Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Chanukah: The Story Written in Flame
489 views
R' Tzadok on the reason why the real miracle of Chanukah could never be written in a book. Watch more Torah classes with Rabbi Shais Taub at https://www.soulwords.org/ Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/rabbi_shais_taub/ Support our work at: https://www.soulwords.org/donate/ --OR-- PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/soulwordspayments CashApp: https://cash.app/$soulwords Venmo: https://venmo.com/u/soulwords
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
i'm going to i'm going to start over
though because i'll probably cut this
out you know
okay it's thursday night challenge we
don't have childhood we have latkes ends
for uh chanukah we're learning a special
chanukah edition of the thursday night
tone
music
lila from sadhaka khan
from lublin he was a
rebel coin rabinowitz who was the uh
he was a talmud of the ishbitser the
maya
who in turn was the talmud of the
kotzker you mentioned that we did a lot
of cuts recently thinking also of the
guerrero the fassemest was kotsk
and did we do anything else that was uh
derivatives
i think that was probably
what we did
and uh okay so uh the sodic was uh was a
was a litvak
and he became a host he not only became
a hustler became a rabbit
actually i think most of his life he
would not take it a bonus he had a used
clothing store
for whatever that's worth interesting uh
information he was a very very prolific
writer one of his father is a lila we're
going to learn from tonight it's
interesting by the way
oliver shalom
was speaking about
working on the circus and the lobby
and one of the examples he gave his
memory he said that once there was a
sikh
that uh
the
edited version of the circuit that ever
wrote in a quote from uh tadik from uh
ccli actually it's nitrous ccli that's
the there's a like a soft on the back
of this lila that is published with it
and uh but anyways over there i've saw
this talking about the the opinion of a
birthday of a yamalatis
and uh so the rabbit wrote in the edited
version of the circle here's the quote
and the rabbit told you
i'm not sure this is exactly the quote
so just look it up and make sure this is
it's correct and i'd be all set you
looked it up it was like word for word
and you're saying that that shows you
the kiss of the rabbit because
it's fairly new stuff it's not like
somebody's quoting shaas or uh madras
valparais you know the classics
this is uh
you know riptodic passed away in 1900 i
think he was born in 1823 and passed
away uh 1900
so oh and in case
those uh people out there who like
seductrivia the circa that ebbiel was
talking about is khalik hey of la cotes
and this
is entitled hofmar
it's about starts with the story about
the rabbit hashab a little bit of shab's
birthday was khof
it's a story about when he was a little
boy he came home from cader and he was
crying about uh
wanting hashem to reveal himself to him
like like hashem revealed himself to
avraham anyways so that's
delilah
and we're gonna learn from
we're not gonna cover it all but we're
gonna learn from
uh
where's page one
why am i missing 165 did i
take this packet okay
what did i do with my paper oh here it
is i found my missing paper this is
another packet okay
all right so page 165 starts um
paddock
nun we're not going to learn the whole
paddock but it's very interesting stuff
maybe we'll learn
maybe maybe we'll jump around let's
let's see
okay so uh
indian mitzvos ner
hanukkah
where
we're gonna later on when we upload this
to soul words i know people are watching
this on youtube people watching this on
torah anytime if you want to get the the
full features if you want the pdf you go
to soulwords.org
and uh there should be a study guide
underneath the video player it should be
like a little clickable thing where it
says download the study guide you'll get
a pdf of exactly
this
page
that we are
reading from here
what's the concept what's the idea of
lighting them
to commemorate
the miracle of hanukkah
sadik asks a question it's it's it's a
strange thing that that became
the way that we commemorate
hanukkah uber amis
the main miracle actually had nothing to
do with oil that was after the fact
discovering the
oil but really it was that we were
rescued from
the hellenistic
attempt to assimilate
the jewish people
the miracle with the oil happened
afterward and it's really its own story
it's sort of almost an epilogue to the
main story
yeshua's
and
it really has no connection
to the main story yeah
it's only two words so he said that's
