Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Genesis: God told Adam to Enjoy ALL The Fruits of The World! But NOT this!
104 views
Quick Translations: Bereishis = Genesis Adam & Chava.= Adam & Eve Gan Eden = Garden of Eden Nachash = Snake Kavana = Intention Hasped = Eulogy Yerushalmi = Jerusalem Talmud
Categories:Torah/Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
As they say here in Israel winter, you
should be well in the winter.
As they say, be strong and well for this
winter 6 months until pes until another
yam which comes.
I would like to share with you a
fascinating insight from the Samra from
Dinsk who made a beautiful point on the
paras which I'd like to share with you
and the insight is exceptional. You
remember when told uh in the Ganed look
at theseim here
elohim
the almighty commanded
hashem elohim hashem's name is given
there lema to say meaning pass on this
message the message is
from all the fruit in the tree you can
imagine the most fabulous fruits there
must have been in Ganedan the
pomegranates the apples the oranges
whatever there was you can eat from it
all. Not only that, you should surely
eat from there and the mitzvah was to
eat from the from the ganad and eat from
the fruit whatever you can. Means you
should surely eat it. Eat it and enjoy
it. But there is a limitation clause
but from the one specific tree
that you should not eat from there.
From the day that you actually eat from
that tree, you will surely die. The
mitzvah is to enjoy to eat whatever
there is in the garden. It's all for
yours. Surely you should eat it. Now
later we see that when was approached by
the no, she answered in the following
way. Look carefully.
She was the the no tried to entice her.
This is in giml right at the beginning
of gimlisha.
And the woman answered.
She answered the snake as follows.
We can eat. You can eat from the fruit
of the tree. You can eat it. You can
nash. You can take whatever you want
from the tree. But
in one specific tree which is in the
garden
here's Hashem's name inserted Hashem's
name in the say you must not eat from
there.
The mime and not to touch it yes you
will die. There was a major inaccuracy
here in what said to the snake from what
told to meaning as follows says the
beautiful point the commandment was
given to eat and enjoy and take whatever
you can but's message he picked up that
the mitzvah of Hashem was not to eat and
as far as what you can eat you can if
you want to it's you're allowed to do
that the
makes an incredible a brilliant comment
I think let me give you just a little
bit of an insight a deviation but
understand who exactly was Rome Simra.
It's a beautiful story told about the
background. In 1887 almost over 150
years ago the uh community of Dinsk in
in Russia suffered a tremendous tragedy.
The two great leaders there was one
community and there was one liter
community
and both leaders died. Both were
exceptional.
They both died after pes within about
two or three months of the other of each
other and the community was completely
bereff at the time of the hespadim of
the funerals of Ru vain lavine he was
the lipish god from the misnagim the
maggid from vnner whose name was raak of
kharif came and gave a hesford and he
said the following point he said at the
time of the revia which the community
was in tremendous mourning for this
great leader who had died and the
actually har turned out to be with
Bakavo, the chief rabbi of New York. He
later went to New York and he was the
only chief rabbi as far as I know of New
York. But he made the following comment
at his hesford at the time of the the
funeral of Buuin Lavine who was the the
w of the visagdim.
