The Machlokes Rosh & Ran Regarding the 3 Yomim Tovim of Ba'al Te'achar & the Lomdus of the Grana"t

okay friends good morning I want to show with you a beautiful had a sh I understand how you have B byos how do you have so first the G said you know how you have by if you say when I want to be a I'll be another so if the guy delays he to which the gar asks well he didn't want so if he didn't want you're not over about so the G's first attempt is where a guy says I will not leave this world until I accept Naas where it's incumbent upon him to take and observe the nazus as soon as possible lest he leave the world immediately the ran asks when are you over if you don't he says when you don't accept a Zer immediately you're not over until three until three says the ran that's by that is by Carbono by Carbono when you accept upon yourself to ring then you're not over until you delay it three however by when somebody says I won't leave this world until I'm a nazer that implies you have to be azer right away fine then the gar brings another uh possibility in someone who made a and he's in the base so if Theus is not he's over right away ask what do you mean is says well he's delaying observing the nus of tahara according to that answer when are you about right away if you delay it then the says you're delaying sh let's say another delays shaving when are you about to right away and then marut says you're over on oh you're over comes the ran and the ran says according to this answer says my is according to that you wouldn't be until because according to this answer that it's of you're not over until three pass which means all the previous answers of the gar all the previous answers of the gar were saying you're right away somebody who says I'm not going to leave this world until I'm if he doesn't take on Theos right away he over someone who is makes a and he's in the he's over right away on B someone who delays shaving is over B right away way but when the is on then you're not over until pass right that's how thean learns that only this answer in the gar would be saying that you need to wait three regum until you over all the other attempts of the you'd be over about right away but not all the agree with the ran namely The Rush The Rush disagrees with the ran and the rush holds every answer of the you're never over until so for example look in the rush over here and the G's answer could go shazar sh okay the gar says the rush says if you make and you're in thee not like the r that you're over about immediately if you making and you're in the you're not over about until you remain in the for three and z and you don't become tahar so according to the rush the answer of the G of your in the it's only you remain that way for three and the rush earlier that I won't leave this world until I take nazos the rush also says the same thing here [Music] look says the rush even the Mand that says we're not concerned maybe a person would die so the Russ is bother by aasha not everybody says we're worried that somebody's going to if if somebody says to his wife here's a get a moment before I die there's an opinion she doesn't have to be worried every second he might die here says rush you have to be worried because it's going to be a long time says Rush if you delay his so we have a massive the rush and the r the rush says every time the gar gives a possibility that maybe you're over the rush says you're only over after whether it's somebody who says I won't leave this world until I'm AER whether it's someone who made whether it's somebody who delayed shaving you're not over until you three the says no someone who says I won't leave this world until I'm he's over if he doesn't immediately take someone who takes upon in he's over immediately someone who delays shaving he's over on B immediately the only time the r says that you're not over unless you wait three is if you delay bringing your car the sh is what is the rush and the r why does the r say is only a sheer in and the rush says is always a threee gem is always the shear so we come to one of the famous kakas in ch one of the famous pieces of the granat raali TR the gr was the rashash in Ren hired the grad to be the r and in the that I was to learn in in the in the comes from the so the comes from and the D learning comes from the granat and the granat has a a marvelous the that b is it that even though you need to bring I'm not to bring it until the end of three regum and I have three regum to bring it is the is is the our three the of my I am obligated to bring carban but I'm not obligated until three regum I I don't have an obligation until three regum pass but the moment three regum pass I'm done I'm nailed I violated it so is three the shear of my no or maybe no I'm to bring it right away I'm obligated to bring the caronus right away I just don't violate the a until three regum pass in other words are the three regum in the that I'm not M until three gum or no I'm right away it's just I don't violate the sin until three were gum pass in other words is my obligation that I need to bring it by three regm or is my obligation to bring it right away it's just I'm not going to be nailed for a crime until three regum pass so says the gr this is Aus the rush and the run the rush holds that I'm obligated to bring