The Watch In Halacha - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

foreign [Music] foreign [Music] automatic wind-up watch you know that's basically you wear it instead of winding it and doesn't go with the battery it winds as you walk and he was going to the square feet one ton of you had to wear it on a two-day jump to the three-day empty because inevitably he's winding the watch as he goes then a different child from a different cousin he got a gold watch very expensive gold watch could he wear it even on Shabbos even if there's no air of these are swear of problems we have with you know he's going to the severe he's afraid not to wear it and the third question if someone has a regular watch and let's say is it within a narrative and the watch broke so yes what to do to take off the higher the broken watch might be considered so taking it off here moving books but then again wearing a a broken watch might also be like is it is it is it considered tilt to be a diamond so as we'll see we have probably close to 20 different shylists regarding the watch on Shabbos or yamtiv today they have solar powered watches and we'll talk about changing the time of of the of a timepiece uh winding a toy winding a swing and we'll touch upon basically three major suggests the Sugi of tekum Kaylee foreign but the truth is what makes this sugier challenging and probably the right word is gishmak because when something is challenging and tired up until kamat 100 years ago they didn't have wristwatch they didn't wear wrist watches now they had clocks and they had grandfather clocks and desk clocks and and they had pocket watches at plenty of time device pieces but the concept of the wristwatch that we have today I I did the little researchers just about 1925 limits Forum when they started using it and a more common way so you're not going to find the wrist watch tonight and tomorrow night speaks about a wall clock and and a pocket watch but there's no mention of a simple wristwatch so we have to really try to look at these site there's an apply a tower wrist watch so first time I must make two points the halachas of today just like Shabbos don't forget tick and Kaylee and muktsa apply to you I'm David okay I saw it was a little more lenient and we'll see even if you don't wear a watch but as we'll see we touch upon them as you saw this that was we're going to see of taking Kaylee heightsa and of course I think the point that you have to clarify the one the code that we have to try to understand is a watch that stopped going is not working either because the battery burnt out or it it needs to be wound again at the power Reserve has depleted a watch that's no longer working but could be wound up is that considered a broken watch in other words we know the SF tick and Kaylee is even a simple repair for example the glasses fell out of the the the screw fell out of his glasses so now the temple is separate from the actual glasses so they put the screw back even if you you could do it you don't need an omen to do it but to put the screw in and attach the Temple of the glasses to the glass itself you can't even use it without screwing it in taken Kaylee is laughed after built with a hard hat it's any type of impre a correction repair of a Kaylee so now the child is this watch for some reason is not going or maybe itaki didn't wind before Shabbos the question is is an isaf taken to wind it on Shabbos I mean the truth is you look at it and you see that it wasn't going after you round it it is going so it's a form of triosa Mason is that considered chicken Kaylee foreign or maybe you'll say wait a minute a watch that's the way your watch works you you wear it then you have to wind it but it's it can we really honestly say that a watch that's not going is broken and here's the point that we have to clarify you know the the quote the slang Lush and that if it ain't broke you can't fix it but we'll be more you know more prop but if it's not broken you can't fix it if the watch that's not going is not considered broken then it can't be ticking Kaylee ah you can't use it as it is so then I'll give you a few Michelle um you'll understand a a a plate of China that you have to suit up you can use it as it is you have to wash it did anybody say that washing a plate is ticking Kaylee uh you can use it when it's not clean but the Mississippi lot of wash dishes and Shabbos as long as it's for you sunshabbas so why isn't washing dishes of chicken Kaylee there's a spot the plate is not broken that's better you use it and you wash it maybe you'll watch the same thing I'll give you a better muscle they started making thermometers to take temperature so the Shiloh was that if let's say a child has a high fever Friday you know Friday evening 103 the muscle so you want to take the temperature a few hours later to see if the fever broke but if you don't shake it down if you don't if you keep it 103 it's not going to be an accurate reading because it doesn't go down so there was some poison that said that shaking down a thermometer is a problem of taking Kaylee because you can't use it as it is but most parties can say it's not broken that's the death of me so you don't buy a thermometer for one time use so shaking down the thermometer is not a problem of taking Kaylee maybe a watch also that's the way you use it and I'll give you even a better muscle this is what today is very popular let's make it the more common child for us a person has a table and one leg disconnected it fell off so of course you know how to repair that that leg to the table that's a ticking Kaylee in fact some saying I want to use a whole table even with three legs because you might repair it so now let's give up what sounds like a funny question but it's not funny let's say suddenly you had the unexpected guests and you need to pick a table so run to the basement then you bring up the soccer table that you folded away and use it to one once once a year on circus so you look at the table it's folded in half there's no legs all you have to do open the table and tighten it then open the legs and then grab a fold the table why isn't using a folder table chair or bed considered ticking Kaylee mad that you can add one leg to a table that's taking Kaylee here I'm taking from a folded item it doesn't even resemble the table and I'm making a table but the Mahaba says you're allowed to use a fold up item because it's one piece now the same