Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
The Jerusalem Talmud concludes
Seder Moed with Tractate Moed Katan.
And the last Mishna there
ends with the verse from Isaiah:
“God shall wipe the
tears from every face.”
The commentaries explain that the
Mishna wants to end on a positive note
– “God shall wipe the
tears from every face” –
and therefore the Talmud, as well,
ends on a positive note:
“Flutes may be brought to the
house of feasting and rejoicing” –
even during Chol Hamoed,
when ordinary mundane
activities are limited,
one is permitted to bring flutes to
a joyous occasion and play them
– even though on the Three
Holy Festivals it is prohibited –
because, as the commentaries explain,
it is the rejoicing of a Mitzva.
Regarding this promise to
“wipe the tears from every face” –
the Talmud rules in
the laws of acquisitions:
“A reversible change
is not considered a change.”
One cannot establish ownership of
an object by making a change in it,
if that change can be reversed.
So too, even though there
are tears in the world
God will eventually
wipe them all away,
because at the outset of creation, death
was not a natural state of existence,
until man sinned.
And even after the sin,
first one has life,
long life,
and at its conclusion, temporarily,
there are, God forbid, tears…
The Mishna therefore
concludes, for all to know,
that the world will one day return
to its natural state of eternal life,
to a state of joy and light –
because, “God shall wipe away
the tears from every face.”
There is a profound allusion to this
in the teachings of Rabbi Isaac Luria,
that the numerical value of ‘<em>Dimah</em>–Tears’
is 120, which in Torah signifies <em>full</em> <em>life</em>.
But the individual letters
only add up to119,
so the word ‘<em>Dimah</em>’ as a whole is
counted as an additional 1, to reach 120.
Asks the Shomer Emunim:
What kind of game is this?
The numbers must be exact!
What do you gain by factoring
in the word as a whole?
If you’re interested in the real
numerical value, it’s only 119.
And he explains:
For certain concepts
the whole is greater
than the sum of its parts.
Focusing on all the details
will not enable you to grasp it.
In such a case, the calculation requires
you to also factor in the word as a whole
to indicate that there is a higher purpose
that brings meaning to all the details.
So too here, the Arizal states that
‘Tears’ equals 120, <em>full life</em>.
The explanation:
Tears have no true
purpose on their own.
And the proof is: They are temporary
– because “God shall wipe away all tears.”
So when we try to understand
the meaning of tears,
we must look to the wider
purpose which they serve.
What is the wider purpose of tears?
Since it is sin that brought
death and tears to the world,
so the purpose of tears
is to wash away sin.
Tears were brought into this
world temporarily, to rectify sin,
in order to bring man
to complete repentance.
Therefore, when the Mishna concludes,
“God shall wipe away all tears,”
Tosafos explains that
this is a positive ending.
Why is it so positive? Because it
indicates the <em>purpose</em> of tears.
What commandment do tears fulfill?
Tears are not a Mitzva on their own.
Maimonides explains
in his <em>Laws of Mourning</em>
that the purpose of
mourning and tears
is <em>repentance</em> –
that “The living will take it
to heart” and return to God.
Maimonides rules in
his code of Jewish Law,
that all the tears associated
with the <em>Laws of Mourning</em>
– which are the subject of the preceding
chapter of Tractate Moed Katan –
are in order to move
one to repentance,
through which “The living will take it
to heart” – while they are still alive.
When remorse for past sins spurs one to
unconditional repentance in this world,
then his past sins are forgiven,
and more so – they become
considered “like merits,”
and then, in the Alter Rebbe’s words,
they transform into “actual merits.”
It is this transformation that elevates
the Baal Teshuva above the Tzaddik.
This, then, is the common theme
of the Mishna and the Talmud.
The Mishna concludes that
tears are in fact a Mitzva
– which is why Torah law delineates
the various stages of mourning:
the first day,
the first three days,
seven days,
thirty days,
eleven months,
Yahrzeit, and so forth…
But it is a Mitzvah which
is an “incomplete service.”
In the Holy Temple, there
were two types of rituals:
One was called an
“incomplete service”
because it required a subsequent
ritual to complete it
– even though the first
ritual was certainly holy.
It was a service in the Holy Temple
– but not a “complete service.”
A “complete service” is one which
requires no subsequent action.
“<em>Dima</em> – Tears” without repentance are
an incomplete service, equaling only 119.
But when repentance is added,
it becomes complete – 120 –
and that is what the Talmud
is coming to add.
The Talmud’s function is to take
the succinct wording of the Mishna,
and reveal all its hidden
width, depth and breadth.
And that is why the Talmud here
ends off with bringing the flutes
to rejoice in the Mitzva –
because the true Mitzva is the result
of the tears of true repentance:
“God shall wipe away
the tears from every face,”
and then, as Maimonides
concludes in his <em>Laws of Fasts</em>,
“These days of mourning will be
transformed into days of rejoicing,
into days of good <em>Moed</em>”
– just like the term “Chol <em>Hamoed.</em>”
“<em>Dimah</em> – Tears” plus 1, equals 120,
which is the exact numerical
value of “<em>Moed,</em>”
for after all the tears are complete,
will come the ultimate rejoicing.