Q&A In Halacha - Rav Shmuel Felder Shlit"a

Huh? >> Don't kill him. >> [clears throat] >> would like to welcome the answer to today's we have the to answer the shas anybody [snorts] I think last time said that anybody has a sha they was speaking You can ask how to play [music] there's a two part about filler who is a Ben and he's ding and usually on aish where you don't say he doesn't make His committee is not to make the braha on but [clears throat] now he's lords when they didn't make the braha what should he do similarly who got by on a on a tin and his mic is not to say what should he do [clears throat and cough] [clears throat] has a Ashi Ashi came to so the people in told him they said the you said you should make soashi it seems wasn't used to the lion of kadusha we we know we say kadusha and kadush just by government. Some say it's some say because you always say by government by any occasion. So that's why it's he wasn't used to that. So it says the says [clears throat] he didn't know what to do. So he said Mosha whether the kdish is the night's kdish that's why they called the kdish or it's a day kdish or he said any kdish starts with break up anyhow so I'll say a I'll shle it out the oven I'll do it very slow and then the very slow so then I'll see if somebody from the crowd goes starts reaching reaching out for the wine. So I know that the kdish is the priak. If everybody just waiting and sitting there, then I'll realize that the kdish is the the night's kish. They're supposed to be saying nightish. So then I'll know that it doesn't stop. They're supposed to say nightish and that's what he did. And as he finished when he left with it, he saw this old person the shi and he stretched out his hand and he drank. They say he had his own place. That's why he was like treating him. So he said, "Oh, that was his [clears throat] at that mish. That's a gar. That's they bring down says that when it says it means they bring down. So they say the made a special thing that should come down. He shouldn't be embarrassed doesn't know how to make. So sent him special to save from the that's the means if he wouldn't have had the riot that the kdish is just he would have made the whole kesh with them by day what do you mean it's his meaning was not to make the whole kish by day just he thought maybe that's their meaning so you see black and white from the even though your meaning is not to do such a to them and he gets to do it. You have a right to do it to them which [clears throat] he shows. What do you mean? He yelled that you're not allowed. He yelled you're not. So he says that make he thought he wants to say that he thought that they didn't make kdish by night. They miss kdish by night. Allah is you don't make kdish by night. So then you make the whole kdish by day. But that's what he wasn't sure his fact that they need the whole kdish because they didn't make kish at night. They didn't make kdish at night. If they need the kdish to make that's what because he says then there's nothing to learn from this. What what do you learn from the story without anything? Maybe the but the rift brings down the whole. So it must be that you learned something somear must be that he was allowed to make the k by day even though the you don't make so there's a from the inside and he has a case like this you the person and he's from he only says when you finish he doesn't say and he came to and the the place they they say and they were him that he should be the [clears throat] and seems he couldn't refuse [clears throat] so uh so he said the nicer nicer it was and nice it was that he made the and he was mighty and somebody came up to him and tell him you're a Ben what did you do making it was a bra that you made and you weren't you made everybody go home without the bra because you're can't be somebody with a that's [clears throat] so so so he had a right to do it and brings down That's you see he was ready to make a great day for them then the whole and he says is so he's called so he's to make a so it's not and they can be so he says it's black and white since even though You hold your man. But as long as you can make and >> isn't also even if you hold it you don't make a bra but the makes the broccol I I can't >> the the the of the And the made and no one else made the brain >> going make a say that's a bit >> okay down seems different That's that's riot that's he says it's no riot our case that we're talking about we have the same but the press is making he's from he wants to make the hollow [clears throat] and his men is that he only makes the case that he says that he was being made to the call it seems that men and the same thing he was going to be. So then he might since they have them meaning they do it so and he has a dinner. So he's allowed to make the outside but in that case as far as I know when the gets up to say the he's not being s everybody makes themselves unless somebody goes up to him and he says to him but I'm saying does not so complain he's not being anybody so doesn't pass that he should have to make the So there's no right from the in our case that has a right to make and that's the is also when he speaks out this thing he says even right to make it so [clears throat] he talks about a case that person his meaning is to say [clears throat] not to say hello the night of pes and he's in a shul that they say hello if right so he talks about is he allowed to say hello you could say but is he allowed to say the according to him as many he doesn't make that he's he's made I I think it's akin who says how I think anyway. So he's a he doesn't so so says that if it's not it's not a problem. He doesn't have to say it. Nobody's going to know. But he says to go out. Everybody's saying it. He's going to leave. That's he's not allowed to do that. That's all. Yes. Are you doing what he wants? That's what he said. But he says, [clears throat] he says, but the nobody's going to know if you're making a so say the without the but he says