The Resounding Voice of Moshe Rabbeinu - Understanding the Book of Devarim

this store class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay okay welcome everyone thank you everyone for coming we'd like to welcome our anytime viewers Tonight Show has been sponsored by Rob C Merlin who came in in the clutch at the last moment when uh as the gates were closing he came in and uh she was been in the show for a short time and ready plays a very important role and he keeps me on my toes for the shoe room subscribe okay okay this evening we have to answer some very serious questions if we were to ask who was our greatest teacher of all time who's our greatest Revy of all time who is the greatest ever had right we would have to answer would be unanimous and if we were to ask what are the qualities necessary to be a good rebbe so we would come up with many Midas Thai Vice yeah you have to be patient humble you can think of many good character traits that are necessary but above and beyond inequality the Revy needs to be able to speak clearly the Webbie can't speak clearly you don't know what in the world he's talking about so not only is he not gonna be an effective Ruby it's let's get him to listen right you're sitting there you know what is it going to be over already the most important quality needed to Be an Effective Revy is you have to be able to convey the idea clearly the people need to know what you're talking about and yet who is considered our greatest teacher of all time why did the riban inshallah make Maisha it was difficult for him to talk he stammered he stuttered he couldn't get the words out and even when Hashem says you know go speak to Paro unless you said me you know he got the wrong guy I'm the last guy in the world to be chosen to convey to have an effective a conversation with somebody so of all the qualities you would have thought God would have bestowed upon you would have thought my shepherd would have been the great greatest orator of our time no he's the only person in the Tanakh that we find he could not speak close there has to be a reason for it you know obviously God knew from beforehand my shravenu would be the the one to transmit the toilet Cloud Israel we would have thought God would have given him the tools the capabilities necessary to to fulfill his role properly and just the opposite the one person in the entire tanatha we find who cannot speak clearly was my shopping oh who wrote them who wrote the books of Tanakh says the gemara Maisha wrote his book in the book of villain and the Pasha villain so now why does the gemara specifically mention parishes Villa doesn't say anything bad Apache is graciousness okay we once had a share on that a few years ago a few months ago in other locations but what does the gemara mean Maisha kasab sifri Moshe wrote his book leaving his book which book is moisha's book what there's a book that belongs to Maisha which which book is that um that's the next line in the command that it's not on the sheath we're gonna make it but if you look at the action open up a real gamara the next line is you know if it's safe for Eve but what does it mean he wrote his book what's his book presumably that means the Tyra but why is the gamara calling it sifri his book it's not his book more than my book and more than your book why is it called his book okay very interesting there's something called a get right a document of divorce right because right now working out you have the Escape hat there's something called a get a get when you write again again it's not something you know you take out your lead pencil you take out a scrap of paper paper towel and you know you write again again you need a certified Cipher and there's a certain specific formula necessary to write again and in fact a get has to be written on a certain number of lines 12 lines they get when you write a get the safe right to get rights to get on 12 lines look enticevis looking number three um why do we write again on 12 lines Why 12 the numerical value of get is 12. gimmel is three test is nine according to higher mathematics three plus nine is twelve right twelve tices further what's the significance of 12 lines the shame of haigon over shame rabinu sadya because the Tyra says about again what is again again is a document of Crisis cutting cashier your base equal to the 12 lines that separate between the four books of the Torah in other words if somebody would open up a safer Tyra between safer voracious and safer shamas there are empty lines anybody know how many empty lines four between Mauritius and shemais four empty lines between four empty lines between my midbar four empty lines so therefore since a get is a document of cutting where do we find cutting we find voracious is cut off from shemais chemise is how much are they cut off four lines between race essential mice four Lives four lines between vayakura and the nidbar and according to higher mathematics what's four plus four plus four what about the four lines of space between says the separation between which begins with Words which is called Mission attire right safer de Varma is called mishna Taira those four lines like hush if we don't care about those four lines Why is China because devarim there's nothing new in davaran there's nothing new the varum is just a repetition of what you have in the