The Character Witnesses - Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 22a-b, Beginning of Chapter 2

the yeshiva dotnet shot a vomits luckless we start a new paddock today Parrish a knee that Huff basil Dallas on the bottom Amina and McKinney no sir the last mission us of para Calif dealt with kidney Shahi dish the months when business sends out solution to notify everybody about the new month and the next Mishnah about the months when aid this can be mcconnell Shabbos in order to come used to be every month today after the urban based on Victor's Roberto diamonds are made and only Nissen and history and then the Commissioner spoke about relatives coming a father and a son and then the mission of spoke about those who are disqualified for a this for kadesha fighters my gamblers and so forth and then finally the last mission to spoke about the fact that if somebody can't walk they can take him even on a donkey on Shabbos they could be Mohammed Shabbos you can walk for our distances you could take food you could carry sticks because Illinois they are chamois creditor should ticker om Amaya them we learn that the declarer Scottish in the right designated time is a top priority and it overrides even shabbos the next pea cleric Shanee continues on the theme of Kadesh are either sanctifying the new month unrestrained ish and it's going to basically explore three topics number one how they received the witnesses who observed the new moon the act of sanctifying Rosh Hodesh and how they sent out a notification to all of the Jews so the mission are now continuous paddocks Cheney in Maine and mercury no sir what happens if best in of the court don't recognize the witness Rashi says in Maine best in my curie/nasa 8 Desmond does not know who the witnesses in a mount of Akasha who if he's trustworthy and he's culture you are asking why don't we say every Jew is Velasquez Cassius we assume innocent till proven guilty so the mission is going to explain because of something that happened you're right usually we wouldn't ask questions call you so we have a Clow call you sir all the huskers Cassius we don't believe that you're guilty till you proven innocent on the contrary have a fresca Scott shows the status is you're a good person you're an innocent person until it's proven otherwise best in trashes in maine destin ce'nedra y son had a more clear than Bezdek depends is best enough 3 this burden of 20:23 in this burden of 71 was the son hector in the main son had in the main court so if we know that this witness who's going to tell them about the new moon they don't know him we know the people in the city or the bezel in the city knows that they don't know him Mashal seen in Myakka they sent somebody else wah-ha-ha-ha a doe to testify on him a character witness with the messenger the messenger is coming to apparently that person they knew because if they didn't know that person see him back to square one so apparently that person they knew somebody who had a reputation and therefore you suspect you assume that they knew him and he was the character witness for the witness who saw the moon that's what they did and the mission explains the reason but as shown in the beginning I am accompanied the Socrates Nikola they used to receive the testimony for the new month for the new moon from any person whether they knew him or they didn't know him just like in all of our waka you accept witnesses anything whether it's monetary issues even capital issues whatever it is the claw is call you sir all yesh Laham Casca's Cassius we assume every Jew to be innocent so here toe anybody who came and said he saw the new moon they accepted but then something happened we should kill Kahlua by twosome ones the group known as the by twosome deteriorated they ruin things his skin o best in instituted Chalet Yuma Kabul in Elliman a macaron they shouldn't accept testimony only Mohammed Kiran only from people that my Kiran that best in knows them best in recognizes them as a rim and ammonium as kosher and trustworthy witnesses who were the by to sit by twosome was a group known as by twosome very similar to another group known as Sudoku Sadiq and by tastes were two people two individuals they were students of a man named antagonize antagonize each sir is mentioned in pretty office in the first panic Antigonus in Tsukuba Mishima not Sadiq shimon hatzadik is the last one of the antique necessarily the hundred and twenty sages who rebuilt yi disk right and Eretz Israel after the destruction of the first base of Mukesh and the renovation of the second base of mechanician shimon hatzadik was also a Kohen Gadol in the second base i McNish for 40 years he had a very long unusually long tenure and was was a giant of a person the whole story a lot of stories about him in my sector Yuma Antigonus was a student of shimon hatzadik he had two students saw the can bite this because i'll teach that when Antigonus said like he says in pre-k office in the first chapter one of the things he taught is Altea cardamom assumption Monsieur averman our lockable brass Allah hava kavod mom assumption ourselves earlier Manaslu cava Pross don't be servants who serve the master in order to get a prize the word prize from the wordpress which is proof silica Pisa a piece of the cake but be like servants who serve not to get a price so because I'll say that when they taught the silver from Antigonus so there's two opinions in that there's students their students miss represented and misinterpreted what they said he said you see there's no no reward and Punishment to Judaism nothing and therefore they abandon either shrine some say it was they themselves it wasn't their students it was Southwark about this you have different versions in the house Allah they were shining whether is the students and these two groups became to be known as stupid named after their revered Sadiq or by twosome named after their ever bite us and one of the hallmarks of their philosophy was that they denied the authority of tarisha Baba all Hollow collimation be seen I all oral traditions not explicitly in the posit they denied which of course was only a way of doing whatever they want because once terror ship exam is so cryptic it's so misunderstood without Tarrasch about there you can't you can't begin to attach a posse you must have tarnished about private ownership exam once you remove tarnish about pair then you could do whatever you want everything can go are you well this too is - I found him some well monastic of applause well I'm not sure Yeah right so once they ruin the situation and the Gemara is gonna say what they did best didn't realize that they can't accept witnesses from anybody because they had an agenda and here they specifically had an agenda to cause besson to make a mistake and therefore they needed to have witnesses for the witness either they knew the man they knew they could trust him he's not about to see is not a follower of the right to sue if they did a northern man and therefore there was suspicion they had to send another man who they didn't know and they could trust him to say this witness is trustworthy that's what the Mishna says Rashi says he made McCarran oisi main best in McEwan estate in Neman Vikash you know if he's trustworthy and kosher michelle gielan are kerima so - she says Michelle Shan who's Michelle him Michelle she invested Shapira the best in in the local town every city had its own Bezdek besides did the best in your shall I am or ever the Sun Headroom was Lucas are gaza centimeters every city active a peasant roasting for sure can tip the macaw whole charter every city needed to have its own best and of course he couldn't take every question to to the son head and this beds in had the authority to deal with most issues not with all this is what was most issues so the best in in the local city had to send with the witness another witness after in my La Jolla the lovely from a bedzed in her girdle Shameka de Chasseur fetish so he would testify for this man in front of the great Basden meaning the great Sanhedrin the Supreme Court so to speak about this man wish to kill kilobyte Olsen what's the connection the father's muhammara what they did they sent for the witness another witness as a character witness well we'll discuss that now it seems like one big man's gonna explain with dealing with two but with it it seems like one so famous answer and asked asks an interesting heart a very interesting are rashly says Michelle can Bezdek should be era yeah best in in the city has to send this person why does best in in the city have to send this person mistress says Michelle can in my after Louie de you send somebody else look Aida this second person serving as the character witness best in has to know them they're sending somebody who has a reputation because the best doesn't know him you got the same problem you need a character witness for your character wills so if des des needs that knows him why does he have to be Ashley at the best him why does the best of the city have to send him let's say better than the city doesn't send now she says Michelle can best and should be either so could be that she just means practically in other words best in knew that la a witness wants to go and he says I'm going to well wait don't go now the best in would know it's a practical thing that's not a halakhah that they they have to send them because why would they have to send them the best in I call them knows who he is right so what do we gain from the fact that he's Ashley s best didn't so you might say that this leaf is Ashley her best and they'll give him a piece of synonym if it's a code or a document or a letter that he could come to the best in her garden even though they don't know him so if he just comes and he said oh this guy is kosher and fine but how do we know you she says I'm coming from my better than here so the sauce ember sister they could do that with the witness they don't need to send a new guy with a simin or exam or a let they could do that with the witness himself and this guy's also problem so they know him so what do you select what is best enough to send them for well they finish this best what do you need to be a slave Basden for the big bet that best and I gotta lose this guy hello am i they didn't know this guy yeah so best in has to send them and give him some code or some letters they could do that with the witness that's his order what do you need best in the sender unless they're actually just means practically that's that from now it's much more the best it has to be ashley resident was if they're still president if they knew of they know him he has a reputation daenambo talkin hooker skittish a fighters puts it a little differently he says that people in the city the people in the city sent character witnesses to the testify court did this you could say they're actually just means best in as in charge of the city not best didn't you need a did enough destined to testify for him because because then they could whatever they do for him they could do for the the first aid could be from the by to us and that's why you need a character witness who the character witness can also be from the back to sit so then they don't the wouldn't send them to allow the character witness the saying that he's not from the by too soon ah even even the also could do yeah also could give a cinnamon I mean I'm sure they could find something for the egg what do they need you say they wouldn't want to give us a because it's extra little shops it's a new filler shop is to make a new start and sending the ad is saying is less what you say yeah yeah yeah the witnesses there you could bring them on a donkey you sing instead of best in writing a letter Tomlin okay okay fine so a mailer we had to send somebody else to testify for this person toaster says Michelle came in my Alcala he died but all you see out here Nami McConnell oversaw Shabbos this character witness is also were allowed to be Mikado Shabbos for him he's also a lot of be McConnell Shabbos to go could the production of Elvis I pray tradition as we explained right the previous tie service at the end of painted Christian take a look at class sizes second to last Isis on the page makaula Nessa Shabbos where it says that what that for all elements of kadesha hydrogen can be makalah Shabbos a crisis a them shadow as a fighters the witnesses who saw the move isolate them on me Eden male him be Shane beds did my kid in a toy - Macao - I sharpest lawyer the leia and evaan the character witnesses when best and would not know the witnesses they can also have criminal Shabbos in order to go and testify for them pay the Mucca the bidets paid exchange all of them no Yuri AIT's a lot eight Volusia but sharpest lawyer the love will soon see a story that gunnery Roy was one of the great sages went on Shabbos he was Mohamed Shabbos to serve as a character witness for a witness who saw the new movement he himself went on Shabbos even though was a violation of Shabbos so from here we have clear proof that the civil service is not only for those who saw the moon but for those who enable those who saw the moon because if somebody sees the Newman but it doesn't have a character witness it's worthless it's futile so in other words anything that is necessary to have their testimony accepted today in bez Dhin you can achieve can do even though it is a little Shabbos that's what toys for sister odka deca the pineda show us says a very interesting deal to prove the accuracy of toys versus statement when you read this mission if you had to write the Mishnah you'll forgive me for phrasing the question this way how would you write the mission take a look at the structure of the mission wishes us if they don't know the witness you have to send somebody else to testify then the Mishnah gives history in the beginning they used to accept from everybody later because of the by toasting they change the policy says the panini is sure the mission should have been written in a different order to go in the order of history very shy him in the beginning they accepted witnesses from everybody then that a problem with the bite whistle so they decided we have to know who he is how if we don't know who he is make sure you send somebody else that we do know to tell us who he is okay that that should have been the structure of the mission and the issuer says why does the mission to put it this way because this way it comes as a continuation to the last mission last mission er was mission ossified you could take him on a donkey could they come on the bed you could take sticks you could take food shall mahalik I love you I'm a Shaolin as a Shabbos cuz you could be much on Shabbos to get the best in a limber - a mission - crystal my other so right away the Mishnah now continues they made a mock hearing noise in my shower scene in my ass Aloha either also on Shabbos we're talking about Shabbos if you would start interrupting with the history you wouldn't get this point the mission right away continues and if we don't know him we can send somebody with them when I'm sharpest we could send somebody with them on Sunday Monday Tuesday we can also we send somebody with them but the vote is it's a Hampshire that we can do it even on Shabbos so it brings out it brings out this this Nikodim there's another interesting deal that there is shining ask and that is as follows let's think about this min hot area you don't have to do this min hot area call yeastrol Velasquez Cassius you accept any witness this is a problem that happened because of the by twosome so it's the common during bias Cheney suffering from the document by twisting who instituted a whole new didn't so it's a did Madeira buona notte a did me not tie today after sending how then could you be McHale Shabbos violate an instrument operator to do something with the Rabanne and let's clarify there's a halacha that yesh Kuya Piazza common Lockard of Amanda Turner be Chevelle possum the same God who gave the mitzvos also gave a common when they're following the formula of Toyota we always have to say that to uproot something from Toyota only in a passive way where's my muscle mr. shunderson Holly is Bashar as you supposed to blow chef sook is that Shabbos she's supposed to shake a little it says in homage the custom remember humor you should create other Sunday through Shabbos we don't shake a little on Shabbos how how the tailor says yeah who else that are