The Takanah and Origins of Krias HaTorah - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner at Scheiner's Shul

we started the Winter's man mentioned expressed their excitement it's somebody just mentioned right before it's the tomorrow morning it's n Monday Thursday shabas chabas in the morning shabas by and EMS says we're coming off less than two weeks ago we came off a whole KU of Y most of the was last month rer we had K we had a KES all the different koreas the the M for all the is all in the already in the mishna I would like to focus today share more of a overview who is Ming all these C who is Ming so let's begin with doesn't list everything what's about Monday and Thursday and Shas so theor the gar says the says that Ezra was M Tas two out of the tasar two of them one was Monday and Thursday the of Monday and Thursday was Ezra and so if you stop right here it's very CL very morning Monday and Thursday and however yeah as well it's interesting thei says the it's from a it's not the say it is but not but it's clearly says you're telling me that Ezra was Monday and Thursday it was already brings when went through three days went without it doesn't say particular and Monday and Thursday Thursday wasn't me from Ezra was way before was wasu was really even though doesn't list Monday and Thursday will Bei soon but Monday and Thursday was also however expanded in the either it was and he made it into that's what we have now it's temp or and it was one Al one one person was and E was M three people are that's what was and the the says also that was clra that's CL and thear explains because there were those that didn't make it out into the city for for those people e added made a new cre a new ofas afternoon for the people that are not going to have Monday and Thursday it's not going to help to go three days without extra so thear brings both the gar says the says one person even with three people in other words made it from to the question is did he make it from one person to three people also so what do we have so the V we have before we go into the shist now very Mis is and was Monday and Thursday also expanded on that and then there was also then he also Ezra of shabas in the M the goes through the minion Al and the later explains why each day yam is five and yer is six we're not going to go into it thear explains reasons for each one the M goes through the each of the amounts how many Alias are per Korea so Rashi says when the mission lists that Monday and Thursday there are three alas Rashi Monday the C of Monday and Thursday when the Mish says why is rash saying EZ was M was M Monday and Thursday CL he brings the Raam it's really the gamorra that we sort of gar already says but the RAM spells it out clearly the rambam says this is really a that we have so far when was when was and then he says should also and also the Monday and Thursday e expanded what's rash saying that Ezra was wasn't e and the EM is this exact same question the right here we started learning asks the same sh on the Riff it's not a sh on the Riff it's a sh on theii that we mentioned before the Riff quotes thei thei as we men mentioned before says but then goes right says should have been in the list early with Ezra expanded on the Tak so the if you want to call it m or answers that this that thei the Riff says that Ezra was doesn't mean was because Ezra expanded on the that's what it means doesn't mean that this that it says that as was he expanded on the Tak ra M says the same thing in thei that's going on the Riff is thei because the Riff ising thei just to explain it a little bit I was a little bit bothered that who made the wasu how did understand EZ made theu made the tomorrow we're going to lay who made the Tak tomorrow Thursday were laning if I ask you who made the Tak that we shall LAN made we're Ling because why why Al that's but the is that the beginning of I he's not addressing I don't think this but speaking about not to go into says a few words like this like we that because it was such a call it a it was just three maybe even only one person it didn't really take off never came in during the week it was but it didn't uh there was a but it didn't really if you want to say it didn't take off it wasn't so they weren't it so much till Ezra came and made a temp with three Alas and then already so that's the why it says wasu but didn't take off fully that enhanced to make it the and it did take off the yeah the same and the himself brings it the asks same question that we we asked on Rashi and we asked on the Riff the asked this question on the same thing to says that Ezra was M Ezra was what do mean the is going in that every Crea every Korea is a Korean it's a it's not it's not it's gave it us but it's the that's the that it's the same says that even though we call it Ezra because Ezra was enhanced it add it expand on the Tak just a small that this terit of the that answers the Riff and answers doesn't answer Rashi we started off asking the Rashi rash also says that that was was what you could say the same thing but Ezra added on you can't say that Rashi cuz if you continue in rashi rashi says it would [Applause] seem what we're saying is the the first isra was saying up until now is that the Ezra only added on what he added on that's the end of rashi rashi WR the beginning says the whole B is Ezra that the as well as the rashash learn that thei argues on the B thei argues Andi holds that the cre of tomorrow morning the of B is so Andi the B that we learned the gar understands that says that it's you could be it only means the extension but the rash says no that's what he says he says Rashi this Rashi that says Ezra M he's going withi he just says why would the why would Rashi leave the B go to thei so before going V just to be massak