0:00 / 0:00
The Comparison Trap | How to Find Your Place with Rabbi Eliezer Breitowitz
104 views
Rabbi Eliezer Breitowitz explores the quiet feeling of “I’m not enough.” He shares personal stories, discusses heavy topics such as therapy, pornography, and why there is no such thing as the point of no return. Find your place in this world and your bliss rests there.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
I'm fond of quoting President George
Bush II
uh was once asked in a press conference
if he watched the news.
>> So he said, you know, why should I watch
the news? I am the news.
Comparisons are always dangerous.
If a person tells himself that I'm going
to be measured by the reonish lum by
comparison to other people, he'll always
fall short. What does it do to the
person who already has seen that image,
>> you know, and now is told that this will
remain in your head for the rest of your
life and there's no hope and you're
finished and you're you're a failure.
Well, where do you go from there? Person
has to seek his bliss. He has to find
that which will give him true
satisfaction in life. And I think that
if I have to convey one message, I would
say do this for yourselves. Do this for
your children.
Beyond Therapy, bringing you emotional
well-being.
>> Thank you so much for the Shiva for
agreeing to do this and talk about
emotional well-being and people's mental
health in terms of yeshiva bakim and in
terms of all of us. We all go through
difficult times and what could happen is
is that a person could spiral into it
could spiral into depressing thoughts.
they could spiral into that very hard
moment in their lives. And how does
Rashiva go about managing those times
when things are very hard?
>> No, I'll mention that this this
phenomenon can affect even the greatest
person. I'll share something personal
with you. Many many years ago, this was
in the first years of our marriage. Uh
we had a child who was hospitalized for
a extended period of time. And at that
time I was learning in Kyle. I was a
younger man. So the expectation was I'd
be their morning sader and afternoon
seder and night sader. They'd be
devoting much of my time to learning.
And now we have this this crisis which
meant uh that the regular seder hay the
regular order of things was just totally
disrupted. I was sleeping every night in
the hospital.
>> And uh by the way from that I learned I
could sleep anywhere today. I can sleep
sitting up. I can sleep standing up. you
know uh I I trained myself
>> middle of the year
>> in the middle of a year everything would
have fallen apart during that time but
interestingly during that time I was
giving a dioir
and I told myself that I'm going to keep
that up because whatever happens the
rest of the day wherever I have to be um
I'm going to keep that shear up and uh I
did it and it was interesting that when
uh our child was diagnosed with a
serious illness So um Dafimi had just
begun mas Noir which is a very very hard
maka
>> and uh that was my commitment. I'm going
to keep up with Dimei for Noir and every
day that was one hour I was away from
the hospital. I went gave the shir came
back and that meant I had to prepare.
This was before art scroll before there
were lot of all I had was a a gumar and
uh it's a difficult mak it but that was
the structure that was the anchor that
kept me afloat in a very very very
difficult time and I think that this
might be a piece of good advice for
anybody and everybody was there are
difficult times keep at it keep up um
your fixed
starim
for for Torah and you'll weather the
storm. I think that
one of the things that is good about
Judaism is that the structure of mitzvah
uh keeps us in line even in the
difficult times was a person who uh
davins but sib a person who has fixed
times for learning. So of course
there'll be times that he's more
inspired, times that he's less inspired,
times that everything is going well,
times that things are difficult, but if
he's able to maintain his program of
mitzvah, maintain some type of a
schedule. So this will keep him afloat
in the difficult times which eventually
will pass. Interestingly, this is easier
for men than for women. Whereas women
>> have a schedule
>> don't have the same type of schedule,
>> right? So sometimes for them it's a lot
harder to uh provide for themselves that
anchor that they need in times of
crisis. But for men I would say this is
certainly something that's that's worth
doing.
>> What would the Shiva tell a woman
>> would tell her that it's very important
especially at a time like this to
establish for yourself some type of
regimen something you're going to do
every day
without missing. You know this really,
you know, points to the essential
difference between a woman and a man in
terms of Jewish life. The man is like an
employee.
He has a job. His employer tells him you
do this at this time and do this at this
time and do this at this time and the
structure is provided. The woman is more
like the entrepreneur. She's the boss.
You know, she has to decide how to use
her time and what to prioritize and
that's a big challenge. But it can be uh
accomplished
>> a feeling of I'm not good enough. I
compare myself to him. Compare myself to
him. Or anybody in life, they compare
themselves other people. They're chasing
status or whatever they're chasing to be
the better this, the better that. And
they feel not good enough. They feel I'm
just not good enough. Whether it's I'm
not good enough for Hashem, I'm not good
enough for my friends. Um and they're
constantly fighting this battle of I'm
just not good enough.
