0:00 / 0:00
Understanding How Torah Evolved Through the Generations
1,052 views
By Dismantling the Sanhedrin, the Sages Saved Judaism This class was presented on Monday Parshas Ki Sisa, 13 Adar I, 5779, February 18, 2019 at the Ohr Chaim Shul, Monsey, NY
Categories:
Torah
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
the yeshiva dotnet the sanhedrin
continued till almost the end of the
Gemara yes in Archie show and it's a
shawl and above all they said I didn't
want it to go low so so yeah yeah yeah
yeah
but by the time of review Daniel Mayer
there was a real functioning son had
room it was after the base-emitter
she wasn't even shall I am anymore
do you I said I hadn't when at the
gallows went from you shall I am Teavana
it went it see poorly went back to
Yvonne I went to a lot of places there's
a whole saga inertia Shana but there was
a son had ruined it was a Renison hadn't
continued for another few hundred years
but then it couldn't be sustained
anymore they have a son hadn't yet have
Smith Lee ish my parish from I should've
been oh yeah have told me them it was
just xavius the Jews were getting
scattered they couldn't do it anymore so
they were avital it yeah yeah yeah so
these debates I'm not stomach his debate
somewhere in a corner these were the
debates of the happiness and at night
they were members of the Sinatra
it's usually yet this was an argument of
Hoffman son Hunter I mean was it the
argument right before the vote was it an
argument previously but there was an
argument that and and they had to pass
can Liholiho
yeah we know of the names you had the
Nazi of the son had a burden of the son
hydrant yet 71 people who had to make
every major decision but there was a
decision about how Lhasa should we make
this guy's a toe should we make this
Sarah is this the pre shot and pain is
this not the shotgun Toyota should we
make this Takano Hanukkah candles we'd
like to know who the son of - I'm
reading the Megillah all these things do
what they were taught these were to
commerce that does enter with the word
do with the base don't eat chicken with
milk gravy I see Angela Lee the camera
hasn't fallen he held y'all ready it
should come with milky a chicken with
mom he said there's a ders a foolish
doesn't make sense there was a vote the
boy said Lily used to eat chicken with
milk
tomorrow's clearly a lot even Shipton
with multiple night Ida he felt that
there's no need to compare chicken to me
a common felt not chicken is by people
considered meat then of chicken if you
do chicken burgers chicken cheeseburgers
you can end up doing meat cheeseburgers
but this was a real mattress
same thing when do you stop eating
comets
yes same uh collectors have made of you
when when when the Easter of comets
begins
does this your comments begin yeah yeah
yeah they had to debate yeah yeah yeah
same reason the fish no then there's
later generations everything changed cuz
then its local stuff once the sanhedrin
was gone everything became localized
she'll have in this country you have
this in this country it's not there was
no any there was no sensual body through
Messiah of Claudius on they couldn't do
it anymore so kidney is in the Middle
Ages - Kinnison assert kidney is on pace
right like beans and rice legumes what's
called they asserted because their
fields they used to grow together with
wheat then they saw a lot of problems
despite the communities never asserted
so that's why they're not a problem with
rice if it would have been by the Sun
Hedren then it would be everybody
there's no mid sea as the Sun had
written said something because how much
is on the Ashkenazim listen to think
Nicholas comments is that miju why
because it comes from the Sun headland
comes from the tamale all the Tacomas
that come from then you'll have every
drew will be Makai of every Judah will
never be differences anything that
happened post that for example davon
Inge
you'll have gnosis fired no sir - que
nos because it doesn't come from then
there were no different than honey
they could be they could be different
men Hagen if the Sun Hedren didn't pass
again right well so she couldn't be no
you were sucking mom ray if you if you
went against he was uh Kaname well
didn't have a place in a law Bashar my
basil--oh argued once that looks like
missile you have to follow like be civil
yeah yeah son had yer
most of them went son hundred it depends
but most of them yeah in the 400s in the
5th century a by n rava yeah and by the
way kiddush a kurdish went who kiddush
asteroid this was the same thing there
was no calendar as long as it was a son
head and they had witnesses testify for
the new moon same thing they didn't use
calendars yeah once the Sanhedrin was
the was dissolved so key - ahoy - was
dissolved they couldn't do it anymore so
not they had a calendar that's what we
use today the Sanhedrin was dissolved
and the whole system changed since then
there was no Mitzvah that the rabbi
could make that's Makai of Claudius so
there's no such a thing anymore
there could be man hug him there could
be humorist Haqqanis even I've been a
garrison all this talk honest you know
about marriage and this it was my high
of his careless nor other killers fast
you derive is rabhasa this law you
follow the best in but there's no one
best in that's Makai of Claudius don't
know such a thing anymore they can't do
