Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
What Does Judaism say about Marijuana?
223 views
Let's consider a serious question: According to Jewish law - Is there a problem with recreational use of cannabis? The video raises questions about the private use of marijuana and the potential issues surrounding the use of pot, even in places where weed is legal. The discussion dives into Rabbi Moshe Feinstein's Zt"l famous ruling on the matter. #judaism #marijuana #canabis
Categories:Torah/Halacha
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Let's ask a serious question.
Is there a problem
with recreational
smoking marijuana?
A person goes inside his house, nobody
sees, nobody knows what he's doing. He's
under stress or he just enjoys it or he
wants to experience what everybody's
talking about in a place where it's
legal. I'm not talking when a place
where it's not legal. In the eyes of
Is there an issue with smoking
marijuana?
>> Why is it lethal?
>> Is it lethal?
>> It damages your health person's health.
>> Is it going to kill you?
>> Is it changing your
>> Is there a doctor here? I think there's
a doctor here. Is it lethal to have
marijuana? And cigarettes also is not
lethal but we we say not to smoke.
>> Cigarettes are lethal.
>> The cumulative effect.
>> I think it's more lethal than car
accidents and uh maybe other forms. It's
one of the highest rating. Uh what about
marijuana? Can it kill you?
>> Car accidents can cause car accidents.
>> It can cause car accidents. So we're
going to make sure this guy doesn't
drive.
>> Is it the cumulator effect?
We're going to have we're going to use
that.
>> Is it is it the cumulative effect or
just what?
>> I would like to know if there's any
issue.
>> There's an issue.
There's evidence cumulatively that
>> that it does what?
>> That it uh breaks down breaks down some
of your thinking, some of your ability,
some of your
>> So, you don't like it?
>> I I what I know now, I didn't know them.
>> I'm asking now. Would you instruct your
grandsons to have it? They're sitting in
yeshiva, a very stressful tis. They were
able to figure out, right? They go back
to the dorms. A little relaxation.
>> I'm I'm paying him not to smoke regular
cigarettes, but he's all vape. Vaping is
not
>> We're not in vaping. We're talking about
>> it's a drug. Marijuana.
>> It's definitely a drug.
>> I know it's a drug. Is the toy Does the
toy have a problem with you having drug
taking drugs? That's my question. Why
purpose? God, isn't it? It's not a
Jewish min. No Jewish.
>> And what if all Jewish people would
practice it? Maybe it is a Jewish mach.
>> I don't think it's considered a go. For
that reason alone, we're not going to
usher it.
>> What's that?
>> Enough Jews are doing it.
>> Enough Jews are doing it to form a
Jewish.
>> No, no, no.
>> What are you saying?
>> No, we al also have mind altering things
like uh drinking too much also can do
that can affect you. So it sounds like
there might be a hat there.
>> There's a hit. Shh. We have a hit.
>> You like it or no?
[Music]
>> Someone gets drunk.
The lamb says it's disgusting. Stay away
from this practice.
>> But that's about drinking.
The didn't discuss it. Taking drugs.
>> Not talking hard drugs. Talk your
marijuana.
You're okay with it cuz you're not
jumping at me and say
>> you're saying which I don't know which
one
is not lethal.
>> It's not lethal.
>> What's wrong with you supposed to do?
Watch yourselves. Don't do things which
are dangerous. This is not dangerous.
Don't under these drugs. They do all
sorts of horrible things.
>> No. No. I don't think marijuana. We're
talking about specifically about
marijuana. I don't think it's lethal.
Don't think it's dangerous. People don't
do crazy things. We'll make sure the guy
stays at home. In fact, he'll say, "You
know what? I'm going to use it. Take the
key so I won't be able to get out of the
house. Lock me up." How much
>> if if he planning on smoking tonight?
>> Why?
>> Mark the next morning. I think he's But
he's not.
>> He thinks he's ding, but he's not. It's
a good point.
>> If the drug if the drug is is helping
symptoms that he may have.
>> No, no. I'm not talking for medicinal
purposes. I'm talking about a guy who is
100% healthy, but he wants to experience
what everybody talks about. He wants to
feel
>> a little less stressed.
>> He has peer pressure. Is that what he
has stress
>> in the yeshiva?
So, he wants to release the stress.
>> The rabbi yelled at him today.
>> He didn't understand the for hours. He's
trying to break his head.
>> And that's going to help him understand
it.
>> He thinks it will. I don't know. Maybe
not understand. is going to help him
feel a little better today. Tomorrow
he's going to come back with vengeance.
>> And and when and and when someone else
when he smashes his car, his finger in
the door, he go smoke in place of
>> he wants to he wants to know if it's
okay or not. If the toilet allows it or
not
>> for those reasons, I would say no.
