Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
hi everybody Welcome to tonight's share
with Coach Menachem burnfeld thank you
for joining us on this beautiful Sunday
night
and being part of it tonight's year is
sheer 124
and um
the guy who makes the mattress is is out
so we're just gonna go with his gametria
was one one times two is two two times
two is four you know a little bit OCD I
guess but uh not a good Camacho but next
time we'll get it but the next year is
124 again we always start off every week
thanking uh people that are coming every
week and telling people about it Amber
Hashem is worldwide and we get you know
messages from all over the world
literally right Monaco
yeah from all over the world and we
appreciate it especially thanks to all
the viewers that tell their family and
friends about it they post it on
WhatsApp they emailed around they're
gonna say every week if the topic is not
negative it's fine you can join when it
is but let people know that you never
know what's relevant to who and it could
be really helping people just by letting
people know about the share
tonight have an open conversation about
uh you know anxiety and OCD will get
into it with Revenue
and um if anybody wants to join the
WhatsApp chats please WhatsApp me
personally at
848-525-0066 you could save my number
and your phone and every Sunday I will
send you the flyers and then later I
could also send you the the replays um
to his website you could sign up to get
the weekly emails and then you get the
weekly replays that's shame you could be
part of the coach family
tree community
like for those people watching this and
you the the replay of this on YouTube
please click on the Subscribe button and
also click on the and the on the like
button and every Monday morning uploads
it you got a ding and you're not gonna
share it up you can watch it please join
start off always thank all of our
advertising sponsors that promote us the
liquid scoop here on Lakewood is always
supporting us on the liquid in the
liquid area Ariel Sharon Ellie and Ariel
from Five Town Central special thank you
to Kyla California from JC Andrews kind
of always promoting us and all the
Jewish digital platforms again if
anybody's here the first time every
Sunday night for the past two and a half
years share 124. at 9 30 on this Zoom ID
we have many different abundant
different topics and it's been a while
and we have a lot of big stuff coming up
and uh next week
we have a very very big share his name
is Moshi Robert he's a robin Thomas
River he's a good friend of mine he's
been on once before he's a Rob and a
therapist he has both Milas and he's
going to be talking about is there a
concept of too much therapy think
there's a concept of too much therapy
maybe we should get rid of all the
therapists I have three more kids to
marry you off so I'll answer okay so
we'll push up the sheer until that's
done let me know when they're married
but the topic is is there a concept of
too much therapy what are the roles
bottom and therapists and do they
overlap
so um that should be something very
interesting and uh we got the right guy
for it so we'll see how next week plays
out should definitely be a meaningful
powerful program so please join us
whatever nobody till tonight we have
this awesome honor having world famous
therapist Michelle used to be an old
liquid residence and I was in Scranton
Pennsylvania but in this sugiya and this
parachute OCD and anxiety
he is uh from the good Island so that's
that's my uh my knowledge about how do I
know because I had friends that use them
so I know he's
and uh thank you for coming on I'm
trying to get back to him we're gonna
start off first with opening with Coach
monaster I know Coachman has anxiety
before he speaks so it's perfect
thank You Usher for giving me the
exposure
so I can get used to the anxiety
welcome everyone to another sheer your
Hashem we're up to 124 and with a lot of
Seattle
tonight we have a very special guest
like we heard
I mentioned to a few people were
discussing OCD and right away they told
me
Sean Epstein looks like uh his name is
out there
it's an important conversation
and there are many people who who are
suffering it's not it's not something
that we should take lightly
and I was sitting and discussing with uh
Michelle for a few minutes
and uh
sometimes you can throw a joke
and it looks like he takes it lightly
but
you have to know that those those
suffering and he knows because he deals
with it
it's not not an easy thing especially
talking about people
um in The Firm world
people want to do things right
and they want to do it
and they're not sure
they're not sure and sometimes it can be
instead of getting them closer to Hashem
it gets them further away and they're
not they're not able to function in a
healthy from elephant eats so it's an
important thing to learn what am I
supposed to do
by the way for those that have admired
that you say the same Palin Mata
oh now everybody's thinking I'm not sure
that doesn't mean I don't think it's OCD
I think that's pretty normal because
tonight was the first night
and for those who live with someone
someone in the house a close one who
suffered from these
from OCD or anxiety it's it's important
to understand understand what they're
going through
and the truth is that if you don't work
Hashem if you don't suffer from these I
I promise OCD and anxiety that's really
hard to understand what they're going
through what they're what the other is
feeling
but it's important to understand number
one what their what they're feeling
number two
what's my role
whether it's a spouse parent a teacher
because it could get a little tricky
sometimes you want to help but if you're
not sure how
you can be enabling and sometimes making
it worse
which will hit tonight
so these ideas come up in a lot of a lot
of places talking about the first
broadfish monastery
should I continue I should say it again
but even when I finish monastery
again
I'm not sure
whether talking about
I wasn't allowed to Daven talking about
having a clean body govnaki comes out a
lot of different Allah has come up
or even checking the door every night
before you go to sleep
the gas
making sure everything's okay and how
many times you do it
and then people have those thoughts that
they just can't stop their thoughts go
on and on again and again and again and
again they would love to just relax take
it easy
and you know
figure this is what it is now I can
continue life but they can't
so it's a big Sports to have with us
tonight
let me show them Epstein with us
so number one we can understand
for those who need to understand what it
is
understand what exactly
um am I going through and what's it can
I heal what do I do to heal where do I
go what do I talk to and if it's not you
if it's somebody that's close to you how
can I help them how can I be there as a
help whether teacher or parent or
whatever it is so we should have Allah
and we should be able to gain grow and
become closer to our channels remain
with a beautiful opening okay let's get
into it tonight first we're going to do
the shared position this is
all the hundreds of people that are here
now I mentioned the thousands thousand
people that listen to it all the help
you know that drop all the government
interviews for them and also for this
woman that had this terrible traged in
the Caribbean her name is henya devara
Leia should have a mouth and her I guess
a child should have in the summer
okay tonight was actually with us I'm
gonna read your bio and then you're
gonna open it up okay
sounds fair here we go here we go
show them epson's a license licensed
clinical social worker he has been
involved in treatment OCD the past 20
years and he has special interest in the
intersection
of anxiety and halacha he's The Clinical
Director of the OCD and anxiety
treatment center which Services the
greater Lakewood Community he received a
ba in Hebrew
completed his Master's in social work at
Maryland the university early in his
clinical work he met with Jonathan
Grayson PhD director of anxiety and
however you say that Center of
California in Pennsylvania a nationally
known expert in OCD the training was
beginning of a lifelong professional
relationship after training with Dr
Grayson Schumann again specializing in
treating OCD and more specifically
eruptly how do you say that I'm sorry
scrupulosity group velocity okay
um since then he has been in demand for
trading and consultations in the U.S and
abroad he's professional member of the
obsessive compulsive foundation and
thought that he has cultivated
relationships with leading researchers
and Clinics across the country since
embarking on his career machine has
spent countless hours discussing how
lucky implications of his work with
leading police came to dial them and
most recently has given training for the
base of our medical division currently
has offices in Lincoln New Jersey in
Scranton Pennsylvania he resides in
Scranton Pennsylvania with his wife and
children Epstein is supposed to have you
with us we appreciate you coming in here
tonight and spending your Sunday night
with us floor is yours
thank you thank you
thanks for having me
um this show is uh known for having
um
these Superstar guests like
Jacobson and um everyone else who's been
on it and so it's a big honor
I also want to say that
I don't know what's up with Usher and
Coach Menachem but
I don't know what this I'm jealous of
their suicim that they have just helping
so many people giving them inspiration
and hope and
there's some kind of subliminal
advertising going on but I can't figure
it out yet but really the truth is like
I can't afford therapies I figured I'll
just do it
so really hats off to you uh really
really
um really terrific
and
um
I'm fortunate enough to uh
grow up in Yeshiva and be any be any
achievement for a very long time so
this uh career sort of came together
in in a very good way so
I'm going to start out
um
by
telling you a little bit about OCD
I'm going to make it first through a PSA
public servants announcement
uh and then
um give you a little backgrounds
and then I think that once we have the
framework
a lot of the questions are going to
start to
follow a certain pattern and people are
going to really hopefully at the end of
this they're going to have a much
greater understanding
they'll realize that it's very
uncomplicated
so
um let me tell you a few things just
off the bat
people who suffer from OCD
are in a lot of pain
uh the it's a mental torment
and at as as painful as it is
they're excellent at hiding it
very mostly uh very highly intelligent
people and very very often high
functioning people
and uh you would never know it
um
that's number one number two I'd like
all your listeners to know that when
they hear the word OCD
they should not think of cases that are
portrayed in the media
that uh
are written for dramatic effect
because not everyone who has OCD is
walking around with garbage bags under
their clothing in order not to get germs
I just think that's one real example
that was printed
these are really the people that I deal
with they're very high functioning uh
accomplished uh professionals
and um once in a while you'll get a
severe case like the ones that you read
about
but that is not the norm
that's number two number three
I would like for people to
be careful when they say
um
I'm so OCD or he is OCD
first of all it's not a it's not a word
to use just to describe uh a friend
who's neat or yourself it was neat it's
a disorder and the people who really
have it throwing it around is really
cheapens it a little bit uh and secondly
a person suffers from OCD or they have
OCD they aren't OCD
and so I know it's a subtle distinction
but
when you hear it
he's OC it's just uh jarring to if God
forbid someone has it or
those of us who treat it it's not the
totality of the person the fact that
they have OCD
so uh that's just uh to advocate for uh
my clients
uh
Menachem knows more about this than he
let on when we spoke uh so I will say
that uh
these kinds of problems are discussed
widely
uh in halachic literature uh the stipler
writes about it extensively
he's when when someone when Rabbi a
psychologist named Dr Greenwald also
Thomas wrote him letters
very often he would say I've seen many
people like this I've seen many higher
Bakers erasia so many many people like
this
so
it is uh it's very common it's not
something that uh just showed up
so uh it's been around
and
the
OCD normally attacks something which is
most valuable to the person
so if the person's relationship to
Hashem is their most valuable thing the
most important to them
so the anxiety is going to threaten that
thing
just like a terrorist
or a kidnapper you know
the
take away those kidnap Someone's Child
why because they know
the person would do anything for the
child
so anxiety will take something uh
that's a very important to you so in
this case it's the person's uh the
person's Yiddish kite
uh
I'm supposed to come up with an
inspirational story about OCD
uh that's on my to-do list here tonight
uh is there you know what there are
hundreds and hundreds of inspirational
stories
uh I'll tell you this
it's very very treatable
uh it's it's uh one of the most
um evidence-based
treatments that exist in mental health
and this treatment is very
straightforward
once again you the person has to uh you
know be an expert and experience but
the the the success rates are
incredibly good
and uh I feel very fortunate and people
um
have told me
for example
uh they when they're 65 percent better
they said it was like going from black
and white to color
in their life
it's uh you don't have to get 100 better
to have a great life
so people are constantly constantly
getting better
some cases more complicated than others
but a straightforward case of OCD is
um
very very treatable and I want uh people
to we're going to find we're going to
ask probably about when and how and you
know what's considered OCD and what
isn't we'll get into that
but
but the people should know that uh it's
they shouldn't be so scared about it
and
um they certainly shouldn't be scared to
go get treatment for it that's uh
that's uh that should be uh understood
and um the good thing about treatment
for OCD is that they don't ask you about
your mother
so you don't have to go into all that
stuff you don't want to uh you know
again it's a straightforward case
they're not gonna you know go into your
kishkas it's a behavioral treatment and
we'll get into that
uh it's very behavioral and directive
and all you have to do is get the model
and be motivated and that's all
we have a lot of questions that came in