first four books so therefore you have four lines between voracious and shamas let's count them four lines between let's count that four lines between let's count that but the four lines we tuned by midro and davaran that's irrelevant who cares why what do you mean who cares isn't bad isn't davaran part of the tiger yeah but it's just Hazara that's why rabbi's going vacation during safer environment we already know it nothing new Hashem doesn't talk nothing new it says and since divarim is just repetition of the first four books the space in between is not counted what the inverted as much as I like those inverted nuns we're not going to be using them tonight I have a different shot why they don't figure because it is closer and being that you're you're giving increases you don't want it to be poisonous very interesting I don't want it to be very good so you want to give the creases it should be a full accomplished Jesus and the fact is because you know you don't want it to be in the shelters okay that's a happy amgos right that's uh the delay make of tices but still still what we want to examine is why are we saying that devaren is a Hazara because in fact in fact we find something very interesting tells us look at number four there are just over 100 laws in the varum okay if you would count how many midsole starting safer divarim there are just over 100 laws in the barn so we would expect all these hundred midsoles are merely a Hazara of what we have in beration first not true 70 out of the 100 Mitchells in davarium are brand new we never saw before brand new for instance you ever hear that mid-sun it's not doesn't appear anywhere until davara not to marry a guy right you ever hear it's it's something that you can marry a guy don't ask right not to sacrifice an Obama my sarani baltoises right I know not it's a Mitzvah it's right avoidazara dozens and dozens of mixels which not only appear in davarium they appear in Divine for the very first time now you do have some mitzvos that are repetition he brings down you have the midsos of dam which is repeated which is repeated um all of these myths are repeated but nevertheless the vast majority of midsos that are mentioned in davarium are brand new out of those just over 100 Mythos mentioned in the varum the majority of them are brand new so what in the world is Tyson saying that the separation between doesn't count because devaram is merely a Hazara of a merely a repetition of the first four books not a repetition there's more new information in the barn than there is old information what's Tyson's talking about so there's something Paul Hirsch explains what is this concept the mission of Torah we're going to try to explain tonight is what exactly is the identity of safer Divine what is this entity of safer Divine is it part of the other four books is it connected is it an entity in and of itself says the following was given on the precipice of cry you throw going into Arkansas they're about to go into the left now just imagine being in the mid bar is obviously a very different existence than going so when you go in times as well it's going to become an Agricultural Society you're going to need to appoint the king you're gonna have a base time McDon you're going to be working the Land There are many many Mythos that are more relevant in areas Israel than they were in the mid bar the midsos that are either repeated or said for the first time in davarum are those missiles that are needed for class new level of existence for their new existence and Earth Israel in the mid bar they've sat in their down almost they sat in their tents and what they do all day they learned Tyra right like Newton Ella the land Israel in the mid bar they learned Tyra day and night the midsource given in the first four books of the Hamish are those Mythos relevant to the state of classical are undergoing a new status a new state the midsos being given in safer divarim are those missiles relevant to their new state but this does not explain in any way what in the world Isis means that devarim is merely a repetition of the first four books that a repetition the first four books of those missiles needed for classical and the mid bar and the midsole is needed for Claudius thrall in Arizona were those missiles given in tomorrow it's not a repetition at all there are small amounts of missiles that are repeated but the vast majority of missiles are given for the first time in safer Divine okay so this question is raised by none other than rosmeisha Feinstein if anyone ever opened up the difference Maisha but Maisha has I'll go through a certain subject and what other Russia shivas would take one or two pages to explain with Maisha could write 50 to 100 pages on a studio if anyone could get beyond the first page or whatever moisture writes please let me know you explain it to me very complex very complex analysis but in the back I'm assess the good thing as Maisha has what is called hot rice and in his fourth his third Horan asks please tell me that much has a different calculation safer divarim has more than 200 mid slice that are not mentioned earlier in the time you hear this but Marshall rights midsize you have more than 200 midsoists that don't appear anywhere else you can tell me than any other say fan and Tyson says no the virus is nothing new just a hazar of what you