Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Rav Shmuel Rozovsky on the 2 Aspects of Zikah {Daf Hashavua Iyun Sugya Nedarim 74a}

87 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

Okay, good morning dear friends. You should be blessed. It's Arab Pes and you're learning of Thank you for hanging in there. The Mishalid discusses a woman who's aime she's waiting to do. And now the question is can the yam can the yam be made for theim of this woman who falls to him? So the garra says it's a three-way mus between and Yeshua and Rabaka whether you could be made for theim of maybe these three when they were in Ben and they were whether they uh maybe they discussed this after the came and they said so after shakus maybe they discussed This by the way once we're on we said over yesterday in Shabas that why does the say that they were and if they were in a lot it would make a difference what difference does make that that they were in furthermore what's the significance so writes in it's also in a footnote that this was the of Now Hmon try to be mat matzah. they had to fast that year on PES and if there's no matzah there's no so in order to rectify the sin of their ancestor there were now what else did he went in the morning says so therefore the were they said Anyway, but these tan also debated whether a shimeas yam could be maf than a darim of the woman who falls to them in ya rabzar who says they could be maf. He holds y zika but the question is there is a tana that holds even if there two in that fall he could be made for the nadarim. So the garra says we're talking about where the one that you could be made for you did to you did to that one and holds. Okay fine. So all the rash yes shakavid pavarski rovski the stipler going they all asked the following question. Even the man only holds but not. So how would Zika explain how you could be made for the nadarum of your wife? Ifa I could understand the ishos right Michael we were discussing earlier whether what allows a husband to be made from the of his wife. Is it the fact that he supports her and in lie of that he can be made for nadarim or is that is it a reality of the ishas? So in this you see that it it seems like it's the it's the reality of the bond that allows him is that's exchange for the livelihood. In any event, the the rashiva asks since the conclusion in yamus is only why would yik explain how you could be made for the nadarim of a of a wife. So let's see if we could get this up on the screen. Um Mhm. I think the there really two aspects of marriage and therefore there are two aspects of zika. There's the relationship, there's the relationship, there's the ishus, the marriage, and there's the kenyan. There's the fact that this woman is user to the whole world. She's your wife and there's an isva to everybody else. That's the ishus element of the marriage. And then there's the kenyan element. You own her. You you have a kenyan. you have uh you have a certain proprietary right and ownership. There's a financial aspect of it. And what uh the rashisha say is that zika therefore has two dimensions to it. It has a dimension of ishus and it has a dimension of kenyan. The ability of a person to be may in a d of a wife that comes from the kenyan not from the ishas and listen the when we say that zika if you hold zika it's man that's only the ishas is man and therefore if somebody lives with her they're not living with a isa they're not living with ana they're living with an but The Kenyan aspect. Everybody says the Kenyan aspect is full-fledged. That would entitle you to be made for the Nadarim. The Nadarim come from the Kenyan. Let's see if I could before we see in Let's see if I could read what it says. He says that the rashish say there's the fact that the woman is koi to you and then there's an a a kurva a a relation between the husband and the wife that's created through the zika. Um the ability of Hafar's Nadarim emanates from the Kenyan aspect emanate from the ishos. So even according to the zikan that's the ishos and the isayasan. But regarding the Kenyan then then the would be here take a look at what says he former even according to the accord being it's worse than a Kenyan. It's it's worse than Kenyan. However, it's worse than that to inherit her because inheriting this is interesting. Inheriting a woman that comes not from the it comes from the isos being tummy to the woman is the bus. Listen carefully. An has is considered more of a than a zuka. A zuka is not there's no basar at all to a zuka. Therefore, a woman who you're zak to, you don't inherit. You can't be mama to her if you're a coen. Because the ability to beame, the ability to that comes from the there are two aspects of zik there's the aspect and there are two aspects aspects of marriage. There's the ishus, the basar, and there's the kenyan. The anus is more of a even than a even than a zuka. We were discussing this that an arous do we do we think that maybe something happened? You see here the saying openly there's more basar by even then as a kuka tum the tum and the yusha are dependent on on isim that's then the zaka is more of a kenyan even than an ara that's amazing because you did a kenyan it's almost counterintuitive somebody were to ask what is and what is what is nuin you would say is the kenyan and nuin is the basar but here the is saying there's more by the ken you wouldn't have expected that because that's the full kenyan but still I guess the kenyion of ishas is stronger by a zuka. Wow. There's a canyon of there's there's a byuka that you don't have by but only regarding things that are connected to look at the unusual status of a zaka. It's a very unusual status regarding Isus. There's less I ishos than Arusa. regarding Kenyan there's almost Kenyan Kenua and therefore you could be made for an that's again this is in the we say um says This is what we explained. Okay, that's the uh small point that I want to share with you this morning and stay tuned for this week's Dasha schedule. Definitely Monday night, whether we do Sunday night or Tuesday night, stay tuned. Okay, have a good day everyone. KV