The Sugya of Chanukah - Gemarah Shabbos 21 a-b - By Rabbi YY Jacobson

the yeshiva dotnet will begin today miss after Shabbos it's not follow from an olive close to the bottom you see the two dots three large from the bottom on me Ramona this is a self-contained sugar with the damara goes off so to speak what seems like an attachment and to another theme that has to do with yarmulke the whole office of Hanukkah and it continues for more than three blocks in the Gemara in the sector shop is the second pay dirt the way the Gemara gets into it has to do with the fact many people say it every Friday right in many many know slice was a harsh Kano's before bar ho on Friday night they say that pay dirt the second paddock of mush nice interceptor shoppers by my mother Lincoln but met a mutt Lincoln it is fired then and the sitting they say instead kagama which is article from Isaiah Parsons by jackal about Shabbos so the no Sahaj canals you don't take a governor you say you learn a mission and the mission is about hot luck assign layers a Mehmet Lincoln about my in mudlick basically hazael instituted a midst of lighting Shabbos candles before Shabbos remember then sometimes the only meal you would have at night was Shabbos because every day you ate you ate before it was pitch dark because once it was dark remembrance before Edison's days there's no electricity so it was very hard to eat once it was night it was pitch dark in the house we don't even understand what it means because it was electricity everywhere even if you have a blackout in the house there's a light outside somewhere but then it was really dark but Shabbos you have to eat the meal at night unless you brought it in early and therefore they MoMA sockin narrows Shabbos so cos Allah said by mehmet liquor my name i'd look into certain types of wicks you can use for Shabbos candles and there's certain types of oils you could use for Shabbos candles certain types of fuels certain types of wigs from different materials and certain types of you shouldn't use and the general principle is if it burns nicely in terms of the oil the fuel feeds the wick nicely and the flute whip burns well what do we care the Dozen burn so nicely we're afraid a very practical fear and that is a person is gonna want to read at the light of the candle remember this is the only source of light Friday night and it's not burning well so the person instinctively will adjust will move it will increase this will move it around here and this will be a mulatto man I tell you to call ma here which is contributing or increasing or decreasing a flame extinguishing the flame or increasing the flame from this whole discussion which starts on the fulfillment base in the Mishnah the Gemara now goes off to Kanaka what's interesting is tamas Hara and that is that is enormous sector can attend much nice which was I reviewed the Hanafi who wrote the mission is American Commission is he has a receptor for every UMP if both military damage they're abundant so say the money they have Shabbos you have a driven TF Pesach you have problem you have humor which is written Kippur you have suka bait sir which is as you know young Tiff's you have kindness ya Magilla which is pullin you have my eight cotton which are the laws of valus and then you have Haghighi which are denim of hackle and other denim of yontiff now carbon a Giga also connected to young teeth so there's one young tooth missing here right Miceli rosh hashanah we have juist is enormous after because Luis who would know mitzvahs to do on show us besides regular health is Yom Tov which are a common denominator to all the empty but you have so PF saw him so what happened to panic wise enormous economic initialize it's not like there's no Hollow for some Kamaka we're gonna see this plenty of a lot of some Hanukkah so from Oracle's hispanica is very elaborate just like Ephesus McKinley Aviles Chanukah their album her husband killer a lot of a focus on Konica not endless our office but there's plenty of others why is the enormous economic this is a shiny yeah oh you mean McGinnis chemicals I'm gonna give us antiochus right that's the story of the man halakhah locust Palika they say a void from of some cipher all those many dispute it because it's a very difficult mark to say it's not that it's not an easy part too safe but it quarter is forming the names of some sci-fi song that reviewed the how Nazi did not put it in a sector hanukkah's was because they reviewed a Nazi was from based of it he wasn't he was the grandson of course of the whole shall shallow small chain of randomly land a pitiless up in all the family of double homily and there was an issue with the Cushman I am the freshman million were great people and they defeated the eve on him and they gave us tonic and they gave the Jewish people to be some initial and they saved me the fact they waited my they made one mistake this is the RAM bond right system parshas by your feet on the pasta closer shave it me allude them if I can from Bainer agua Jakob says that rulership will remain I shaved it Yehuda the scepter will not go away from you to the Rambam there asks a question what happened at the fashion when I look at the line he says would subject indeed island were extraordinary people I mean they literally saved we save the Jewish people they say if you differ a little bit nosy that to you described at all if not for the customer nine if not for a father and five sons who revolted and then a hundred years later it turned in one of the most corrupt families in the history of Bayou Chene in history of the Jewish people the grandchildren the great guns no match for my Civil War they went to the stokin they ultimately brought the Rome they ultimately brought Rome into Internet era too strong the bloodshed the murders you have Alexander Yan I am a cloth or eight o'clock over the tickets are thickened it was one of the worst worst bloodiest periods among Jews themselves between themselves as a result of their work and there are balm attributes part of it of course people make bad choices and horrible choices he says also to a tragic historic mistake that they made and that is they were families of kiona they all the beim artists job and you're gonna go - Manali Ivana they took for themselves the coronary dialer which was fine they were planning they also took for themselves the Maluku they also became kings each one of them I mean according to the succession appointed themselves as the Mela as the leaders just like Malta based of it and he says this was a terrible mistake that they made because they took over them alone so they send an ambulance I'm safe friend that have you heard our Nazi who came from based of it didn't put in the sector Chanukah for that reason the question of course is it's very hard to say this because probably the most important axiom of perishable pet is the intellectual integrity of the people who wrote it you could see it throughout the Gemara throughout the mission eyes they were interested in one thing and one thing only what's the truth that's the whole power of Allah at the moment is I don't like you you don't like me I have something against your family you could throw out the whole Turkish about that what somebody who learns tersh about / what you see is they're looking for one every month like this think is a faithful minded margin but what they're looking for one thing what's the MS what is ms what's the MS of terror whatsoever so Allah say that he wouldn't put in a family he didn't like Chanukah candles Debbie it's a thick enough kazow Hanukkah Rosa cause out instituted it admits with your opponent sombitch to the hotline it's like whoa all this early did have one home it's lose me Ramona so to say it is a very difficult thing that's when many disputed what I saw one for a lot that I can't believe that some safer who was wrong if it was a ishyama it was very easy and that each amis would say this others want to say that the reason is Norma's economic is the perishable car was written for one reason forgetfulness there was no reason to write it wasn't written for hundreds and hundreds of years for Terry tomorrow says engagement volumes about path the after our show a list a bunch of books a viateur I show them up at their ships ever supposed to be written perishable / was not supposed to be with you remember from motion available to reveal are not see there was absolutely nothing written everything was transmitted or carrot that was the say that pal made them sit by the river and they learned for years first of all it puts a new responsibility on their every when he knows that if he doesn't give it over to the commitment it's forgotten that puts up different responsibilities on the phone with them also there's much less debate because everything is live you could clarify everything once you write something unless you're gonna write on every mission a thousand pages there's always room for did he mean this especially with Jewish heads did he mean this didn't mean that didn't mean that when you see every much-loved you could they said so first of all perhaps remembers tremendous qualities and they didn't want to tell you didn't want those up but Debbie realized it's gonna be either or either we lose everything because we don't have the infrastructure and the centralization to be able to motivate that transmission in a powerful way for this people have to be calm and relaxed you have to sit by a lever three years after middle son nefesh by let be here any saw that the dispersion the Gullah s-- is getting very heavy Jews are gonna end up all over the world I'm not gonna have that ultimately a few hundred years later the Sun Headroom would dissipate it would mean no anymore they wouldn't have that little cut to be able to cultivate it so some say that Chanukah was so fresh in the Jewish mind was it happy in the middle of my Shanee so if your dad knows he looked after by a shame but it was still so fresh in the Jewish mind that how love this were fresh was it was relative relatively speaking it was a new younger so you didn't feel a need to write my sector Kamaka the Gemara however which is a few hundred years later decided to incorporate although has a vanity that may be another reason that I once saw why does not myself Amica but it's an interesting question the only young to the little making it too much - but it makes it into tomorrow into mass after Shabbos ok so let's begin I'm ripple enough you wanted to say something another stomach interesting harder about this when you open up a rumba rumba myself is Magilla and Hanukkah together first he starts off fulfills its Magilla and then he starts off with ultrasonic way he starts off with on his McGillis he starts off right away with the halacha there you have to read the Megillah put him at night and put him by day and you make Abraha and he goes into the hollowness of reading the Megillah and then he goes into all the whole the whole office of a forum that other halakhah specialized Mollison honest love your elements of this put him on the main most a locus of put him around the Megillah writing them and give them a few skip and what are you saying from what do you say and loud the chatter comes to hookers comic in the same section of rambha he starts off three hulless with history we may buy his shaney camels amalfi of gaza luke Zetas part so posh - yada monomer didn't they say everybody's voice of massacre Marcin everything that happened and then he tells speaks about the victory of the most calm and then he speaks about the miracle of the oil and he goes Walter and then he says mayonnaise er he finishes after two long Huaraz American he's a nice kid mocha kamancheh boys yeah third that should celebrate eight days and he starts off with a celebration and then he gets into the WA so when you read the naamam you wonder when it comes to this Magilla he goes straight into the Hollow Hills its kind of you can also start as a minister for mitochondria ignites through hunger can you make a broth under so what you do at cetera over the first tells the story the whole background and then he starts this is a shine that interesting shadowing rambha so I saw once a year I'm a cup of slaughter only to show off somewhere I forgot his name but sort of safer so he writes es SI phan Konica so I was reading it's I saw this akadama so there's a Kadam I saw them and when he says that he was one city once one into a little bobberts whatever and he asked him does China so the rebus said right away said those Isis looking to have the dumb of Rambam to the mission of toner dark Adama of the rambling to the Mishnah third album said I called the safer mission a failure why did I call that mission to tell you that Michelini ii like Shanee like very because i want this to be a mission a turtle ship itself and he says like this a person reached a terrific South the whole time I then a person reads my safe and and he doesn't need any other safer then you describe to know all of our line he week there's some books out and he reads my safer the a methodical some safe route of course God has a sense of humor so there's not there's no safer in Jewish history that has so many before him like the Rumba that's that's