Sukkos: How Does turning The Esrog Upsidedown Render the Bracha Effective For the Other Minim

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com frank in the mccrory kaidesh discusses taisus in the sukkah alam and testament aleph who writes that the wayward mekai making the bracha on the dao mini is by flipping over the asteroid in other words we take the dalai medium but we take it with the esrog overturned and this way we make the bracha and then we turn the s-rogue right side up so the bracha is before the performance of the mitzvah this is codified in simultaneous before you take the esrog s so the question raised in the makai kai dash is that very nice the brah has overlapped of the proper taking of the s-rug but it's not overlapping for the other three minion lulav hadas there you took it before you made the bracha so the brach has only overlapped the assam on the asteroid but says of superior frank in his opinion this is not a question because even though truthfully you could be you'd say taking thou meaning one after the other after the other after the other so in this case you already took three and your mikayim three quarters of the mitzvah before you made abraha however since if you didn't take all of them you were not making any of the mitzvah if that's the case as long as you didn't take all of them you didn't even begin the mitzvah the mitzvah only began and concluded with the taking of the last one and therefore it comes out the bra the mitzvah is done when you take the last men and therefore the barakah is in fact awesome says frank this is analogous to the fact that we make the bracha of every social abramovinu does the before the priya so the question is how could you make abraham on the pre-lachanisa research was not mitsave on priya priya was not given to abramovino must be says frank since we passed so it's not only everlasting on the priya so as well so too here by the dollar meaning even though you already took three of the four minimum and if you take one after another after another you'd say nevertheless until you take that fourth one you're not making anything and therefore it says it is considered a relative on all four species wishing everyone a good time you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com