Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
I think there's confusion
today I think there's confusion today
because we've come to a
point where we recognize that certain
paradigms that were familiar to
us are no longer
effective I'm talking about the old
style of parent
that perhaps was quite popular and
pervasive in previous generations or
maybe
even not that long ago a few years ago
even and we've come to a point where we
realize that's not really what toyoto
wants it's not really what cidus wants
and besides for all that it doesn't
work the children don't respond to the
harshness and fear-based and shame based
so we've come to a point where we
realize that we need to
unlearn some of the old
models but the question becomes what do
we replace that
with it's easy to just throw around
words it's easy to say well we don't
want to educate children out of fear
we're going to educate them out of love
okay I agree but what does that look
like what does that actually look like
to educate out of love and I
think what's happened I'm just saying
this as an
observer is that in many
cases what we've done
is we let go of stuff that we know
doesn't
work but we haven't yet really replaced
it with
anything so we
know that we don't want to
be so hard on our children that we break
them God forbid we know that's not the
path but then what do we do instead of
that it's like
well I guess nothing
right just stand back and let them do
whatever they're going to do because we
can't stop them anyway and if we try to
interfere they're going to get mad at us
and God forbid we're terrified that
we're going to turn them off they're
going to go away away from
us
so it's like
yeah maybe we've eliminated certain
parenting styles that you might
consider on some level to be
abuse but in many ways we've just
replaced that with
neglect and th neither of those are
desirable we don't want abuse or
neglect but if we don't yet know how to
parent out of love so then it's like
we're kind of stuck we know what not to
do but we're not
yet proficient at what to do and then
just nothing happens and then there's a
lot of what we see which
is
um to use a a Hebrew word heus a lack of
order a lack
of a lack of Direction
and then sometimes we think well maybe
we should go back to the to the old way
I
mean maybe it'll emotionally destroy our
children but at least at least there'll
be some type of order there'll be some
type of normaly right and then we say no
we can't do that no okay fine so we have
no choice we got to go back to the new
way which
is no standards no goals no guidance
and I don't really think anyone's to
blame here I just think it's a new skill
set and it takes a while to learn and
it's and it's and it's radically new
it's radically new I don't just mean
it's new to us I mean it may be new in
terms of the
entire timeline of human
history because a lot of this has to do
with the fact that Messiah is coming
very
soon and everything is
changing including and especially
parenting so we have to learn this whole
new approach this m approach to
educating our
children and uh I think we need to be
understanding of the fact that we
haven't mastered it yet and that's okay
but an evening like this is an
opportunity to talk a little bit more
about it and maybe to hear different
ways of explaining it and allowing it to
sink in so that we can study to be a
little bit more comfortable parenting
the new way the loving
way so
that's that's what we're doing
here and like I said we're in Crown
Heights I'm talking to leiters I'm
talking to the
initiated so I'm just going to say it
straight
up you want to know what it looks like
to get the best of both worlds to be
able to guide our
children without breaking them or naming
them to be able to get the best out of
them but also to show them how perfect
they are already you know the Paradox
the seemingly
impossible contradiction you want to see
how those two seemingly opposite
approaches are
harmonized so that's like I said Crown
High
labers I can say it like that but let me
support this statement because I think
the examples will be
helpful
um there's a
story that the rebbit
told that basically sums up the entire
new paradigm for Our
Generation Um rebba told this story
at a
shab was right
after it
was and you can look it up in theas
in also it was included the edited
version of this talk was included
in in the back in
the for
bimas here's the story the story is that
that AB
job was once on uh
vacation he used to take trips for his
health at least ostensibly the reason
for the trips were to visit different
Spas for
healing so he didn't have a lot of money
in fact to the
contrary the financial situation was
very
Bleak and he came home not home home he
wasn't in laich like I said he was
traveling to one of the spa towns in
Europe
but to wherever they were
staying and
rebit shab's wife was waiting for him he
came home and he was holding a new
purchase a uh cane a stick a walking
stick with a silver
handle and she knew that they had no
money she knew that if he bought
something new he bought it on
credit and she asked what is this so
theab
told that I just couldn't resist buying
this as a present for our
son
the's only
child who was
the and he explained what it was that
aroused his feeling of of love for his
child while he was he was out and about
he was strolling and he saw something
that made him really feel strongly he
wanted to do something nice for his son
and and he bought this stick and he
brought home the stick and that's the
whole
story it doesn't sound that deep it
doesn't sound that cataclysmic it's just
okay but in the Reba's
hands this story becomes the marching
orders for a whole new
paradigm a whole new
reality so theba asks okay I get that
the abbab was a loving father and he
wanted to buy a
present for his only
child but why that
present why a can with a silver
handle okay good
question so that EBA proceeds to unpack
this story and I should mention to you
and I think it's significant that EBA
says that the FED rebba never told this
story publicly the rebba says he told it
to me
privately there are many things that Reb
heard as privileged information from the
F things that we know now were Reb
training fbba was training his
son-in-law to become his successor and
he was telling him things that really a
reab only tells to a
reab and then the rebit turned around
and
took this information this privileged
information and he shared it with with
us which is another of theb the Reb
took Reit training stories and he shared
them with an entire
generation so the debbit explains the
story what's a stick
well a stick everything's from
Tyra in the
mishna in
aara chapter 3 at the
beginning it says if you come to a town
and you see a statue and you're not sure
is it just ornamental or is it
idolatrous so the mishner says well it
depends if it's holding a stick mention
some other things too the statue could
be holding but if it's holding a
stick then it's an idol because a
stick is a symbol of rulership the