>> Well, this is a serious problem. Um
comparisons are always dangerous.
If a person tells himself that I'm going
to be measured by the reonish lum by
comparison to other people, it'll always
fall short. There's always another
person who is better in some way,
another person who's better in a
different way, and a third person who's
better in a third way. and uh I'll
always be deficient in relation to
somebody in some aspect of my life. But
a person has to know that um the rebon
designs each person's nishama and the
parameters of each person's mis in life
um as suited for that person's nishama.
So therefore every person is born into a
certain family. He's born at a certain
place in a certain time. Um he's born
and given certain opportunities, certain
natural talents. And these are for his
unique challenge. And you never want
someone else's challenge because you've
been given the tools for your challenge.
You haven't given the tools for his
challenge.
>> The expectations that has of every
individual are different.
The uh problem is that uh school by its
very nature can be competitive
>> and sometimes schools encourage that.
They figure that competition is a way of
um driving people to excellence but it
often is a mistake. It it really is not
a question of how I compare to somebody
else. The question is how do I compare
to what I can do? And I think that
educators
rebel have to be conscious of this. But
when they speak to a boy to make a
comparison and say look at what that
person did, you can do the same.
>> There's always a mistake. That person
may have talents, skills, abilities that
this person doesn't have. Um rather you
have to be able to point to a young man
and say or young lady and say know these
are your talents these are your skills
this is what you can do and uh you can
be the best you can be will it be equal
to the other person
um not necessarily but that's not
important you know there's a story
that's told it's an interesting story
that um know the altar of Slovaka who
was a master you know Mann
So there once was a boy learning in the
yeshiva and uh the boy came one morning
to yeshiva and he learned the entire
morning. He learned bas learned well.
And uh on his way out of the banish, I
guess going to lunch, the altar called
him over and he said says, "You must be
a terrible Russia." He said so said the
boy was shocked. What an accusation. I I
sat in all morning I learned. Says, "You
must be a terrible Russia." He says,
"Why?" Because if you went to Russia
after such a successful morning of
learning, he says you should walk out
with a smile that goes from ear to ear.
>> Yeah.
>> Says if you walk out with a sense of
being uh not ecstatic.
>> Yeah.
>> It must be there's something wrong. And
the the altar wanted to point out
something which is very important that
um you know a boy comes to yeshiva and
he learns four hours bas and uh he
understands the gumar on his level
that's a tremendous accomplishment that
should give so much satisfaction so much
joy
>> that if you don't sense it there's
something wrong
>> and then for one boy would be I guess 20
minutes or one boy would be whatever
whatever the amount that person is
>> yeah of course and and and I think that
that um a lot of people are down on
themselves because they feel that in the
vast scheme of things what is what is
this uh
um did I really accomplish anything did
I really achieve or what I could have
achieved but a person has to be uh in a
sense you have to be happy with your lot
and that's even in spirituality even in
um you have to have tremendous
satisfaction and pride and a sense of
accomplishment and that will be the
force that will proud you and push you
to achieving greater heights in the
future. But when you have a system where
there's one winner and many losers,
well, the losers are uh losers.
>> Losers.
>> And I I I think that um by the way, this
is a misconception that really has to be
um addressed. There's a famous
the say that the Mikra. There are a
thousand that enter the system, the
educational system for Mikra, for Kish.
And then there are Maya, there are
hundred that exit to Mishna. And then
from the hundred, there are 10 that exit
to Gumarra. And from the 10 that go into
Gumra, there's
one becomes fit and worthy of being a
pisake, a person who can issue
rulings in Jewish law. So people
mistakenly believe that the point of
this kazal is that the system is set up
in such a way that uh onetenth of 1%
is successful
>> and the rest are failures and that's how
it's supposed to be. It's a mistake.
That's not what mean is saying is
something else which is that everyone
has a place in Torah. In other words, a
thousand go into Mikra, 900
may remain there, but they'll be very
very happy and successful and
accomplished on that level. There'll be
a hundred, they can go to the next
level.
>> Um, of those hundred, 90 will remain at
that level of Mishna and be happy and
successful and thrive on that level. 10
will go beyond the 10 will go to
Gammorra and they'll thrive at that
level and one will bear. In the
meantime, the remaining 999 will each
find their place in the hierarchy of uh
Torah and uh learn with great levels of
satisfaction. Part of the problem is
that um our educational system is geared
to the 10 that enter to Gumarra.
>> Yeah.
