Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Shnayim Yomi - Tazria-Metzorah - D'var Torah

148 views
Shnayim Yomi avatar
Shnayim Yomi

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

foreign [Music] how are you today we're going to have a special dessert a genius Paradox and Jewish law that will be what we call a brain teaser the mythical was a rabbi who published his Monumental work in 1869. it changed the world it was on the 613 missus what he did was he wrote a mythology on the 63 613 Mistress of great questions great answers fundamentals and stuff like that he wrote on the midst of Mila as well I put out a volume of English taking those ideas and translating it for the English audience he has a famous paradoxical question which we will do today he does not give an answer to this question it's a circular question others answer let's try to use our brains and follow this through step number one we have to know the only time you're allowed to perform a Britney LA on Shabbos is when it is the Eighth Day of the child's life if it's the 9th the 10th 11th day we spoke early in the week you are not allowed to do it if someone circumcises a baby on day nine 10 11 or 12 he is a violator of Shabbos not a lot to do with the Torah gave a special leniency for day eight but cannot do it day nine now to elaborate on that the question becomes we have to understand a second idea that's extremely important is that in order to Violet Chavez one must do a constructive act a destructive Act is not a violation of Shabbos so if someone rips their jacket that's a tear that is not a constructive act you did not biblically violate Chavez if someone cuts someone punches someone in the face and makes them bleed that is not a constructive necessarily a constructive act and therefore it would not be a violation so the question becomes why is it brismila a violation of Shabbos it's cutting a child so the answer becomes that when a child becomes and has a circumcised label onto himself he is now a Jewish child that is considered a constructive act if a child would have a brisbee law that was not Kosher it would be a destructive act and it would not be a violation of Shabbos so again Eighth Day only but it has to be Eighth Day a constructive act if it's a destructive act it would not work rule number two the only person qualified to perform a circumcision is someone who is obligated in the Mitzvah and believes in the Mitzvah that means someone who's a female someone who is not necessarily Jewish some these people cannot perform the personality because they're not obligated in the midsole as well someone who does not believe in them as well cannot perform a personal he doesn't believe in it it will not work so if someone who is not religious performs the breastmila it is invalidated it doesn't work that is Step number two now goes the Memphis Comics wild idea let's say there's a person who we thought was a regular Jew and now he wants to come out publicly that he's irreligious he's anti-judaism there's a baby initial the baby's day nine day 10 day 11. not supposed to perform a prismula at all on this day and this no one's even near the baby because everyone knows you can't do a person Elon Shabbos during one of these added days besides the egg and this person goes over and he decides he is going to do a Bismillah on this day and he walks over to the child takes out the model's knife and performs the Bristol what is going to happen right now is this person considered a violator of Shabbos or not let's go through the idea if we look at the person that he did at brismilah and the child is considered circumcised then what happens is this person now is labeled as a violator of Shabbos day nine day ten he considered a constructive act because the child is now considered circumcised that means constructive if it's a constructive act he's a violator of Shabbos wait a second if he's a violent of Shabbos then he wasn't allowed to perform a Bristol it doesn't work okay she'll say the bridge Mila does not work that makes a lot of sense because he's a violet of Shabbos if the Bristol does not work guess what he did not file a Travis because if he performed an act of cutting a child but he didn't perform a bris Mula that's a destructive act he's no longer considered a labeled a violator Shabbos if he's not a violator of Shabbos then guess what the prismilah becomes effective if he becomes effective he now becomes a violator of Shabbos we are now going in a full circle to get a clear the the person walked over and at this moment in time he was a kosher Jew he went and caught the baby on day nine but he wasn't supposed to do it because he did it he now violated Travis day nine we don't do it since he violated Chavez he now becomes labeled a non-jewish person or a non-religious person as a non-religious person the circumcision becomes invalidated if the circumstance becomes invalidated then he didn't violate Chavez he did a destructive act therefore he becomes once again a crochet Jew okay kosher do now performs the brzmila and we're going now in a full circle the question is what do we do in this case is he considered a kosher Jew and therefore an invalidated potentially brissmullo or reverse leaves it with a paradoxical question if you could think this through in your head while you walk on the show while you're walking back from the show it's a fascinating idea get the pieces in order and you can have a good time with it have a great Travis foreign [Music]