coming up with the answer is if they have a reason which they had a big reason because they felt people are gonna do Hillel Shabbos so they could tell Jews don't do a mitzvah not do a sin just don't do a mitzvah called shevelle fascist sit and do nothing don't blow Schaffer don't say clueless here what are they doing they're not telling him to sit home and not make a this then I tell him to do that that I can deal with don't make kid this you gotta go they're telling him to be miserable shoppers that they made is no such a thing there's no limit serious that car coming to tell a Jew to transgress a lie sir sir to do something that president says not to do they could tell him to be passive and not to ask you're showing mainly the aid going for kiddush I like this this is a minute Ida the same Hashem who said to keep Shabbos said this is nicer shops but the shmoo him that you're sending to testify for the eight that's a dinner to bother the thunder demon operator and the trains because it's conscious how then does there be a perfect little shoppers for that and we see clearly there Bernardo it was makalah Shabbos that's what tasters proves it and that's the whole structure of the Mishnah the answer that there is shining him say in the Torah heaven did they were showing to bring this in the tree Evan explains this is as follows once there are common it's very interesting once the hakama made at econo that you cannot accept witnesses for the new moon if there's no character witnesses who testify that these witnesses are kosher the fact is whatever the reason is the fact is that kinder shall carry this now depends on these character witnesses since we cannot make respondus without these character witnesses automatically Hillel Shabbos becomes motive and therefore they could be masala shot ah right I mean how tiny he could be masala shops in other words ms the reason I'm sending the character witnesses is not because Toyota tells me to do it it's because they have come and told me to do it that's true that's the reason I'm sending the witnesses but the player mama SH because of this Tucanos ha common can I make restraint miss without them I can't make this right this way so now I have a question can I be my phallus can they be makalah sharp as they can be McCollum's it's not that you masala Shabbos because of AD in their opponent and their IQ tired and all you be Mahalo shoppers to make a refiners that's a ten minute I'd why do you need them to make research that's not got the color sama that's what the restrain him explain that story Evan explains an interesting example a little different so Honora corral Bharat initials on Oricon books his paces and cement off from involve he says something fascinating there's a question let's say it's a very practical questions I mean hopefully it's not practical but it's practical sometimes you find a piece of comets in your house the first day of Payson on young before yump if you get rid of it hello my ID you find it on young teens what do you do you find a nice under the couch under the couch do you know this beats a leftover from last minute shoppers will have a Monica nice slice of pizza left over what do you do ah you cover it do you burn it or not so this is a Big Mac Lycus some restrain them say burn it ah on Yom Tov burnin do beer karma to empty if you don't you've been over I'm by your by your matzah man I'll try to remember little comments doesn't help for this comments you know why if the comet was there before Pesach its bottles at least Manhattan you're not over because you were market but let's say this hummus yeah you had a dough and the hummus became comment on face if you were know about all those almonds so as long as the comment is there every second you're over I'm by your by your much one is burnin I have you make a fire on Yom Tov so mitzvah says see to rest it's a mitzvah slices the answer is remember making a fire mean hot oiler is mud terrain yontiff may not tell you wanna make a fire a fire on average it touch the hood to let Cyrus but number so low that it and this is natural oil inside if this is what so a mitzvah they say burn it you could burn it I'm a dry bun and we don't make a new fire on young Tim it's an island we only we only pass one flame to another flank but we're talking man I play a lot of the second the second that does hurt Isis actually is you now let a burnin onions what do you do you cover it with a Kayleigh but saw yum tough right away you go burn it the first ship that says you could burn it or if there's a river you could crumble it in and throw it into the air even though it's or it's windowing but again I mean I tidy a lot of zuzo around young TIF in the texture is winnowing throwing it in the air and letting the wind to carry it away flushing Anatole but that you could that's even better then they couldn't flush it in a toilet but then the second says you're not gonna burn it Waianae with a permit the answer is because or take it to the river or throw it away the answer is cuz it's mo pizza why is it marketer because you can't eat it let's pay something you can't sell it it's not useful it's like raw flour on Shabbos Mucca Mucca you're now allowed to move on Yom Tov because you're not gonna move on yontiff you cover it you cover it and that's what you do I you being over by a row by your mod Said's comets in your house minute I'd the answer is yes kaya be out ha common Locker government a terrible Chevelle cos they're not telling you to eat comets they're telling you don't destroy comets for market sir I booked is not a lie so much this Madeira bomber ah so the Shakalaka robber says why don't you do a simple thing bring the fire here bring the fire right here make the fire right I don't have to move it that would be that today its pacer I can't I can benefit from come with some pacer it very second really holds you allowed I but we're talking while Lanza you know the benefit bring the torch make a fire there so what is the answer he says you can't do that you know why because I'm in hot area you don't have to burn hummus I mean I didn't you could be my father Mozilla Rua I'm Italian you could crumble hummus and throw it into the ear you could throw it into the sea yeah I mean I told you you could do that you don't have to burn it we can't do it because marketer but me not Tyler you can't burn it burn it is looks wrong mama shall I let silent there's no sorry even Tony Mitzvah why would you can throw it in the river we have a problem cause motor but player doesn't have a problem of books I see having a very interesting situation I mean I tell you that when I am inside the how come you should burn it I mean I play to you now let it burn it because you don't need to burn it you could throw it away physically but there's a problem of butcher so what do you do now so the Hammond say do nothing do nothing you can't burn it cosmonaut idea now let her burn it right so you're being Mahalo yontiff you're being masala Leon Tiffin Yom Tov is also an essay and a boy sister so therefore touch be so and bow arrow is not very young TIFF because both are sa annoy sisters yeah you can't throw it away you could do minute Ida why because it's Musa they say do nothing leave the comments and then he adds then he adds because you're an honest you're not even on by you are by your mother because you're an honest you're you're forced your hands are pan you want by your by your matzah means you could and you're not he says here you can your tied you tied up your hands are change so to speak illogically so you're not open up I hope he might say so why not everybody loved by in Mott say yeah because the have come and said it smoke - so you even are gonna buy her by a matzo this is yours something I saw you how cost of kilo Burris yeah that should be su there's a mitzvah ceci analysis no because Yom Tov is also an SN ELISA to rest not to make a fire on Yom Tov is also an essay analysis it says to should respond to Shabbat something and by Sasha melaka so you can have touched be sue and buy a rugby diaper Young Turk little Cecily what right yeah chef autopsies just leaving us that's why they could do it they can't count the e comments it's up marketer with the muck to make some anonymous of men is not a Villopoto so the pile is not over by a Watson this is a simple toughen involve no sorry you're allowed to do on Yom Tov if it's less IRA yeah because it's a Toyota Mitzvah you need some sort of young turtle it's us how you gonna do laughs i'll ukalaka hot you're gonna crumble at Colossae yeah you could you could you have according to this there's another that you burn it burn to or you or you throw it out but the point of this you put a pair and it'll of Talmud scientist coverage lavalava yes and competed value robbery matzo means you now lie to physically have comments in your domain you can't see it and buy your matzah me none of about your matzah means you can't even have it but doesn't it doesn't take away it by your own means it shouldn't be seeable seeable ok you could move it with your foot but what are you gonna gain from that no you can't once this man is sir begins you don't have the authority remove a lot of you it's not yours to be move out to let me kick it interesting you want to know why doesn't kick it out all the way kick it kick the comments all the way to issue sir album so mailer becomes half your onion huh because you could carry see saying kick it kick it just kick it all the way to show Sarah no it's okay fight so let's go right to now so mailer there is showing them explain what am I'm just saying that's an interesting sue still here it's a little different but the Vorta is here too yeah you're being Mahalo sabes why it's at econo sky coming but it's not that the how come am i telling you to do he lo sabes for me because tacoma sky come in I'm stuck I can't make this restore this because I don't have character witnesses so be Mahalo sabes for day nice effort Ida it becomes a dental aider huh it becomes a din tighter just like there i can't burn the comets but sudden i can't carry the comments with submucosa so mailer i become on honest and mail already may not tell you I'm also not over by you know about your months okay now the Mishna when the Misha tells the story but is shown I am a Combinator sir hi dish the mission is basically giving the reason this is the pastas why the mission is structured this way we asked before why doesn't a mission of first tell the history and then the consequences first say how it used to be then say how it's now what used to be comes before what is now so first saber is China so the pen a sure says the reason is to teach you they could be Mikado Shabbos for the character witnesses I'll propose there's also another element and that is the brew Shona is not a new part in the mr. Bhushan is a reason why do you have to send the character witness so let me tell you this story in the beginning you didn't have to and then there was a problem and therefore they made that you have to the second half of the Mishnah is justifying rationalizing and explaining the first half of the mission saga Gomorrah Maya what does it mean out here it says my shouting in my idea they sent somebody else what does it mean literally it means that you said one right if my afterthought one person Michelle him in my up here you sent one more press ready to get more of Assad me Muhammed one person is believed to serve as a character witness Rashi says la she really lost Hesketh NEMA one person suffices to make the witness kosher that we should assume that he's trustworthy why not by tanya we learn to price my sis above huva a dummy my lawyer the love there was once a story that a witness came together with his witness says a dove muhuali the loves a crash she my sister bar her aid lift nay best in Bathsheba's lawyer de la fetish there was a my said that a witness came in front of Bezdek on Shabbos to testify in the new moon the aid of a boy and he brought with him two of the witnesses last second Emma to give him a Hesketh Emma what do we see from here a dove it doesn't say a doughy aid of a dove is two people so the bride says says clearly these two people that they sent now rush she adds here by Shabbos how does our she knows Shabbos as my sister bar huva aid the women I read the love how did I she know was sharpest maybe it was Tuesday afternoon what's the difference you need character witnesses whenever they come with on Shabbos Rashi says sharpest and even if not she knows of a Sabbath on - kabuna who kids if it was Travis or not sauce Emma says they're a she learnt is from the word miser my sis like episod you know let me tell you a mice I'm not gonna tell you a mice or we woke up this morning it's not a miser if it was not a unique story we wouldn't say mice the fact that they had to send character witnesses was a constant situation if bez didn't know the person and how many people did they know they knew every single person they always have to send character witnesses what makes it am Isis that had happened on Shabbos that they sent everybody on Shabbos in other words there was still Shabbos involved why is that so important because now let's think about it how many people did they cause to be makalah Shabbos the witnesses and another two witnesses if one would suffice if one would be allowed why make a Jew be masala shoppers in vain send one character witness why if it was a middle of the week you know what send another few send another few in cases you know they're not gonna believe I don't believe another guy who cares cent - it's not a big deal to send another but showers you're doing single Shabbos why would you do this is the hard I hear that you have to send to it it makes it much stronger that you really have to send to to the point that they can both be Macao summers that's why I - she has the bashar bus it's all different dish mark in their eyes right right right they aid with two witnesses they aid with two witnesses on the Left shows a big quest our Mishna says after the brightest says aid of Homer if popular puppet said my actors ooh gotcha when it says in our mission of a thousand in my ass here it doesn't mean you send another person it means you send another couple after means one actually means another couple another couple to testify to people you sent and you can send them on Chavez - huh Konami mr. Brell prove it to you the Eloi tomorrow if you're not gonna say that child actor means an individual might appear let me ask you a question let's start off the Mishnah in a non mock hearing eyesight if they don't recognize him who's him the witnesses my eyesight who's him the witness no Elena is a shadow say Oh some i some is a de-icer is him that means there was only one witness Elena I said God if you're gonna say oh is that one witness who saw the moon and now I asked you a question but God me man do you believe one witness who says he saw the moon you need to maybe not cuz miss but save Bay Micah - ahoy - it says into Hillen pay Aleph Tico bhai decipher Bacchus le I'm huggin looky high-cholesterol who miss Litella k yeah we already learned earlier you tickle behind cypher is blows over in the month what I mean blows life in the month why this doesn't mean man fried dish means the new moon we spoke many times hiders means colors the new moon the only time when do you blow so for this new moon recessionary stylish but Castelli I'm a gamer the only yontiff that's by the new moon is russia sun every other young to visit middle of the month hey socks Luis took as it's all middle of it later in the month the only Yom Tov that is the new moon is Lissa Shauna tickle box i decipher key quickly sir although this is a statue mike is a law established by you strong besten mishpokhe mother k Yakov it becomes a mish but that means it has a gather of mich Mich but is basically the term for all civil law justice by misha the law says you need two witnesses I'll be Xiaoyu made them y'all come over so we learned from here the killer struck reddish also needs two witnesses miss believe me so how can it save aim the material I saw that's the same ænima Kiran I some ela you have to say I say I say how's Luke Oh Issei means not he but then that my Kiran I see means they don't recognize the pier the couple it huh Kaname my actors who got same ænima Kiran are you sorry if they don't know the pier of witnesses who are coming to see the moon Michele Janine my after they send another Zhuge another