I want to just clarify something and
then we'll jump into the polls and the
questions you just clarify what OCD is
what it means and said in the beginning
but I don't think you clarified it
that's the general mouth that will
answer a lot of the questions and then
let's jump into it okay great so
we're gonna Let's uh look at it like
this
we make it two columns O and C
obsessions and compulsions obsessions
are just intrusive thoughts
that have two elements to it
they uh they contain a doubt there's 95
of the cases they can't detain it out
and they come with an uncomfortable
emotion
anxiety tension uh that kind of thing
so again it's very simple so yeah that's
all two ingredients doubt and discomfort
under this the C column A compulsion is
something the person will do
to either reduce their anxiety or to
gain certainty
there's a function to that behavior
so anything that does that is considered
a compulsion I'll quickly give you five
major areas where you find it
number one is I think monogram said
repeating something you do something
I get this feeling a thought
maybe I didn't do it right I feel
uncomfortable do it again
then we have checking
people could check the lock they could
check their pulse they could check their
filling all those behaviors come from a
thought that maybe it's wrong maybe it's
unlocked some kind of dangerous thought
so for someone who learns the gemara
that um
villain a head that doesn't have
twilling on it is uh is in trouble so
they can get oh my gosh maybe it's in
the wrong place that's checking number
three
here comes the interesting ones
reassurance sinking
that's when you involve someone else
in getting your anxiety down or being
sure you ask your spouse you ask your
parents you ask somebody ask your friend
and the pa the person being a nice
person will say yeah don't worry they're
worried they're worried that's just
reinforces the cycle that's called
reinsure reassurance and that's where
rabunum come into the picture talk about
that later number four is an invisible
convulsion mental compulsions
so sometimes those person will get a
down in their head and they'll just try
to talk themselves out of it logic
um
clarifying things so when people think
that they're obsessing
really what they're doing is compulsing
they had a question and they're trying
to answer it
and we don't see that they just in their
head okay and the last one is the fifth
one is also invisible
it's avoidance
you avoid the situation in which the
uncertainty could come up so for example
there are people who don't have any
milks in their house
we're not going to have milk there's no
Milkshakes that way we won't get into
any
possible of questions we're just we're
not allowing the situation to come up
somebody once never had any power of in
their house because power is very sneaky
because it could go either way become
military conflictions without telling
you so
these are all not doing something
in order to avoid the uncertainty so
that is the basic framework when we do
treat for OCD what we're trying to do is
help the person raise their tolerance
for uncertainty
so just like there is uncertainty in the
world in general
there's uncertainty in the world of
Allah too and I want to urge anybody to
ask any question
no matter how
strange or
provocative you think it might be please
ask it and or if you think that I'm uh
going off the reservation
uh yeah call in and ask and challenge it
uh because that's what this is a
conversation that's why we're here
tonight exactly you got it beautiful
opening I just want to clarify it after
all the things you listed I think were
basically all certified so questions on
how we're going to get help was uh
yeah most people have one of those
dangers not all so they seem pretty
common to me
just being honest okay let's jump at the
polls and then we'll get in again the
way it works is anybody has a question
text us upon us a lot of questions go
first we have time we get to the text
questions a bunch of emails came in and
we'll try to get to it and the Machine
was here he's the expert in the field of
anxiety and OCD if you have a question
about yourself let anybody ask it
easier to answer it with a lot of
clarity on all these questions
let's start the three question Paul here
we go
three questions oh I forgot what Paul is
here you know you got it
and that's where you see the ball
I forgot what the ball is I I now
remember I'll tell you to pull
afterwards I'll put it after after I
read the three what percentage of people
do you think have clinical certified OCD
in your opinion zero to five percent of
100 people six out of ten people six out
of ten
of a hundred like six six six to ten MN
are higher than ten percent of people
what's your opinion about clinical OCD
second question how do you deal with
your anxiety four options be honest
medication substance abuse
therapy how do you deal with your
personal anxiety on any level
third question do you feel Orthodox
Judaism Fosters OCD
washing your hands all those different
things that we you know deal with yes no
just it's an opinion it doesn't there's
no right or wrong yes no definitely a
contributing factor
those are the three answers the fourth
poem so I remember what I want to write
I want to make a question like this does
this question bother you Capital small
Capital small Capital small Capital
small Capital small and do yes or no
that's what I wanted now I remember this
cruel yeah but obviously I forgot so it
wasn't meant to be okay everybody answer
these three questions and then we'll
review it together over show them and
then we will get into a lot of questions
a lot of bunch of live over there and
um try to cover as much as possible
okay
five four
it's gonna show them you can see what
people are answering now but they don't
see it and when I stop and I share with
everybody sees the final answer so you
see the way everybody on well 565 people
are contributing to their opinions and
we get to clarify isn't that important
to them 400 of them are my family
members they're just on many different
devices I think is this the sky is this
the schizophrenia which part of the
okay
let's share the polls here we go share
the results okay
what percentage of people do you think
have clinical certified OCD so we have
wow very interesting results 28 to 28
both think zero to five or six to ten
forty three percent of people have to
people think more than 10 percent of
people one in ten people have clinical
OCD or moshula map student whoa correct
answer
uh the correct answer is 2.4 percent
but that is
I always thought that was a lot that's
one in 40 people you're in a room you're
at a Hasina and there are 400 people
there
you know you got some cases
you know probably a higher number that's
not clinically and certified well well
what I mean is um they have clinically
significant OCD so you can have
subclinical OCD uh but
that's not interfering with your life so
that's like quirks and things like that
right if it's subclinical
okay the second question
um how do you deal with your anxiety on
any level 18 of people say they take
medication three percent of people do
substance abuse 49 of people over here
I'm going to be talking that's the
winning answer and 30 of people are
therapy Michelle so
um it goes like this here's my opinion
and uh that's all I can give you
um I would assume that immunity is the
answer for anxiety that's not
uh not a disorder
so that means as Jews our first uh our
first line of defense so to speak or our
our perspective on life the moon and be
toughen but when you when you cross that
line into
um clinical
uh area
not only is not the answer
but it could be a problem and I'll tell
you why
because let's say somebody is
um has anxiety and they're told that
they they need to have a moon in
Metuchen and they continue to have
anxiety so now they have two problems
they have anxiety and they don't have a
moon and be talking
so we have to be very careful uh when
dispensing that kind of advice
uh I think that uh is
is going to be the answer when you don't
have an anxiety disorder
um and therapy and medication of course
has their has their place and we're
going to talk about that later probably
um when medication is in order
um in OCD treatment
medication is considered
a partial it only gives you a partial
response so even if the person goes to
psychiatrist and they break it and they
prescribe medication they will always
tell you do CBT do cognitive therapy
cognitive behavior therapy because the
medicine alone is not going to do it and
very often the therapy alone
can do it the last poll is do you feel
Orthodox Judaism forces OCD 17 people
say yes 34 of people say no and a
whopping 49 of people say
definitely a contributing factor amazing
you can definitely feel that either Sky
definitely
upstanding
yeah what's your opinion so so
um
there hasn't been definitive research
but
but uh all the research that's done so
far indicates that there is no
correlation between uh religiosity and
OCD now I don't know if they did their
study in Lakewood New Jersey or
Williamsburg or wherever in in these
enclaves of uh
of uh from Karate jury
but
it happens to be
um
across cultures even there's no there's
no correlation and there there was one
study
you'd have to ask my friend uh shout out
to Jed Steve who's a researcher from
researcher at Swarthmore uh I think that
in some studies show that religiosity
actually there was a little bit less OCD
but the thing it's easy it's easy to see
it that Yiddish kite is a fertile ground
a fertile ground for OCD because we have
so many rituals and this and that and
the other
um
I would say
that
if a person's in an environment that's
very high pressure and the pressure is
about
um
pressure is about being
adherent style up a maybe I could see
how that might um
you know bump it up a little bit but in
terms of the research
it's just um if the re actually that
they say if you did if they didn't have
it about the Yiddish kite and they
weren't from they would have it about
something else
that's uh that's the conventional wisdom
so
um yes here we have a lot of questions
people want to ask please Grill them
let's do it you're on first
hi there thank you for taking my call
um I wanted to ask you that I have an 18
year old daughter who has OCD Tendencies
her whole life
she constantly stresses about making
things straight and neat around our home
should I let her or should I tell her to
leave it alone at what point should I be
interviewing
perfect question
thank you for bringing that to the
conversation so
um are we assuming you haven't said
anything yet because you're a saint if
you I
um I try not to say anything I really
try amazing
um
okay so here's how you you would uh you
would approach that
you would
I I the first question I would ask is
how upset would she be if it's not
straight
that's number one number two is
if you have a obviously communication if
you could have this conversation with
her what is she free afraid might happen
if it's not straight
and once she is a if you can get that
question answered
then you'll know
um if it's a sensory thing
does she just like things straight
or is she afraid that if it's not
straight some train is going to go off
the track somewhere
that's not
psychotic a person could have magical
type OCD or suspicious superstitious OCD
so
um that would be the first person you
would do have a conversation with her
but
let's say
she said I just don't like it
I don't like often her answer oh
I don't like the way you feel so
so then you have a you have a child who
has a sensitivity
which you as a parent are probably
concerned
that is going to get in the way of her
life moving forward relationships
functioning
and
um
at some point
she or she's going to realize either
with your help or not that it's it's
going to interfere with your life and
there's something she could do about it
in that particular case
it would be their skills that people
could learn to tolerate discomfort like
mindfulness type skills things like that
so uh
you know I always ask people you know is
this something you like
how's it working out for you so if the
person says something they don't like
then the next thing is uh
well let's let's get it taken care of
you know so the first question is what
might happen if it's not straight do you
think anything crazy might happen just
like it doesn't like you just don't like
the way it feels
okay would you rather not have that be
part of your life and then there is
there are therapists who uh can teach
these skills
is that answer your question okay yeah
beautiful answer okay great Next Live
question we'll try to knock out a few
lives now and then we'll try to get some
of the email questions
okay I'm here
on Zach
I'm talking
okay you're on sorry about that
hi uh thank you for taking my question
um this is a question more of like
related to OCD uh I would maybe I would
call it self-posed OCD
um I just want to know you know this is
a
maybe a lesson I didn't learn properly
in Yeshiva or I took a 10 extreme and I
want to know what is the I never got the
real answer
it's more of like when tragedies
were the situation which is looks like a
there's a danger we have to Don for
something
and uh we're just reading to heal him
and reading and reading but the things
should get better
and even after we've finished reading
and we cry or whatever
I tend to just like I'm still worried
what if my child didn't get answered and
you did get answered maybe it didn't go
all the way and didn't deserve to get
answered or even I had the same thing
when the
you know the young Titan come up from
ello you know I prepare for metal I
start so hard I prepared from Rosh
Hashanah get a little bit exhausted Rosh
Hashanah by push until the mkeeper and
then Yom Kippur they say this is the end
and then
you know FTM people they say sukis is
the elevatorium keeper and I I just
sometimes feel I got the lesson wrong I
know there is a right lesson there but
there's just like this feeling of It's
never enough like how do I like take
that lesson whatever I did appreciate it
but also strive more the way the common
one us to
um and balance everything properly and
appreciate what we did and also have
this drive to continue on so
um sounds like your heart's in the right
place
because a lot of times when people are
worried about their diving
I don't know if this is you they have a
an exaggerated sense of responsibility
so a lot of times uh even if this
happens a lot with children where they
say feel them in their class and then
unfortunately uh
person whatever is Nifty or whatever the
case is
and one and one at one kid out of 40.