says that if you have a meter geltasium which is a Gamora which basically means that when when they used to travel so they would have a bed that was made with pieces they assembled it when they want to go to sleep the next morning when they woke up they took apart the pieces put in the knapsack and they travel I guess they don't have a mattress but that meeting because you're assembling a bed so why is a fold-up bed chair or a table motor there it says if it's not broken you can't fix it if it's one piece that its mode is defold it and open it it's not broken so here we see three Michelin that even though you really in a certain sense you're making something you're making a usable plate a thermometer and a table but if it's not broken you can't fix it I'll give you another muscle you blow up a balloon the only problem with longer balloon is because you might come to make a knot and that's a cashier that's a question that's gonna come to stay but no one says blowing the balloon is a ticking Kaylee character that's the way it's used you blow it then you take out the air so the question very simply is a clock a watch that's not working and you wind it are you being the second Katie if it is you can't do it if for some reason this is the day of touch me then it should then this should not be a problem so again they didn't have wrist watches but I'm gonna tell you what the Panama here is I think the one the first that discusses this is he discussed what's called a Myra Choice which basically is the Los Angeles term for a watch Daily call that's a Hebrew word but basically he's talking about a clock and it's interesting we think we have funny tumbles there was a scandal about a Rob that he would move the clock I guess it was a desk clock to see what time it is and the quote the Lawson he was if he used to speak many hours three hours but he didn't want to speak more than that they used to speak three hours but not more conversations yeah but not more than common choice so I used to move the watch the I'm sorry the wall the desk clock to see what time it is and how could this rub move the clock everybody moves clocks that was the end of him explains look why don't you look carefully look up the Macabre look at them in the Mario you'll see the shot the Muriel was a question of madida measuring now what are you measuring with a clock or watch they used to have a sand dial that will tell the time or measure time an hour let's say a three-hour speech was the this clock so then you're measuring time that's medida and therefore smoked so but our clocks are not measuring sand it's just the time is going there's no problem so even if when you learn you'll see that's a Sandile but not our clocks oh but then the Panamera says by the way not only you're allowed to move the the clock but I believe that even a lot of wind it and those days was not like wine like today but they were pulling a string to make the chain but I believe that even wind this to sell shell Less on Shabbos because La Mesa meeted the Javier meter that we said that the case of the bed the folding bed and Mother's Day you're making a better smoother because it's all one piece and it is a normal testamentions so too says them Panama Heroes and he's very confident that the like that this room is a bizarre MIDI meeting and he seems to be learning out the head of Direction at the end he repeats himself the deity heptagamore and don't worry so we have a Panama erase to Wine to collect presumably even when it stopped working it's not broken however there are mahmirim and I should mention the primogada means erase he says because the Miser you are making from a dysfunctional clock to a functional clock now it's working foreign found the Gomorrah that seems to be a source for the Issa winding a watch now you listening to the riot and you see what you think the gamarin air van kuf gimmel speaks about a harp Aquino that you have to adjust it in other words you can't just play an instrument on a string it has to be exactly the right position top and bottom and this loosened and you can't use it as it is says that you can't type you can adjust this harp on Shabbos why not taking care of them is how to adjust a harp so on Saturday that's where he uses andreian a clock and right now it's not working at all it would be awesome to do it I'll stay concave and even they ask a guy to whine the clock is awesome so what he's saying is that just like you can't repair a harp you can't repair the watch so he's saying basically that a clock that's not working is indeed broken now the mice is a big monkey like between a clock and a hop a harp is broken it's supposed to It's Made to stay and that's supposed to disconnect if it's broken and more so you need a mice to Oman to repair it that could be taken Kaylee but tiny the Pharisees wrong to kill his Shabbos if the quotes Irvin he says but a clock that's the way it's used you wind it it goes for a few hours and you have to wind it again so he back to square one if it's not broken you can't fix it there's a very beautiful very thorough tube and this the two was Hara caramel similar if it's been to the end of the two is very small and he's also Mako it's not macabrepatish it's not broken and he says I don't believe the problem is because it's not broken but hazinis does say there is a problem with winding a watch because La Mesa as a lotion is you being a yatzer you're creating a koyage until now the watch is not working now it's working so that's a form of makabapatish it's not the winding of the watch but it's making the watch go from non-functional to functional because but the embassies is also Mako for the same reason and what I found interesting that the children may have a that's the talmud movement he says this can't be that the normal establishes is considered a Misa a macro package and it gives a funny muscle but you think about it's a very penetrating muscle let's say you have a clarinet and you pick it up on Shabbos and you blow it is ask yourself why can't you play an instrument on Shabbos is there a bonan show me a second Glacier Frank D two may have a why don't we say it's because the clarinet lays on the table it doesn't make noise so when you're blowing it you're activating it so you can't play instruments Terraces no that's the Derek histam shoes it's not considered macrobatus he used the motion of a clarinet I think a balloon is also a good muscle no one says blowing a balloon