>> And this is a serious deficiency. Um, we
probably need an educational system that
could allow people to thrive at
different levels. And u, you know, maybe
it will be addressed someday. You know,
I don't know. I'm I'm certainly not uh
the person who's setting policy for the
Jewish world, but I'm just pointing out
that this is something that that could
be addressed. And I think it will go a
long way towards
um addressing some of the
negative feelings that people have. the
lack of selfworth, the lack of
accomplishment that then
>> emerge in all sorts of uh
>> pathologies I think could be addressed
if the educational system was was geared
to the needs of the individuals and
provided them an opportunity to really
thrive.
>> Yeah. The unique thing that the rashiva
just said was the they think that so a
lot of our yeshiva is for lower boys but
they all focus not all most of them
focus on garum she was saying unique
thing that don't necessarily focus on
garum find something else that the boy
is interested in learning right
>> okay know the assumption that we have to
learn Gumarra because Gumarra is so uh
intellectually stimulating
that may be the case but is that what
kids are looking for is every boy
looking for an intellectual challenge.
>> Some boys may be looking more for a
feeling of accomplishment and a feeling
of accomplishment often comes from the
completion of whole things. Right? So if
a boy can uh
um learn Mishna and in a relatively
short time finisha that might give him a
sense of satisfaction that uh sitting on
a blat for a month won't give him
>> right
>> you know there's a a puk which says
that the days of a poor man are are
wretched and uh a person who's
good-hearted. For him, life is an
ongoing uh celebration. And there's a
mus
what these halves of the verse refer to.
But there's one interpretation that says
that
refers to bal and refers to balishna.
And the interpretation is given in one
of the who says that uh the person who
learns garra how often can he make a
seal very very rarely. says call and his
life is wretched. Says the person learns
Mishna every day can make a mish for him
life is a celebration that's pointed to
a certain truth. People need to feel a
sense of accomplishment.
>> Was in learning garum
in depth. It's very very hard to
quantify the achievement.
>> Yeah.
>> In other words, it's very subtle. When a
person uh learns garum in the manner of
bikus, he can say I covered this many
blot. I covered this many makas. And in
the Mishna certainly that's the case.
For example, you know, if a boy um is
down on himself, you know, he may um
feel the need to
satisfy
what is missing artificially,
>> right?
>> You know, this could lead to uh alcohol
abuse. basically lead to drug abuse. Um
you know if a person feels marginalized
because his friends are performing at
one level and he's performing at a
different level that could result in a
whole different set of uh you know
social issues. So I I I think that that
um
the lack of of accomplishment can be the
root cause of of of serious serious
problems and once those problems uh
manifest themselves then the solutions
become very very very difficult.
>> Right. Right. So let's say we have a boy
in front of us right now who's coming to
Shiva and is he's struggling with his
struggling with anxiety and feeling down
about himself. Shiva tries to tell him
um maybe see a therapist or this could
even be an adult. I mean this is but if
the boy is very very hesitant to go he
feels ashamed to go. He feels not good
enough if he goes like he already feels
not good enough and now he's going to
feel more not good enough. um and he
doesn't want he doesn't want to go. What
would the Shiva tell or a woman or
anybody who who feels this way?
>> Okay, the first thing is this. Let's
talk about the the long-term solution to
this problem. I think we have to
eliminate the stigma which is associated
with uh
mental health professionals.
A person wouldn't hesitate if uh he had
a medical problem. was if a person uh
had a problem breathing or problem with
his digestion or chest pains uh you know
he'd go to a doctor and u no problem and
he would fully understand that he needs
help and uh this could greatly improve
his life. Somehow we have this uh sense
that uh
a a an emotional problem somehow is
indicative of a moral failing and
therefore there's a certain guilt
associated with the fact that I need
this type of uh help. So we have to put
that aside. First of people, a lot of
people say that I should bring on a for
here would be very helpful. I bring on
somebody and they'll talk about not who
somebody just talk about their own
experiences with their mental health and
their own challenges and their own how
they got come through them and whatever
and I tell them find me somebody who's
willing to come on. Nobody's willing to.
People are nervous to say that they ever
struggled in any way. And
>> yeah, but again, but but a lot of the
struggles again are are um physical and
again biochemical in in source. And uh
sometimes very they're addressed with
medication. Yeah.
>> And uh you know the person uh is able to
successfully function as a result of
treatment and therefore there shouldn't
be a moral stigma attached to that. This
is um if anything it it works the other
way. Other words, let's say you have a
person who who has a problem and because
of his pride or his arrogance decides
well um I don't need help. I can solve
this problem myself. That's a moral
failing.
>> If a person doesn't have the the uh
self-awareness to understand that he
needs help.
