Siyum by the Lubavitcher Rebbe on Mesechta Pesachim in Niglah and Nistar

the yeshiva.net a little introduction to be able to understand and have context everybody knows that there's a mitzvah called pidyna ben taylor commands when a person has a baby boy first born male 1 so my 30 days after 30 days is a mitzvah of ben of liberating or redeeming his son from the kaiju this mitzvah clearly says is an obligation on the father the father has an obligation to perform the mitzvah in parish's boy this you know because your mummies say it every day in the past the father with your sons of your children you have to liberate a few lines later your child will ask you so you'll tell them hashem killed every point of mitsuram so therefore i liberate every part of my sons again clearly the person is explaining why he's doing it that's the first time pagina ben has mentioned as a result of the fact that hashem treated the differently quietly were killed and the freedom of the jews were speared and therefore i redeemed every cut in parishes towards the end of fashion moshe gives the commandment for the for the yamantavu and then he says compass is all the gifts that a cayenne gets and there he again says and here's the first time with the word padau is redundant every other time it says the ones here it says you should redeem redeem you so these are the fourth succumb pity this siddha look at this boy that ever said aleph nissan thompson base the 11th of nisa 1962 was actually my leaders hashishem 60th year of the rabbi and it was the first time he made a public vibranium for you all of nissan and uh and this was the sea of which deals with which is of course in this parish say no from the possible every pride of your sons you should liberate in this week's parashat and the parishes boy the first time it's mentioned we learn out a special din from this that whatever in addition to the actual obligation on the father that he has to do not bad for his oldest male son that says clearly in the past that let's say the father never did it for whatever reason he didn't wander he didn't have money he didn't know the din he was not alive whatever the case was and now the child grows up is he even picking up no it's not his problem it's not an obligation on him toyota doesn't say clearly titus says it always you have to do it to your son what if you did it he says from this passage we learn not another din that that the ban is how do you learn this pasta so he says in order for he brings from carbon he was the bay one of the great commentators anu dushami he says in for the adam sir the word adam is we know that your children are people maybe not but we would assume that if you're a man your child is also a human being your child is not a horse if you're a person we learn like this we touch the person himself the prayer should liberate himself that's who explains it justifies the extra word to teach that there's a fear of on the person himself not only on the father of the person without that otaku which means also the mother because if there's a thieve is not on the father but it's on the creator as well technically or that there is an indian to be right there it would be whoever is responsible if the father's not around they say about the vilnigan this is that he always walked around with him and any kind ever he was any kind he ever met throughout his life he liberated himself again again he didn't stop redeeming himself why why because okay and the reason is because the shash that the first cayenne was not a real cayenne he's not from zara you know today it's not so clear so mela any queen he ever met he liberated himself again and again of course but he didn't stop doing it so this is the xiaomi says you learn the fourth time it's brought much later than partisans but in parishes where it says from there the beverly learns out that you have to liberate yourself if your father didn't redeem you the pastors how do you learn it from there because there's a redundancy it says why twice so you learn that there's two types of pigeon there's the father being paid and then there is a second tif then that is the son so the bible he learns it from completely a different prosecutor xiaomi conduction is one past second by the same person from where you learn the din itself that the father has to do it and the bible learns it from apostle comparison and it's interesting as he says in three that the he of on the father to be paid that the beverly also learns from a different passage not from the past comparisons belief but to the puzzling parties what's the nathan what's the feeling the fact that he chooses this possible he chooses this possibility the din is the same dude is there absolutely has to be achilles base my timer number the first question is what's because the difference is there a difference the fact that you learn it from a different process or no just the same thing apaches if you're learning it from different there's some ramifications some application and why does the baby choose which person can parse this boy how do you begin to answer this question so you have to look the way the mitzvah is described in each place the way it described gives you the context of the mitzvah and then it gives you the definition and then you see if there's a difference from here or from here he says if you study the way the mitzvah is described in body and in qaeda you'll see there's a difference in theme and context by the emphasis is towards your son clearly an obligation on the father truly learns from it also the sum that's true from the extra word but in both places as and it says clearly because what hashem did in mitzrayim therefore the quran so to speak one and they have a special kedusha they belong to him and therefore they're given to the cayenne who represents hashem and therefore you have to give the money to the client and liberate the child because the prayer is born as a divine being as a child of god it belongs to the kayan who represents hashem after the whole story of kyra hashem tells iron all the special gifts a coin gets not only pig in a ben there's trumus and this mysterious and there's a lot of different gifts from every animal that a client gets one of them is what pidgin and there he adds details that we don't know yet first of all he says me ben kaidish you have to redeem him from a month old the next thing he gives you the prize hamashes skull these are details that we didn't hear about yeah these we learned from parsons says difference number one is the father versus the sock in paris it's about the excellent that you have to redeem it doesn't talk about the father and the difference number two that the paratroopers bites behind and as an explanation for what happened by inside and in quite if it's an independent dinner as a gift to a cayenne will understand the reason between the bow of the indeed or xiaomi about the source of the din that he has to redeem himself if his father didn't do it but the bible learns it from pashas but to understand this we first have to explain [Music] it you can all you can all uh visualize the scene so right away they ask him a question what's the question they don't know what to do every video then this happens but the difference is what happened at that page in that band was recorded in the gemara and it became a basis of allah so he says they asked him a question this is how they introduce the question who makes this black the cayenne should make it or the father should make it what's the question they asked absolutely koi and mavari perhaps the client should make it the kamati han aliyade because there's a benefit that's coming to his hand the mitzvah you know you make on a joyous occasional jewish experience experience right you build a new house you buy a new house a new calendar new fruits so mailer the cayenne is getting another or maybe the father of the son should play the bracha because he's doing a mitzvah and of course he's doing a special mitzvah unique mitzvah mitzvah that you do once a lifetime it's not a mitzvah that you do every week or every day like twilight or tsitzis or shabbos so maybe he should make shaky on that we don't know well you have it did not have the answer in his hands he did not know the answer so he went he came to the basement and he asked the question they told up father of the sun must make both bronchus and the father makes but when you read this story in gamara the stories in yamada every word is every word how they describe a story what's what's difficult in this story shitty you don't have to introduce it before the question right for example let's say you had an opinion about yeah they're not going to tell them that you need a coin for pidgin not that but we have a question do you need this if the first block is a partition so why did they have to introduce it before they asked the question we would have expected this question episode why are you here we have a shiela who makes the shahiano who makes that good the fact that they introduced first another i know clearly that the first black is made by the father but now i have a question in the second means that the first statement is important for the second question for the for the for the question for the second state that's