0:00 / 0:00
Standing For Mitzvos - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith
72 views
Does one have to stand up for a chosson and kallah? Nichum aveilim? Can one sit by a bris? Does one stand up when an aron is brought in by a levaya?
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
on the topic
standing for mitzvahs today she is my
grandmother that
cyril but also the outside is today and
we're going to be active smash later
once again we're amazed by the arukamir
it's me that the great kind of torah
the tremendous wealth of our torah we
see
i started with a simple shiala a few
simple shy of us and it turned into a
beautiful sugya with
a mishna babli xiaomi
you start with a question now you go to
akhasana and you see
that when the hustle and color walk in
some people stand up a lot of people
stand up
and some people remain seating remain
seated
not they forget to stand it seemed like
they haven't paid their not to stand
when the husson carlo walks in and i
wanted to know
what is uh the explanation to this
then we had a shia la i guess uh the
other side of the spectrum
leilano by nicola marvel
people are sitting and then they stand
up and they say
i'm standing as if it is some kind of
paid
afghan to stand and i want to know is
that talking true
i was once by a bris and someone told me
you see people are sitting by the bris
it's wrong you're supposed to stand by
your bris
nope is that true and then just it was
actually almost two years ago i still
remember it by the vrabelski's
so it was a it was a very you know made
a tremendous impression when they
brought the
nifter into the levaya the entire island
stood up
and again i made a very deep impression
and i was wondering is there
to stand up for a person that's no
longer alive
and as we'll see all of this is actually
part of our sugiya
which goes from yaradaya
and evaneza
standing for mitzvahs when and how was
it
so one thing i want to mention the
concept of standing
is not a clinic you know stand or sid
big deal that's not true
we learn we learn in the beginning of
the navi scheiften perry gimmel pasta
the passage says divar ali kim lee when
eggland was told hashem
by yo kamala kisa he stood up
he heard that hashem and he stood up so
rashi
and other washing him quote ghazal that
happens to be the makariza mejitan kuma
either his daughter or his granddaughter
who became the greatest mama of david
and schleim
imagine a guy used a king he was a guy
he stood up for the viral sham and he
was occurred to a daughter like russ
but it's more than of course the
medicine in fact in russ bay's test
ads because he stood up off his kise
he was saying to an ankle that
yoshis hashem he was the pasik
see you know we talked about uh
took three steps or three or four steps
to
show cover to academics and he was
called
to destroy the base hamikdash because he
showed cover he took a step
for quite shame
but what really seems to open a new
chapter into our sugya
is a missionary right this is the the
beauty of the sugiya
it starts with the missionary gemara and
it develops into a very
very detailed sugy a little background
we should know
the mister and the peric
gimel and bikuram speaks about when eden
brought bikurim
the tremendous parade the fanfare that
went on there was music playing and and
the kohanim the levia man and everybody
went out to greet
the mavi bikuram they were bringing
their bikurima
the first crop and the whole ushalayan
made a prey to welcome these me via
bikurim
says the michigan parry gimmel mishna
gimmel
kobale um
all the work is stood up
stopped working and stood up to show
respect
for these mavia biku now it must have
been an awful
aw an awesome sight this the as the
mystery calls them to
the the segane the sagani the
all these different gadoli israel and
even the workers that were busy working
stopped to show covered for the mavia
become
now if you have a sensitive ear
for tam is only a keema
kiss if there's no loss of money you
stand up for
if someone is working for someone else
and by standing up he's gonna have to
stop working for
that small amount of time the gemara
says
he's not allowed to stand up for him
and ty says yes
what's wrong if you do what's in a
vehicle to stand up
they says yes if you're standing up and
you're
wasting time from work that's an issue
you know it's it's another reminder of
the
tremendous importance of
but if you're working for someone else
now your obligation is
standing up takes a few seconds i it's
only a few seconds but a few seconds in
a few seconds
so it's wrong and i will show you to
stand up for tamil
when a person is working as a state name
frank di gemara so
fragment how could that be when a
person's working
he doesn't stand up for talmud even
though it's a midst of their isa
and now when the victorian come which is
not a direct
you stand up even though you're working
how could that be
them you're right
look how precious it is when someone's
but for a person that's doing the
mitzvah that
transcends that and you stand up even
during the work
and bamas rashtri the gamora has the
same
and rashi adds sriracha
we have to magnify we have to accentuate
the greatness of a mitzvah and therefore
even though it involves
you stand up for me
ah you'll say but what do you mean this
is a pasha to farmer he probably came
with his overalls and his graces
what do you say it's not for him it's
for the mitzvah
in fact the gemara then says maybe
it's not such a riot video
and rashi explains maybe there's no here
to respect
isa mitzvah but why do you stand up for
bakurim
so rashi explains otherwise he thinks
who am i
you know you have to think about the
mitsubi kurum there was a tremendous
parade in shalayim
what was this farmer bringing how many
bushels how many
sacks of uh fruit was he bringing not
one
he was bringing like the mystery says te
anesha bikra
riman shebika one fruit becomes one
fruit
he was bringing one fruit and he must
have felt
he's sleeping from the other side of the
world perhaps he must have felt so
unimportant what's he doing
so if you don't show him covered he
won't come next time
rashi says if he doesn't feel important
he's not going to come next time so
maybe taka there's no
for a mitzvah it's only machine learning
but as we'll see this is only a deal
it's only a decline
le mais gemara is the makara to stand up