pier but if Papa said there's no problem they Tucker sent two people yeah two witnesses saying they saw the good moon and you had two character witnesses testifying for for one of them or for both of them maybe they knew one of the witnesses they didn't know what other witness or they or they didn't know both witnesses were pastors and they sent a couple for both of them is Potomac a Yaakov that this declaration of Rosh Hashana as a holy day is a de novo it's called Michelin's it's one of it's just like it's a Shoshanna it's every destroy dish they she shows all yom tov happens to describe this it's it I know how this is something happens to this right of course if the second pair saw the moon then you don't need the first pair let them come themselves if there's the new then maybe what do you need the first stop them what she hidden they wouldn't come if the first paper by twisting why would the second pair do why would they lie again the second pier bears the knew they were honest Jews they were not by twisting why would they test the file I that these Jews are not by twosome so then good what's the problem if the first witnesses will by twosome they're not going to testify that and I prayed they had to testify that their culture airless leaden they're good Jews because if and if they're by twosome why would they testify that unless they're also by too soon unless it's formed by too soon right that's why the second pair best in has to know if not if not you have a problem what are you gain couldn't be over to us goodbye to some of our students document by too soon of course there were periods that they controlled the whole kahuna the whole base of McNish one way or the other way yeah they had tremendous power there were there were times that the Kings would stuck into the grandchildren of the hush when I became stupid you're cynical god those symbols become a smush my name's Shawn of innocence dokie the grandsons of the hush man I am their great-grandchildren become a became took him and they had all the power they they they control the whole base on victors and they control the malucia there was a point where there was civil war I mean it was it was ugly was ugly there was a water wasn't simple it was a lot of problems with its tooken listen I don't think it was that state you know it's it you hear what you want to hear of some well you know what I mean that's their excuse was that they don't believe in Irish about pet but ultimately it allowed them to manipulate either the way they wanted once there's no tarnish about path you could already do there's no straightforward the Hamish is so cryptic there's not one person that doesn't need an explanation not one the superstation was shavasana this is the sukkah station receiver comm sit in a Sukkah what does that mean a glass huts on the porch what does masuka's taste for children shout to my cell you that's a tie it on your hand tie one on my hand potato peels what do you do boiled that off has been enough lie serve a shock the but hey love emo don't cook goat in the fact of its mother how do you know it says but all of it but Halloween my milk oh because you haven't a goodness who gave you the Nicholas the secretary there's no goodness alternate everything is there about without tears about pair you can't move you don't know where to put a comma don't put a question mark you don't know how to pronounce words you don't know the meaning of words they they made that's what that was the point the point was once you once you dismissed Irish about past they had a few Coomera so so they had their my sis you know let ignite fire on Shabbos menu now let it will have traveled on Shabbos huh they sat in the dark here you know what a fine even a mikvah what's a mcknight asked by a smile or a mikvah miami attire okay so fill up a bathtub and go to the mikveh right there's not one mixer instead even a bris how do you know what a bris is maybe if the core of your finger even a bris what do we learn it says Arnold's author so we learned for me that arla is weird is the male component not a female component right what's a bris some says make a bris what's up Chris circumcise circumcise what for so what what do you do with you put a bullet in his head maybe that - what do you do for just crash at CVCC slaughter animals like I commanded you the posix says never he never commanded you from he also said - Theresa Papa to say that there's no tradition about Pam means is not Arabic South you understand me - taters no tears about Pam means that God was making a joke he gave you a document for absolutely no purpose somebody parish about pears something new and separate the Rambam says tired of the Phoenicians Athena when moisture gave terrific self he gave it with a sheer he gave it he gave it with a manual not a matter if in manual he gave it with an oral manual he gave everything was with a sheer for character the written Tyler is a summation of the sheer you understand it's not that Tyler said ball pair is a Peter son Telemachus table if you really want to know the truth tarisha big sob is the written summation of Teresa Papa when you read a person and you're heard mine should have been this year you see the whole shear in the pasok he put into the pasta all the details hinted and compressed and one pasta you can have a hundred I'll office if you know how to analyze it he gave the Jews a written summation of everything he spoke so the two are are are inseparable that's how the Jews understood it but still come and bite us and three that now was particularly with they were obsessed about something as the Gemara we'll see what they were obsessed about I mean if you would think what's the big deal here what are they careful said it's a mood what do they have to fight about the moon I mean what's the fight about today it's document by to sin to come and bite us you still have the chrome the crow you met you have the chrome were the carrots the carrots was ready later in history groups that were following the traditions of the Stuka again developed and they were also very strong so yeah they reinvented the content of the document they made their own tighter they deny terrible paths so that you still have you have in California I believe of rules of care rights and you have an Israel a few of the corrections they're called quraíam so no sacrum they're called the carrots the cryin the rambam thought them very heavily I mean it was well well known much like this document that was written officially people would take notes always they always took notes yeah everybody took the novice considered a shear they take notes like but the Mishnah is was with Tamara Thomas how long after my shoulda beena so you make it read when the base--emitter it was built four hundred and forty years for the hunt for hundred and eighty years after its use Messiah it stood for four hundred and ten years right so that's eight hundred and ninety years no say from Cormac so you want to go from commas you want to go from comer so you have eight hundred ninety years and then you have another seventy years and then another four hundred and twenty years so it's approximately sixteen hundred years after the main thing was represent student everything was there ever and the students did well everybody had students any notes now we have all the prices all the Mishnah is or the prices or the madrasah as a cipher came back with the beginning of by Shanee yeah but that but but the Mishnah was written around the hundred and fifty years after hoarding by a shiny and then you century later right so that's the beginning of by a Shanee so it's around 500 600 years by Yusheng he stood for four hundred and twenty years and around 150 years later the Mishnah was written and then later the Gemara was written and so forth so it's a few hundred years past something tomorrow the ad Lima Hammond and one person is not believed you're establishing the pup is establishing you're right you need to character witnesses like the Brice's says eight dog and our mission that doesn't mean one person it means a couple you send the pier after is appear Zog Takamoto really even have my Mohammed well Tommy we have a price my symbol of no hero he is store with ribbon or sha Allah it's allied lawyer the love be Shabbos be you sure that Nora he went to the witness who saw the moon to testify about him on Shabbos in OSHA yeah no refreshes we're gonna see later in the flama Dallas that s-sir gully is golf so son hadron meaning the sanhedrin's place was in Yerushalayim place called lishka sagas 'as a room in the base emitter if they had a room that was made for the court on the hera bias on the Temple Mount before hurtin by you Shane Lee they have to leave and they went through ten exiles one of the places that the Sun hadn't ended up was in Russia so at this point the Sun hadn't are you sure that's where the witnesses are coming so Rory knew that there's a witness who was testifying about the new moon but the witness needs a character witness so on Shabbos he went even though he was it was a simple Shabbos in order to test the fight for him and the question here is how many people went up now you know he went himself there's a whole lot hates a Lloyd Lloyd love Shabbos bush it seems like you can have one witness not to look at the Gemara I'm read the mayor yeshiva said no governor are you sad that her and I have a bad day that's not the point of night I really had another witness with him for how the boys hush of lay what do you mention him some avoid there showed up no I right out of respect and honor to have no idea what shot whoa how would it be disrespectful to say he went with somebody else yeah what subscribe so Rashi says Busia Keshava Sanhedrin Shama Shama yamakasi hide this mission quoted in urban areas or crashes Sharon Lee whose scarab Mary Ryan the loom with me men who shot them gobble commotion or that debate over may avoid nation obvious really say no Africa very a cotton me man what's the point of this Bryce that you have to have a character witness with a mission the point is that a man may clip nori Roy who was one of the great giants of the generation was an autumn goggle he himself of McHale Shabbos he was redundant he was MacDowell Shabbos for what nothing to say he saw the moon testify about the person who said it no moon that's some thick knock at the Vltava so therefore it's not respectful we're gonna bring our ire from somebody in terms of of godless in terms of spiritual and moral and and scholarly greatness is smaller than so of course he went with somebody else but that's not relevant to our story what do we say and by the way there was another guy Franco was awesome okay that's not an idea what i want to tell you is if no you know you went to be Mahalo shoppers that's a statement so the price has not coming to tell you how many people went it could be two people went could be Matt but we can't prove from the brighter that two people didn't have to go maybe two people after go the point of the price is to tell you that they've no hero you went did he go with somebody else may have gone with another person but it wasn't in the statute that's over him not to show how important in us NEBOSH Shyama trabocchi says different yep no you know he's sad ocarina have a bullsháá lib no you know he knew that there's another witness another character witness in who shot he knew that but also Devin I know it looks to refer behalf so if now you know he went to combine himself with that character witness in others you don't have to say that two people went and the only reason you don't mention the other one is because of coveted ebonite I he took her when himself I went himself you said you need to answer is he knew that dear there's one man who knows this guy he know you know there's a guy who knows it so I don't have to worry I have to go myself so there should be two witnesses so mail that the bottom line is that what that you need to love the Kumari are fee if that's the case milah memra what is the finish what's the kiddush here if this is the case Milam member what's the finish what's up shot Qaeda according to the first answer the finish is my Roy was Mahalo Shabbos that's a big thing we should not have no euro is Mahalo shops that's not a small thing that's why you don't even mention the second person because it's not negate what's negative negligible cost point to the second answer second answer is not trying to tell me that Deb Hanoi was McHale Shabbos right and that's why you don't mention the second person you don't mention the second person because there was no second person he went himself right so yucky my lemon bruh what's the finish what do we mean you can't tell me the hidden issues they allow to be mcconnell Shabbos for this situation that we already see from the mission the mission that says you could take a bed then you can take sticks and you could take food then you could take whatever you need and if you're mailer for these Slocombe you can also be miserable shoppers because you need it for the ages so you can't tell me that's the footage of the price so what's the finish of the rice according to the first interpretation then an Odom girdle was Mahalo shots an autumn cut according to the second interpretation of rabat see that's not your point because you're saying that whatever now you know you went himself it's not like you're eliminating the second person because you want to be not an IROC you're just telling the story so what's the point of the story she says the point is Mao the time I would say miss Faye : hello Linda Shabazz perhaps for a soft we cannot McHale Shabbos if no Roy doesn't know for sure that that person is in who sure maybe he's away for Shabbos maybe he went to his daughter for Shabbos he doesn't know that he's there so he's being Mahalo Shabbos our softened the doubt he may come and the second character witness is not their commercial Melun that he could do it even for our software that would be the signature Quentin abbaschian that even for a Suffolk that it may not even work if Nevada is walking with the person himself he hasn't but according to their Bashi he's not walking with the second person he's realizing that the second person is a neutral what if he's not there what if he's not capable of testifying or what if he's away spilling his McCarl shoppers come on mother no Ezra Pedroia was macao stop asthma yes the question is there's one person or two people Jabbar she said there may have been a second person over there we know them no no you went that's not a Schuyler and we know you need to but we don't know what but doesn't say somebody else went so so bad she says you have to say so based on this no he's actually what's the bride's are trying to tell you not that you ought to be my college shoppers we know you a lot of in makalah Java so what do we need this story for the story is that you could be mythology office or something that she says miss raker Shimane I said the basin the guy may not be home no he knew the guy lives there I'm Michael as a witness that night I knows that Ben doesn't know high-ankle they're gonna think is a by to see but crime my ankle as a receiver and the urgent Shiva lives this is great we were together we would have roses in Geneva we will have roses in yeshiva by this teacher let me go there and he'll testify I meant to live with him he was his neighbor he saw the moon just let's go back home have been there Mae West already whatever I guess I knew that he saw then he left we sought Friday night and he went to pester him no I knew he needs a character witness so he went no he went himself aide one himself no no he knew it's not gonna work so he went he went with them we told them to go whatever that's obviously it had to happen you never know you know you didn't have to cool it far away from the eight if not he wouldn't know that he's gone what's this - good no no we have a problem with this story yeah but problem with the story is you need two people okay that's number one and it says no no he went himself doesn't say there was another person it just says he went you're right doesn't say well himself but it says he went so we have a problem we have a problem you understand we have a problem we wouldn't have a problem you're right well we have a big problem we need to it says if neither I went we need to lose was dismayed the man's rush London so one answer is which the bar she did not like you understand why I didn't like