>> You would say no for a reason. Allah
reason.
>> The reason is if you're being pressured,
peer pressure, you don't you you have
your own standards. You have your
standards that you have uphold. You have
to understand
>> why do people go on vacation?
>> Because
>> release some tension. He's releasing
some tension staying home. Instead of
spending a lot of money and time, he
only goes for two 2 3 4 5 6 hours
staying at home.
>> That's why we have Shabas every week.
>> But this is a question for Monday.
>> He can't wait until Shabas.
>> Isn't that addictive? I mean, if it's
addictive, then
>> is it addictive?
>> The question is
>> I don't think it's addictive.
>> It's not.
>> No. We're talking about marijuana.
like
>> psychologically it's addictive because
you want to experience more of that
pleasure plane that you were on but
technically speaking the drug itself
doesn't cause something in your body
like nicotine which is really addictive
>> I think I think the Torah
>> am I correct
>> as reverse tolerance reverse tolerance
the more they use it the less they need
to
>> I think the Torah would not there's no
there's nothing with getting hah from
certain substances in the world but
Yeah, you you need just a certain, you
know, ask.
>> So, don't go crazy.
>> Yeah.
Before you said yes, now you're saying
you're modifying it. Yes, but don't go
crazy. Let's see what has to say about
smoking marijuana.
in your
he discusses just that I heard that some
people in the yeshiva are starting to
smoke marijuana. So he was asked what do
you think about this and he goes to town
on this listen what he does with this
first of all it's that it's
from some major principles in and they
are the first thing you're destroying
your body and even if you'll tell me
some people are strong and it doesn't
affect their body fine it's something
worse than affecting your body and that
is damaging your das because when you do
you can't learn on the highest level
that you were able to 5 minutes before
without the drug. What is life without
Torah? So this would only apply to men,
not to women because they're not
obligated to learn to. But then he
continues and says, and let's say
somehow it didn't, but it will change
the way you're dabbing. Exactly what you
said before. You think you're ding,
you're not ding. You're on autopilot
mode.
You're doing mitzvah as a robot doesn't
need robots to do his mitzvah. You can
stand and shake from here till tomorrow.
If you're doing it without kavana, it's
as if you didn't do anything. That's the
language. He says it's
as if you didn't fulfill the mitzvah.
Was human beings who understand what
they're doing, not the person who's
floating somewhere in the air. So, first
of all, he says because of this, this is
terrible. This is wrong. It's awesome.
Second of all, he says and this is the
and that's why I'm bringing it today in
this para
you're creating in yourself a great
desire
and this is goes under the umbrella of
what does do he goes after the desire of
eating so says eating is a very natural
desire we all do every few hours we eat
a little more that's very natural and
you need it to live The body breaks down
the food, shuttles the nutrients where
we need it to go. It's great. But he
takes that job and he's only eating
kosher and the toilet doesn't like it
because you're taking the natural desire
and you're doing something wrong with
it. How much more so he says when you're
taking something upon yourself which you
don't really need to survive. You don't
need those drugs. You're creating a new
desire in yourself for something you
don't need. It's worse than the ta of
Ben. So he says it's true that it's only
and therefore technically speaking we
can't give lashes because of
but you should know it's worse and a
person who does this definitely
transgress the negative command that the
discusses in our para
he brings says why does the doesn't like
this kid doing what he's doing because
what happens when there is no more meat
and wine in his father's house he's
going to on the corner street and starts
stealing and then he's going to kill. He
needs the money. He needs that meat when
you want something that again you don't
need. You're creating this desire to
have something and if you don't have it,
you're going to go just like the mur
steal from people and potentially kill
from people kill people in order to
obtain that which you want. Not because
it's addictive because you're creating a
desire for something you don't need.
It's not enough. So he says
and explains
sanctify yourself with what you are
permitted. In other words, do not become
a
don't become a villain with permission.
It's only kosher. I only I eat meat
three sometimes four sometimes five
times a day. Highest level kash kash 5
kilos every single time I eat. That's
but it's with permission.
The Torah wants you to sanctify yourself
even with those things permitted to you.
This is exactly the opposite. And
therefore he continues and he says,
"What about the parents of the guys who
are smoking? Are they happy about it?
They're so upset. You're transgressing."
So no matter where you look at it, he's
closing all the doors.
says
it is clear that this includes many
other severe ones. He doesn't tell us
what they are. He says but if you don't
like what I said it's not enough for
you. It causes many other
severe ones and you must try to remove
this impurity from cloud soil and
especially from the sitting in yeshiva
and learning.