God's you mr. Romberg said you know it was safer for the time sacred created the most before him and beat him in his bathing and every year she wishes she is around mama the number mausoleum Amazon okay that's that's that's a funny thing but what was the noms objective his objective was he says Gomorrah is complicated people don't understand they don't know how lawsuits we know boys very winding so I took everything that the called Pavley rashon meet SF this is for the all the mad Russian and I took out all the hollowness in any suger you read me and you'll know you took her shoppers everything but you asked to know what to do not know I chopped it so you have by me and then I'm gonna bid that I mean of course the ramen is so so concise that from the ramen himself you know what's trapped in there I'm gonna together but then I'm gonna did that he defined everything he took every halacha that was available to his day and that was relevant to his day and till his day and I put it in there she thousand social she V says I bazooey the Rambam expects a before me alone mission of Tyler and he says you read through terrific sound so maybe you read Nicholas Esther you read me Gillis Esther so then you come to help us McGill you don't need a history you read me to assess it she starts off haha what's that water from McGill II don't know how long I'm shaking hostess Connick he's not expecting you learn till such a miss active Shabbos begin with something office you heard story books or story tapes you would learn attention because have you come see album closes Konica what's comical one kind of it woke up like eight day while what happened so he doesn't the story it's it's it's the cup guitar you have to know the context of the Rambam numbers not a safer in a vacuum but everything is Basayev asunder so now let's start I'm a diploma something tomorrow miracle say the VARs huh we I thought I saw Molly I said was work I'm Maria Bruna you see the bottom omerta Bruner who no set Silvester chuan and Shamrock acaba Mehmed liquor been the Shabbos a mad lickin man back on all the types of whisks all the materials and all the oils at the her comin said don't use them for Shabbos candles why shouldn't he use them for Shabbos candles because they do not produce a robust good flame and the oil the fuel does not follow the wick and therefore you may come to manipulated on Shabbos and be liable in one of these three choppers Hanukkah has the same principle this is baby Shabbos members are not only Shabbos Chanukah Friday evening when you lie be Chanukah candles but even Monday Jamica Sunday Chanukah which look I did this is strange I understand Shabbos is a problem of manipulating a wick on Shabbos Botanica who cares but that's what Ramona set so the Gemara is now going to explain the reasoning of ribbon on my rather serova says my time Damona what's the reasonable Epona who cares if I'm Hanukkah you do manipulate it then who cares if you don't have a good wick and such a good oil the main fingers you let commit accounts so rubber explains cassava a Bruna holds coughs aw Zaku cloth we have here aren't very interesting my focus when it comes to Hanukkah tufsa means if the Nair Kanaka gets extinguished cuffs of the word key boy that gets extinguished before it burns the measurement of time that the command wanted you should light Chanukah candles long as we will see the common didn't just say light a candle and put it out they wanted it should burn a certain amount of time why is that in a gaya how much oil you have to put it if it's supposed to burn for 60 seconds you could light a match and let it burn not even 60 seconds 20 seconds generally the time is approximate a half an hour as we will see on that follow from at this so they wanted it should burn for a half an hour hmm so you have to put in enough oil for a half an hour or at least if it burns more they don't care but that's the minimum what happens if cops saw what happens if a wind comes or another reason and it gets extinguished a child runs around and gets it which as we all know happens often or it wasn't burning well whatever was it with their coughs uh rabbuna holds a coke law your must've to light it again as long as it didn't burn through the shear but maila since your muscle youth and if you're not if you don't do it you're missing your mitzvos of locusts now honey can't just say I let it it was far it had oil there to burn it just went out not sucker claw the main listen Sokka claw so therefore you have to use oils and wicks that burn well why because if not what happens if not so let's see Rashi so crash he cuffs an aircon a Kazakh call the sack no Hill cervical cap until the last as he often dilma possible I'm a sock in LA so Rashi says were afraid that if it gets extinguished because it's not burning well the person will you notice of and parsha he'll be negligent will be a little lazy and he won't light it again and he won't be able to do he will not fulfill the Mitzvah of Hanukkah that's what Rashi says dilma possible I miss a comma so that's why make sure it's burning well the first time even in the weekdays we the days of the week days not only Chanukah Shabbos but also hammock in the weakness or mood to establish later they're gonna hold something else you allowed to use the light of Konica for your own needs you want to do work you want to read a book you could use the light of comic the mela on Shabbos you could use the comic of manator since you could use the Hanukkah menorah if you don't have good wicks and good oil so what's gonna happen you may manipulate it on Shabbos or obviously have an extra problem and that is that you will be makalah Shabbos so therefore the bonus said baby oil vein by Shabbos even Hanukkah make sure your Pasillas and SHM on em are doing well that's what the Punahou his dumb - she says Mutola stammers Florida Huxtable shabbos ah sir Shama yah - Latoya - much he may incline he may raclette he may move the Cielo in order to be able to use it for since you're lighter use it so therefore Friday night I may move it around that's the of reppin even if not cuffs on Friday night any night you could use it but any night I don't care if you manipulate the wick so that wouldn't be a mister every night the only reason it's an Easter every night is because cuffs are Zaku claw and make may get extinguished right then yeah you just leave it alone you know your middle of dinner yeah you went to sleep whatever it is and you won't be Mac I'm the Mitzvah goes up Kirkland that's the middle of the week what's my problem Shabbos this job is you have a whole new problem and that is you're gonna want to read Co Co Co I don't read by the comical candles and it's not burning well so you're gonna manipulate it and you're over it either and Miletus of our molasses keyboard either an igniting or extinguish that's a bonus now comes a second opinion his dumber is this says Matt lickin ban but I love a load by Shabbos you can use these wicks and oils that are not of the best fabric and material to burn and the week days of Hanukkah but not Chavez why let's now understand the prison Kasab where he all scoffs a soccer club I'm sorry coughs ah exactly he owes that if it gets extinguished you don't have to light it again so therefore what do I care if you use inferior wicks and inferior oil Saul's I'm the flame gets extinguished you already out amid so as long as it was lighting you will yo to the Mitzvah but Mela if that's the situation I don't care if in the middle of the week they you use similar sense mononym that are not the best however motorless bombers lawyer but you're allowed to use the night light of Hanukkah for your own purposes so they're fun shoppers we have a problem because talk if it gets extinguished you don't have to light it again that's why middle of the week I don't care but I'm Shabbos I'm afraid you're gonna want to read so you want a better flame so you may come to ignite the fire on Shabbos that's the second I'm an absurd I'm Adam a sinner observe a sudden death never imagined a third view of I'm real are Madhav's ADA I'm arrived opposite view silver sushma and shamrock um a matte liquid member Shabbos leakin behan bein Bahama kabane but oil bein be Shabbos all the limitations that we have when it comes to Shabbos does not exist by Hanukkah you can use any type of oil you could use any type of wick whether in middle of the week or the middle of Shabbos and this is the halacha in shelf American Health Islamic a tough race ing mo what's the reason I'm gonna beer me and my time in Iraq what's the reason of RAV cassava yells coughs our aims are cool first of all the old if it gets extinguished you don't have to light it again like rip is de and therefore I don't care if a middle of the week of Connick you young you lose the best wick what's the worst the thing will happen will get extinguished up you won't realize it okay and number two Vasilis famish later rava halogen allah to use the light of Kanaka for your own purposes so what do I care on Shabbos if it's not burning well I'm gonna want to read it you know how to read I'm gonna want to read but you're not allowed you mean it Bates Bates so we assume that he's always fires enough bait to the Comerica say no but it doesn't hold background when he criticized it of carne doesn't hold my ground what do you have to say opponent tell me they did not have how does he tell him that were then it goes that it doesn't go crackling me significant say it when all crackly I'm affricate what's the big deal problem I don't know otherwise you assume that he holds like ground but otherwise if he says of the first he doesn't moment no but over there oh so with their with what does he say he says when they asked a question arrived from the mission and he says she you should like Aaron's office there was his tenets on the name of Ralph so could be that meant could be that man that Reb Hoonah was maintaining the of Ralph the opponent was just to find the of rob this so therefore they assumed that he was not arguing with rav4 here he says he argues the pastas soda but Ave says you're not allowed to use the light the mainland sharpest is also not a problem so there's absolutely no issue so we have a three diss epona sister and finally episode either in the neighborhood have masked on his head of rock seeing the corner agree maybe let you say the who know it was the one who wanted the first version you want coughs uh cook and a similar stomach knew and what would be the halacha then think about it what would be that no no no think about it let's say that luck would be coughs as uh cook so you have to redo it and move us will astonish so then you want to say shop as you're allowed oh right because austere list Amish but Chloe you now loud hookers cuffs us up no Shabbos is tapas is a bigger problem cuz coughs ours uh cook and you're not allowed to touch in coil my problem is cuffs as uh cooking I'm gonna be lazy shop is I'm not gonna be lazy I can't we can't be Mikado Shabbos - like Anika candles and you don't do that come on can tell you to do a mixin Aviva College Shabbos become vas so be the same how Martha you understand so a mailer that one who says he can use a coil and Shabbos that help even if you hold cuffs as Zaku can also you still can't do it on shoppers and I don't cut so the holocaust is only three but you bring up a good question why did I rather give two reasons for the buna he says cassava coughs as aa cook and cassava mutalisk famine just take a summer coughs as a cook once you say cuffs as our cook so exciti call sighs Shabbos for cash that was a much bigger reason cuz he's gonna be McCallum shoppers buffer that actually says the guy is lazy what if to say is lazy what if these are Elysee he's not lazy you say it happens people are that way dolma Porsche but Shabbos the career a much better reason so he has to say it's a whole new verb what may be the corner holds our silver star much lighter we need no further boner that Mutola stomach slider that's a good heart a very good artists at Isis take a look and Isis you see how follow from it all of the last Titus mutalisk Amish lawyer he asks this question the last one on the page the IMP time I mean knowingly rather the suffered opponent the motiveless Thomas later we didn't ever get this Dilma ha the government a matte liquid my Shabbos mission the summer cuffs a sucker cloven y'all collab with the Shabbos that's it you now let alight on shop this so that's why the column said don't use Wix that won't burn well they'll go out Friday night you sitting there and you can't do anything and you want your it's a Hanukkah it's over the Ashley Marceau toasters I'll tell you how and this is very interesting the deal where did it over get this because he listened to the Buddha's words the in pain if the reason they you don't light on Shabbos is the same reason that you don't might inhale meaning cause coughs a sucker claw well I have a Saudis Leyla made my baby girl baby Shabbos Kevon the hard time ooh-hoo Ella Havel a the main my aim my lick and stop for me to call my baby ho baby Shabbos mommy oh yes tom after possibly logic revived me tomba coil highness emma yatta the in case of art moot earliest Amish life the balloon is