exactly what he's about to say because
in the al-anism it doesn't even mention
the nace it mentions that they they that
they lit the minoda right
it's all about the muhammad it's about
the defeating the odds and about the the
the small over the the great exactly
exactly what he says
it doesn't mention the miracle that
mentions that they lit the menorah it
doesn't mention a miracle of
one day's worth of oil that lit for
eight days it doesn't say
what does it mention that after they
were victorious with the battle and
that's what it speaks about at length
they were victorious militarily after
that
badly noticed that afterwards they lit
the candles it doesn't even say that
there was a miracle involved in that
okay
so it's funny that we end up with
the mitzvah of hanukkah that
the story really isn't mainly about that
and yet
that's what we get what do we get from
it
for all these centuries and millennia we
get the
the mitzvah of lighting the the minotaur
so we want to understand why
the mitzvah that we do seems to be
so tangential
to the to the main story of hanukkah
okay so now he explains a little bit
that you need to have something you need
to have some type of act
i will call yeshua
nick
ladaines any
salvation of the jews that becomes
commemorated for
all generations
he explains that that that
what
when we commemorate the salvation of the
jews what are we commemorating we're
commemorating
that there was some type of spiritual
deficiency
that was the source of the problems the
problems were a manifestation of an
inner
deficiency within the jews and that that
got cleared up
but there was an inner deficiency
that
what caused the
in this case uh
evil decrees but the oppression the
what caused the
threat to jewish safety was an outer
manifestation of inner spiritual stuff
that we needed to fix
the haqqael bamishpat all of this stuff
is sort of
cause and effect
that there's inner stuff that we have to
do and therefore
there becomes an outer
representation of that and then we fix
the inner stuff
sometimes we call it the ketrig lamaile
we fix whatever is going on in the
heavenly court and then everything down
here and the terrestrial plane clears up
as well
so when the jews clear up the issue
that's going on in their hearts the
internal issue
oz
they get saved from the
from the problem from the
from the threat
okay so we're understanding a little bit
better
or we're on our way to understanding a
little bit better what exactly happened
okay we understand that there was a
military victory but why did there need
to be a military victory there needed to
be a military victory because we were
under threat and why we were under
threat not because the greeks one day
decided to to oppress us but because
there was something internally that jews
needed to work on
and we successfully worked on it and
since we successfully worked on it in a
sort of permanent way what he's saying
here is that when
sometimes there's a microcosmic victory
sometimes there's a macrocosmic victory
sometimes there's an individual
sometimes there's a the whole claustro
has a breakthrough and that breakthrough
has
permanent effects for the good and when
we commemorate something eternally for
all generations what do we commend why
do we still commemorate it because we
are reaping the eternal benefits of
that
breakthrough that they had at that time
that that's what he said okay
why is why is this connected to lighting
a moneta we still don't know we don't
know that yet okay
israel
when the
source within the jews is
fixed
in such a way that from now on for all
time forward the jews are going to be
relieved of that issue that issue was
cleared up in that time and now barak
we fixed it then
oh so then what do you do when you have
a permanent victory when there was an
issue that was plaguing us and then we
got it behind us we cleared it up and we
moved on so then oz nikoba yeshua zu
zekel of deities that salvation becomes
established as a as an eternal
uh celebration something that you
commemorate forever why are we
commemorating it forever
because it's not just that something
cool really happened one time it's that
something cool happened which
is benefiting us
has been benefiting us
all along since then and continues to
benefit us now
okay
what is it we don't know yet but
we're getting closer
okay uh vacaville is there we're going
to flip the page the cavo
now
when you want to
reap the benefits when you want to sort
of tap into and
be aligned with
the
breakthrough that happened and that
we're benefiting from
so what you do is you need some type of