for an isomet
the usalmi has the same halacha
and the usami also
suggest maybe
maybe it's not every mitzvah you stand
up for
but it's a mitzvah that comes
infrequently like bikum is once a year
maybe that's why you stand up
or other rare mixes will soon see maybe
a hassana
a bris which is not every day for most
for all people but we definitely see
this concept
of standing up permits but what's really
striking
which put things in perspective the
xiaomi then adds
elon the caiman and kaimen misum those
that stand up for amaze by a leviaya
this is mama's
island you stand up for a maze loyam and
kami meesa
we're not standing up for the mace who's
atomic hawking because even if he's not
at
home you stand up for the those that are
being malaba the mace
the kadisha that are bringing the mason
to the levia
they are an isaac mitzvah so the ashami
gives
a striking example of covered
for i say mitzvah it's not the mace
it's the ones that are doing the mitzvah
of the voyasamese
so our shiala is of affairs to your
xiaomi
even if the masonry you stand up for the
ocean
and that's why we'll see there's shining
for example the rav on that mishna
according to most it was a reason the
rav says therefore you stand up for the
people that bring the mason to all of
you and for the father by your breasts
we'll soon see about that
to say them was definitely a reach of
buddha
in tough pay even our morats that
carries the mace
or does a mitzvah we stand up for him
like we learned by bikurim
in
also says it it's a cloud for all
mitzvos
a mitzvah that's at risk like
but every mitzvah that a person does to
stand up for
why it's not the person it's the mitzvah
you know it reminds me
of a gemara in in kadusa bay's
when he heard his mother's footsteps
amma he would stand up and he would say
become he stood up for his mother
but the way he described it is very
moving i'm standing up for the shrine
now i imagine rabbi aces mother did not
learn like our
daughters learned you know she didn't
know she wasn't the buckingham
commission and was showing him
are you the shama but if you have the
the eyes to see in his mother
says you respect your parents like
respect so he saw his mother and he saw
this is the attitude when you see a
mitzvah forget about who does it he
could be in our mouth
but he's doing a mix of durability and
that's why we stand up we see the sticks
that's why it's positive that even
though the mishna says this
and today we don't have bikurim but
basically
this is a mitzvah for diversity and i
just
saw the other day the the maric in the
end of in in a tuba and shirish test
he has a whole scandal over the
arranging story there was a certain
killer that had a minute that shabbos
beratious
they did not give the koi in aliyah they
gave it to the one that
would they would donate money shemalam
are that would light up the shul for the
whole year he gave enough oil
that there would be lighting for the
whole year it was like i'll get covered
to get the aliyah
so if you pay the money you got kayan
and the kayan of course was michael one
year claim was defiant i'm not
gonna be michael i'm gonna come to i
want my aliyah
so they told them basically don't come
we're not gonna give you the leave
and it says there they had the police
stand outside and not let them come into
show
so it was pretty uh you know scandalous
so they wrote to them
and they was all upset
so marik says listen la maisa
showing covered like this to mitzvahs
that you sell
the imagine that you sell the skus to
pay money electricity for the whole year
and show
you know you you're fighting for this
course it's covered in mitzvah
and we find the mishna in bikurim
that they showed geval to get covered
from its more than
that a person that was working stood up
for the for the farmer
so we see that it's even bigger than
krait
and then he adds which is to me was the
punchline he says
in bayam and we show you the times of
the mishnah
but he's talking in his times and then
he says but not like
it's not bad but not like that
yes we have to show cover
so he puts things in perspective it's a
question of covered
mitzvos that is applicable at all times
now la maison this is definitely a here
to stand up for an isa mitzvah based as
we said on a mishna
and we'll soon see as we saw already the
babli the russian me
all record this if you ask what's the
reason for the
simply put it's because of the
mitzvah we also saw sometimes there's a
concern
and if we could add i think the words of
the nephew
allah periglous is very appropriate
he's talking not about our mission he's
talking about
the effect that a mitzvah has he paints
a picture of what a person looks like
when he does a mitzvah and just the
words are uplifting
you will say that
a person becomes enveloped surrounded by
a kedusa that's
awesome and they say that's kadish
he brings a zarya that it's
a person and through this kudusa or
makif
from this or of granadan
a person does a mitzvah we don't see it
we don't have the eyes to see it
but he's surrounded and he's overtaken
with a tremendous kedusa
no such a person you stand up there
and the mark says in conducion the
flamma gimbal obeys
for about my sim a person that doesn't
make a good deeds you have to stand up
for
so i guess the point is we have to stand
up for nice submits
and i saw in a wonderful safety struggle
by my mother he has a
big anonym of standing for all mitzvahs
and empiric members he brings in our
terrorists i don't have the terrorists
but
the darius is in the safe and similar
base
adera says the reason why you stand up
for an isa mitzvah
is because of the kedusha of the noise
he might be an amaranth
but right now he's doing a mitzvah a
clinical mitzvah
therefore he deserves respect i will say
so
i'll also do a mitzvah because the
answer is
be my guest why not a person doesn't
mitzvah
he becomes enveloped with this this
is
to apply this i think hopefully by now
should be simple
first of all as we saw even when
someone's working
and this bit of aloha for someone else
you have to stand up
how about if someone is learning and a
mitzvah walks in so we can make a simple
hajj
when someone is learning and
walks in does he have to stop learning
to respect thomas
because as we saw from the mishnah
gemara babli and you shall me
there's more for a shrine it's one of
the first
on the mission of bikurim he doesn't
