0:00 / 0:00
Tefillas Maariv Weekdays and Shabbos - Different by Nature or Just by Nussach
14 views
Shiur on Tefilas Maariv by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner at Beis Medrash Ohr Chaim in Monsey, NY
Categories:
Torah
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
in this
week's the
begins Rashi brings
a it's also a that this is the
every single
night where does it come from com some y
right here this week's
para the EMES say if you look in the
over
there the we a
m one
the right here and then the brings
another says
that
and
says and that
says
what's so Shak is
conned Shak the carbon that was brought
in the
morning and by the way that's what we
have
is
and because
the was usually brought up until the
time that we have this that's when it
was always
brought you cannot bring the
after so that's if
is is at the time
of in the
was brought from
after so what's these only two
carbas
what's so the says is
connected the leftover from the carbon
that they put on to the m to
burn that's what how feel
ofand arm carbonis and they on whole
night so that's why
do for the
M of MV is it Y is a k the
the brings like and
therefore like
both the r brings
the the and the
r when the ra goes through the history
when
the came what
was and then the ra says over there in
the ra says that
was so it's both the BRS both
the where is what's the source where
does may have come these two
makusu and also
[Applause]
kbus the sh is the following
we know it's a gamar the gar says that
is
a is a r it's actually in the and had a
if if the source for the of
is so that we understand is not like
Rashi says in shabas Rashi
explains that if you brought a carbon
and for some reason didn't make it onto
the the carbon okay so if is
connected so
it's but
if
is so why is it a just just
like it's not
a not why should
be
one and a say for the says that really
like the gar says wasn't even
planning y like the gar says Yu passed
and he said how could it be that I pass
the I'm not going
to so yov went back and
yov that being
didn't he
wasn't is that I wouldn't call it by
default but the passed already like the
gar says Anda he came back
because he's not gonna over there also
says along these lines but a bit
different and he
says
only maybe he knows it based off the of
what says but he says
says the
Yeshua as we'll see a bit more about it
soon the Yeshua says that as we know the
sun went down
early so it wasn't even the time
of but it wasn't even the time ofv so if
I understand correctly the was it wasn't
a full my the way we have my by night
was really the later
afternoon these are all to explain why
my
is end of the day it was night
time a good was by night was T night
already more about your question shortly
we'll see in a moment more about it that
was not
already but these are to explain
whyu wasn't planning on daving my only
just on a side note but of course very
important even though we're saying that
may
is and therefore
says that there's
no if you ever wondered why
is why not why
is so doesn't have to be anybody
because in the olden days he was no City
he needed to be somebody that wasn't a
my Riv is so you don't have to be
anybody
however M over there explains he've CAU
an Al however
however even
[Music]
though what should not miss one should
not
skip even though it's
a
as even though it's we took it as
a it's not a it's a now it's
a however what still stays from the r
the M over there brings is this that
most ladies
don't is T because it's
a so is the part one of the
part and as we explained if it's
con why because
they
if we explained
why now we're going to go on to the next
part these
tonight Friday night
we
earlier than regular whatever time you
di a myv on a regular night myv Friday
night we di a my
earlier what's theat why
so
a what I mean AG is it's a different
reason then we'll go to the that
connects to what we spoke about
before this week's par says you know why
we di a Friday night
earlier
because and has
that that night was Friday night
so even though like you asked that was
and now was night and withing earlier
that night that's what I meant to say
before that more about here
also that's the reason for
the earlier Friday night because the
whole came about the story was Friday
night
and Friday night early that's
this week's
par says the reason why
we Friday night earlier what's the
reason in
the you know what
earlier
my like we just said
before okay
Friday nights had to be put on Friday
afternoon you can't put it on Friday
night
it's so being that
the Friday night was put on Friday
afternoon so four that's how
we just to
clarify this before going to the
Kasha Thea says along these lines also
and to explain it R pal explains it
nicely there are two so to speak issues
that could come about with daving Meer
of early tonight Friday night one
is before night so for that that's what
the explains that my is
Conn and Friday nights were brought
earlier good that explains why you could
have a my
earlier still Friday afternoon but
there's yet another issue How Could You
D Friday nights M shabas when it's a of
shabas I understand that you could have
a
my Friday afternoon because that's when
you
brought but wait a second Friday night's
is
a how do you a Friday
afternoon for that what say it
wasn't yes definitely let's say Tuesdays
let's very good you're bringing it out
gal excellent let's say Tuesday for some
reason Tuesday the din Wass to bring
their arm up D Tuesday afternoon so good
that's why Tuesday we early but being
that is Friday night
I understand you could early but how