a physical action something tangible
that you can do
can't just be passive it can't just be
well this is a special time it is a
special time and there's a special
energy in the world the energy of of of
the the breakthrough that happened in
the times of hanukkah that's available
every year at this time but we need to
harness it so how do we harness it you
have to have some type of an action that
you can do he calls here isa de la sato
an arousal from below there's an arousal
from above happening anyway but we need
some type of arousal from from below we
need some type of an action to harness
it
okay
the cold dover
any
any holiness
will not enter unilaterally
on its own into the heart
it'll sort of be out there it'll be in
the ether but to enter the heart
to move the individual there has to be
some
action
from the person himself
or like we say
if you open up
like the eye of a needle and often the
famous uh rest of the vote which
absolutely doesn't bring if you open for
me hashem says like the i have a new
i'll open up for you like
the uh the corridor of the hall of the
basement
at any rate the point is that there has
to be some type of action on our part
yeah
uh
what does it say milo mata
vacavo mitzvah
so the sages set up a mitzvah that would
be appropriate
for opening ourselves up to have that
particular holiness enter our hearts
okay so we still don't understand why
the miner was specifically chosen
but we do understand that there needs to
be some act
that is a good
tool or technology for harnessing
the particular spiritual energy which is
available at any given time and for
whatever reason
lighting the mineira is the right
technology for harnessing
the energy that is unique to chanukah
now what is the energy that's unique to
hanukkah we didn't say yet but we did
say it was something that once it was
achieved it was a permanent
accomplishment and that we reap the
benefits from it
until today
okay
let's continue here
if you do um
the arizona says
what did matasyau do the head of the the
maccabees
he fixed
hoid hoidu is one of the spheros
you have
das which are the intellectual spheroids
or actually maybe i should say because
it's going to refer to
uh cassers the first sphere you know
there's that
different ways of enumerating the
spheroids so if you say kasir mabina
then you don't say das but at any rate
you have the
gimora shyness the first three and then
you have
the the seven lower spheroids which are
good forest nets
we're going to talk about
marcus we'll also talk about satan
marcus if we get that far i don't know
we'll see if we get that far
but
matissio fixed
something that was
damaged in hoyt
this is a passage from daniel
from the book of daniel
daniel is describing
this great state of fear that he's
having from this vision
of the jews in future
exiles of course he's in exile in
buffalo but he is
seeing future exiles and it's terrifying
him so he's describing
losing control of his faculties and he
describes it as hoidi napahala lamasques
it says it in chapter 10 of the book of
daniel i believe it's possible
i think it's daniel chapter 10 verse 8.
those online can go check that up
and those who have this old technology
called a safer they could also
they could also check it
i gave you the actual chapter in verse
so you could go look it up in any book
of daniel
okay
when this was revealed to him
the hines saryavanba
he saw the future
greek exile
the
persecution that the jews would suffer
at the hands of the greeks of the
hellenists the yavanan
and he describes that as hoidi
hoidi means my hoid
however you want to translate hoid
sometimes they translate it as
majesty i don't know if that means
anything or glory or splendor
splendor what is splendor so isn't that
a sweetener
splenda
so ahoy d yeah
we're going to say that hoid is also
related to the word
which means gratitude humble
gratitude which is probably a better not
a literal translation of hoyt but
probably a more functional translation
would be
humble gratitude okay
so anyways
daniel foresees the greek persecution of
the jews
and he refers to it as a like a
dysfunction in the sphere of hoyd in the
faculty of heide the alcane
and matissio came and he fixed the
dysfunction in the sphere of
whatever that means we don't know yet
that's why when we celebrate hanukkah
when we celebrate that the hoid was
fixed
we say the alanism which is a way of
giving
his humble gratitude but he does also
relate it to the word haid
and that's why hanukkah lasts for eight
days
ki
who spiraches
because hoyd is the eighth sphero
that's right and by the way in benching
it's funny because in schmidt acid it's