during work and even during learning
the question which i would like to try
to clarify is let's say the ice and
mitzvah says
you're standing up for me come on little
old me no i'm michael
can an ice admits it be michael
undiscovered
so if you think like allah should think
well
for standing it's not a new concept
[Music]
so why can't it be that i submitted
but i hope you realize it's not so
positive because let's think for a
moment
this the fear of standing for a son
is it for the i say mitzvah
or maybe it's for the midfield if it's
for the ic mitzvah
so he could be michael it's his carbon
but if it's standing for the mitzvah
it's not his covet and reza pela if you
look at the
the person that does it in fact the
xiaomi concludes you stand up
when they bring in the mace not for the
mace but for the
for the ones that are doing the mitzvah
so it seems that the question of
standing up for a mitzvah is it for the
mitzvot
maybe is bothering you
but his truth is it's not mustafa
because as we said
the really the
you have to stand up for so i think it's
pretty logical to say and i
saw the mach on our gamer in conductions
at the fairish
that even though of
because it's not his mids it's not his
cupboard it's the cover of the mitzvah
now consider the next question that i
think is very enlightening let's say
you're in shul
and someone walks in with his thousand
phil he's going to put on thousands
villain gold daven
you have to stand up for him it doesn't
seem sensible i mean still
every single year that comes to shul but
then again he's going to do two minutes
three mitzes talos chillin and dabbing
someone comes in the shoe with dal and
meena we stand up for him
why not so the end this is according to
me you shout me
it's pretty passion because the ishami
says
when is there a fear to stand up
that was lush you mentioned earlier a
mitzvah that's infrequent you stand up
for him
but let's say it's a daily mitzvah
palace and filling
krishna maybe there's no
which one which would explain why we
don't say that forever he submits
so based on the vishal we have a lima
trust we don't say that for every
other and what's really interesting
in the chuva and with an an
is a totally different child he has a
shylo and oinan that's
la elena and oinami a slice what does he
do about the mitzvot sphere
he won't count sphere a whole day you
lose the mitzvah and i do that as a
philosophy which he doesn't
really accept but he has a suggestion
maybe a mitzvah that's
the shaita a real mitzvah there's no
tour of iron and he says
varia the kim marine conduction says
that
the stand up for when i say mitzvah
do we stand up for everybody that's
going to darwin and say krishna
is going to a mitzvah
which means a infrequent mitzvah then
you stand up like bitcoin
like leviathan will soon see
clatter maybe going but a mitzvah like
of
every day when he's going to say krishna
and we can
of course assume filling in
palace a daily mitzvah there's no here
so we haven't used xiaomi and we have an
idb huda
who's mahatma
plus we could add the baby has a
the dilma
had a suggestion maybe the only three of
his
if you don't do it like by beco he'll
think he's a nobody
and he won't come next year so
that's at risk that if you don't enough
him he's going to feel
so unimportant that he won't come the
only question
is is this
how do you learn a gemara in kadusa we
all learn digimara
the dilma maybe yes or no make it be
mine
if it's a mascara then the above
standing is very limited
if it's just then maybe
we could still say it applies to all
mixes so i looked into this
on the gemara in conducion
it's true only a mitzvah
at risk that means um that
when is there a fear to stand up even
though this bitter malacha
amidst that risk but let's say it's
there's no vitamin
then even a mitzvah is not at risk every
mitz across the board you have to stand
up
so here we see that the mice it's true
every mitzvah that a person does
you have to stand up tala sends filling
what about thousands villain
so we'll say the first chat that we said
only an infrequent myth
now every sugiya is only only
complete if you have a kashmaka rambam
well this suggests
the rambam and piracy mishnais and that
muslim
seems to change the whole the whole
direction of the mishnah
the rambam says the ballet um
have to stand up for the maybe a bikurim
you have to stand up for the maybe
bikurim because it was done
with great fanfare with a lot of
attention
and now it's a question of kroy that
sibo and koi that see
bashani the rambam seems to say the only
three of standing for an isa mitzvah is
if there's a cebu that's doing it
and then on that conduction elaborates
since that's the more it says
they came with khalil they were playing
music it was such a fanfare there was
such a roi bomb
that's why you have to stand up but
otherwise if it's a yahood
mitzvah on explaining the rambam
there's no here to stand up now
according to this
rambam i understand a person walks into
shul
thousand children krishna dalai meaning
the works there's no here to stand up
but the emma says it's very hard to
accept and i saw the mystery china
quotes to rambam and says but how could
this be
the commishner the gemara explains
nothing to do with roy vaugham the marit
quotes to rambam and says but the gemara
is washing his body
the xiaomi also says
who said it was done the rav
that we mentioned the tas that we
mentioned i saw him kanyevskiy
on the rambam says
all seem to say it's even if there's not
see but there's a clear to stand
now the mice of the rambam has a very
nice
but at the end of the day we could say
the following it seems
to stand when a person goes to do a
mitzvah
no does it sad to say maybe only an
infrequent mitzvah
maybe only love maybe all the rambam
that when there's a rabbit but as we'll
see and i will apply it
it seems as a here to stand for some of
the mitzvah
within reason as we're going to explain
to apply this a little more to myself
let's
go in order of the
first and foremost i must tell you which
reason again
many times a day that aki maisha
involved
when you hear double ship kadusha being
said you have to stand up
how do i know apostate can shift in
paragumo
and he stood up so when you hear a davos
of the douche which means
kaddish borojo aliyas will soon see the
bear
more the ashkenazim usually show covered
by standing