it you can't do it anymore because for
the Sun heading to function you have to
have that level of intensity and
cohesiveness and and unity that they
couldn't sustain anymore you know
talmidim who sit with years by the
rebels and they have Smith it was a
whole system that they couldn't do
anymore to keep the Sun headin alive
would have been a hormann because if it
would have been hijacked it's the end of
it the fact that they dissolved the Sun
hadn't really saved the Jewish people
just imagine in the 1800s right if there
was a Sanhedrin and say the reform
movement hijacked the Sun a dress what
would have been done what would have
been it would have been the end of her
locker they would have made a tack on an
exit who would have been the end because
there was no Sun Hedren
so other Yama's and nobody can hijack
Yiddish kind it's a was tremendous thing
because even if if country after country
falls to the reform yeah
if there's one shtetl is one shtetl with
a rough and talmidim ownership with
Herschel tomorrow if they're not
changing and that's what happened
Napoleon Napoleon forced to Jews to make
us unhappy but it was a fake thing I
mean they did it
the Karen IRA yeah he wanted it to be
Martin intermarriage and they had to do
they made us an hadrons to appease it
but it wasn't a real thing it was he
made us in Haran yell yeah intermarriage
should be motor Eric ceased role is not
part of the agenda Napoleon wants him to
change a lot of things and then he would
accept them and they had they're one of
the great early adorab dove with the the
Karen one of the boys camp he went and
he basically ran it as I he'd the play
that he played a game he played a game
he made a son hadn't but he knew it
wasn't real it was just that in the
early 1800s but the fact that there was
no son Hedren protected the integrity no
because if you haven't somehow see you
might have had some people but you
didn't you didn't because because there
was an immune system cause he who got
Smith at the beans and then you have to
get Smith from a previous generation and
those people had real tired Authority
whenever kid was giving you Smith her
yeah where it may is giving you Smith
sure these were people who got solution
from the previous ones all the way back
to much Moreno they didn't have
submitted to a torque they case make
sure the people who were going him an
ear Shania and so forth can there be
once in a while somebody was corrupt
yeah but the system was a very holistic
system the system worked at that young
Manette works even today you'll see it
works let's say there's a robbed of a
Orthodox show a real order shop and one
Shabbos he says today we're bringing in
the piano right and instead of filling
on Sunday were putting on tefillin on
Shabbos yeah he lives in America nobody
can do anything but what's gonna happen
nobody's gonna take him seriously
anymore as a thority of a locker because
it's a shelf America let's say even
cross mccollum 10,000 rabbi
go corrupt and they decide to change our
love it's not gonna affect you this kind
as long as as you have the books it
means this guy is not interested fine
let's say each slips with him a million
people that's what they reformed it they
shocked millions of people with them it
didn't affect it I mean it affected it
in reality of course for millions of
Jews but it didn't affect the purity and
the integrity of Allah huh
as long as you haven't we could trace
back every minute you go back to the
price can we go back to shorten our if
you go do the tour you go to there and
mom you go to there is showing him you
go to the Gemara you go to the Mishnah
you go to the so can you see it I can't
change it somebody who come tomorrow and
say there's no see of Nicolas comets
anymore now on the night of before pacer
we're changing the halacha
it's gonna be a joke I mean you could
say it but it's not it's not real the
immune system of our lhasa is one that
can't be broken by anybody because they
wrote everything down if they wouldn't
have written down nobody didn't only
write it down they showed exactly how it
developed exactly
they didn't just write down this is the
hollow Kiev Dubnyk as comments yeah the
Gemara pointed out why when who said we
why a Kangol why not a candle why by day
what you understand how they did it and
they we know the names we know who said
bit lelou said dick when how what
everything is with names so they you
can't you can't Forge it
you can't fortune a guy today can say
I'm being my vassal I walk it's not
gonna be taken seriously get there
before they do it but but there was no
argument to it the Reform said it's a
new age we want to be accepted yeah they
didn't have a real argument to it what
did they refute what did they refute
what they said well you got to be
mcconnell Shabbos Shabbos is Sunday what
they didn't you understand so even if
somebody wants to change how lawsuit
today it's not gonna have value because
the the system is so clear everything
has a source you can trace it back all
the way to the generations there's
nothing you can't play games with it
anything we do what we don't do we know
exactly when it started how it started
why it started by whom it started now
are you with that if you can argue with
that fine yeah there could be arguments
that the day they'll argue today about
kinwa what's the
that's a real argument are you allowed