could you a when
it's for that the ter is is that being
that will ma shabas early whenever
you shabas with even before once you
shabas you already have K shabas so if
it's
you so these really two things that you
need to take care of when you from
Friday afternoon the
itself it's not shabas the answer is it
is chabas because you Mable shabas
early of that's Universal that applies
to everyone everyone in the world the
shabas is a little bit more unique
because it's chabas for you but your
neighbor is not
shabas so how does that work
it's not universally Shas re some people
do a little earlier some people do a I
mean now it's it's everyone's doing to
late right almost every yeah but yeah
but so so what is the question some
people make shs early at 6 o00 and some
people do Shas at
8:00 so you it's not equal for everyone
so you're doing Meer
early for you it's chabas for the next
guy it's not chabas so it's not a
universal my
allowance but what is your question it's
true these different people have
different times during the week it's no
problem you D my early because it's it's
everyone's on the same page because of
the we we learn it from the
caranas but Friday night it's different
for everyone not everyone's in the same
boat but so it's true what you're saying
that not everybody's in the same boat
it's very how does it work Friday night
versus one could be in the same no
but what it doesn't doesn't have to be
the idea is is that any person when
their ma shabas as long as it's after
the plug doesn't make a difference even
if everyone so yeah so it's on the
person not on the correct the correct so
Mich you bring up a good point that even
though it say one second let's go slow a
brought Friday
afternoon therefore you could dive a my
already Friday afternoon doesn't make a
difference if you're going to dive in at
8:00 when is 8:30 or if you're going to
D at 6 o' you could you
could brought Friday afternoon however
how could you personally d a when it's
not chabas shabas no matter when it is
you the whole this person could do 7
o'cl he's a 7 o'cl minion he's a 8:00
minion and you're going to D A my at six
o' it's no problem because when you
shabas so you personally shabas even
though it's Friday
afternoon early so that the answer is
that came Friday afternoon doesn't it
wasn't a particular time that it was
6:30 or 7:30 it was B Friday afternoon
so you could have M Friday afternoon the
shabas part that's a personal thing that
you needed D when chabas so for that
whenever you want whenever you shabas
it's you
couldas why is
there for sh because it
was
before so you're saying the the
says maybe it is but you're saying you
see a lot if not most people don't die
before shabas or
not so so the truth is
that so you're
asking
early
laa we see we'll see over here this is
we're going to spend a few minutes
now it's not so
clear what exactly do we accomplish by
daving early of course we said very
nicely because the was brought Friday
afternoon so that's why we D
early the question is
theha wait a second when you're going to
di a my
early shabas so what did you gain we say
you early because they V Dar were
brought brought Friday afternoon before
shabas new and when you D early before
shabas so now it's shabas for you see
invite the bringing
the on chabas so what did you gain I'm
not saying that that frags up the dinner
of the what you're pointing out not
maybe not but that's the Kasha that's
the Kasha what is the explaining to say
that you D it's not once you D chabas so
you bring the on chabas
so the says two answers answer number
one he says
is when we d a early let's say 20
minutes before shabas so it's shabas
because you can only d a when it's
shabas but it's to
shabas it's when we d a we're not
actually
bringing it's
so it's enough we're not shabas by ding
even on shabas it's enough to D early
even though when we D in early it's shab
so it's V shabas but it's enough to have
this remes let's call this Remis of
daving before shabas to that they before
shabas even though it's still to for
shabas and we're not going to have this
Remis in the to for shabas because the
to of shabas shabas already but it's
enough of a rem with DAV that for the
regular shabas we're not bring you have
to bring it before
shabas what's the argument that people
have against shabas so here we're not
really speaking about early shabas in
general it's hard to say what people are
against it's a gamor it's a gamor that
ra mat that made early shabas what
things we actually we here in the
morning call a bunch of years ago at
whole series of making early shabas it's
impossible to give a clear answer on the
spot over here but there's many
different shist that come up when you
make early
shabas one after the other and if you
let's say you finish early I give one
example you finish just you after know
if you finish
ear pretty close to the it's already
questionable if you can make k then
because you have just one poter after
you know different shist that come up
the suda maybe has to be by night so you
should eat another kazas by night
there's a lot of that one should know
about yeah you're right you're right but
what says is because
the were brought before shabas P from
the means that it should be
before earlier so what's the during the
week
after
connected so this is also good good sh
you want to know first of all it's not
it's
not so it's not the if you
after
being the together of PL that's for
itself we could speak after I gave a few
sh on it I think two sh to try to go
through