Usually a usi he says the yami brings
down in a void zora that the time of the
loss of a leader there's a tremendous
loss in the community the loss is
enormous and then he turned around and
said to the community almost with a
pivot he switched around completely he
said but for this community particular
community there isn't such enormous
tragedy why because in reality your next
v will be the husband of the shopkeeper
in bialisto and that's what he said at
the end and no one knew he was talking
about who is the who is the shopkeeper
and who is the husband of them and they
went and asked the basi the basvi of
Yoshi be solvic who was the great leader
at the time they asked him who on earth
is this person who is uh learning in
bialisto the husband of the shopkeeper
he turned around and said why are you
asking me what I think about him ask him
what he thinks about me meaning knew
exactly who he was
interesting at the age of 13 he had gone
to learn in a famous cole called in
Aisha shock where the had learned as a
young man and also Abhimosa Gjinsky had
learned as well and later he went to
Hashid was made for him in Bialisto at
the age of 16 he got married and his
father-in-law actually set up his
daughter with a business a business she
was the shopkeeper and she was very well
trained and she made a very good living
in Bialisto and she supported her
husband and he went to learn in the
besame of the mialisto he sat there for
28 years they say he sat and learned
every single day for 18 hours a day a
phenomenal
Simra just a little background. He wrote
two famous works which we have. The
first is called the Sam on the Rambam
where he goes into great detail
illustrating exactly the questions which
the Bible asks on the Rambam and
different questions and queries which
people have on the Rambam. The other
commentary which he wrote was on the
Kumish called the mema. Interesting. His
father-in-law
was his wife's husband, his wife's
father, turned around and said to him,
"Do not publish first your commentary on
the Kumish, which he wrote as a very
young man. He said, "People will then
think that you're only a maggot. You're
a person who makes dashes, but in
reality, you're a great and a poek and
therefore he first published the oam."
And then afterwards he actually never
published in his lifetime the meshma on
the kumsh which is supposed to be
absolutely fascinating astonishing
comment on the hum which I want at this
point which I want to bring out to you
here and actually after he died he left
money that his safer on the should be
published the me that's what we have
today and it was an incredible time at
actually when salant had died this is
I'm diverting a little bit but to give
you a little bit background who exactly
was the when salant had died in Yusaleim
who was a wobb of yushalime then the
zakanim the bastin of yushim asked for
mayor simka to come and be the wob there
but there was such an enormous protest
and complaints from the community in
nins we're not prepared to lose him and
he stayed there he stayed there even
during world war I when there was
bombing there was tremendous danger in
the community he said if there are nine
people there then I will be the 10th and
I will stay in the community a
phenomenal time at kam he never they say
left shul on Friday night unless he made
sure every single stranger and person in
sh was lked After tremendous besid and a
great yo and a po of the du the osame
coming back though to the insight which
is a beautiful point what happened here
the almighty had told alisha tell over
to your wife that you should en it's a
mitzvah to enjoy the food what does it
mean the mitzvah to enjoy enjoy what I'm
giving you in other words
wants to us to enjoy his world
enjoy what I have for you take pleasure
from all the what I'm giving you enjoy
it. But there was one particular point
you can't do. Mean you can't eat from
the tree theas
that was a message. It's a beautiful
point behind this and meaning there's ai
the usi brings down and the mayor brings
this down in his comment in the it's
very brief very concise but he says as
follows oid lover in the future a person
will have to give a dineshman a
reckoning to the almighty why didn't you
have pleasure from certain things
delights which I gave into the world
meaning person is supposed to enjoy
whatever the gives I suppose we can
extrapolate and go a little bit further
person has a mishbah a family enjoy your
family you know person is given and a
wife. Enjoy your wife. No, of course
enjoy what you're given. Person is given
good health. Enjoy what you're given in
life. Don't just regard it as nothing.
It's a mitzvah to enjoy. I would like to
extrapolate more. Not just in the food.
If you see a beautiful view, a beautiful
scenery or something. Enjoy it. Enjoy it
and say no. Say say something. Say thank
you.
Enjoy what the almighty gives you. The
point which the is saying is that the
Almighty told him enjoy take pleasure
from what I'm giving you. And that's the
mitzvah. The mitzvah is you should
surely eat. That's the point. Kaba got
it wrong. Or rather says the in reality
never told her never told that was a
mitzvah to eat. Meaning the loas look
carefully at the words which Kaba had
said. I'm being very this is not my
insight of course. Here's the as
follows. Kaba said as follows. Yes we
can eat. You can nash from everything
else but Hashem's name is written by
what you must not eat. And therefore
says the she never knew of the mitzvah.