we'll we'll think it's their fault
and uh adults as well
you know uh the the these chain tell
them calls that go around are fantastic
except for my clients because how could
you not die for this you just took one
little tool to get them over the edge
and
you were not present
so so there's often an exaggerated sense
of responsibility
um that's I don't know if I sense that
that much from what you said uh you know
one of my clients once uh went to rev uh
Jacob mayor Schechter is that his name
in Erica yeah
and uh one of the things he said was
means that if it comes with pressure has
no roots in holiness
and you know this is a very holy person
okay for those of you who don't know him
he's uh he's a huge everything
and he's telling this person a cloudy I
heard it straight from the person like
this is not and you know this whoever's
asking the question that's not the way
it's supposed to be
so
um
let's take let's see let's shunningham
Kipper so the person is worried
no no it's just the speech I get you
know Roshana we forget about our
accomplishment in Errol and we'll come
see him keep her buying if we're tired
they give that I get that speech that
now is the end and everything goes by
now and we better put in all our
questions and if I'm tired I feel guilty
like I forget about all everything I
accomplished till now and then comes to
Shawna rabo they say now is the end and
then Thompson say no no this is the peak
of everything and like everything
depends on this right so so here's this
first question
is your availab going up as a result of
these species or going down
I'm just pushing I'm pushing I mean
maybe not up and not down I mean yeah
out of breath out of breath
let me let me quote you uh someday this
is uh
let me get the stipler wrote to Bianco
Greenwald
it's translated into English
um let's see ordinarily a person may
occasionally find himself in a situation
where it's difficult to carry out a
mitzvah
so that he cannot perform it with the
usual appropriate pleasure
this is natural
he sees this as a challenge and on the
next occasion we'll carry it out with
pleasure since usually does miss us a
pleasure
however the person who whenever he
performs the ratsun Hashem
science's soul and his energies
contorted by feelings of discomfort fear
attention and misery
overdoing that mitzvah
and on the contrary that's how it is for
him
most of the time and to carry out
Commandments out of joy is the exception
then this is clear proof that this was
not hashem's intention
this is from the safe air
is I didn't find the exact page yet
okay this is a safer with the
correspondence to Bianca Greenwald to
to the stapler so
the person uh
you hear these um
what I used to call them scarier pants
off schmoozes you know
um
so there are other ways to motivate
yourself
and
um so either
so here's how is this is a good case
where
if it's not clinical you should be
reading different smart
how there is actually a safer written
all about Roshana you know Kipper
the simcha part of it it's called
and or the other the other possibility
is that
there's something that you haven't you
have anxiety and therefore anything that
you hear
you you're afraid not to do it so you're
very easily influenced
so in that case I would explore that but
you have great Insight you know that
it's not healthy so
awareness is the first step
okay let's jump to one uh email question
we have a bunch of live still but I want
to get through some of these questions
okay
go ahead
I was diagnosed with OCD but I also feel
a lot of anxiety as well can I get some
clarification what is the difference
between OCD and anxiety and can they
overlap
sure
so uh the answer is you can win both
and have both anxiety and OCD but
they're very similar uh so
OCD is only when you have those two
things that I described an obsession
followed by a compulsion and the
compulsion is basically one of those
five things
when a person has anxiety they're
excessively anxious about normal things
and
the response of the anxiety for the most
part when you have general anxiety
disorder is avoidance
so that person is not necessarily having
intrusive thoughts uh that they don't
want they feel like they're just pushing
themselves into your head uh that's
that's not anxiety is just worry worry
and if I can get my if I sometimes
people will organize their life around
not having to worry about certain things
so they will limit their life
and start doing fewer things in order
not to be anxious and the anxiety will
be feel like just worrying a lot OCD is
where you have this boom you know some
really
um almost like outrageous sometimes
outrageous but a thought that
you're much more sh you're much more
aware that there's something wrong with
the thought most of the time
so you can have both you could be a a
very uh worried person
and
um
and then that would be you know we'd
have to work you have to deal with that
and uh ocd's uh you can have that as
well right but I would say though I
would treat them both very similarly
where the person who has anxiety instead
of
avoiding whatever it is they're afraid
of
we would purposely
accept whatever the worst case scenario
is
a practice accepting it and we'll get to
if you want to learn about how the
treatment works we'll get to that uh
what what exposure works but the idea
would be just like an OCD we we could we
get the person to do exercises where he
he uh he faces the worst case scenario
so through an anxiety I would do the
same thing even though it's not it's
it's uh more normal type things
beautiful
okay
um let's take another Live question
you're on oh hi
um my question is I have a nine-year-old
daughter
who since the end of the summer she
started displaying OCD Tendencies like
she'll just asking me is it okay if I
touch the table and then I touch my
mouth is it okay if I the paper touched
my hand and then my hands out to my
mouth like all these like reassurance
questions and then like
so also like in general like everything
is like is it dangerous like oh
um not even touching just in general
like is it dangerous that my neck let's
say my shirt was too tight on me like
something happened everything got
dangerous so my first question is it
came out of the blue so like should I be
worried like white all sudden happen
number two is like how do I respond
because I don't want to feel like I'm
enabling cards every time I say oh it's
okay or what do you think she'll say
like she knows it's okay but like she
still keeps asking me so like I really
have like no idea what to do so you just
like tell me like a guideline or do you
think she needs therapy or could I do
myself
okay
perfect that is a question that a lot of
people can relate to so I'm glad you
asked it
so this is a very good uh time where we
could talk about what we call
accommodation
and that is where parents and spouses
feed into the OCD
and
um
feed into the OCD and uh it just
continues and continues and continues
um sudden onset OCD it depends how
sudden it is
like if it's really really sudden
there's something called pandas I don't
know
yeah so that is pediatric audience
sort of associated with strap something
like that so I mean just the thing is
she did have she has like she always had
a drop in anxiety like it's not but she
never had this kind of like OCD thing
it's always like a little on the nervous
side but not like anxiety you know what
I mean yeah so so nine years old is
um is actually
[Music]
um
right around the age that it comes out
in children
so
so number one accommodation
so what do you do if you're not going to
come that you're going to feel really
mean if you don't right that's what
you're from mothers
so
um
I would do this first there are a lot of
good books for parents okay
um she's nine
so there's a lady named Don Huebner
h-u-e-b-n-e-r something like that
on Amazon what to do a whole series of
what to do when you worry too much and
then there's one specifically about OCD
what to do when your mind gets stuck
and it's they're very very well done all
about all different CBT but kids read it
you read it with your kid your kid can
read it themselves
then there's a book um
uh freeing your child's but most CD by a
lady named Tamar chansky
you know if you read that book that's
for parents you will number one
understand what's going on
beautifully
and uh and then you'll know
when it comes time to seek treatment
if the when any diagnosis in what we the
DSM which is the
psychological uh manual
the menu of psychological disorders
uh it always says does it interfere with
their social occupational or academic
function
so that is usually the line where
you know the person needs help
so you would I would um
once again uh have a conversation are
you afraid what are you afraid of
you know they're usually pretty
articulate
and then um how much does it bother you
and then uh
you know would you like to speak to
somebody but I don't have a problem I'm
not like uh you know enough for
schlepping ever you get to therapy so
you know you could you could you could
try to you know do something yourself
but the idea is
that
um
parents who have an anxious child need
to model two things
acceptance of uncertainty and acceptance
of imperfection
so you could look for opportunities to
um
uh to say oh you know oops this happened
or oh well
or
I'm not sure how this is going to work
out but we'll figure it out
meaning you're not you're not
continuously planning for the future so
you say those things out loud
you're modeling that you're can live
life with some uncertainty you don't
have to know everything right now
but uh definitely keep an eye on it
beautiful let's go to the next question
here we go you're on
hi
um I have like Tendencies to be OCD and
sometimes it gets it makes me feel like
I dislike some Mitzvahs like for example
like Mikvah or other things how do I get
past that
okay we got quite a few emails like that
by the way okay
so
I don't know I mean if I was terrified
when I did something I wouldn't like it
either
but it doesn't mean you don't like the
mystery it just means you have anxiety
so
but you know this is what I said before
you don't have two problems just have
one problem anxiety don't have anxiety
problem and the yitter Skype problem so
um
you probably don't have a Yiddish guy
gravel especially since you're worried
about having a Yiddish guy problem so
you probably don't have to hear this guy
problem but
but
there has to be a way for you to do that
mitzvah
without it being
um such a burden
it's not meant to be that way
so
I'm not sure uh if you're having uh a
lot of doubts about something you have
to repeat things do you
is a huge huge Topic in OCD
um there are women who spend hours upon
hours in the in the mickville you know
doing the khafifa and preparations and
and there's also a lot of other uh other
uh other rules
um every every
um young married guy who comes into my
office
I say okay so to keep your eyes closed
in the bathroom
oh yeah eyes closed lights off you know
so because they don't want to see
nothing so
uh
I don't know you know you got to find
out if does it sound like you do you
have doubts do you have intrusive doubts
about what's going on what you're doing
yes yes yeah so so those doubts are just
produced by anxiety
and there's no end that means you cannot
answer every single one of those
questions but if you answer one there's
another one right behind it there's
going on forever
so at some point
you and me and everyone else have to
okay
now if you don't have anxiety you sort
of intuitively know when to stop
but if you have anxiety it pushes you
and pushes you and pushes you
even in in even a ready as far back as
the mishnayas
we have this idea in in two places but
one of them for shorts or places one of
them is
talks about checking for comments
so they said well what about
if you check the room and you saw a
rodent
right uh you have to worry that it took
comments from a one place and put it
into the place that you checked
so the mission ends off and says well if
you have to worry about that then you
have to worry about it they're brought
from someone else's house they've heard
about that you have to worry that it
brought about them from uh the next
neighborhood if you worry about that you
have to worry about
herself
there's no end so even seeing the
mishnayas they're not telling you we
guarantee you there's no comments in
that room
they're just saying
there's no end to that question
so you got to let it go
so
but knowing that is if you have OCD
knowing that
doesn't help
because
whenever there's a conflict between
logic and emotion I'm betting on emotion
every time
so uh you would need a a therapist to
design exercises for you where you could
literally raise your tolerance for
uncertainty and discomfort
almost like a um
a thermostat
so
when the thermostat is this high
so the so the the air conditioning
doesn't kick on until the heat reaches a
certain point if you have OCD it's down
here
and all you worry starts kicking in at a
much lower level
so actually behavioral exercises could
just raise that and then you won't start
getting nervous so around the area where
other people might start getting nervous
or ask a Shiloh
so you sound like a uh
very textbook person who could be helped
is that helpful
yes thank you
it's Locker what happens if you don't
trust your therapists
Oh you mean like a Harry from Scranton
that kind of therapist well he wants to
make you feel he wants to make you feel
good
oh I see but at the end of the day
you're still not sure if you did it
right oh that's a beauty
and um
that is true
that you have a brother who looks
exactly like me
this might not even be Mitchell
Elementary
okay which I do say that sometimes but
