu la share well I shall uro of cosmonium he bailed Oh what can we possibly do in a Shems eyes a Shem is infinite and we're finite and he is what he's given to us from the day that we were we came out of our mother's womb and we were slapped on the backside by the doctor and we breathed then we ate then we were clothed and everything was taken care of care out for us by Hashem ultimately through people now we're all X ages yet we're however you are everything that God gave to us we can never pay back as if Mitzvahs was a payback as if you're saying look I deserve this look at what I've done no matter what you have right if you have billions of mitzvahs it doesn't matter billions of misses the same as 5 in you know examine you're talking about in regards sham when he's given you which is infinite love what can we ever say we have in our bag you know to pull out to say we'll exchange it for something you follow where he's going with it commotion means they're the safer place the Silla bubbles this has been already discussed in duties of our heart in chapter 4 now Fazal say in gomorrah brothels interestingly enough the story about Hezekiah and Isaiah so Hezekiah was guilty he got sick Isaiah had to come and see him in the end because he was so sick he couldn't move but really the king should have seen the nothing the prophet so the pus so what do we know in the Gilmore prophecy which discussed the guilt of his Akaya she knew as as his kin what did he do he was should tell the massa he himself was talking to God about saving you shall I am based on his own merit zoth or not if I shared it how I feel if another man met the field in second Kings chapter 20 verse 3 write the verse over there mentions that Hezekiah says please Hashem remember now that I have walked before you faithfully wholeheartedly and I have done what is good in your eyes in other words with a matter of things that I've done on the deeds that I've done please save you shall I am so the answer that God gave back to him was not dependent on Hezekiah steeds with toad Lopes coos I can read in the end the Shem son on the same the city but not close to you on whose account so in second Kings chapter 20 verse 6 God says I will protect this city for my sake and for the sake of my servant of it the gun ot our ear has I've heard of it a body so he min Hashem I ever loved God actually showed him as if from heaven shame low shoes clothes you don't have any merits no matter what merits you had they don't compare it's not enough pika bar a hollow his skin actually he ate them up he consumed them within it Cayenne bovine mark and what was fulfilled through Hezekiah was the statement in Genesis where this is Yaakov correct me if I'm wrong Yaakov is coming back to Eretz Israel and he says Cottone t Mikolka Sabine compared to what a shame has given me I can never repay the words I'm unworthy of the kindness you have shown upon me this is in Genesis 32 verse 10 and Jacob said God and my father Abraham and God my father Isaac Hashem who said to me return to your land and Shera your relatives and I will do good with you but 11 he says I have been diminished by all the kindnesses and by all the truth that you've done your servants for with my staff I crossed the Jordan and now I haven't come to camps so Yaakov enters the land and before he approaches before he approaches a saw a thought is coming and he's preparing himself and he's praising a sham and what does he say he owes Hashem everything there's not a lot that he could you know base his own merits on Hashem is provided he heard of the armor Shack atone Yaakov Indaba mitzvahs mid-cycle Cassady Havarti Bale certainly he praised Hashem and he said I am right Yaakov is small and poor in mitzvahs in respect to all the great kindness that he's already received from Hashem he the yank a brew so how is it that Rashi says includes quoting an earlier source of appreciation that Siddiqui little oppa masahito beam that tsadikim could but they gone it said we got them to the point where to the human wouldn't even think of it we even come up on their minds that's not what tsadikim do so how does why she come and say even though they could so the horizon made him in a puss look and not only that the CLE car is bothered by the proof that the rock that Rashi brought the canova see a Teixeira called and God was going to Guru Granth grace to whomever he wants to a Narayan Akkad the clear card says this is not a good proof this is not as a horrible proof keep asuka's that ain't l'm made me me meadow he shocked me shameless coots this verse is teaching it's not teaching about someone that does have but it's talking about someone that doesn't have any merit right it's like a double negative here he puzzles that ain't love maybe makan it's not teaching except only someone who doesn't have any merit she could his birth will also email outside Hanina that hashem is acting towards this person out of grace because they have nothing of emotion and mashed potato Shalini comically Hamish Lawrence but on Moses I get plenty of merits but he wasn't able to enter the land because of a particular sin he was being punished for a particular sin not to enter the land so my annyeong Allah pus exact how can we say Moses didn't have any merits he you Madai gorilla me Misha a low blow slew the look over and the tussock is putting him to this whole idea is putting it into a precarious situation where