it because of course he doesn't like the first answer could the first answer ultimately cuts out part of the story it says no you know Ujala hates away no it's a big deal but you can mention them know you're aa lot right in havedo or ameesha out there to be made and about she says no your act I'm keeping the story SS he wasn't south that's Sebastian says nothing room that's what he says is true direct drag the Gemara what do you need this whole Brice so for what's the point thumb to telling me stories but you lie to be Macao Saba signed off that's very likely McCauley yeah a lot of people I know from the Mishnah surrender oh so that works according to the first pence first answer you trying to say that kiddush let him know you know he's a big person and that's why you don't even mention the second person right exactly that's the point machine Kuwait they Adam that might make I don't need to bring guys from the second person that can person whoever he was he was all thank you bench nothing wrong but II Hakim ila membra Lloyd the second interpretation of Rabat she know what I'm accustomed us to go with other people so yeah but no the question is the question is matter if it's a busy and I'm gonna tell Shabbos for that atomic Rock'em has to go with somebody but not Hillel shoppers unless it's a danger of life you're not gonna desecrate Shabbos for the covered for that then yet you understand the middle of the week atomic Holcomb has to have an escort you're right but here it's killer shops that they can't do the covered of the Thomas Holcomb doesn't come before the cover the Russia on the contrary comfortable Sun cosa Michelle so the question is like trabocchi obviously it's not that the kiddush Isnora was Michael shops because then he could have said the first answer so ever say what's the head is that you could do civil Shabbos I knew so what do you tell me stahma miser might happen are you I thank you says no there's a kid this year okay this year is a Suffolk the guide may not be home they may not be home make an assumption that the reason it's not mentioned is because there was a guy in that city and you're asking you're asking how could a bar she make such a radical kiddush based on his assumption go back to the first answer yeah and don't make such a problem is it doesn't say there was another person because you need two witnesses that very that's what about she said that's what about she said there was another but he tonight he doesn't know if the guys home what if the guy left for Shabbos there's no whatsapp that's the soffit maybe that guy is not home maybe that guy's not home you're right maybe he wasn't there because he knew you need two witnesses but the commentators it's a strong assumption you know take away the first answer a minute okay but to understand well you see that second answer has a certain you schmuck to it yeah if I say a story Lee a semester Naaman three a semester you took okay if I say a story okay Isaac I say you traveled yeah it was a mice said there was an emergency you had to go you a mahalo Shabbos mamas to save somebody and you traveled on Shabbos yeah from here to measure bush okay that's the my son the only thing is there was somebody else with you by you know by you might say I don't mention a word fine but I'm some ice it's a my sir yet tell us stories say say what happened say three people went two people went so the bar sees is obviously one person went how you need two witnesses he's not doubting that so you gotta say the guy was if he was a she says what's the covered of ribbon are you know he wants to cover it you're not gonna learn the halacha from a second person now the cord to the first shot you want to teach this or not um gondol and you don't need the second person it's disrespectful what we're gonna bring arrived from a second person also he's much smaller the penne issuer says a guest mark of art what's the cover the ribbon I Drive so the cover the ribbon area is that they wouldn't accept him as an aid as an ADA on God without arms and says this guy is a good guy that we could trust him oh very interesting he says the cover the ribbon i drawing that do was they wouldn't trust him play shores of arts they wouldn't trust him why because you need two witnesses doesn't help who you are you talk a it not not that we thought that I know he's lying but you need two witnesses doesn't change the fact why should I be know himself comes and says ADA's that this man did this in this sorry can accept it not because we think my shoulda been AA that's an interesting voice ah and what's the and it's a bigger leadership because generally we have a clown then a tear cut Neman be sue him when it comes to regularly sue rim of Mitchell's you believe an ADA hard right you believe a shyster that the behavior is caution you believe a woman that did the home of the homeless caution you believe in a that not be syrup not the questions of monetary issues of dealing the flushes and this is an issue this any of kadesha high dish the Cohanim said you don't believe in a that thought because they're afraid that one character witness is also rented by the by twosome he's also up for money so you need to even though they could rent to people to it's true you can always rent people but but the more people the harder it is to make a conspiracy so one person they didn't trust as a character witness because maybe he was all supported by the by twisting well i don't know your icons you should say you know what a tax ID is namma and you know I wasn't bored off by the by twisting but the shot is like blerg nobody is above the law there's no such a thing in Judaism that somebody is above the law I mean this is a recent invention but some people think some people are above the law there's no such a concept ingenuity everybody is under the law moisture is not above the law nobody's above no it's one of the few do some of Yiddish kind it used to be a concept the king is above the law the monarch somebody's above the law any the scanner doesn't work the MELAS is under the law claim gutless under the law moistures under the law there's no such a thing it's not the moment you do that it's not yet this kind anymore the moment somebody is not under the somebody above the law it's done now okay those the same thing say once the car come and made a dinner you need two witnesses Nanaia is not an exception that's it that's the cumene a character witness on the character with interest the witness has one character witness and the character witness has one character witness ah no play shows a different shot shmakov chapter ah she says quite the ribbon area is that you don't have to learn the halacha that Hillel Shabbos could be done through an autumn goggle in other words we tried to teach that even an autumn goggle was makalah Shabbos for this purpose so what are you gonna bring another person here who's much smaller than it's not the covered yeah sua says it's not the cover that they wouldn't trust him as an aid that they didn't want to say he went with somebody else even though he did Metellus cover they said he went for carrot it's a fact obstruct my trash he brings out the godless of ribbon I Roy wait the play sure it brings out that habanero he is the goddess of the Toyota yeah looks good huh even a benign I won't miss bikini to a diesel bus a timer Rosh Hashanah is made like any other issue but every baby Pesach Roo asuka's I mean you have enough you could you could match that it's only tissue yeah but why should why should you do that the place show us as Kane Italy knockin Lula sure - gee Lloyd padushka now she didn't say this but he says this is how I would types - come on Lula shanachie lepidus the second person you're saying we don't want to mention the second person so people should think that the escort atomic us come on shoppers who's a lot of Italo shoppers you're allowed but why would somebody think so all understand the reason the guys coming is as an aid why would somebody just if the story is his time coming Mela but it says he's coming as an aide so why would somebody compare it to regular escort I don't see how that mistake would be possible he asked me for the hood atomic Hakeem needs an escort but that doesn't justify his little Shabbos in the middle of the week you need an escort I don't see how other mistake would happen I don't see they used to be in the in the old farm you see that the printer would print it and the one who wrote the safest saw that was half of the page was empty actually Lodz yes and now you're colic not to leave the page empty he'll add something for example there's a comment a of the rat doll I'm pretty good at a blazer it's a beautiful commentary so in the opening page he says solenoids yes an eye or colic I'm gonna say something and he gives an incredible incredible explanation gomorrah says that the qasimi's saw how a homeless had an argument what happens to the Sun at night yeah the catch me almost said that the Sun goes to the other side and the fashionista said that the Sun goes there's a window in the heaven and the Sun goes in and then in the morning it comes out of the window and the gomorrah says that this is one thing with the fashionista doll how you do how you do the Hoquiam asylum at the end they said that the customer sell on my right the cuvette Govinda bender tom says how you do have a la embassy cacophony is all cinema by chaos Eleni rakia almighty cameraman climber we say in domine so that explains the whole thing starting I'm saying well though it's just a nice column I'll say of art it's an interesting question in ruse that we learn on shoeless it's brought that ruse was married I read there was a lamella when others had a wife Naomi Nami she had two sons Madeleine and Killian they married rusyn arpa and then L M Ellis died Macklin died Killian died ARPA went back home Andrews converted to Judaism and she went with Nami back to base Lawson bacteria too strong they were very poor they didn't have anything they went to collect grain from boy Oz's field and boy has happened it happened to be a relative how is he a relative basically aleem Ellis had brothers right one of his brothers were still alive and Baez was a nephew of Ali namaha so Baez was a first cousin of Naomi Baez and Naomi were first cousins so mitts odd with son relative so Naomi felt that there would be a good shooter between you know sent by us so she sent rooster by us maybe buyers would marry her and also Baez would do what we call concept of Yibo not mama Shivam but similar to even sahiba Miz somebody dies with our children so the brother marries his wife and has a child on the name of the man who died here the same thing Macklin had no children Killian had no children and ARPA was graceful marry boys and focaccia wait perpetuate the family so Ruth says I could do it but there's somebody closer it was still an uncle alive remember his brother was still lives you have to ask him his name was toys give me a golf Atari vehicle and if man I'll do so boy has asked I've if he wants to do it merry ruse and take over the fields that they had so the man said he can't why pen ash this is not halassi I may destroy my nautilus or as she says what's the knock Allah sorry my kids because ruse is a mole white woman success well your VR my name Arabic Allah say you know letter Mariam over to convert even if she converted she could career but you know what a merrier only a one more vote convert could marry another moment or one convert could marry or others similar but you can't marry something I can't do it because if I do it panache missus are they my kids forever will be blemished nobody will be able to be married marry a normal Jew that's what that's what he says therefore I can do it boy us therefore satphone I'll do it he married was why bias felt there's no din on women on the unmanned a more white woman could marry rebel okay that's that's rational here's a big fella now she says the man refused to marry boyars to marry rose why cuz my kids maybe that maybe blemished what about himself if you believe that you now let a marry a Moabite woman or man who converted forget about so what she doesn't have a kid let's say they're not gonna have kids or married was they won't have kids he's not wanna do it it's like people say I'm not sinning because my kids kids huh a big fella dashi pen Ashley says re yourself in a little Mary Mir people your kids let's say you're not gonna have kids yes colossi is sorry Shan Emily Ave are mining my kids forever all the generations all the kids that come from roofs are gonna be a problem cases with chador we're shitless crisis it's a big battle our noshing what's your son so the Marsha asks this question and Gomorrah and you've ominous the marshal says something is very hard to understand my Shuster's for him it's not a problem si dice el asesor the SAV boom is dicey the voices of not marrying on my evite his kids don't have an essay how could the marshal say such a thing he boom with the first cousin Yee boom with the first cousin this man was only melons brother naomi was his niece and Iommi was his his sister-in-law ruse was his niece with the e boom with a nice he was a brother-in-law who is the it mother nice a mitzvah Skiba man Acharya virtual Mitzvah Mitzvah is if a woman dies if her husband dies childless it's a mitzvah that the wife marries her brother-in-law not a nice was such a thing of even with a nice it's a nice thing it's it's a concept of evil missus mitzvah a mitzvah to marry a nice if he dies without children who ever heard of such a thing you have Richard Cho Mitzvah son ie Mitzvah driver hey she saw the marshal says mitzvos s a joyful noises John pehle so the brisket of tradition agrees our toilet the British screen of Ravello brisker says something and I saw that it was really set a generation earlier by the Benishek I have a new Yosef I'm from Baghdad he says the same thing but in the Shiva sure well they said for the blister off but the Benishek i said it already earlier he says something very interesting it says that Javed Doig told Saul about David Saul asked if he thinks David is worthy to be a king because he says don't ask if he's worthy to be a king ask if he's worthy to marry a Jew because he comes from my earth love it was a great-grandson of Roose they went to the base Madras and they started to ask so they said that she's a woman she's a lot of married Roose is a wonderful so Doug started to ask all these questions it's everybody a man a woman they went back and forth back and forth and finally somebody says not scared of somebody put a sword in Miss Minchin said makka blonde even raised initial small her amasi I was macabre from the best in of smaller mind evil AI - male Bible in my office doesn't apply to women what was the fitness share everybody knew that that's what boy Roy Baez married her that's wide of its father married the Kalani Bay's dinners are smaller on Massey what's the finish the brisket off says like this very interesting insight beautiful inside there's two ways how tarish about pet development one is you'd give Omid this and one is a logical emotion we see that welcome emotion is Sina is how do we know to fill in our black how do we not fill in a square how do we know this for par she's since villain how do we know moysha set called a logical emotion is it then there are things my she never said the haha amused the formulas that Marcia gave called you'd get moment discover hi menges Irish oven and they develop they deduce trapped and learning what's the difference between the two a local emotion is seen that you can't argue you'd get mo mythos there's different logical ways of looking at something in one generation Basden could say one thing another generation you can have a new best in and if they're greater and wisdom and a number they could refute the other best and it could change yeah today we say a logic a basil--oh the reason says loss in love with Santana's gonna possibly not logically Bashar my how they're gonna read and they're gonna see the world differently things could change because these are not much like us in with is our local emotion Messina it's based on perspective based on logic people's logic changes and personalities change that's part of that's part of the fabric of Tyler that's part of the fabric of Tyler somebody sent me yesterday a whole sharp email about something I said that it's against das Tyra what I said something they said it's against