why mamish our sugya our plastic and
shift
i'll give you another application which
to me is
because we once learned to this at the
time i had not seen this
but it was very enlightening we learned
just about i think it was two years ago
we learned to suggest which is a whole
cinnamon in our
base you know to sit within dalaramis of
some of this
my nester so the question that we
struggle then is why not
and also it is a you know how to sit
next to someone dabbing
so when someone's saying krishna yazaka
shouldn't be able to sit
don't forget krishna is it the raiser
into my nest or maybe it's not at their
iso
so why nestor not and krishna yes
so we spoke about it then it's quite the
of the shrine
so i saw this recently that's
the son of the mahne in semen
since the person that's saying is doing
a mitzvah
you have to stand up for the i say
mitzvah so if he's dabbing you have to
stand up
then he says i understand why krishna
because if the person is doing them it's
that he's sitting
so you don't have to stand up you have
to be more than him so krishna that he's
sitting you could stay seated
but when it comes to shrine sir that
he's standing you have to stand also
then he says therefore i can understand
another the love is let's say i'm
learning
and someone come and start establishment
next to me i was there first i could
stay seated if i'm on the side i could
stay seated
why is that my nest the turret says
the whole thing is standing is pretty
standing mitzvah
no when a person is learning there's no
here to stand
continue learning and not stand up for
the person that's gathering
now this was the kiddos to me because we
saw the mystery
shyness as the favorish that you have to
stand
for foreign maybe he means to say that
you know you have to stand the whole
time
but it's interesting how in its
but we we haven't seen anything yet
listen to this
in fact mr burns you've gotten out of
quotes much
earlier sources if elena the cayenne
cannot stand he's a wheelchair bound
can't stand he can't standing is
very integral to the mitzvoth
the question is fine they kind of have
to stand how about
us levine and israel that are receiving
the bracha
we have to stand so i'll piss you it's
it seems to be massive you don't have to
stand you could sit and you could have
carvana
be i guess they're pun intended but
you know you should more than just
sitting physically but you mean you
should be sitting
but the meaning as we know that the they
must borrow
him stand so
who writes to follow him and he says
since the queen is doing an awesome
mitzvah
how inappropriate he's doing in mid-son
you're sitting
if his mits are standing you have to
stand i'll our mission and be cool
everything ends up the mission to be
cool but what to me was amazing
his son wrote her goys on the bottom of
his father's safer
and he says but i don't understand my
father because when do you stand
amitsv
it is a big excitement that big rival
then you stand
but what's the excitement oh
so you're wondering what do you mean
the answer is of course but this tape
was written in there at this row
they took it every single day so there's
no pumps
so therefore for us at least we can
understand the reason
the stand
also his assumption of pumbias and robin
is based on the rambam sheet as i told
you earlier the ram says only rebound
and we don't go that round so this is
another good reason to stand up
when israel lives are receiving the
broker
our mission i'll give you another
example
many people have a minute to stand by
laney now i say that
with great respect because many people
russia people sit by lane
there is alsa they don't negotiate so
those that sat are certainly in good
company but for those that stand
what's the reason so the mordechai one
of the residents
shabbos is recorded as saying
the that the ram ruttenberg
why so it doesn't say exactly why we
know one of the reasons because
it's reenacting kabbalah satire but if
you look in the shielding
boy on the bottom of the murder also
he's also a reason
he says i know why the motherhood stood
by laning because he shall because he
shall me says in bikurim our mission
when someone's doing the mids we have to
stand up when someone's leaning for a
sibling
what a perfect time to show covet for
mitzvahs so
the reason to stand by laning is our
mission be cool
everything ends up a mistake oh maybe
taka we could understand
why many people sit i the mission be
korean
but since it's a frequent mitzvah maybe
there's no
what to me is a mitzvah the farsin the
ramami panel and the tube and sim and
sadika
i said i found others who say the same
thing but their mommy panda mama spells
this out
and he wants to say that really
maybe there's no to stand by laning
in other words laning is not itself but
you know why people stand
because he says that even if you're
making to sit by laning
but you must stand by the aliyah the
baruch
because of the ali is the do devastation
so if a person is going to be sitting by
laning he'll end up sitting by baruch
and that's uh unacceptable so therefore
people stand the whole landing and show
them all you throw as i stated
my family others say the same thing so
today we have made even
you see many people that they stand
fellaini
then gabriel they sit down but the mice
when the aliyah starts the the next
aliyah they know they are busy
schmoozing you know isaac bavers put
them in a mitzvah
so they can't stop talking and they end
up sitting by baruch and jumping up
fellaini
according to their mommy panorama better
sit by
laning but stand by the ball
a beautiful concept of this michelin
bikum how we see it's all over
the marsh dam it was one of the
kadamayanam are the earliest
fathers he says a story also a scandal
someone
spoke very critically of a chevra
kedosha of gombe he doesn't say what the
tamil was and
but he says people there are people that
were very critical of a certain cover of
going and he says they are very is
unbelievable the ionis is unbelievable
and he says did you forget a mishna be
cool
that when someone goes to do a mitzvah
you stand up for him that's more than
covered you showed
but then he says listen to this he says
even though
these guys saw them are not doing a
mitzvah right now
so maybe right now you could be them now
maybe they do it
he says no if someone has dedicated his
life
he's ready on call 24
7.
