Tisha B'Av: The Greatest Tragedy - Turnus Rufus Plowing the Beis HaMikdash

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com we're already holding uh Eric Tisch above say about some Cipher they're already out of Tish above he was uh crying bitter tears to the point where he uh was able to fill up an entire cup of the mice with which he would dip in his bread for the sudhasana the Indian of so gemara says is referring to what the mission is the mission said that there are five tragedies that happened on Tish above and then says five things that happened on the base it says the five things that happened on Shiva savitamos and then the mission continues what five tragedies happened on Tish above the tush above the queen was on our forefathers because they would not enter our sisrael China first place was destroyed the second base was destroyed foreign and the city was plowed over what does that mean the city was plowed over who plowed over the city so the gemara says a little bit further on in that cloth Testament I left Tanya we learned in abrasa khara foreign was destroyed by Titus so that's why the chance says the correct gearsa is when he uprooted was really destroyed he plowed it over and in fact that's what we say and to heal him remember Hashem what the children of Adam did the day of you shalam right they wanted to uproot the foundations of the basement aside and the question is and this question is raised by the briskarov and really it has two parts to it number one why did he do it basically this was really burnt down to the floor what was the purpose of uprooting it in a way you could say uprooting it is a good is a favor for us uprooting it is a favor why because when you when a house burns down to the ground the first thing you need to do is to rebuild it is uproot it from the foundation you can't rebuild the old foundations so why would tunisu he's doing us a favor why is he uprooting it why is he plowing it and why is it such a tragedy that we list what are the five tragedies that happen on Tish above number one the first base sellings was destroyed number two the second base and you know what else they even plowed it I mean who cares once it was already destroyed Mali they plowed it they didn't plow it I could care less what they did after once was burnt down to the ground once it was burned to a quest what difference does it make to Claudia Israel if it was actually uprooted or not cesarama that must says hey that there are some people that have a Minogue that the night of Tish above that's tonight they go to sleep they put a rock under their head some people do this says Sam people put a stone under their heads to remember what it says it says he took from the stones of the place he put rocks under his head so therefore there's a custom that some people have they put the stone under their pillow the night of Tish above question is what evidence do we have that when jacovino had his dream on the harabayas he saw the Corbin says I didn't know I was there so where is there any evidence that yakovino when he's having his dream on the harabayas is that what it says it says yeah abramovino wasn't really sure where he was going he saw the place from far away so the infarction explained how did he see the place from far away what did he see says at first the place was very deep deep down in other words Not only was it out of Mountain Not only was it not flat it was a valley says God I don't dwell in valleys I'm not a valley God and Derek let's go into amec it's not proper for a king to dwell on the valley but rather in a high place in an elevated place so what did Hashem do he took the valley and he raised it up Harry Maria was not always a mountain it started off deep it started off a valley it started off low God says this is not uh this is not my kind of hangout place I don't hang out in these kind of places so Hashem gathered the valley he raised it up Le Coq nikra Haram at a fear of Hashem it became a mountain by the way the Matter's time Kuma says the same thing the mattress asks like Olive since Hashem said to dwellersham turned it into a mountain how do you see a value from far away it was sloping down looking down you're sloping down okay it says the tricester is that a prerequisite for the shrina to return to the base is if the miktash again becomes a har becomes a mountain in other words Hashem says I'm not coming back on I'm not coming back if you want me to come back it has to First be a mountain it says the toy softer will not return until it's a mountain this week's parshaif the question is this question what do you mean hashem's not returning till it's a mountain what do you think it is what is it now it's a mountain it's called harabayas I'm not coming back until it returns to being a mountain that's exactly what it is Shabbos miros one of those mirrors is ra yeah right so Andrea look at number 11 by dunish IBN labrant and like him [Music] very good A Plus good it's good to get the audience around you know okay so the uh the drawer you quote says like this Ella Kim tane Hashem right we're asking asham to do us a favor and like Kim Tain Hashem give by mid bar in the wilderness make it a mountain Hadas is a Myrtle shita is another kind of wood acacia wood spiritual Cyprus Titar I believe is fur what I think titara is fur and and uh to ashur is box is that I think so okay so now that I know what boxwood is but uh right but that the the the the zimra is saying Hashem make the desert a mountain very beautiful now dunus IBN LeBron who's sitting in Spain he's not sitting back on his hammock thinking Hmm let me write some nice words let me write about different trees that I want to grow all the Peyote mother's mirrors come from sukem so presumably this uh stanza of the zemer constantly I will place in the desert eres Cedar cheetah Acacia bahadas Myrtle AIDS Shaman Pinewood awesome in the desert Cyprus Titar is the fur box right so wait a second if you look carefully at this plastic it doesn't say one word about making the mid bar into a heart it says that Hashem is going to make the mid bar grow with all