learned before you know maybe it's because you know when I was in high school so first the Revy would teach a few blood of gamara and before the test he would go over again Hazara but then everyone realized you know why listen the first time you could just listen to the saying that sashem was smart he said you know I go straight to the khazara right that's what it's like devara images they never learned it the first time what's the kazara so I'll tell you what somebody said Revolution said to answer this question even though that's not what he writes and if you could figure out what he writes also please let me know I heard from Rob Israel reisman shlita that he was there when ramasha asked the question and remote should give the following answer and this is based an idea doesn't sound like something but much it would typically say but it's based on the following idea and that is the Torah existed before the world was created how did it exist there were six hundred thousand letters right but the formulation of the letters was not known yet as the history of Collegeville developed that put into place how the letters would be formulated but in shamai and these letters existed for instance we once learned from the villagan the at the last possible at the last eight Sacrament who wrote it with tears so the question is what do you think he wrote it with tears Moshe is going to write nyamas Moshe Moshe died how can Moshe write while he's alive then Moshe died so the bill nagone says you got it wrong the word does not mean tears demma means Mishka Bible uh right a mishmash right that's not an English word by the way right a mishmash something mixed up what that means is the rest of the Tyra was formulated but the last they took him because they didn't happen yet so much you couldn't formulate the words so Masha wrote it the way they were in shamayam until after Moshe died and then they took the form that they have today but there's an idea that before certain events took place the letters were there but they weren't formulated for instance was the hate of clairach supposed to happen was that predestined no karak had free choice was the state of the miraglan predestined no they had the free choice to sin no all of these things developed when the Jewish people chose to sin so then how was the Torah written in shamayam before these events took place well the way the Torah was written is the letters were there but the letters were not formulated as words yet according to this eyewitness account what would have happened had seen had the miraculum that's in had the Jewish people not send with Diego you wouldn't have had to pass this Kyra you wouldn't have had practice and you wouldn't have had a pasture so what would have been in pasius you know what would have been there all the new Mitzvahs that are now in safer davara and what would a devarim have been Hazara of the first four books it happens to be because the jewson with the aegon they sinned with kairak and they sinned with the miraglim so those misses had to be so to speak removed and I shouldn't have to fill it up with the story of kairak kisusa and now these missiles didn't have an opportunity to be taught until safer divare but Devon was supposed to be Mission attira unfortunately it's not he means it should have been a hazard okay that is supposedly what ramosha said I wasn't there but this is what is reported from a very incredible source so you have your homework cut out for you right it you got to take your computer and figure out if the the words in Kairos if they equal up to those words then you gotta scoop okay but now we move on now we want to try to understand what exactly is Mission attire what is it is it on the same level of the rest of the title now if you ask any Jew is devaran part of the Torah of course the time the Torah if someone says I believe in the whole Torah except for Apostle compassion for a what is he he picks up your bottle of wine Gotta Throw in the garbage he's not precarious yet the gamara tells us in the Sacramento something very interesting the gumara says what if it's official you could drink it yeah okay thank you it says like this said that when you're reading the toaster you know what the Tulsa is the stern rebuke in practice which is unsafe which is in safer Divine you know the balcory is they they Mumble it they say very low which is not proper sometimes because you have to read it out loud you have to read it carefully but any event many ballet kriya they like to read it quickly they read it whoa the halacha is you're not allowed to stop in other words let's say a guy you know sometimes you're in a shul and some stranger walks in and he has yard sights and you need to stop him in you have to give him an Aliyah what if a guy walks in the middle of the price are you allowed to cut the pressure in half and give the stranger and Aliyah no very good no you're not allowed to says the gamara that's only when you're reading the taisuka in Terrace is an appellation for safe this rule that you're not allowed to cut the taisuka in half that's only the avoc but the curse is you could cut in half in other words when you're reading you could call up this guy who has a yard side and that guy who's on the outside and this guy whose sisters graduated last year right you could call up anyone who wanted my timer why are