a person that's on call 24 7.
that's
when he's not actively doing a mitzvah
and that he says this is pashit
someone
amazing you know somebody that's ready
to do a mitzvah
deserves coverage even if he's not
actually doing a mitzvah
i was thinking you know how appropriate
this is
24 7
365 days a year now i think if you stand
up for the tell them when he walks into
the room he'll probably call the police
i'll probably call that the something
you know it's like very strange
and i'm not saying daft or not stand up
but the attitude it's so
precious
you know there's a tremendous lust in
the mice so we can learn what it means a
mitzvah
and unfortunately you know people have a
certain tendency when someone is a
clown person they're quick to criticize
him you know whether it's at solo or
that
the other organizations the absolute
farther he robbed him
but there's always there's a certain
geshmach quote unquote
to find fault in those that are doing
good you know because you know they're
in the
limelight they know but i give this
attitude is
someone does the mitzvah 24 7 ready
on the call of duty is this mishnah as a
missionary
the amsterdam and xuber's perry bay's
mish uh
simon hey he speaks about showing cover
to an
isha asia the whole ghost of the holy
suggest
he says
another example the yada leo one of the
earlier charleston chubby simon dalit he
writes the following
the one that's collecting money gabe
tadaka you have to stand up in front of
him
why and he calls the marine chambers
in other words when someone is
collecting money and he comes in to your
house and comes to the show is it clear
to stand outfit
a perfect muscle of our exam of our
your xiaomi factory bull just told me
coming here that he has
industry showed this by the dinner of
irregular
do you have to stand up for for for a
gobby
now some people stand up for gabriel and
they run the other way
that's not what that's not what the yada
yada meant
but definitely you know there's a
there's a there's a sword to this you
know especially
sometimes uh don't get the most covered
there's a there
you know so definitely this is the point
now what's interesting is what i saw and
it's me it just it shows up
the pictures we once spoke about
and this is tape 738 a long time ago we
spoke about
when which parts of the dabbling you
have to stand so
as you assure many people
that we say in davening some stand
and something there's no whatever the
reason is when i can get into now
but it seems that it's not such a fear
of like the rest of davorin that we
definitely stand like miserable
to stand sir bianca says he has a
different question why we stand by
because the bianca writes and this is
that it was it was um he said he writes
there but
the belt was macbeth to stand up for
someone that was
either collecting sadaka or giving to
dhaka because this missionary
since the ice cream the bhagavad-gita
quote the minute
that by ibrahimovic you get up to give
sadaka
so in every shul there was someone going
to give to dhaka so they stood up not
for that
per se they stood up for the sadako
ah no so then it became like you know oh
we're standing up i have a variety of it
but it's not true
the real kid the stand is for the gabba
tsudak now bank of stress is the people
that are giving to dhaka
i wonder why he didn't say the the gaba
goes on to push him maybe he meant to
sailor abuse him even if there's no
goblin
but if you your neighbor and shul gets
up to go to the pushka
stand up for him but thinking how that
became part of claudius rose daily
activity
we stand up by david for the god for the
collecting of the saddam
diana yo himself claire's ashaila do you
stand up for a god by that gets paid for
it
now that it gets paid for it it's not
such a mitzvah but i saw the peerish on
the safe
sedan that i mentioned earlier and also
the min
sim and pay verb both don't understand
the sufficient
true a mitzvah a monastery
is a greatest car but it's still a
mitzvah master cable process what's
wrong
so la maisa i think we could say that
there is a sad to say
to stand up for agape tsudaka but i did
see
i guess the defend those that don't
stand up abstinent
he says maybe the hector is that today
there are so many
tadaka so many collectors it's now a
frequent mitzvah
and we rely on that sad that only a
mitzvah keeps him
but certainly i could tell you if a
someone comes into the house collecting
and if you stand up and you give him a
tremendous physique that he desperately
needs he's
broken as it is and it could be very
much our mishna
in bikum as well now one thing i should
mention
is a different that people confuse the
aria kardashian this is quoted by the
magana
mr to stand up for a
stand up when you give to dhaka i'll
pick
when he gives a duck he's supposed to
stand so there are two deanna
when i give sadaka home alone i put
money in the pushka i stand up
i must have got for myself i'm standing
up for the mitzvah
but when someone else gives sadaka then
we have al mishna bikurim to stand up
for ayse mitz
i was just boxing by a brisk friday and
i i was able to put this
up the rav and our mishna and
in the gillian on on the page in your
idea
if kotnal quotes this that when the
brings the baby into the bris
everybody has to stand up this is mamish
our mishna
they're bringing the baby to a mitzvah
you're not standing up for the baby
he's standing up for the clatter now if
the father is an alta zeda and he's
above 60 or 70
families he had to stand up for his
opinion but even if he's under that age
is the mitzvah to stand up for all
sea bass to stand by the entire bris
entire proceedings chanema pasik in the
navy
by yamato ombre bris people stood by the
brisk
nope so it's a ferrous drama that
not just when the clock comes in but to
remain standing for the entire bris
and unfortunately people don't know this