There was no mitzvah as far as you can
take whatever you want. But the mitzvah
is on the say what hashem has actually
said on the positive mitzvah not on the
negative. And therefore the message was
wrong. It was inaccurate feedback. He
was told was told lay you must tell but
he didn't tell her. And that answers the
second point which is a beautiful point
also which the mentions as follows. We
know there's a concept if a person is
busy with a mitzvah then he's protected
from any aa why therefore was kaba not
protected by the mitzvah of eating
eating from the fruit of the the tree
why wasn't she protected why wasn't the
able to entice her and seduce her away
from what was the mitzvah here if there
was a mitzvah here problem is she never
knew it was a mitzvah and we know
there's
no mitzvah when you do a mitzvah do you
need to have kavana or do you not need
to have kavana
in simmon pas according to the mitzvah
thank goodness for that every time you
do a mitzvah you don't have to do have
kavana but you have to know it's a
mitzvah at least maybe for example a
person says a shahak says the there in
the he brings that if it's evident if
it's obvious from the act that you did
even though you never had kabana you
still get the mitzvah of course it's
better if a person has kavana to do the
mitzvah but if even so even if you do
mitzvah. Supposing a person says benches
and it says a yatza. Even if you never
thinking but you knew there was a
mitzvah and you didn't have kavana but
it's obvious for example you gave money
of charity to a poor man you're never
thinking of the mitzvah but obviously
you realize it's obvious from the fact
what you did that you were doing the
mitzvah and therefore there is a for the
mitzvah I must add here one particular
point that brings down there in
there are two things which mitzvah even
though we pas in mitzvah do not need you
not need intention but two things you do
The first line of
you must understand the words and know
what you're saying. And the first of
there you must have kavan. You must
understand the words that you're saying
and the mitzvah you're doing. But any
other mitzvah says the like if it's
obvious and evidential that what you
were doing you were doing a mitzvah then
your mitzvah mitzvah but if it's you
aware of the mitzvah and therefore let's
come back to kava.
Why wasn't she protected by doing the
mitzvah because Hashem had told Adam
it's a mitzvah to the positive mitzvah?
She never knew about it and that was the
inaccurate feedback. The tragedy of the
inaccuracy was that he never told her
about the mitzvah says. Therefore, she
was just nashing and there was no
protection for her. There would have
been protection if she knew there was a
mitzvah but she never knew about it and
therefore she was enticed and as you
know that led to the awful tragedy of
eating from the adas and Adam ate from
there and there we have the great
mistake which happened to mankind he was
sent out of Ganeda because of that.
Therefore, we must understand the point
here. The necessity to follow exactly
what the toy is telling us here. The
importance of being careful and precise
exactly what the Torah is telling us
here. Odam did not do that. He did not
says the he did not tell that there was
a mitzvah to eat. She picked up on the
low of not eating from the where's the
proof says because the word elohim comes
from of not eating not on the act of
eating. Eating and nashing from the food
was just nashing. You can eat from that.
But there was no mitzvah from there. And
therefore she was not protected when she
did eat from the eat. And therefore she
was enticed by the the snake and the
problems which we know which led from
there.
We perhaps bring a proof from all this a
beautiful words of the novi. He says as
follows.
The words of the Almighty are correct
and theim they take the words and they
run with them. They follow the mitzvah
and they perform them properly. But po
people who are careless and negligent
you stumble in the mitzvah. Why? You
didn't really understand the mitzvah.
You don't doing the mitzvah as it was.
The mitzvah is is a powerful mitzvah is
and a person meaning if you're not
careful with it, you can stumble with
them. But
let me give you some examples what I
mean. Suppose a person gives a
tremendous amount of money for charity
but his intention is really only what a
name that people should know he's a big
giver. In reality he did the mitzvah. Of
course there is but it's not the same.