late so you have time like in the middle
of an essay like did i miss violence no
no it's later but benching it creeps
right up on you because because we're in
benching where do you say
right
is
so and that's that's earlier adventuring
right so it's not about if it's earlier
it's later it's the context of where you
mention haida so wherever you say hey
that's where you say
and we know here naphtalic is telling us
kabbalistically that's because
hoyde was damaged and hoid got fixed
and
um
hoyd is the eighth sphero and that's why
hanukkah is eight days right the eighth
sphere he's he he says he counts from
casey from aliday
eight
i feel like the count from sesame street
okay
all right
we still don't know what this means like
tell us what what is the real issue here
um
and how you'd go together
you never really hear about a huge by
itself
it goes with naza
nazar is on the right side on the right
axis
cava you mean
and the hoid is on the kava small
but they're they're mirror images of
each other
and anatomically when we speak about the
spheroids
in terms of
the image
of
a body like in passage
when we speak about
the the spheroids
in terms of
anatomy
right where we say
kindness is the right arm
and gura drayasmola
restraint or strength
discipline is the left arm
and tifares is guffa
tiferes is the body the torso
what's natsuk and hoyd so he says
natsukin hide
haim
train
bein
they are either referred to as the two
thighs
because they're beneath the torso
beneath the torso lower than tifaris
so they're called
the shuiken
that's what it calls them which are the
thighs
or they're called the two
being
the two
male
reproductive
organs
and what does that mean spiritually well
not just spiritually
biologically as well
uh what does it mean spiritually and
biologically the biological comes from
the spiritual we learned yesterday in
the tanya kitas
that the reason we have asaka sanafish
is because it's nishtal shal
it derives from the astrasvirais
and in turn it doesn't say that over
there in in
yesterday's time yeah perigymal of
but it says elsewhere is that the reason
that the body the physical body is the
way that it it is is because that in
turn is a manifestation of the
configuration of the kaikas which in
turn is a manifestation of the of hashem
spherus
so the way that these two
um
these two body parts work
is
that
by the way i'm being i'm being careful
not to
i'm not sure if i'm censoring what words
i'm using because
i'm uploading the torah anytime or
because i don't want youtube
to uh think i'm the wrong kind of
channel but
not sure which one i'm more concerned
about but at any rate
um yeah
so i bet anyone who knows what train
bayon did means you could figure it out
so
what is their function they are
in other words
their purpose
is to
prepare something that's to be given
over
reproductively speaking
just talking about it begasmius
that the purpose the function of these
body parts is to prepare
the genetic material that the father
would give over to the mother to gestate
for nine months in the in the mother's
womb
and
you could describe that also in terms of
emotional or cognitive functions like a
teacher for instance who's preparing a
lesson so there's
how the teacher processes it in his own
cognition
and his own feelings about the subject
his own law of his own
awe
but then the nets and
is
just before the transmission just before
i give it over i have to attenuate i
have to mix and match and and make sure
that the right formula the right
combination
is
is struck before i give it over so it's
like the the the the last adjustments
before something is given over that's
why sometimes it's helpful to think of
casing as emotions
and and that's
attitudes
because an emotion is more something
it's more it's more pure it's more
my actual feeling
about this concept attitude is more how
should i approach it it's more adjusting
the
how do i go in for a landing how do i
actually
get involved in this thing an
orientation maybe even you might call it
so
nets
now
when ace of
or asa's malach his sar
his ministering angel wrestled with
yankovino
where did yankee get injured
he got injured
and the the the socket of his hip
which
damaged his sciatic nerve and we have
the prohibition of the giranosha from
that
from that story
but absolutely says something here
interesting
that
the ministering angel of asav
he damaged
the hip socket
he couldn't
he couldn't have any dominion over the
essence meaning the more
internal
faculties
shikule ms
umitase leima
because we know about yankovino that he
was totally ms remember a couple weeks