luster should have been silver Sussman and some Rock'em a mud lickin bamboo Shabbos a Matt listen man Veronica that's it Kanaka I'm not making any qualification specifically no difference when and then I'll understand why because cuffs are so cool and that it could that applies to every one of the eight nights of Hanukkah no different shoppers a weakness why does Ramona start saying bein back oil actually first baby shoppers baby cut wide that distinction just say all of Hanukkah all of Ghana concludes also Chavez is the flare area then a Bruno was trying to say it's two different guitar de Bain but soil is one gadget one reason maybe sharpest is another reason what would be the other reason same reason coughs Isola is the heart that he has to his bonus one is coughs huh za cook and one is bootylicious look at the spammers Lena that so a shop is gives me a new Cashman if it would only be motherless time much lighter and cuff saying sucker claw then only Sabbatini forbidden she has both that's the riot of rubber to the to rip on the D of Bangla shoppers by Muhammad if it's one gathered you don't have to make that distinction why should you shop is is no difference for character purses is even better than comments of that reason that's what I systems now let's go fight their anti service what was the of Wrath the of Rav was that bacillus M&M you're allowed to light on comic even if you know letter use it on Chavez and the reason is why cuz cuffs are a knuckle claw so it's not a problem and therefore I don't care if the Nair gets extinguished he also says us illest Amish law are you ready so therefore even on Shabbos it's not a problem because even though I'm shopping secret it's a problem of schemata there's no issue why cuz us in the summer Ibis I frakked Isis in loves lotion What did he say Dobbs lotion was what was it arms lotion silver Sushma and summer from a mudlick and member sharm bismuth lickin behind the hanukkah bein back i'll baby showers baby oil bamboo Shabbos why does he say bein becau baby Shabbos right me you love the Komarov says laughs says matte liquid been below been brush obviously have a matzo l'm a mom at Lincoln stop RAF couldn't just say mad Lincoln stop why couldn't he say mud licking stomm Harv I mean I would think Daphna because of ABBA Shabbos a medallion Shama yata if Rob would have just said stop mat lickin you might say when is that only bahut but on Shabbos is another husband because even if cough saying sukuk Lord is a problem of Shama yata so even though if we just say my lick the pastor's you would say it's size coil size Shabbos but nonetheless Matata svarga you would say Shabbos you now louder because schemata so therefore you're gonna say it's only cut the best umba lawyer ECI mission Adam Yauch with less and less damage Lloyd as long as I don't hear it clearly I wouldn't say that you now that he use the light of Hanukkah candles so mainly if you hold multimers damage bonus so then you can't use it on Shabbos because Shunyata so we would say my lickin means only foil not Chavez so that's why now has to say clearly my lincoln member Club members Shabbos what does theis was trying to say here you build a whole case you built the whole case that of Hoonah said Ben Massell Bemba Shabbos ain't my lickin and from that we prove that it's two separate reasons he says officers the same washing Rob says the same washin and the positive Matt lickin members called member shaunb us and he didn't have to he could have just said just mud leakin where mail is the food it's not so true you cite sometimes he says no because if he wouldn't say it we would go and say my lincoln is only call not Shabbos because it would be absurd because it is to say that you know that he used the odor of Hanukkah Shabbos is absolutely no problem he would say he means only because of chiapas there's a problem of some a Opta just like there is for Shabbos candles so he also has to say both toaster says the same and this is the halacha he goes not Allah the same Hill sister what's the halacha the ner comic established Amish loiter Corral you now let me use the light of Hanukkah like Ralph jeez these Ian's only people like homeless because they feel like holy yep he says with a hostess of the near time the customers later Qaddafi what could it be open up will see the bureau and hold the same thing and we're gonna see a by UNAMI Qibla by by UNAMI Qibla i by you also agreed this with abusive nami marshmallon this riddle a huffy the mela taster says that losses like this and therefore Shabbos you're allowed to use it what about the second issue and that luck is also cuffs r8 the cuffs are aimed sukuk law the Kumu sweet allah hafiz over miriam in our sugar which means all you need to please derive not Ramona old cuffs in some Googler so it's the majority with abouna you often do the less he'll Christa covers say so tasters gives us the halacha it's not like the moon because the moon is the minority so pleased and revolt cuffs in soccer club what about us or Moodle astonished lawyer to look under why this Rav win he's also the minority the banana prefers to disagree that serious cuz rob has the support of many others which makes them the majority so Tyson says that law is established Amish learn and I love his cuffs a sock o'clock and that's why that look at our control honora's is you could use all the wicks and oils because you're not gonna come to read on we read with it on Shabbos and cuffs are ain't you you you don't have to you don't have to it's good - it's good - but you don't have to and you don't make a profit therefore and you don't make a bra know that gonna cap it didn't catch my lit for a second I'm Amish a second you're saying you mean if it was a fool's burning no sometimes you know that it doesn't you hold the match enough so that it wasn't burned anyone out shall have a sailor man you need to shall have Isola may Allah yeah she loved a said the man yeah that's random there's a slaughter like that would be a smaller on this many possible also it's not always because he's not burning the run sometimes because of the smell sometimes because of this yeah then we said this shaming you can use it because he's not cover Chavez because of the smell but he burns very good well you can't use it on Hanukkah even if you said that for those the thing no he means talking with said that card on the final I would think I would say the hello future of America the beginning of the game of those all oils and wicks arkasha for sonic even though the oils do not follow the wick and the fire is not good is not connected well to the Winx however there are moss says the midterm and a muffler is to use olive oil which of course you don't have to it's the myth swim in a move curve but if you don't have olive oil use any oil that is good and over here he says in Eastern Europe in the Krakow and his Medina stay use native soul shy Verbeck scandals because the oil is as beautiful and as clear as oil even Shabbos you can use anything they're conic even the finality who's it for near Shabbos and because you know letter using their Hanukkah side Shabbos I call you now let's check money you now let account money and I'll gonna do you not to learn and therefore it is it is us turn that so we light another name so if you lose using the eyelid as we know you you it should be to the extra light and put it a little far from the other neighbors mitzvah and there I must speak sir about the shamans okay so that's basically the hollow huh and if cuffs are before this man passed a muzaka claw you don't have to lie even if it extinguish dead of Shabbos before couple of Shabbos it's still Shabbos the layer of Shabbos you don't have to re relighted if you want to be marksman and do it that's fine but don't make up another bra right was your fault it was live it was your fault just like the wind without protection it's right right the Mishna Brewer brings from the poisk um if somebody lights a monoid aware it's windy so it goes out right away he says you have to relight it in a place where it's not windy because this is like you didn't put an oil you didn't put an oil enough oil to burn you say oh I let it know you lit it and you know it's going out so tiller your HUD locker wasn't the way it was supposed to be he says don't make a second brothel don't make a second one he says vital he says if you see that the light never caught on to the wick it's burning but it never caught on so you know in a minute it's gonna be out you weren't here to with this HUD locker and therefore how logical you have to relight it after it gets experience because again it's not that the halacha was good you put in the chemin LMI something happened later how'd the locker wasn't kidded Bowie you didn't have enough oil you put in a windy place he'll it never caught on to the wick I had burned for 20 seconds that's not called it burnt if what go make another brothel I don't think so now the camera tells an interesting story something come uninvited so toy service gives us the halacha that luckily the third - like route i'm Ruairi Bannen kamehameha which made it a beer mia the rabbi's came they came to our buyer and they said over the explanation of the beer Mia - abaya and the name remembered of year me explained the reason of rob that what cuffs saint-jacques o'clock and also list Amish law you know so they set this over to our body electively didn't accept it he didn't accept what the burma is sentient kiosks are often when Robin came to bother I'm lured a bun and comida by mesh material kana they said over the same vert in the name of regulation and explaining the of Ralf the Qiblah a body accepted he relied on to be O'Connor Robin was one of them Iranian for mayor to Cyril who would travel from register all to bubble and back so he gave over a lot of traditions back and forth so Robin gave it over from the VA - so the buyer said mama Ramaiah said 'yes Akari if I would have had a sauce c'mere Tillis might to me Carla I would have learned this I would have incorporated this to this I lost initially in other words if I would have had a schools I would have accepted the words of Revere Mia explaining Rob but I rejected it dragging a mother who cares Valdemar at the end he learnt it he accepted it for the Gemara nasca manila gears to the young casa the difference is the learning that you do when you're young the learning that you do when you're young remains with you forever so a buyer was upset that this heart he didn't accept when he was young it never became part of him when he heard it he was already much older said it's already not the same old old then with everything is relative name 70 give me the gum on rosh hashanah a by n rava no no no no rubber was phoria by our citizens by over 60 Mira Shoshana Duffy's husband a a Lima schmuck available by it was 60 there wasn't considered so young that today it's wrong but then 60 wasn't so young yeah home such gears are the youngest of a sufficient people also become teenagers at seven so I've said advice they didn't have the sauce to be Makabe this Vaart when he was younger from yes doesn't say master that way now she says is a car you know he sees a solenoid a cigar circus Marty edition gear City Uncas Emma Skye a Mesa missiles it okay stahma Harada the first earn a solenoid the pista says that cuffs in soccer club Ultima stomach slider so therefore a pista says because of that it's not a problem you could Matt lickin man-sized my urban often Shabbos why with his cuffs as a new cook but nonetheless motiveless timers latest sharpest is a problem even a piss de la fighter who says babe it's all been with shoppers let's say you hold cuffs saying soccer club those Ines like but everyone holds that native sonica have to burn like a pillar the sheared of a half an hour so if so why didn't they ask their bad oil or bad wigs because it's gonna get extinguished before a half an hour it's all signed coughs a in soccer so you don't have to rely Dan even didn't like the damage but everybody holds the unique Shemin cashier of a half an hour so if you know that it's a situation and it's not gonna burn Fran for now with that should be there sir except even if a soccer that's literally the Schuyler what's de Voort aims up but still they should have a siddhis Pasillas inch mama so the Mufasa brief advice lav miss Olivia was the first first the father of the dynasty of brisk with your vessel of a trick the father for kindness the Bissell abusive David Levy the rub of and then the Rav of brisk the Bissell lady writes that the shot from a youtuber is a shot rocket we're not talking here about a wick like the mission the brewery brings you put in a windy place it's not survived it's a funny wick it's royal it's gonna burn it's not that we're it's a common thing that every candle or every other candles gonna get extinguished it's a charge it can happen because it's not the best it can happen but that's not a sash that we're worried about so rep who know who halts that have cuffs on Zaku claw were afraid that if it happens he may not light it again and therefore he makes sure you now let her use it but app is that rival hole that even if it gets extinguish you don't have to light it again we don't have to be harsh