>> Yeah.
>> And thinks I have a problem. I can solve
this myself. I can address myself. I'm
invincible and I'm self-sufficient.
>> That itself is is a serious moral
failing. Yeah.
>> So I think this is the first thing that
we have to impress upon people that
there's no stigma attached and you know
the idea of advice
is um you know I I I I think something
that we all have to uh appreciate. You
know, the Torah itself says that uh a
wife is meant to be an Azerdo.
A person isn't meant to live uh in a
bubble. He's meant to share. He's meant
to commiserate. Uh he's meant to seek
advice. And again, seeking advice from
people who have valuable experience, you
know, is a a very very commendable
thing. So I think that we have to work
to eliminate the stigma. Again,
you know, finding a therapist is like
like a shock. It's not always a match.
And sometimes the particular therapist
just isn't a match with a particular
young man for whatever reason. Or a
person goes to a therapist and doesn't
click and they think, well, maybe I'll
keep going. I'll keep going. I keep
going. Keep going. And then, uh, you
know, they've been going to that
therapist for six months and, uh,
nothing has happened. There's been no
progress. and uh
you know they realize that it's going
nowhere and they'll just give up. That's
unfortunate that that probably it would
seem to me that if it's a sh if it's a
match then it should be something which
is apparent in a relatively short period
of time. I'm not saying in one session,
but two, three, four sessions, you know,
if the you can connect,
>> there's a connection, right? If it's is
if it's moving somewhere and if it's
not, it may be time to begin looking for
a new therapist. Um before the person
becomes sour on the idea of therapy
generally.
>> Yeah.
>> Right. In other words, as long as he
thinks, okay, the therapy is a good
idea, but this particular therapist is
not a match. Okay, he'll try somebody
else. If he waits six months, he might
just say, "What's the point? I'm
finished."
>> And that will be a shame because he
probably could be helped by someone
different.
>> Yeah. Does Rashiva feel that everybody
could benefit from therapy at some point
in their life? What does she feel about
that? Now this is an interesting thing
that um you know getting back to Sigman
Freud you know if you wanted to be one
of his disciples you had to subject
yourself to psychoanalysis.
Um you see he held that psychoanalysis
was not a treatment for mental illness
per se. Psychoanalysis was a process of
self-discovery coming to know yourself.
We think that uh the purpose of seeing a
therapist is because there's some type
of mental illness, some pathology that
needs to be addressed. And I think
that's that's the mistake. I think that
that everyone probably would benefit
from it. Um
you know, if it wasn't for the expense,
>> yeah,
>> in terms of money, in terms of time,
>> um you know, I I think more people would
would want to do this. And you know, I
think that that that everyone needs
someone to talk to and and and share
with. And um
you know, I I think that that nowadays
um rebim
are much more um comfortable filling
that role than they once were. Yeah.
>> Um nowadays I think that uh in most
yeshivists at least war enlightened ones
it's understood that that a very very
important part of the reby's role
>> Yeah.
>> is to be that type of counselor.
>> Obviously it's very important for the
rebby to know what he doesn't know.
>> Yeah.
>> And this is an important thing where
limits are. Sometimes people don't know
what limits are and they think that a
problem comes to my table I can
necessarily address it. You have to know
at what point you need to refer to a
professional. Uh I I I think they have
to understand that this is part of their
responsibility,
>> not just to be uh not just
>> not just for the year they're they're uh
it's it's a lifelong commitment.
>> Yeah. Rashiva felt that Rashiva went
back to Israel. Is that something Shiva
felt connected to?
>> Um
let's put it this way. I I I did feel a
very very strong connection to uh to
some of my um you know weber who was
naasha in my years there. He was like
the second in command
>> but we were very close and uh you know
until he he was nif um
we remained close and and I would
consult with him often. Um, you know,
sadly, sadly, sadly, uh, at some point
you you reach an age
>> where Euroba are no longer here in in
this world.
>> But you still ask yourself the question,
what would they have said?
>> Yeah.
>> You know, in this situation and
sometimes if you have a relationship
which is um deep enough and and long
enough, sometimes you can you can even
answer that. No, I think that the
Rashida would have said this, he would
have said this and maybe that could
provide some guidance.
>> Um, yeah, I guess when you get older,
this is always the challenge like who
who do you who do you speak to?
>> And um,
>> so what what does Rashiva do now? How
does Rashiva like
>> I don't know maybe
I can't tell you that my mental health
is what it should be necessarily.
um
>> you know
but I think there is a certain truth to
the fact that um you know when you're in
your 60s
the issues that emerge are really reruns
of issues that were u applicable in your
50s and then your 40s and your 30s and
your 20s and your teens
>> later to take that Even if that person's
not around.
