Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
You
[singing]
see your [music]
[singing] tomorrow.
[music and singing]
Oh my n
>> [singing]
>> All right.
Good evening to everyone. Good evening
to all of Ami is another beautiful night
learning to deepening our kavana of
together. Thank you to for having us.
Um, I wanted to dedicate our learning
tonight specifically for the Rafu Shimma
of Yeshua Benbasha Razel of Josh Leman
who needs a lot of pleasing
us this
should you know give good things for the
whole world take down all the evil
despits of the universe and uh we should
all experience revealed
is
all right so we're going to do
two funas tonight please God the first
we're going to discuss is
shalani
okay a very controversial topic and then
we'll do the easy one of shalani goi
okay actually it's out of order in the
brahas. But you know, I'm an out of
order type of guy. I'm just in the mood
first off to jump into deepening our our
kavana. That's our holy intention.
What do we mean when we say these
beautiful brahas that kazal taught us in
the gumar in okay so let's just quick
review
of mayor of mayor taught us in
meim
first off you need to say 100 blessings
every day okay it's a serious thing
I'm learning through the ram site's
coming up and the ram counts every
single braha that we say in our day how
do we get to 100 and oh shabas we have
less than so we need to get some extra
braas in there uh luckily today we have
you know we have extra ways to get 100
blessings we have coffee and bathroom
and fruits and snacks and all sorts of
Doritos that we snack on just so that we
get 100 blessings that's the only reason
we do it and then a line letter a line
later in the we have says
b three extra blessings separate from
the other
which is shalomi shalani a and
shalom asani isa as we mentioned
originally it was actually shalani bore
who didn't make me a fool but then we
said ah who says you're not a fool and
we edited that out and the conclusion is
these are the three blessings and this
is accepted by this is accepted by all
the poin by the and this is what we say
every morning And it's interesting,
you know, I'm going to I'm going to get
back to the we'll get we'll go back
there. But uh first I want to talk about
you didn't create me a slave. I know
there's probably a lot of slaves out
there who who you know say that hear
people saying this braha and they're a
little insulted. You know what's so bad
about being an eid but uh what can you
do? This is this is the braha to to to
highlight the the beauty of being a free
man. Okay. Now on a pit level,
what is we we mentioned this last time.
What are we really highlighting is these
three blessings? What's really trying to
say? Because if you think about it,
there's a lot of stuff that we're not. I
don't know. We're not a butterfly. Maybe
we should have a I'm not a butterfly.
I'm not a rock. You know, so why da do
we go out of our way and go these three
things that the categorize the things
that we have to thank Hashem for. So the
understanding of the and the
understanding of the toa at which are
written again
same time as the gamarra is really what
we're thanking Hashem for is mitzvah
mitzvah. Okay. So what we're saying is a
they're amazing. The thing is they
don't have as many mitzvah as us
the shas mitzvah
and how you define that exactly is
controversial. So it could be there's
actually more than seven depends how you
count it a lot of books about it but
they don't have as many as Jews. So we
have more mitzvah than them and not only
that I have more mitzvah than an a
slave does not have as many mitzvah.
Which type of slave ker are we talking
about most likely? So it says the
reenyakar
rebakar was a 13th century cabalist he
was the rebi of the ramban. So whenever
the Ramban quotes my Rebi, he's talking
about amazing POK and cabalist
says obviously we're not talking about a
non-Jewish slave. We're talking about a
Jewish slave. Thank you Hashem that I'm
not a Jewish slave because a Jewish
slave has more mitzvah than a non-Jew.
Otherwise, well, we're going to go
through every different type of non-Jew.
And thank Hashem, I'm not, you know,
this Puerto Rican. And thank you,
Hashem, I'm not No, I'm not. No, I'm I'm
not going through every single type of
non-Jew. I'm I'm going through different
categories of mitzvah.
No, and I think thank you that I have
more mitzvah. And then I get to a woman
and I say, "Oh, thank you, Hashem, that
I even have more mitzvah than a woman."