you allowed to cut up the tices huh foreign is said to the entirety of Khalifa everyone right it said to the Seabrook so if you have a guy who says yeah but it doesn't apply to me no it applies to everyone it says it from God himself in other words you but if a guy is a Big Sandy he could say him but not me um said it on his own you hear what things are saying Moshe is saying over the word of God [Music] he made it up he woke up in the morning and he said you know what these Jews are not behaving let me make up some kind of punishments that they're gonna get if they don't listen to tan unless she got up in the morning he said let me think of some good ones yeah yeah you know if you guys don't behave you're gonna get uh where's my shopping list get hemorrhoids moisture says made it up okay you know he opened up the dictionary you know most grotesque punishments you know he's flipping through he said oh yeah let me say this one and then you know this one will really scare them what does it what I mean the gamara is saying the tokikan let's just said it on his own what does that mean furthermore you ready for this one is it says the following there's a concept okay which means you have a love and when I say the assay pushes away the license now don't try it at home doesn't mean you know going to a Shear is a Mitzvah eating at McDonald's so if I'm going to a sheer I could pick up something from McDonald's on the way right we don't apply the rule of assay in that case has very limited applications for instance are made out of shotness well in linen you're allowed to wear them but that's only in the times of the gemara that they had feila nowadays we don't have trailers right so therefore you can have shyness so why are you allowed to have shyness and sisters when we had say less there's something called smochen is juxtaposition when you have two concepts in the Torah back to back the Torah says Royce still bashanas don't wear shyness and then the Tyra says good deal and pastel I thought makes it this why does a Torah put in close proximity go and wear shyness but weird scissors back to back to teach you you're a lot of weird sisters even if your sisters are made of shyness this is called smuchen when you have two things right next to each other they have a car like they have a connection for instance another example it says the higher giving whip right nowadays we don't give whips we don't give whips only Marcus Meredith only the rabbano only the rabbi's a lot of whip nowadays not initial we don't do it usually we don't usually whip over here but the turret says right don't muzzle your Ox what does one thing got to do with the other just like muzzling your ax is what we call nice uh it's a lab that has an action so to you only give malkus for lab she is famous this is the concept of smoking smoking says the gemara not everybody buys into the smoking business not everybody says you know because it says a right next to B there's a connection between A and B however says the gamara even those who don't buy into smoking accept it when it comes to nishna Tara to safer Divine says even those who do not darshan smoking Bahama which means if the A and B are next to each other there's a connection how do we know this because rabihuda normally doesn't say for devaram he does says it's not that there's anything special about davara technically speaking we Kardashian smoking anywhere it just happens to be that any time you have smoothing and safer devaran there's an added factor to darshanet either there's an extra word or there's an extra or the context of the Posse is what we call lens to the drasha in other words what Isis is saying is that there's nothing special about safer divarim that we would specifically Dash and smooth them into varm all the gamara means is whenever happens to come out and say for devarim there are reasons to darshan it and if those reasons would have appeared in other song we would have dashed into another song but they happen not to appear though we're going to see not all reshine him agree with this analysis of Texas there may be something special about safer Divine that we only darshan okay it was Pyro's birthday it was the anniversary apparels avidazar and all the kings of the world come into power and what do they do they bow down to power they take off their Crown right they put it down on the floor in front of parallel they humble themselves in front of power and all of a sudden pyro gets a message Paro there are these two old Jews standing at the gate what do they want let them in Moses and Aaron they come into power and instead of putting down their crown and set it and bowing down smile you know what they say to power off let my people go let me people don't what should a pyro done Powers should have said Off With Their Heads to kill them right just the day before when Pyro's Jester made a joke that power didn't think was funny he killed him right if you don't if you rub power the longer the wrong way what does pyro do that's the end of you you know he takes a crocodile he feeds you to the crocodile so why didn't pyro say kill them what what happened says the government couldn't talk to save his life he was a stammer he was a stutterer did not see clearly he was ahead he spoke heavy not a good speaker and all of a sudden this clad pedically this stammer comes in