das Tyra so I said I have a few questions first of all who invented the word das Tyra which year and what's the source for it second of all what happens if two rabbis disagree which one is das Tyra just interesting which one what if two rabbis disagree which is das tournament yeah second of all what makes one rabbi's view das Toyota and another rabbi's view not a styler how does it work what's shot what's that you know if it's consistent with solution or if it's that's tight if it's not something that shocked America is too this yeah see after the stern what's a das Toyota what's that - Tyler that's tired it doesn't something is that straight no no what's the union what's the union it's except if it has a maken antennas a maken entire if it says emotional control not because unless be moccasin right so this different person the biskits of cells like this he says this man thought that the reason you a lot except truce is because the haha man based on the edema myth is decided that it's only a man not a woman so therefore he could marry her it's not a problem what's the issue in a hundred years from now there's gonna be a new bathroom and they may revoke it so retro actively all the children that were born from this marriage now in a hundred years won't be able to marry even though I could that was the vote because it's one of the gimel mythos what was the condition based in initial small harem are see that it's a loss animation Messina it's a local emotion to see nine then there's no way it can't be changed that was biases kiddush that it's a luckily Winston that man said it normal motion is denied this is your logical formula you're the best and I get it I'm fine but in a hundred years there could be a bigger bed Xena don't change it that's what he says what's the value that the brisket of his right hook this is suni BIA naamam says a local emotion is seen I my of evil my my illness how does the Rambam know this doesn't say anyway in Gomorrah that it's a logical why should Messina anywhere how did their I'm not emotional dimension is Cena the Mishna says I'm on evil eye.i - how does he know some local mission Messina how did the RAM know LM I did I don't understood this is how it works the man's thought it wasn't a lot of the way should be seen it was just a logical form you love the sanhedrin said that could change in 50 years and I'll be fine my kids will be ruined this is it's a welcome with someone so mission missing that's not a problem which tastes wish my calves are done she do she agrees a lot Ida in the back it was a few stickler Hanavi nos a lot Ida you know it's typed up I would with the bass Olivia yeah yeah it's a small thing in the back in the back he has a few little stick lock on knock a few little stick lock the end he has a little sticker on Ross it's just a few lines he says this but the Benesch try has a Peter sunroofs I think it's called a mamela and I saw it over there also the banished I came before the banished I was much older than the US so that's why it really comes before I think it's a mamela something like that okay so in summation the Gemara wondered if you can send only one character witness to testify that the aid that the witness who came to see the moon is trustworthy that's what it would seem in the mission or when it says myself in my Ocklawaha IDO you send somebody else but that can't be the case why because we have a story with the price it tells us clearly that it was on Shabbos and two character witnesses came the puppet says you're right Oscar doesn't mean one more person actor means another peer just like I say a maenam akhirin place it doesn't mean they don't recognize him because there's no him this then because you need two witnesses for kadesha hide ich mich both lilica Yakov it's a misfit so when it says afterwards Michelle said out there just like you say doesn't mean a single person it means a cop will appear to people that's I say icicles on the pier on the couple not on the individual actor also goes on the pier you send a zhuge after another couple to serve as character witnesses about the witnesses that is out of puppets playing the mission you say not connected stomach well what's negate here is de Voort measurement you say Mahalo other close-in yeah come yeah this motor says we have a story that contradicts this conclusion the Naro Yi was McHale Shabbos but he went him see it says he went to testify so they answered that really there was somebody else somebody else went with him the Bryce is not mentioning it out of respect to him but there was somebody else that went calling Takashi it means the whole reason we're telling the story is to teach us that even on Adam god--all a great man found within himself the ability to be Michael Shabbos for this purpose so we want to bring a proof from heaven Irene are you we're not just telling a story for stories sake want to bring the proof to bring the proof from the other person who was far less than ribbon are you re in terms of in terms of godless in terms of greatness it wouldn't be it wouldn't be respectful to them naira or as I said the Pinay sure says the respect of ribbon I draw that they wouldn't believe him even if he would come himself he still need two witnesses that's the respect of alumni ride the palatial NEBOSH she says no he tucker win himself the prices says he went that means he went nobody else went he knew that there was another character witness in osha so when the comes he'll be able to combine his testimony with somebody else but according to both interpretations you still need two witnesses so there's no contradiction to the other bracer and repop is right in his interpretation in the mission of this the Gemara asked if so what's the finish what's the finish and when i learning like like Rashi that it seems like the question is if so if it of Ashley is right what's the finish meaning according to the first interpretation there's a give all the kiddush that we're learning from webinar here are either you could do single Shabbos even an autumn goggle it's not a piss-up did the other thing it's like you know let's try to get away with it now he went to be miserable shoppers even though he's not the witness he's just a character witness it's really a hash a mitzvah right he's not doing it but still if they're makalah sharpest no he doesn't work all the shops and that's where you don't mention the other person that's a fish according to the second version of Ashley didn't accept this as an answer in other words he doesn't believe why doesn't he accept this as an answer okay that's a very good answer really they went with two but the other one is not Nagaya here because if Ashley doesn't believe that you need the Bernardo as a source for civil shoppers in other words once we know your letter B McConnell Shabbos and we know it already from the two Michener's the Mishna says that even carrying a bed or sticks or food this pillow sharpest and others whatever is needed so you could do sila Shabbos including character witnesses like the next mission so you don't need a Bryce if for it and you don't need to learn from ribbon Rui and that's where the bar she gives a new interpretation that was no you know I just went to meet somebody else so what's the whole kiddush of the price dish answered the Gemara is that you could McCarl Shabbos on a Suffolk what's the Suffolk in the first interpretation there's no Suffolk he went with somebody else according about it is a Suffolk the second character witness may not be home for Shabbos Rashi says a neighbor base say that's the Suffolk Shama aina I said the base say you could be Mahalo Sambas on the Suffolk it may be futile you're traveling you're violating come Shabbos I don't know what else happened over there why maybe there'll be somebody there hopefully he'll be there but maybe not right it's a Suffolk nonetheless she could be McConnell Shops at Khadijah that's already a fitness Accord to the rush now let's take a look in places over had me Muhammad the Gemara opened up the the sugi of the Gemara is can you believe one the after can you believe one had me man you see the top toys risk of base of advance you'll see tie service learns the good mother differently you see Rashi says without me madman like a shitty la cerva khuskhus woman do we believe one witness the khuskhus Neman do we believe won't witness to make this man crush or we need to tie service says Tama what's his question he Lloyd ma'am and Nami McHale ELISA Shabbos Leila - Sean show me it's not a Samak even if you want to tell me that one witness is not believed to testify okay fine she's not believed but look either Nami McAlister shabbos Leila shot you should still be Mahalo shoppers to go why show me it's not effeminate maybe he'll find somebody else who knows the witnesses okay and they'll combine together just like we said the same a lot about seeing the moon could Atlanta pay the camera we learnt I'm cabeza Matt olive Gaby of a good night a father and a son who both saw the moon they can testify together because their relatives according to atomic camera what's the Allah who yellow who they should go even on Shabbos why let me be they say it starts with emza not because we're gonna use them together because their relatives Ellis Cheney pastilla as the tree that if a shiny market if one becomes disqualified the second one could be combined with somebody else who saw the moon is that means because the moon there's no chance that somebody saw it when he goes and he doesn't know that he's in the in the case of up in Hawaii he knows he's gonna find somebody he knows the e there is somebody there but maybe he's gonna be a baby's not gonna be yeah it doesn't have he doesn't know maybe there is someone that know him but I have not we know I knew that there's some are you saying that the software here is much more is this moving the moon is available for everybody here you first of all okay you saying it could be there's another character witness but I don't know you can't be sure and even if there is just have to find them yes to be the right place you have to find it okay saying it's not a saint I think it's not the same Tiger form so the part is you thought if I say Nehemiah what do we see from here that even if you yourself are going and you know that your testimony is futile because your father is also going one of you can't testify nonetheless agreement how the shop is why because I could combine with somebody else if so fractal is the Gemara sets beside me mayhem and it's one believe that therefore why should it go be masala shoppers that sell toys first learns the Gemara why are you letting him be based on how a service learns that the mission is trying to tell you you could do Sheila Shabbos why did he do Sheila sharpest with one person what's the point why are you letting them in without shoppers thank you yeah why I want to be miss Howell shop is doesn't make sense for what for nothing one is not believed to why are you letting him do little Shabbos so taste versus I don't understand the question you have it with the atheist themselves so you can either with the character witness also you're going to combine with somebody else we need yeah the line max hey ask him a color Shabbos given the lime animal day that wasn't the question wrong interpretation the question was not how are we allowing this one man to be McCollum Shabbos since we don't believe him on his own as we said that's not a question even if we don't believe him on his own he could find somebody else and Lamar colletion of the muscle is he's not asking on the hollow he's asking on the language did not get after the match for the hot man the word that the Mishnah services were shouts an acid not a pain in my favor it means others after means one other washing your head that's the question portion not a question of people why allowing him through the collar shop is add a good answer for that the question is why do you say the word after when you can't send outfit because asset is not enough you have to send back Haden it sounds like that one is enough until you need to like the browser says eight of lost your novel that's a poisonous learns which essentially now she said without me ma'am and la she died but khuskhus luck she deliver khuskhus nine right direct I was Republic so what is your papa's answer after doesn't mean one person act means to people what's his proof it says in a non McEwan eyesight if they don't recognize him it's best and doesn't wreck if they know that the besten does not recognize him who's him the witnesses for the moon which sounds and ask him a strap up over here nobody argues you need to what's I say I say you should have said le sub the answer is it's a couple askin is Osaka fact Isis very interesting question Hema my karma and the alkali metal Miyoshi hazard how do you know I say means two people maybe I say means one person they don't know one person of the couple two witnesses are going to see the moon one guy is the chief rabbi officer of the chief rabbi of tel aviv they know the other guy is a fine jew right they don't know it what's the big deal vice versa I don't understand the populace says it says mashach a main McKean or you saw it can't be one person it needs to be too cuz you have two witnesses I know you have to have two witnesses but maybe they didn't make know one guy they don't know the other guy so I say mean one person I say means one person of purpose all proof is gone I said means one person and as it means one person but hey you have a problem cuz I said could mean one person cuz one of them they know are there you have to send to you have to send two character witnesses for the guy they don't know so let's light it Texas doesn't have an answer wrap up is a whole dryer it's thrown out of the window you understand of purpose a tie it was I say can't mean one even though it means one cuz it means a couple so since I do you know maybe it means one individual because the other a they happen to know they don't need a witness they know they got everybody no Benson in this city knows that guy they know they just don't know the other one so they have to send somebody to testify but now they have to send two people to testify so hundred of Papa's Italia is out the window sigh so this morning the article in mayor says that he thinks that the gomorrah's logic is simple another holiday says apportions espanha he says why would the mission to say I say not awesome you're right there could be a mid CEA's that they know ones that they don't know another guy your act but what two people are going it so why don't you just think he really some just do with ball about let's do it straight they don't know them so they have to send somebody to be made just say so it's impossible they should know one or not the other it's possible but why would the Mishnah insist on the friendship eighty one day they know one guy they don't know just say made my Kiran isomers do with glad to hate yeah what are you gained by this differentiation is it suddenly gaya hear the voices that you need a character witness well what's the difference for one person two people just say for both a this so the purposes the mission of those do that I see doesn't mean one person I say means both if I say means both African also mean to that's how the article Annette answers the toast was himself sustainment without an ass sad ballerina Hoffa no hero he went with another witness don't think he went himself there's no proof from here that you have one it look faceless here evite it he has a very interesting interpretation we're learning like Rashi what's a battery in the hava so that he never meant that sad that he didn't have said this in a bashes interpretation sad that first interpretation is M no no attacker went his to interpretation one is sad that harina have a bad day there was another witness with him who went together and if as she says there was sad that I didn't have ablution there was another witness in ocean sucked Isis Sode Aronoff the yesh Lyman you could say ah the mighty according to the ashy it's not like we're learning like Rashi that in osha there was another character witness know that according to the boshy the mighty beit avichai rawhide there was no you know he saw the moon he wasn't a character witness there was one witness who saw the moon sha allah have no royal it started female height nami al qaeda say maybe they carried something maybe we could say that maybe maybe