but that's a fair question so how should
I trust my therapist so if I'm the
therapist
I would do this
um no Let's do let's say normal
behaviors on a Continuum right uh line
right so down here people who well down
there people who don't care
right up here are people with OCD and I
always say the option of a rabbit
because he's super special now in the
middle
all this is Norm normative Allah
Behavior okay
I am going to ask the client or in this
case this person right here
if you would do X
what do you think
you know do you think it falls in the
middle I'm not I'm not going to be
somebody's uh rough I let the I let the
person decide
and look is a good opportunity to point
out two things
one is I have something called the Shyla
protocol okay I don't know if you uh
this woman asks a lot of shilohs but
that's typically what happens
so
a person can say
would a non-anxious person have this
child
okay
now sometimes a person can answer that
question
now it doesn't mean that I'm okay it
just means we're learning what is an
acceptable level of risk
so when I say answer the question and
say a non-anxious person wouldn't have
this question what that means is
a non-anxious person would accept this
risk now
if you're really really anxious the
person will say
I can't I I don't know how can I guess
and I say that's what a guess is when
you don't know but I can't I can't I
can't so then you do what's called the
gun test this is all part of therapy but
I'm telling it to you for a reason
and uh so the gun test is you have a gun
pointed at your head what would you
guess would an anxious person have this
question or not now now I'm telling you
this because
because
I
this and the next thing I'm going to
tell you I ran by many many
and they say sure the person
the person could guess
who I asked they're not telling you that
you're guessing right you have to always
remember that they're telling you that's
a legitimate way of conducting yourself
in Allah I don't know if you're going to
be right you're going to be wrong the
Rob doesn't know the specific question
but they're giving you a mahalos a a
pathway
to keep the halacha
with some level of uncertainty and the
second one is
what do I think the rub would say
this is an interesting one
so
the way the question goes is you just
left the rub's office or you just hung
up the phone
what did he say
and you have to go by what do you think
he said
but I don't know so guess I can't guess
gun tests
now it's interesting that Rabbi
forsheimer loved this one I was really
surprised he said yeah I like that one
better than the other one what would the
Rob say
now you have to be careful because
you've talked to a London that's why I
said you left the rub's office because
if you once if you're in the rub's
office okay he's saying this I'm saying
this he's saying this I'm saying this B
you have to go through the whole thing
with the guy no you left what did he say
so uh there there you could
you know that that's that's a um oh you
the question was how do you trust a
therapist
that's how I didn't I didn't say
anything
I didn't ask in any L office I just said
well what do you think
you I think it's not good I think I
didn't do it because it didn't work out
okay
so I have to do it again
that's what you have to do
the person
the person knows when they're being
honest and when they're not being honest
now if they think in OCD 99.99 of the
time it's a doubt
so I'll say are you afraid you didn't do
it good or you know
and they'll say I'm afraid so that
scenario where they say I'm sure which
is one percent of the time I say go
ahead ask the Shyla or do it again but
it's rarely the case so if I'm afraid
that there's comets in my house after I
made mediko's comets I could just tell
myself
it's fine
right so
I don't know but it's fine all I know is
you don't have to zoom I should check
again it's not fine I can't live like I
can't go and prepay stuff like that
because you're anxious oh yeah right so
what we're gonna do is if you can't go
into pay stuff like that what we're
gonna do is
you you you have to do a
the cure for OCD is here's the sentence
frequent and prolonged exposure to the
feared stimulus results in habituation
habituation means getting used to
something
so just telling myself something is not
going to work
you have to go to Michelle and Epstein
and in in uh in August he tells you to
take a handful of Cheerios close your
eyes and throw them
so you don't know where they go
and they're already preparing in August
for the possibility because there's
comments in your house
now what do you mean how could you do
that
well I don't know do you have children
do they eat Cheerios
need I say more
I mean do you know where they're putting
all their Cheerios well I try to make
sure yeah well your kids are going to
eat therapy if you're chasing them
around the same with your Cheerios so
what you see what I just did I just made
it normal I didn't even I didn't passion
people have kids they throw Cheerios
right so what you so it takes a while
a little a few months of treatment not
that many
to gradually get used to the uncertainty
so just saying something to yourselves
isn't going to do it you have to do
these exercises
but it really works very very quickly
very quickly uh it surprises me still
not quickly but it's not a one-time
thing it's a it's really a getting used
to the water kind of thing so you have
to get into the water and stay there
in order to get used to if you jump out
and do a compulsion or do some safety
Behavior you're not going to get used to
the water
so uh I don't know so the therapist
really does not have to
have anything to do
with what the halacha is so
um
if the therapist is
is good
you know you don't have to have this
fake sperm screen behind you to boost
your credentials
yeah you could just ask them what what
do you think everyone else does
and
that's it so everyone else does that or
sometimes when it comes to the dominant
question I think I'll show you someone
mention it
does do you what do you think Hiroshima
does what do you think he does when he
washes his hands does he watched it you
know 50 times
I'm not we're not saying those things to
talk The person out of it
we're saying that to
show the person that there's uncertainty
that everyone lives with
Shiva didn't get a memo how to do an
eagle vosser perfectly
everyone's in the same boat
so
it's just about understanding it's all
about the level of uncertainty or risk
and looking around and seeing okay
what's a normal level of risk to accept
I'm sure we have a lot of questions live
and we have a lot of copper we've really
covered anything so we need a put it
both hands are shorter no no no whatever
you'd be faster
[Laughter]
okay you're on next
hi I want you to know um why it's like
so
um look down upon in the Jewish World
with someone has OCD or anxiety
um more as in the non-dressed world it's
like they're taught about it or their
teachers are just much more open-minded
about it and let's see I'll give you an
example like my sister she suffered with
OCD when she was younger and because she
wasn't taught about it
um when she was younger she felt so
embarrassed to like embrace it and now
that she's older she's having so many
issues and that's it also I'm like if
someone has OCD or anxiety or is on
medication like automatically there's
something wrong with them
well that's a fair question uh it's a
little more of a um cultural
socio-cultural question
I don't know the answer it awareness is
growing people know more about it
I don't still don't think they're
talking about mental health except for I
teach in evasiakov
9th to tenth grade so
in our school we talk about it a lot we
have coach
hey Olsen I think we have Coach we talk
about it oh yeah right we have this
right exactly so uh but but uh but it is
true I don't know if they look down at
it you know
it maybe yes or maybe you know when it
comes to shizukam though
it's getting better well okay all right
what can I tell you it's getting better
um
are getting more uh having a better
understanding of it and
what happens is let's say a person
discloses on uh that they have of your
anxiety
they will give the other person the
therapist's phone number
and so if the therapist is fair
the the the person will have a chance uh
if the other person is not tolerant of
the person's anxiety Then should it was
not for them
yeah
one second one second
all right okay sorry continue
that I I wanted to be concise I hope you
know it's a it's a fair question
let's go to the next question
hi hello I'm I'm talking from South
America Chile so thanks for the for the
for this uh opportunity to ask I I was
wondering if have you heard about
kids
that have been diagnosed by Panda by OCD
caused by pandas
and have you seen what's the treatment
that you have seen most successful
all right tell us about pandas but I I
wanted to ask about that
right so uh I don't have a any direct
experience with pandas
uh the treatment from what I know is
long-term antibiotics
uh but I also think that they need this
cognitive behavioral treatment as well
I don't think that the antibiot I don't
think it remits goes away
uh that quickly with the uh with with
the antibiotics but
uh is becoming more and more an accepted
diagnosis not 100 percent
uh uh it's not it's not only strep now
it's other neurological
uh type things
so the typical treatment is antibiotics
and cognitive behavioral treatment uh
therapy
okay
let's go next
Ariana hi I was I was just curious you
mentioned earlier like the idea of
exaggerated sense of responsibility so
people you know be Carrie I just
wondered if there are other
underlying causes of OCD like you know
like a
maybe there's a guilt but I just
wondered people would be to be used uh
need for you have sticky even somebody
with an eating disorder
trying to you know maintain a certain
sense of control you know unfortunately
you can try to control others that way
as well but do you find that that you
know sometimes there is an underlying
that has to be treated somebody might
even be I don't know genetically just
you know predisposed but but I mean just
talking environmental factors right
so um there's a significant minority of
cases that have a trauma back
trauma
um
so we uh what we try to do is uh
what's neat what what needs treatment we
don't necessarily treat the trauma first
just because they had trauma but if we
think that that's the
the main issue
then we'll treat the trauma but I have
to say quite openly we often don't and
that we don't ignore it
but we often treat the OCD
first it's the most prominent symptom
and it will CBT will help
and but we have our eye we always
monitor for trauma
um I don't know if it's always
um
control though or response that's a
little psychodynamic but it it meaning a
person can have a trauma in one area and
have OCD and something completely
unrelated and it's not controlled about
everything it's a very specific
idiosyncratic thing that they're focused
on but yes trauma for sure I mean
about probably five years ago now we
were at a conference and one of my
friends
we're just going over to researchers and
asking them could you please do more
research on trauma and OCD but I think
everyone agrees that there is there
there is a decent percentage minority of
cases that that have trauma but they're
not directly related so what that means
is that a stressful event could trigger
OCD
but it may not be the cause of the OCD
it could be like you mentioned like
that's a that's fair to check
responsibility oh did like I don't know
does someone die on their watch or
something you know it's fair to look for
that connection often it's it's not
there it's more like there's a stressful
event
and the person just uh their OCD gets
triggered but that's that's fair that
happens
that does that clarify it yes
okay you're on hi
hi
um some of you have heard my story some
of you have not I am 32 years old and I
lost my mom about three years ago
and my anxiety has been through the roof
my PTSD shot up and covered spun around
I'm in a facility and we're having a
little bit of a winter Spike with covid
and I can't control my anxiety I can't
control my PTSD I'm losing it
well it's a good thing I'm here
ah I feel terrible
he does the death of your mother have to
do with covet are they related no they
don't know something different but it
happened like around six months before
kovid hit
and do you know what you have Steve from
no
it just I have I've had a lot of things
happening in my life like deaths back
back to back surgeries back to back to
back
covid popped up I had covered and then
when we spiked again I tested myself
three times in one day because I thought
I had it
right is that what you're anxious about
or you're just anxious in general I mean
just in general okay yeah all right so
we can't do treatment on the show but he
cannot resist asking is there a content
to your anxiety or anxiety about are you
anxious about something specific
wife
it's a four-letter word did you know
that
yes
uh anything specific about life
what's around the corner next for me
because I'm also disabled on top of
everything so I've been having surgeries
back to back to back I lost both my
parents my uncle my grandfather
all in the last 22 years
yeah okay so you're anxious about life
but you really mean the other thing
so uh I'm not saying the other thing I'm
trying to spin it
of course of course so um
well I feel terrible for your situation
but the same rules apply
the same rules apply that means you can
tell us more than anyone else
that life is full of uncertainty
I don't have to tell you that you could
tell me that
right so
the thing is that there's nothing we can
do to get rid of it that is part of the