is Mack of a practice and that's why I could say many pie skin disease base the end of Simon Huff quotes from the marshak that was Mako because it's any child could wind The Watch the mice it's interesting although we have a great case to say that winding a watch that stopped is stopped you can't wind it because there is a Toyota Camry scheme as he's gracious for the Prima Gotham and the kayodam and he quotes uh foreign and I must mention again even though there are many makilim but the shaver a lady and daligid basia's Tube is that has become we don't wind a watch that stopped working so that's step number one what's much more challenging is why watch now that's still going in other words let's say your watch typically runs for 24 hours and typically you always wind it right before listening this Shabbos Arabs obviously forgot so you calculated less than you wanted it was a Friday morning Shabbos morning it's all over gonna be dead can you wind it now Friday night when it's going so we'll stay for Shoppers now we're not talking about you know whatever's extras and there's a you know this is more of an unavoidable on a two or three day octave let's say some watches go for 36 hours but none go for for 48 or 72 hours so you need to do something to wind the watch but here the mileage it's already going so the question is if it's going it's certainly not broken if it's not broken you can't fix it so the embassies it could be even the mahmir of the Prima godim and the hayab that acid winding a watch that stopped will be makal if it's going now but this is a unique situation because the mice you do want to give it more energy you want to otherwise it's going to stop so you're giving like a chicken it's like you know a layaway plan for a ticket so we could definitely say in swar it makes sense it's mutta but we don't work as far as we have to find radius so symbols an animal and you have to Salt it we call kashri within three days if you don't sold the cash within three days then your meat is awesome it's only Moto if you roast it get out the blood but you can't cook it foreign question let's say you shifted 12 o'clock Wednesday afternoon shab is 12 o'clock the meat's gone to become awesome because he didn't salt it before Shabbos so right now it's Friday night and he's all panicky if I don't do something with the the soon then it's gonna be awesome can he wash the meat till wash his hands he'll see a dime and wash over the meat he'll put water on on the meat if you rinsed it then it's not us we have another three days to capture it so here think about it you're the similar situation the meat right now is okay tomorrow it's gonna be awesome is it traffic by putting water tonight to save tomorrow and more emphatically than I'd be hold up in a beautiful tuba in tinyona Simmons don't even consider it a problem of tekkun and who this main focus is a pool to the meat but El girabba says it clearly that right now the meat is okay what's your problem and he Compares it to Allah if you have cut vegetables that you want to keep them fresh cut them before Shabbos you ought to put it in water because right now it's not spoiled you it's preventive preventive approach so isn't this analogous to our case your wine need to watch Friday night it's working it's like they're like putting water on the meat now the the Buddha doesn't make this connection but to show the massive in in gimmel whose Mako about winding a watch grab them like like we saw earlier like other pie skin but he said but he said he says this you saw it he Compares it to the case of salting watering the meat on Shabbos that's motor so to here but then he says even if you hold like some sheets that you can't put water on the meat Friday night that's awesome because it's a chicken that I understand because this meat is awesome right now it has blood in it meat and blood isn't there's no no good connection none of us you could capture it and get it out but right now it's awesome so maybe be my dear to meat is a form of chicken because there is a problem with the meat but this watch is perfectly functional what's the problem so you have one good sword that when a watch is going it's even better than than this than the meat that needs a little bit rinsing oh that's all different because the end of us you're keeping it going okay good good there's a question of keyboard okay that's a good point hope to do that difference here timers and alarm clocks as a whole set for itself a good good sound now but we could even do better listen to a perfect Demian the treatment has discussed the question that comes up many forms but the kids lets you have a fill-in that one of the letters Apostle mom is puzzle so you can't just repair it like they say for tire up because the world has to be considered so if it's possible you can't correct it Trump's attention was this let's say you have a lettering on on filling and it's failing it's getting lighter and lighter right now it's caution but if you wait six months it's gonna fade it's gonna be possible can you now go take a uh you know a quill a pen and go over the lettering so you could stay for many years or maybe it's like decision what do you mean I was caution no problem it's preventive you allowed to do it now to keep it later hey this is a watch that's going is not a problem because right now you're just giving it energy to go fight it but it never broke and we're back to square one if it's not broken you can't fix it here again I must say that our place in the next line says even when it's going since you can't wind the watch even when it's going now the Maison I did do spoke to someone who knows about watches that when a watch is fully wound it is more efficient and also the mechanism is maintained when a watch is what is going on low in energy it uses it deteriorates the quality of the of the watch so maybe in a certain sense we can understand when when the power Reserve is almost depleted maybe there's something wrong with the watch because doesn't have full energy and that's probably explain why because not to wind the watch even when it's going but I must add the monkey tests says that he rather hell that it's more to the winder when it's going but he has someone else to do it but he felt in its motor rewind the watch that's going The Orleans that I mentioned are also Mako so we could say that when the watch stopped all the boys you can't wind it if it's still going the Mr Brewer