he's being put in a situation was certainly worse than someone who has neither but he had we know that he has plenty of merits so have the shoe mother calls it the way the clear car wants to begin to answer this is shamash embouchure she Ashlyn tsadikim lidless from marseille momento beam from the fact that we said that there is the possibility for the tsadikim to hang up their merits in their past actions their past good actions ain't a parish Peralta mas a moto de Guiche para su don't read it don't understand it as those actions those good actions that he's already done in the past ella rather how should you read it understand it Alabama sama Toby ICT muscles it's those good actions those mitzvahs that he plans to do in the future he must Allah called Sadiq ænima vaca shoe Manabu honey first of all we know this is the general rule there's no righteous person who's looking to derive any physical benefit from this world I'll read the exact words we star most likely the way we understand things is that every righteous person anyone is righteous he's not looking to derive any physical benefit he in kanesha arya da would ever been a physical benefit he is a pure carrot at curing it's really only yellow muhkam look I made a mitzvah right all the wealth in the world that we have and the beautiful homes we have and all of our Odessa our resources should be used for what to fulfill some type of Mitzvah connecting to a Shannon xenoverse daughter abuse my that's what Ruby's enlightened more assaulted was darting out expounding upon the Fela called the periodic motion can you imagine Moses intent was coming into the land so he can eat the pomegranates and the grapes no way no yeah and what are my rather what did Moses want to come to land to do and to fulfill hardly Mithras to Lamar as he wanted to come into the land because there are so many mitzvahs that are dependent on the Land of Israel you cannot do it includes lives in the desert or anywhere else in pain if that's the case hello limos because October Oh son Maxime told him shall see who lasso so I did the cushions ooh then what Moses really wanted to do right or but it'll say he should have and if we understand it that way maybe that is what he was saying that he was should have depending depended his request on those good actions those admits was that in the future he would be able to do through coming into the land because that was his request to come into the land with zebb daughter ami T and that's certainly the truth short that did nothing she male Hashemi shouts liebe it certainly would have been even just according to the letter of the law I would have given Moses whatever he wanted Yankee annual campaign scheme at Bifengxia Shambo the only thing that Moses wanted was to please Hashem he only wanted to do God's will I pop a shoe petal Nick masala but cannot even though he threw his sin that he was penalized there was a penalty placed upon him nekoma come nevertheless a man ischemic like Miami Shing haha light a may lay more nevertheless this is an idea that God doesn't do and we do also shouldn't do as parents we shouldn't punish a person who's seemed by telling him right here's an example you did let's say your child was bad and you say you know what you have to stay home from school today what does he benefit from that that's like causing him to sin or better you're not going to go to shul he's gonna go to Shu and he's gonna pray and you tell me you know your onus is you're not going to do mitzvahs so this audition was not going into the land where he could do more business so I'll read the words again a mine in my machine title oh my you don't punish a sinner by saying lik I would've boda Sheehy's Zara Epps Lacan go and serve some other form that's fard to you the hi-c Bobcat the soap Asha because that's only going to add on hit this sin already that he has already transgressed Elish and they wrote another remember when you walked in motion so we're gonna talk about in the beam so Ella she may roll on a vast ball because of the great amount of humility that Moses had Loretta Lynn low such a lobotomizing told me show us he do last so valued a acnes appliance he was so humble and honest and transparent that he didn't want to hang his requests on those positive actions and in the future he would do through entering the lab why queue line economies remilia-san mitzvahs what happened perhaps he would enter the land and not do the mistress right it was a future hope Rock ha ha ha agua an IndyCar Bell and the only benefit he might receive at that point because he's not doing interest would be a purely physical and all pleasure at Oh glory combat so the ultimate good he wouldn't be receiving Lacock be case mushroom Hanina and now we get back into original Rashi of the epilogue that's why Moses asked in a way of pleading or using these words kameena of imploring madness Keenum yama for a free gift that's all he wanted the cotton mr and now we understand what it says the ace high heel a more right face on helium more we said at that time saying he also should a lot o Basha who shop alcohol bet because he made his request as he was at the moment in the present tense should I am ain't shoes scoop the other he did not yet have any of the mitzvahs that he would have cured in Eretz Israel they did they weren't there and they might not be there mealy she uhshe hate our policy level without a total vision and a