what he's asking since the first thing in parentheses he's adding and if it's such a positive thing so certainly you don't need it offers was authored by rabbi landau the love of prague the author of noida be hood he's one of the greatest guy in him of his generation who is a contemporary of the balsham and the noida behuda is a peter shangham it's called he asks this question the whole introduction he says it's strange doesn't belong so the bidding comes up with a brilliant idea he says no the is the basis of the question and here he's media fascinating thing there's a famous concept by british amitrus some bronchus are different than other brothers some brachas we say li in some brackets we say ow for example when you put on the size so this is the question why hazal changed the nusa back and forth here here al so in the first period of massachusetts is a discussion about it and then you're showing them there have at the end of the first predicament all elaborate on this as elaborate upon this at length there's a few different angles tonight to be the this is his creative idea he says as follows most mostly chinese explain the difference is if it's a mitzvah that you could do through or it's a mixture that you have to do on your own i can't make a shliyak to put on villain for me i can't why it's called the mitzvot goofy it's not that the action has to be done i could make a shliya to be makadish on isha i can make a shleak to give a get i can make a schleichtv i can make a shade i can't make a to sit and eat this sukkah for me to put on filling for me to put on citrus for me i can't because this is a mitzvah that doesn't just have to be done i have to do it it has to be on my body i make a schliere it's not going to be on my body isn't it if it's a missus i say that you have to do let's say daily you have to fill them so that's one together but then if you're if you want to accomplish a woman you ha you don't have to if you want to then you can send it it's a midfielder i need to come into my house to be clean but you can do it it's fine filling i can't so this is the general principle that mitzvahs that you have to do on your own you can't make a shlee if you say why to the channel but when i'm making you wish um but the places where it's all and it's still a mitzvah but go for it there's specific reasons i'll i'll i'll show you in a moment but but from it i don't i could do it jewishly except maybe i could say al because ah you say al cause le means to mitzvah to do it when i'm your sleep it could be through me represents that it's a mitzvah on me to do it all means you're such a mitzvah it has to be done there is a mitzvah beer i can also do it for you that's generally the principle comes denied the behavior then says what's the mitzvah that means you can do it through [Music] explains it in two ways the person himself makes a so he says should you give it to the father even though sometimes if he appoints that bracha will not be made nonetheless give it to the father because he's the one doing the mitzvah s or maybe perhaps since when you're going to appoint a slave there won't be a shakiano anymore so that's a reason to give it to the cayenne not to the father and that way you'll ensure that in every pidgin every period is always going to be there can't make a picture i've been without a client you can make a pigeon have been without a father but you can't make an opinion i've been without the client and since he's getting ham loss even though it's a mitzvah on the father and you're taking it away from the father but at least you guaranteed that the shakira is being made every single time by the korean who's getting that's one way the native hood explains the question this explains why they have to say shita that you make but if you wouldn't be able to do it through then it would be no question that the father makes the shakiano because it's his mitzvah and it's a special mix and it's going to be every time because he can't make her sleep this is one way the neighborhood explains bays another explanation is there's another explanation in showing him for the difference of li and al there's a few different angles one of them is it has to do if you fulfill the mitzvah completely through yourself or you need somebody else's assistance to help you you cannot do it on your own you need somebody else to help you do it and because you need somebody else to help you do it so that's why you say ow a counterpart and assistance huh you need somebody else you need the cayenne so without the coin you couldn't do the mitzvah and the cayenne has a double plus sai the kayan is an essential part of doing the mission plus he's getting annoyed he's getting money so maybe he should do the shaky on because he has these two reasons for him to make shakhianu he's part of a special mitzvah plus he's getting unknown with the father there's one reason to make shakhian that's the second way that answers this gemara so the native they gave us that the is part of the question they didn't just ask who makes jacquiano it was alumnus you see how they spoke i guess that's a different thing that pigeon had been in our opinion eventually see how they spoke they didn't just ask a question first they gave the introduction to the question and this allowed them similarly to understand what the question was of course if similarly all have to understand this from the way they asked it that he makes but these are the two efanum of the noida bihoud you'll take a look in our other 12 he 11. okay in the addition i'm because i guess it's a star it's not 11 star star so in the new editions they removed the stars but this is 11. okay has a different variety but the the the idea the nucleus of the approach is the same like the naughty b hood that it's about the ow the medical now i want to tell you what the sum surface says it's a very very geshmaka voice i'm sophia he says he says you say not right the fact you say al means you can appoint that's why you say al you don't say li but it says and nonetheless in most situations the father is the one who does it himself you don't appoint us you do it yourself by a bris for example we appoint ashley usually the moyal i mean unless you know okay for that's also for technical reason it's hard to learn it in a few days by pitting we we do it ourselves that's what some cypher sucks and he brings a lot of sources the question is why we do it ourselves do we do it ourselves because because of mitzvah such a precious thing it comes once in a lifetime there's a big sim card you want to do it yourself and then you should be making the shakiyanu why should you be making the shahiano if you're making the shakiyanu because it's a tremendous symbol you do it yourself even though you say ow or the reason we do it ourselves says pasha why are we doing because hashem killed what does it say hashem didn't do it through if we say so just like he didn't do it through you don't do it through a shake it's not because this it's because you want to emulate the source so if it's not let the call you make because he's getting the hana that's how the sum surface but it's all based on the owl on the owl okay so what do we have from here we have for me have all uh that the basis is what i'll put in abandon therefore we have the question who makes shakianu why because either al means ashley or al means that you have somebody else involved that's what they need to be good to learn the question is can you learn the gem out of this way so he says as follows but i just want about one before we go invited you asked about philip writes um by tulane and philip it's two different mitzvahs to put it on you to tie it up not to put it on but that it should be on your head in other words you don't get the mitchell by putting it on you get the mitzvah by it being on your head is the moment you tied you to the mitzvah big enough come in let's say you put on to finland before before dawn but then you leave it on you all day phil and shayadi weren't making it so let's do it i remember that episode he says it says it was muslim it was beautiful how he said it he said it's a possibility he's right everybody does it themselves so even though you could make a slid but you don't make a sleeve so the cypher says oh so you say alpine but still everybody does it themselves but you say al to bring other you could be you could do it through a sleeve the question is why do you do it yourself is it because of our and that's the basis of the question okay now let's go back to bow it's not settling so much when you read the sigoning and the hamstring of gemada three questions aleph first of all mei hanigud from the contrast look how they phrased the question shita it's parashat that bottle says the question is [Applause] who makes it the father or the kyan or the father so it's mashma that the part that's partially the same theme in which the question is right by the i don't have a question or or it's clear the father now the question is or him or him oh yeah ben bass huh this is a very strong opinion a very strong question like the knight of behuda the way the question is being phrased is very wrong let's understand what was the question according to him [Music] that's your vote that you're making up