our place against when this becomes more challenging is a self-winding watch now let me just say basically what it is is watches can either go with a battery that goes for hopefully a year or so there's a watch that you have to wind and again it goes 36 whatever depending on the quality of the watch they design it's interesting when did they design it I saw a trooper from the hell Casio dated tough race static test 1939 less than 15 years if they started using wristwatches they already were they upgraded it to automatic watches so it's not it's not a new thing 1939 they had the automatic watches so the child is by wearing a automatic watch because basically every movement you're winding it so it's almost unavoidable that you're winding a watch on Shabbos says what's that they're wearing automatic watch it's inevitably a ticking one of my watched now of course if you all you had a wine the watch that's going so there's no different we're talking about like those that are made gimmo he says that this is a really only winding As you move so he calls it up secretia into durabanans first of all the whole winding when the watch is going can't be at their icing because it's not broken is okay that's what he wants to singer it says this is the normal way of doing it you know you wanna you wanna wind to buy a regular watch but this is the normal mode of wine in fact he says something very Exquisite it's made me have an obsequentia maybe it's a mice of your diet the grace she means you do something something else this is the way to do it and that's why Lamesa it's it's really hard to say that this is a shinoy it's not a Shino it's I mean it's maybe literally but there is a different side to be making a beautiful einfeld that basically the first first we could say well if some hold you could even wind the watch that's going you know even when you're dying but but I saw him he says that the starting point is you have to have a major ticket to say something is awesome now when you wind the watch there is a mice a tick and you're winding it but something like this a to new account that a person does and he does it hundreds of times a day is it logical to say he made hundreds of ticket monitors during the day in other words the what he says is that when something is like as simple as this that you're not even doing a mice of tikkun so it can't be broken if you ever watch that you have to wind every 36 hours we'll say when it stops maybe it's broken but this way of using is whenever you move it winds it so you can't say it's constantly being fixed if it's not broken he does say if you pick up the watch when it's not working you tackle the user you left it Thursday afternoon you've got the shop as you pick it up or you put it on your hand you say automatic work I'm gonna Wind It Go that's not good because picking it up already starts to wind it but his point is that something as frequent as this that's that's the way it's used is not never broken winding it if you need winding you might say that's a ticket but automatic is not a ticket at all and then I saw the shave at alive he has an incredible approach and he says with Grace the places got a strange case but it has a lot of relevance that will still give they used to want to man they always wanted to produce silk you know as in a silk tie so they had silkworms and the silkworms produce silk ties but they but they they had worms that the beginnings the Zera of toyloid the beginnings of these worms and you have to keep it warm incubated so to speak so they kept it on on the underarm in a place that it was warm on the body so the body warmth would stimulate these Zera tell them to be the hatch and they should have silkworms so the Mahaba says that that you know how to do that on Shabbos and there's two stars one as far as this Tilton boxer and one Suarez you're creating silkworms the your body heat is is creating these worms so the soil set up so if you can to create worms with your body so how could you shake how could you wind the watch with your hand so you saw it that he uses in a lot of ways and he says the dimming is no good because the olive of Shabbos is equations but the starting point before Mark service is the word malacha foreign a person that's going on Shabbos is going to school and he's saying is far with his hand and waving to someone with his hand and he's using his hand to make kiddish there's no malaka of of winding a watch normal activities if you wind your watch with your hands that could be a Malachi naturally and moving his hands constantly that's not a malaka wine watch it is nothing to talk about but he says why is any sane person keeping these serotonins on their arm he's having to do in Islam oh then you have Mercedes then you have cavan and you have you call it whatever you want but here it's not a misis and there's no cavan because the watch is going and that's why he feels there's no problem with this automatic watch the heart 3 is also quoted as being Michael hey and basically even though the K you attest he mellowed samat and he said also that you could wear these automatic watches the kids the classic safe in the khashabis the only issue is as we soon see a two or three that yam till get back to that soon today they have what's called solar powered watches actually the solar power recharge the battery and that keeps the watches either the Sun or light so the embassies we have the same ethereum like we have by an automatic watch it's probable that there's a little more of a head to with the solar watches because there is a step removed you go into the Sun and they recharge the battery now then what after the batteries you charge then it goes more but this could be that the automatic watches is more of a more a little more of a miser than the solar power that you were charging the battery first but any case the solar powered battery is not a problem I'd like to pose an interesting question let's say a person had a watch that battery operated he was afraid it might burn out on Chavez whoever it is so before Shabbos he bought a battery and it's me it's always he knew he might use it on Shabbos can you replay on Shabbos or yamta it is can you replace the battery so obviously if you can't wind the watch that stopped Avada Nevada you can't replace the battery but I'm wondering like the part of my ear is the a lot of wine to watch that that stopped can you replace the battery because if we say winding is more