human condition
how we relate to that
that idea which is sobering
right relate to that really determines
our quality of life
now you know
you've been you've you've been you know
uh face to face with some very very
difficult uh circumstances
the
I'll I'll quote a uh a uh someone called
the um
oops sorry about that
no we now we know we're telling the
truth uh the the quote the the Guerra
rabba the Emory emus
one of the rappers he was in lives in uh
Europe so he said the following I'll say
in Yiddish and I'll say it in English
if I can
he said
sorry to get the Rebellion is
now I have to spit out all my teeth in
English it means
God gives pain but suffering depends on
the person
so it's very profound statement between
distinguishing between pain and
suffering
so
suffering is determined by how we relate
to the pain
now he didn't mean to blame the victim
of course
but he's just making a very important
distinction
between now I don't I don't know what I
would tell someone like you is really
really been through
been through a lot let's say someone has
a tinnitus right ringing in the ears you
ever hear that disorder so it's very
clear
that the more the person is is fighting
with it and paying attention to it and
wishing it wasn't there the worse it is
right so how he's relating to will
determine that person's quality of life
and one more thing and then we'll move
on they actually did a study of people
after surgery medical issues I think
that I remember it was a knee surgery or
hip surgery and they rated their their
quality of life one group
scored very differently than the other
group
and one group was the mindset was I
can't believe that Alexis hurts how do
we get rid of this pain I can't believe
it I would be doing this and this and
this if I didn't have this
those people were not doing well then
you had the other group
whose mindset was
oh my gosh this hurts like heck this
must be what a knee surgery feels like
oh my gosh okay
that's what new surgery is
what would I like to do today
now of course it's easier said than done
but I'm just trying to illustrate
how how attitude and outcomes medically
were proven we're shown to be different
so
um I I wish I could help you more you
know in this uh in this in this format
but
but it's all about embracing the uh that
that part of life that we have no
control over so I do wish you the best
beautiful beautiful really really nice
okay next Live question you're on okay
Amazon Dove here
um just very I guess maybe basic
question for those of me trying to
struggling to figure it out exactly
where is the line when it's kosher I
guess kosher anxiety healthier samayam
um and when do we say no this is
something that needs some sort of
therapy treatment does help us whether
it's for ourselves or people we know
I want to couple that with another
question if that's okay
go ahead okay so let's put that question
together with a Daven a very long answer
because I need to make sure I have
kavana by the first brother told me once
that if I overdo it
I I once that that I overdo it but it
isn't something that the must I'm not
I'm not if I don't put on the first
brother would you call this OCD
okay so uh I was waiting for this
question it took a lot longer than I
expected uh I think someone actually
typed in on the chat uh OC could cover
up uh
bronchiter from OCD and maybe so
how do you know was that the question
uh it goes like this
uh let's say uh there's two ways to look
at it as an outsider
so we would ask
okay is this is approving the person the
way this Hashem or not
okay actually I had this conversation
with her matisseur Solomon
I should should be well and
um this is uh this is one of the things
we came out with
is it enhancing you everybody just
remember detracting number two is that
thing about what we read from the sniper
that's a general
in theory but I was asking the the kid
this buffer or whoever
are you responding to doubts
or are you trying to have Cabana
um do you feel like you're forced to do
what you're doing
meaning if a person is draining
themselves
to do something
they could be going towards something
but they could also be running away from
something
so there you want to find out what
they're doing you know are they running
away or they this is something that they
want
when we're talking about OCD
we use the word
egodistanic meaning they don't want it
it just
it's not me meaning uh uh let's say a
person is getting thoughts of hurting
people like aggressive OCD or right
it's ego this tonic they feel it feels
that it's not they feel like it's not
them
then there are thoughts that are ego
syntonic it feels like yeah this is me
so
so the second question was do you feel
like you're forced meaning I'd rather
not be doing this but I'm doing it
and sometimes I'll ask the question
are you thinking about Hashem and this
is going on
now believe it or not sometimes before
the question is even out of my mouth
the person says no
they're they're being Ovid the word the
words or being Avid uh perfectionism not
Hashem
so
um
do I what was the question do I have
does it do I have OCD I just want to die
Domino longstrom and x-ray
well
it's a little tricky depending on the
age because it's a fair because
developmentally
a teenager will do something very very
intensely
and then
integrate it in a more normal way you
know if you go into any Yeshiva you see
ninth 10th graders they're
chuckling up a storm you know and is not
necessarily
pathological
so uh you you would uh is the person in
distress
like is is uh does it bothering them you
know sometimes if they see a kid
happening and he has this pained look on
his face
if you're ready it might be worthwhile
going over and it's saying hey you look
like you're pretty uncomfortable
you know what's going on
and let's say he says like Usher said
well I have to have cavana
so when you hear the words have to
yeah for me it's a red flag
because
the person might be this All or Nothing
type of thinker that it's if it's not
perfect it's not worth anything and then
you might be dealing with uh
perfectionism which is a characteristic
of OCD it's not OCD it's um it could
either be a part of OCD or part of
perfectionism in a in a different
context which I don't know if you want
to get into now so uh I have a lot more
I want to cover
go for it
before that I wanted to stop but you
could be thinking about Hashem
but he might have an image that Hashem
is dearth and waiting so that's perfect
or he's scared of Hashem right and
Hashem is scary and all of those ways of
thinking that Hashem is not happy with
what I'm doing so he's thinking about
Hashem right right so
so there
you know you see people are asking these
questions there's no way to find out
unless you have a conversation with the
person can't tell from the outside
that kid you know believe this is true
one of my clients went around Columbia
robinovich
who again is this noted to straw a very
holy person
and he said to him
why does everyone think that Hashem is
sitting behind the machine gun waiting
to shoot you down
very graphic
so this kid may have the wrong idea
about Hashem just may need a little
tweaking in his ashkapha uh
or
if you talk to them more
there are certain people who feel
obligation in a very oppressive way
like when he that's why I reacted to the
word have to
some people experience have to's as 500
pounds of pressure
uh so that might that would be a problem
uh because uh you know
there's no way you're going to do
everything perfectly so then you would
sort of get the does this happen in
other places what's the scope of the
problem you know do you have it other
places
and if it is you're right it could be
thinking about Hashem
but um it would be a different animal
then you know it wouldn't be OCD
people very often the person is I say I
mean yeah the person very often I shame
is they're so focused on getting it
right
that the relational piece of the midst
or that they're doing is completely lost
so and that's about anything's possible
go
okay let's go I'm alive and I'm going to
cover all the other questions
okay you're on but you have three more
left okay sorry you have all night
tonight right don't stress what's
confirming me we start when we started
it was past my bedtime so we're good the
the co-sponsor of let's get reals by the
clay Soul who didn't send in a gamatria
oh my gosh he's laughing okay so it's
perfect we'll go straight to the second
okay Live question you're on
Hi how are you thanks for taking my call
Great platform really enjoy it I have a
15 year old son who has definitely has
OCD Tendencies and anxiety what happens
when the compulsions that he does are
things that are actually considered
healthy in our world for example
um he's a very big mosque and he's a
very big learner not to uh not not to an
unhealthy level and we would like to
take a trip to RIT Israel for my son a
different son's Bar Mitzvah in March and
because of his anxiety
of of leaving his comfort zone and not
wanting to fly necessarily not wanting
to go out of his comfort zone he'll use
the excuse to ask like well I can't
leave you I can't miss Yeshiva or
um you know other times where he's there
are certain things he's supposed to do
he uses
you know right he he uses the Yeshiva
you know the learning as his crutch but
we we don't want to you know we don't
want to make him feel bad about the
learning because he is a big mosman and
he is a good learner and he's not doing
anything obsessive so how do you balance
like helping him get exposed to other
things but not putting down things that
are actually important so this is a this
is a TR not tricky but in this case
you can call them out on his anxiety
without putting down the learning
because he's not learning compulsively
he's just you know he's just doesn't
want to own up to the fact that he's
nervous about whatever it is that your
family wants to do
so uh you know I I think you could do it
without uh knocking the Yeshiva system
you know uh is it about Yeshiva or is
about
or about being afraid of flying but if
he says I don't if he really means that
it's Bittle tell you where it's a go
then you're talking about somebody who
um either has perfectionistic or anxious
attitude towards the learning
so uh I don't know if that would be
called a compulsion it's not in that in
that case it's just uh he's hiding
behind it
right I feel like he he uses he he uses
his anxiety he uses his learning and his
piety
um which is great to cover up a lot of
anxiety
and help him avoid things I see but the
but the piety and the and the learning
is not the Cure it's just
a way to hide from it
is that is that what you're saying oh
yeah so well he's good he is pious and
learn it also at the same time
yes sir I'm sure I'm sure
I'm sure he is so
have do you ever use the word anxiety
with him
yes and we do what you mentioned about
calling them out we do call him out
um
he doesn't you know he doesn't like it
but you see that he's uncomfortable when
we say it so you see there's definitely
element of anxiety but he'll still try
to convince us it has nothing to do with
his anxiety has to do with the fact that
it's Bittle Torah and he can't miss his
rebbe sheer and he's gonna you know it's
it's gonna affect his learning but my
husband and I both believe from no you
know raising this child from the
beginning and he's been anxious and OCD
that a lot of it is like you know well
well first of all we can't weaponize
anxiety and um you know call people
anxious
I would I would just go with it
what does Israeli have to say you know
just really you're so tired let's see
what their Rabbi has to say the one
who's Mr Torah you know I would I would
just cause Bluff
yeah we've done that no and what has
happened we said that to him and he said
yeah I know my rubby's gonna tell me to
go
all right here we go so and then oh then
that's such an opportunity
what might be happening here if you're
ready would tell you to go and you don't
want to go stroke your beard
okay and say hmm
I wonder what it is I don't you know or
your husband right I mean you have her
he's handing it to you right well hmm
what you know
another thing if either you or your
husband have anxiety it would be a great
time to uh
tell them
you know Mommy or tati or whatever
you know we struggle with this too so
that that is a very powerful uh
parenting
tool and it's also a good thing to do
I'm sure let's go take a little turn
over here
now that his return is 11 o'clock we go
with different angles over here
hey Matt it might sound crazy but my
spouse loses it when I chew gum I mean
loses it out of proportion first is that
something that you deal with and second
isn't it the way to heal this problem
through exposure so shouldn't I be doing
it and to help her and exposure and help
her get better by cases of gum
yeah so uh we have a rule that uh
whoever that asking the question
I hate to disappoint you
but you can't you come on purpose I mean
you could but you're gonna be sleeping
on the couch
that the rules we don't do exposures
against the person's will but to take
the question a little more seriously
you're talking about misophonia which is
a
very very strong reaction to mouth
sounds chewing burping uh Gump gum
snapping slurping sometimes heavy
breathing
there is no really good treatment
protocol I was just talking to some
colleagues about it
for misophonia what they're doing now is
there's a guy Ezra Cohen who's uh I
think he's uh
he's uh setting up shop in Lakewood I
think it's c-o-w-a-n
who definitely does a lot of this work I
haven't
and what they do is a combination of
exposures
according to the patient's guidance you
know what they could tolerate but
there's also a cognitive piece because