ago we read from the from the balatanya
he said midosa yankee vs
emma about that
anyways yankee vis-a-mes tiferos is ms
and mitose leima which means that
mito means the bad his intimate life was
perfect what does that mean his intimate
life was perfect that from his intimate
unions with his wives
came only sadly him not like avraham who
had a ishmael or like yitzchak who had
an ace of
mitosis
his intimate life was perfect
the aim by psilos clow he didn't have
any
negative derivatives like the
aforementioned ishmael from who was casa
de clipper or
or asap was guru de clipper right
[Music]
which is ace of combativeness
warlike uh
aggression
but the yankee vista ferris which is
also called ms because it's consistency
it's harmony
it's
truth is truth has an act to be
consistent it's always the same mark
twain said if you never lie you never
have to remember anything
okay something that's a lie
works one place doesn't work the other
place the truth is
always the truth so
yankiv is truth
ace of couldn't
damage the essence of yankee
but he was able to get he was able to
put a little bit of damage on him
on a superficial level
avon avo noga because
he hit him in the in the in the joint to
the ball and socket joint of the thigh
what we're saying is that that's
equivalent to remember we're saying
before that that
hoi they're called also they're called
each one is called a thigh
so
nets and
are sort of the
outer
spheroids
it's not the actual essence they're
what i mean when i say they're outer
spheroids they're
close already to the
to the delivery to the to the outer to
the outer form so
that's all that the sar
sometimes he translates partial but it
makes more sense they pedic
safe pedic iron zion chapter 77 of
gracious rabbi
it says
talks about i actually looked up this
message over here
and it is at the end of paddock
i in zion abrasion
he says over it's talking about yankev
wrestling with saudi shelters
and
it's talking about
the
the jewish people remaining
unassimilated
specifically
uh not succumbing to intermarrying
with the nations among whom they're
exiled
so it says
the nations of the world try to cause
the jews to assimilate through
intermarriage we'll we'll be able to say
to them your
ministering angel could not uh
defeat us
yeah
the atom of action is
and you're trying to uh cause us to
assimilate through intermarriage
and he
that's what the verse says the the the
ministering angel of ace of
touched meaning damaged yankees
this is the quote that is brings
that he struck
the righteous men and women the prophets
and the prophetesses
which would
in the future
come from meaning be descended from
yankiv they says
and who are these
kanye's and the vieux and the vice these
are
the great valiant
martyrs of the era of persecution
historically there's an era of
persecution
and it began with saudi says
a few lines from now it actually it
began with the hellenist
movement
or conquest
yeah let's uh
look back inside here lost my place
kila
that the era of
persecution oppression which really we
equate with the romans
but the
history of
it really started from the greeks the
greeks are a little bit before the
romans
var posca navoor misreal
now at that point
there was no more prophecy
the it was the end of the era
of prophecy
but they weren't full-fledged prophets
they were like junior prophets prophets
and training he says to go look in the
murmur
[Music]
like it's known and actually it speaks
about this
in many places there's a whole long
letter in igetus hakredish
in tanya that speaks about this
that the navoor is from
android the alkane korem khan naveem
that's why they're referred to
as naviem because they have this
connection
to netacan haid not that they were real
full-fledged prophets but they had a
connection to natsukin hoyt meaning
that is going to explain maybe i'm going
to start to summarize because we're
getting getting late and there's i want
to jump ahead to another part but
basically this idea of preserving their
integrity
in terms of not assimilating
specifically through marriage
specifically through marriage which is
the idea of nats
which are the
kaijasbo which are meant for
leido which are meant for reproduction
and they're not to be misappropriated
for other purposes
so uh
maybe i'll jump ahead here
he speaks about and i
yeah wanna
a few and
i hate to do this but let's jump ahead a
few pages to page 168.
um
look here at the beginning there's a sub
chapter here this is still within the
same mimer which is uh
non zion or pedic non zion
uh that we started
at the beginning
yeah
but uh there's a sub
chapter here on page 168.