If you understand the point of the
mitzvah of course if he thinks he's
doing a mitzvah it is but it's not as
powerful as if he would think he was
doing the mitzvah. You follow the point
or
hospitality to people. There is a
mitzvah. Of course, if your whole
intention is only not to just to have a
good name for yourself of being a home
which is open for people, then surely
it's not as powerful as if you did it.
Meaning it's a little bit different from
because she never even knew she was a
mitzvah here. But here the person maybe
is opening their house or giving money
to it's the question is whether you're
going exactly according to the way the
Torah wants it or not. Are you following
the lines of the toy or you're making
your own deviation which is not really
so accurate to be careful of what the
mitzvah is give you another example
person gives a shia and his whole
intention is become a famous dashion a
famous [clears throat] magia and gain
popularity from that it's all very well
but he's thinking only of himself and
his own prestige and his own glory not
the same thing if he were doing look at
lishma therefore there is a certain
power behind the mitzvah which we have
to understand the accuracy of the
mitzvah is crucial
And that's what he didn't even tell Adam
didn't even tell Kab about the mitzvah.
And that was the tragedy which we saw
behind here. She was unaware that was a
mitzvah to eat and therefore there was
no protection for her. I was thinking as
I was preparing the Shia thinking about
it on you know wherever I went on to
it satisfies a person and it makes a
person tranquil.
The the testimony of
makes a fool wise meaning
if it's
seeing
when does a person get mash tranquility
and contentment when it's if it's purity
and it's Torah in its essence if you do
it like that meaning what the mitzvah is
and you perform it that is the echo
behind it when is it when is It make a
fool wise when it's near mono when it's
faithful to the point. I was thinking
that isn't that really the point here
behind it behind here. There was a
mitzvah here to eat from the fruit and
never knew about that. But the wants us
to enjoy the mitzv he wants us a person
will receive tranquility and mishesh and
contentment if it's tamima if he follows
exactly what the Torah wants from him
and doesn't deviate and doesn't bring
any other side point into it but he
competes the mitra as it is. When does a
person become a wise person?
A wise person becomes only after he
understands what is near mana. The
genuine item. The genuine item. Not
deviating and putting your own version
into it. We see exactly the tragedy of
that. Also went even further than that.
She turned around and said to the snake
as well also we're not allowed to touch
the tree. There was no mitzvah about not
touching the tree. What happened was the
noish pushed her onto the tree as you
know and she didn't die and therefore he
turned around to her and said of course
nothing is wrong yet therefore eat and
she ate from there and from there there
led enormous diversion and the tragedy
meaning she added for herself but that
wasn't timma no mention was mentioned
about not touching the tree she added it
on
if it's timma then it's good if you add
in other versions it's not good you'll
only become a wise person if you're
careful to ensure that the mitzvah is
tima is pure in its essence by itself.
Let me give an example personal things
that happened to me. I remember I was
once in Los Angeles and I was asked to
give a sh to a masipto to yeship gatano
called yola. It's a comm a school in Los
Angeles and they asked me I remember I
went to speak there it was parasash
parvash all about when yhuda comes and
complains to ysef and begs him for mercy
that that he should have makus and give
binam back again. You know the story by
Bayash. I went and told the boys in the
yeshiva exactly what happened by Yseph.
He accepted what Yehuda said. Eventually
he he admitted who he was. And I
explained to the boys the greatness of
Ysef was that he wasn't taking any
revenge. He immediately realized his
intention was only to fulfill the dreams
that she had had. Meaning that everybody
had now bowed down to him. And now he
could reveal himself. I told them
exactly what the phat was in the story.
After I had finished, the principal the
manal of the school came running over
and says, "You gave a wonderful,
wonderful shia. Thank you so much." I
said, "What was so wonderful? I must be
honest with you." I just told them
exactly what had happened by Yoseph.
Yseph had now fulfilled the dreams and
therefore he now could reveal himself
and he brought Yakabino down to Mitsim
as we know. And the brothers were scared
maybe he would take revenge but in
reality there was no revenge by Yseph.