and in other words you can use or you need an assistance of somebody else so now i have a question about shakhiyam so that should have been the way you phrase the question my question is who makes how does the gemara now according to the the beauty that's not negaya here that's also the first question you see the first question is who does it him or him so that's that's the contrast the contrast is here i know who does it here i don't know who does it according to the neighbor that's not the contrast the country is not here i know who does it here it doesn't know who does it the contrast is there there i know have a question here is it him or him so the signal in harlow the way to ask the question is very strange according to the heart of the of the noida behood you understand you're not supposed what's for stay tuned or think from them here you can ask the question two ways okay i could say like this what you should have said shita yeah not ben the father of the son makes a brachy now i have a question who makes shakianu oh now i understand you just told me alpina bets i have a question of shakiran how does the gemara say it and who makes it the father of the son now i have a question the emphasis is on the father that doesn't make sense because that was an obvious thing the father does the question was on the out that's not obvious in the question now comes a bigger question gimbal why would we call mentioning the father according to the neighborhood it's not relevant that the father makes it happen mentioning the father that's a partial thing it should have said in other words even if it would have said like he asked him shiloh babies it still would have not been loved even if it would have said that by pigeon abandons by the father of the child and the brah is why do you put in the father of the child that's not relevant to the whole issue we know that the father of the child doesn't the question is based on what so even if it would have been in the stated silent base it still wouldn't have been it still wouldn't have been quite thick and smooth certainly that the whole say that is confusing and the whole arithmetist doesn't make sense he should have said since by predicting the question is so we're back to square one what's the meaning of this whole introduction that the father of the son makes a pity in a ben it's not negated via very good he comes into the basement and he says i don't know who makes shakhianus they tell them we knew about the first one we didn't ask that you should have just said the same at the end of the gamut we see here that the whole basis of the discussion is all based on the aviation making the first bracha that's the basis and that's why they keep on repeating it everything is tight in another union one person who's eating two carbonas there was the carbon pay second it was the carbohydrate two carbonate to say the night and the question is if you make two breakfasts if you make one profit so since you're talking about two blocks by one person who's doing a myself what do we mean he's eating the pesa and he's eating the zeva which are dependent on each other myself doesn't mean one action my second means it's one one story a person doing them both together because you eat the before the pesar so therefore he brings the story where you have two brachas on one myself and one why it belongs in the end of sachin because you're talking about a similar situation of one person making two brachas in one setting the question is on the if and of the difference what they did if you learned it if the alphas at the end of gemara what they did was in every message they removed all the debates and they just took out they made a a a compilation of just the halachus and every mistake they just they take out from all the shackles the questions answers debates and they just you read them they just go through all the halachahs all the mascaras were myself but mellow what they did was they take all the if it's a certain they take also from another they'll put it in you have a full comprehensive system the diff is the first one who did this and then later did after this the rambam also took out the but he made a separate safer derived that's where they should have put it they also put it in the sector so the carbon is asked this question there that is to put it all in the sector that it belongs this means that according to them so the explanation and all of this and now we'll see how you have to learn the story in the gemara hamitzvi there's three active participants in the midst of pidyin there's the father who's redeeming his son the title tells him to redeem his son there's the child who's being redeemed and there's the cayenne who is receiving the money in lieu of the child consists of the fact that he is obligated to redeem every jewish child that's not it's an obligation on the cayenne doesn't say anywhere there's no obligation on him to be part of the rather the toyota makes him a part of the mitzvah or at night in the midst of another for me to redeem my child i need a cayenne i cannot do it without a kind so he's an integral component of it he's a condition he's a he's a an integral component of the of the mitzvah it's a tanay in the mitzvah i can't take a levy i can't take himself i need a client but it's not a shield on him that's clear practically there's no did it ever happen that someone said you know what keep making no because then would there be a would there be a a a some degree of on right to say you have to be i'm taking your money you have to be right take your kid back i'm just wondering if there's any because then there is a fear of on the cayenne right he says in 17 look at 17. the game is is a helix of the atsum habdiya in other words in other words this is how the mitzvah is fulfilled just like you just like the child is part of the mitzvah the cayenne that's another myth was fulfilled it's not episode tonight's daddy this is how you do the mitzvah so immediate of course the cayenne is part of the mix with the claim to be willing to do it he's the one who fills the mitzvah even if you're going to say that he's not doing the mitzvah opinion about it's clear he's helping he's making it happen fine but not on it but now we have akash when you talk about the other two parties the father and the son here you can clad in two ways aleph mitzvah ben but he said before the mitzvah is on the child when the mitzvah is conferred upon him when he's 30 days you can't expect a thirty year old boy to fulfill this ah so the traitor so to speak upon so to speak the child doesn't appoint the title points a delegate an ambassador representative yeah the father is the son so to speak not a regular appointed by the child obviously but the tithe places the mitzvah and the father in lieu of the child there's no question to the even the father it says clearly doesn't even the father that is not asking he doesn't what definition of the theory is it because it's an obligation on the child the child can't do it he's 30 days old so who doesn't the father does it for him it's like a power of attorney or beings may cutted the dynasty of abdio allah you had a baby you have to liberate the baby that's the that's the dip the mine of kamina what's the difference lapel the father man i've committed who today has the obligation right now who's the first one that has the obligation we all know that if the father doesn't want to do it we learned before the child has to but let's say the child doesn't want to the father is ready to do it who right now it depends what had a sun remover and he never made a pig in a bench for him reuven became by mitzvah okay reuven tells the archives he said oh yeah yeah i'm going to do it he says no i'm i'm doing it he says no it's my mitzvah no i'm doing it they come to argentina they both want to do the mitzvah i want to do the mitzvah no you want to do the mitzvah what's the question who gets rights to do the mitzvah it depends how you learn if you say that the ikemits was on the child it's just when he's 30 days old it goes to the father now he's bar mitzvah so who gets the mitzvah who has to do it who has the school of course the son i the father had the he had the fear as long as the main principle of the thief couldn't do it but now he can do it automatically it's removed from him it goes to the son but if you said it but if you say that that he was on the father it's in principle it's on the father it's not on the child i have an obligation to liberate my child element we have a special limit that if i don't want to do it or i don't do it he he is to do it but that's a special new halal so what's the difference if he's 13. if he's 13 i didn't do it i still have to do it if i didn't do a mitzvah last year i don't have to do it this year i never fulfilled my obligation as a father so now when the father is a god i'm the one who's first and i have the first host if i say no then we learn from him this is the question that the bowed xiaomi are arguing about this and because they're arguing about this therefore they derive it from the from it's not just they have different circum they looked that pity not been differently one of them saw the father as the kill one of them saw the thief on the sun that the father is