clearly plag is applicable out of myv as
well
also if somebody needs will come
after you could lay Milla after the pla
like a case of that somebody came he's
he works in the hospital he had to be
per by night the whole night and his
shift finished afterwards in the morning
and he went in already before such a
case would be I don't know why I wasn't
he couldn't hear Milla in his shift he
couldn't so that would be a case of
anyways as I
first is
that
we for that we talk it on another ter he
says is like
this what we add on more time that's so
in they were able to
bring even on the shabas so what was the
question
with shabas so then you can't bring any
more the answer is you
could shabas it is shabas but in the to
be able to bring
it another terets another T and this ter
is
the he says like
this while all of clus was ma shabas
early at any given time they don't wait
for the last second they were always
always shabas early it wasn't like that
in the bdash the
bikash as hopefully we'll get to we'll
soon
see there was a lot of work especially
Friday afternoon I V up as we mentioned
before you have to put on
before on a regular day you could really
put it on later Friday to there's a lot
of work so theah went there was reason
that worked in the BD up until shabas a
minute or two for so while the rest
of early worked in
the we early because when
we shabas we were always shabas and
while we were shabas working in
bring so that's he answers
we obious you can't bring a v we can't
bring the V theah and brought their
V the yit asks the following question on
the mavam so we had one question on
the
already theit asks a different
question and he says wait a second let's
back up for a
minute how did it work let's get a
better understanding with aaram before I
kind of just said it vague that AAR Pam
were on the M burnt the whole night so
that's why we D you put it on it's
burned you put it on the Y says let let
me let me ask you like
this when were they put on
to they was put on by day that was the
man if you didn't make it on if it
didn't make it on by day you put it on
by night but it was put on by day every
single day of the week including shabas
that means for tomorrow afternoon's
carbon they put it on on chabas they
didn't wait for by night it was always
put on by
day so why do we have my of By Night de
P will put on by day the terror say you
know what we have my by night cuz when
was it burnt it was burned throughout
the whole night
so what is the saying we d early because
of what was different today than any
other day every day he was put on to
the in the
afternoon and when not for when it was
put on you because it burnt on the the
whole night so why should why should we
D tonight earlier because of why because
you put on every single day a week you
put it on my not connected what you put
on my connected it being burned through
throughout the night so Friday night
also a bird throughout the
night
so answers and he says that it was still
a little bit different Friday than every
other
day a that went on to
the it couldn't just sit around on the
MB and not get burnt so you see in
regular night you put it on during the
day and if it doesn't get burnt you push
it in Into the Fire it can't sit on the
m and it comes the morning it never got
burnt see 1:00 in the morning if there
was a part of it that the fire didn't
hit it for some reason you push it into
the fire
shabas
shabas you couldn't do that shabas
Friday night you couldn't push the into
the fire so what did you have to
do says
came
shabas and whatever wasn't burning
meaning to says it wasn't it was didn't
catch on to fire they took off the
Miss that's why we D early true you
always put it on before shabas and true
my is connected what gets burnt but
shabas it need to be burnt before shabas
doesn't mean it have to be burnt crisp
but it have to be on fire already so
that's why we di a m of early we di a m
Ked what not ConEd pudding on the MB
ConEd what it got burnt but Friday night
it had to have already gotten burnt
already Friday afternoon that's why we D
of
early there was another point that I
wanted to speak about I'm just going to
say the D real quickly the yit says very
interesting even though we said up until
now that my is
says that says that Friday night
is unlike the of the whole week so these
are a few reasons that time doesn't
allow
it oh very good said the same as well
also that's why Friday night we have a
to be very good I didn't he pointed up
now when we were learning I didn't look
through it properly very good these are
few reasons
and if you want to afterwards why did
say that it's a why should Friday night
be
different I just want to end off what
theit as we mentioned the beginning of
the explains with why it's as we we said
that it's because y wasn't planning to D
then he goes on to say the following he
says unlike the
ofu and the g con which
was it was
straightforward 400 years of and then we
come
out of he
says of B it's also straightforward 70
years and we're
out Mas the gas of yov the gas that
we're in now there's no there's no
Kates from right away
right when we went into G already it's
not like it was a set time it was a set
time here there's no set time so what is
it's but he says R means that it's up to
us if we D we're we're we're so to speak
we're in we're in the control we have
the to control to end this Gus if we dve
him properly we could end the Gus so the
and
also goes in
that at the same place
that is
be all this is means it's an our hand to
be able to bring the to bring end of
theas