people
to suffer from it
it's they feel like someone is doing it
on purpose it's like a it's personal
so there's a cognitive distortion there
with misophonia that they feel like
they're being attacked
so uh they they do the cognitive piece
to straighten that out
if possible and then they try uh not
exposures but
they have the person practice
mindfulness skills and mindfulness
basically is
the ability to be in the presence of
some kind of stimulus without having to
react
it could be a sound it could be a smell
it could be a temperature it could be
some kind of discomfort it could be an
internal feeling an emotion the basic
idea is cultivating the ability to be in
the presence of something which is
unpleasant without necessarily having to
react
that would be the treatment do you use
mindfulness and meditation for OCD and
anxiety
oh
so we do we do it for the discomfort
part of it that's one time we do it
there's also something called Act
acceptance and commitment therapy which
a big piece of it is mindfulness
and it's about this thing about getting
used to the discomfort and then doing
something that you want something that
has value to you commitment right commit
to your values
um
then
um but
but during the exposure what I do is I
do Erp straight exposure exposure
exposure
and then if let's say the person is 85
to 90 better
so sometimes I don't want them always
doing
exposures I'll have them just let the
thoughts be there and not react to them
so I'll do it at the end of treatment or
sometimes during the treatment if they
have a hard time with the discomfort
that the treatment entails
okay here's another interesting question
that came in my husband likes all things
super straight
for example on pesoff needs the tape on
the cabinets to be perfectly lined up
is this classic case of OCD or for
another example is the the tassels on
the carpets need to be all lined up
straight
what would you call this
I would call this my father no I'm just
kidding uh he's probably listening
um
right so let's but let's just look at it
the same way
what is the person afraid might happen
if they're not straight
that so let's say the answer is
something bad might happen probably not
the case
um it makes me uncomfortable
so
um
does it so it does it interfere with the
person's social academic activation
functioning the answer is yes because
marriage is social functioning
right
so it's very hard when the spouse asks
the question
you understand I'm spoiled people walk
into my office and like they're the ones
who are the patient you know I don't
have a the spouse coming in and
complaining
um
so sometimes people are visually it
could be a sensory issue and something
this sense is
um
visual right so I can be sensory hearing
I give a sensory tactile right the kids
who don't like the tags and the clothing
and so on
but it could also be visual so
um he could be really thrown off by
things that are so
uh depends how severe it is how much is
affecting your relationship and once
again
a person can if they're interested
train themselves to be used to that
discomfort
you know I I can't force the guy to but
you know
um
there is one thing there is one form of
OCD that is called symmetry
that things have to be symmetrical
um so I don't know exactly because I
don't have so many of those cases to be
ocp whatever it's called
yes so let's either could be the
person's afraid something's going to
happen which would be OCD
or it could be sensory I just don't like
the way it looks
ocpd is obsessive compulsive personality
disorder where
it's
OCD is anxiety driven
and ocpd is Rule driven
so it's more about perfectionism doing
things the right way
not letting other people do things so
they're not going to do it the right way
and
um you're saying basically everybody in
Europe
very frugal they don't spend money
except in emergencies
um so
that's more uh perfectionistic those
people
there are different
[Music]
um
see if I have it here yeah
they actually have it right here there's
actually two types
of ocpd
there's the anxious type which you're
describing and then there's the Hostile
dominant type which they drive everyone
crazy and they can actually be a little
bit abusive to others because they have
to do it that way because it's the right
way and it could be that they're right
but still everyone having to toe the
line is uh they really uh they they
really um are abusive anyway so it could
be either one of those things could be
ocpd but that would be you would see
that it's a it's a trait meaning any
personality disorder it's a trait it's
part of their personality rather than
something bothering them from the
outside
pardon if you're afraid is the treatment
of Freedom it's also exposure
um
the treatment is
it depends how severe the case is but
let's see someone is perfectionistic we
can
uh have them be imperfect like somebody
who says the sub the lunches must be
ready the night before school you can do
it in the morning even though you wake
up early because it must be done at
night correct is that ocpd is that it
well it depends if it's rigidity rule
it's been being sticking to the rule so
I don't know if that's ocpd but if it's
interfering with the person's life you
can I had once a client who was an
engineer
and they're all like that so uh this guy
was from Finland
not Jewish I didn't come from Finland to
see me but he was from Finland
and everything was perfect literally
with the tassels and the cleaning
everything and always on time to work he
drove the same route to work he drove
the same brand of a car every single
time it was amazing
one time
he did it himself I mean wait this is
what yeah I'm going to tell you so
what's good about him is he followed the
rules of treatment very well also
we so we use it to our advantage he
mummish turns his life upside down
we did we did he did everything
illogically he came a different time to
work every day he drove a different
route to work every day he bought a
different brand car
he didn't dust this house until he could
write his name on the dining room table
it didn't fold his laundry and when he
went through a movie he came 15 minutes
late so he didn't know what was going on
of mine
his whole life changed now I give him a
ton of credit he was able to do it but
everything he had friends he became the
flexibility that he that he was able to
learn
really opens his life up now not every
case everyone has is so amenable to
treatment this is probably more unusual
than usual but he was a real engineer
there's a right way to do it and the
wrong way he had to
uh the manufacturer things to tolerances
of like thousandths of an inch
and that's that's what it that's what it
uh that's what his job required that's
what his personality was like
so
sometimes it's exposure
um
sometimes there's a there's a TR there's
a a profound lack of insight
which is uh common among a lot of
personality disorders
and if that's the case you have to think
it's been root this is already clinical
clinical material where you just talk to
the person about okay what will make
your life work better forget about when
these first people come into my office
the first thing we settle on is I say
you're going to be right every single
time
okay so we're not arguing about right
you're always right now
it's good you should all use it it's
very good at uh
you know takes a lot of fun people are
fighting and so you might see your right
you could be right no not to be
manipulative
you did you know we're not going to get
into it about whether you're right or
wrong so let's just assume you're right
and let's get down to businesses to make
your life better you know and they are
right A lot of the time unfortunately
they're like wives
let's go next Live question you're on
hi
um okay so my husband suffers from
extreme debilitating
um anxiety depression and OCD
um he's been
through medications and stuff like that
for some reason medications have a very
hard time they haven't been working even
though he's tried a lot of different
things but
um specifically he's dealing with OCD
around his eyesight
um he's hyper focused on his vision he
sees gliers he
um strong colors he went through a a
period where he was seeing black and
white
um to the point where it's very hard for
him to be awake because he's it's so
debilitating
um he he feels like he is the only
person in the world with such an OCD
um and he actually asked me to ask the
question he was curious if you've heard
of it and also what the treatment
protocol would be for it I have a client
right now with it
not kidding around I it's not 100 true
because he's 99 better
but uh like the floaters and the
flashers and the and the retina stuff
is that what we're talking about like
something wrong with his eye
so there's nothing actually wrong with
his eye yeah you and I know yeah right
yeah sure he knows that also
yeah of course he does is most people
have such good Insight you know
so so the the knowing that nothing's
wrong like we said before
has nothing to do with the disorder it
can no and no one know and you'll still
be nervous so I don't know if you're
here since the beginning of the show
but the
uncertainty is medicine
reassurance is poison now I don't want
to interfere with your relationship
but
the only way out of this and I don't
know if he's what kind of treatment he's
had or the right treatment or some
people need inpatient treatment
you know but
until he accepts
that he could go blind
in five minutes from now he's not going
to get better now I say these things all
day so I'm used to it it's brutal you
know
but uh but like I said in the beginning
of the show everything is going to fit
into this model
of
intolerance of uncertainty versus
acceptance of uncertainty so I don't
care what it is whether it's a guy going
blind
or it's
I don't know I mean I I I had a client
who thought that he was his brother's
father by accident
I don't know we gotta accept the
possibility that your brothers and moms
are you know or
uh the the human mind is capable of uh
has a tremendous uh
capacity you know John Grayson once said
that people with OCD
have a great what does he say great
imagination for uh looking out for
danger
so they can uh they can
create scenarios that are very very
creative
um but here's a good example also where
most cases are about something that's
real that means
uh Renton detachments are real floaters
are real Buster McCollum is a real rule
right
so they're I don't know if from what I
understand from him I don't know if it's
the fear like let's say that he'll go
blind I think it's actually the
distraction of
okay so this is called a neutral
obsession
and they are sometimes the worst so
blinking breathing
don't like that
um a neutral Obsession could be
a song
in the head disease it could be a
billboard that you don't want it in your
head
so so you just the same thing
if you accept that that thing is going
to distract me for the rest of my life
life will be easier
same thing with the guy with the
blinking uh but I'm not going to be able
to learn I'm going to this I'm going to
that okay that's possible
but if you fight it the more you fight
something the more it's in your
consciousness
and that's just again this is a much
more mindfulness when someone has a
neutral Obsession I actually a lot of
this mindfulness stuff where you allow
uh you allow that thing to be there
uh so that would be a neutral Obsession
if there's no feared consequence except
they're the fact that it's there
it is a
neutral Obsession and uh there's a
section on it in John Grayson's book
Freedom from obsessive compulsive
disorder
I don't have to go but I have to excuse
myself for a second I'll be right back
okay it's all on you now beautiful take
over yeah
yeah I think very important
a spouse or anybody instead of saying
don't worry you're fine
you say yeah it could be
that's the way I understand it's just
basic
um
um the way how you react
somebody says I'm not sure if I'm
feeling well something is wrong I don't
know I'm not sure I don't know instead
of saying
you're fine don't worry you're fine so
you're you know
you say instead of saying you're fine
don't worry you say
Maybe
could be
and uh it's very uncomfortable to be
there
and I do talk a lot about this
uncomfortability
takes us back to what I talk about a lot
is running
we discussed it many times
and this goes to everybody not only OCD
and anxiety
because we're always busy
and doing stuff always busy on our phone
and if you want this if you want to see
how it feels try not to do what you want
to do and sit there and don't do it
don't pick up your phone
don't do the next thing and see how you
feel
okay see how long how long did you sit
without a phone uh you're talking crazy
enough enough let's talk reality now now
I'm taking it personal
let's go to the next Live question that
will repeat it to Michelle when you're
on
hi hello hi
um I would love to know
um about if this form of OCD correlation
of OCD
I know it's on the DSM but I'm wondering
if it's a real kind of OCD and how do
you differentiate between real
relationship issues
and relationship OCD and how do you heal
from it
I mean could you specify what
relationship OCD is I'm not familiar
so what I know about it is that you're
obsessing just like you obsessed about
let's say you obsess about by your hands
being dirty
so you're obsessed about your
relationship and your compulsions would
be like will be like reassurance getting
reassurance among the people that your
relationship is fine
or checking on your relationship
um
I just I feel like I've bumped into
therapists that didn't know
anything about and I know it's not in
the DSM but I'm wondering if it's if
it's a real thing if you see clients