obligated to liberate his son and that the child is obligated to liberate himself as his father doesn't do it in other words according to the irish almighty in the source of pidyin haben in the passage we have both of them in the same passage both obligations were communicated together in the same verse in this first source of pitying ben we include both obligations to liberate yourself and that your father should liberate you so the urusham he says what does this mean this means that the etsim it's a key of on the son from the thief and the son comes also the key of on the father because since the fear of the son is when he's a baby and he can't do it so the titus says right now you do it says what father son no no mention of a child you don't do it it's told the father is father father the son passion redeem your son all you only father no mention of the son in other words the source of partisan pity not been in the context of mitzrayim mentioned his only father the son in the universal mean that include also some to himself in other words in the source opinion of men you have both obligations together in the bible in the source of pity number there's not a mention of the boy doing it for himself suddenly impartial in another place talking about magnus kohun and a detailed magnus there you learn out that you can do it yourself clearly the bob lee does it for miracles he wants to prove that the fear of the son has no connection to the thieve on the father it's a separate limoud that the sun has achieved to liberate himself to put it this way the mitzvah pigeon had been is only on the father it's not on the sun it's my it's my obligation it's not yours are you a boy it's a father's obligation it's not a son's obligation just like i have an obligation to do things you don't have an obligation i have an ability to do it with you but it's not your obligation it's completely it's a father's responsibility it's father's it's not a son's responsibility clearly that's what the baby holds but mela when the child grows up my obligation was never taken away i still have a fear of i still have a school whoever the titan never says when he's 13 i don't have to do it anymore i always have to do it this is an obligation of a father towards a son elema once he's 13 he's mahu of an all mitzvahs his own mitzvahs and evie mitsubishi's one of the nyanim is that that mitzvah which the father was obligated to do with him so the father didn't do it uncertainly the father doesn't want to do it so tayden now places this here on the son among all the other you know that one of his many obligations as an adult is that that mitzvah that his father had that he never did with him he also has to fulfill it himself because he was relevant in it he has to do it but that's not the did the din is on the father and that never changes and therefore if there's a choice between the two who does it the father goes first the father has preference because that's the initial now the thieve and the son is only in the case when the father refuses to do it now there's a new obligation transfer on the child but as long as the father wants to do it and is about to do it this somehow doesn't come into the picture he's just a passive uh recipient of the mitzvah but he's not he's not there's nothing for the president and that's why they both learned from the same pasta the same pasta that says the father has to liberate his son you learn also that the son has to liberate himself from the saint bosak why is it from the same passage in other words both were said in the original source because the original is on the sun the reason the titus speaks about the father is because he's a child so it goes to the father but it goes to the father it goes to the father from the child it doesn't begin with the father begins with the child and the reason the father is obligated is because the child is obligated but the child can't do it and that's where from the same posse you learned that if the father doesn't do it who does it the son because really he always had to do it i'm shaking according to the ability no the fear of the father to the son over there you don't learn not that he does it himself you know why because he doesn't do it himself it's a hebrew the father it's not that the king of the father comes from the son so practical between the babbling when there hasn't been one until bar mitzvah and that comes by mitzvah yeah the father automatically he has the first three of us 13 years no no father yeah do you show me the son has the heavens because but doesn't begin by mitzvah that's the vert it begins the moment the child is 30 days old according to the universe xiaomi it was it was a din on the child the reason it became on the father is only the father inherited it so to speak obtained it from he he took it from the child the moment he doesn't have to take it from the child anymore the child is an adult automatically it goes back to the way it was supposed to be what the son doesn't and that's why whether you learn out both denim from the saint paulsick the source of the side that he does it himself and said that i do it for him as a father why are they both from the same puzzle because really it's his mitzvah and the only reason i do it for him is because he does it himself he's really supposed to do it himself as a child he can't so the title says you do it because that's the way he's supposed to do when he's a month old but if not automatically he goes back to him automatically he goes back to him because it was always his now he's an adult it's a separate din in particular a separate place in toyota not in the source of ben with the father and son relationship is discussed it's only father and son you don't learn from them that you don't learn from there that he does it himself why don't you learn from the day that he does it himself because it's not even the father the king of the father doesn't come from the child it comes from the father himself and therefore even when he's a god let's delicate on the father element is a new deen that the father doesn't do it part of the obligations of the son to himself one of them is another din and that is he becomes a mitzvah one of the myths was that that mitzvah that his father was about him and he never did he should do and the child of course it doesn't mean that theo is called practically on the child it means the way it's set up minhat is that the key of israel and the child but the traitor appoints somebody to stand in lieu of the child and fulfill history of so the pearl the thief is on the father there's no question about that we all know that he was on the father the moment the time of pigeon even comes the question is what's the definition of that is the father being obligated with his own obligation or is his obligation stemming from the fact that toyota want to challenge so i don't think it's a contradiction to that india the father has a benefit from being being paid to his son because he gets the son back but the kid what is what's the benefit to the kid if he's not fighting himself he's 13. he went through life big deal so i'm a clean technically probably has some advantages okay can a kid that wasn't being played there can he eat tremendous like you said british is the same question who's the key of ambris is the thieve of briss on the child but he can't circumcise himself so you have to do it for him or no the thieve was on the father and this is a big discussion in nacharena here the rebb is introducing it to pigeon up now based on this what the bible holds look how beautiful this story in yamada is now come back to the story and you'll see the glottic a minute to understand the question of you have to first introduce the to the father makes alpine event why hadiyoko the diocese not like the knight of you said that it's about the noosa no that's not the quest then the whole grammar the whole structure should have been different it should have said that you make the voice from the question you get the answer the question was if it's so positive don't talk about it says that's the question [Music] m he never asked this question but it's a strange it's a strange indian the way they phrase the question to the sim lawyer is shita alpine or recording the way that russian that if quoted he does it the question is now we understand because part of it is shita that the father makes this bracha always even if the father even of the child grows up and the nu is if at some point the father wouldn't be making this only the child [Music] if it's clear that the father doesn't make this baraka forever in other words when the child becomes an adult he's the one who does patina ben and he's he's makhiv to do it not the father why because the mitsu was always his the tighter just brought the father in in lieu of the child then it's not a question who makes shakianu of course the kind should make a shakianu because he's getting the benefit why should the father make it the father is not even doing his own mitzvah he's doing the mitzvah's song just like this writes in we learned earlier if i send you to do a mitzvah for me you make the brahma you don't make a shakhtar no only i make i make it only if i'm doing my own here the father is like so why should he