leader holds a stick a
Mel so the statue is holding a moel it's
a symbol of leadership of dominance and
therefore you know that statue is an
idol so the stick represents
Authority Now with an idol it
Authority that comes from klippa from
the negative spiritual Realms but also
in kadosha there's the idea of
leadership and Authority which is also
symbolized by a
stick so the debba says that ebab by
giving his son this stick was
transferring to
him a new paradigm of leadership and
proceeds to
explain there there's a prophecy in
Zakaria you all with
me this is what the Reb does with a
two-line
story there's a prophecy in
Zakaria zakaya sees these sheep being
shepherded and he sees two sticks you
know Shepherds use sticks when they're
shepherding and he sees a mam
what does that mean a pleasant
stick and a
MIM a stick of violence or
brutality this is what zakarya sees in
his
prophecy speaks about it in in gamar in
sanadrin speaks about two different
styles of rabbis says the rabbis in the
land of Israel they were more mellow
they were more peaceful with each other
they were the makam style and in bubel
they were very
harsh like like Russians like liters you
know they used to bark at each other so
that they were the makim they were they
were tough guys but that's what it says
in the gor in sanadrin but in uh there's
a mimer h from
the so the madash explains that these
two sticks represent two Aras
of Jewish
history and in turn they represent two
redemptions two levels of
redemption why is a stick related to
Redemption when we left MIT it
says you're GNA leave with your sticks
in your
hands but when we left MIT what kind of
a stick you want to guess which was it
the Mak or the Mak was it the Pleasant
stick or the violent stick when we left
MIT the violent stick why did we need a
violent stick when we left mitam because
the the evil was still so powerful that
we're told what does Tanya explained to
us when it
says that the Jews they fled they
ran out of MIT why were they running at
that point par was
devastated who are they running
from ananya tells us they were running
from themselves because the was still so
strong if they didn't get out of MIT
immediately they would have fallen back
into their comfort zone the ra within
them would have overtaken them and
that's it God forbid there would be no
Exodus so they needed a they needed a
violent stick to address the evil they
needed to hit back the
evil but then when mesiah comes
it's going to
beem says and I will remove the spirit
of impurity from the face of the land
there will be no more
evil so you don't need to hit the evil
the Evil's
gone so in that case what kind of a
stick are we going to have when mhia
comes is what the explains the makam the
pleasant stick
so that ebba says that EAB in giving
this present this seemingly simple
present to his only child his son and
future
successor by giving him this
stick he gave him a new model an
unprecedented Model A Gad
model for
leading he transferred to
him the mulam the pleasant stick that
we're going to use to usher in the
Redemption and theb then explains that's
why the stick wasn't a simple stick what
did it have what was the handle made out
of Sil silver silver in L Kesh is CIF
CIF
is kis
longing
love I've yearned and longed and loved
and pined
to be close to return to my father's
house so the silver represents you get
the play on words the
theis represents the love what's the
makam the pleasant style of leadership
it's leadership with
love now that doesn't
mean that you abandon people now that
you're no longer beating them with a
makim now that you're no longer
brutalizing them it doesn't mean you
drop them off and you say okay you're
good you're on your own now I had two
modes rage and silence the rage is over
now I'm
silent right
no when we go into the
makam mode as the Gula draws
near we
don't leadership doesn't abandon
us parents don't abandon
children teachers don't abandon students
the doesn't abandon as we go into the
mode to the
contrary we're just is involved if not
more involved it's just a different
style of
involvement and the ju opposes these two
Styles what's the difference between the
two
Styles the Mak and the
makim theba says the difference between
the old way and the new
way is very simple he says in
Yiddish not
breaking nor
rather lifting up and drawing close so
instead of leading with
harshness with threats
with
shame now we
lead by telling people how great they
are that's ufh Haven lifting them up and
by including people in our lives that's
Susan bringing them
close so it's not that we've stopped
parenting no oh boy now
we've as we're getting started parenting
now the real parenting
begins o
lifting them up and drawing them
near the also describes these two
paradigms in terms of roten and
toog La audience here so I know I can I
can drop terms like that but I'll
translate it R is
Will Ty is pleasure in Crown Heights
everyone knows that Rin and Ty are both
makim they're both k
right but the difference between
them you guys all know this stuff what's
the difference
between and I'm not talking about
although obviously the way it's
experienced down here in uh in human
psychology is a derivative of the way
that it happens in in ilise but let's
talk about it in terms of The Human
Experience what's the between R and will
and pleasure so the Reb says very
simply
R will
willpower
breaks pleasure
attracts those are the two pares the old
one and the new one broken down in the
most simple language possible the old
style rain willpower it's my way or the
highway
R when you lead based on Willpower
someone's going to break and it ain't
going to be me right so when the
leadership leads based on authority of
willpower then those they lead either
conform or they shatter and that was the
old Paradigm tyo is a totally different
style pleasure kog is
pleasure it
attracts it doesn't mean that we're no
longer leading it doesn't mean that
we're no longer involved in our
children's lives it doesn't mean that
we've abandoned them God forbid doesn't
mean that now that we can't beat them
with the we have nothing to offer them
to the contrary now we've started
influencing them for real the real
influence you see when when you break
somebody
that's not
influence that's
coercion you've left them a shell of
themselves all you've done is you force
them to do what you need to make them do
and maybe in certain context and maybe
in certain eras in history that was that
was necessary maybe I don't know I
didn't live in that era I only live now
on the cusp of the
Redemption so we don't break people
anymore but here's the thing who has
more influence the one who breaks or the
one who attracts when you break somebody
there's nobody left over after the
process when you attract somebody the
process is just beginning hey this is
Shas tab you were just watching a clip
from this class if you want to get the
full context the full class that this
clip that you just watched with from you
watch right here click right here here