various types of wood so I get when it says intar that's from this plastic that's what we're asking Hashem lost the lava all of these various trees are gonna grow in the desert but the beginning of the plastic alloy came the Wilderness a mountain has absolutely no Source in this plastic you see anywhere in this pasta where Hashem says that he's going to make the mid bar a mountain Sean doesn't say that so where does this come from where does this come from trees go on a mountain they're often growing on high heels fashem wanted to grow see they're all all the trees and all the Foresters the the harvesting the wood is all high up okay fashem wants a tree to grow in a desert it could grow in a desert right so if it's going if it doesn't need water then I need a high temperature either right okay so it comes along the briskarov and the risker of really opens up this whole game riskarov quotes and this scrub is cool is caught in the safer of a represent my brother so he brings down the Madras in the outcut that says that originally uh avram avinos originally it was a place which was and Hashem said it's not proper to dwell on the amec and therefore Hashem raised it up look on the fourth line they say um how do we know that Hashem will not return until he makes it into a mountain what do you mean until it becomes a mountain is God won't return until it becomes a mountain it's a mountain now it's called harabayas yeah says the riskarov that we learned in the Fourth Park of Tinus we read it number one that five tragedies happen on Tish above one of them was we were it was the Creed we couldn't enter Arts Israel one of them the city was plowed yeah and the gemara wants to know who plowed the city plowed the city and the rambam also brings down that Turner Surfers plowed the city foreign for what what's the point what was he getting at and we can ask and why is it so tragic to us that he plowed it if anything is better for us who wants to see a remnant of the ruin better a plowed field but I know says the Grizz ly that God said he will never return to the harabayas until it returns to being a mountain so therefore eternus Rufus says yes is destroyed but God could always come back because it's a mountain what I'm gonna do is do it I'm gonna plow out the Earth and it's not gonna be a mountain anymore part of the mountain will be missing it's not a full Mountain this is not a heart anymore torna's Rufus wasn't just removing uh the the memory of it tonis Rufus was removing the criteria the ingredient needed for God to return he took the edge off the mountain he took the tapping off the mountain he made it that in order for God to return we don't just need a basement we need to rebuild the hair we need to rebuild the heart therefore that's what the tercefta says that God will Elevate the mountain and restore it to being a mountain in order for the Shino to return so by the way rebirth the rights parenthetically this is alluded to in the in the alchem because the Alcove said that as soon asham came to haramaria Hashem said I can't dwell here why couldn't he dwell there like what the text after says God will only dwell on a her he will not dwell in an AMAC and therefore elevated ah so says the briskarov now we understand go back to the possible nowhere does it say hashem's gonna make the desert a mountain so the question is look on the second line in the this paragraph This is a source foreign that one day God will make the desert into a mountain is there any prostagintanasa says God will make the desert into a mountain doesn't say that anywhere so what's the source says the briskarov it's very possible now that the author of The Royal Iqra had in mind what we're discussing that God is destined to elevate to Russia in order for the shrina to be there and this is the meaning and like him Tain uh mid-bar higher he says the briskarov this could be this week's parachute Parcels what do we say in shabba's not coming what do we saying they have Torah call Gay yinase every Valley God will raise up what's that referring to it says the prescribed that is referring to this episode that Allah Hashem will take the harabayas which unfortunately now has been resigned to not being ahara and Hashem will elevate it to the status of the heart in order for the shrina to dwell okay so this is the shot of the risk around yeah afterwards okay okay so this is upshad this is the shot of the riska it comes with nothing Adler I'm not an Adler is the rebellious says like this we say that when yaakovina was on the harabayas so some people put a stone under their head because he he saw Corbin we're in the sukum is there any REM is didn't see her missile ladder he saw angels going up the ladder he saw angels going down the ladder what's this all about says there's nothing Adler the plastic says he met the place we meet him at the place that I'm not going it's Sahara when was it a muckling by Afra mavino by Yaris hamoko and miracle so where why is the pasta keep on saying what he went back to sleep and to see and to meet up the place of where Avril Lavina was before Asha made into ah this is a remise to the fact that in the vision of yaakov avinu when he's seeing harabayas he's not seeing it as a her he's seeing what the did to it he's seeing when the guy made it a Makkah means a place void of any elevation so that's the remes says with nothing Adler in the state of terrorismus he says so he says if you look into it there are some people they put a stone under their head foreign who Hashem you hear this avraham called the name of the makoim Hashem why that it should be said today it wasn't a mountain before today it became a mountain okay some services like this that in the times of Daniel that took the word why did Daniel take Noir because he said where's God's Moira akovino we're going to come to this there's a stanza in the kinis that says he was making the words now that's a kinna we know yakovina said that's a kinna we would we would think aquavino saying a beautiful thing you know where I'm sleeping it's not just the monkey it's the it's not just only Kim an amazing thing