for the roshambo user but that's not a shock so therefore I don't care if you use it because I'm not afraid it's gonna get extinguished and therefore why do you let him do it he could do it but it could get caught it could get little burn so and if that happens it's za cook so if your holds a book then I'm afraid but if you hold things up with what's the problem what's the problem that you can't do it now why it's likely to happen and if it end of it and it's likely that it's gonna burn and if cough sir okay you didn't lose anything because I hold eggs up but if I hope salt cook then I am afraid taco won't happen maybe but if it happens it happens but according to them Fame something even if it happens there's no problem that's all he understands and I might have come in because if you know that it's a wick that it's not burning but to the mission of burners says then talk or not it's not like he's talking about take a wick it's gonna burn for 20 seconds then it's like you didn't put in chemin so that's an important idea cuz people don't realize cuffs ends up if they think it burns Bette said boom no it has to be something that the normal things are Brandon Alba Shawn if something happens fine in soccer that's the math come in here it's not some of our cuffs or soccer good we don't care about it if there's our shot card of that it's gonna get extinguished they would have I said it it's not a shock collar was a shock and a knock so there's no issue my schenken Ramona Holtz parker sar avec but if it happens you were yes sir because he may not ride it again so therefore they made it they made this do something about a fight the cuffs are in Saco claw really Taverner please the hold ain't so clever damn into I'll ask you a Schuyler trial is we learned Mitzvah so the Mitzvah but lucaswnash amicus mishit ishka comma from the time when the Sun sets at satisha Larry Gilman Ashoka until the last leg goes away titla goes away from the marketplace meaningless nightfall when the street market gets emptied out of the last people because there's no business going on at night in the pitch darkness no nightlife that's what the bright success from skier says how much a tickler Grenache my love what does this mean doesn't it mean that it has to burn from skiers a comma until terminus of the cuffs are the mat liquor if it got extinguished before this time you have to light it again when the browser says MIT's Vasa from sheer tilt is Loretta Manoj shocked how do you understand it that's when it has to burn and if it doesn't burn that time you have to read you can hide it so how can it up his the area of argue with this but Isis so come on it says not what you understood misunderstood at the Eloi ad League mudlick he's not talking about that it has to burn till then and if not you won't go to the Mitzvah he means this is the shear told when you could like Hanukkah candles if you didn't light by she is a comma you could light a particular element of sugar afterwards at this stage it seems like you can't light that's the vote but you don't have a value from the price of that of coughs aw so cook law that you don't have a right enemy a second way to learn the prices Lisi order not like the first way the Shira what Shira the sheer of the oil that I have to put into my cops in order to burn the sheer it has to be from skier such a person she is a common thug of ownership but it doesn't say that if cuffs are Jo Copeland we understood the Bryce omits Lawson means it has to burn till then in reality and if it doesn't burn told you have to relight it suck Okla see since now I really can learn the price that is talking about till when you could do the Mitzvah after that you can't do Mitzvah stomach anymore it's mine is over right that's one way of learning it or not another way of learning it is how much oil I have to put in it should last that time but that's add in and how I light it not in how I how much it burns and if it gets extinguished things are good so we don't have a stinner through the price of course if Hoonah would learn the price like he wants to learn it right that coughs is a coke law that's well he would learn the glass but rather the prisoner don't have a problem with the price because you can learn the blacks are differently well the question is what does it mean Misha tishka hakama ox articulated Russian what does mr. tisk economy from sunset what what's at sunset doesn't mean like many who shine em say from the end of skier Misha tishka , means from where after the Sun sets after the end of this man of science we would call say circa cover when the stars come out that's one orphan that's the of the rush at the of the tourist potential Honora examine the fisheye base I mean that but what's this man of Chanukah candles this man of conical candles is and tastes like a coffin nightfall then there's the of the girl the finger of the Vilna Gaon the Misha tishka comma means no from the beginning of skier from this man of skier the old something else that is Jonathan it ah no no no this man about Lucas Neff hammock is right after the Sun disappears from the horizon yes yes right so the the the the the macabre initial analysis the first thing he says that you like Chanukah candles not before scarce a comedy light by so Vyasa so she also means the end of skiers our Karma meaning when it finishes setting and it stays like a government's dark when it finishes setting and and and you have to have oil filter clergymen are shocked the Vilna Gaon holds beer a Groucho Canara he says no it's right by the beginning of Shakya the moment the Sun sets the ball of its the light outside because there's a still a lot of life like right right my skier yeah if she is it's 4:30 that's this man of this monopod look is no comment it starts it starts much earlier starts much earlier than end the same way right and then you have a third it was a of the rajma and iran and that is which Atisha car camera is the beginning of the second sphere right the beginning of the second which would be around a quarter of an hour before say circa cover so you have really three skiers it's three jitesh comet a second cover we should tishka comma right the beginning of skier which could be 40 minutes before 30 40 minutes before and then you have them in the middle then at the beginning of the second ski which is a quarter of an hour before take a combo no it has to be a particular Illuminati demoys and I'm gonna discuss what's the cargo - oh like the Vilna Gaon that happens to be that de Ville McGann and about here and agreed like it like like in many other areas also so near common could you have a manager before skier and right after ski you go like before - the first ski a right after school it's still very light outside it's still very light outside but it's after ski after sunset mission accom but others like the Sahara clearly says taste like a car doesn't someone Chrisman everything else oh right if it's highly it seems from the commodity the first chapter but I see Eloy a bleak mutlaq do you can't write all night okay so take a look in enticed vus delay I'd lick my lick I've only come to the ælis Alvarez monde after this it's all over are you marrying her reap itís the ash lizard will have big ball island me odd shall I yeah after you see me die don't delay it if you don't mind right away at night you may not do the mitzvah Oh Macomber comes a crisis in is there God let me Suffolk if you come home lay you should still light miss Suffolk what's the Suffolk mashanda she New York arena cuz the commander gave a second shot to my son the camera gave to be shut up in the price the one shot was you can't light afterwards another shot is no you have to put enough oil to burn that time but afterwards you could still light she says depends so therefore you should like - optical Lavinia the octane lockers most erotic in our days this is the Reese peaking right 12th century 13th century there's no difference why the on new a la una caída other the Binet abayas name I'd look into thing as we will see near Kanaka went through a drastic transformation in the time of the gomorian time with a based on mikdash when they made Hanukkah and for hundreds of years afterwards everybody lid outside the menorah was outdoors not endorsed it was all changed he says after we burned inside if we put it inside the whole Vaart of the Gemara is that the monoid is really being light for the outer loop england for the outside world the moment tickler has I'm gonna smoke streets are empty right the streets are completely empty but today he says who are you doing it for the B'nai abayas no they're not running away ten o'clock eleven o'clock at night they're still there so what do I care if you like later so do you need but Klaus says the whole outlook does not make a now even if that's kept in the price but Magana because there's a market changed if you want to sell very hot Sacco's did he is talking about the 1200 to 1300 when there was still no nightlife today in America when many people wake up at night and the whole outside were hoped not Muncie maybe but you go to Manhattan suddenly everybody's alive at night so then even late at night you have a big personal meanness there's no difference I'm not changing that locker what like me my TV point is you should have make a broth with only a less often correct you know if you add litmus Suffolk but you can't make a bracket a colloid did you could make a broth that would be the filling that would be the same like you could make a broth so toaster says the past isn't the Gemara is like okay don't mind it's over vicious unattended you didn't belong chef you don't go show for some good dial you know you don't eat max a lot boy Amen cause he didn't need much some pace that's right it's over it's over so there so the lead pilot says do it anyway why because it's not so clear that it's over because the gomora gives a second answer and then ty suicides Dominion to make a new one apparently they learned that it wasn't a dimly kuva it was it was well understood get tomorrow is up there was the midst of a muffler wasn't a dimly cookin it was a didn't leak over you're right if that's the Takano is open to making a new Hanukkah it was an interesting change that question is about too strong kiss love is not warm right so how exactly was it supposed to burn there's people that I just saw the light outdoors even me yeah we must everybody outdoors so the family comes outside okay colors a good margin of olive on wood base the line starts at reticular degelman a shook right the line before that starts low the Eloi I'd look model agree na mila Shira I'm not around 10 or 15 watts around 10 or 15 lines from the top the line towards the launch sites I particularly germane are shook vodka mo so what happened the Gemara tried to contradict or question the position that cuffs ain't sucker claw if my candle of Chanukah gets extinguished I am not obligated to reignite it even though it went out before it burnt the full time as long as I lit it the way I was supposed to line it look all you know we have a clip riser that says and maintains that there is the Mitzvah of Hanukkah is from sunset until the last people the last person leaves the marketplace which we understand to mean that what that it has to burn till then and if it doesn't burn till then you're responsible so the governor gave two other possible interpretations no that's talking about the time when you could light it initially you can only light it till the time when the feet last foot leaves the marketplace and another interpretation is no you can actually light it whenever you want during the night it just tells you the sheer how long does it have to be lit for it in other words how much oil do I have to put in initially that it should burn once I do that I'm good because the had luck was a good locker I lit it in the proper way for the proper amount of time based on what I did what happens now after my actions that I'm not responsible for somebody comes and extinguishes it something happens whatever it is cuffs are a zocalo so that is how the gomorrha reconciled this position with the browser and therefore there's no proof to the Horner rejecting and no proof rejecting his de and rejecting wrath now here it's important to emphasize dialogue we learnt I Swiss and toys for says that the two answers in the Gemara are not just two possible answers there's a huge argument between the two answers because according to the first answer even once called Sir Eagleman Ashok once is nobody in the marketplace I kept my Tomica candles anymore the time of lighting candles is over that's what I see ourselves according to the second interpretation no you could light that time is only about the quantity of oil that you have to put in that it should burn for the amount of time which is from sunset I particularly governor shook which as we will see is approximately 30 minutes a half an hour but if you like later if you light 11 o'clock at night it's still fine as long as you put an oil for a half an hour so therefore the second answer in the Brice argues with the first answer and that's why toys reset that looks a killer you have to light in the time between skiers are calm assertive irregular