but it's in the ferris suramar
now it sounds like a ferris state posse
but
you look up the past it has nothing to
do with brismila bris means a treaty
so the goyin kedarkay writes it's
and he throws in with sinha big mara
now the going when you learn when you
learn to go it's always a treat he says
a few words but there's so much meaning
to
it the guy in here is saying a second
macarthur to stand by the bris which
really the mordechai that i mentioned
earlier
says the fairish the mordechai points
out in shabbos kuflam with zion in the
days imara says
the participants those that are standing
by the prison
obviously you're supposed to stand by
empress so the mice
it seems that the this is the the murder
is tough
the attack of the minute is to stand by
your breasts maybe it's not
but definitely that's the meaning but i
was
saying to a pigeon i've been whistling
and it was interesting you don't see a
pigeon in bed too often but
the island was standing that's where it
should be and only one person was
sitting the cayenne
and it was strange to me you know
manishtana
so the truth is that why does it cebu
stand by the
by the pidgin of ben says the maritz and
the emery embassy and
i saw this in that safety show my mother
both say it's a michelin biker
the bet libya ben is going through a
mitzvah you stand up
and it's not a mitzvah it's a mitzvah
that's very rare
very rare because not every mostly khan
among the vegans children there's no
pigeon at ben and if it's a
you know it's a diaphragm on a cave so
the having of a
a pity in a pen is extremely rare that
justifies standing
so that's where the whole seabester
stand fine why does the cayenne
sit so taka there are some that the khan
used to stand
but the minute to sit that korean sit is
based on the
marie bruna and the chubbus kufra bays
that everybody stands but the koyen
sits proudly
now he says just that's all he says if
you look inside
the client has to show his importance
this is not this kahuna this is him
redeeming a child
this is his so it's a it's a display of
quite a kuna
he has to remain seating even though
everybody else is standing
we mentioned earlier when they bring the
mace to levaya
the you shall me says to stan
xiaomi and that's
received and the task says you stand up
not for the mace but for the ones that
are doing the mitzvah of the
assemblies what's to me was marvel
says that have a costume because
it says the famous story when they
brought the orange
fur in the uber
although they were already deceased
communicated it's not right that we
should be
sitting lighting whatever when they when
your hoon is standing so they also stood
up
so the ties with the sensitivity to
every vertebra so we see
that you stand up not just for the void
of the noise meetup
you stand up for the mace because they
said let's stand up for raphuna
so the sarcasm says i don't understand
this i mean this is out of our range
but we have mason standing up for mason
that i could understand
but who said that for a mace so whether
you stand up
extra for khashoggi according to the
tasman abs
according to the food is the question if
not but the taz does
say emphatically from this we learn
you have to stand up when someone's
going to do a mitzvah not for the mace
we stand up by a
lavalier when they wheel in the maze
even if it was a simple yid for the
noise
another question i would love to hear
some clarity about when you see my
nikoma velen
this is really based on this
ideally based on the pastic and eoi
beige you gimmel the menachem are
supposed to be sitting on the ground
because they stayed in the past second
year and that's what the shogunate says
but barak hashem the available see a lot
of said on a cheer
but nikama veil is supposed to be done
sitting
and the husband is passionate if you
come into someone and you're standing
that means you have one foot out the
door you're coming you're going you hit
and run
sitting shows a hashtag of tsar it's a
real noise about when you sit down
but there's no doubt about you look in
the shack and taz on that mahabharat in
shin paisayan
that ideally near mabel should be done
sitting and it always was strange to me
why do we see that people deliberately
stand up
and then say unlucky why did afghanistan
didn't amid them i mean when you say
this you have to stand when you say
we have to stand
but you say this when you're about to
leave
so it was a different prayer they may
preacher
say it when you're leaving so then
you're allowed to stand
so not that in the stand you're allowed
to say it when you're standing
no so okay in other words there's no
here to stand
it's a head to the stand but maybe talk
it would make more sense just
to remain seated so i'm not going to
change mini golem but if someone knows a
little more than this i would love to
hear this
talking about these type of menyana one
point that we see that
yoshi that i mean is the gemara may
caught in the half of the base and the
mahabharata quotes this
kriyas rising kriya on the maze is
absolutely ma'achiv has to be done
standing is based on apostate
and someone writes kriya be yeshiva by
sitting he's not yo it's up even with
the other because the passage says that
moving on to ebenezer
there is a knesset dollar in the vanessa
simmons
base the bergev and simmons base quotes
it so it's on the page
and an earlier source of tekunis that a
person
that was that the islam was supposed to
be standing by the entire khopa
the zaya seems to say that said affairs
there islamic club in allah
but for us and taka
it's beautiful i found this but fairies
we can understand why you have to
stand by the choppa because
because a missionary court they're doing
a mitzvah
a rare mitzvah hopefully you can marry
just once in a lifetime
so that's what you have to stand so many