make a shaking he's not even doing his mitzvah he's doing somebody else's mitzvahs he doesn't make but if you say that the father makes this black always and that's why the clutch is on avihaben the word is not the word he makes this always always that's the word he's always it's there's no conditions that when the boy is 12 he makes it when the boy is 14 he doesn't make it that's the there's no conditions there's no border there's no boundary he always makes the black why does he always make the baraka because it's here on him always and the have never went away he says that's what the mother quotes hashem commanded us he's not just making it as a schlesis for the with the child the mail uh now i have a big question who makes the shakiano perhaps he should make the shakhiana why gave him a special skus it's a mitzvah once in a lifetime that god gave you you could never do it again it's a happy occasion oh if it's not my mitzvah then what's that i'm not even doing my mitzvah i'm doing the boys myth for the boy can't make the shakiano i also don't make this because i can't make for somebody else i can't be happy for you i could do things for you i can be happy for you it's a mistake when people think that somebody else could be happy for them important idea it's an important idea you can make for anybody else i could do what you want me to do uh [Music] but we see that the gemara is asking sounds like someone that doesn't make money but we see that the mother is asking what's it like really believe that when you buy a new house you make money you uh you make a shakiyam whoa for me it is yes why don't you make why don't both make so it says like this you could say jose this wasn't even a hammond it's only one shakian we don't make a shakianu on every hannah that we have if you give me five dollars i don't make a shakiano a storekeeper every time he makes ten dollars it doesn't make a chance you make on a big sim you bought a new bias or you built a new bias a beggar that's remember people didn't buy clothes every day they bought a bag and sometimes once a year once was a kiddish to buy a baguette right that's why today every time you buy an undershirt you don't make a shakianu every time you buy a shirt coming people bought a hashem buy lots and lots of shirts and set it it's a different mahalo but when it's a big sim card so mainly it's types like this for getting five forty slide fifty dollars thirty dollars whatever it is it doesn't make a shahyan the shot is it's not a regular five slaughter it's a hannah that's coming from a mitzvah so the mitzvah makes the it's not stop five slaughter it's not thirty dollars it's not been thirty dollars it's a different engine so if the mitzvah gives hashibas to the hanoi that's the vote the mailer the mail so now is the kash does the father make shakhianov for the mitzvah he says this doesn't make sense because if the father is making shakhian in other words he's celebrating the mitzvah so it doesn't make sense that the koryan should make shahiyanu because of something that's toefl to the mitzvah that the mitzvah gave hashem you understand so you wanted to make the bracket for the so what is he celebrating the fact that the mitzvah gave service to the money it's a toefl of the mitzvah it's not a nikki that's a toefl that money came from it you understand elohim you want him to make a black itself not a toefl to the mitzvah for that you know mcabrach is only five that's what you could say why there's no have a minute to make two brachas but the question is who makes the bracha are you focusing so to speak on the russians are you focusing on the gosh you're focusing on the father you're focusing on the kind you're focusing on the guy who lost the money focusing on the guy who made the money it's the same reason when the child is an adult just like he makes a big dinner ben because it's his mitzvah so the mailer he makes because it's his mitzvah he's celebrating the india i the client is benefiting from it yeah that's like that's like the child's here that's just the result of history of because he has a view of so therefore if the child is an adult and he didn't do it so the child has to do it but the thief and the child is a result of the father's ki if not the other way around that's the question it's part of the equation just like the cayenne is making because from the heel of the father like we said before i think what it means because it works a beautiful contrast either you say one way is that the three was on the sun when he's a child and the father is because the sun can do what the father does it or you say the he was on the father and when the father doesn't do it so the son is as a result of the father's in other words because the father is when the father didn't do it so that gets transferred so to speak to the son in lieu of the father the son is is the sanskrit is born from the father's heaven or you say the father even the father is born from the sun because the father because he's having not know from the father's mitzvah like we explained before why are you giving it to the client you understand just like the key of a ben it's the father's indians that it's a once in a lifetime for the father but the kyin could be on the uh every day every day more than that that you were saying that there's a different gether it's like a subjective level of if if this is something that's important to you like a a house is something you say right but here the cayenne he can do this theoretically ten times a day but they wouldn't he wouldn't have a shafiano soft course of apparently it's akasha because i guess tangible physical hanoi in this world trumps lots of other things you see it was a habamen hobbin [Music] what's the big deal of getting five slayer just like you know unless you have a new house just like a cayenne doesn't make a shakiano for every one of the madness kahuna when you give him turmeric doesn't make shakiano why because it's not church that's why he doesn't make shakiano to teach that's not the words he says the reason he makes not because the korean can't make it because it's not a good ham no or a similar reason no then we would misunderstand what the mahalaka is the reason it's because it's his mitzvah and it's a special mitzvah once in a lifetime and therefore it's a similar on the father to make the midst to do the mitsubina ben and that's what's warranting the shachiyanu it's the same reason that he makes the bracha pidyna ben always even when the child is an adult because it's his it's his it's his mitzvah okay if who steals [Music] is [Music] just like in teresha where was the midst of opinion i've been placed in parish's boy as a continuation of the etias mitsune and the rationale is yetis because hashem saved misra and he killed him it's night so therefore every jew is to liberate his belongs to the queen which belongs to hashem so in total shabbat you have the same structure most of the sect of sacrum is he leaped over pesach means leap he leaped over on the homes of the jews when he killed the british and he deployed him and he saved him he slow so that's the reason for opinion advance on terror the result and the end of massachusetts is what the mitzvah and us to do pigeon have been just but now we have one more of art putting it at the end of him is connected not just to the concept of fijian event but to the diverting gemara the whole reason the father makes shakhyanu is why is why because it's his mitzvah it's not the sun's mitzvah now we understand why because it's at the end of soccer who saved israel on the father on the father to be poiso because he was the one who got the dentist hashem liberated his child so we liberate our children self-serving we liberate our children in 42 he says if you remember i said earlier that somehow he touches the gemada that because the block is like the united beauty because the block is which means you can do it through ashley and still we don't do it through why we want to do it ourselves like the question is why is it words because hashem did it himself so we also do it ourselves some safe is bringing a similar voice but again the void that you don't do with the sleeve to do it through yourself here in the circle bringing the vert just like hashem did it to the mitzvah is on every father to liberate his child just like hashem liberated his child but may let's have to end the psalm and that's why they did ashamed bring it in we don't do it usually we try to do it ourselves the whole thing is the ponzi scheme because there's no net benefit to anyone except for the guys that are okay now now [Music] on this whole mahalaka niggler we can explain it that we have the end of which is the end of the pidion of yidden saw the ultimate pidgin which is liberation of golis we know what the matter says that the mitzvahs that hashem gives to eden he does himself he tells us to liberate our sons so certainly who is uh he's going to fulfill his mitzvah of piano ben to redeem his child from ghalos so mayla that's the end of that the end of the soccer is the serum of pigeons on you [Laughter] he now addresses a very very big issue yeah you're not not so far from here [Music] the way the theme starts is [Music] he's the one who says you don't just get up and