with it
and how do you differentiate between a
real relationship like how do you
realize if it's a relationship issue
or if it's a OCD type that's fair that's
right so
I don't like the fact that they made
this thing called relation rocd
relationship OCD yes it's a thing but as
far as I'm concerned
it's the same thing as every other OCD I
have a I have an intrusive thought
it can go a few ways I don't love do I
love my spouse or it can go doesn't my
spouse love me
and then the compulsions uh I don't know
personal check do I love her
I would you know um I'm serious by the
way uh you know I don't know what it's
supposed to feel like really I love her
or or if the person gets annoyed by
their spouse they get freaked out
because it means I don't love her oh my
gosh is
so so yes the answer to the first
question is it sure is a thing I don't
know about the DSM I think it's just
part of OCD but
um how do you know
last thing goes to everything else are
you having intrusive thoughts that don't
make any sense to you
and are you doing
um compulsive behaviors to reduce your
anxiety or gain certainty and those
things are interfering
so
um usually you're able to tell I mean
there's a there's a there's because a
person is so anxious if you're talking
about yourself
are you talking about yourself yeah like
I I like I had these types of thoughts
for like a year and like Obsession about
it and then I
I ran into on Google which I'm saying
Google's not the best place but like
once I saw it I'm like everything makes
a lot of sense sure and
um
yeah you like obsessed about every uh
like different parts relationships you
could switch from one Obsession to the
next
and I think
it makes it I mean I guess like every
kind of OCD it feels very real like
I didn't mention this yet to the
sufferer
if they could look at their clean hand
and it feels dirty it feels so real
but
the way it works is whenever whatever
we're concerned about we are uh hyper
Vigilant about it and then so what we're
doing is we're seeking evidence
to answer our question so now we notice
everything
oh she didn't turn the way
maybe she's not interested or I you know
I don't know if it was a you or her but
so you start noticing and Gathering
evidence and we have an intentional bias
the research says an intentional bias to
the things that reinforce the fear by
the way
so we're only seeing those things
so between that and it feeling so real
so uh
it's hard but once you if you came to
the point where you you think that you
have that kind of uh OCD then you're
ready you're ready you're ready for
treatment
one of my first clients was a lady
who
would it I think uh she
actually uh thought her husband was uh
not faithful
now
very from lady
from husband
the thoughts were ego dystonic meaning
why am I having these crazy thoughts
he's so not the guy to do something
right
so I still remember her she was in our
ninth month crying on my couch
anyway this lady today
goes to support OCD support groups and
he yells at people you gotta do
exposures you got to do exposures she's
like uh a real cheerleader but it was
excruciating
like we did we exposure means you do
something to bring up
the worst the possibility so
I'm embarrassed kind of embarrassed to
say what we did to her you know we had
him
go to Atlantic City
he didn't really go to Atlantic City he
just went to you know on Route 70 and
stayed in the hotel there about
we made him reservations for all kinds
of stuff in Atlantic City which she did
we she did it
and he
and I just wanted to block the bar yeah
yeah you didn't mind so much
so but she's driving him crazy who's out
of here in the background where are you
where are you you know that guy you're
driving him crazy he's a good guy
patient guy
so the
therapy is frequent and prolonged
exposure to what you're afraid of so we
designed all these exercises that would
bring up the possibility that he is
misbehaving
no compulsions no checking no nothing
is better
it's BR it's hard work but it works like
crazy
like crazy it's a
I don't know it's like magic it's a
little
foreign
it's amazing how it works if you if you
if you make sure that you have no no
safety behaviors happening
and the person is sticking with it and
they stick with the discomfort
what they find out is that the song goes
up up and they go down like that
it's just Behavioral Science if you want
me to explain it I could explain it but
this is not a a clinical training
whatever you want
so uh if they can stick with it
is incredible I mean remember you just
got to find someone who knows what
they're doing so rocd yes
get it treated have a good life
okay next Live question you're on uh
thank you my question is is it
um is there any correlation between
um anxiety and emotion suppression uh
and as a side question is there a
possibility of getting rid of anxiety as
a whole
so the first question is I I don't think
I can answer I don't know uh it's more
of a um
we're uh I'm not I'm not familiar with
the research on that so
I could look into it I don't know you
know uh emotion suppression I'm not sure
I don't know but uh the second question
was can you get rid of it yeah fully at
least
well life has anxiety I don't know if
you noticed
do you have children yeah I I don't
anxiety attacks I guess is more what I'm
okay yeah right so yes
person can
have a lot less anxiety in their life if
that's your question a lot less to the
point where you would be satisfied with
the amount of anxiety you have in your
life well you most probably between
medication and and and and therapy
I'm a pathological Optimist but I also
think it's true
yeah I would definitely say yes all
right thank you very much sure
okay remember so let's get to this
question I think it's an important
question I know it's late but I want to
cover just at least the important things
that I feel that we need to cover I was
told that treatment of OCD is exposure
does that mean if a person needs to
break in order to heal is there such a
concept of like breaking Allah for
exposure therapy oh that's an amazing
question explain the question because I
I mean myself I did understand it so so
the therapy is you do these Behavior
examples Give an example
I will you bring up the the fear so
let's say the person's fear is
uh the fear is uh mixing meat and milk
so we have to bring up the possibility
that of Buster the call of mixing so a
lot of people are very nervous about
this therapy because oh my gosh I mean
in order to get better he has to he make
possible Olive
because that's an exposure
I have not only have I never had to do
that which I could have every Heather in
the book if I needed to
I never even had to get a a header to do
any exposure ever
and I'll tell you why
it's a very common misconception A B A
lot of people who don't have the Tor
background are nervous to do therapy or
Sometimes women are afraid to specialize
in
because I have to know
Allah no
I worked do I I don't know I don't know
I don't speak or anything
so
um it goes like this it's a very so I
want to clarify you don't and oh here's
one more very important point
there are rapunin who have written
shubas about
treating OCD
um
uh I don't know if I should say names
there's a beautifully written tuba about
somebody who was uh
foreign
I mean even though it's it's great to
learn Torah it's completely unnecessary
because if that person let's take a case
of basketball college
and if he's worried about
uh making tray for reading traits
the goal of treatment is that he should
live with the possibility of eating tray
for making trade to the extent that
everyone else lives with that
possibility we spoke about that there's
an acceptable level of risk in every
area of life and in yiddishkai so the
example would be
I would have that person do something
that would happen in the course of
anyone else's life in their
kitchen that for them would trigger
their anxiety about maybe possible
olives happening but it's a completely
everyday Garden variety
uh event I'll tell you just happened now
somebody
um
they're afraid
this is on the books so this is a great
example
uh that if there's meat between your
teeth after eating meat
so
they talk about whether that meat will
make you lasiks or not
if you find it
get out you swallow it if you don't
so this person was
um compulsively flossing his teeth
to make sure there's nothing in there
so let's let's set it up
the fear is maybe there's
meat there
meaning you
maybe there's meat there so that's one
maybe
um maybe it will
um render me Flay shakes
later on at some time
and uh and eventually The Next Bite Mill
clicks within whatever six hours I'll be
eating you know be over uh so
do does a person have to go that far
to
to make sure that they that they don't
have meat between their teeth and the
answer is no
how do I know not because I'm a basic
because I can look around and I know
that the whole world is not flossing
your teeth
for an hour after they they have lasiks
if they feel something to eat they've
lost their teeth if they don't they
don't
now
you see so I don't it's not you don't
need to you just look around as a matter
of fact
there's you xiaomi that says
that
is
basically what it means is if you're not
sure what to do
look around see what everyone else does
that that is what the Gomorrah says
because not everyone
knows
not everyone has a rabbi following them
around they can ask them all their
questions they're paying him for the
money they say by switching to Geico
so we we're all in the same boat
that we there's there's a certain
tolerance that we there's a certain line
that we go to to avoid being either in
Avera
where is that line
well somewhere in here if you're more
conscientious here if you're more
relaxed it's here
now in that particular case since I knew
the guy wouldn't do the therapy unless I
spoke to a rough
spoke to my favorite Robin and like what
uh
he he almost doesn't let me finish the
questions uh is uh uh I said well this
guy's you know um
flossing his teeth can I tell him not
that yes he should never floss his teeth
like that now I didn't need to call the
rub but I needed it to get the guy to do
the therapy
you follow so there's you can always
find something that is within the the
realm of normative Allah practice that
will trigger the person's uncertainty
and anxiety it will go up and go down
and you have great exposures they don't
have to do anything wrong I will not
tell them they're not doing anything
wrong I'll just say they're accepting
risk
I never I mean I'm I'm such a action
they will never get a word of
reassurance out of me because it's not
good for them I think I'm dying
what color flowers you want at the
funeral
like that
okay you just you have to be a certain
personality to do this but
if you understand what what you're
seeing
right you have to that's what that's
what the situation calls for it helps to
have a good sense of humor but
people are coming with fears like brain
tumors and this and that and the other
you have to yourself be okay with with
uncertainty because these are very
serious things so is everyone walking
around with the possibility that they
have a brain tumor yes
so are you
what's the difference between you and
them well you're thinking about it and
they're not that's all
maybe maybe it's true yes
any further questions your honor
I should go check it out Maybe
I should go check it out no
I don't say anything I just
uh here's what happens why haven't you
called the rubber why haven't you
checked it out I'm embarrassed I know I
right but
here's how it goes do you think someone
else
right now would go check it out
at this level of um symptomatology
okay
probably not
okay but you want but I want to I know
you want to because you're nervous
what would you rather go check it out or
get better from OCD
but you know I I can't force anyone to
do anything
but if it ain't this one it's gonna be
the next oh one second you're gonna go
for an MRI
is it possible that the second you step
out of the MRI you're gonna have a tumor
start growing
oh my gosh you might have to stay in the
MRI we'll bring you kosher food
don't worry about it
one second so if we get to that point of
trying to ensure that you don't have a
brain tumor
you'll be alive but you won't be living
what would you rather
so it's this kind of conversation where
okay because the ocd's main trick is to
try to get you to prove a negative
prove that something is not and we take
the bait
and then it's it never ends how do you
prove that something is not maybe it's
not now it'll be tomorrow
[Music]
so here's here's one question before we
wrap it up
my husband really struggles with anxiety
I have two questions
how do I keep myself from getting
annoyed and upset when these thoughts
panicking about something
and how do I help him get through it and
calm down
foreign
[Music]
let's see
my husband right right that's gonna be
the whole takeaway of the share by the
way yeah you're like well that's my
exactly
um uh well they haven't lost my license
yet let's see
so
again you see how it's the question is
from the spouse from the
it's so hard so
number one let's assume that they're
both know that he's anxious yeah
so that's okay fine so
being mad at someone for being anxious
I I can't blame the person being annoyed
I mean it is it's uh it's
it it affects your life in a very
dramatic fashion
so here's where
you you there's a relational piece and
then there's an anxiety piece
so
um the anxiety piece would be
feel so bad that you have anxiety
there's nothing really the spouse can do
except for
um
be with the person their anxiety
and I said that very carefully because
we we said to reassure the person is not
going to do anybody any good and she's