shook but if you did not you came home late so then miss Suffolk you have to light after that time because perhaps the halacha is like the second dance then they retried to say that maybe these days but growl the whole issue is different it doesn't apply because we're lighting inside and if you're lining inside your family as long as they're around it's fine now Liholiho the sequential Vanara is that till dawn break till ELISA Shekhar a person could light Hanukkah candles and make up if people of the family are up and therefore there's a pearson there's a publicity to the miracle like Titus argues at the end so even if I come home three o'clock in the morning from a business trip or very late at the office and my wife is up my child is up I could light and light till dawn break with a brockett's now call the brothel of atala of course if nobody is up then you have the problem of toys for saying that there's no personal minister so now you're left with the two interpretations in the bracer so now it's much out of Suffolk someone's out of Suffolk what do you say Suffolk brothers locals are therefore you would do it but you don't make huh right you mean even if nobody's up no toaster says oh right right that's why you can make a broth oh but sub that you said that okay so that's the suger we okay it's a cater for the bionaire bye sir yeah they could be back here my wife has for life wasn't in a place where I could light like a match you know she should like you lit in the room but in the normal place right database now of course even when we're lighting in the house you still need the shear of oil and the candle that it should be able to burn the shears man from the Shakya articular degelman a shook which again is approximately a half an hour suck the Gemara action tickler degelman ah shook what does that mean until the foot the red girl the last foot the last leg leaves the marketplace at comma what does that mean what how long is that that you say that that's the time when the last leg left the marketplace I'm Arab I'm Arab American American so robbed at the son of our connoisseur in the name written on ad the failure riku the tire modo what this means is until the rig regolith legs the feet of a nation of a tribe called time would die oh it's gone from the market that is the shear that we're talking about so - he says what's shot rag gudetama die shame uma thurman oh he was a name of a tribe Malak they ate some Dakin they used to gather thin chips of wood who miss acumen be shook they would remain in the marketplace Absaroka by now Shukla battalion mashenka shaker oom I've eaten the bottom oil until everyone working in the market would go home because of sunset when it was dark and of course there's no electricity everybody would have to light a fire in the house to be able to function and live because if not it's pitch-dark unless you're going straight to bed the homes would have wood where they were light a fire and they would wait in the marketplace it simulates and people are home and they realize they don't have wood or they don't have enough wood that they don't have good word the word got wet what do they do yeah it's in they go out because I need wood but it's already dark the coin in my hand and they would buy from them so as long in other words that you have still this year I am the last people that hang out in the market even though it got dark already why are they there because they need to be there cause it's an opportunity for business for the people who decide now I need a fire because it's dark and I don't have wood or whatever it is I have a situation so they go out as long as they're in the marketplace like Hanukkah candles or according to the second interpretation in the Gemara the shear is till they leave so from skiers Akama all the way till it's dark and after it's dark until they hang out on the market you are good now of course for the time of the Gemara when they were familiar with these people in the marketplace this was a significant practical this was a practical shear because it was like as long as they're around you're good to go right so the Rambam rights to different the number right that basically there Derek was to remain a half an hour after from sunset there Derek was to remain a half an hour from Silesia Hama so that's why according to this the shears man of their hard luck the shears man about luck is basically a half an hour after ski us ha comma this is what the riff and the Rambam says so but mela that's this year that they estimate the Gomorra means so if you say that it's of course the question is what's mishit ich komm that's an important question right what do you say Oh so we said one Indochina MS Mr Scott Rama is the end of skia when the skia period is over in other words a second cover that's when you start actually to clear argument I shook a half an hour later because as long as according to this as long as she is still around other than after sunset it's the light outside we notice that the government still quite like the ball of the Sun is not present but the light of the Sun is present so according to this the earlier name the light of the camera candles is not recognizable and therefore it's not as man of Chanukah that's the of many restrain him and that's the in torrential Canora that's the classic inshallah Nara that this man begins by say socket cover however as we said the beer hugger ah and it seems that way to Eddie to say Rambam that Misha tishka come as much earlier in which the Trischka come as what from the beginning of schpeel the beginning of sunset right of sunset is 4:10 that's this man that's a circle of them it's a big difference to be it there and itself could be a difference of 30 40 minutes right between ski and sex could I like Hanukkah candles right by ski I dive in menisci it comes for 10 I could like candles even though it's quite light outside so that's the second that's a second to that that's this man of and then actually the Cuyahoga the Commodore would mean a half an hour from them and then there is they'd have a mighty bow so you know right right and then there's those who say that it's the beginning of the second skier which would mean as I said a quarter of an hour before tastes like a cover but Lakota alma it's a d'Italia degelman are shook which most titles are half an hour from them and that's the shear of Hadlock 0.2 the two interpretations either you can't like chemical candles after that or that's the amount of oil you have to put so it's a de Callier regular the tar mood is not as itself says from says the time to start yeah but the evidence that you'd said but but this man but this man of course a Shabbos we anyway I have to I mean out of jobs we can't do that we can't even do the first set we can't even do this off from skier because Shabbos so then you have to go with the be ever that if you do it from plug harmonica which would be of course an hour and a quarter before sunset for example if sunset would be six o'clock those nights that it's mom or six o'clock that would be 4:45 of course in most cases it's not that way so exact but it's an hour and a quarter before skier and an hour and a quarter we don't mean 60 minutes plus 15 minutes we mean an hour and a quarter that you divide the day into 12 equal hours and an hour of that and a quarter of that is called pockemon huh so if you lit from plug a mannequin on new yes yes octagon motivator Tonya Bonham the rabbi is taught mitzvahs Hanukkah and nave issue baser the mitzvah of Hanukkah who was the midst of an account what's the Mitzvah now we have to define it so the Mitzvah is name it's a candle issue basic for a man and his entire family in other words there's a common instituted that for eight nights of Hanukkah every single Jew lights one candle every night that's it and you fulfill the mitzvot poor family issue base in others my whole family fulfills the mitzvot through this one candle per family man and his family the father and the family and it's one candle every night that's it that's the Mitzvah waha Mehadrin then the woman of course just like the other way around when it comes to Shabbos candles right this is the woman is not doing it the man has to do it varma hadron those who are Mehadrin Mehadrin what's up shot varma hoddan so it's interesting we say the word Heder Mitzvah right by Mahad if you take a look at her she now she says name issue base near Quebec Oh Lila the ich the whole Binet base is saga Luminara heart per family one candle is enough each night varma hadron that is about Mehadrin after her mitzvahs those are Mahathir after mitzvahs which gives us a Titan what Mehadrin is in Aramaic Mehadrin means to pursue like we say the end of a messiah Hydra no lock myself debates all right or how to know luck whatever my sector with me I'm gonna return to you I'm gonna pursue you I'm not finished and closing the book I'm never gonna see you again I'm coming back so Mehadrin means that you who pursues the mitzvot he's eager for the midst he's running after the mitzvot in other words he's not just interested in getting it done he wants to do it in the most wholesome way so vie Mehadrin those who pursue the mitzvahs and they're eager to perform it in the best way there's another way of doing it and that is nail the collective effort one candle for each member of the family so if there are eight people in this family it is the husband and the wife and six children so then eight candles every single night the same amount every night but not issue-based say which is the the minimum way of doing the mitzvot but there's the better way of during the midst and that is each member of the family gets one candle a night like Rashi says I Mahajan are mitzvos Orson Arabic all isla the call echoed McNab eyes again it's one candle each night if you're alone in the house it's one candle each night if it's two people in the house is two candles each night based on the member the the number of the family members that is Mehadrin I should just say Rashi here says I Mehadrin Acura mitzvos in the commentary of Rashi on the reef he touches Mehadrin he says Mehadrin s ha mitzvah not Mehadrin acura mitzvahs Mehadrin esse mitzvah that's a big difference it seems like he's tithing Mehadrin is from the word 3/8 Hodder not Mehadrin i pursue the mitzvah Mehadrin i beautify the Mitzvah secondly one value i beautify from the word ha door Heder mitzvah means a beautiful mitzvah not pursuing the Mitzvah therefore it's not Mehadrin after a mitzvah beautifying after the midsummer Mehadrin estimates you beautify the Mitzvah with Mehadrin means pursuing you say I pursue I follow the Mitzvah I go after them it's I run after the Mitzvah so it's two interpretations of how you touched my hand and it's they're interesting because of the two to two different ashes I'll cope on him so when we have a situation of Mehadrin everyone likes one candle now the interesting thing is you have a third category if I Mehadrin minima hydron those who really love them it's those who really want to beautify the midst I'm gonna do it in the most perfected way here you light candles corresponding to the days of Hanukkah every single night gets a different number of candles but on here there's an argument what Mahad Romina Mahajan is this is already an argument based shamayim me be shy my time is your ammunition the first day I've kind of come out looks many lighted candles in the conve left places void and from here and on you decrease each day one candle so the first night you did ate the second I did at 7:00 the third night you do 6 and the last night at last you do want solenoid name the house of Hillel says no your ammunition the first day Matt Leacock as you liked want become they look from here and onward most of all if you increase each night one more candle and finally on the eighth night you light eight candles so on my heart on the regular classic Mitzvahed one candle per night for the whole family Mehadrin is one candle for each member of the family every single night the same way so if we're eight and the family we're lighting eight candles every night if we're two in the family - candles every night Mehadrin min imagine now you change the number of candles per night based on which night of Chanukah tis but there's an argument by Xiaomi says you start with eight and you go down bacillus as you start with one and you go up until you reach the crescendo the combination which is eight that's what the game owner says a trashy by Mehadrin okay haha commit suicide in Arabic Allah Allah collected retinol now bias now here we have the gamora's interpretation what would be this Vajrasana Lycus why do we sell them at Chaminade chuckling tomorrow Omar Allah Allah set clicky but today I'm a driver my rava - I'm Miriam in the West have an argument about this now of course Ulla was speaking in bubble and Babylonia which is present-day Iraq so when he said my Rover he's referring to air it's a straw which is on the west of Iraq Iraq is to the east of Israel so to our morale iam living in the West have an argument who are these people the POC bar of him and Rubio you see bars evade the 2wo he sees with different father right so we'll see choiceless good question good the yoke so we'll