dirt because it's not broken maybe this watch is not broken and you might even say that winding is worse than replacing the battery because winding you are creating all that energy that power battery the power was there but the same as almond who is Michael regarding will soon see the guy be winding white so they're going especially but he has he says he had two tubers one was writtenishment that even if you're able to wind the watch but replacing the batteries vadios okay right but the problem uh so so through this some people could change the battery okay good you're all good but he says a more better time going back to tickling Kaylee you can't put a new shoelace into a shoe I was taking careless and you're dying that's what you're doing here not as shoelace is a battery winding has a Miler you're not repairing to add some watch this is a repair of the ad so much and that's why replacing the battery is also the holidays good next question is adjusting the time let's say the time is off and you're a punctual person can you adjust the time on Chavez so yeah just move the dial the watch is going the clock is going those you put mostly probably remember years ago not so long ago they used to change the clock on the summer a few weeks later they do now now they they moved it up a few weeks I remember vividly it was a once changed the clock but Soy Shabbos on pesach paper Pace was Shabbos and Sunday Missouri Shop if they change the clock and all the soyuz were like beside themselves what are we gonna do it's the wrong time change the clock not change the clock the old time new time against the gunson against can you take out the clock off the wall and change the time so what's the question the same question is it broken then you can't fix it but who set a clock that's an hour or two off is broken especially if you have a guitar so you look at the time it's not 10 30 it's 11 30. you don't have to be a big long then just to convert it to an hour a big deal or it's a half hour 30 minutes 25 hours so the embassy is there's a famous I don't know if you ever said it but everybody says to be smart what's worse a watch that stopped working or watched this the wrong time everybody says watch that stopped working is wrong crimes is not true the watch that stopped working twice a day is accurate to watch that's the wrong time is inaccurate the whole day so if he said it or not but if if that's the truth then I could understand that a watch that's that's the wrong time is broken but then again you could in your mind you could convert it and also what are you doing moving dials you know maybe you've more power you wind it this is 10 30 now it's 11 30. so it's not even broken the calculus Shabbos that I mentioned the Dr Khan but I mentioned the bear moisture even wearing automatic watches Michael by adjusting the time is he says once for is that you could adjust it in your mind I the problem is people don't know the problem will use the wrong time so that he says that there's no sticking in the watch and this point is the Sheamus is to turn the dial when you have to but it's not bro it's not broken you're not being the second like winding up a watch and he seems to be makeup foreign not to adjust the time of a clock but later in says as we saw this most poised my makeup in fact even the Khazana has a problem of its by winding but it's not a problem by adjusting the time so definitely if a person is makeup but even without that it seems that this is not a form of taking Kaylee at all the next group of questions is muktsa and this is an intern so a very fascinating turn of events in awasuke here's the question can a watch that's going is is there any muktu to watch that's going or watch that stopped so first of all a watch that's that stopped because it's not wound would that be a broken watch we would consider broken watch because we don't wind watch it on Shabbos is that considered muktsa because right now it's stopped so the highest since our minigers we don't wind the watch that stopped Mr Burris Heights weather Isa it's a broken watch unlike a folding table chair that's not broken you could open it on Shabbos but a watch that stop is dysfunctional so basically it's a Chevy now if you have a fancy watch that you would wear even if it's broken up a gold watch so it's not broken I mean the toxic faster is not broken but says the player Shabbos because the watch stopped so disability is basically any watch that's not working whether the battery burnt out or it's broken fell down or even if it stopped you have to rewind it is considered now you might say but the date is still accurate I could use the date but that's not the shimmage of a watch now this is the easy part someone asked me what he thought a brilliant child is a bosses even if the bus is his header the bus takes on the identity of what's a base for a contemporary muscle a computer desk and desk is not booked up but a computer desk is a buses to the desk and therefore the computer desk is locked up right so he wanted to know a battery like you all said is muktsa so the watch is a buses to the battery how could you be a battery operated watch on Shabbos I told you make new mistake because tackle the computer table is a base for the computer but you don't buy a watch to hold the battery what's me me nipple but me the batteries they have service to watch so it's unreasonable to say that the watch is a busted battery that's not a problem what is a problem and this is a beautiful Aura where is the gimbal cinnamon mem test was asked about a old-fashioned uh fan or a clock electric clock if you still have it plug it into wall and it tells time maybe it has an alarm to it but you plug it into the wall and it goes whether it's a fan clock refrigerator any type of electric appliance because it's going with electricity but you let him move it let's uh Governor McClain mate you let him move with the fan turned on you to see the time but if it's up but the head is the tail to save the cave you can't move or maybe you'll say it's it's anything else so Moshe says there's a time God the Lesser because you need electricity to keep it going and therefore it's not a Christian and you can't move itself again you can move it to your own use if you need them so someone asked me oh I bazoi a battery operated watch is also having generating power from the battery do you tell me that it's a cliche will lock the list and you can't move it if you