my caronus right away I'm obligated to do my to take care of my responsibilities immediately but I'm not nailed for AA until three regum pass therefore even if I say I won't leave this world until I take upon myself nazas so it's true I'm obligated to do the nerus right away but still I don't get a until three were going pass and even if someone's a so he's obligated right away to take upon himself naus of Tara but still we won't nail him for a sin until three we going pass and even if somebody delays shaving he's supposed to shave right away but he will never nail someone for a sin until three regum pass the opinion of the rush is three regum is we don't uh you don't incur guilt until three regum pass even though the obligation was immediate but the ran learns differently the ran learns the three regum is I am not to bring the carb until three and pass there's no yet not just I'm not guilty there's no obligation but what if I did obligate myself what if I said said I will not leave this world until I take upon myself nazus that means I'm obligating myself to be a nazer now so then the r says then I'm immediately and if somebody says somebody takes upon himself he's got to get out immediately to observe that neros and if somebody delays shaving he will he's obligated to shave right away these are self-inflicted obligations in other words the of three regum is that I'm not obligated to bring Carbono until three regum but if there's any other obligation and that would be sooner then if I don't fulfill that obligation sooner I'm let's take a look at this uh granat let's see if we could figure it out V you could be you could have the of the is it a she in fulfilling your the Torah set time that during the course of that time you have to fulfill your any within the appropriate time and after can delay it even a moment do we say it's the she in my I'm obligated to do it by three any time within three I'm obligated to do it which is we say um which is what the Run would hold and therefore if there would be a way to obligate myself sooner I would be sooner or maybe you'll say really I'm obligated to do right away and as soon as I delay I'm delaying but I don't I don't incur any guilt I'm not violating until three pass the is the in delay not in the says the the rush holds the rush who th out the always holds you're not over until three pass that's because he holds is a she in the delay and always is immediately I'm not over because me until three pass therefore the rush even though I delayed theer I'm not over until three pass not the same thing would be if somebody said carb if somebody said I take upon myself to bring a carbon immediately the rush would say you're not ever about to until three because the three go is not a Shear in the it's a Shear in the delay but the r hold is like the first sad that it's not a Shear in the delay the shear of gim is the she in when therefore that only applies it's three but you could be immediately and anytime you put a self-imposed deadline earlier you'll be over earlier that's why the ran learns throughout the you're always over right away except by that which thean says that if you say before two years I will be AER you're after even though he's saying I don't want it to be let's say somebody says I'll be another with within 2 years within three you're over you will not you will you will still be over after three and you don't have an extended two years because it's like your the says three so he says when you make a and you don't explain immediately the is not it's when you're if you say that it should be two years maybe that would not be like your because the t is not giving a in the the is giving a in the so but if I make my of two years in other words the Run holds that if somebody says I will be another within two years you're over as soon as three pass because your why because in the world of Iran the shear of three regum is the shear of when I am to take upon myself the nazos or the carban but according to the rush the the shear of three regalim is not a Shear in the it's a Shear in the delay and if I accept upon myself to right away I still won't violate the N the the I still won't violate B until three pass so if I say I'll be a within two years I'm not the never said when I'm to take Theos the T just says how much I have to delay so if let's I say I'll be in aerus within three within two years it could be I'm not violating that until three regum pass after the two years so basically the the ran who learns that only gives you three for but not for other thean holds three is the sheer in but if I impose an earlier I will be over about earlier but the rash holds that gim is not AAR in the gim is a Shear in the delay and I'm always right away so the fact that I am myself earlier will not make it that I don't have three regum to yet to still have flexibility in in other words in the world of the rush the three is a in the so therefore even if I'm myself earlier I still don't I'm still not violating an a until three pass and the rush the three in the so if I'm myself earlier then would be earlier okay so that's the subject of and this week one sh will be Monday night and we have to figure out when the other one will be because I have a wedding Tuesday night okay have a great day everyone recording stopped