And woman, as he spoke last week, so
that I don't need those mitzvah in order
to be connected to Hashem. By the way,
parathetically, what about a guy? A guy
who says, "Now, you might think I'm
crazy, but there is a sitter that was
put out recently. There's two two
different versions
for goim who believe in the Torah
mitzvah no goim and giving them a text
of prayers to say so I don't know what
their is you can ask of shy he was the
one who the ro that that wrote that
sitter there's other versions of the
sitter I'm not sure did they say
shassani konu I don't know food for uh
research can uh look into it after shir
but in any case that's really the the
the highlight the the what we're trying
to highlight the different levels of
mitzvah and therefore we're not talking
about a non-Jewish slave we're thanking
we're not an ebid which is a Jewish
slave which is really thanking for the
ability to do more mitzvah so far so
good beautiful now with that said
there's a number of other in creative
meaningful interpretations that can
bring more meaning to our kavono
the Second shot that I found in this
beautiful safer. I always quote it. I
figure today I'll give it some press.
It's my favorite safe for talleos and
it's a it's a le it it quotes from all
over uh the place to bring many
different sources so that I look smart
really I just open up this safer and
others and
quotes the leavah
has a be the following beautiful shot
[snorts]
he says the Jewish people are a hashem
the parro this week's para right we're
living with the times we're connected to
the para God redeemed us in this week's
para the four languages of redemption
and
he basically made us that our Jewish
nature since we left Egypt is that we
can't be enslaved
right because we are we already have a
master and who is our master,
Hashem.
We only have one master, so we can't be
slaves to anyone else, right? Like Bob
Dylan once saying, it may be the devil
or it may be the Lord, but you're going
to have to serve somebody, which means
everyone's going to have some sort of
master. The Jewish people have, and
hopefully religious people have one
master, Hashem. And since we've taken
upon ourselves that Hashem is our master
and built into the Jewish nama is that
we can't handle being slaves to anyone
else. Maybe that's why Jews are very
independent. You know, we don't really
like having a boss. Everyone wants to
start their own startup and have their
own shul and be their own boss because
it's our nature, you know, to do our own
thing. You know what I'm saying? So it
says that's really what we're thanking
Hashem for that that we our very nature
is not to be enslaved but to be only
servants to Hashem because when you're a
servant to Hashem you're not really
enslaved. You're being true to yourself,
true to your soul. So that's not
slavery. But when you're feel enslaved
to anything else except your true
calling in life then that's really
slavery. You know what I'm saying? You
can have one guy, he works 24/7, he
feels amazing, right? And another guy,
he's working all day and he feels
terrible, right? Because one guy is
doing what he wants to do and who he
feels is his true self, right? Take
sports, right? I this afternoon was
running back and forth, back and forth,
back and forth in thevitzy sun and I
loved every moment because I was playing
basketball. another guy you take him and
you make him run back and forth, back
and forth, back and forth in the sun and
it's mamishim. Okay, in the army I I
felt that at times um so the point is
that that's it's all about are you being
true to yourself. So since we are being
true to ourselves we're only toem and
we're thinking of to external things
that are not true to ourselves. A good
little pes you know since we're in the
par of pes. Yeah, that's shot number
two. Shot number three. This offering is
brought to you by Rosher.
He is the author of Tammed
which and he was a big sadic. He lived
here in
uh in the early 20th century. He
actually wrote a book about Salash just
like the a different book on wrote a lot
of Muslim books and uh was a student of
Israel and a big sadic. So in his safer
he comes up with the following idea. You
know what we mean? Shalomi.
What we mean is every day guys have this
kava. We're fulfilling the mitzvah of
remembering that God took us out of
Egypt. Okay? Because teaches us in
in every generation we have to believe
that we left.
It's not talking once upon a time. You
yourself, you common, you Gary have to
believe like you left Egypt every single
day.
Okay? So we do this in the third
paragraph of but when just in case you
spaced out, you might space out in the
third paragraph of when do we fulfill
this mitzvah? when we say the bra of
shaled,
right? Because if not for God taking us
out of Egypt, I'd still be, you know,
working on the pyramids and the Sphinx
and I don't know, the canals that
they're they're doing in Egypt over
there, trying to c, you know, seal up
the border so that the Gazins don't
sneak in, whatever they're doing around
there. The point is, and thank Hashem
every day when you say that he took us
out of Egypt. Why not? You get a
mitzvah.