Yeah. The um
so challenges today are different than
the challenges in the past. Every
generation has their own unique
challenges. What would Rashiva feel I
guess besides the basic technology
challenge because that's
the common theme but the the um what are
the challenges of boys today that affect
their mental health, their emotional
well-being? what does see that are
common challenges and that are unique to
today or what's going on in the world
today. Now you mentioned you know
technology
and um you know I I I think that there
are a lot of people that that present
the idea that technology is a unique
unprecedented challenge and the truth is
in in many many ways it is just the same
challenge
um with uh a modern twist. Uh let's say
for example
what are some of the issues that relate
to technology? First of all, it's a
tremendous time waster. Well, we wasted
time back then, too. I mean, maybe the
uh the internet has made time wasting
more efficient, but but there were
plenty of ways of wasting time uh 30
years, 40 years ago, and 50 years ago.
So, uh it's not a new problem.
um
pornography,
you know, it existed then too. Is it
more accessible today? Yes, it's more
accessible today. But to say that this
is a new problem, you know, it's not a
new problem. It's a problem.
>> It's much more accessible.
>> As I said, so the accessibility doesn't
mean it's essentially different.
>> A buffer today, a bucker today could
access this type of this pornography
type of stuff in a second.
>> 100%. I'm just pointing out it doesn't
mean that it's a fundamentally different
problem. Um you know boys were always
interested in girls. No this is hasn't
changed from the shi raas. Yeah,
>> but uh you know the questions of
accessibility don't make these
fundamentally different problems,
>> right? They are just um problems that
have become more uh intense because
theility has gone up. Yeah,
>> but I I think that there may be a set of
problems that that is um unique and um
it's you know there there's a uh an
acronym you know FOMO you know fear of
missing out missing out
>> which uh I I think is maybe a unique
problem
>> social pressure
>> the world the world has become more
accessible popular culture
>> and Um and therefore it's uh it it there
is this sense that I have to participate
in uh the world or else I'm being left
out.
>> There's this desire to be part of the
world.
>> Yeah.
>> And to join in and uh not be left out.
I'm fond of quoting President George
Bush II
uh was once asked in a press conference
if he watched the news,
the television news.
>> So he said, you know, why should I watch
the news? I am the news,
>> you know, and I think that that we have
to have a similar attitude to say that
why do I have to participate
>> in in the culture of the society?
I am the center of the world. In other
words, as a member of Claudia show, I'm
I'm uh I'm the newsmaker. I don't need
to see what they're doing and you know
which movies are running for the Academy
Awards and whatnot. What I'm doing is
important. Yeah. When we understand that
that we're doing work which is
infinitely valuable by comparison to
things that are by comparison totally
totally insignificant. Um then a person
will be filled with a sense of pride a
sense of accomplishment. Be less tempted
to want to follow closely what everyone
else is doing. Certainly won't feel a
sense of of missing out. And I I I think
that will lead to greater satisfaction
and and greater mental health, if you
will.
>> Yeah.
>> Because they're not going to be feeling
um sense of alienation from things that
are truly important.
>> Yeah. Yeah. We are the news. Very
powerful statement. Um the Shiva
mentioned before pornography and that is
a issue that um is very scary and reason
I want to talk about it is because let's
say a bucker gets stuck in it buck
watches it right and the problem is is
that there's right away two things or an
adult there's right two things there's
an automatic pull to it it's like a drug
it's the pleasure um signals go on and
number two tremendous amount of shame
both those things are the two biggest
causes of addiction. Now, what happens
is the boy feels so much shame, feels so
terrible about himself, doesn't want to
tell anybody. So, what does he do? He
knows something could give him pleasure,
goes right back to it. And the the scary
part is it's it's not an uncommon issue.
People get stuck in this cycle because
they they can't get out of it and
they're they're stuck in it. And it's an
unfortunate issue that we're dealing
with and particularly because of the
shame and because of all that and and it
is bad. But what do what do we what does
what does she tell such a buck or such a
an adult such a
>> see I'm not an expert in in in this
issue. uh I don't know if there anyone
who is but I I do want to mention one
thing which I think is important to know
that I think a lot of the publications
and a lot of the drious that are being
given are conveying a message which is
actually counterproductive and causes
more harm than good. Let's say for
example you want to impress upon a
person the dangers of the internet and
you tell the person if you see
something on the internet which is
inappropriate
>> it will remain in your head for the rest
of your life
>> and you are finished
>> this is this is the end. And a lot of
the people think that this is a a
productive technique because it'll scare
people away and stop them from even uh
looking
>> right
>> and so on and so forth. Okay,
maybe they're right. Maybe we'll scare
some people off. What does it do to the
person who already has seen that image?