the first
there's different histories of why the
hashmonoi got involved
why they took up this battle uh but it
they're in the yoytzer which is the poem
the liturgy that's written about it
it says
that the
officer
the uh
they used to have a thing that the the
head of the military the military
governor in any area
would have first rights with any kala
and the the the doctrine of primonacta
so the
the
kashminoi would not allow their sister
to be taken in such a way
and
sadik mentions is also mentioned in
gemada not explicitly in gemara but in
in perish
that's the suggya that talks about about
hanukkah so they're and
aloft of comodo shabbos
why are women included in the miracle of
hanukkah or the celebration of hanukkah
because they were part of the miracle of
hanukkah and what was their
inclusion in the miracle is well
their inclusion in the oppression
unfortunately peter schmidzera
the vote
very strong language absolutely says the
main ness
before he said it was the military
victory but now he spells it out more
explicitly why was the military victory
so important
because if you remember
the the hellenists did not initially
want to conquer us at least not um
not in the in the classical sense of
conquest they were okay with us being
culturally colonized and paying
obviously our tribute and our taxes but
um they weren't going to force us
to be uh quote-unquote second-class
citizens they were very enlightened very
civilized they would they would let us
be one one with them that was the whole
pitch that they were making come on and
be
mix with us intermingle with us
uh specifically through
the lure of of intermarriage so that
today says the main miracle was that we
didn't allow this that we didn't allow
the co-mingling
uh the the spiritual holocaust
of allowing
a
seemingly
enlightened
oppressive
entity
to invite us
to become to dilute ourselves to to lose
our identity by by marriage with them
he says an interesting thing here alkane
there's a whole story in the beginning
above a basra wild story actually
interesting i got it in the beginning
but the hordes was uh was a slave from
the house of hashmonae
when he tried to become
a uh
when he tried to marry into the
hasmoneans lay also there he was not
successful commission
talks about in the beginning of of that
gemara giza
hamish it
that is the essence of the holiness of
the hasmoneans which lasts forever what
is it
characterizes the unique holiness of the
hasmoneans as the preservation of
the integrity of marriage
so now we're getting a little bit closer
to understanding what is the unique
character of hanukkah
burning a candle wasn't to do very good
because the oil oil was an
epilogue to the story the main story was
a war but what was the war over what did
they fight the war over because remember
if we would have intermarried with them
we wouldn't have we wouldn't have had to
fight a war so what was the war over it
was about the preservation of the
sanctity of jewish marriage
very interesting and i'm going to
summarize here but he connects that with
natsuki and haid
he also connects with the idea of yasoid
we know that according to kabbalah yasif
is your side yes
and he
talks about the fact that hanukkah is in
the weeks of the yeashev and me cates
which is all about yasif and yasif how
he protected his sanctity especially
when he was tested with asia's platifah
and all of these things are
interconnected it's all one theme okay
uh so much beautiful stuff here um
i think i wanna
just look at one more thing
so much wonderful things here
um
maybe let's
look um
on page 170 yeah let's look on page 170.
uh
the first full sentence on 170.