Apparently, they brought this shot to
the Reb Punovich and he thought it was a
great shot.
>> So, I hope you guys also thought it was
a good shot. Okay, shot number. We're
going to give five shots that I'm going
to offer unless you guys have more to
offer and then we're going to move to
the next bra. Shot number four. Okay,
this one I think is brilliant by our
Rabbi Rab Daniel Gladstein. So Rabbi
Daniel Gladstein points out there's a
very famous in
the inal
says
the Torah tells us you are children to
Hashem your God. Who's the Torah talking
about? You guys Jews. We are the
children of aes. We have a special
relationship with
says
the kaduc says
that
when you're acting like good kind you're
keeping the and the mitzvah. So then
you're called a ben. But when you're
doing a
you're not a Ben then you are in the
madga of an of a slave
your closest to Hashem is dependent on
how much you treat him with love and
respect's
opinion says rebi mayor and they even
have a song about this
by Joey newcome check it out on YouTube
says
bub
Either way, says Remy Mayor,
you are considered children. Even if
you're sinning,
you're still the children of a kadesh.
Cuz a real Abba, even when his kids are
acting up, he still loves him.
And that's the relationship that we have
with the Kadesh. No matter what, no
matter what
loves us, give out. There's this in
unbreakable pint
that every Jew feels and that's the
essence of a Jew. Now, in general,
interestingly enough, we don't pass like
Rebe. We can never understand Ror. We
pass like Rhuda. just learning suka with
and we I was telling we we pass like but
there's one exception in this
in this
brings down we go like mayor we like
mayor
is always the special
like we read in our para firstborn child
okay
Now,
how does that relate to the we say every
morning? Let's put it together.
What are we saying?
That we are not pasing like we're pasing
like Ror.
We're pasing like Rome
says
we're not anali
rather I am a Ben
you here now what makes this so
beautiful you guys remember who is the
author of this brai
mayor the same rabbi unbelievable
mayor is the guy who says is we have to
say because he's really it's beautiful
not my Daniel's
[clears throat] beautiful
so we're saying then that even though
maybe I might have messed up you gave me
back my soul and you consider me a child
of a kesh and and and he loves us and so
we're domining to him we're talking to
him that's my favorite shot but I'll
give you one more shot which I also
think is a beautiful kavana
what do we mean shalomi?
What do you guys think? What What could
it mean? Let's use a be a little bit uh
creative. How does that apply to us? In
what way are we really saying, God,
we're not a vodim? We're not slaves.
We're not slaves to our tas. We're not
slaves to our desires. We're not slaves
to our addictions. We're not slaves to
our past. We're not slaves to our
traumas. We're not slaves to our phones,
okay? We don't have to check the
politics 14 times a day to see, you
know, compare if CNN and Fox News has
something new to say about, you know,
Mamani or this or that. No, we can
decide our schedule every day. We are
not determined
by our bad habits. Shalomi
and we're reiterating that and reminding
ourselves and who's giving us the to
overcome our negative
habits
every day. You can take a meditate. I'm
not going to whatever my bad habits I'm
working on. Think, you know, to each his
own. We just like picking on phones cuz
it's the easiest habit that everyone's
addicted to. But you know, everyone can
ch you can choose your own habit to
thank Hashem that we're not slaves to
it. Especially during the time when
Hashem gives us extra strength to
overcome our tyas. So we can overcome it
through our connection to
So there we go guys, five kabanas. You
never realize shal was so deep. Quick
review. Thank you, Hashem, that I have
mitzvah, a lot more mitzvah than even I
as great as they are. We said, "Thank
you, Hashem, that
um I'm not the nature of a Jew is to not
be enslaved, but rather only to be a
slave to Hashem and as we'll sing at the
end of this year." [snorts] Shot number
three, thank you, Hashem, that he took
me out of Egypt. Fill the mitzvah every
day. Shot number four, thank you Hashem
that I'm a chill bang bang. I'm not an
Evan, I'm a Ben. And shot number five,
thank you Hashem that
I am not slaves to my addictions and to
my bad habits. Pretty good. Yeah, with
that alone, we could have called it a
shir. Yeah. But you know what? We got
more. Don't worry. I want to get to the
less controversial topic of tonight and
that is the brother of Shaligoy.