let's say it's going to be that you're not making the or he says he says and he makes the on the night of even though it's not his and he says where do you get such a thing? He can make the braha. So he says he made was ready to make the whole of the [clears throat] people by day even though he felt that's not you don't do that he never did that so he says she says what you know you're allowed to make the that's what he says they're saying the person also pays since [clears throat] if he's not going to make the it's so it's not a he's not so so he didn't just like said and you have to keep them the same and you have to keep them and even to make a Because the who said you can't make a prophet same said that you can't make a said you can make a prophet to make a that's says >> what he's make the prophet it's not a to make the misha says you of making The is not a [clears throat] making his name. So it comes out a very big mouth for you to make the is not because you have to you have so even in case you're not being also make the really I think the [clears throat and cough] means that request to do what he needs [cough] and he [clears throat] says is that is one. So that person is missing a certain mitzvah or a certain brother. So it's like you're missing because you're one with him. So you is going to be missing. So me you could say that's only if you could say your is going to be missing. But if you hold you don't even say it. He has a minute to say it. You hope you don't have to say it. You don't you don't say it. So doesn't make sense to say that your mish is going to be missing something that you hold that you [clears throat] don't even say it. So that's what said how could he do it? understood was according to that it's only the case his meaning is he doesn't say in dominion a lot of places most of the places to say and he came to a place they say and uh and they him to so so he brings then he brings from [clears throat] the he should say it not anybody with the from there from that he helped this you state of emotion. So I think a lot of the seems also goes with the but people it's not you're allowed to say the you do >> you try to avoid being >> yeah why should you get into them but if they ask him I mean they're and and I have a question. Why isn't he daming? Every time he diamonds, all of a sudden it's the first time he said no. So that's obvious. >> Everyone knows two different >> every two different [clears throat] say everybody knows. He don't say that >> same was given to the Spanish. So it would be all the case is like this. It would be the one thing and then between [clears throat] the night of sphere. Where's Mr. Knight of Spir and now we have to get the sphere. >> Mr. Knight of Spir missed the night of >> spir asking a sh let's say a person missed the night of so now he can't count his brother. So every night he asks the next person next to him and he might see him. And [clears throat] now they asked him go up to lead. Now he's going to be very embarrassed that he missed the night of spirit. That's true. But it's not that's not going to make a with him. Why did you miss the night of spirit? They might he might feel bad, but that's nothing to do with. So he can't make rub but he can ask somebody that's what they did in nature. So let's say a rub for the rub. So the rub should ask one of the people in the in the thing stand next. You don't have to stand next. When I make the brocc you'll be nice. should make >> can one make can one make a forid that doesn't know how to make a because it's to eat without a braha and the person doesn't know how to make a braha so could you make the shame for that e and similarly can one make a for so what's a sh the person's not going to be able to eat unless you make the so you should know what the person shouldn't I don't see the shining but there's often not like that there's a few places one first place down it says like this a person that's not eating himself you can't make other people he says of Even today explains but he says any you can't be if you're not eating you can't make it broken for somebody else I he says no it's not no [clears throat] mitzvah he's not going to have the mitzvah it's like you If you want to eat, you have to make a mark. He can't say that he's missing the because if he doesn't eat he doesn't need the so he's not missing the only time it's past says there's no back says back to that and I'll explain the meditation that's a different thing and and even though and Mish says even more not only your own even the is also he says he could be of the other kid also it seems that even though there's no father but there's a anytime you're of anybody can't make is not that matter different person. He says they say also he can't make a brotherhood. There's no arguments. What was the question again? >> This he is not going to make a brother and he's going to >> he doesn't know. Let's say he is a he's just becoming firm. He doesn't know how to make. So maybe at a person that knows how to make you're not teaching him to make. So then you want to say there's no but you're talking about a person that doesn't know how to make a just like a kid doesn't know how to make a bra. You have a right to make a bra for the kid. So the person doesn't know he's like a kid. So you should be able to make the him worse than the kid that says you make a [clears throat] such a thing as a grownup. >> Why not? [clears throat] I would think if you as me I would say it's supposed to be a kid to make a brother what do you say >> not your son >> no but Mishu says cotton even your cotton it could make the make the because even though you're not but also that's why I would say look you can say but says black and white and I like that speaks sound when it says says it can't be mighty he says even even the person attempt to make the bra also they can't And the says where does he get such a if he doesn't know how to make the rabb he says he says it's not even he doesn't have to say the reason