start asking what you want first you express praise of hashem and then you start doubting that's why the structure of sheminastra is the first three black is and then you start first and then he's the one who says when we express the praise to hashem it's in two dimensions the revealed and the transcendent like you're talking to somebody in front of you at a second person you and then we say thank you for sanctifying me no thank you because he sanctified us we address our entire experience of hashem is right here he's right here he's in everything and he fills everything he's right here but we also acknowledge there is the he there's that which completely transcends our mindset our experience our emotions what's called slave of kalaman that's mister it's concealed it's who it's not he commanded us in other words the mitzvah is not only rooted in mammalia it's rooted also in god's transcendent and he gave us an opportunity to sanctify us and he commanded us and connected to uh to him on the level of save right because the mitzvah is from not only so we say and then we shall we'll soon see the difference between and the father what it means spiritually so we understand first you always talk about atta and then you talk about kid yoshano first takayam then as we will see is during english davening is a fundamental component of the jew like it says and the gemara says this is the one who tells us that you have the foot filler available so this was an indian in which he learned and he he dealt with that he was involved in this because we see he's the one who spoke about how you have to darwin this is a great engine it's a central idea so there's the physical fact he can't push it up in the band but then there's the spiritual dimension he got involved in a discussion around the concept of pidyin bend not just physically on a mystical level what's where it comes to pediana ben he gets involved in a discussion in the concept of the ultimate pidna ban of the time when hashem is going to redeem the jewish people from mashiach or as the rabbi puts it here he begins discussing our generations of similarity because this is like we see from the monument the time when hashem is about to redeem his child from gallows rip simulator is discussing this error that's what it means he comes to picking up ben he goes into the sugiya to discuss the time of pity [Music] magazine and he continues in the seoul and the parentheses he says he means he continues in the theme of but in in the parentheses mystically we're talking about the theme of gallows just like by a person is beyond your relationships with others and each sickly and intellectual as an isolated person is not social medicine is the way other people affect you that your interaction with people like love so represents the madrigal which is beyond our relationship to creation beyond the functions we say al-qaeda mitzvah famous is and it relates to the structure of the universe i will teach you wisdom so s [Music] you graft the vine you you you cause an extension so a viable the ghoul itself is going to come it's going to be nemat you could say the jews are not worthy the midst of them worship idols the jews worship idols nonetheless hashem did not consider all the khashbyness of estonia rather he himself liberated them because it was beyond the starships with such structure you could say they're in the same trap that's other statues could say they're not worthy but it came from a place beyond the starches and there it's my child so you overlooked everything and he redeemed it he's the one who's going to initiate and bring the ghoul the cash is cashes not where the ghoul is coming from the kasha is how it plays itself out the method the mechanism through which the gula comes here's a big question the fashion the quality the way it's coming into the world in time and space who gets the benefit or is it who does the mitzvah means man comes through whom through the client through [Applause] the way it's going to come this manners as through asset through middles through those through the structure of the world through us through inaudible beyond anything but the way it plays itself out is that the kamati analya the reason it comes to the client is because he's getting meaning slivers beyond the worlds doesn't say hashem will return the jews he will return with the jews he's getting the valdikan off from the the process is going to happen through him the way it's enclosed in teva in which goes into gullivers and is therefore suffering that's the way the ghoul is going to happen the mutti and all the other it's his unknown it's his i'm not the god of god so it's going to happen through that process for the jewish people it's like a sky for all of our avoiders what do i care if the hammer comes through the main thing is that allah comes so it's fine mata i know the main thing is that knowledge if you want to give me sky for something what's the difference if hashem gives me 100 million dollars right that comes down from heaven or it comes through through a real estate deal of the whole process of the main thing is it's a scar for eating a male like it comes through the cayenne when you get let's say you work for it and you're like no but jews work for mashiach they worked very well thousands of years they worked mainly can come through yeah yeah yeah this is and that's the union of the golden thing one of the nyannam of gold is what let them happen it's coming through spousal you don't have the guillermo mileage tonsils it's not coming through the cayenne which represents the structures of teva that hashem created it's coming directly from the father of venus [Music] is that it's a mitzvah it's that it's what hashem wants it's his commandment he wants there should be a ghoul and he wants it to be the vacant with him in this manner that's the main engine who it's hashem's commandment that's the meaning in england not that life will be good life will be fun life will be kashmir but if you don't feel hashem in the ghoul it is if the indian is you got your money you got your benefits you think it's teva but the main engine is the mitzvah of it the main engine of ghoul is that it's a mitzvah it's what hashem wants it's his commandment the meaning of ghoul is the relationship my you probably understand how fundamental this question is in modern jewish history don't you huh it's the big big debates the big debates about how moshiach is gonna come the big questions that raged in jewish society fifty six seventy eighty years ago the whole process of goula right the whole relationship of israel and heritage role to gull i mean all this hope this whole issue this is the whole question you could say jews jews are having a no they're having a no keyboards goalies they're gathered together there's so many advantages so many miles through the cayenne cos so then it's not guaranteed it's been so many years now take a look fine that's that's a difference about because he makes alpina burn his whole life because it's his mitzvahs because the holy enough comes from him so the way it comes down into the world is also completely from him in other words not through teva the ghoul is going to happen in one moment in one egg suddenly mushrik is going to come not you'll be able to see the structure this is going to happen that's going to happen the world so to speak will naturally usher in the gula it's going to happen a via ben but on the other hand you can only say when you have a physical pleasure in your body so it's going to express itself in the regis of the gut and that's what he says there could be a lot of ups and a lot of downs because you're busy waiting for diplomacy to take place you have to convince this one convince this one but if it's completely one moment one second [Music] it's an aramaic word it says so and even in lush entire even in the lavusham of the world where there's lotion time it's going to come in a tremendous because it's coming from a ban it's coming in now um where is the first place they said that you say even the father says that's the first place that the was established we know the truth in other words even in the world first it's established in thailand as you know that the whole goal is even the shakiano of gula then it comes into the world foreign father when the child becomes a goggle the father is the kid that doesn't yeah now in terms of your question you want to know what is say for yourself and why uh didn't want to teach up similarly for you so the source of it is says that representative who wasn't a murderer he lived in the days of ribyochanan and uh he came to the beach and he wanted to learn safely and rashi says that sephi yohsin is a madrid of khazal it's a list of brices it's a safer of brices on the safe which is basically the book of chronologies the whole yikes of claudius from other mauritian all the way down the generations this is bryce's ghazal on andi rehayaman and the biohanan refused to teach it to him why because rebecca and asked him where he comes from so he said that he was born in lud and he lives in nahardo in bava sir said we don't teach say for you not to people from loot and not the people from narada certainly not to you because you're born in lud and you live in ardor