left it out in the rain or a child's gonna play with you you can't move me handle the tail so here I again I think there's this question is based on an error because the truth is hard to understand why is a clock electric clock instead of mixer but Shabbos you're okay right that's why you get filters so why is electric you plugged in an air Shabbos but now it's not our shop that was shot I'm not doing anything inside if you plug it in Arab shop is but you still need electricity to keep it going on Shabbos so the fact electricity is being generated might make it a melancholis so his lotion is Tom goggle because you need electricity to keep it going once you made the gefilte fish it's fine according to this understanding a battery-operated watch that does not need electricity the electricity is all in the battery you're not doing a car there's no continentality taking place and taco the battery operated watch is not a problem even like your Maisha who's Christ is by a electric appliance and the biggest ride is in the save until too late Shabbos Sim and Olive the first two of them and Maisha was asked about a battery operated watch is that it's not looked up and I guess the headsback said you're not you don't need electricity to generate it so therefore to move a watch of any sort not only the circle of McLean but even Muhammad the sale is okay now the challenging but where the question is when a person is wearing a watch and it broke either some reason it stopped working battery burned out or he banged the wall the watch is not working what should he do the assumption is that taking it off he's moving books but maybe by wearing it is be a diet but that's incorrect because that we mentioned earlier and shin has member of about the silk the worms under his underarm he says one of these suramisa ah you're not moving it with your hands the terrorist is what's the dark and that's the Derek then it's Tor Isa that's the normal way of moving it Sam is on the feet not in the hands that's tilted pagama so this is what should you do it's broken take it off it's tilt to be a diamond keep it on is moving uh almost tilt to be a Die Young so he lives he points out correctly that taking it off is a miser of tilt to be dime a new Miser tilde this is resuming continuing what you're doing till now so once it was on the head to so to speak whatever it is maybe take you later go bite them so he thinks it's worse Paka believe it or not to take it off be a die him then keep on going as it is on your hand but you have to realize that let's even on yamdiv you shouldn't be going out and just Arab with a watch that's broken because it's a cloud so you might end up carrying it so the best states that really which avoids all issues very simply put is take it off if you can with your teeth a tilto the goofy of the watch that's once it's off then of course you could then you drop it down and you have no problem at all today there are watches that have digital display yet and you have to press a button to light up so that is real Shabbos of course says that if there's no way of using it beheta okay pressing a button of either that would be in this of on Shabbos to do and therefore the watch becomes because you have no way of using it bad now people ask her but let's say I have a watch that's I could see the time but there's a feature I want to see the date I have to press a button so body can't press the button on chapter so I have to put a black on the button I mean by about a small black so and the truth is it it makes sense Tucker put on a black you know put on cover tape but I can't say there's a key if they put on a cover on that type of Watch to make a cover on the button on your watch we don't have the jurisdiction to make new takons I always say it's probably more Mustafa to put a cover on the light in the bathroom people wake up at night then they go in and half asleep they put on the light and the worst thing is when they do that and they close by quickly so they think that's even worse so make it they have to put a lighter Beth might have black there it says you could say what you want you can make your own you know smyrus but you can't make an Isa durabanon to wear a watch without a cover on that button also the truth is the original case of the black he could do Tui Suite with one stoke havara of the fire increasing the fire and also like here pressing this button at Moses and probably an LED light is not either more than their bottom solemiser if you want to put on a tape on it you want to be shiny Shabbos and uh you'd be ashamed you know soccer you want to be very careful wonderful you can't say is to have a cover on the watch as long as there are functions that are without the button you're okay now someone asked me I have never seen this before he showed it to me he has a new type of watch it it measures your blood pressure heart rate and temperature he said he first been used to get very scared because he thought he was dead I said well he because he looked he saw the numbers are so high then he realized it was the temperature not his heart rate heart rate supposed to be in the 40s 50s this is like 100 or so so you got nervous you know 80 whatever I know what it was got all nervous I said you know so you have to be careful that there that these watches are probably my Shoppers because every as you're going it's measuring the heart rate and the blood pressure and it's a digital digital display is being changed so every movement is causing some type of activity we had a question about interesting Asylum they had a wall clock on the wall and the kids could the child that was different Shabbos could not sleep it was tick tick you know they're one of these regular clocks they have a little he's getting all nervous you want to take it off the wall put it outside and put it back the next morning is a wall clock s okay take it up because of the noise or you want to adjust the time like those that I make up so the Mr Brewer and shinch has listen to this he says although the Mario hell a sand dial is muktu no he's talking about uh probably a pocket watch or a desk clock it's not much like I told you because it's not there's no medida going on but I was told is a German word for clock vandor is a wall clock also the title why doesn't say why so the shot is gimbal see if you die and explains that whenever you say I wanted to stay there is almost like it's a it's like no it's not a song Because