Okay. Um so uh Rashwab
brings in his beautiful safer probably
the most classic book uh that I use to
connect to David. This has probably
aroused more uh wrath and more anger
than any other prayer in our liturgy
except for maybe last week's shar.
Okay, it's competitive.
Um
but we won't shy away from it. Okay. Now
as I mentioned the says says we have to
thank
interestingly enough there are many gear
of the which do not reach rather it
reads
Israel
that's nicer right thank you Hashem that
you created me a Jew
positive you
this and in fact there are some gears
the rush brings this gear down
and there were maybe a few sitters
throughout history that took this
approach.
It's a bit controversial.
However, here's the problem.
It's almost for sure. It is pretty much
it's it's it's well known that this is
not the original gears
of the Gamarra. You find in a tota and
rights are written at the same time
period. You find in the riff and in many
other gear the original text of Shalani
So what happened? Why in some gar
does it appear?
It's pretty obvious what happened. It's
called sensors. And you see this many
times throughout Gomorra that either
there was a Christian sensor who didn't
like the idea of the Jews uh saying
or more likely the Jews were scared
you know that the Christian sensors are
going to are going to read this and
they're going to be very ticked off and
it's going to start up a grum.
So they changed the gear.
Does that mean in in people's jewels
they were saying
instead of honestly I don't know I don't
know but it seems pretty clear that that
is not the original the original is in
fact
and that's the gears which was passed
down throughout the generations and made
it to the okay and that has been
accepted by the vast majority of Israel
by Orthodox Jews at least for the last I
don't know 800 900 years. Okay. Um and
probably going back to raime mayor, you
know, going back 1,800 years ago. Okay.
So that's what Amish accepted upon
themselves. Now
with that said, it is interesting to
note that you find some fascinating
gearas and random sitters. There was uh
in Italy a gears of Shalo is
because I guess the Christians would be
cooler with that. Um so it got censored
in different ways but the original text
is is as as we as we noted it. There are
even for the sake of honesty there are
even some modern-day great rabbis who
changed it from to
for example
apparently and um and a few other big
rabbis I'm forgetting it's noted in some
German
that they wouldn't say they would
say
why so part of this was because
sometimes refers to the Jewish people
right for example we
We're
We're a nation. means nation.
kad.
So I can say we're not We are
However, the ma majority opinion is to
say because we distinguish we have a
principle that the rabbis when they
establish these brahas they're using the
language of kazal and in kazal language
ago meant a non-Jew okay even though in
biblical language ago could refer to a a
nation a Jew including the Jewish nation
but in times ago meant non-Jew so it's
not a problem to say and that's the most
accepted uh gera today you'll find that
in most sitters. Okay, fine. So that's
just a little uh historical background.
Um
now
still it begs the question
why
meaning there were rabbis who I I was
doing a lot of research about this.
There were orthodox rabbis who really
didn't like this nus. They knew it was
gonna get them to a lot of hot water.
You know, they knew that Candace Owens
is is not gonna really jive with this
braha. You know, she sees me on YouTube
land. What's up? Um, and like let's just
change it. It's just getting us into
trouble. You know, shalo isa too. People
didn't like that so much. So, I was
reading this rabbi in the 19th century,
you know. He said, "Listen, Rabbis,
let's just change it back to Sha is
it'll get us out of all that hot water.
We because if you say shassan is you
don't have to say
because Israel includes within it an
ish, a woman and also an oven. You don't
have to talk about slaves. Want to avoid
that whole topic." So, you know, it's a
it's a win-win.
