Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
I want to share with you a very amazing
regarding the establishment of Tinus
Esther and have a incredible prop for
this sheer that you don't want to miss
we know that today is when we observe
Tinus eser even though today is
not
usually it doesn't even need a right the
says you don't even need a that you read
the but
to but since perm comes out on Sunday
and you can fast on shabis so now the sh
is when do you fast do you fast on let's
say Friday you know if it would have
been maybe it would be a Friday but we
fast on Thursday the says
in you fast on
Thursday okay so you would think
everybody agrees you fast on Thursday
then M says why do you fast on Thursday
why can't you fast on Friday says M you
can't you can't beus
on Friday because of K chabas so let's
get this clear what exact is the C
chabas says because on Aus they say a
lot
of it's a long daving and you can't do
that of shabas because then the
children's not going to come out good
you're going to be sitting
around and you know the guy he's every
year he can't read the word n you know
that word Nish every year he he stumbles
on the Nish you know you would think you
said it last year so take a minute
before to get that word down um anyway
and you know there are other in the so
there's no time to do that on Friday
that's the Mish by the way there's an
amazing the says a different re and by
the way this comes from the ran the ran
sayses
says
why why not so I would say you don't
have time
no you can't taste the food you hear
this you can't taste the food you can't
have
t you can't taste the
food now here's what I'm getting at what
I'm getting at is now one
second I want to share with you
something else comes theama theama says
if P comes out on Sunday they you fast
on
Thursday and the there's a bris on
Thursday says
raama you could eat on
Thursday not the bbrus not the sanduk
not the Mel
everyone everyone even the guy let's say
he comes to shakas like three times a
year and Es um he makes sure to be there
whenever there's a bagel he could also
eat anyone could eat at a bris on
Thursday you blew it
why didn't you find the bris
today however the says but now you have
to fast
Friday what you have to have Friday but
Friday's not a fast day what's theama
you go you anyone can eat on Thursday
but now you have to fast Friday what's
theat now by the way the Taz disagrees
that disagrees he holds the Tinus is
beer Thursday
therefore everyone um nobody's allowed
to eat on Thursday and you make the
meal in the
night only the bis and the sanduk and
maybe the mo could eat but nobody else
could eat says a primam if you want to
be make
like and
the agreed to so that you're allow
everyone could eat so let's try to iron
out for a moment what's
this
whether everyone who's invited on
Thursday is allow to eat or not
the that
the that the ofus
is of course
it's what else is it everyone agrees
it's Thursday what do you mean oh the T
holdes that nobody's not eat because the
Tinus was enacted on Thursday as opposed
to what nobody says the tus is enacted
on
Friday
H
now you see this book you might be the
first to be seeing
it this is a very special book this is
the and this was the that was owned by
the it has the signature in it two sign
first of all over here you
see he used the
word this was owned by and the reason
I'm showing it to you today is today
yard
side okay and this is A's boat signature
see this right over here that is's bat
signature and
the says that it's not P that you fast
today
brings a third reason not to fast on
Friday you don't want to go into shabas
starving and the
rush this is what they do in
Spain but in most of
France they fast on
Friday the end of
the end
of you're allowed to fast on
Friday the minog in France in most of
France as they
fasted now we don't PK in that way
because the rush and the rambam both say
to fast on Thursday but there is a
legitimate
sh that you fast on
Friday it seems like that the Rama is
taking the sh into account so the Rama
holds
that because of the uh legitimate
possibility of fasting on Friday we let
everyone at the bris eat and also the
fast Friday the fast Friday that's not
now I saw a
farar let me just pull it up that
really you can make the the case the
other way
around by the way theuk says that in
narbone in narbon they also fasted on
Friday the Mii says
Friday someone to say that most
people they don't do
well going into chabas fasting because
they can't eat a lot but some people
just the opposite they could eat a lot
cuz they're starving so I'll p
their Thursday but if wanted maybe there
is there is some wiggle room now in the
sa they bring from what's
the between the provia whether it's
Thursday or Friday the Shila is when you
move a Tinus is it the Tinus is really
shabus and we take the Tinus
and we take that very Tinus and we're a
different day or is it there is if it
falls out on chabas there's no fast and
they have to reinstitute a new
fast so the who say it's Friday they say
no it's the very fast that was supposed
to be on chabas okay so then we'll slide
it over to Friday after all the gar says
that on Friday but if the is that no the
fast is Bal and we're a new
fast so then we don't have to do
it we only do it if it's that fast but
we can't do it so we have to push it off
so we're going to make it a little bit
earlier but if it's a a different fast
and the a new fast then it would be a
Thursday brisker would not take an alah
on
why
now I found this out after I got Aliyah
this morning not on Thursday say
Thursday he would not take in Aliyah
today Thursday
yes he would not taking Aliyah why he
would not taking Aliyah why because
maybe should be Ling
by me th maybe would anyway maybe but
that's not what it says says he would
not take he would not take Alia oh you
know what I have it here I'm going to
read it to you
you why because the would say you can't
make
a it's the wrong day tomorrow is a fast
and he definitely when brisker if he
would go on a trip to P he also wouldn't
take a he also wouldn't take
Al have
a now I'm not saying that uh that one
should do that not is today's the fast
but it does seem to play some role in
terms of eating at a fast on uh at a
bris okay say so that's just uh an
interesting um perspective on Tinus
Esther does it make
the
cow not sure not really the right day
maybe mean because a
suff guidelin Sayes difference I
couldn't
find oh that
that the fact that it's alone makes a
difference in the in the Kula of it the
fact that it's that it's pushed
off
um okay RAB have a good day if you want
to hear one more Z you could Contin to
stay on
recording