necessarily but it's he brings a Raya and he says to this concept is the the wall the clock on the wall that basically the Mr Brewer quoting Saratoga says it's because this is Markham if you never move the clock punct is a need for it the clock should be treated as much now I told this person if your son is always sensitive and every the night he takes it out of the room so it's not experience Malcolm if the shoe is constantly being the time is being changed so it's not if he is Malcolm but it is a legitimate Prius Marco and a Konami you should not move it next question also fascinating because his mom is from a different angle today they have toys that you winded and the the car goes and the robot walks today they even have swings that go you know we used to push a child today you can't do that because it's the you know instant Society you wind it up and it swings on its own can you wind a swing or toy on Shabbos so I hope this sounds familiar because if you hold that you can't wind the clock watch that stop because it's ticking Kaylee so why is it robot or a swing any different and taka the xiaomi Huda it's dysfunctional to function now La Miser I would say many place my makeup and as far as passion the starting point is if it's broken and these toys they have a use in a manual form before you wind it you could push the swing but you're dying so happy you say it's bro that this tickling if it's not broken and representative tremendous analytical mind he's Mako and he has another sorrow he says a watch is broken because it's supposed to be going at all times or at least 36 hours straight the toy it's not supposed to be gone all the time is that going you want to use it so this is the normal establishes normal this time just can't be tickled and he says an interesting analogy many doors haven't they haven't but it basically it's a spring in the in the thing that connects the door to the to the actual door post so when you open it you push it open there's a spring that gets wound and that spring that you created by pushing door in that closed the door it's an old-fashioned spring you open the door you turn the spring and that close the door on it like winding up the watch that's the normal establishes you're using it 50 times a day he's no you're not breaking and fixing it and that's why he is because basically it's not broken so you have a manual use of it and it's not broken attacking the bear motion on makeup do you want to be very firm the hydrant so I would advise you first push the child and as the thing is going manually then wind it up then you have a head to like winding a watch that's going that's really much like Manny Pacific the only reservations himself points out this is a problem because by winding a toy or or a or a swing that's a yeet and the fact that you could do it manually doesn't make a difference you're creating this functional kayak so later we have to step back but the other place so basically we have a sword to be make especially if you push it now the question is whenever there's an Issa of winding a watch in any case is there any head ID so it's very simple amirula akum to quote one rub he says he has a problem about them they think he said they told me he says they think I'm here is a way of life they don't know what's in Islam so but foreign says regarding winding a watch that stopped the worst scenario High yeah he says wine to watch now why should why should I need a watch that's wound so maybe uh he has to eat with you and he has to space it out in clear Hill or maybe I'll take his medicine very punctually but Kyle needs a watch that stopped you'll have a guy buying the watch another important cooler that wind it when the watch is going even though I'm here but to have a guy wind it so to continue going throughout the Shabbos not only foreign if it's okay available I mean Israel's gonna be doing biodium that's basically the clubhouse puts it very beautifully whenever it's an Issa the Riser we can't have a guy do it it's our button then we only ask for and for amitsub we can have a guy to a durabano now people asked I heard there's a difference two day or three-day is it such a the difference of a Shabbos or two or three days so the truth is it's only a technical reason why there is a click and I'll explain if a watch the battery burned out so there's no difference and you can replace the battery two day three day where it is a big hillock is on a regular wind-up watch or a automatic wind up because again to my knowledge none of them could go first for three days straight I was told between 30 and 40 hours it goes if it's fully wound so the problem is you have a two or three day until you want and you very much want to have a ticket on the watch if before Shabbos you have your automatic wind or you wound up the watch so it's going so even if it's be automatically wound you don't need it but to watch the best watch cannot go for two or three days so you want to wind it as you walk you want to use the Autumn Wind feature so the Chevrolet gimbal the end of Simmons have anxiety and he says although I was Mako by an automatic watch but a two or three day yum division because if you can if it doesn't have enough power to go for three days so when you're going you're in Italy you want it to you can't just say I'm just looking I want it but he says and I understand where it's coming from because what his assumption is it's not broken number one is going and number two there's no my system but they might say I think developed this crazy for two or three-day optif to avoid using a watch that automatically winds now I should also add that summer Michael even though in our Trail they don't have to say typically but he says could be a lot of wine to watch or at least certainly in an automatic wine because also he tells you to be mindful don't wind and the last question if I saw glad we once spoke about it and today everything's recorded you can't repeat things but I want to mention the details that we have to know basically the halache is in a place where there's no area of his only motive it's a Malibus a baguette a toxic Albus it's a serious and the cufflinks the question when they started wearing wipes and again not before 1925 they didn't even have wrist watches Mr Brewer says now that we are pocket watch about that that's but they started making this watch is that a weird pushes her out but there's no air Anaya so most players can say a