>> Yeah.
>> You know, and now is told that this will
remain in your head for the rest of your
life and there's no hope and you're
finished and you're you're a failure.
Well, where do you go from there?
>> Yeah.
>> Okay.
>> Yeah. Maybe you're stuck in it. You're
stuck. If the only thing you know, the
only thing you know now is that oh, if I
want to feel okay, I could go back to
it. Yeah.
>> And that's disaster. But let's say you
would convey a different message and you
would say that you know every day is a
new day
and what happened yesterday you put
behind you and uh every day is a fresh
start
>> right
>> maybe that's a more productive message
>> right
>> for the person who already was already
stumble
>> right
>> and I think that this is something that
that um we would have to uh you know
press upon that young man let's say the
boy comes would come to the likelihood
of this happening is very slim. But
let's say a boy
>> the
>> boys don't want to talk about it. That's
that's what keeps it going. That's the
problem.
>> Let's say a boy in a moment of cander
would would would come and say that you
know he's grappling with this problem.
>> Yeah.
>> And you know he's watched this he's done
this he's seen this etc. and come to me
and I would say okay that was yesterday
>> right
>> and today is today
>> right
>> and uh let's start for a new beginning
and uh just you should know that doesn't
mean that every day is going to be
perfectly successful
>> right
>> the fact that today you had a good day
doesn't mean tomorrow will be a good day
tomorrow might be uh it'll slip back
>> but the important thing is that that
generally there should be an upward
direction like the stock market
>> the person will Well, the person will
tell their Shiva, um, okay, that's very
nice, but I'm already a Russia. I'm a
terrible person. I did the worst of in
the world. Like, just by looking at the
and and the person feels completely
their their life is over. Like, not life
is over, but their Yiddish is over.
>> But it's not true.
>> It's not true.
>> That's the point. The point is that it's
not true. Yeah.
>> In other words, there's no such thing,
>> right, as as uh the point of no return,
>> right?
the the amuna of chuva
means that uh a person can always change
right
>> and it's important to understand that we
talk about
>> other words we think that karat has to
be this burning sense of of remorse
>> that I'm I'm totally pained my heart is
feels like it's been stamped
on the simplest level just means that I
understand. No, I don't want that,
>> right?
>> I I I wish I didn't get into that. It's
a mistake. I would like to change. And
that's already a chuva. And I think that
um you know, it it's important for for
uh talum to know
that um everyone grapples with these
issues
and uh
what she was saying. You're talking
about, you know, things that a person
shouldn't see and a person shouldn't
look at.
>> And uh, you know, obviously, look, there
are levels.
>> You know, there's hardcore pornography.
>> And, uh, there's looking at a a pretty
girl passing by, which are two different
things, but not essentially different,
just differences in magnitude.
>> Yeah. And you know a boy who thinks that
his problem is unique and and who can
understand that has to know that his his
rebum um
have grappled with the same issues maybe
again not to the same extent but same
types of issues and maybe are still
grappling with the same issues right
>> you know there's a famous story of you
in a meeting I guess and some people in
this house maybe it was and there was a
girl who was uh helping in the house
helping his son
>> and she's walking in and walking out and
>> and the just at one point says what does
she think we're Malib this girl is
walking
was talking about
>> you know he was an older man at the time
>> but you know there's a girl walking
about he said this this is a even for
him
>> whatever this means
>> I'm not going to try to interpret the
story but the point
We all grapple with that.
>> Yeah.
>> Right. And that a boy should think that
his rebal and I'm the only person
>> Yeah. that struggles with this
>> who struggles with this is is is a
tragic thing because this is a problem
that we all we all face and this is the
nature of the world in which we live.
>> Right. Just for Shiva saying this, I can
imagine if a bucker is listening to
who's struggling with this and Shiva
says this, that immense shame is already
released somewhat because if Bakar feels
like oh I'm okay then the bakar can get
out of the cycle which is amazing thing
a very powerful
>> 100% 100% men are interested in women
has been the case from the onset of the
bria
>> this is not a new uh issue
>> um it's always been the
And there's no one who is exempt from
this. And uh
you know it's important for for
everybody to understand that um
they're not alone
and they're not unique.