he just finished speaking about yasif
and about jasof's
moral fortitude
and how that's connected to hanukkah
okay the davar zahu bisgalas bipol
he's talking about this
sanctification of
of uh intimacy
kia dua midday
like we know about again he's speaking
about the generation of of greek and
roman oppression
israel
you don't see that russia is that often
the wanton sinners meaning people who
are
deliberately
not
religious
and empty people people who are
religiously empty shamasru atsum
al-qaeda
they chose to die as jews they chose to
die as jews
it's interesting in tanya it mentions
how
pertinence
the peculiarity of
the jewish soul that to say the
religious jews died for the religion is
not a religious
every religion has religious people who
die for their religion but what's weird
about jews is you have so many instances
historically
of irreligious people who died for the
religion how do you explain that
and here here again he spells it out
what were they
what did they give their lives for
valerotso
they didn't want to be assimilated
the alkane
therefore
nais di purim nitin lichte
the miracle of purim was allowed to be
written this is a gemaran yuma
it talks about
why esther is called
called morning or dawn
because like the dawn is the end of the
night
purim is the end of the era of writing
our miracles
if you think about it historically
mcgillis esther story of purim
is the last
national miracle
wholesale national miracle
that we commemorate eternally there's a
mitzvah for it
and it's written
officially written it's canon
like the star wars fans say it's canon
by the way star wars fantasy voice canon
canon is a biblical term and so
is it canon
can
this is a whole interesting topic we
should have a whole class on this
another time
but there are svarim which are
contemporaneous
to the nach
which are not
to use the proper term canonical i
believe that is the correct
pronunciation canonical they are not
canonical
um in fact you know we're in the in the
in the
mishnah in sanhedrin says
and then it talks about people who are
jeopardizing their portion of the world
to come and says people who learn uh
there's different interpretations of
what those
foreign means some say just mean secular
books but uh
one one explanation is i believe it's
gonna be akiva i have to look at it look
it up haven't looked at it uh looked it
up recently that say it means the
um
now here i'll use a really uh academic
term i believe it's called
deuterocanonical texts
or the
apocrypha yeah you're going to google it
for me yeah deutero deuteron means
second like deuteronomy is mishna toyota
it's the second repeating of the toyota
so
deuterocanonical texts those are
books that are contemporaneous with this
forum of nach
but they are decidedly not redacted they
are not part
of the
forum of tanakh
and
what's interesting is that in
the
christian version and there is no one
christian version but in many of the
christian versions of the quote-unquote
old testament many of these books were
included
i'm sure we've heard of the septuagint
which is
the
well at least the
toyota portion of the septuagint meaning
the
commotion
the five books of moses that was
translated by the 72 elders the story in
the it was in the mother magilla the the
72 elders who were locked in separate
rooms tomorrow the king
made them translate the terror into
greek
so uh the septuagint
at least the hamish part of that was
written by those 72 elders and that's
the quote-unquote old testament in greek
and the nach part of it
should say lahavdil because it's not
nakh
but that
the pseudo
nach part of it includes many of these
books which were decidedly rejected not
included by the ancestors
and some of them are
books about hanukkah
there's a scroll called yehudis
there are
there's a there's a scroll or a book
of maccabees in fact i guess it's a very
long book because there's a first book
of maccabees in a second book of
maccabees
these are not
reliable books these are not part of our
canon
and uh
going back to the southik here
the last wholesale national miracle that
we have
that is recorded in an authentic
biblical text
is
poor
after purim that's it there may have
been wholesale national miracles but
they're no longer recorded in the bible
chanukah did not make the cut hanukkah
is after poor much later after porn and
chanukah is not in the bible
okay
so reptadik now explains
a deeper explanation why purim is in the
bible why to use the the gematis term in
yuma that it's nitin lichtoff it was
given over it it was eligible to be
written
whereas hanukkah cannot be written
purim is the end is the end of the
hashbah which corresponds to yasoid and
malchus which are the end of the body
the reproductive organs
the hanukkah purim
proceeds not only chronologically
hanukkah but purim is the hakona is the
preparation it
it primes
things to be ready for there to be a
hanukkah at a later date shahu lavaday
is funny it is
unique lovate he said is it is the only
holiday it is the only
occurrence where you have a national
miracle which
is commemorated for all generations but
yet not written in any official
canonical text like one or the other if
it was something that was only
significant at the time and they stopped
celebrating it after a few generations i
get it fine it's not written
but here's something that we do continue
to commemorate every hanukkah every year