seeing of what the future could bring she's so full of the lead a human mitzvah that in the end perhaps it would come to the fulfillment of the mistress quiche Emma Yoho oh whoa yeah whoa but there's no 100% a surety that it would right perhaps he would fulfill them perhaps he wouldn't fulfill them look how I'm a blush on now we understand why the Torah uses the word that command key hiya Sarge lavaca smartness Keenum ow I hate how he come and because it was necessary for him to request a free gift out of his humility he did not want to first of all tsadikim do not request past their past merit should be in lieu of any future reward that was a misunderstanding when we read Rashi which I think anybody would read that and think that and the clear card gives us a really clear understanding of that Rashi wasn't tall doesn't say anything about Kivar assume but now I understand that the epic anon was going on the future and yet if that really wasn't one in the future but it should have because that's what Siddiqui might bargain but out of the another and the transparency he wouldn't even go that far and it was but ASA he as he was now while he still had to cured anything not knowing if he would just give me a free gift I don't deserve it back from the past I certainly don't know about deserve it from the future but I want a hinge on that because then I'll lose everything because then I'll all I'll get is the goof I mean it's a physical pleasure so give it to me the free gift clear for years my you like that I probably spend a bunch better this year than last year right I want to go until the end of the next piece which is just halfway down the next page so the clean car continues but II thought he lay more at that time say we all know when it says lay more it's usually a command that he should say over so kavorka top knew we've already written shot to feel a lot to penalise out there aha a tie he that his prayer and his imploring and request were at that moment but out that he thought he maybe we should get flush a lot all the Massa Tobias offal Marvel logo that was without hanging and depending his request on any future actions on the actions that might come in the end if he does enter the land the in all Marshall what does it say may work ladoris that this is a I wouldn't call it a command it was advice it's it's a Torah principle that so too we the people should also request Michelle madness Kingdom we 3,300 years later she Colts Aditya vodka stocked a new name Omaha spinner that everyone who wants to be righteous who is righteous and desires to be righteous should request these requests from Hashem as a free gift in the takamine way and in the pre gift kind of way now he brings an alternative explanation some savvy a genre motion bar basically and that was another part of the Rashi that we didn't read base aji Rashi says Zeff had michl Oshima combos this is one of three places Shama Moshe live near Malcolm where Moses said before God ami money magnifico I should Toby Amy I'm not going to let go of you until you inform me in pass - a la Co lo if you're going to know feel my request or not so that's the words he brings down where Moses are saying I'm not moving I'm not budging until you tell me yes or no Vale's and I wanna that's why it says base I'll heal a board at that moment saying meaning to say she overload the shoe but take half the eggs I eat I'm not asking you I'm telling you to please give me an answer right away VA shall Riemann sum said there's another alternative answer shoe out Derek Hashem said but I did talk and this is how we open up our prayers if you look in Psalms 51 17 Oh Lord opened my lips that might mouth may declare your praise so this is how we begin our Shmona srei though nice and protective thought goofy ie pilla petha that's a zipper asking permission we ask permission so he says should be k shinee metal-eating the muffled lame world Devorah allowed me place or space in order to say my words like it says in also till 21 verse 3 you have granted him his heart's desire and the utterance of his lips you have not withheld right it's the same concept and when Rashi explains the asahi so this is another explanation in Rashi lavash kiboshed ii after I conquered this is if Moses is saying after I conquered Aaron sequin vogue the land of secon anode the me see I imagined it to be it seemed to me Shama who thought had made their that the valid gainst my entering to the land would have been rescinded released so the clea kaarvok continues to say Wilier it seems akash of motion what was Moshe thinking he Tom Haneda who the reason for this vow of God was because of the verse in deuteron numbers 20 verse 12 because you did not trust in me God said you will not enter the land the people you will not believe the people into the land so because you didn't cause them to trust in me look around Tim Lee Israel I mean B it wasn't just that you didn't trust I mean you didn't trust in me to cause them to believe in me either right you didn't cause Israel to believe in me alienation you room a sum of forces at that through them seeing such a great miracle publicized miracle right we're talking about over there by the water the main Mareva talking to the rock who will myth heaven see honey mashallah we learned Gomorrah tight as the Moses caused the son to state standstill during this war are you they Mase look for some Zeb lease affection na sue Bunyan a