are macbeth
rights that was diminishing shallayim to
stand by hope
now a lot has been written to try to
understand why today in america they set
up chairs and people sit
so i saw the sherman son of a lock and
kuffman
he says maybe since the coppa is held on
a platform
which is a different resource than the
seaboard so there's no here to stand
but many people who know these would
daft
but to stand by the hope but what to me
was intriguing
what we see today that many people sit
and when the houston kala march down to
the football you'll see many people
very proudly stand up and come covered
with a hustle cow
but many people amongst them could early
israel remain seated not they don't
realize they don't
they defiantly remain seated so when i
began this figure this is one of my
focuses i have to figure out what's the
map so passion you think about it
objectively
this is a perfect example of our
missionary court the host is going to a
mitzvah
mitzvah a rear mitsura standoff
this is a mitzvah kitchen attack i found
the favorites based on this
nest sega dollar kaminsky and many
others said
daftka to stand when the hassan and
khalid go to the hoop
they're going to a mitzvah they're
bringing because they end up they're
going to amid
but they're moisture and this i know
this person they are moisture set by
explained because it's the in america
it's the meaning of reform
and i would say here comes the bride and
it's it's more of a a gayisha minigo or
a foreign
when it's a religious custom this is
just a you know a minute
but what to me was interesting is i was
thinking because it's a
four minute so you changed the meaning
of claudius from
but i thought about it i'm not no one's
changing a minute you have to realize
probably up till 50 years ago people
stood the entire cup
why me boy but that was outside so it's
time you stood
but even in the minute was like we said
earlier
based on azaya based on all the price
came to standby
so it wasn't the question of standing up
for the hustle cow he was standing
anyhow
this this this was safe this
thing so tell me yes why don't we stand
up for the hustling
so crying did not understand this
question he says
he's standing up and hustling like who's
sitting so if you're not sitting you
don't say that
but take it comes out that today and
tough
it's it's it's it's so maybe the ants
like we said
is is is because it's a miniga of the
reform so this one
savage told me which is interesting that
both were abducted and verb reuben told
him that they
did like their father's meaning but over
the years they had gotten so many
comments people looked at him
like mama's like they don't know
basically how do you not stand up
they started to stand up also you know
because everybody else does it
but maybe there's there's got to be more
to this i would love to hear from
someone knows that you know a little
more about this
but their bell ski talking is chuva and
italki said this first here and
arrogance
he said attackers it makes sense to
stand up outside
he says don't tell me that colors are
they're not doing a mitzvah when they're
going down to the hoop
because basically even though later on
the famous round on the dome she's only
passive
but they're still going to an oyster
mitzvah and therefore it makes sense to
stand those that don't probably have a
treasure
just quickly the last group of questions
i hope are very passionate
standing or sitting by verhasa we say
that mitzvah
so the we would say why not stand i
stand when i make the bracha on svera
and i make the bracha race on
on the other mitzvah's lula
but the atmosphere now we really is not
so passionate a mitzvah that's done
sitting the brach is also sitting we saw
that from earlier
and taka i saw a list of israel
why does it why not stand so this is a
pillar
twice this in broadcast says when a
person benches
kidafka should sit how do we know it's a
pasta in the tire this is a very weird
isis we would think of some type of a
drizzle
is a conjunction of chev ace now is the
time to sit
twice it says to sit by bench because of
the rise
and you look in the boys can say
and this is the kofbe gimbal test the
mahabharata says why do you sit by
benching
there's more when you're sitting so i
was thinking based on this crisis i
understand why the africa to sit by
beijing
since there's no here to stand and it's
at the right
it's like benching now in the olden days
when the end of sight to the mishnah
when mishnah says they used to stand by
learning
maybe have to stand above satire but
today we sit by learning
viagra can be said sitting i did see
some good early israel daftka stood up
no i'll pick ebola fine but if there's
more kavanagh sitting it's good eye to
sit
a regular beer a shackle and a cup of
coffee
in other words you're allowed to say
it's sitting or standing there's no
either way i once had to shy that
someone wanted to be
shall keep it off to his grandfather so
by regular shabbat suit he brought it
until he died him to the table
take the shizzle on the cup so zade
would have to get up and wash
so zade the wash sitting down afterwards
he felt terrible what did i do
he was marshall isaidah he did a mitzvah
when he was sitting
so you want to know is there a problem
with make until you're dying when you're
sitting
if this time is appraisal to the mitzvah
of eating
and eating we do sitting so why can't
you make this a diet and when you sit
talk up say the pasteur by night many
people bring the roisa biased here's the
dying
to the tape now i did hear some some
said deacon by a fish that could stand
up and they watch others
sit but it seems clear there's no ending
to stand by a mitzvah that's done as an
and last but not least an interesting
question someone just asked me this the
other day
when they say simon of ali kenu