he says we know it says is like the city attached to it so ask the Gamora the city attached to you shalayim there's no City attached to shalim your sign is there's no City to the east there's no City to the West there's no City to there's no City there's no sister city of yusheline it's not like Dallas Fort Worth there's no sister city so what does it mean your slime says the gamara you shall I am Allah we know there's an idea is yeah so it comes out says as long as corresponding as long as they're perfectly aligned the can never destroy the base of mcdosh because the the Earthly is being protected from the Heavenly based in order to destroy this to make this God has to shift the alignments remove the alignment and that's what the plastic says [Applause] God shook his miktas he moved me something the shamala away from islamata that allowed to enter and to destroy the base exam Cipher when came tahara Maria what happened in the north and on his way he passes by the monkey Dash and the base time is right we know the basement was uprooted from its place and it was moved to Yakov ah so think about what's happening Allah remains where it is uprooted and comes to yakulovino yakovino is coming back from right from Bay sale to yerushalayim ah is not aligned anymore he said like this in other words elsewhere that's how we know yaakov saw the Corbin because if if if um you shalayan parabayas that makes it that is no longer alive that allows for the Horgan that allows so it comes out but how do we know that foreign for 14 years see some people they sleep even during the day during the shift some people don't even sleep at night yeah for 14 years didn't lie down at night didn't sleep that night yeah he slept in that place but the 14 years I have a question for you you think for yaakovino yeah he went 14 years without sleeping so why is he sleeping tonight what pain has made him comes and then all the learning is down the tubes why is he sleeping if it's 14 years that he went without learning right 14 years that he went without without sleeping why is he sleeping tonight and even more during the 14 years guess how much praise Jacob avino gets not one word we don't know one word what he's doing for 14 years it doesn't even say in the Torah that he slept for 14 years yeah the moment he goes to sleep oh got him we didn't even know he was learning and as soon as he goes to sleep ER this is not the guy of Jaco vavino we're not disparaging him he's not allowed to learn it's Tish above he sees the korba Mesa miktas he sees the Corn based on mikdash huh tissue buff it's also don't learn on Tisha now I'll tell you a very interesting thing I'll tell you a very interesting thing so you say what did he do for the last 14 years last 14 years on Tish above he didn't know it was tishov I should have never showed him the Corbin now is the first time that he sees the new of course by the way very interesting mask like us between we spoke about this on Friday we know that it's also to learn on Tish above and you're allowed to learn my run you're allowed to learn yeah so now the question is well once you're allowed to learn these things yeah right when was a person obligated to learn only during the day and the night all other times you could you could you know twiddle your thumbs only during the day and then that's the only time you have to learn so does that Mitzvah plan Tish above do we say like this well you know you could look at it two ways you could say Tish above you're not alone there's no amidstv if you want to learn we'll give you a recipe of what you're let alone you only got to learn these things but if you don't want to learn them you don't have to learn them or do we say well once you're allowed to learn these things now you're my cleave to learn those things no the question is are you to learned or is it only Russia so Valencia Navajo says to learn these things it's only rashus but if you wanna and uh adios foreign yeah why it wasn't uh why wasn't yakovino learning because it was Tish above he should have been learning he should have been learning yeah Terence is to learn what about the retailing are you out of retail I'm on tissue only only for only for an ace only death not stamp to not stop that stuff but what about learning most are on Tish above are you allowed to learn not the rest of the year the rest of the year okay uh what is it Monster okay so let's take one step One Step what's this Indian that originally the base how mikdash was uh bica it was a machoim and through the Thriller of avra mavino became ahar Tyson says commenting on the mishnah but vikiva says I want you to know that every single mountain in our system every single mountain in Arizona and it cannot be used for a double College says rabi Akiva Akiva even I will show you might say anywhere that you see a high mountain the eights run on and Shady trees you should know there's by the way the gemara says well can something that's we know something that's worshiped right if let's say uh your friend has a cow and he says I'm gonna sell you my cow the only thing this is a holy cow you know I've been worshiping I've been washing this cow for a long time yeah you can't be Nana from it because the subway what about if somebody wants to sell you real estate he says you should know this is a wonderful piece of land the only thing is I've been worshiping the land can't buy it it's also bad enough because Nevada is awesome so as toy Swiss so how do you build the base you can't build with some English based some English is built on higher bias it's a her it was and rabikiva saying that he has a kazaka that every Mountain has Israel was worshiped as Zara says hey very mysterious he quotes you xiaomi but you shami Paris and you show me the gemara asks and you know what you show me answers was built based on the navi presumably that means the navi said we know this mountain was not worshiped what exactly does Tarsus mean says with nothing Adler says of some soifer and two different chubas says and says the river of pesho he says like this rabba is if you look in the medrish you find that