Shnayim Yomi - Re'eh - Shishi - #6 - Rabbi Tzachi Diamond - What Makes Tzedakah Different?

Welcome to parcer a shishi in the middle of the aliyah tells us you should be careful and should be aware that you have to be aware of the the poor person in your midst and you have to give to them and if you don't then there's going to be a sin and a vera credited to you. That seems to be very strange. Any time we fail to do a mitzvah, shouldn't that be a a sin accredited to us? We missed the opportunity of a mitzvah. What's unique in this situation that it's pointed out by it'll be seen as if you missed a mitzvah. you have a and so Mosha Wolfson explains it's a little bit different when you have an intent to do a mitzvah but it's lacking the mitzvah itself is also lacking but when it comes to if you give that dollar to taka even if your mind and heart wasn't fully into it the results of your dollar to taka has the full credit The full dollar goes to help the person you gave it to. And he says a beautiful remed is saddaka. Regardless of what your intent is, you automatically get full credit. And so therefore, in the realm of sudaka, the only way for it to be a is if you don't give it. Because if you give it, even if it's lacking your heart and your mind, you still get full credit.