Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Why I Disagree With Jordan Peterson...

3,643 views
SoulWords—Rabbi Shais Taub avatar
SoulWords—Rabbi Shais Taub

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

tell us about your rule on parenting and your thoughts on how children are raised how they are raised and perhaps how they should be raised don't let your children do anything that makes you dislike them right right right well that's it's a it's a funny rule in in a kind of harsh way again the first part of it that's harsh is the Frank admission that children can do things that make them dislikable right right and that's something everyone knows but no one wants to say and the second part is that you as a parent despite loving your children might also not like them let me tell you my reaction to that first of all it is factually correct this what that's Jordan Peterson by the way he's famous guy um he says that there are two things basically implicit in oh those are his rules for living he has a bunch of rules for living and I looked at I actually had never seen the list of the rules for living before but somebody this same person who sent me this sent me the list of rules for living one of the rules for living is parenting related and this is is the parenting related rule for living um so forget about the rule for a second you know the difference between a descriptive statement and a prescriptive statement a descript a descriptive statement is the just a description of this is what it is it's not a judgment I'm not saying it's good or bad I'm not saying it's right or wrong I'm just telling you the fact prescriptive means like a prescription like a doctor says take two of these and call me in the morning meaning this is what you should do so set aside whether this is good advice or not let me just zero in on the descriptive aspect of it so he says that it's implicit in his rule this sort of I don't know I don't remember if he uses the word shocking but uh the shocking implication that children can do things that make them unlikable and that like he says this as a second thing that a parent could actually love a child but dislike them so I want to agree with that as a descriptive statement it is true that children or anybody can do things that make them unlikable that's that's true second of all it is true that a parent yes even a parent could love a child and dislike a child at the same time totally true I'm I'm agreeing that that is true now there's where my agreement ends because if you get into the prescriptive part of it meaning what you should do meaning what is guidance or advice or Direction um I would go in a totally different a totally different approach and I would say like this yes it's true that people including children can do things that make us dislike them yes it's true that a parent could even love a child and at the same time dislike their own child yes it's true and because precisely because then that's true my advice to parents is you got to be on top of that don't let yourself succumb to disliking your child because of their behavior in other words it is only human nature to dislike People based on their behavior I know that I'm saying as a parent you got to dig deep and you have to transcend that you have to transcend that and why why am I saying you have to dig deep and transcend that because Jordan Peterson is saying don't let your children do anything that would make you dislike them as if he's saying it as if making sure that your children do things or don't do things that are dislikable that is the path to successful parenting and I would say it's exactly the opposite it's exactly the opposite successful parenting is not the result of not letting your kids do things that you would that would make you dislike them but rather being immune to dis liking your child is the path to successful parenting hey this is rabish shab you were just watching a clip from my six- week online parenting course which I offer about once or twice a year we're opening up enrollment right now for another cohort of that course if you want to get in on it there's information how to register in the description of this video below hope to see you there