when abramovino came to the basement she saw it was a makoim foreign ask Samus and Adler what is going on with this mountain this mountain has an identity crisis first it's a valley then it's a mountain then turn the surface uproots and it becomes a valley again and one day again only Kim tame why didn't Hashem just make it a mountain to begin with says I'm nothing Adler says look Sam Cipher says the river of Hessel if Hashem would have made haruh Maria a mountain you can never have a basement there we couldn't go there today to diving at the hotel even though by the way the hotel has nothing to do with the base of mcdosh it's not a wall the basement people mistakenly think it's the retaining wall of the harabayas it's not the Western Wall of the basement otherwise it was Western World you couldn't go there you'd be Tommy yeah the way you said it is it's the retaining wall the higher advice yeah it's not the world if it was you couldn't go there there's someplace you can discuss whether you could uh stick your finger into the wall because like where does the kadusha start so it's probably motor to stick your finger in because it's again it's not the wall of this something that's so retaining one okay but says says the um with nothing Adler had Maria always been a mountain you would never be allowed to build a basement why because it would be about because we have a tradition that every mountain in Arizona has been working so what is do don't worship valleys they don't go to valleys then abramovino says God you don't throw on the valley he made into a mountain he was macro if you talk at that point in time Hashem gave haramaria to Abram I came later and worshiped it and Adam oyster Dover it was ready hours if the game would have worshiped it before adamino got there they would have come first they would have answered it and we never would have been able to build the basement for all eternity so God did us a favor he made it a month going he made it in amec aravino came along he was misspella to turn into a heart it was never awesome Taurus Rufus came along and said look if I plow it over if I if I remove the status of the shrina can't return and it comes out that of all the things that we mourn on Tish above the mark of the patish the final thing the nail on the head is the nail on the head is because that sort of is is an insurance making a little bit more difficult for the Revenge some to return to return to the heart ceiling so it says because obviously no we don't have that no that's not a Higher One the horrible no no the gemara says your shalayim is the highest place in the world it's the highest place in the world we don't we don't have we don't have what was take a look at him nothing he says on the third line it appears to me that the reason why it wasn't always the mountains foreign and it was already sanctified and a person cannot answer something that doesn't belong to him ah now we come to Something Beautiful says if nothing ever is there a sitter here or with the tillem has a tillam in it yeah okay so if you look in pack llama base whoa cooked lemon base oh oh he says like this uh sure I will not come into my house I will not go on to my bed um I will not give sleep to my eyes Slumber to my eyelids you know what I need for Hashem I need two things I need something that was once amokling because something that was always a hire would have been worshiped by the Zara I need something that was one summer going that turned into a mishkan and what is that harabayas says says um I'm not an Adler okay says till I find a place what is that we need a mountain now but not amaka but we need anavi to tell us what place was originally amokoi that became a heart that became a miscon yeah was it on mountains is different the the actual Kaka became a double kadash so they're for the mountain a mountain which is worshiped but the mishkan is uh is uh transient it's movable you're only using the actual mishkan itself you're not using the ground possibly as part of as far as Michigan so Rabbi say this is uh this is what we're hoping for we're hoping for LA kimid bahara or maspalo or mahani into the ribanishlam that he should restore the amec of the harabayas into the real hair the way the hair was it's interesting your slime is never a mid bar doesn't necessarily mean a Wilderness that is the way when you have when you have para autumn no matter Nomads living there you know where else do they live for this that's a mid bar okay foreign a lot more than us they were already from the beginning of the three weeks already every night of the year where they were saying taking they were certainly misaba on your shalayam you know people used to come to get out of the uh the draft in the um 19th century they used to go to Assad and he would give them a special battle to drink from and it was a school to drink from this battle and they asked you know what are you giving these kids to drink these were his tears from that and yet this to see be sure they did not seeing so what does the gemara mean s has nothing to do with mashiach yes so what does it means says the ritzvah you ready for this it must be they're two three assames once yesterday will be at the end of days for those who deserve it for those who deserve it there will be a special Trias Amazin for those people who are Miss they will get up to see the Binion base Hamilton this is what it means there are five tragedies that happened on Tish above Israel first place to make this was destroyed second made something this was destroyed but the biggest heartbreak the biggest Tsar is the fact that the shrina is missing and that was accomplished by the final Mark of apathis of necro I heard from that a few years ago he went when he went to artiswell so he went to Daven by Rebel yashiv and he wanted to hear how Rebel yashiv damaged Vanessa was not married and if you wanted to hear there's certain special things that is that he says more slowly said God up to the words he said these words the slowest with the most Cabana you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you byctoranytime.com