front of parai and in a loud clear resounding voice he says say what where was that coming from this man who couldn't talk to save his life all of a sudden gave this powerful drasha Taro could he was shaking he couldn't he couldn't believe it what happened to this man by the way this is as opposed to Bill him billum his donkey opens up his mouth and instead of villain being shocked he started yeah he said yeah he said what are you talking to me he starts arguing with the dogs he wasn't he wasn't a spoiled it was like you know nothing happened but pyro at least had the sense that when something out of the ordinary happens he was so shaken he was scared to say anything if power just witnessed one of the greatest Miracles he had ever seen in his life and that is this man who couldn't talk all of a sudden he's the greatest author in the world what happened says I'll tell you what happened and that is when Moshe Rabino came to Claud Israel to teach the Torah how is kaiso Gonna Know that how's Carly still gonna know that these are the words of God maybe woke up in the morning and he said you know what I think you know it's going to hurt your digestive system to eat milk and meat together so don't don't do it I think it's you know good uh calisthenics you know take the rule of an asterisk and start shaking it how do we know that Mike Champion didn't make this stuff up says the dim the maggot because not talk he couldn't speak clearly he couldn't open up his mouth he could not get out one Cogen sentence that is until he started to teach the Tyra and when my shabano began to teach the Torah Moshe yada there but like him yeah she wasn't talking he opened up his mouth and it was what we call shrina medavaresha God spoke out of moshe's throat when mashabin went to the store to buy tuna fish Studio he'd have to write it on a piece of paper could I buy the tuna fish but as soon as my shabenu started to teach kaiso the Tyra he was the greatest speaker in the Hawaii so that claw Israel should understand and know that he's not talking it's not that mission made it up most you couldn't talk to save his life when it came to the time he opened up his mouth God spoke out of his voice box by the way this is one of the fundamental ways that we know that the tairos says one time I went to visit Nairobi who was the rebbe of the dim the Magid the rebby was who he calls my reyno harav rabinu hakadosh who's that guy and he says Rabbi please tell me what is the difference between say fibration very simple you know what the difference is what's the difference between Tyra and Naveen Taira Hashem didn't come to my share teach Moshe something and then the next day motion related there's no no relaying my show was a non-empity he merely opens his mouth and God spoke out of his throat nivian God comes to you Shia he tells him a message the next day ishaiah tells it to Cloud yourself God comes to hear me Yahoo tells him a message so shows him an image yummy always tells it to call you God comes to Amos shows him a message he tells him to call himself that's not God speaking out of their throat Tyra is not the words of my shot they are the words of God himself speaking out of the throat box of Moshe says the villain going that is until you come to safer devaram all of a sudden you come to safer divarim it is no longer so much God was not speaking out of the voice box of motion now safer divine all of a sudden God came to my share and then when Moshe was ready he taught it to Kalisa like all the other Naveen but you asked me Akasha if that but I thought what unless you couldn't talk so how did he teach Calisto safe for divine it's safer Divine is God tells my and then Moshe tells claw Israel then how can my shravino talk when she wasn't able to speak take a look at the first murder Mission safer Divine look at number 10. China look at the language of taramak Aviva how beloved it is cures the tongue the matter is further but lay the armor my little woman before Maisha was given the tarah is he couldn't talk but once he was zaissa to the Torah and he began to speak he could speak clearly that's why I've been to introduced the safer Divine with the words now I'm finally able to talk in other words says the village before my shopping will give the Tyra he was a stammerer he was a stutterer he couldn't speak why because Hashem wanted to demonstrate to Cloud Israel that the words of my shaven were not his own words how do we know they're not his own words because not get one word out of his mouth but when he came to teach the Torah it was because but once my shopping already taught the Tyra God didn't make much of into a stutterer for nothing it was for an intended purpose and the intended purpose was so that they recognized that when he teaches this is the word of God once that purpose was realized and devaran is merely a repetition there's no need anymore for Moshe to be a stammer and a stutterer that is why I say for divarim which is mishnata which is merely a repetition was able to talk that's the difference between the first four books of the Torah and the Varan the first four books God spoke out of the voice box did not say a word he opened up his mouth The Voice emanated from Russia the fifth book of the Torah now it's Maisha talking now it's not much uh saying his own words these are this is Moishe's interpretation of the