So, let's just change it. you know this
rabbi recognizing that he doesn't have
the authority to change it just because
he decided to change it but he wants the
the consensus of the rabbis to move
right as we read last week uh even
modern orthodox rabbis
like Rhenin who was very like
sympathetic and empathetic to more women
causes said at the end of the day the
consensus of Orthodox Jews uh has not
shifted on this and so we cannot shift
on this issue we need to follow the of
our forefather fathers just like the
Rambam and many and the Roas and many
great rabbis bring down we don't change
the we don't change the but and yes
there have been some modern modern
modern orthodox you know and the rabbis
who have in their own written articles
about how they personally won't say they
they shifted to shastani is but that has
not that's not the accepted opinion in
the let's say mainstream orthodox world
that I put myself in that camp. Okay. So
that's that's true. But at the end of
the day, why? So says the Bach circus
and this is later reiterated by the
remember we began our gamor says we want
to get 100.
That's how you get the fear of God in
your day. The Gmorra says how do you
what does Hashem ask?
What does Hashem ask of you? Don't read
it. Ma,
how what does Hashem ask of you? Say 100
blessings. Bring God into every moment
of your day. How are we going to get 100
if we lose two? Because we're going to
say is and then we lose our
and then we lose our
because has within it those twoas. So
it's the opposite. We want to get more
brahas in there. So we're going to dwell
on every little aspect
not of how that we think we're better
than the other but rather of how lucky
we are that we have more and more
mitzvah. So ju just the opposite says
the bach we want to dapka go out of our
way to to to not put it all in one to
bear
because asimis
brings down the end of the day you know
why do we need any of these braas let's
just wake up in the morning and say
thanks hashem rub dubdub thanks for the
grub you know appreciate being alive see
you later you know what's with all the
details you Oh, the the ashayatzer and
the impossible and the and the you know
the eyes and the walking and the
[laughter]
all these blessings and what are we
doing here? So says Rapinis because
that's the whole idea
we need to engender within ourselves
gratitude.
Now [snorts] how do you feel gratitude?
Let's say I go to my host, right, and I
say, "Ah,
Gary,
thanks for everything. It was amazing."
So, that's one thing. But then I go to
him, I say, "Gary, the soup, it was
unbelievable.
So perfectly spiced. And the salad, what
dressing?" And I love how you cut the
cucumber so small. That's my favorite.
And then you go detail by detail and
detail. By the end of the day, not only
is Gary gonna always want to invite you
over, [clears throat] but you're gonna
appreciate that dinner a lot more
because you went into death to mafare to
detail.
Now again, I guess we have to we can't
do it all day. Although halav a person
should walk away all day thanking Hashem
for every breath of your life. You know
is a holy practice. I once heard that
when he goes shopping he thank you for
this orange and thank you for this apple
and mish bring it into into real life
but at least in ding I mean ding is
already long enough you know we got to
learn also so we have to have some seder
so we have 18 blessings 15 plus three
it's also not a coincidence but we want
to
and to say thank you for making me a Jew
it just doesn't hit the spot as much as
to point out the alternative and to
appreciate what we have. You know, light
only is appreciated when it's in
contrast with the darkness. So, you need
to think about the opposite reality and
appreciate what we have. That's the
approach expressed by Shimchin Pinas. He
says it more eloquently. You should look
at it inside. But in terms of why we
want to detail, we want to detail more
rather than less. Now
um there are a few more uh interesting
um interesting perspectives that I read
when I was uh researching this topic.
The first is mentioned by the bure
and I found this all throughout
cabalistics the schlawit
who wrote a book on when he got to and
the
we mentioned last week and the balabad
they all said the same shot which I
don't understand but since they said it
I'm going to also say it okay we'll get
what we get out of it they say that
cabalistically
every night our souls go up to the
heavenly chambers.
Okay?
And then it comes down
freshly reincarnated.
Now, it's possible apparently that some
kipos
of the chamber of could stick to
us,
you know.
And so when we wake up, we're saying,
"Thank you, Hashem, that I'm a shalo,
that my soul is purely
Jew material."
That's what we're thanking Hashem for.
We have this po pure extra special
beautiful nam not not that there's
anything wrong with being a but
that's what they say now I have one
kasha on this perspective I'm sure
there's an answer I just don't really
understand it which is who says how do
you know how do you know you didn't you
didn't get come back as as a as a
meaning if there's already a possibility
say say that you could come back as a
soul so then or an isha soul so then
who says you're How do you know? You
know, so I don't know. Ask your
cabalistic friends. Um maybe you could
say by the fact that I'm saying this
braha, then I must have a Yiddish. I I
don't know.