moon ball that Moses assumed okay if I buy the rock and Mary law I didn't do the right thing and I need a tea cooler right I could have ready I could have spoke to the rock before God even commanded me but I didn't I went ahead he told me to speak to the rock and I hit the rock but over here I went ahead Moses went ahead and told the Sun to stand still as we'll see shortly but what would that have done that would have been a tea Countach appeal Kel if Moses would happen he did by the by the Sun he asked he commanded the Sun to stand still in this in this in this war situation and that was a miracle that he commanded it and it happened that would have fixed what he had by hitting the rock were speaking the coach Kannadasan for Akari according to the opinion of the safer Akari he writes she cusses the Tom caveman Reba that the really the reason for the the sin behind the sin of the the contention by watters he high a little emotional adhabi Amiata moella stella code them sheets ablution what was Moses big sin that what Moses should have spoken to the rock all on his own right before God even commanded him to do so he cold enough he goes there owner of the kind low because every prophet is able to make his own decrees by speaking and Hashem will fulfill it for him commercial açelya of Elisha what examples do we have by Elio and Elisha we have the the bow where le le ah who made certain decrees that this should happen and fire came down from heaven what was it by Alicia weird Alicia make commands to a Shannon Mike Oh God hook it up but the pain Yahshua you're sure did the same thing he actually made the sun sand stand still and give off as the pus ik said in joshua 10 verse 12 shemesh big evil dog that the Sun Stood Still cozy torrid be forever ah you're causing or forcing the words of the rod right the student makes a statement in the Rope has to fulfill in this case we're talking about the student being the Prophet and the rough the Rebbe being God Himself being a action of ulsan Moshe commercial also you're sure we're perhaps really making this comparison by Joshua and Moshe see now the Moses did it did what Joshua did we understand Josh would definitely did it we Moses did it but since Joshua did it we could certainly understand that Moses did it as well of I mean a comma came a official Athena because their shava because of what we call under the thirteen harmony the principles of the isère shovel where it says I hail I can this verse and Joshua says this day I begin that's Joshua 3 verse 7 and we also have in Deuteronomy 2 verse 25 this day I shall begin to place dread and right and this is by Moses so you have the same concept of a hail of causing this dread just like Joshua cause the dread and we know that Joshua made the commandment of sonship stand still we learn out that Moses did exactly the same thing and we don't make a heck ish we don't do this only halfway we don't make this harmonica principle only halfway in a casual country commotion shoe also came the Ox mo that just like Joshua made it happen on his arm so too we learned out the Moses also came the Osmo Moses also caused the son to stand still in the coma of all this on his own to stand still who presented Kadesh a shame and through this in the war he caused the name of a Shem to be sanctified and that was with TK Masha pill cow and that fixed what he had previously messed up or so he thought the pisac hamona to strengthen not only himself but the whole people to believe in God I'll came cachaca hoot Arnett there now to understand why your I she says that at this moment in time a time he he thought that that would be a release of God's original Val that he comes not to go into the land because he didn't cause them to trust in Hashem look below Chautala BuChE BuChE Eric C Conn Bobby but you know what Moses did not do he wasn't causing it his request to be dependent on the conquering of this land of seats on a note he lokahi lelou happy clown show who are because originally it was not included in the oath that God had made right as you can see in numbers 20 verse 12 lack a motive you alcohol has the l air to shitake Lechem as moshe pointed out this wasn't part of the land that was going to be given over so that wasn't the reason he gave not based on he was talking about the t could on the son standing still right i'll just read the verse in English this is numbers 20 verse 12 because you did not believe in me to sanctify me in the eyes of the children of Israel this is the verse we read before so one second where is this look halo 2 view at the Kahala has that l air to Shinnecock you look 10 or even again because you did not believe in me to sanctify me in the eyes and children which are therefore you will not bring this cartridge into the land that I have given you giving them which is referring to the land not belonging to seat on the note so therefore that wasn't part of the earth I knew artists Chevrolet motion cover not a level song it was only the the land of the seven nations that Hashem had promised to give to the forefathers I will Arrecife oh boy i'm a lambic flower kakuzu and that's why Moses did not say let me enough I copied them it was living in now that I have fixed my sin I imagined the Sun to stand still and that should be enough to release me from the valve because I made it tickle on them not believing in me meaning you wash em and therefore that's a fantastic explanation