so certainly you're disqualified rashi brings to production one is that he was just he just didn't want to teach it to him so he would just reject him another reason is because they themselves didn't have the lineage there was a question on their issues and the jewish people so he didn't want no he didn't want to teach it to him it's interesting in euro xiaomi you have the same story that the sim lawyer came to the no there's a gift to be innocent and he asked him to teach him a god and he told them i have a tradition not to teach agada not to abbavilli and not to adore me because they're arrogant and they have a little title in them and you're both so what does this mean he's telling rep that you're you're if someone was one of the great the greatest by the way the whole source that we have six hundred and thirty minutes of us in yiddish comes 365 live in like the days of the sun and 248 microsecond negative of a person this is rip somewhere what does it mean that tells them so this is what the levitz is explaining you have to understand it in a much more adele way simliar comes in a word simla in other words connected to the helicopter of trident which is the lavush it's the way is is ainsaif but there's the way tyra is manifested it's millubish it's enclothed in the levushum of negla that's what simlia is that's what he probably means [Music] which is more physical more concrete so much the transcendence the insafe that that's so this this makes sense doesn't want to teach him because your sin is connected to right why this is your father and mother is the father and bin is the mother a god that says it says say this the deepest secrets of kabbalah are hidden in a goddess he doesn't want to teach the traps no it's not shaykh it's like to stay with arizona you know that al-shah used to fall asleep by the sheridan of the reason himself didn't have the answer that pidgin had been is all from the av which is which is beyond the stars now you wanted to know why is why is higher than establishment it's the epiphany but it's still a nakuda it's a seminal point there's no there's no uh slapsticks there's no expansiveness is that first revelation that comes from ayan from hamas from the unconscious and it comes into revelation it's a it's a nikuda and that's why it says in tanya peter klamadal heard from the market that dwells what does he say there that gilly of the eighth cypher is completely is the interface where there's still no development intimacies been already begins more yes certainly midis because michael generally are also much more abstract they're more transcendent right a person when you're in a cognitive state you're isolated you're in your own zone mid this is all about relationships it is about my connection to you so that's the difference av is the indian novella coast that's la mela is beyond the structures that create teva and the structure of the universe so that's the pidna bender that would be from the father and cayenne represents me like it says in in like he brings in the footnotes out of 53 that's why they say in them remember we once learned the whole uh the whole mahalik of the whole in uh you remember why only a queen is allowed to is allowed to deem somebody amitsara and him even if you have the biggest hassle in the town you have to have you have to have a cayenne all the same nakuda because it has to come from the kind of so this already represents a whole different nikola that's already the oil of a lacus the way it comes into a structure the way there's a relationship with the world there's already in the sinus machine forever that's that's the difference between does the shaykh you know of the lisman does that also come from the avi haben la mila mr or no that already comes through that already comes through the cover you were made or something before this is an important order the of the rambam i'm going to ask you to take a look how other 18. you see no other eighteen had eighteen he brings the of the reverse says in trouble he holds like the first iphone what's the first iphone that the mitzvos pity in haben is on the sun not on the father it's just the boy can do it when he's a baby so therefore the father does it for him but it's not a mitzvah of the father now let me tell the phone so he says in 18 you see you say alpidian haben if you applied it yourself you say no leave those why kevin the ek mitzvah elisha because so the divorces because of the main myths is to do it yourself when you're a child your father has to do it so that's why you say i'll pigeonhole because it's not a mitzvah on you you're just doing it so to speak for schlichters of your child so that's when you say al because it's not even your own mitzvah like i'll be your comments when you do it yourself you say leave this says yes he doesn't bring them sukim where discusses the father's mitzvah he only brings the passage in qaeda where it discusses the mitzvahs this would work very geshmak with the explanation of the about the difference of the of the urushami and the beverly that they like to you to show me the mitzvah is the ben it's a mitzvah on the ben not a mitzvah so this works very geshmaq with the pasta with the sukum that the brings so now you're asking why does the father make a shakianu the whole thing doesn't make sense why would the you're right obviously the divorce wouldn't learn like this you as white says al there's different reasons you could say al the divorce gives one reason but many of the police can disagree right you're right you're right why do they wash you can't say this because then why would the father make a shakiano the korean should make us the father makes yeah you would have to give a different reason for al you're right i want you should look at one more order this is this is quite fascinating 30 33 that it's a dover portion that when it comes to pidyna ben the father of the child makes a brah and he makes abraha always in other words it's a dover parashat pasha means it's simple and partial means there's no strings attached there's no conditions this is something that remains their fathers even as her son is 60 years old if the father is alive he has the first right to do the mitzvah was never taken away from him if he doesn't want to do it his son has to do it that's the and there's no strings attached it's not like you'll be worried as long as he's a baby if he girl gets older now comes the chai lip shirt if it wouldn't be the mitzvah of the father it would be the mitzvah of the child the father's justice league then i would say okay of course the client should make shakhiano because the father's not even doing his own mitzvah it's not a mitzvah on him he's doing it for his son so therefore the father should make shakha the kayan who's also part of the mitzvah and he's also getting a noise but you're getting money but since it's what that it's always the father's brother in other words it's a mitzvah and the father so he should make us he's doing the mitzvah he's doing his mitzvah and it's a unique mitzvah that comes every every day or even every month or even every year comes once a lifetime epidemic it's a very unique mitzvah it's like yeah so therefore he should make a rock or maybe since the client is getting han no he should make the block yeah that's how the devil learned to shire and what was the answer the answer is [Music] to do both in other words it's a gathered in a via ben just like having a ben makes the alpina ben because it's his mitzvah and he makes it always he has to make a shakh so the rabbi asked why can they both make shakianus what's the problem what's the problem let them both make shakhayamas he'll make for the mitzvah the mitzvah he's giving he's making for the giving and the korean is making forgetting i'm giving i make sure you know you're receiving him because you're getting hannah so the rabbit says no why you don't make shakhianu when somebody gives you a dollar or somebody gives you twenty dollars you make for a hush of a thing you build a new home you buy a new home so therefore the five slaying is not the sufficient matana to make a shakhim it's significant it's not just five's lawyer not just twenty bucks fifty dollars sixty dollars whatever the number is thirty dollars whatever i think is somewhere between forty fifty dollars sometimes the forty dollars it's the forty dollars of the mitzvah in a ban it's not just forty thousand it's forty dollars that allow this this valdo commitment to happen it's there's no point the cayenne to make a second for that which is tougher to the mitzvah for the physical money that came from the mitzvah it's positive you already made you made it for the mitzvah itself you're going to make that for you're going to make for the physical benefit that comes from it you wanted to make for the itself itself is not enough so he says in 33 that there's but you see is is in the mitzvah who should make this what do you mean by the client the ikea is the money the ram doesn't put it this way the number says the question is because since there's a shakianu in this mitzvah in the mitzvah so this is the rashford makes sense i now we have a question so why doesn't the cayenne make by every madness every time you give a kai and a gift of kahuna you give a kay