image of Hashem so you'll ask if safer davarian is like all the other in a VM then why is it part of the Hamish should be part of the Naveen the answer is because even though it's navua like the other Naveen my shavenous is on a much higher level of than the other Navy is what we call ask a clear prism so he got precisely so therefore it is still allowed to be incorporated into the Corpus of Hamish as great as they were it's so that is the fundamental difference between the first four books of the footage and the fifth book another question 38 years what's happening motion because he didn't have a chance to teach the whole thing Magilla Magilla Mina but once is already given now it's just crazy so now he's cured Ayla hadavaram right like the matter says so listen to this says there's only going now we understand the gamara Magilla why does the gemara Magilla say you're not allowed to interrupt but you're allowed to interrupt the Tysons is the word of God the title sign the Varma is the words of Maisha look at the word of Moshe that's Michelle Moshe made it up no Maisha didn't make it up what the gemara's saying Israel are the direct words of Hashem speaking out of the voice box of moisture albino is so there for you now to be map sick but it's safer divarim as great as it is and it's part of the Torah nevertheless this is merely what we call nivua of Maisha doesn't mean it up it just means that's what the donor gun says that's what my route me product says in the safe it's Pharisees round anybody else we shine and say this if you look on that tysus and ivanish that we just learned Tyson says his opinion is there's nothing special about Mission Tyra it just happens to be that whenever you have there are other indications that lead you that lead you to dashing smoking says open up your chass you'll see on the side of tysus there's a footnote called hagois maharav ransberg he says the following he quotes he says I don't agree with Isis Tyson says there's nothing special about davarium says ravan I feel it's all about the Varun why if the first four books of the Torah are the word of God itself Hashem speaking at emotion's voice do we have a right to ask why did Hashem put a next to B can't deodorant into the reasons of God why Hashem decided to put one thing next to the other we have no idea why we have no right to ask why there's a rule the Torah is the wisdom of Hashem we have a right to start analyzing why one thing follows the next we have no right to ask why is a next to be we have no right to darshan smooch him but when it comes to davarin the environment was formulated by moisture Rabino moisturabino was the one who chose the order of chronology in davarin so we have a right to ask why did Maisha put a next to me that's what ravan says it's not a matter of it happens to be in the barn whenever you have smoking there are indications it's all about tavarin devaram you have a right to ask the about the chronology you have a right to ask why does B follow a in other books we have no right to ask such a question that's the way the ravan understands the gamar I'm going to tell you over one of my all-time favorite Rock my father always says over from the shame Ishmael and parashas the shower right claw you throw is coming into the yams of they're about to to cross the sea and what do they do they sing they sing Shira so I have a question for you what did yankel sing the uncle saying what did Daryl sing Daryl saying what disciples thing Bible says what did uh what is same thing every all 600 000 Jews they sang the same Shira really how's that possible right if I ask all of you right by the way after this year I want you all to say over this year how many different versions are we gonna have yeah like ten thousand right different versions of how is it possible that Claudius throw is traveling through the yams of and spontaneously every single Jew came up with the exact same words okay another question then Maisha sang really you're kidding me he sang then I mean obviously saying then I just want to tell you a very big Critters whenever you do something it's always then you can never do something at a time that's not then whatever you're doing it it's then so what's the time saying oh then it was us you can't do something that's not us right whenever you came to this year early late it was then right whenever the share was over soon not yet it's then whenever anything happens it happens then so why would the terminate us so you're here listen to the survashi now she says us means first they decided to sing the Shira they decided whenever you do something you decide to do it before you do it right there is never I know there's some people they do things without thinking but in general right us as she says means they decided to sing why does Atari have to tell me they decided to sing they sang we know they decided to sing another question [Music] that when you head you know a woman walking through the yamsa and she had you know she was carrying a baby in her in her womb to Baby sang Shira you know you you put the ultrasound on you could see you know the baby was singing the Aussies could someone tell me how in the world the baby was singing the azashian so you're saying what kind of question is how in the world they did it it was a miracle no not so fast there was another by the name of a mice