>> Right? And it's also important to
understand that a rebi let's say and the
rebi is happily married and he has a a
family and children and and a wife and a
very very settled home and so on and so
forth that there's a strong likelihood
that perhaps when this was a teenager he
was grappling with simp similar problems
>> right
>> and it didn't prevent him from being
able to get married and have a
relationship and have a success
uccessful family and so on and so forth.
The same thing with you. In other words,
what do you think? You think because you
have this this uh interest. So it means
that you'll never be able to get
married. You'll never be able to have a
family. You'll never be able to have a
proper relationship with a wife etc.
Says don't don't assume that. Don't
assume that.
>> Interesting.
>> Right. Don't assume that because could
be that these people also had it. just
that they they're now past that
>> I wanted to thank you so much for his
time. I wanted to ask the Shiva closing
question as follows that if the Shiva
could have everybody in the community
listening message about mental health
emotional well-being shouted from the
rooftops everybody heard it what would
that message be several messages one one
message
is that in structuring your life
you should find the thing that will give
you happiness and satis satisfaction.
Um, do I have time for a story?
>> Yeah, sure.
>> Okay. Let me tell you years ago, uh, I
started a yeshiva in California in San
Diego and San Diego was not a natural
place for yeshiva. There wasn't a lot of
funding available and uh there wasn't a
large community that was interested in
the yeshiva. So a lot of the fundraising
involved going to Los Angeles and
speaking to people there who were more
understanding. So I was driving a lot,
>> right?
>> So I would uh listen in the car to to
books on tape.
>> So I was once listening to a book by
famous writer Joseph Campbell wrote a
book on the power of myth.
>> Interesting
>> mythology. Okay. And he said there are
certain themes that are common to the
mythologies of many many uh countries,
many societies. And one of them is this
thing of the mythic quest. There was you
have people that were searching for
something, you know, Jason and the
Argonauts searching for the golden
fleece or the holy grail or whatever it
was.
>> And he said that that all these these
myths of the mythic quest were really
symbolic of people seeking to find their
bliss.
>> Interesting. In other words, that they
were structuring their lives in a way to
find that which would give them
satisfaction and happiness.
And everyone at some point has to ask
themselves the question like, am I doing
what I really want to do? Is this going
to make me happy? Is this going to give
me satisfaction?
And I remember I'm listening to this as
I'm driving to Los Angeles trying to
raise money to keep our yeshiva afloat.
>> And and I had this question. Is this
really what I want to do the rest of my
life? fund raise.
>> Was I started this yeshiva because I had
an idea of what I'd like to accomplish
with the yeshiva, but but now I'm
spending inordinate amount of time just
in survival mode to keep it alive.
>> So, I was thinking about this. Anyway,
the next day
>> I'm back in San Diego
>> and I'm looking in the the newspaper
>> and there's an article about Bill Walsh.
Now, who was Bill Walsh? Bill Walsh was
the the coach of the San Francisco
49ers. I think he won four Super Bowls.
I mean he was a big coach
>> and then he left the coaching he became
a commentator for NBC sports and after a
year he left that and he went back to
coaching college football in Stanford
and there was an article in the paper
interviewing him and I'm reading this
this article and they asked him like
like why did he
you know leave um television
broadcasting where he was making a lot
of money to go back to college coaching.
So he says that he was a fan of Joseph
Campbell
and he was reading in one of Joseph
Campbell's books about the idea of the
mythic quest, finding your bliss.
>> And he asked himself, "Is this what I
want to do?"
>> This is the next day.
>> The next day, "Is this what I want to
do?" No, coach. No, no, be a
broadcaster. Yeah.
>> And he said, "No, what he really wants
to do is work with kids." So he gave up
all the money and he went back to
coaching college football which is
really what he wanted to do to seek his
bliss. And I have to tell you that that
episode was a a very strong um push and
my decision to ultimately close that
yeshiva.
>> Wow.
>> And ultimately that brought me to
Toronto and
>> and there but I think that this is this
is a fact. A lot of people find
themselves in situations and
predicaments where their their lives are
structured in such ways that that they
have no satisfaction or little
satisfaction.
>> Yeah.
>> And really, you know, they they want to
do something else. I remember when I was
sitting Shiva for my father.
So the family barber came, he was a
Jewish fellow and uh know as kids he cut
our hair and you know
>> and and but I never really had a
conversation with him and I left Yeshiva
home for Yeshiva when I was 14 and after
that I you know maybe I got a haircut by
him.
>> Anyway, but he came for the Shiva and I
was talking to him
>> and I asked him says if he enjoyed being
a barber and he said he hated every
minute of it
>> really. So I said, "So, so why did you
do it?" So he says, "Well, he was an
immigrant. He came after the Holocaust.