see in a moment we'll go to Toys R Us in a moment so to our uranium argue in the West Rebbe I see Vera Verna be abuzz with Cod Omar what's the argument they're not argument then they're arguing in the reasoning they're not arguing what Bashar Mian vasila said everyone knows they want to understand the reason Kadam are one says I'm emphasizing this because this is an interesting argument in Kamara usually the argument is the halacha what to do they're not arguing about how lava and then argument the views they're arguing to understand why which is an interesting argument but as we shall see that it's not such an abstract argument it's also a practical argument but let's not jump ahead of ourselves let's see what they say God Omar one says time at the Bashar my connected young woman I cannot see the logic of a Shama is he says we have to look at the days that are still coming in the days that stand to enter in other words you have to light for the future for the days of Chanukah that still have to come in that are still going to come to be celebrated this year so the first night of Hanukkah what do I have from Hanukkah left coming I have eight I just started the first night I still have it the whole day right because the first day is not finished yet and then after that have another seven days coming cuz I like eight the second night what do I have left of Chanukah I have tonight is the second night and I'm gonna have another six afterwards I have seven the third night right two are gone so Mela have tonight plus I have another five so I have six I have three sources have six and then finally the last night of Chanukah what do I have I have one day coming young amount of Colossus and everything left I have one night left one day of high right one candle that's young man exhaustion they say a little time at the Basilica never my oats vasila says no the focus should be none of the days that are coming but on the days that left the days that are going out the days that were already experienced on Hanukkah the first night I have a little bit of the first night of Hanukkah sigh like one can the second I have already one day that left plus I have the beginning of a second day that's starting to leave I have it already a little at least a few minutes into the day I'm lighting candle and into the night of mining candles so maila have to in the last night I have eight days that is a night light eight that's one way of looking at it as Rashi says young a man is now somehow Sydenham lava elements in shiatsu Kivar possession I meant by nimnim is that's the key the day that you're now celebrating is called the Olsson because the first night you lighting one can the didn't leave yet but that's called already a day that left because you have already part of it that's one view atom or another view is time at the base Shama can I get party her hoc the reason of my Shama is he compares the hollow kiss of Chanukah to the hollowness of Parihaka Perry a frog means the Bulls of the yom tov circus which the toyota says in parishes Pintrest that every single day they had to bring a special carbon for circus but the number decreased from the previous day the first day of suckers you brought 13 12 11 10 9 8 on her shine Arab at the 7th day of circus you brought 7 balls and that was at Romania Terrace pie record you just went to one ball so the process was posters of a challah he went downwards they Shammai says Chanukah which is also eight days happens to be like circus was instituted in the same style at para ha ha the time in the basil--oh what would be the bacillus reason the myelin becau it is very married when it comes to condition when it comes to holiness you increase and you don't decrease therefore I like tonight one candle tomorrow I don't like less tomorrow I like more I certainly don't do 8 7 6 Milan because this for sure for sure aim we did it but even more Milan because it for sure in Meriden that's the second way of understanding the civils should the kimono says I'm Arab a Bahaman of Johanna Robert the son of a connoisseur and the neighbor of your enemies they scan a mall you but see them there were two elderly sages in two elderly men in the city of Sidon and artisan ekadasi kadubic Shama one of them followed the words of Bashar my when it came to Chanukah candles the eckhart also could do BB Silla and one followed by Silla then noise and omelet var of the one who followed by Shama gave a logic for his behavior he said can I get back I'm following the system of circus you'd go down there and the other sock you know followed missile noise in town with what if he gives a reason to his words Milan because this rain may did so the bureau action was basically test to find that these two skein and maintain the second view in the McCoy because between by shamim basil--oh and that is if it's party our cargo Milan because my knife came in okay one second so let's see Rashi parry a card miss Martin Vulcan cubic our bonus the parsha spinners Milan because this rain were hidden McRoy our pin and lobby monocular paydex they have left them that introduced so you go up and you don't go down now look lady asking a good question what would be the difference between this view and that view so let's see for a moment Isis which will clarify one of the differences place who says I'm a Hydra minima hundred let's remember what did the Gomorrah say classic mitzvah Hanukkah is one candle per night for the whole family even if there's thirty people in the house one candle every night Mehadrin every member of the family one cat of his 30 people in the family living in the house 30 candles every night same that same same number how do you mean a Mehadrin is every night it changes based on the number of the Knights either going to be some according to missile choiceless has a very interesting question his Mahajan minima Hadron ahem Chester Mehadrin or his Mehadrin minute Mehadrin I Hampshire today issue Basin does my husband know Matt mean I'm adding leap over my hard work and say you can or Mehadrin will just do a new type of hitter which is even better or no it takes into consideration the first hitter and builds on that so toaster says need led the bechamel basilar like Amy L on a ensure basin the argument of a shaman and this little only applies if you're following the classic way of Chanukah which is each family gets one candle and now they argue I wanna do my abdomen ah Mahajan I'm lighting one candle per night for the entire family that's the classic mitzvah comes basil--oh says you want to do it the nice way the first night light one taka the second night light to the last night light eight increase it over sama says the other way around but it's always one per family the second night two per family the third night three per family or going to be Shama eight per family seven per family six Y chicane yes yes sir he door because this way there will be more hidden mitzvot the EK akhirah it's recognizable Kshama safar learn when the person is adding candles based on the nights or even faster is going down according to mr. Bashar my show connected young man a slow simmer how I said I could see Oh last night there was one tonight this too why because you have two nights of comic or last night's there were eight because there's eight days left tonight is seven cuz the seven days left it's clear I've really moist and nail the color but if you're gonna do the Mehadrin and you're gonna light a candle for each member of the family a filler McConville ale if you're gonna start adding now more candles the second night the third night Lecky akkada there's no Hecker there's no recognition that you're celebrating the number of days she used brew anybody who comes in will think shikaka has been either my bias you have more people in the house of course you added candles so therefore toys for says the only way Muharram and I Mahajan will work is if you keep it to one per family and now there's supposed to be one the second night is to the third night is 3 the last night there's 8 ah yum and my oats and all coins to be Shami the other way around but if we have said 10 people in the family so the first night you want to say you should light tent to 2nd night what are you gonna light you're gonna light 20 right why are you gonna light 20 because you're adding everyone is doing another to the 3rd times you're gonna like 30 the last night you're gonna be lighting 80 candles twice the size so 80 people moved into the house and I think you're gonna think that so many babies were added during Hanukkah but 80 people moved into the house you have guests whatever it is there's no heck hear that what does 80 candles have to do with eight days of Hanukkah and what happens if it's whatever it is right you have three people in the house or the first night is three the second night is six the third night is nine was if do with the third night of chronic and nine candles there's no heck you're for Hanukkah not Accord to be Chaminade according to basil--oh so the REE is Mossad ish that Mahajan minima hydrants skips over Mahajan you don't do Mahajan if you want to do the best way forget lighting for each member of the family that's the yeah but it always matches the day so it's a funny and cool it's a funny coincidence it always matches the days of Hanukkah so you're good pump the fourth night of Hanukkah four people moved in poop the fifth like a five people moved in I mean this is a really organized house in the nineteen ninety nine nine people move it it's always matching the day if you're going according to the members of the family one side will match the names I'm gonna match the day right I have two people in the family the second item item for candles what even I think he means even a cater to the people they're gonna have to do alumnus there's nine candles cuz the third night of Hanukkah but it's alumnus even the people themselves right however if you have one monoid of per family like by us let's say you think practically of one manator see one candle two candles three it's right away fourth - ramicus four candles you have a bunch of monotonous right a bunch of my eyes and they're not separate from each other a bunch of my notice together yes and now you have a face 100 candles okay so the eighth night of Chanukah 100 candles you're not accomplishing defeat places if you want to do my heart and imagine if you want do my heart minima husband is not my hundred skippers separate my notice it's just candles candles candles every Midnighter has that quality every miner has that quality right correct right now now now now here's an interesting thing the Rambam and hoses can occur when he pass can't scan pletely different than tasters Raman quotes the Gemara of course mitzvahs kanakas nadyusha basa Mehadrin every one of the family every member of the family does it Mehadrin minima hydron every member of the family adds every night clearly the Rambam completely disagrees with Josephus and says mahadji Manama hydron follows my hydrant and builds on Mehadrin and here the halacha we have a very interesting phenomenon to show sonora the Shulchan Aruch of the macabre no hispanica pass construct Isis there are ma ads over there that the mimic Porsche at the mojave minima Hadron like the Rambam that every member of the family has every night so the tars right intial Honora that here we have a hidden halakhah that is fired the mccaskin like toy service and Ashkenazim poskim like the Rambam this party the macabre of soccer Nora was as fired in abusive Cairo was a Spanish boy left Spain he went it's fast he wrote the South America the 1500s he was for the contemporary of the Rizal of reply meet all of the base Joseph's reply mal cupboards the Doyle is the gorilla glass Talmud of the Mari Bhairav there are mock remark Rivera the whole group of the you know buried in the old cemetery of Swanson on the forum with the blue he was aspired he usually he follows the Derek of the smart their arm of course was the rough of croc Arab mr. lurch the quintessential Ashkenazi Eastern European Jew who came from ashkenaz the restaurant was 203 and took the majority and right no so that so but it's not clear but but the pile mama she says despite them I know you'd like - gonna zoom in other words like toys fists war of course Ashkenazim this is the family of Rashi who came from France and then Germany Russia she was in France this is Ashkenazim and thus far there were no Vatican azam and - canasa are no York like Dominica us fired them which was around the houses here you have a finish in Halawa because there am bob hoskins so that's what we mean that's we do what we do which is basically a round bomb in other words people who will do the Mehadrin that every people person of the family lights the father and the children and the boys and so forth so everyone adds in the candle every night one per family one per family one minute per family in your admin no Ashkenazim oh you make a lion come on him okay what you're not you're the real thing you're the real thing the thoughts of Rd Tahara I passed by D tau but here you have so here you have an interesting voice Dupree cutters which is a potential tomorrow and the briefie Yosef which is the cedar and the beer Agora all say