>> But they did say only they didn't say a
whole.
>> Ah, so so you're right. The the says
there was a whole but when I read it in
the alter, he says kipos. So but how do
you know no kipos came down? Who says
>> maybe through the brah is released.
>> Oh, maybe that's a good answer. Maybe
the act of saying the braha gets rid of
the kipos.
That's a good answer. Beautiful. Could
be. Could be. There we go. We lucky that
Rabbi Poston's here, our local cabalist,
you know. Could be. Could be. It's a
good shot. Best shot I've heard so far.
Beautiful. Another shot. Take it or
leave it. Very interesting.
We can't say.
Why not? Because you have to earn being
I could say
that that I can say but say I'm because
the
is of
so I can't it would be arrogant to say
right
but to say I could say so that's another
okay
>> no god doesn't make you sound like you
make decision.
>> Oh, interesting. They're saying even if
I could say is I make that decision
I want I want to get back to that the
last last segment of our when I talk
about gir and we'll talk and we'll just
mention if they should say this and just
uh me get to that momentarily a few more
notes um says
very interestingly on that note
before he would say this it's brought
down he would check himself
to make sure that there was no gayish
kite that no gayisha culture I imagine
he meant negative goish culture which
was stuck to him so before he would say
go he would make sure you know no kipus
you know this man make sure you know he
didn't listen to any goes music that day
and no goes images you know whatever the
I don't think the was listening to like
it doesn't matter the point is check
himself. You guys want to check
yourself? You could do that. You could
do it. check yourself that that you're
mishiwab
also points out that when we say this
we're not talking about the lower
level of
because there was a many great in
our history that the Torah talks about
the whole para named after him no
ether
I was reading I from Ever the Rebi of
the Jewish people
he he was he was a great manzer
was do
says he was teach he could have taught
Torah to the whole world they're amazing
but we're saying thank you Hashem not
that we're better than them but
that I have a special that I have a
special tap kid
you In other words, like repent says,
you know, does a rock say thank you to
Hashem because he's a rock. And would a
horse say thank you to Hashem that he's
a horse? Why? What do we We're a man.
She's a woman. I'm a he's a go. I'm a
Jew. Everyone has their tough kid. He's
the guitar player. I'm the I'm the lead
singer. What does it matter? But the
issue
and the cow has to say thank you that
he's a cow. And the rock has to say
thank you that he's a rock. And the Jew
has to say thank you that he's Jew. the
boy, you know, that says the taz, we're
not saying we're better than anybody
else. We're not saying we're better than
that. We're just thanking Hashem for our
lot. Whatever our specific situation is,
that's our mission. Like we spoke about
last week,
[clears throat] it's not about being
better. It's just about being happy with
our lot. Everything that happens is
exactly the wrestling of Hashem. Okay,
there's a cute story. There's a RV. I
think it's a true story. It was I forget
the name but the the RAV um basically
was called in by I think the communists
when they heard about this braha and
they said oh you anti-semitic Jew how
you say every day you hate us go
he showed him the next he says but it
also says
you think I don't love my wife I love my
wife with all my heart but you know I'm
a man she's a woman we each thank each
other so I love you know love No,
nothing against the I'm just happy
that I'm a Jew. So that's what he that's
how he said it and that's what I think
is the truth. That's our kavanu. Okay,
that's our kavan.
Not saying we're better than anyone.
We're just being happy with our lot.
Okay, two last thoughts quote from two
tumors and then we'll talk about just
for so uh first off wanted to mention
this beautiful Aer uh who has also gave
Shir
uh and they recorded it and made a book
out of it. Hint hint in case anybody
wants to uh you know write a book for
me. Um one day AI will you know just be
able to convert a year into a book and
author. So says
he says like this
the rav says and when says the he
doesn't mean he means
so says
I love every person
I don't have to force myself to love
every Man,
that's my nature. Cook says the more I
love
non-Jews, the more I love Jews. The more
I love Jews, the more I love non-Jews,
the more I I don't have to limit my
love. Love by nature expands.
But I'm not ashamed to say I love
everyone, but I love Jews even more.