He was only concerned about the dreams.
He turned around and he says, "Yes, but
you have to understand Yonison." He said
it's me as follows. I can still remember
the point. Last week we had another
guest speaker coming to speak to the
boys and it was Paras Mikates and the
young Bob turned around and said to the
to the boys as follows. He explained to
them, you know what happened between
Ysef and his brothers? Well, you know,
there's a film called The Godfather.
They're evidently about the mafia. And
in the mafia, one of the biggest
problems is to take revenge for the
blood of somebody else. And the Italians
in the mafia are interested in taking
revenge. Y was taking revenge here
against his brothers by torturing them.
He said this. He said this was
ridiculous. Bish that's not what the
means. He contrived his own meaning to
them and that's not to me. It's totally
inaccurate. He didn't get the point. The
point is to understand exactly what is
the Torah telling us here. It's not
revenge. Ysef was bothered about
fulfilling the dreams. Turned out to me
said it was so crooked. It was so
peculiar
is telling us here. That's the point
here behind it all.
I remember I once gave a shia to several
uh gentlemen here in in Israel and uh at
the end of the shia I always remember
there was a nuisance at the end of the
shia one of the gentlemen who listened
to my shia then told man to me says yes
you know babam you know in science
there's a theory which backs up exactly
what you're saying in the toakadosha and
there's a certain principle I remember
he mentioned in in physics how it proves
what you're saying is correct and also I
once read in a secular novel this
certain incident which backs up what
you're And said eventually it became
ridiculous every time he took away the
points of the Tory because he wanted to
add in to the Torah his own formula from
the secular world. The Torah doesn't
need that to leave it as it is. The
problem with Adam he never told he was
taught lay tella exactly the mitzvah is
to eat. Kava never knew about the
mitzvah to eat. This is what the oame is
saying. And therefore, there was no
protection for her against the snake
when it came to the problem of the
enticement because it wasn't the
mitzvah. It's only it's neon if it's if
you do exactly what the Torah is telling
you here. You can't you don't the Torah
doesn't need secular ideas behind it to
back it up. Eventually, he left the
Shia. Thank goodness I was such a
nuisance every time. He took away all
the points which I was saying in the
toyaka and he left it with his own
scientific secular thoughts. Torah
doesn't need that.
they are
do what exactly what the Torah is
telling you here. Don't add in your own
version on your own connotations on your
own thoughts. Torah doesn't need that.
It's
if you leave it as it is. Therefore, I'd
like to take the words of the is telling
us here and extrapolate. As I mentioned
previously, we can take this point as
follows. The Torah is telling us certain
things. We have to be super careful to
be accurate with our understanding of
the Torah and not bring in our own
versions, our own thoughts. I often
remember I remember used to hearing
years ago I used to go to a certain
shaven and the the rabbi used to bring
in all sorts of theories which he
thought it's not what the Torah was
telling us here. I remember when I was
in gates remember
she was now in gates said I was in his
shia remember the comedy always used to
say to a certain person when they asked
a question
what's written inside the gamma what's
don't bring me something else you're
telling me something which is not there
the biggest problem for someone who's
learning gamma is what does it say here
what is the Mishna saying what is the
gamar saying don't bring in your own
version you have to be super careful to
be accurate that was a problem did not
have the accuracy of what was told.
Eat from here. Look exactly what is
being said here and follow the words as
carefully as you can. That's the point
here. The accuracy. And remember, what
does it say? What does the Gar telling
us here? Don't bring in your own
thoughts. The Torah doesn't need your
own thoughts. The Torah wants you to
understand what the toy is saying, not
your own ideas behind it all. Let's take
that idea a little bit further. I was
thinking you know we say all the time in
dabing certain words but we have to
understand the words that we're saying
you know
you are the king who heals completely
when we say the wafur does not come from
the specialist doctor or the consultant
comes the almighty you are the
we say at the end of a he is the one who
wonders wonders us in in vikab it's from
the almighty not from ourselves meaning
If we're saying these words, you must
understand the words yourself.