to eat quinoa on Pesach okay those are
good arguments right
those are real arguments things that
come up today electricity questions IVF
these are new things but ah so bye they
had to dissolve the Sun headed by
dissolving the Sun Hedren and writing
everything down in detail everything is
secure now nobody can play games with it
what am I gonna do burn every Gomorrah
in the world burn every chosen artist in
the world it's just that that was the
power that's what they did the vision
was unbelievable how they did it because
it's secured it secured the Eternity
when you had a real Sun Hadron happening
you didn't need this because you had
live communities and it was fine it was
very good
now Buda I'm not see already saw the
beginning of the end so he wrote
everything down in Machias with why did
he mention all the McCoy Kherson because
he wanted everybody to understand this
is this that's that of hooli
your typhus very important this how it
worked that's why that's why the mastoid
Kison are so important people wonder you
learn all these much like us and like
what do you want to tell me what to do
no they don't tell you what to do if
they tell you what do I can also make a
book today and say what to do
thank you Varis - they don't do that
they never tell you what to do I'm gonna
tell you everything and you'll see what
happened you ran away see that it's MSO
wasn't stuff a Roth got upset today we
mean by the comments will be doesn't
work like that who are you who comes -
why did you say what was your source did
anybody argue with you and then you can
say there's a McCoy cause there's a
halakha that's why the system of Gemara
is so intricate that everything was
recorded
there's no loopholes there's no like
somebody you know creeped in and did his
own thing nobody made their own malapa
Malka here everything is documented
recorded yeah even if you do you say
then what's your that you really
hold like this you don't hold like this
everything is is always get judgment to
the deal because then you could trust it
such a thing you could trust you see
that nobody is manipulating the system
there's nobody who has a little money
who has a little cover that has some
buildings and he's manipulating it
there's no manipulation of what would he
admit what are you manipulating right
and you see it constantly but the Gemara
finished it went on to the next level
yeah they were showing him they did
exactly the same thing
they wrote everything the arguments and
the Nasher item and that's how they did
it it's it's it was a very very powerful
way of maintaining the MS of it and it's
it's indisputable you know you could say
I'm not interested in it that you could
say but if you're interested in the
truth this is the truth of how you did
should I develop it's not like there was
no it wasn't a half Cavell where
somebody sat down and decided we're
making new mitzvos today we're making
new our lockers today we're answering
this while sitting that it doesn't work
that way you don't ask their things or
who was venting what's gonna be century
stuff yes yeah they saw they saw it says
a Schlosser /mf a rotary circle Tara
show up it was not supposed to be
written down because they wanted the
living connection between Reber and Tom
made them it was very alive but he
realized if it's not gonna be written
down then ultimately you'll have
charlatans and con artists and it's done
your Yiddish guide is done I'm Yankel
smart guys gonna get up in his place
he's gonna make his addition he has my
Sawyer miss Sawyer the word mr. Woodman
Sawyer me the tsardom means I want to
see them as sorry you have to see the
Messiah if you could show it to me it's
Messiah sir doesn't mean I'm gonna bad
mood I'm in an angry mood I need to get
rid of my brother or get rid of somebody
else I have my own traditions doesn't
work that way then it becomes tyranny
becomes an exercise in power and people
don't trust it the reason people trusted
halacha
rub on him and buzzed in is because the
integrity there was a commitment to a
mess I'm not here to make my rules I'm
not trying to control my community try
to do the right thing this one associate
associate
that's why I'm very much been on source
as always I just feel it's it's it's
it's much more respectful when there's a
source for everything you could see yeah
oh yes and then yeah and then you could
say and this is an idea that I think
based on it fine but you know you know
what what's what's what says what
doesn't say what's quoted what's not
called what's your that they knew the
responsibility because they knew the
responsibility that's why they didn't
cut corners they didn't cut corners take
the system they could have written the
night before pay stuff you do but in his
combats and you use a candle no how do
you know a candle why by night why do
you have to check what Hiba call us to
check do bitl I mean all these things
believer holy there's nothing mom has
taken for granted even even this thing
oh we learned today
they sold flour in Eurasia Lion Ramaiya
said it was against the rules
no Buda says it was pro the rules even
that there was nothing they ignored
is it right to sell flour in your salon
or not rev mayor you said it's not a
good thing they don't have permission w
this says you're wrong it's your opinion
it's not true that her comin were very