they took her you know let's say to through the two hours the guy left Friday night and Benson says you need somebody else so maybe they came together up not really what they get tape to get somebody else and he came let's say Shabbos morning let's it was an hour two hours so it's moving to come shoppers of the skill of Shabbos wait up night I want know they were new should that to go to butcher to the Sun had read the Sun Hatton was a no-show yeah yeah yeah Sanhedrin now she said the Sun had there was a no-show yeah yeah yeah it actually says clue the Ksyusha cachet Yahshua Sanhedrin some wish summary I'm a consciousness of hydrogen that was the place yeah we said even the father in a son could both women Carter even though one guy you're not using you don't know you hope what if it was a foggy night and you guys had Mazel but probably if you two saw it probably somebody saw it but you also need that guy to come it could be with his son had room was you couldn't see the nose Yeah right maybe maybe the fellow two things maybe the fellow campers are you want to know how toys miss could say how did I you I knew the second guy saw the moon right maybe they sent a messenger from OSHA they said we need somebody else there's no witness sort of note I went with them if you're looking for a witness with I don't know or or or this aid maybe was with her if not a toy and wherever they live and he went to OSHA and they said you don't haven't we need another witness she went together my not a no-show Abner I wasn't a no-show let's say on down not far but Tom Chalmers more than the come Sean was it yeah to get him to get somebody else sword in their town so the man went they said you needed to bring another person they said you need to bring another person he thought there'll be other people you wonder wine really didn't go with a pillar you wanna know why he didn't walk with this guy maybe so the highest a love according to this would be no the moon is Russian Russian Akiva unless it's Syria there Erica suckle of vaana's in the cave Oh LaVon but la jolla the love sometimes you have a love with him Parsons by mid bar a la motte a vowel of could be with him on him with him so you could say la jolla the love with the precious right so so terseness says how much ribbon I know that started in my Aloha Nami elevators I've heard the clown diva Bryce la jolla a love ahoy - call you my love and he catches on the new moon on the - ballot elections occur she died just I call love on him I thought you can also say with him but he says all of means on him in other words on the new moon Avel I will be roshaniya be chase after I'll tell you what he's gaining no no I'll tell you what he's gaining very good smack what is theis was gaining what do you need this die thick yeah push it cuz now the question and the answer of the gomorian much mortgage smack the gomorrah says e Harvey Milam maemura what's the kiddush it's a much tarnish a little bit to understand the question is absolutely this year no it was Macao shoppers like pie service talk about the buckram I remember another what's the finish so what do I the other with what's the question what's the finish that it might I want to say you saw the new moon we haven't we had mission as the hell out of me Mikado samus clear mission assailant Moya - so one mission after another mission after another you live in Macao service so why tell me that no you're are you believes you're letting him in how the Sambas to see the moon what's the kiddush that he went to say saw the moon okay big deal why shouldn't team and for the Gemara the finishes it was a lot Suffolk we know something so the Suffolk would be taka so now we have to change the story that what Isis was learning was that it was completely a Sutphin Naruto he himself saw the movie and he didn't know he's gonna meet somebody so when it says he went to AA hired the love it sounds like in the beginning of the story he knew there's a guy there right see it's a I came back the guy how he was struggling what happened whatever there was a telegram so the kind of shot is he knew nothing mahalia the love means he hoped nobody saw the moon near him yes yeah he was looking for that so the higher that love doesn't mean Lahari the love doesn't mean he went with some sod back her in that doesn't mean he knew there was another witness he hoped he hoped there was another one so in other words in his town there was nobody to saw them were know that our Suffolk yes yes no Suffolk Subaru is also something you mean it'll be somebody else yeah maybe there's nobody back on that plane and Ed ahadees as a sapphic every time you have one one witness I saw the moon I just go where you go maybe you know maybe nobody's gonna come you know that we didn't learn yeah because it's much fish market we're single if you go with two it's much better there's no question about it so if no no you probably saw the moon himself nobody in his City he probably asked people said they saw so you could think okay I was just having you know a vision but he said no when the hollow shop is Alice offered that's the kiddush appointed abortion or cording to this the EEOC is only under boshy yeehaw fini husky Milam a mer is only a question under Bastion the first interpretation I know what the hidden is the second interpretation that he went to see the new moon what's the finish of question kolima hollow Shabbos then series a la Suffolk is Mikado sharpest all of something that's how that's the my love this interpretation but you're asking a good child you ready have a mission you really have a mission that was a low blow you should both go you mean solder Farina yeah Santa Fitness sounds like there was another witness now he thought maybe we'll be another witness I've also placed his bearish owl near but a scepter Mousa behavior debacle aside my but the way the story is called an English army and interceptor in Musacchio Shoshanna it's clear it says clearly that he went to in order to tell Basden who the ADA's in other words the whole doctrine our hero in La Jolla the loved Akasha no I don't want to testify that he's cautioned not that he saw the new moon but hatred attraction that's what - she says there also but in Bush he knew there was a second man who knew witnesses saw the moon and at night I came there according to this Kali painted the Alfea activation knew you so now toys - sir yes he throws a new bomb that the question iha see my love memory is not going on eboshit what's going on both answers side the first answering the mother that they've married I went with somebody else as a character witness and we just not mention in-game mouses covered side the second answer to bash that he went to find somebody else as a character witness in both the Gemara says I don't see what the redness is and we have to say the villagers are suffering not when you look at Ashley on the word miss faker actually the word mistaken which is the answer - Emma ain't I see aid the basin in other words who actually is learning that it's all about the second question the second answer to bash it because in the first case there was no such a suffix maa made the basin he went with two people you go with two people there's no suffering sir - he is learning that liked Isis - you think the question was only unabashed she and the answers on eboshit dices says no the question was on both answers oh so that's the Shila what would be the Suffolk in the first interpretation how could I still say that it's a question I'm both maybe not maybe based in Donna Gallagher ah maybe the Bayesian don't know they know I know they know I've no way you're gonna Gallagher you seem so yeah we have to so what would be the question according to both answers the question will be Hakeem I'll Amanda what's the sitter's that now Joey went with somebody to be Macao Samba sits another partial to be Macao Sambas I were gonna say the kiddush is that it's an autumn goggle and if was gonna be Mahalo Samba the Camorra doesn't believe it's a hitter's why so tomorrow is for every joke if you allow to be my scholarship is a lot of different colors opposite when I was in the car the camera doesn't believe it's a finish if it's not a Fiddler's wonder what if the brides are telling you stories we have a mission there you can go deployed right went very nice thank you what why are you telling this to me my remember what's the finish the answer is the finishes in Nuala suffer what's the Suffolk now the second interpretation is a niche market suffered we don't know if the guy's gonna be home the first interpretation is no Suffolk so you're saying the Suffolk is that what you know you know he knows that best didn't knows him yeah he was uh he was one of the great they had nobody say maybe best who won't know him best didn't won't know him so that's the Suffolk right that's the Suffolk best them all not so male it's our Suffolk or you could say whoa no the second guy no the night I was nicer no no no I wasn't sure but to say that with but I'll tell you to say that would be strange why because then her accustomed and are safer the whole kiddush is that he took a guy that they didn't even knowing you don't even say that according to the head the understand I don't that would be offended you're telling the story and you're deleting the detail that is the point of the story the boy is not murdered no you're not you're telling me should clean this up you know the whole point of the story is the other guy map him right so that would be a little strange but did it first says that this fake is it's not like the Suffolk in the second case serve a key is that the ADA's could back out tomorrow there Abner hero and his friend who are going it's a Suffolk why is it a Suffolk because to be a character witness is not a push to think today you decide to do it tomorrow when they come to bed and they have to testify one of them may back out why would one of them back out because when it comes to the moon Marshall yeah let's say you're going yourself to say you saw the new moon or you're to aiders are going we're not saying it's a Suffolk why would a this back out and say no we didn't see the moon you saw the moon you saw them all but to be a character your own reputation is on the line right well this besten says maybe the guy is a by Tyson no no I know how do you remember from your Shiva it's 30 years later you know what happened you know who was fred is you know it's figure is right now you're putting yourself on the line seeing the new moon so the moon did I trust this but here to be a character witness you're putting your reputation on the line remember you're the one who testified for this person here you have to be managed a thousand percent sure so it's always an engine of a soft but that's what the Gemara means it's always a Suffolk it's not something that you may go through with that's the Platte entice them in other words it's an onion of a Suffolk that they made back after that's that's it that's it about that call to the boshy for sure you write according to the bastion for sure you're right but oysters also asserted that it's actually it's a triple at saturation no it's on both answers dr. Yamazaki tasteless exactly mother white he us rule above all we said that you need two witnesses to see the moon and you need two witnesses to serve as character witnesses two and two now is one more question do you need two witnesses to tell the Jews what happened to see the moon I need to to tell me that the witnesses who saw the moon are good guys I need to but over there he was intervening with their you've kept it already so he said I didn't hear from best in Mukunda that was the problem that lady didn't have messed him up so he says so so my sake of Allah once Allah came to bubble to Babylonia from air to serum Omar he tells the Jews living in Babylonia she surely Erica be my Rover in my Rover in the West and remember Iraq is to the east of air to stir all so when you're in Bothell you say my rubber West you mean air too strong so he says they sanctified the month in air too strong at a particular day doesn't just mean they sanctified the month that's not a fitness they did it every month it means at a particular day doesn't finish the sentence let's say on Monday they made recitation almond of Kahana and of connoisseur don't think we're believing him because it's he's Allah worried me boy you Ola no question Allah the God Abu who is a great man the man and he's believed nobody's questioning if we can accept his testimony when reduces Allah friloux English the AL Minami man any person from the world will also be believed my time' why would he be believed one witness coming and saying something that is very consequential remember all the element of them are gonna be establish based on this when we don't need comets when we don't do Malacca etc the answer is my timer calm Ilse da fiddly Gloria Lima chakra in shape a psychological principle and that is anything that is destined to be revealed people don't lie about right in other words you can have even a single person I watch them to have two witnesses it's a very serious issue here the answer is usually the witness is telling you something they're not gonna find out right here it's most of the riddle igloo you next week a week later two weeks later guys it's a filthy lawyer if you're a human being at the bestop mansion see you don't want to do this most of that with a little oh you don't worry about right do you say something in 20 minutes late everybody knows you're a lawyer therefore we could trust there's an old void they said and out the Vetal you see that people do lie about Melissa dahveed Alleluia answers like my chakra in she does right Amanda a human being doesn't do it like the man she contrived if you have a something you might you don't delay it usually perhaps perhaps my first mask well you know why does the gimana need this Toyota Deepika Honda has this whole tighter most of the video leg lien but while we have a Clow eight akkad Neman be surah you believe one witness when it comes to forbidden or permissible things for example I asked a guy is this piece of meat kosher is it a live or is it not say live right I could even an ADA a woman yes you go to her house you eat you trust on the conscience you trust her on Neda right if she started she's not toying 8d may mom for kidney shot like this we would host believe they now but there's a faucet mistress so we compared to civil law understand I made them y'all come dollar comes to capital punishment issues like swishes Dublin's little shop is over there's on it says clearly you can't kill a person based on a town no mouth cuz based on a desk no monetary vertical face to lay down but a that phenomen be certain yeah yes 11 be sued right somebody does because hummus he believed them somebody says this is kosher you believe that so what will be the difference here this the coming in of not the possible issue will hide its in the universe Turkish so for kids I've heard is she need to so the first room say you're right but here it would look like that the becomin would have been careful why since the common made we're gonna see soon the whole reason they sent him was because there was a problem because the by twosome tried to fool everybody there used to be a system of torches they had to cancel that system in central him in order to avoid that problem so we would think he had such a problem so you would need more than one person because here there was an exception because he had a problem with the coos another issue here is it stuck honest homogeneous it's not stand there telling you this is kosher trade all the Amin toy them and the killers are gonna be established based on that so you would think maybe you can't just use anybody to testify or you could say hi mare Amalia diced homra vehement item so therefore without the reason of Musa Dagh vid Allah glory let my chakra entry they may have not believed one person sort of Kahana says we would believe anybody tangina me hacii we have also obliged that supports does the browser says boy I heard the sofa eylem but Omar keeps your best in a Sahai dish Nima even if a person comes from the other side of the world in other words nobody knows who he is comes beside fella from the end of the world the Barkers made me so far Lumia but I heard me suffer not bit beside further means he comes at the end of the world he comes from the other end of the world we don't know him and he says