that the maloik is between poisonous and their Rambam depends on how you learn they Shama imbecile oh if the much like casaba shaman bacillus connect the government it's an awesome can I be done with my yoke soon so the key is you should be able to see how many days of Hanukkah so of course toys versus right if you're gonna start having the whole family lighting more candles you don't feel the other - crossing it's in the mail a toaster says that you have to light one per family and you add in that way or you decrease in that way but like the second view of Bashar man basil--oh the second it has nothing to do with your money on my age and it has to do miss hello says Milan because there's very married then so fine the first night you had 70 candles whatever you had the next night you have 140 candles all right so then I don't see the second night of Chanukah huh that's a real math come in that too sir Amba and they somebody says connect it pouring half dark souls right the first night yet 140 candles the next night you went down I don't see it's the second night of Chanukah I don't see that what I only have seven days of Hanukkah left because I have so many candles but the main thing is I went down connected party rock and not my limbic registry married that's the Nazca min of the huronian say huh no yeah what's the reason what's the reason of my argument I don't care I don't care according to the first Peters that's the reason that's what makes it mildly mean I'm a hydrant well why would you know hello says the first night you liked one candle why would you what would you sell 100 candles townsman that's not much so you start with one you go up no Evander the number of eight and one has to do with Hanukkah there's eight days of Hanukkah you're doing one two three four five six seven eight it's structured according to Hanukkah but it's not Nagaya to see in that young man is not snow in my yard said we're going to the first reason that is the whole part I want to celebrate the amount of days of Hanukkah so choice versus you're not celebrating it because it's not visible but according to the second reason I don't care that's fine so it's not visible but the poem Amish I added where I went down some mail it works this would be the naphtha coming of a pole between the two shittest and that would be a reason why they're arguing about it it's not Stallman argument and abstract my enough come in if if you keep the second one i didn't understand say label ad Rambam it's an extra hinder cuz you really did second you're adding so to speak you spending more money practically speaking according to Tice's love daf keep spending more money is saying for can't forget if Navy is your base if you have ten people in the family right you actually doing it less because you're only doing one two three four five six seven eight so why is it called Muhammad Ahmad [Laughter] that to go left to go get that to go get dad to go get I just want to adhere this is the most likely choice to surround the dark emotion there are more rights that this whole mark like us he says isn't a gay or only if you lighting outside that's what there are muscles they're actually motion but if you're lighting in the house since the people of the house he says that he says this was not like we said since the people not know how many members there are in the family so a male according to all this you could do both he'd do him there are moles even tourists would agree could do mahad them in amman because everybody knows how many members in the family and therefore if you see 20 candles a second night you understand it's because 10 and 10 it's because the second night of Chanukah and the r-mo also says since you're lighting in the house you're not lighting outside outside you don't have endless space in the house everyone could light in a separate space and then you have a heckler like you said before everyone has a separate notice you see here this - it is - here it is - and that's why they're not mine is a golf so Canora says that Dominica shatters that every one of the house lights and they add day by day by day like the Rambam but he says everybody should light in a designated place in order to before in the problem of toy service cuz he wants that both shittest should should be dealt with another interesting nazca manner that's brought in a huronian between the two ways of learning by shamim asila very interesting Africa minute I'll tell you what happens it's the first night of Hanukkah I light a candle the second night of Hanukkah I want to follow Bissell I want to light two candles I don't have I don't know if I have only one candle so of course what's the challah light one that's the classical look Nate issue base now comes the third night of Hanukkah the third night of Hanukkah somebody gave me candles what's the dinner do I like three candles or not if the reason is yummy managers no say no Yama my oats in for chef like three I yesterday you did one so is one one fine yesterday didn't have a choice he did one tonight do three but if the reason is Milan because there's rain married in so from Milan because ish all I need is one more than last night so you could like to you know if like three or to put it more sharply let's say the third night I only have two candles somebody only gives me two candles what should I do the third night the second nights get gave me one candle the third night I have only two candles what should I do if this word is young man you know some of my Utzon should I write both candles of course not it's gonna be it's gonna be worse the third night of chronically lighting two candles what's your point light one I have to there's nothing to do but if you say Milan Bacardi dish last night I did one tonight we do is the third night of Chanukah that's fine so that would be another nasca minute between the two shooters you understand I'll explain it to you don't worry if you'll understand you'll enjoy it let's say the first night of Hanukkah add one candle right the second night of cranek I would love to lie two candles like we do they sell oh but I don't have I only have one okay the third night of Hanukkah somebody brings me two candles what should I do the third night of Hanukkah practically speaking should I like to or should I light only one what should i do the third night of Sonic so I should like to but if the reason I'm adding each night is to celebrate the amount of days of Hanukkah that I'm celebrating the third night of Hanukkah is three nights I'm lighting two candles what's the point I'm actually making a mishmash so what should I do I should go back to work and the next night the fourth night again somebody brings me three candles I should go back to one but if the reason is pasillo says you should add because it could do so you go up and you don't go down so as long as it go up it's great so the third night of Hanukkah light two candles great but shopping the same thing all the way around the same Nakota the main thing was to go down I mean this is two ways of this another way of learning what's the smartest ride the first way that we explain ties or something AMA it's another way of learning the mark like this I'll give you another example the other way around the second night yeah you have two candles right the third night you also have two candles what do you do what do you do the second night I have two candles I like two candles the third night I also have two candles to light what do I do if you say it can make it governments in what are you lighting tonight two candles for SoCal what but if you say Milan because Ray Murray didn't know because at least don't do my readin at least don't do my reading if you say over my yesterday the two tonight do one it's pointless why do - it's actually it's actually it's counterproductive you celebrating the third night of chemical with two candles at least do one again dick that's the Mitzvah but if the word is Milan because there's rain we didn't say even though I can't go up because I only have two a nice night I did - at least don't go down don't go from two to one so they me silly what are you you have to dock your light so even though you're not celebrating young myojin that would be a similar way the other way one thing your candles you simplify the enables you actually Mitzvah okay okay whatever the circumstances are whatever the circumstances you're right yeah now I want to say one more thing we have no comes who says it it's broad enough for anything it's broad enough right now you want to bring your favorite coffee maybe all this mess over there you have the madameharris upstairs upstairs or Chanukah I don't know that hammock Irma Kate's probably Hanukkah cover their villas if they have admission list look at this surface there's a sit over there ballon and there's demand McComb is divine or member wearing yeah but now with an interesting question here we have 630 mitzvahs we have mitzvahs Dearborn we have mistress minute Ida we never find such a matsyas lulav how do you shake a lulav mitzvah is to do this if you're my hard to do this if you had them in know how to do this there's a concept of hidden Mitzvah everywhere a beautiful love a beautiful Esther beautiful to fill and beautiful misses a beautiful cat was beautiful safe attire right there's a cousin a mitzvah should be as beautiful as possible but here we see a different thing and I'm just saying the Mitzvah of Hanukkah do it as beautiful as possible get the best oil get the nice monoi together get good good wicks not here the structure of Hanukkah Turner a bone of the structure of Hanukkah is why that the Imam is divided it into three categories which is a unique thing by Hanukkah where does it come from so here there's a base la vie huh how do you know okay so this is the Shiloh what happened by Hanukkah so there's a dish mock of art from the pineal schewe and the dish Markovic from the vase la vie the pinellia schewe time is that the reason they made it this way is because Hana kotti unique situation why did the kind of cover unique situation we're gonna soon learn into the Gemara the famous story that everybody knows that it was not enough oil and the miracle of Hanukkah was that it burned for eight the oil that lasted for what that could should lasted for one night lasted for eight nights the question the plane is sure asks is why was there even an issue that it was not enough oil the answer is because all the oil was coming but the claw is that tumor hood tribute zebra tumor hooker but zebra means if most of the timber is Tom a the traitor allows you to do that void in the base--emitter Schmidt tumor so for example you have a carbon that becomes Tommy and it's possible disqualified generally or a koi hen who becomes Tommy is now let it do that void nonetheless if it's a carbon sealer and most of the deceiver is Tommy so let's say most of the coin in my tummy you go into the base I make this with tumor we do it by Toma that's the halacha in this case all the oil was Tommy right the Jews were tumbling because of what happened so therefore to Mohammed Zippo you could take chemin Tommy so why but cloud there was their problem that they had to look for the jug of oil is to motorboats it the answer is that you're right I'm inside the acre had didn't they could have they could have done it but Shimon Tommy however the reburn is shillelagh wanted to show his love for the Jewish people so he said I know you can get away with femin Tommy but I want that the head Locker should be in the most beautiful way in the most wholesome way it should be and I in a hitter dick away that's what he wanted so the whole Hanukkah was celebrating not that I could just get away with it that I wanted in the most beautiful way so therefore when they instituted Hanukkah they didn't just okay we'll just do a candle there's a you could do it in mahogany Mahad Romina Mahad debaser LaVey says a similar of art and he says what they could have done was created very very thin wicks creating woven very very thin wicks and that's way that way that the the wicks would be 1/8 of the regular size of the wicks and because it would be 1/8 that would only eat up and consume an eighth of the oil that was usually needed and therefore he would take the same amount of oil that they had split it up into eight night so you don't need a miracle make much smaller wicks and as a result of that you'll be able to light them at night and do it Ella my the nests was that the monoi de should be able to burn in the same beautiful way and with the same beautiful wicks like before so that's why here the base a lady says that become aware miss a can hinder it doesn't exist in other mistress that's the reason that Hanukkah has up so unique standards that you don't have other tops yeah we'll get to that the next Saudia y8y why we celebrate eight you saying the miracle was only seven right yeah that's that's the big the big question on Hanukkah ah yeah today probably more another right lapid Lapidus should make the Lapidus yeah yeah yeah yeah Bates's of yom tov another interesting thing is what's the smallest McLucas yama - nah see no my oats they silver Lawson knows that his eight days left to hanok and Bashar my Olson knows that was