Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Jacob awoke from his sleep and said,
"Surely Hashem is present in this place
and I did not know."
That's where the teachings of I I didn't
know
comes from.
Where the sages say that a person should
teach themselves how to say I don't
know.
But as a side note, there's a joke,
but certainly some musar from it. There
was once
an evil
priest
that had a lot of control over the
government
that
said that he wants to pass a decree
to hurt the Jewish people.
And unless they could defeat him,
defeat him in a debate,
where the first one in the debate that
says, "I don't know."
Not only loses,
but gets thrown off a bridge.
Now, while the sages, chachamim, of the
time
were debating who should go, who should
go,
some
average Jew, not exactly known for his
wisdom,
if quite frankly the opposite, he was
known as a fool,
comes in and he says to the chachamim,
"Listen, let me go and debate this
priest.
I'll go to the bridge."
You?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, listen.
Best case scenario, I win.
>> [music]
>> Worst case scenario, if I lose, they
throw me off a bridge and you guys don't
have to worry about anything cuz if they
come to you say, "Listen, you're going
to get punished now." Say, "No, we
didn't send out such a fool, it's not
our fault." And this by the way is a
something that the chachamim said that
Amisadai has done several times over the
years and it's mentioned in the Gemara.
So, anyway, they say say, "Go ahead, go
for it."
He goes to the bridge, of course, the
priest is with his people.
Everyone's excited to defeat another Jew
when they see this lowly Jew.
He says, "Okay, priest,
I'm ready for this debate, but since you
are
so honorable and so majestic and so
respected and so much more knowledgeable
than I am, I think that it's fair
that I get the first question."
Priest, of course, with his arrogance
says, "Sure.
Go ahead. What can you possibly ask me?"
He says, "Well, can you please give me
the meaning of the verse
where the Torah says,
"What does it mean v'anochi lo yadati?"
And the priest says, "I don't know."
Quickly,
his
foolish people that were supposed to
guard him take him and throw him off the
bridge.
Now, of course, that's actually what the
verse means. "I don't really know what
that means." I don't know, but they
didn't know that.
But the clever, foolish, average Joe,
average Jew, I should say,
wins the contest, is celebrated, comes
back to the Jews,
and they all ask him, "Listen, amazing,
great job. How did you do it? How did
you know that he's going to fall for the
trick?"
He says, "What trick? What are you
talking about?" "How did you know
you're going to defeat him that way?"
He says, "What do you mean?
For 20 years,
I've been coming to synagogue
and we get to this parashah,
and I look at the parashah and I see the
translation,
and over there in the translation,
it says,
"I don't know what that means." It says,
"I don't know."
So, I asked the religious guy next to
me, "What does this mean?" And he says,
"I don't know."
And I asked the guy next to me, "What
does this mean?" "I don't know."
So, then I went to the rabbi, asked him,
"What do you What about this one?"
"I don't know."
Nobody knows. So, I went to a different
synagogue and asked them and they kept
saying, "I don't know, I don't know." I
asked big rabbis, rabbis that were
visiting. For 20 years, I've been asking
rabbis and different religious people,
"What does this mean?" And they kept
telling me I don't know. So, I figured
if these big rabbis and these religious
people all don't know, then surely this
priest doesn't know either.
So, a little humor at the expense of the
uh
of the enemies, but nonetheless, this is
actually something that the Gemara
brings. Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan is
telling us
is telling us that this is actually
something that a person needs to train
themselves. Train yourself to say, "I
don't know."
Now, why would somebody
want to train themselves to say, "I
don't know"? I mean, this [music] quite
frankly seems like it's the opposite
of the MO today. It's the opposite of
the way people behave. In fact, he says,
"Train yourself to follow the sages'
principle
to teach your tongue to say, 'I don't
know.'
And with people who are careless
in this
specific teaching of I don't know,
speak to you about frivolous matters,
you should use any means possible to
avoid conversation.
And if you cannot, you should offer the
briefest answers possible, no more than
absolutely necessary."
So, obviously here,
without us understanding what is this
teaching of I don't know,
we're going to be dumbfounded. We're
going to be
at a place where we have no idea where
to go.
So, of course, we have to find what does
it mean to say, "I don't know" and why
is it great?
The Gemara
in Maseches Berachos,
page 4A.
This you will also find in Maseches
Derech Eretz
in Zuta, chapter 31.
And the Gemara talks about
when is midnight?
And it says, "Who knew exactly when
midnight is?"
It says David Hamelech knew what
midnight was because David Hamelech woke
up at midnight each day
to pray to Hashem.
And he had even a
special musical instrument, a harp,
that would automatically, by itself, he
positioned it in such a way that the air
would go through it and it would make
music in the middle of the night to wake
him up.
So, what? David Hamelech knew when
midnight is and Moshe Rabbeinu didn't
know.
So, why do you think Moshe Rabbeinu
didn't know? Because when Pharaoh
told him
about the plagues to stop it, uh when is
it going to be? Is it going to be at a
certain time?
And Moshe Rabbeinu pretended like he
doesn't know the exact time. It's going
to be around midnight.
Meaning Moshe Rabbeinu
made it seem as if he didn't know what
what when midnight was. So, the sages
say, "No, no, no. Moshe Rabbeinu did
know exactly when midnight is.
It's just that Moshe Rabbeinu was
teaching us
that you have to teach your tongue to
say, 'I don't know.'
Lest you be caught in falsehood." Baruch
Hashem
and say thank Hashem for more Torah. 1 2
Baruch Hashem. 1 2 3
B H Kids
>> [music]