best didn't make this and this day refurbish Neman this man is believed so clearly dab Kahana is correct that were not believing over because he's over but we're believing over like we will believe any person who comes even though we don't know him cuz mil Sedova de la gloria most of of italy Gloria Lloyd my chakra ba inch so phylum well at this point so far them like within from the Balamory with the east of China east of China 90 miles east of we're too strong right now you'll ask a Porsche to question one second you just said that we only accept witnesses from people that we know so why here why don't we say you need somebody you know the same problem if we really have Tucker this is a shy life we talk I have an issue of by twosome who want to fool everybody right they want to fool everybody in other words they're ready to do anything in order to deceive best and and that's why you can only accept ages that you know so why shouldn't we be worried here a guy comes and he says this - I - maybe he's lying so you have to say this murder of Mills of the Videla Gloria Lima shot Creon she's really powerful that even the by Tustin will not do it because they're gonna be exposed as lawyers they don't mind saying they saw the new moon they don't think it's gonna be a video Liguria wherever they were I don't think it was I don't think it was one place so it's interesting we suspect them that they would rent false witnesses hire false witnesses to say they saw the new moon that's why we're not accepting witnesses unless we know that these people are trustworthy Jews that they're not up for sale they're not up for hire that we suspect that's why we have to have all these character witness but yet so in other words we're dealing with lawyers filthy liars but yet to lie to others about the day that Bezdek major traders were not being suspects well why Milt's adavi de la gloria lima chakra lima chakra inching but now the question here is we're going to learn in the next mission I guess the night of our tradition so the visibility is so small they think they can get away with it the big question here on the Gemara though is we're going to learn in the next mission that they used to light torches on the wrong night in order to deceive people so you see clearly they did this you want to say most of the vigil igloo in lima chakra in they used to light tortures to deceive yeah that should look like it's reddish as we're gonna see soon the night they would do it on the wrong night whatever their own one choice huh why would the obsessed will soon see will soon see excellent nobody knows who did it right you go up the mountain you light a torch you give it to a kid you say hey go up to the mountain yeah you see torches and bubble you don't know who did it so they huh here the guys coming and saying no that's not a vid illegally a very good answer no no it's a bail about - answer you can also say the tortures accomplished that the whole Claudius all got confused here coming to one community with you know the whole cloud is so that's a Poisson accomplishing understand everybody outside of of the area it's complete chaos and then it's not gonna be so a little igloo you somebody else will come and know that's really know anybody look the whole community is doing it this way here they're coming to one place it's targeted and then you find that in the other city it's the exact opposite so therefore it's a much a much big lesson shot that it's gonna happen I mean could you have a lie of course you can have a lawyer but I'll pee right you're not gonna have a lawyer and therefore we rely on the majority and we say that you could trust anybody who says that this is restraint dish and it's good finish off a dish they don't and depends I mean this offensive agents I'm gonna system like crushes on losses Michael if you come and you say I owe him a million dollars then you have to pay but you show nah the Mission Continues but is shown I in the company there's a hotel in Colorado in the beginning we're gonna see we're gonna see the story now the assessment of malkos Marcus Marcus up it was but a show named accompany this a her dish Michael odd number holy in the beginning as the mission it says why do they sent character witnesses cuz they used to accept the testimony from every person mister till kahlúa by two cinemas Skinner's Lima carbon aluminum akin wants to bite us and ruin this they decided they instituted we only accept ages from people we know so the Bryce is now gonna tell the whole story to explain to us what happened little introduction it says impartial Emmer was fartin lehem me Maharaja Shabbos me i'ma be a famous American official sure buses famous DM we have to start counting 49 days from the day after Shabbos me Mijares from the MA after Shabbos the day that you bring the special carbon i'ma and you count seven weeks and you celebrate she was dead that's a pasta conveyor assembler what does this mean it means that a day after Shabbos there was a special carbon called the carbon element they would go to the fields they would harvest barley they would bring the barley to the besan mixer they would grind it up they would grind the kernels into flour they would refine it the Cayenne how much flour they had a flour which was the measurement of an image is basically 4340 3.2 volume of 43 mm gimble baits in the flemish baits of 43 eggs and a fifth 43.2 that's how much flour they needed the client that commits aright he filled up much of his fist the three fingers with flour he burnt it on the Misbah the rest of the barley flour was baked into matzah and eaten by the cayenne him on Pesach that a lovely lovely meal my mother as a Shabbos and from that day we start counting the women from the night before sorry what do we tighten Maharaja Shabbos Shabbos is Saturday Shabbos is Shabbos muscular humble should mean Sunday we don't touch that we said ma Caruso Chavez means mothers young shoppers doesn't mean shoppers and means young it could be Tuesday it could be Wednesday could be Thursday right second a young TIFF me mother s our Shabbos which for us is a second a young TIFF Annette your souls hello Maya it's not the UM if it's not the regular M yes different time so when they bring the carbonara has Zionists in in the morning when they start counting volume and a Zionists in at night denial - Zionists that by - Sid who deny perish of all paths they had a problem with this they said stop manipulating Toyota I mean mother s a Shabbos means Sunday a day after shop is Yom Tov is not sharpest sharpest is a seventh day of the week that means the carbon iron ray has to always be brought on a Sunday what if the first day of pacer is Tuesday I don't care you're not bringing the carbon diamond till Sunday yeah start Sunday what is gained by this Lewis is always on a Sunday because if you start counting Sunday you count seven full weeks so the 49th day will always be on Shabbos the fifteenth day is always on Sunday so by then Luis was always on Sunday and serious however always started on a Sunday massage shop as he started to count Sunday morning you bought the carbon diamond that was the shift of the by twosome who denied the tradition of Toyota Chevelle Pithom and modulus of Shabbos means the day after young love the Gemara turn Arab on the rabbi's taught a story they told the history mark kill kill kill kill Arbutus when the Mishna says that by twosome destroyed the process and that's why best didn't change the laws what did they do Pamela's something happened one time what happened Big Show by to sing La Havas hakama the by twisting seeked to confuse the sages the hakama what is the story here the story is it was the end of other 29th day of other was on a Friday the 30th day of other was on a Shabbos okay now if the moon would show up Friday night Shabbos morning to people would come to best in and say we saw the moon last night Shabbos would be stylish Shabbos would be Aleph Nissen if Shabbos would be Aleph Nissen when with pace of be remember Pesach is always the same day like Aleph anism okay right which every day is gonna be restraint isness and Allah finesse and that's gonna be the same day Pesach because Pesach is the 15th day yeah so if Shabbos would be fresh traditional would be Sunday this would be Sunday Pesach is gonna be on a Sunday because Aleph is Sunday you dowered 14 days later is Shabbos two weeks right and tests valve would be Sunday if you're a technician is on a Shabbos the first day of Pesach is gonna be on Shabbos they always wanted the first day of Pesach ensemble's because then they'll say ah tomorrow's a Shabbos three assignments on a Sunday the prob right so it's what happened here this was within the day it was Friday night 30th of misson there's no new moon there was no new moon that means it would be no destroyed its 31st way this would be in other words elephants will be Sunday in other words Pesach will be Sunday in other words they'll start counting though I'm around Monday that's when they're gonna be in the carbon diamond they went crazy so what they do Socceroos Schnabel a hardened by urban Mizzou's they hire two people for 400 zoos they gave each one 200 tools which was a nice summer cash eckhart but here's what happened they wanted these two people to go to bed then and lie and say they saw the new moon Friday night so Shabbos will become rich tradition even though they never saw a moon but here was the deal they had bad Mazel Mazel was one of the people who took the money was not on their team he was undercover at Birth by the way the expression mr. Looney comes from the schemata as mr. Looney you should just know at Michelin oh the Gemara is like the Bryce is saying one of them was one of ours what do mean one of ours a man who was loyal to the hot column to the castle detection about bet they didn't know him so he said hey give me the cash he took the cash but he was loyal to the hump but a crook Michelle ahem and one wasn't by to see who really believed in their cause Newton Michelle ahem there guy shall ahem hey they do say he did his job he came to besten and he lied and he testified and he said I saw a beautiful new moose now bears den with listen to the ADA separately because they wanted to examine each person individually and see if it matches right so this one did his testimony Viet saw and he left mashaallah no shelah knew our person came the bracer says on ruler they tell them as they said to every witness and markets at recess a lavona no tell us how did you see the moon this was always the opening question tell me how did you see the moon meaning what did it look like where did you see it everything yet to describe all the positions on my land so this he tells that listen to this guy was a heavy man he's an oily sebum I'll abdomen I was walking up to a region called male adumim which is actually already mentioned in Tomas clothes it's already mentioned time I can't say for sure my Leatherman hoo-ee civ and I saw the moon I saw the area I saw the moon sure who rob would Spanish nice slow the first thing is the moon was crouched between two stones ruddy shadowy mela eagle the head of the moon looked like a calf Osun of the ears of the moon diamond Liddy looked like a goat a goat Sears kind of the horns of the moon time islets Lea were compared to a deer a kisser who's nobody and the tail of the Moon Moon obviously been our closest was lying between his thighs you know the the tail of the moon feet SATs the boy I take a look at the moon when you're Tati I got terrified than a faulty Lahari ride and I fell backwards that's basically my testimony the II may not that unevenly and if you don't believe me hooray Messiah Zeus surely busy me I have to hundreds no remember this is on Shabbos this is on Shabbos right I have 200 zoos in Savini in my in my kerchief they used to into my couch in my pouch so something is like a blanket of curtis and my cloak in my cloak yet 200 zeus if you don't believe me i have 200 zeus and now you'll believe me on rely me Scott meeska color Kaka I don't understand who forced you to do this who made you do this what's their point the point is obviously you're an honest man you're telling us the truth you saw the moon we avoid them you didn't see any moons you saw animals what what do you say you're a truthful person you saw a zoo so why did you take 200 zoos you took two hundred jewels to testify falsely you're not even doing your job I'm mother ham I'll tell you what happened some artists a picture by to Samantha's hakama I heard the news that by too soon were looking to deceive the high command through hiring witnesses a Marty I said to myself hey honey I'll do it I'll go I'll take the mummy void er ahem and then I'll go to the best in and I'll tell them what happened why did I want to do this what do I have to take money and do this Shambo your vote you'll be near them Shana moved on and we have to succumb and if I wouldn't do it somebody else would do it they would that could get to people who are not moved on and one in a poor not trustworthy and they would that could deceive you um rule a the judges told them Messiah Mizzou's the son of the of Madonna firstly you just made yourself a couple of bucks the two hundred zoos you can keep it's a gift even though you would think it's theft because they gave it to you in order to lie if you didn't lie oh you didn't lie so this is a very interesting ayahuasca just because just because they think you lied you're now gonna take the money you took somebody else's money the condition was you afterlife you didn't lie and how would they take the money besten said we're still halat eclis allowing you to keep the money you actually will say why vos I prefer and the one who rented you you musta kalam it he should be placed on the on the on the pillar to receive lashes are you so sorry skin oh that moment they instituted shallow Yuma compliment on my catered they realize we have a real problem there you can have every month false witnesses we're only accepting people that we know we're not accepting any more witnesses that we don't know so now she says let's see that she is ahaha yeah they control bested but look what happened take a look in a Sheila hot this is a common iriyama shallow double Shabbos when it if I dismiss mana xxx of other was Shabbos but the no New Moon appeared but by 2 sin miss Alvin da Washington the by twosome have at either from the word tiger they have at either CA your additional pace of the Shabbos today said - hey I'm novice or Barabbas Shabbos about Sarah's birth of the shoppers they want that you should lift up the oiler that's the carbon I'm on Sunday and smooth on Sunday of course yeah if they would get bested to make Pesach right on Shabbos and and Monday and Sunday then they send out a rumor that best and embraced our view that's a give out the can think for them of course the fish a Anderson and Mercury such are busy and if an ELISA muffler shop is bodacious can my smile like the literal interpretation of Shabbos the solution ebony Omaha you should all suffer the Shia so they hired two people to testify falsely that they saw the new moon and called Michelin Oh so they actually said so why were they hiring below he knew they didn't know the guy they thought he's about to see Messiah mezuzah sanam Lahab Madonna hooter hey deshyla aqua you could keep their money alpha B slash Lambton I shall call us Africa even though you didn't fulfill your condition you didn't lie you said the truth so hydrogen Ava so trashy the ashes love best and licinus mum and vilasa a after part of the authority of bez Deniz they could penalize somebody from money and turn the money into only its owner listen money have compassed enough to know these two hundred zoos they could say it's odorless it's Africa it's part of the authority of best and they could make the money ownerless if it's onerous you can have it good I'm gonna be a Varmus million Africa best in health care how do you know maybe they can't again everything has to have a source best and there's no such a thing as a dying does what he wants it's not half very good Africa Basden Africa doesn't mean that best in is African Shan Emma this Apothic the coil ash olive oil is luscious a young and the glamour yet harem colder who sure as you said whoever doesn't show up within three days he convened the Jewish people his comfortable confiscate his property as we're safer was the leading custom of this time and the founder of an