we continue to commemorate it
but it doesn't have an official
written
recording
all those
uh apocryphal texts notwithstanding by
the word apocryphal is also with a small
apocryphals like
a story that
you know it's a good story
a mice are shaharya that wasn't really
it wasn't really shahya but it was you
know it's a good story so that's they
call that apocryphal
but the apocrypha were these these books
that were not
included in in tanakh
so it's interesting chanukah is the only
national miracle you will find
where it's significant enough to be
commemorated forever
but not significant enough to be
recorded in
in the bible
like one way or the other i get it if it
if it's not enough to be in the bible
find something don't celebrate it
forever but if it's enough to celebrate
it forever how come it's not in the
bible like poor porn is in the bible
so he says like this
these miracles the hanukkah miracles
which were not
that which do not lend themselves to be
written
in his galaxy
they still haven't been fully revealed
you can't write the story because the
story is not over
it's still happening
the full revelation of hanukkah
hasn't even yet come out
for at least
a hundred years ago and tadak was
writing
the story of hanukkah is still going on
it's too deep it's too much
to cap it off at any one point and to
write it down and say and that's the end
of the story
the after
shiite bullet days
there's only
you can only capture
an aspect of it
for
being commemorated through the
generations
this is such a beautiful concept here
in a way chanukah isn't just about
something that happened
when the maccabees fought the greeks
hanukkah is a catch-all
for all
it's really beautiful
for all of the miracles the ace hagolas
that happen in exile
shalom
which
don't lend themselves to be written they
can't be written
and yet they have eternal significance
the only way you can capture it
is with
the glow of a flame
if you would try to write the story you
couldn't write the story because in a
way the story's still happening
what's the story he's describing
the integrity
the the struggle to retain the integrity
of our intimate lives
which is a miracle the jewish people's
identity is a living miracle a testimony
to the integrity of
of our intimate lives
because
if all of our oppressors who tried to
murder us didn't finish us off
assimilation should have intermarriage
should have and you can bemoan what are
the intermarriage rates that's fine you
you can you can look at it glass half
empty
but let's look at it for a second
let's marvel at the fact that we still
exist that after
thousands of years in gullus
intermarriage didn't finish us off
so it's an ongoing miracle
that itself is you can look at it
pessimistically if you want it and and
of course there's what to be improved
and of course
we have to to be extremely vigilant
about this issue but for a second let's
be positive
the the miracle of the
preservation
of
jewish
identity through the preservation of
jewish marriage
it's not just something that the
the maccabees fought to preserve it's
something actually
that they
they had a watershed moment at that time
that's how he's describing it something
that they accomplished that basically
from that point on
something changed for the good and i
mean
i mean that in both ways it changed for
the good meaning in a positive way and
for the good forever
at that point what the what the
maccabees accomplished
in standing up against the lure of
assimilation through intermarriage that
basically made it that the jewish the
jewish people would never succumb
would never be destroyed through the
assimilation of intermarriage that's
basically what was accomplished at that
time and that's something we celebrate
every year now how do you write that
story
how do you write that story you can't
write that story you know why because
that story is happening
every time some college kid on campus is
sitting in class and some girl asks him
to borrow a pencil and he has to
struggle with his identity and doing the
right thing that's not a story you could
write it's not a story you put in the
bible it's not a story you could read
from a magilla in shul it's a story
that's happening right now it's
happening in thousands of places all
over the world at this second right now
this very second
so
it's a story that can't even be written
in a book
such poetry here the only way we can
capture it
is through the symbol of the glow of a
flame
words can't tell this story
the light of the minorita tells this
story it's really it's it's gorgeous
okay let's finish it up here
anyways baha'is ner through the glow of
a candle
whoa
the candle represents the the the
glowing the light of your side your side
is connected to reproductive
uh functioning
how your slate can shine and overcome in
the realm of the superficial in the
realm of the of
heterogeneous liaisoner
gambinemius
and to cause not only that it should
shine into the superficial realms but
then also permeate internally the
heinough whole mine
arabovum
to
[Music]
basically saying to nullify any type of
potential
commingling
that's that's really what the
the moneta is all about
and there's this much much more i mean
this is uh
what one two three four five six seven
pages
we we read about uh i'd say about a
tenth of it
it's gorgeous stuff
okay anyways
all right felik and kanika