What could he do?" He had no skills. He
had no education, right? But he figured
he could cut hair. So he became a
barber. So I says, "Well,
what would you have done if if you could
have done anything?"
>> So he says he would have gone into
gardening. He loved gardening. This was
his hobby.
>> He loved planting things and growing
things and nurturing things. And and if
he could have turned that into a
parnosa,
>> right,
>> he would have done that. It was a
fascinating thing. And I think a lot of
people are like that. They're they're in
jobs, they're in professions, they're in
situations where they just have no no
satisfaction, no happiness. And you're
wondering why are are they so,
you know,
>> right,
>> disturbed?
If I give everyone a message, I would
say that that that the most important
thing is you should do something which
you feel is meaningful, which gives you
satisfaction, which gives you happiness.
And uh if you have that, you'll be going
a long way towards addressing uh any
possible questions of of mental health.
Yeah. And I think that okay even if you
feel that um it's too late for yourself
know don't make that mistake with your
children
>> when enforcing them in a way
>> forcing them in a way sometimes know we
vicariously want to live our fantasies
to our children. Yeah.
>> So you know how many times have I seen
the parent who uh has this dream that
his child should become a doctor. I
remember had it once that there was a
there was a a boy in the yeshiva and his
parents had his career all planned out.
He's a normal doctor, but this boy's
Achilles heel was math. He couldn't do
math. Well, if you can do math, he
couldn't do science. Couldn't do
science. He's not getting into medical
school. So, was finished
>> and and I remember speaking to the
parents telling them, listen, it says
this boy is not going to go to medical
school. He's not going to become a
doctor. He can't do math. This is
>> everyone is good at something, but not
everyone is good at everything. and this
boy math is his downfall
>> and the parents couldn't couldn't accept
it. But interestingly, the boy went into
a business field. I don't want to
identify exactly what it was because I
don't want uh people to guess who it
was. And he became very very very
extremely successful.
>> Oh wow.
>> Extremely successful
>> in doing what he wanted was good for
him.
>> He was good at doing. This goes back
also to Yeshiva said earlier about a boy
in yeshiva um like each boy in yeshiva
being able to do what the learning that
they should be doing meaning the
learning that they connect to and this
is really a common theme that she was
saying throughout life is that you have
to be able to do what works for what
makes you happy not what can make the
other person happy or what the you know
>> this limo or that lim that style of
learning
>> yeah I think it's one more important
thing that that a person has to
understand through bonum didn't put us
in this world to be martyrs to the
cause, right? Put us in this world, you
know, less like says to enjoy and the
person has to seek his bliss. He has to
find that which will give him true
satisfaction in life. And I think that
if I have to convey one message, I would
say do this for yourselves. Do this for
your children. Look, everybody's
different. You know, there are some
people that it'll be in in Talmatyra.
Some people it'll be inid. Some people
will be in, you know, other forms of
asos. Some people will be in in pursuing
a profession um
a profession that may be of benefit to
the community as a whole.
>> And uh
you know I once was walking in the
street.
>> Yeah.
>> And uh you may remember Mr. pearls. We
had the butcher and people it's only a
memory now.
>> Yeah.
>> And uh he stopped me and picked me up
and had a conversation with I can't say
that I ever had conversation with him
before. We were cruising in the car
>> and and I came to understand that he
really felt that his providing kosher
meat to the community was a mission
>> and it gave him tremendous satisfaction.
>> Wow. that he was able to do this for the
community and and it wasn't just a way
of making money. It was something that
he really passionate about. And I said,
"Wow, that's that's that's a beautiful
thing
>> to be able to to to do something." And
it's not just about making money, but
it's about, you know,
living a life of of meaning and purpose.
And and everyone is entitled for that.
And that's what the wants. He doesn't
want you to be miserable. want you to
feel that you're sacrificing for the
cause,
>> but that to the contrary, you are
finding your bliss in doing something
which is of value to others. That's a
well-lived life and that everyone is
entitled to.
>> Beautiful. Thank you so much Rashiva for
coming.
>> Thank you.
>> And speaking about it, actually there
we're in yeshiva
which lives a principles that Rashiva
explained and thank you so much. Thank
you.
Up next
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
7 months ago
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
6 months ago
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
6 months ago
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
6 months ago
From this channel
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
1 months ago
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
6 months ago
Beyond Therapy with Tzvi Felder
6 months ago
Trending
Elliot Kress
2 months ago
Elliot Kress
2 months ago
Rabbi Alon Anava
13 years ago
Rabbi Alon Anava
13 years ago
Rabbi Alon Anava
13 years ago