wristwatch is none of the above it's not a Mile Bush so watch not attack unless you have an expensive custom watch is the tell time you know I would carry uh something just because you need it it has to be one of the above it there emphatically says his feeling is anything worn on the body on the gulf becomes a Mile Bush if it's worn regularly and he doesn't just say he has beautiful radius eye and Sham but he said that that a watch is head out small Bush so like me by a fancy watches attached it even a plain white is a malbush now La myself this is also quoted as taking this approach but the problem is as I told you many players can take strong exception to this and again each have rice it's not like just you know approximating this it's a beautiful sugar but I think when you could hear the Shia lab is today which become a very pressing issue people have to go to the hospital and Shabbos they went before Shabbos they have to go on shops visit the patient whatever it is and you can't get into the house without an ID bracelet a cheap piece of plastic you keep it on the end and you show the security guard otherwise you can't get in if you're going in a place where there's no area are you allowed to go out with that ID bracelet it's not a toxic I mean he might feel proud that he became a father but it's not a taxi it's not a malbush and and it's not a circle so the police can say this is a problem you'll have to work it out with the security guard what to do but there's a problem says that he's that even they shouldn't wear watch on Shabbos even though she taught soy because people confuse a watch with a pocket watch and it tells his tummy them that you should not wear watches out of an area on Shabbos at all so that's why we don't wear watches on Shabbos if those are where you can to scold them and but he says the question has become a gold watch a custom zagon Shabbos is that different he said well no problem because it's a taxi I'm not sure why but I think according to a watch because you might wear the wrong watch maybe the same is by a gold watch to a regular watch but that I'm not sure about but I think I am sure Mr Burns says that really make it didn't even attacks and a whole sugar why women with him it's only gonna get used to it Mr Blue says women got used to it you could wear but men equal to give aega should not wear a taxi on Shabbos so if you don't wear ring on Shabbos so even a watch that attacks according to Mr Brewer should be a problem I should mention women for some reason we are playing cheap watches on Shabbos that's a turkey if it's not a taxi you're back to the original Allah watches but the good news a gold a cufflink watch that which basically has a watch in the cufflink that's most of the holidays because that's taka a sorry from Albus and even Myself by watches this is the cufflink and that's foreign the uh yeah you know I'm gonna find someone else congratulations second one okay so we're working on the clock so uh so we're starting this year the secret right away and the watch and Allah created with swatches we had a beautiful circuit today as you saw but just to briefly review The Claw is if it's not broken you can't fix it and that's why a folding table is and knocking a thermometer down his motor and certainly washing plates and but um but the Crux of the issue that we discussed today is a watch that stopped is it broken if it's broken so basically as we saw today that if the watch is not going so even though they're making them because it's not broken but Mr Brewer is Christ's brother Isa and that's Dominican oil and crossed the board that we don't want the watch that has stopped if it's going and you want to get it should continue going the entire Shabbos although at most it's through a bonan because it can be a tick in the rice if it's going now and Taka it's spelled even that should be treated like a ticket an automatic watch on Shabbos there is a very big sat to be Michael a two or three day yum tip is because here it is itself the automatic watch seems to be okay and automatic watch more than any observation except for Corporation a solar battery that's recharged by going into either sun or light is okay that's a step removed from your your from your regular activity changing a battery is a real tickling it's like replacing the shoelaces a new shoelace which is adjusting the time as we said is is thank you if someone pointed it out that in some watches especially I was like over the battery when you adjust the time first as you're turning it for it stops going so when you adjust the time you have to make sure that first of all digital of course you can't change because that's changing the numbers but even on a battery operated watch by changing the time it stops and you have to complete the correction it starts again so that would be tantamount to stopping and starting a watch I forgot to remember that we've got to mention it so thank you very much but the mice a broken watch is muktsa it's a muktsa is dysfunctional if it's attached it as it is it's not muktsa if it ran out of power is the same because when I say it's functionless and the fact that battery operated watch does not make it a buses to the battery either Abba it's a regular clean of that tells time if a regular electric clock you'll add a move let's move from the climate to see the time or you want to turn it off you so you know the light's bothering whatever it is you let it move it your own server for a watch it's more possible to say that it's a cliche and even more because it doesn't involve any malacha being done there's no he of the cover and then a button of a watch upon Him various features blood pressure heart rate that's the problem because everything is changing as you moving the wall clock is treated like muktsum if it's not if it's always moved then it can't be American obviously but a wind-up toy according is Muslim like most poison wind of Swing especially if you wind it as you push it because even winding a watch that's broken even changing the battery if need be if it's going then you could have a guy do it Mitzvah and perhaps even foreign automatic Wind Watch when it when you start kneading the kayak as we said a plane watch it should not be worn out of if there's no area of Summer Michael but held not to wear plain watch and pass this uh even women should not wear a plane Watch Attack for nothing watch for men says not do it and a coupling watches holidays