over here with a clarite to go through all the shabas morning that's was M Monday and Thursday in the it's clear that it's as well maybe not that's CL you can learn two ways either you can learn like the B that is also you could learn that is only it's later then we have the of sh afternoon that's as the brings let's go to a few other other creas this the Crea of PM of now thee of happened later and happened later PM is possible to be a takra cuz was right at the time or right after the time of cuz was way later about 200 years after Ezra but him all this is all in the nishna it's as well as also the of so far I didn't find it exactly Gabus but it's it's CL it's in the mishna what say that c anive over there that's that's Theus but they don't want to be so we have over here different dgas of when did when did the cus happen from was was later but then the and this is we're coming off now the besides the that says it's if you remember we took out two that's we're going to be learning about these many the second the Caron what's the source for that that's not even it's later later after the after the and the reason T explains why why I'll later the gar says how do I know that there's not going to be another m going to be said what do you mean this responded by saying that you say to have the after so we spoke about who is let's try to be Mar now in the of how many alas Monday and Thursday we spoke about that's clar Ezra that these three Alias that's clar it could be even we said three three alas what's about shabas yam these different amounts right the Mion say shabas is Y is six Y is five explains he's Y is more we did all these amounts come from all from brings us he says uh says that the of also it was mentioned earlier I didn't see it inside but to say that the amounts of shabas and was like that if we're explaining we said earlier that what's why is cuz Ezra came and made the Mount of that it's different was the Mount of the Al it's interesting The Who later usually quotes only brings only brings shab and Y he doesn't bring that was we'll focus for a minute or two on the career of shabas shabas 77 thatu shabas morning to lameu was also M seven Alas and we know the seven Alias is a in the T it's different than yam you read the para of yam every week you read in the T where do you read in the t y is clear what you read you read suus you read P you read and Kipper what's about what what do you read what do you read on on shabas so you reading the T so the that the different now the minut across the board is to lay you split the T every single week a different para that's the minic but you have to know starting from the thear says was a to read the to it took three weeks to cover a par if you take a look in thees just a look at the end of the art SC when lists out so it says how many and the whole all the different how many pares 12 pares then afterwards he said the what is made out of 43 s it's split up it's split up into more more than just 12 parishes so the gar says that the Min was a to read they finish the tah every 3 years and the EM say that this this was still going on in the times of the speaks about you need it every year you have to remember it you should do once every two three years one two one or two three years and we read the T and we cover the whole t minimum once every one or two three years the r the r says the ra says that what we do is we read the a every single week that we finish the whole entire every single year however the ra fears just to bring out the is a ra bring in his days and a so is like this was shabas morning seven Alas and the is aore the T now what we do is we read every single para every week another par that's that wasn't from there was actually a minute to read a whole lot less than a whole than a full power one last and with this I'm going to conclude we spoke about the the all the different creus more or less recovered who is masakin Kus shavis that's a Korea thatu was M he was also M like the says seven alas now we said that some finished the tah every three years we every year and we split it up seven alas how do you know what to split up to seven alas you open up a they bring that the go didn't go with the he stopped with he was a pay or to this the has a whole CH he brings this guy in and he expands and he says that the EMS is that it's it's full of mistakes he says somebody put it in but it's he says you see sometimes he's like a that it should have been T earlier or later doesn't have aat and sometimes the re the ends in a place just we had now was moved thean CLS to go with it though it's interesting sometimes you'll be in a different places have a little bit different sometimes but do you to stop is is on top of this already brings if you have a who's what happens if the is a so what are you going to do there's no problem so you read from the beginning of the straight till after even if it's it's not always it's together but let's say it's together which we really we like to have to connect the parishes you go straight but Al what I'm saying is is to get the Mo wasas morning he also he was also M the seven alas how to split it you see the Tak people didn't even read one par they read split it over a few weeks one more it's brought that the father of the told us was they the the fathers of so when he got theah theah of of it's so they made and it wasn't sh anymore was able to be and I I sort of say more so when I was a B I went shabas I went to the a Ley and they gave him also they gave him the of mish to say they they gave the first Al up until and they gave him sh because you have to see you can make more Alias afterwards but how to split it to that's that's different which will learn not too close many how to do it but the break up and where you get to Seven that's already