just going to feel depleted
from trying to keep him emotionally
afloat
so
this go this is a little bit of um
marital therapy in a in a certain sense
where
um one spouse there's something called
differentiation where I don't have to
take on the other person's emotions and
their problems it's a certain kind of
emotional independence from the other
person
uh that being said that's a whole Parsha
in and of itself but
the so the first thing is how do I not
be irritated
I don't know
you know Dr Torresdale used to say
if you have pity for someone you can't
be angry with them
uh but
the the person I said earlier in the
program person is not responsible for
having the problem but I my view is that
there should be responsible for doing
something about it
so the spouse to do everything in her
power
to be compassionate yet firm
that means it's it's hard very hard but
to cultivate some emotional independence
from the problem
because you don't need two people who
are sucked into this cycle of anxiety
one is enough and if the she doesn't get
sucked into it whoever asking then she's
better able to help him
I feel bad that you are anxious and you
see how that sentence goes I feel so bad
at you then the person saying that is
free a lot more free to do whatever it
need is done to get that person help
but it's that's where anxiety and
relationships
it takes a lot of finesse
um not to get sucked into that thing
and it sometimes feels like I said
before mean when you're not
telling Sue to the person's problem
you're not
[Music]
um
you're not
um connecting with the person over their
problem but ultimately is very good for
the relationship
so the other whoever the spouse is who
doesn't buy into the anxiety is in a
much better position to help their
spouse so
a big topic
okay we're gonna go to closing now a few
minutes to think of a good after two and
a half hours of talking need a good
submission put the whole thing in a nice
closing a different music for everybody
who's here tonight especially thank you
to show life Steve for coming on tonight
and giving tremendous physic it's a very
very I don't know so common but it's
everybody's familiar with this topic and
for the people that are dealing with it
obviously how important is to talk about
it try to get some guidance and try to
get some you know and some you know down
down to earth advice so again there's a
lot of questions we didn't get to I'm
sorry about that number one uh again
tonight 124 tonight shares
then there was over a thousand people at
later everybody wants to join our what's
up chats please WhatsApp me at
848-525-0066 and every Sunday I'll send
you the flyer for the share that week
and they're and they're gonna study the
replay and go also to manageable.com to
his website sign up for the weekly
emails with the speakers and well the
replays and anything that's going on in
The Coachman Community next week we're
going to have a very very powerful share
please join us with your moisture wrap
work from here Toms River New Jersey
he's a robot very large tequila he's
also the role of transfer Central Jersey
artsala and he's a very sought out
therapist as well so he's a Rob he's a
therapist he's the he's the package
so um it's a very interesting topic is
there a concept of too much therapy what
are the roles of robotum and therapists
and do they overlap so um should we
something very very special meaningful
to this join let people know about it
and join us next week everything is
recorded.com if there has any questions
please email Coachman gmail.com to hear
the share on the phone share number 124
or any of the other recorded serum we
have a phone number specifically for
Coach
848 777 gross option one and you just
put in the number of the shear or pound
is the most recent share you can hear
any share that we had
um if you want to give out any
information nobody wants to get a hold
of you you can give an email you can
give your phone number your address your
social security number all your
information or we could just send it to
coach whatever you feel comfortable so
people are asking for your emails I
don't know what you want to do I see
um
I'll give my office number my my office
email and I will try to uh you know I'll
try to answer people so give that now
and then I'll just finish the closing
and then I'm not going to wrap up and
then you
so the office emails Michelle gmail.com
m-e-s-h-u-l-e-m Epstein
e-p-s-t-e-i-n gmail.com
my office number is 732-994-3959
one second
again I want to thank all the
advertising sponsors the liquid school
for promoting us Elena Sharon Ellen
Ariel from Five Town Central and special
thank you Kyla California from jcn for
always promoting us on all the digital
Jewish platforms we're gonna go to
closing we'll go first and then show me
a few minutes put all your feelings now
this is this is uh what's it called uh
Improv
this is improv put all your feelings and
leave it alone
I just want to say I personally wasn't
feeling so well tonight but I I feel
much more calmer right now so maybe it's
just your voice it's definitely working
but
um it's a very very it was a very very
popular it's one again it reiterated a
lot of people that text it and people
sending emails and I was not able to get
to them so they're showing me no
diamonds
that means you have to come back around
too
okay let's go wrap it up
beautiful
and Michelle and thank you so much and
um
it's it's good to hear that first of all
some clarity
understand what's going on for those who
haven't you know those are sitting at
home thinking they're the only one
and to see somebody that deals with it
and that somebody who believes that they
can heal
and there is there is um
they can get some healing and
they should get whatever they need them
it's Hashem I do want to mention
interesting about high functioning
high functioning anxiety
high functioning that means you know
even those P those people who they don't
qualify with anxiety and OCD but they
still have these um
anxiety like we mentioned very basic
just getting out of your comfort zone
it's very hard
and you're not going to go to a
therapist for anxiety in OCD because you
don't have your goods you're doing good
but at the end of the day There Are
Places areas in life that you don't want
to go to
and you don't realize because you might
be scared and like we heard tonight
being okay being comfortable with the
uncomfortability
just with that exposure and I think and
everybody can use it those who suffer
from most of the anxiety and even those
who don't
to try out new things to learn to grow
wherever you're going to do is always
going to be new
you're going to feel anxious it's going
to be stressful you'll be worried you're
not sure how it's going to work out and
you call Michelle and say Okay Okay now
what's gonna happen Okay
and you'll go and do it you know it
might not work the first time
try it out again and that's how we grow
in life and that's how we continue
and it's something that everybody can
use so thank you very much for being
with us tonight and the Mr sham all of
those
who needs the healing and the next step
in their life should be able to get it
wherever they need it and it's Hashem
thank you
Maxton greatest pleasure
um if you know I hope this is also
discussed for uh worship Lima too
all my clients who are suffering
um I actually
have a take a lot of their names
um
by the way mostly Robert is a rock star
so
everyone should tune in next week he's
great a good friend of mine
so
uh number one
OCD is not a mysterious monster
um
you see I hope that people see how
comfortable I am with it
I'm not afraid of it
it's not because I don't have it it's
because I I understand it by the way if
anyone's wondering did he have OCD
I didn't my wife wishes that anyway
different story but uh no I didn't
honestly
um but but you saw that I hope you it
came across that
I'm not it's not a thing to be afraid of
once you understand it it's a known
quantity this is not some vague uh you
know uh way out uh psychosis you know
it's extremely extremely understood
not only that it's quite simple the way
is as uh people understood in my hope
it's really just in his Elemental form
is uh about
embracing uncertainty
and
um and some people are are just a very
sensitive to uncertainty I just want to
coach monachum there there are people
speaking about being uncomfortable
there actually is a a research on people
an anxiety sensitivity that
that having anxiety some people
experience it
is more painful than some than other
people it's a so just like ever just
like um
just like the other sensory things that
some people feel it stronger than others
people also feel the anxiety stronger
than us very interesting because I was
noticing my clients like what are you
afraid of the thing happening
I'm more afraid of the anxiety than
actually the thing happening so anxiety
of the anxiety
yeah so I started looking into it and
this is what I found
that that people experienced uh the
anxiety even uh differently
and
um
this really is about life now when it
comes in the form of OCD it's very
circumscribed and about
a few specific things
but that's what attracted me to it it's
really
a world view
meaning it's not about do this and
you're cured
your world view that uncertainty exists
and there's a relationship that's not
the Cure but very helpful
because uncertainty is scary
but
uh but but just changing getting used to
that idea which to some of us is
uncomfortable
then then your life becomes much much
different and much Freer
and to your points
where we sometimes organize our lives
around being
not being uncomfortable
if we notice that
and we understand that
uncomfortable feelings are normal or a
normal part of life
Everything Changes because we don't
necessarily have to react to it
that's what this whole act thing is I
spoke about there's a great book called
the happiness trap about this thing was
interested
um so uh people should know that it's a
known quantity
there are so many
people that have it I go to this
conference every summer there's over 2
000 people there
a third are therapists
a third are people with OCD and a third
are their family members and just the
fact to watch these people with OCD
meeting each other
you can you can cry from it they're
sitting there in Utah and here and there
and they think that they're only they're
the only mashugana
1 in 40 people
is suffering with this
and
it it it's very depending on how it's
excruciating it's very hard it's mental
torment
so
um not making jokes about it or using it
as a tagline
rather this is a very identifiable
illness and the people who have it
they're they're your neighbors they're
your friends
they're they're P they're a very
successful professionals I mean
that I have had the pleasure the
exclusive working with is
is huge I mean one of them I said your
payment is that you have to be my
favorite
and I haven't seen her for years with
this person half hour of his time he
learns 24 7.
uh so we should know that there is it's
the I think it's the most
uh treatable psychological disorder
you need to go to someone who
knows how to treat it
but
it's really it's not it's not a monster
it really I've seen
you know I don't know what you know
coaching you could one you see people's
lives change in front of you
I'm no genius I'm not like this I just
know how the system works people do it
I look great
they do the work it's a great great deal
but the bottom line is like I said their
their lives go from black and white to
color
the everything opens up for you
so
fi if whoever if you're suffering or
your spouse is suffering
um
yeah if there there's so much out there
and there's something called before I go
the uh International obsessive convolves
Foundation
that's this uh organization that I'm a
member of they have a website iocdf.org
they have all kinds of resources there
they have a list of providers now I
think that list used to be more
exclusive
maybe there's more people on it now you
know uh I I I'm there but I'm in
Pennsylvania you know
uh but uh you can find somebody who went
through their course and how to treat
how to treat OCD and maybe
um we didn't get to the question next
time we could talk about if you can get
if a non-from therapist can treat from
OCD
you know if you have a blank slot you
know some Sunday night where I don't
feel like going to sleep you can do it
yeah
beautiful but everybody
um
you know I hope everybody uh learned
something understood a little more about
it
basic uh building blocks of it and um
know that there there's tremendous help
out there and pleasure I hope that some
people get helped look I told everybody
to text you if they want you to come
back so look at your text on the zoom
sometimes people texted you
oh really yeah let's ask
well listen I hope I hope everyone
enjoyed it uh now you know I just we're
here to I don't there's something up
with these two guys I don't know
I mean there's so many people you know I
get help and I hope people got
information and hope and understanding
and
um
and
compassion for the people who have it
they're sort of invisible
so let's let's understand okay I just I
I wanted to make advocate for these my
clients I'm not such a mushy guy
but
I have to advocate for you know these
people are just walking around you know
that I see every day they're part of my
life uh but they have they have you know
they have 30 40 friends and family
members and nobody knows you know so
Let's uh let's understand that 140
people has it okay I hope this was
helpful to all
to you all
my big fish games
to you and we'll see everybody much from
next week same time same place for much
drop work 9 30. have a good night
everybody thank you again
can I take care