So I can also say this proudly and say,
"I'm so happy that I'm Jewish. I'm so
happy I have this special nama
and special mitzvah. It doesn't take
away for a second,
you know, about my love for other
creatures, too. In fact, it it helps cuz
I have now that I'm a Jew, I know I have
the shim, then we're all related. Maybe
he's a brother and he's a cousin, but
we're all, you know, we're all so da I'm
not afraid to say I love them and I love
Jews even more.
gadmat.
Okay? And he says, you know, sometimes
we have to define things by the
negative. Take shabas. Try to explain to
someone what's shabas.
They say, oh, we eat chol. H I don't
know. We sing. But that's actually not
that how we define chabas. We say you
don't do this and you do that and you're
not allowed to do this and you're not
allowed to do that. And somehow all the
don'ts create the space for us to
understand to make proper space for the
dos.
So in the same way sometimes we're just
highlighting the negative to remind
oursel of the positive we have in our
life. But it's not to to dwell on the
negative. Okay? At least that's one way
I make sense of these brahas which to be
honest even when I was young I struggled
with the this these these brahas and I
always think the most important thing is
how we interpret them and how we teach
it to our children and to our generation
>> thought about this have to give myself a
commercial break this is a safer I put
together uh about Carvach's teachings on
Fila um and actually I didn't write
anything about not sure why but I did
find mamish a beautiful teaching on this
topic and slowmo says like this
can read it inside
um
okay a little background's
whole family got wiped out pretty much
by the Holocaust okay he was a Holocaust
survivor to an extent and there was a
lot of hatred in the generation after
the Holocaust And so it would be very
natural after the Holocaust for people
to like just respond with hatred the
goim they hate us you know but that was
the opposite of Rafel Makabak's approach
in fact he went and spread love to
everyone treated with love and kind and
respect to every random [clears throat]
non-Jew he met and taught that to the
world and so once he went back to Poland
and he started doing concerts in Poland
and in Germany where his family had been
wiped out and and he started doing these
concerts to spread love singing and
people said are you crazy
it's a bit too much what are you doing
too much love man
too much of a hippie so said like this
okay so he tells two stories first of
all he says I want to tell a story. This
is something I saw in in the Omiper war.
The Egyptian army was surrounded by
Yidden. We were singing Amai.
In the middle of the desert, we saw
Arabs coming. Nine Arabs coming holding
up their hands. They were dying from
thirst. What did our soldiers do? You
know, in the desert, every soldier gets
a certain amount of water and of
Coca-Cola to keep himself alive. All the
soldiers went to their tent and brought
out all their Coca-Cola to give them
something to drink.
There's a doctor there and he started
treating them. I couldn't believe what I
saw. One of them asked the Egyptians in
Arabic, "Why are you fighting them? Why
are you fighting us?" One of them said,
"Because we want to kill all the Jews."
There was a soldier there, a Jewish
soldier. He said, "I'm so sorry you hate
me. We could be the best of friends."
This is a yidden, right? Something else.
No matter how much another story once
was in a a taxi cab and a taxi comes up
to him and says you know if I could I
become Jewish I love you guys and he's
like why what's wrong with being a holy
go says what's he says you guys
everyone's hated you for all these years
and you still refuse to give in refuse
to hate the world and that was approach
he said you know what you know why I'm
doing this concert. I know there's a lot
of hatred out there. You don't think I
know there's a lot of anti-semites. You
don't think there's I I don't know
there's a lot of uh terrorism terrorists
and people promulating that philosophy.
But I'm a doctor. A doctor's job is not
to dwell on all this sick people, but to
fix things. I'm here to fix the world
through love.
Okay. So as someone who considers myself
a little bit of a of a talmet of cookook
of Schlommo I can tell you with with all
sincerity and I really do love every
human being and I think that's part not
despite but because of my Jewish
upbringing. I really feel that way and
so I really genuinely feel that it's not
coming from a place and it certainly
shouldn't be coming from a place of
anger or hatred rather it's simply
coming from a place of recognizing
what a special gift we have our special
mitzvah and our special that has given
us and again at least I think that's
what our kavana should be now just one
last kind of side topic
What about a
galani
that blessed are you a god that has not
created me a non-Jew. What's the obvious
problem with that?