chicken SS a toilet is what Azra says so we learned from here half cabeza NAFTA mater kilometer crash elem alkis could a minimum is set at the marcus crayfish the other valid you tie both of his hands on on the omelet I have to tell you this McAvoy them to some cipher some sofa asks he said if you don't believe me here are 200 zoos in my cloak how is that a proof that he's saying truth he's basically describing that he saw the moon and the moon looked like a zoo do another was no moon other animals in other words there was nothing and he says and if you don't believe me that I'm saying the truth here's money he could have just said yes just say say listen it was not moon which he basically said there was no moon it's also Bubba my so he's good track the miser and by the way if you don't believe me here's a two hundred Zeus first of all maybe he's lying and it is on two hundred zoos and how the fact that I have two hundred dollars of my wallet how does that show that you hired me to lie let's say I don't do this and I'm making up a story K because I want to tell to say the other guy is a liar for example I'm making up a story like oh here's the money that they gave me what's the proof one what it said it says on the name so some sofas says a very interesting voices he says they asked them Kate said recess al Ivana how did you see the moon why is that so relevant here they always asked it some sofas says it means that he already testified he came to best and he walked in and he said ADIS what's the anus I saw the new moon plaster we have a claw Kiran shahikot shoving a phaser a market once an eighth says a de-esser logically we accept the anus now they say how did you see the moon in other words you're ready saw the moon min ha trader we accept that ms madeira Bono we investigate and investigate and investigate that's true but min our toyota right this is not dealing the freshness it's not capital issues or even monetary issues it's about the new moon we accept his a this and the a this is culture even without scrutiny and examination of Bezdek if so now when he comes and says by the way I'm hired I'm a lawyer what I said was a lie you can't you can't retract anymore how logically so therefore we already accepted his aid this that there's a new moon however says that some cipher it was Shabbos like Rashi says huzzah it was Shabbos you carry 200 zoos in reserve yussle you're not a crocheted is your Mahalo Shabbos and the Carlson's may not tell you that special service did I bother carrying money is a problem of Mook sir that's a dinner opponent but it's just her abdomen so yeah okay depends how far the Tomas but let's say was into him ha let's say was in come see the Mahalo Shabbos so if he was a Mahalo Shabbos he's possible a this one second so another question is how was the Omaha low Sambas the answer is the answer is for kiddush ahoy - a lotta be Macao Sabbath and he was trying to protect kids ahoy - these lowlifes wanted to make a false restraint this in order to undermine their scheme he was McDowell shop has been a predator in order to my character protector that's right so he said like this if you don't want to accept me that I lied because I already said I saw the new moon is towards the bucks I'm a college campus I'm possibly this minute Ida I'm puzzling why do I have my Sciences to see the new moon you have to come with money they say you're right why do you have to the answer is I carried it in order to to prove that they're wrong and to undermine them in other words I'm a kosher witness now what the understand so therefore my first testimony is Allah [Music] in other words been mother ship there's no way you believe the first date is some of McCullough Shabbos and if you believe the second aiders say and there's no way this doesn't say maybe OC didn't want them to kill him and also the parts does he come with your friend and you say so the new moon yeah now sometimes you don't accept their ages without the contrition guy said you kill somebody else you don't just kill them you have to go through a whole process but here kid is a herdsman our toyota it's good so I'm gonna try it it's a good Attis if it's a good a this records when I've tried it we don't suspect that people are lying about the moon we just don't do that so much aghast at the by Tristan went crazy about the moon we know people are honest about the moon or come in what's it what's the issue so the tide accepts people right so therefore you understand the void so therefore he said if you don't believe me that I'm lying because I already said hey this I'm a masala Shabbos so my mom answered my aid this is not good if you believe the first statement you accepting from the Mahalo Shabbos a this is possum LMI I'm not a Meccano Shabbos why because I was trying to fool them so then again my aid this my first day this is false and that's how he solved the problem where do you find that he was allowed to be Mahalo shops so you're saying you're saying a lot of the tillow Sambas to carry them in a bed to take sticks to take stakes to fight over the bite awesome we said you're allowed to take sticks in it's just a Robin right why not cause you need to move the moon each sticks because the by touch them are there and you could fight them off with sticks so you're saying he's being Mikado Shabbos it's be much house obviously get full say this tell you why because benaiah them the same smarter why a lot of the solution bus because they're straight this has to be in the right time is the right time to be shopping on Shabbos no they didn't see a moon the right time is Sunday so I'm be my house numbers for that no no think about it Mike Royko dish I said T crew I Samba Maya done that best and should say restore this is the right time that's not Shabbos there's no new moon when is the right time Sunday zombie McColl's shop is that best and should say but my atom should be the right time I think it's it's it's correct no I think it's sister but it's an interesting and interesting part of course if not es to get back the money he has to get back with money you see it's an interesting thing there's no such a thing best it says you know what they're liars we just take the money doesn't work that way doesn't work that way they may be lawyers the guy may deserve Malchus I can't just take money because I'm taking revenge it's very interesting but you see here how a local works there's no such a thing you know I don't like you with taking the money I am taking revenge we need a mechanism you don't take money when you say that it's a goat the mummy with Shabbos after or a barrel of skis because to go lie why would you lie not for money stop mom was telling that maybe they buy too soon the hired none of my juices so listen they believe that they believe it's the proper thing they knew that to lie about the new moon is not the proper thing no they didn't believe it's the proper thing they didn't believe it's the proper thing because they knew that restore this has to be with the new moon it's just they craved pay sucks to be on Shabbos that's what they wanted they knew they have no control over the hakama there's no way that the carbon Omer and Spheeris Sauber could be on a Sunday it's not gonna be that way that's what they do it but they knew they're doing the wrong thing it's a corrupt thing to do why would you do without money another side to the lie lie it's a movement but you're explicitly lying you're screaming my mother is a shoppers advice secretary cook the same God said not to lie most rosette shoppers - accrediting actually proud now you're asking a good question Dave they're quoting Taylor in other words they care about title - ours by doing this they're eating comments on the wrong day same problem you're screaming emotionless that's Albers you're making Pesach a day early yeah so the eighth day you're making basics a day early you're making basics a day early what happens the seventh day of pace are you eating comets ah so that's what toys for sensors you know what take a look take a look let's just take a look take a look toasters Lahab this is a hakama me see very good very good taste resent you see lattices I come him she eat her your mama tell other be Shabbos xxx of other was on shops but I need her outsiders biz mana the moon didn't appear in its right time or by to cinema sovereignty a mile of salvation for Shabbos by to some have at either that the first day of pacer should be Shabbos could they should say I'm novice imma back of the Shabbos so they should wave that all you Mary the carbon armor the barley offering on Sunday but Sarah's back at the Shabbos and Schwartz will be Sunday by the way the word miss lavendar had at either could be explained the little mortgage market the Gomorrah says that a man office summer hey that the reason they said moisture said me Maharaja Shabbos is because he wanted Jews should have more relaxation if she was is a middle of the week she was is one day so you only have one holiday he says my show was I of Easter all Vanya he loved Jews and he wanted they should have cheesecake for two days a vacation has to be a weekend if she was on Sunday you have a weekend you have Shabbos you have a Sunday so miss Sam and they had a timer that pacer should be on Shabbos so shrewish would be always on a Sunday so the mela they'll relax two days let me show you darshan of marketers are Shabbos Shabbos bodacious commercial my British the country's this is Josh's explanation of the Gemara practices Liam timer no my my revision what are they going again while I miss calculating your pace up they believe in Toyota they're ruining it though so basically you're screaming me mother as I shop but do you believe the analogy come at seven days yeah if you're making today dress like this so pay stuff is gonna be on Shabbos oh so that means you're making pesos a day early so Pesach starts on shop as it goes Shabbos Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday it's free you shall pay staff the last day of pace of seven days and pacer the next shop is what we would call a credential paces you're gonna be eating comets really pace it was supposed to be Sunday and you know Letty comments on Shabbos so the same by twosome who are screaming oh my shrah ha-- shoppers are ruining their all pace like what would be their henchmen via schleimann delicious evenly kill Co for them that's not a problem Majumdar she optima filum is it because that's that's terrible / very good that they accept see another they accepted that were never best it makes restore this it's your stylish optim-r filament even willingly certainly here bez dinners not even do it willingly Benson is making a mistake soba may jalapeño Pesach taka ends on Friday and you can eat comments on shoppers that they're not worried about you say how you gonna get comments there was no frozen pizzas say a bull massacre which I am whatever you say they will move are your comments they will talk about no we have not yes we have it we have pay stuff start Shabbos of course whenever it is very sorry miss start something we don't have a problem with Spheeris are starting on Sunday we have no issue what's the problem of course place that starts on Shabbos you never did you first say the Friday night of course you do the first Seder Friday night basically our shelters of course it happens why not Desdemona of Domino so of them New Moon would have appeared mesda would have done it oh so they were accepting a this but it could happen also on other day of the week we don't have a problem that mrs our Shabbos could fall out on Sunday we just don't make that did condition Badou no Badou Bey's dollars off no you cut Oh here it's eight days in our chest roll at seven days why not what's the big deal if you put it in your freezer your soldiers if you sell your comic store go so - oh you sing cuz you can't be kind of back on Shabbos oh that's where you do your right mitts at that you say you're right wait til after a shop is that was their agenda once besten had this story they realized you know this month we had say after the Shania that the wrong guy was hired but next next year so that's it I changed the whole system they accepted no aid this anymore unless they knew them personally you mean later some sighs yeah but he ruined that it's coming come on no no no listen les if I would have known that he would do it I would have never given him the money and it's can either gravis Doc's mavis das and when you take the money it's game over that's just never started to Canadia so after my film is didn't they accept it even though it's terrible in others the authority of beds and they accept to fool best and they accepted best dinner so yeah you know the votes it was somebody wanted to make us unhappy tonight sister all after the state was established so somebody asked said says that one of the conditions is he has to be assigned a betsa yes to hate money we gonna find today somebody who hates money he says for golf commander sky for knife for money you could also find somebody who hates money if you pay him he'll hate money that's also fun some say for money they'll accept best in oh so you want bezels I learn to hate if you have enough money you can you could afford to hate it when I was a kid than you see but there was a boy who was extremely wealthy and he would come and he would burn five-dollar bills and $10 bills he would burn money and it was like a whole show and there were a lot of poor kids you know the lot of poor kids and they would like stand and look through it it was very very it was distasteful I mean you know we were little kids so it was a little bit of a mockery but very good say a good sews interesting Optima film busy didn't they accept it the maharajah shop as they didn't accept it is just a little difference I mean modulus our shop is clearly says Shabbos stop the best in is cavia colleges are finished has a lot hemorrhoids the notion you still need tarnish about path but here they said that you're distorting the pasta I'm just saying Optima filip mosz even is a little you're not distorting applause yeah but if you want to rationalize you could rationalize anything right to 8655 what on Monday mid-session we're gonna learn the muharram say why did this person make up this whole story with the the goat and the calf and the deer he could have just said they're a bunch of lawyers there was no more mr. muharrem say he wasn't trying to make it was a skit he was giving a whole message that was hinted in all those animals so we're gonna learn in a mitsushima Monday you know he didn't have to do any call he would stay himself the other guy left already was they could have just said they said he made you sub 200 Zeus why not stop enough call off shoppers he probably had to leave the money invest in because it was Shabbos couldn't take it home she probably left it Danny came to pick it up and say shava shava what's up to do psych carrying Sam look at Sam and it's a lot of problems I mean we don't say here that it was the sudden right what he did yeah of course it was right what he did you see the whole state they changed the whole system based on him yeah he's not being criticized think about what would have happened had he not let's say the man would have not accepted the money and he said no I'm not gonna be part of your scheme so what would have happened they would hire you somebody else you're saying why didn't he go to bed in and tell best and by the way there's a plot and there's a plot and then with witnesses would come besten would so scrutinize them to prove that they're liars that's what you're asking why did he have to take the money and carry it on Shabbos he could have come to best in himself so that's the fact like this he knew for sure that the scheme would be foiled if he would have let them do what they did and then come to Bezdek that would have been his word against their words probably he would have been vindicated because besten would examine them best in nool astronomy and they would show that they were wrong but still if these guys were prepped well yeah they may have been prepped by experts so you're risking it so that's why here you know for sure he's going to foil their their plot because he's gonna be one of the witnesses and it's not gonna happen so Messiah Hill this was a very noble thing this class is brought to you by the yeshiva net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they you see the net slash donate