a mice had a lisp he was like a list pack right he tried to say the word vilesh says the gemara what did he say boy lace what do you mean but he's a navi shouldn't his Prophet Powers allow him to say a word properly no he has Prophet Powers but he's limited by his his uh speaking uh capabilities so if you can't talk you can't talk so could someone tell me how these kids in their mother's womb the gamara says Anita the kid in his mother's womb tips awesome the mouth is closed right there even you go to the Guinness Book of World Records no child is talking in utero never happens could someone tell me how the children the name Iman were singing Shira had the highest level of he said when other Naveen said they said Kai what's the difference Kai means this is basically what Hashem is saying approximately but moisha said this is exactly what Hashem said how did Moshe know this is exactly what Hashem said did I tell you how because he wasn't talking because Hashem was saying it out of his voice box that's how much was able to say because he wasn't talking much opened up is now well emotionally Kim yeah what kind of nevue did Claire saw have as they're crossing the arms off what do they do they say is that Haley van video in other words the type of nafua yeah the level of profit a prophecy that Christ was the level of moisture albino it was China midab God was speaking out of their throat so there's no wonder then how yankel and Vero and fivo and schmaro all set the same nivua because it's not like they you know spontaneously composed this Naboo in their mind God was speaking out of their throats so even ubaras even the children of the name on without the faculty of speech they didn't need the faculty of thief because they weren't talking God was talking out of their voice box this was the nivu of my shabenu in voracious says [Music] we'll end with the following we say every Friday night Moshe the aharine the kaihanov ushmuel the Karishma right we talked about three great men Maisha Aaron shmuel sir how in the world are we equating why are we lumping them together you know throw them all in the same path I mean small was a great enough it wasn't my strawberry how do we how does it on us have a right to lump together Maisha Aaron and schmoor another very interesting question small hanavi was once reprimanding someone and he said the following look at number 21. small Hanabi says yes God sent all these people saved you from your enemies now just think that I remember in third grade who's talking to who this is shmuel talking to who you're talking to one of the Malacca and I believe one of them and and small is giving mosa he says what do you want to stop already God sent you rub out they're done you've stuck and God sent shmuel what what do you mean he is shmuel why is he saying God sent small right let's say I would tell you you know I I call myself Gladstone I like me I don't think you know you refer to yourself a third person what's most saying God said you about why is he calling himself shmuel says development gun there are three instances where we have the concept of grainai where an individual opened up their mouth and God spoke out of their voice box number one my sharabeno when always right you know on your Kippur yeah yeah you know the whole thing right everyone bows down right we say the crying godo says the shame Yuma yeah I'd say he didn't say it it merely emanated from his mouth says the girl what does it mean it emanate it from his mouth right it sounds like something you know you take it why did you say that no I didn't say it it just came out of my mouth emanates from your mouth says DeGraw when Aaron hakain or the kind Garden God was speaking out of their voice box when they performed the avoida in the capacity of as playing Hashem was speaking another voice box and it happened to shmuel one time when when he said his name in other words when he was giving Musa and he was about to say and me you know why he didn't say on me because he wasn't talking God was talking at his mouth says the golden going Maisha always [Music] when he said his name all these three instances and therefore we come back to the beginning when the gemara says who wrote the various form of Tanakh says again his book his book does not mean gracious you know why because that's on his book that's Hashem when the navi Malachi says referring says this right is safer divine my costs have separate safer than he points out something amazing the last pause look of safer that mid bar is the last question about member these are the missiles that God commanded mosh is just the the agent he's just the guy who opens up his mouth how does devaram start Ayla had Varan Hashem is but but because the mashabino's greatness it is part of as holy as kadosh and the same way one is not authorized someone who questions even one ice of the first four is not because the same thing for devara but understanding there is a fundamental difference in the format in the compilation of safer divarim and that is according to the Valentine the first four books this is a fundamental Concept in understanding when Maisha taught the Tyra he wasn't talking it was God to every Jew every Jew heard the voice of Hashem with their own ears have a wonderful evening we're gonna have breakfast you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com