Accept the words and have a have trust
in the words that we're saying. These
are the genuine words which we're
saying.
You listen to the prayers of he listens.
He hears what we're saying. One has to
understand the words that one is saying
and appreciate them and take them to
heart. And then you have you have faith
in the words. That's the accuracy. Then
it becomes tima and it's mashes and it's
look carefully I suppose also when also
as a child with a parent know what does
the Torah say about parents
honor your parents what is the Torah
telling us to is telling us there's a
red light when it comes to parents
parents are not normal people in our
lives parents are aristocracy and we are
lowerass they are upper class and we are
lower class in every aspect even if they
might embarrass you. One has to always
remember if the Torah is saying
honor your parents. That's what it is.
Meaning come what may, one is obliged to
honor one's parents as carefully as you
can. How do you possibly do that? What
you have to do is really find something
in the house which is relevant to the
parents and run with that idea. Even
though they maybe there isn't much maybe
you think to respect of your parents,
one has to find something and run with
that idea. Find something the says so
that they are
important people in your lives and run
with that idea and build on that point.
There you have the point quite clearly.
The mitzvah of is to honor them and be
careful not to dishonor them.
How does a marriage work? Look carefully
at the words which we're told telling us
as follows. The last two of the know
when the andala are standing under the
ba number six ends
the b number seven.
We're being told here by what is the raw
material? What is the gasoline? What is
the mechanics to make a marriage work?
It's not money. It's notus. It's not a
name. It's one thing. There has to be
sim happiness between a husband and
wife.
says in the
it means it's a prayer we ask the
almighty
he should make this husband and wife
happy together the ganed to the living
in Ghana no as if they are the ones
which are chosen like an that's the idea
behind it this is the one for each one
of them this is the correct ze and we're
pray we're praying to almighty we're
asking him please make this marriage
happy
That is a praise says Rashi to the
Almighty that he created the existence
of marriage on the basis of
meaning we appreciate that this is not a
working relationship like an employer
and a boss. It's not a master and a
servant. It's not like nextdoor
neighbors. It's not like friends. It's a
relationship of a husband and wife where
we thank the almighty. Thank you for
making this relationship which exist.
The gazelene is simra and that's the way
the marriage works. One has to I only
brought you a few examples here of
honoring parents and marriage and what
you're saying in the prayer to be as
careful as you can be as precise as you
can and as accurate as you can as the
words which we see here that I think is
the insight I've extrapolated quite a
bit from the words of the oame simra in
the following way. His insight is
incredible. The commentary of I remember
reading once that uh when the O came out
they said about the O and the Ramb that
it was very illustrating and very
illuminating when it came to the was
fascinating astonishing the ideas inside
the incredibly beautiful ideas. This is
the point here. Although was told enjoy
the food, enjoy whatever enjoy your
family, enjoy the scenery, enjoy your
health, enjoy whatever it is, enjoy the
mitzvah is to enjoy who hated.
We see it quite clearly. The problem was
he did not mention that says the
you can nash the food and there was no
mitzvah by eating. The only mitzvah was
not to eat from the other the tree from
the aadas. Because of that the tragedy
came about lenu and they were sent out
of ganed. The feedback was inaccurate.
It wasn't given correctly. He never told
her. He was told lay tell her and he
didn't tell her says the oame because of
that the problems came out. Therefore,
as an introductory sh I suppose to the
series of e hashem to carry on this
series, one has to be as careful as
precise as one can with the information
we give. Whether it comes to prayer,
when it comes to a mitzvah, when it
comes to
be careful. If so, we can be promised of
words.
We can have tranquility
or we become wise as well if we're
careful the words. If it remains tim if
it remains perfect and accurate, precise
in its meaning and we are able to grow
from that point. We should want a good
chabases
and a gaz.