What's the problem with the Gary saying,
"Thank you, Hashem, for not making me a
non-Jew."
Well, awkward. But you did make me a
non-Jew.
that how can he come go and say thank
you Hashem for not making me a non-Jew
when he did he was created a non-Jew and
then he converted so how can he say that
okay you hear you hear the question so
in the it's so good that the bas of yo
writes in you're right a g should not
say this braha it's okay it's not it's
not a this he's just he was he was
created a non-Jew so he doesn't say this
braha
in the interestingly enough he doesn't
bring it down. He doesn't say one way or
the other which is surprising because
you would think he would go out of his
way to tell you know be
so I don't know maybe the did he change
his mind later in life or maybe just
didn't want to get everybody upset you
know you want to see my opinion of the
matter go go see the boss I don't know
comes
and he writes
Thank you that you made me a
although that too writes the taz I
believe or maybe it's the bach is is a
bit weird because did Hashem make him a
g? Who made him a g?
[snorts]
He made him a g. God didn't make him a
g. God created us you know but a g he
made that decision. And so I say
that you let me become a g but like what
do you mean you didn't make me a g so
says
the no because it's like and the
who made the souls of karan a
right the people he converted rashi says
now did a make them convert he didn't
make them conser convert they converted
on their own they did chuva but he
facilitated the conversions So helping
is like making
okay
we so it seems like the is saying at the
end of the day
God helped that convert make the
decision and so it's like God did it. So
that's the Ramos version
comes from and a lot of theidics for him
and they say no they should say just
like every other Jewani
[cough]
what about the problem of the of the
how can they say it so no it must be
that g it turns out really was not
created a go what was he created did a
yid his nama was Jewish back at our
but you know somewhere along the way he
got reincarnated as a but his
essence was always Jewish and therefore
they can say shalom asani even
though it seemed like they created a
but really
yeah or you could another way of putting
it since every day we're recreated Today
God did not make make me a It's
another way of putting it.
It's not so clear. Different pkim.
Mishna Bur brings it down. Some say
this, some say that.
I don't know. Ask your local uh Orthodox
Pekk if you're a G. what what it seems
like there's yesesh for all the
different minimum and you should just
ask your rabbi and and go with it but uh
I just thought that was a fascinating
vignette but uh just again putting it
all together we have finally con uh
concluded uh the three part segment oh
as I'm summarizing remember one last
mayor's
And maybe I wanted the
that who is it that teaches us
rebi mayor.
Why dava rebby mayor because mayor is
the mera of the one who tells us that
no matter how many mistakes you've made
you're still the child of hashem.
>> He's also the child of gum wasn't he?
>> Ah interesting. He was a child of gaim.
So maybe he appreciates it more.
Interesting.
Yeah. Be interesting to do research on
raer
naray married to burya. Last week we
postulated why he was the one in such a
isa
having such a holy wife. Um so here I
want to say that since he mameish
um is the one who recognized and brought
to the forefront that no matter how far
we are from the fold that n the shama of
a yid remains ultimately the firstborn
child of a kesh we have that unbreakable
pint
spark of holiness
and so davka he's the one who's able to
say that I'm Jewish not that
I'm putting down being goes he's just
saying thank God that I have this
special gift that uh of being a holy you
know maybe I'll end with a ma once of he
was uh he was having a hard day you know
he was having a hard day he was really
down he's like ah who am I I'm nothing I
haven't lived up to my potential and he
skipped he didn't say shalah sunni go
and then he waited he waited and and he
was able to finally say shaloi and he
was so happy and that brought him out of
out of his stuper because he was able to
just think about the fact that I'm
mamish the child of and no matter how
low it seems like I've sinned how far
the end of the day Hashem loves me just
like a loving father and cha is just one
step away so that can be our we say
and now let's sing
that we're
Not aim but of
[singing]
King
of the heart
[singing]
I need
the I
[singing]
Nana
nana.
[singing]
N
[singing]
I
Nom. [singing]
[music and singing]
[music]
[singing]
[music]
[singing]
[music]