very happy about it now remember they
can argue about this cuz they lived
after the base of McNish they lived
after they lived a hundred years after
the home base some weaknesses they
weren't there by the carbon diamond
right yuusha lion was already nobody was
near Schley many more people were there
but it wasn't that same thing so they
were arguing a hundred and fifty two
hundred years ago maybe others said it
was fine it may said it wasn't fun it
wasn't a gala la jolla MYSA for them but
even then they're arguing about seems
like an insignificant thing people are
selling flowers selling flower w that
says it's fine it mayor says no it's
officer
you see it's sister and everyone has a
reason for it I say this you say this
there's a reason not stung I decided
it's a good thing it's a bad thing I
don't like you so Mellie a flower
becomes also such a thing
there's no agendas that's another thing
how do you know there's no agendas
people have agendas
I don't like you you almost of the
groceries I make the the flower awesome
so it's a joke it's a joke don't do with
God's thumb so that's why it's very very
important that everything was documented
with a reason with a swatter how it
developed coolant you could trust it
tersh about Tyler it's something you can
trust because they it's all open
you don't believe it investigate those
nothing as I as I as I investigate
there's nothing in he descried not even
a min him a minute I'm not talk about my
Ferguson that people have should cast
Amish agasa
and even they sometimes have a mocker
maybe a little distorted but there's
nothing in you describe a diary moszer
three and a half thousand years later
that you can't document and trace back
to the exact date time place person
nothing much nothing much nothing even
the smallest things that seem
insignificant we think and if the tacit
can't be so then you know that it
doesn't there's no source for that and
people and it's important because people
don't know the difference of a very nice
but they're not born on a mimic a homra
I hate learn a mishegoss OCD obsessions
they don't know the difference yeah they
think if they don't do this it's already
like being makalah Shabbos and eating
pork and eating on Yom Kippur and and
intermarrying and converting to
Catholicism yeah there's a Mohammed is a
date I said there's another bond there's
a myth summative research room there's a
meaning there's at a corner there's a
home red is a Hindu there's a home birth
of one community wasn't a father
community okay it's a bazaar especially
when it comes to Pesach racially Pesach
is the the young turf of home recite
okay yeah so in Rob's best in Roth
Baskin this is how he did it this is how
his best and did it this is what the
people around him did yeah and Schmuel
Pasco knows and that he did but then
they had to take a vote
after the moment there was one business
no he didn't Shawna Shawna and he did it
and he did it
dr. faith I'm Gamliel and I be a shoe
had an argument when Yom Kippur is right
and they become real totally sure come
on him keep it with your money and you
stick and you're back and what did he do
he came on my jammy-jam lil vinushka
Elroy shine
he kissed him on his head and he called
him Robbie Vuitton me D you're my Talmud
cuz he did what I said but you're my
neighbor because you know more than me
oh yeah and it said to be sure was a
depressed mate sorry was very upset and
he met rabbi akiva over Cuba told them a
llamar - a machete crew ISIL Amaya de
Alta crew is a mullah attend a Tomasulo
show again at the Murphy limousine at
the McCallum Italian the same rabona
Shalom who made the moon said that Yom
Tov is based on Bezdek Gamliel is the
Sun Hedren if son Edmund says this is
Jim it's not um Kippur
it's not the tenth day of Tishri it's
irrelevant because the whole reason
you're doing Yom Kippur is cause
detector isn't listen the better I do
say best is making a mistake it's still
Yom Kippur as long as the mistake is
l'chaim shamayim in other words if it's
a mistake because they start not
interested then they're not better
they're a bunch of crooks you understand
but if it's a real best then they made a
mistake according to you they made a
mistake maybe you're right maybe you're
wrong it's irrelevant so that's exactly
a case there be assured disagreed and he
still followed him damn Leo because
actually rabwah hot boys if the if the
best day would have voted not like that
they wouldn't have been the cottage
designers and they wouldn't he wouldn't
have listened and if your kid is the one
who told the term without that there
would be no system the terrace is
actually a table hunters if you know if
you can't follow the majority of the Sun
head and then everything would be a
McCoy cos forever
laughs well after the Sun had room was
dissolved there was no more one big
vegetable but there was a Sun Hedren
they could convene and decide a bunch of
stuff but yeah when the Sun hadn't was
dissolved it went to different cities
yet like the Supreme Court Makai of the
whole country the whole nation yeah
the Rambam in his introduction to
Mishnah Toyota and Mathias has a whole
whole article is the history of mission
attained and safe rubbish nice
this class is brought to you by the
achieve Annette please help us continue
the classes make even a small
contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva
net / donate