interim bashar other magnus kahuna the client didn't really do anything it's just hashem gifts it belongs to him the one who gives madness call in a stack of giving but that's not a shakhiano because it's a common mitzvah the cayenne what is he doing he's not involved in doing any mitzvah he he it's just gifted it's like somebody wires in money into your bank account right he didn't do anything the abrasive was mazaki him with these things even though he's not the one doing the mitzvah right it's the father's mitzvah he's not the one who got which but le pal he's part of the mitzvah he he receives the child and he's giving it back to the child to the father who's doing the mitzvah picking up ben together with the cayenne so he's doing something and for this he's making in other words he's not just getting a matana he's not just getting online he's also involved in doing something he's kind of the ben he gives it to the father he helps the father do the mitzvah by taking the child and self-worth in he says it's a small little other so it's easy to gloss over on it but it's it's it would be wrong too and i assume a lot of people just glossed over this odd what's so this is an interesting thing and i think it's worth it pleasure to share with you what's going on here is an interesting safer it's a savior of charles sutruvas from a zeida a sun and an anikal rebecca velazquez was one of the greatest students of the villenegon he was the love of our lodge in lithuania and he built the big village famous village in the yeshiva he passed away i think tough uh 17 18 1821 he had a son-in-law his son-in-law was read i'm sorry i said i said a son and an anika a man his son-in-law and his aunt married his daughter esther raphaim's daughter esther married abhilla freed who was an assistant rosh yeshiva in valarjan together with had a child whose name was rebelli and he was therefore a son of rabillo and of esther who was a grandson of raphael in addition to that whenever freed got wanted to get married who did he marry he married his first cousin his mother the daughter of al-qaima had a brother whose name was and elias fried married the daughter of the ritual of elijah he married his cousin his uncle's daughter so he was a nicole from abhayan village from two ways because his father and mother was the daughter and the son-in-law of the primeval yeah but also beside his wife his wife was a mitchell of a large and his daughter and therefore he became also an assistant rash yeshiva in vallarchy together with his wife was shiva and was a sister receiver together with his father rabitshala together with his father-in-law of elijah rebel freed passed away and then who took over the yeshiva his brother-in-law his brother-in-law another aiden the famous berlin who remained the rashashiva until the closing of allah much a few decades later he was a brother-in-law anyways son-in-law a pretty long hadra this is what ebb is addressing there veer he says a big condition is gemara he asks all the questions that it's asks and some more questions and he time is that the story with representation was a unique story i'll tell you what he says there's a mission if somebody rahman allah had a child and the child passed away child passed away after 30 days but there was no pity not ben so the is eating you have to give the money to the client to redeem the child even though the child is not alive his son died freed this was the story of rip supply the story of similarity was that avi had been makes an alpine but in this case does he make a shakhi or no or maybe the cayenne should make a shakhiano maybe they cut why because the father lost the child how can he say or maybe the kind should make shafiyano watch the kamehameha because the kind didn't lose a child and the korean is getting money so the korean should make a shakian that's the shyla and he explains if the shahid khillah was from the cayenne the korean always made shakhim there wouldn't be a question this should be shaking let them do it now but if it's so you have to know who makes says what's the truth is but if it's the feeling of hannah so then the father didn't have anna here the father didn't have a cemetery here then the kyan should do it now when i read this i didn't understand how he's learning like that chanting the martyr because twice is the one who asks the question and twice says in gemara it says that the father makes two but the question is what happens in this case that's what tracer so he's actually learning that is just explaining the question over there in the gemara it's a very very big but the deb is just saying here in 36 that once you see the rajba and once we explain why there's no two shakiannas because it's all together in the mitzvah so then it's difficult to say in the suggest of the gemara there's one more important nakuda i feel like i have to add take a look in 61 the asia also chose some it looks like an innocent other just a source of some sofa but i want to tell you the background behind this because i'm safer when the rebels said this the second half of the sikh explaining the cmlp siddhas [Applause] was sobbing mamish almost uncontrollably in fact i would encourage all of you take the time listen to the recording of yura finishing base the sikh of the hadrian first of all you'll get a geshmaka havan in the whole the way that ebb explains it the way he asks questions on the slav but especially the last the last piece of the sir he explains the whole indian of rap sim lawyer and the question of pidyin haben it's it's it's incredibly emotional it's unbelievably powerful you also you also see foreign and the rebel was explaining then the two different ways how you could look at the ghoul one way of looking at the ghoul is the bottom line is he said as yidden way it's phrased in the cities it's coming through ishtar shabbos the main thing is the main thing is the enjoyment and the rapper said that and then on flag then the boss you have to ask him everything because basically it's the nations of the world who are giving you permission to be inherited israel and he said then the gula comes kim akim it comes very slowly because it's all alpideric and then he says you have to ask the deus of yenner and there you have to ask this one and that one how to live because basically jews are still under the authority and jurisdiction of the nations of the world that's one way a ghoul is coming and who cares the main thing is the hana and then burst out crying so much he says and he brings the cipher somebody asked us i'm safer if google is a fundamental of you described if it's one of the main principles of your addition says no because it says even if it's not going to come doesn't get destroyed he says we don't serve hashem in order for us to be able to live in a certain country and eat fruits and enjoy the fruits no we serve hashem because we're avde hashem we know that mashiach is going to come because taylor says mushrik is going to come because it's a bait it's a munna it's one of the it's one of the talkers that hashem says in thailand the vehemence of them of course we know that mushrik is going to come but he says what's with the egypt he's he's questioning why the rambam put it as one of the utigamalikram tikkurov is that god exists every word of titus minash he says of course we know mashiach is going to come but that's not the asian sight of everything is that we're here to serve russia says i'm telling you that is crying and he brought that ever brought in the passage of david was running away from afshalam and sadiq brought the orange so david would have the orange so david says no no no go bring back the aaron if hashem wants me he'll bring me back to the to yerushalayim and i'll be with the oran i'm not going to impose myself hashem says i don't want you he name me i'm not here to get paid i'm not here for the i'm here to fulfill my mission i'm here because hashem wants me here so that was said by eden it's part of our way this hashem la payal he says it is an acre not like the sam cipher yiddish kite is the ikea isn't it it is a fundamental principle of but what is it that it's a mitzvah that it's what hashem's hashem wants so therefore beyond the world that's the goal that we're waiting for the gula that's uh that took a look with akash vadish agreement he says it may be all very nice but don't confuse it with google avi that even the girl of the way the ghouler comes in laz man it's all through avinu avinu shibashimaya the liz man hazel also comes from a place that's whatever like he brings from the rambam if you take a turtle so if you struggle and as he says first it's established in base madrish he says that was the job of the jew is to take terra and to transform the whole world into a world of terrorists of mail of a hill from it goes into the halal and the is that that the world is marriage that the etzem gol and hamshacha of the gula in our world the mata master will come from a place of deluge was beyond all the structures beyond all the terror beyond all these thousands all the way down in the most physical and revealed goodness but even because this class is brought to you by the yeshiva.net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot the yeshiva.net slash donate