Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Shnayim Yomi - Mishpatim - Sheni - #2

355 views
Shnayim Yomi avatar
Shnayim Yomi

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] second aliyah of parashat mishpatim in the second aliyah it talks about all the laws that have to do with one another one of the famous ones has to do with when someone damages someone else when someone hits someone else a famous pasuk that says an eye for an eye very known pasuk was very scary people were critics of the torah when they says you're very violent you take an eye for an eye now we know that the torah is not violent at all even when the torah tells you that a person is potentially kayamita for death penalty if you read masechet sanhedrin you'll see it's impossible basically to get a person to be going through the death penalty impossible i'm not going to go through all that now but whoever luna didn't they know what i'm talking about what is i in tahata in an iphone i would you poke the guy's eye because he blinded his uh his friend the gamer absolutely not one of the proofs that we know it's a monetary payment uh in order to compensate the damage is because the man says what happens if a blind person blinds another guy what are you going to take out from him his nose what are you taking that's just an example or someone did not completely blind the person that partially blinded the person so the matter goes through so many examples it's impossible that the torah meant an eye for an eye because it wouldn't apply to all the cases and the torah is eternal and about everyone so it wouldn't work it must be that was monetary another idea on this that the word ein is very loosely translated an eye for an eye but really doesn't mean it means an i instead of an eye the word is used also in akidatis when hashem through them commands abraham to leave its heart alone and he tells him instead of abraham take a ail take a nap he says he took the in the the the the lamb instead as a substitute for his son which means that comes to substitute something that is not the same as the original one the original one was a human being the second one instead of therefore it must be that the second ion is a substitute for the first one and it's not the same nature because tahat is used for something that is different that's another reason why we know it's not a physical eye through violence is a monetary compensation another reason is because it doesn't say in the passoog vela carta you should have said take the eye of this guy instead of the i for the one he he poked for the one he he blinded it says venata you give what mean you give you give an eye for an eye what do you give what is it to give you give something to the person who has been hurt you give the the the the monetary equivalence of what it is to lose an eye to this other person because of the word vena tata the last shot i would like to share with you is the gaun villa the game is beautiful it says the word means what's under the letter ud what's under the letter noon what's these three letters it's money look you take the letters and you'll find what it is it's kesef from here we'll learn that it's a monetary payment and not a violent ad act of removing the eye of the damager [Music] you