or not so this is not brought in
people think it's straight from sinai
but i saw the buchacha in kuftsa the
base brings from israel
why doesn't everybody else do it why do
people not makbid so i was thinking it's
passion
because if the mitzvah is done by
yeshiva
since benching is done by yeshiva and
zeman's part of it
but those that do it's the cover that
evelyn showed i couldn't talk
to you
today is the first day of show with him
hundreds of thousands of eden
participating assure me are they heading
based all over the world
if you don't have a shear in your shoe
please call ign shaytar
and we'll arrange you a share please
take our
card to learn your day inside besides
going to shirum
we need your help rabbi say there's
hundreds of thousands even participating
over 600 places
around the world it's a tremendous
covered shamayim
and kiddish hashem everybody wants to be
part of it
please be sponsor one of these places of
tarasam
it's such a secret album people all
different languages are coming
it's the biggest huss to bring yiddish
india closer to levester
please write out your checks we'll give
you credit cards now to ignore it the
sponsor series of tarantula
has a thousand dollars one shares
dollars
or give whatever you can subscribe
to a man
is
[Music]
in two minutes also the lakewood sure
made our peel we have lake with yeshiva
of cow and stone please everybody help
out that too
write one check out for shiva karma
stone lakewood and one check for
ignition
yes
[Music]
the body
[Music]
is
these two things
[Music]
way
[Music]
i always
is
[Laughter]
is
[Music]
oh
one thing we definitely saw and saw over
and over
we have to show covered stand for the
urbanislams tire for the manuscripts
got an incredible scar for showing
standing up for the queen hashem
even abu khatneza got an incredible
reward
for taking a step for koichi and it's
certainly an inspiration for us
the cover that we show for amidst this
should always be
primary in our attitude but in
seeing that there is a stand up for
mitzvah
beginning with the mishna where the
mishnah says the tremendous
parade with music and with coverage with
with
kehan and levine coming out the show
covered for the
those that brought bikurim but primarily
the bali um workers that worked for
others
and involved bitter malacha which is
something that is an absolute no-no in
yiddish kite
but for here this was an exceptional
case where they stood up
and they stopped doing malach of course
for a few seconds but bali malachi
stopped
even though you don't stop doing you
don't stand up for a time with kraken
and i should have mentioned the pile
bench is a much shorter benching
when it comes to doing coverage showing
cover to an oyster mitzvah
the mission says to stop working and
show covet
the bavaria in kadusan llama gimmel
and khul and nundala do you shall be in
bakurim all
certainly reinforce this mishna the
xiaomi shows that he is
the one that carries the mace the save
the rav say applies to all mitzvahs even
bismarck
as we
more of a covet and perhaps the person
is elevated when he doesn't admit so he
becomes about myself
but definitely to stand up in the middle
of work even in the middle of learning
as we said
because kashiva mitzvah is very
important
pasta is the i say mitzvah cannot be
michael because the cupboard is not for
the icy mitzvah
the covet is for the mitzvah we did see
a few reasons why we don't stand up for
someone that's
going to put on talis and svilin or
dallad minim was saying krishna
but that's certainly not done but what
should be done is what we find in the
poiskon
a when someone says
one should stand according to the
meaning of ashkenazim
even if you sit by laning but to stand
by by the borough
of the aliyah is important we don't sit
next to someone's dabbling finest
according to some because of this
mission and bikuram he's doing a mitzvah
the kaiyan stands for dukhning and the
israelis stand
out covered for the kindness during a
mitzvah
we said as we stand for an isaac
again whether we stand or not for these
giveaways
this 24 7 but the attitude has to be
covered for i say mitzvah we do stand
when the gabriel tadaka walks around
collecting i'm gonna
when a collector comes in to shoot him
we stand when the baby is brought to the
mila the krantara comes in with the baby
we stand not for the baby but for the i
say mitzvah
and of course the entire mila there are
more records the medic to be standing
by levaya the main thieve is not the
stand necessarily for the
mace who was the talmud but for the
noisy amaze
shiva and when we're leaving as a sort
of a
saying goodbye we stand up and we say
even though there is no here to do that
someone pointed out which is probably
true
since there are sometimes there are many
men and you can't yell out from where
you're sitting so you stand up and you
go close
to the mace and then we say makaminakum
so maybe it became
practical to stand up and go next to the
mace and say i'm
going to gig i'm sorry next to the man
the next to the available i'm sorry
and saying kriya is my active
standing is based on aposic it seems
one should stand by the khupa and we
hope we could sanction the meaning of
those that sit by the
but again it seems that there's a strong
reason to stand when hassan and kala go
down to the cuppa
and again hopefully we could sanction
the meaning of those that don't stand
behind can be said either sitting or
standing
like benching maybe it is more kavanaugh
to say sitting
in you could say sitting or standing the
tilt i am both the mitzvah and the brah
can be said
can be done by shiva or media and the
semen of allah keno as we said even
though it seems to be a double shepherd
kadusa
and that's why people stand by allah
keno but it seems that
since this part of benching that's done
the yeshiva and also it's a mitsubira