celebrating one night of Hanukkah there has to be some Mahalo fish ami looks at the AMA Monica Nelson this looks young my age so we say it's a reason hug offer why am I looking at the future and I'm looking at the present in the past syrups let me know subs evan has a safer mired in Baja Lana he was the editor encyclopedia Tom with this all of the bigger in the minutia Lian last generation passed to adoption Lama the class 1970s 1978 he says a fascinating words says a pion brisker asked the Shila once it's above us deshyla and says by Tomica they only had oil to burn for one night and it burned for eight nights so sick of all the Kazaa so what happened so one of the explanations is each night it refilled up it refilled again and was like wow reflective high and brisk you're not really to the Mitzvah why the Mitzvah is the tightest says me a koala huh chemin sighs oh it has to be olive oil now the Ramona she alone could create oil it's wonderful beautiful it's miraculous but it's not olive oil olive oil has to come from the aleph so it's a beautiful miracle but it's worthless you're not the kind of Mitzvah a miracle can change mitzvahs how long as I wash em in his eyes it's not lemons I use it's great it's awesome it's heavenly it's miraculous and it's lemons eyes the myth free you didn't do so you have a big miracle you're lighting the midnight it's great for beauty but you didn't do the Mitzvah it's a pointless that's a shot interesting Sheindlin crime answers that you have to say shot in the nest was not new oil was created rather the same oil remained the quality of the oil increased not the quantity but the quality in other words the same amount of oil that it takes one night to burn it took 8 nights so that quality the Koyuk of the oil was increased 8 fault so therefore normally from my wick to burn for 10 hours I need this amount of oil and if this amount of oil is day it's gonna be gone at the end and here 10 hours it burnt and only 1/8 so male the next night I still had 7/8 left and then the last night it burnt up that's what he said the mela was still Shemin zabis ok others ask on that la jolla is that still Simons is the tone has changed its tacky physically tremens eyes but the qualities change that's another skill the mela a bozo we have a Havana by shamim vasila why think about it the first night of Hanukkah you have the whole oil you have the whole oil what's burning the miracle was increased eight fault right so what's burning what's burning is only 1/8 so now you look at base on my time is connected yellow Mohonasen awesome how much how many miracles do you have in this oil in the menorah you have a miracle for eight days because you have in this monoi de right oil that this oil was increased Eightfold that each night and eighth is gonna burn yeah so the second night what do you have left you have left only seven parts the last night what do you have left you have left one mess one miracle that's what you have left in other words in potential the first night you have chemin that can burn for eight nights the last night what do you have the potentially for one night base Hillel says that's what side the potential with side the poem Amish Mossad not what's potentially in the oil what do you see what the miracle happened in reality the first night you saw one the second night it was already two parts of the oil if this is true so then this would be totally in a general curve that you see between my shaman missile in the whole shots generally they shall my focus is on potential and be civil focuses on actuality for example you'll have a classic example the mission at the end of the end of all shots the end of occasion and that is dog you may Amos I'm a cobbler's tumour fish in the water or not McCobb altima even if they touch a mess once the fish are trapped they're taken out of the water they're dead like all like all food I'm a couple to Iceland I'm a cobble Toma when baisama says mushiya so do they still says misciagna Musa but Shama says once they're in the net even though they're not dead they're mockable Toma basil--oh says Michelle Musa they have to die what's this far as a McCoy cos when they're in the net they're not dead yet but they're going to be the potential is there Bernardo actuality based sharma follows the baqia base Hillel follows the map oil but mainly heroes when it comes to the shot and this is this is you see this very very often in shots between by shamim basil--oh but Mela here to the first night of Hanukkah in this oil whatwhat's the color of the soil agate egg the seven next next night what's the color of the soil seven the last night of Hanukkah what's the color from this world burn for one night base Hillel says in actuality what's the miracle that comes out the first night not eight one part of the oil is burning and it's already a miracle because only an eighth is being consumed the second night it's true submission my says be civil so can I do my notes ready no but it's already burning up much less every minute that's already burning up much less also what started tonight less there for sure but also tonight already right five minutes went in and look only a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of one all was consumed normally after five minutes you would already see a much greater descent one for yesterday it's already what no but if you say the first nighter was depleted and then it refilled I mean as it was burning so cama cama bottle you say comma comma but so tomorrow there's no shear we're gonna have a shear on Monday next we come away from Tuesday throughout the week okay so next month will be a shear Sunday night we're having a special you test kiss love for bringing in homes it's in 10th 7:30 p.m. everybody's invited for men and women all texture Monday Hanukkah phase Russia so the next year Gomorrah will be Monday what do you say this is one of the turrets man the Bishop's capture that he asked la jolla the first night there was no miracle because he had enough oil so while making seven by making eight nights make seven nights but according to this the first night was the same miracle because every night only 1/8 burned top to sort of climb salivate resort it's a known part of the playa you understood or not what did he understand the kama kama bottle means when I pour something into something so each drop that goes in gets nullified to the previous drops that's what he's asking you should say that the oil was increasing a whole time so the miraculous oil was bottled to the natural law that's what he was arguing he understand that the miracle was happening not suddenly at the end of the day boom well it's min Ben memory in the sense of it looked exactly the same and had the same properties it just he just really wasn't the same he's arguing that since in reality it looks like it has I think it would be must not the same thing one of those things here in the tempt let's have a breakfast today after show ruckus no no no not a good idea for you you don't want to start off on an Iraqi it's a week at it's a week after shuttle brothers right oh you mean yeah at the end of shamrock the first year you gotta be domesticated we put on the bus with 40 40 men it's exactly what you need unless you get the private helicopter you could do it in the classy way but yeah Kate said miraculin Hikawa right so Bashan a judge does something according to its full potential even if in reality you don't have it potential is more important than reality so even though the oil in reality didn't burn but the potential according to pochamma is more important than reality you look at a boy comes to yeshiva do we look at his potential or do we look at the reality it's two views in life a of potential or reality you want to hire somebody in your company potential or reality sometimes if potential is magnificent but the reality is not yet realized so Bashar may says you follow pacaya and a lot of much like us and he has the same thing another much like you says how is vash you know how a beehive works you ever saw honey combs right so the question is when is it called on ISIL that's McHale Toma okay so miss Hillel's view is once the owner of the Beehive actually he combs off he scrapes off the honey from the bee hives to take it that's when it's considered a food a human food and it's it's macabre Toma but Shama says no when he just actually mushiya hairy when he thinks about it when he plans that that's enough it already redefines it from just be food into human food because he thought about it another gear said Michener's machine hair hair he used to do is they would bring they would smoke up the distal though they would smoke up the Beehive so the bees would run away and then you could take the honey without getting bitten so Bashar my says the moment you make the smoke you didn't take anything but that's already it's on the way the potential is that the reality is not there yet so quantum a shaman that's what makes it fool even though it's not yet in your kitchen you're not eating it yet according to miss Hill oh no you have to take it again the same as Lucas a similar Marcus right right no for sure but we don't find in other myths is that the way they made the mitzvahs oh you could do it like this you could put up the filling like this you could put on film like this you could put in film like this yeah is there Hitler and Phil and of course have nice past years I'm a good cipher have nice bottom it's all relative a nice s trick we don't say there's an S look like this yeah you can have a beautiful ass you can have a big ass rig a clean s rig right of course right you give moats a let's you can have a more guest for Shabbos less guest for Shabbos etc but here they instituted the midst in different categories it's like a whole different it's not a different Mitzvah but here it's it's one per family here it's many per family here it's different mitzvahs every night and the first one you go to the Mitzvah you like one Hanukkah candle every single night of Hanukkah you good you don't do anything else you fill them it's three make a brush everything is perfect it's not mahogany no Mehadrin so it's a very interesting thing that by Hanukkah they instituted it that way that's why they're sure item say because the whole Hanukkah came from Hashem Hitler so this because Shem wanted it should be a beautiful Mitzvah he didn't just want we should get away with the basics he wanted it should be perfect so the way we respond to that is we say ok we could do it basically which is fine but by Hanukkah they said you know what let's do it perfect there's another finish by Sonic and that is usually Mahathir minima Hadron is for a select few you have people that had their Mahathir and everything but a lot of people are not when it comes to Hanukkah the mimic parshat is everyone as mahogany namaha you don't have a Jew today for example you have many many Jews who don't do many other mitzvahs but can occur candles they write they liked okay if it's according mama is perfectly a logically or not it's a separate question and they all do the same thing the first night one the second I to 2/3 93 in others Mahathir minute Mehadrin became something that the whole cloudiest all does you don't have a truth I'm not a Mehadrin I know I'm not into this I just do the basics no I Hanukkah everyone embrace the Mehadrin minima Haddon that's the fact the Minik pasha there are mother says it's a minute portion in other words we see that just like the miracle of Hanukkah was Hashem said I wanted to be the beautiful way so when the Jews who responded to the mitzvot they said when I'm going with the basics we're going with the most beautiful way it's interesting yeah yeah yeah so that's gonna be the next so you will you place the Chanukah candles it says in a time of danger where where was dangerous for people to see it you could put it on the table with the Evan but for generally speaking you put it either by the door by the window okay clear another interesting mellitus is as follows till when could you eat cream at night the student of Bashan metabolizer holds you can only read at seifish Mura Hashanah till the first section of the night that's when you could read your Gamliel holes you could read em til hot sighs till midnight come say you could do shmatte till dawn break what's the argument the terrorist says you have to read the creation of a shock baka when you sleep it does that mean when you're sleeping when you go to sleep when you go to bed potentially you have the full night's sleep you know when you you go into bed and you cover yourself with a blanket potentially you have the full night's sleep you didn't sleep yet but you the mindset is one I'm going to sleep according to Bashan me that's the main thing but Shaka and that's why once the first section of the night is over it's not Krishna anymore according to the other huh common rabble is is that follows always be Shama Shama the other common no it's about Pisciotta baka when you sleep people sleep until dawn break some people sleep after dawn break but that's not considered normal so what till dawn break is the time of collision this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot lay you Shiva net slash donate