it's so py anybody anybody can figure out the reason that he says that's push um he doesn't explain it. So one thing maybe you could say like you're saying that how is it especially in that they made care people didn't know how to make it wasn't so they never made it to so once there's no make I Right? There's a mitzvah and everything. Okay. So, you'll have to figure out other ways how to teach him how to make a the different ways of English and start off and then teach him. But maybe the maybe you can say that or you can say >> can't teach him the brother. You can't teach him how to say the >> well at the shisp. Why why can't you make the prophet to him just like but you could teach him to speak to you teach him to teach you teach him. Yeah, but for the you're allowed to say the prophet but still for the go you can't say the prophet wasn't so one way you could say you could say interesting thing he says in this case that it says that you make the he says let's say somebody else is listening to that he can't be with that because since the is a person That's exha [clears throat] and he talks about that he the person makes his own savior and then then he goes to other people's stomach that don't know how to make. So says like this can't make themselves say word by word and says they'll answer him. It's not a why says that even it's a teach that doesn't know how to make a prophet word by word and say and because you're allowed to teach a god also that's what he says and he says inhib that you can't make a bra for the [clears throat] not they're talking about you making for them and they wanted to be the came here to teach them how to make the teach so it's important black and white and even for that you should teach a but it's but you're allowed [clears throat] to do it but to be mighty In fact, you can't be my one of the two swars we said that [clears throat] come on that's what it's so going back to the sh could you make a brother somebody that can't make a brother himself and he might see him the answer is no there's no what you can do is [clears throat] you can say word by word say after me he says he do and that you do then make >> and same thing cotton because most of you say now it says that it says that you can say and it says so that's if it's a you can make you don't have to say word by word you can say the whole you can say the words one another does have to be start but it's a exactly this talks about what age is wants to say that once the person taught teaching the kid to make [clears throat] that's called usually >> you know let's say you never teach him how to make the papa come to the You want to show up where the kid is and make the pro that I saw an interesting thing like this that this person he became a boua but his wife didn't want to go along with him [clears throat] but she she wasn't happy but she she said, "Leave me out. You You could do whatever you want, but leave me out." So, you know, he said, "What about making I'm not I told you leave me out." [clears throat] So, he said, "Well, what? Let's say you don't have to make the I'll make the braha and you'll just listen. You by listening you'll be okay that I don't mind if I don't have to make but the person you can't make it for somebody else." That's what we just said. You can't make a bra. And to used to say she doesn't mind her. The only way she'll mask him is if he makes the so so what he did always every time she used to eat. He used to eat with her and he used to make the and eat and then and then she was a very simple solution that he's going to dab in the morning and she wants to go eat breakfast and then go to work. So, so, so now what should he do? Why should he do it? Why should he do it? Can you think of any? So, he says says and take one crumb. She's she used to not wash for bread. She used to pray. Take one crumb and you wash. She's supposed to wash you and listen with his eyes. Take one of them make and she'll listen to she'll be to make you cry. So that says with you and then she'll be able to eat the deal. No problem. But the sh but he said but I'm before doning he said but to eat one crumb even if your whole team is but to eat one crumb in this case that the whole reason you're doing it can eat that one >> what would be in case he couldn't >> what do you think in case he couldn't eat that that he can't make a profit can't she won't be able to be mighty that's the whole deal is saying she can't be mighty even if he says She's not >> no to be somebody with you could do it. >> But she's not going to get the middle. She's not going to get the even if he makes it for her. She's not without there's no den. So it's he made a she ate without a brother. So it didn't there's no no gain. It's very important. It's very important that this thing even the person can't make the braha and if you're not going to make the brah with him he's going to eat without a braha. [clears throat] You can't be there's no den. You can't be with him. So making the him is like is like the without there's no mind making the sh if he's providing the food. >> He's not providing food. She bought the food. He she took care of the house. You didn't make it anyway. >> What? >> No. No. What's the problem making? >> First of all, if she makes a chocolate if somebody remains somebody in Israel, there's no because of that. No, but you're asking a man noticed how they're technical. >> Yeah, but is that is missing something is not missing anything because you can't there's nothing that's that's black and white. You can't even though you're right for somebody. Could you bench for somebody? He's missing benching. >> Can you bench for he wants to shing? That's a shout. What I'm saying is the question because he shouldn't believe that person asked him. But now what's going to be with benching? I can't bench. So my eigh is before they eat meal and then I eat the meal before. >> That was a sh that was a sh in other words to save a person from not going away without the are you allowed to eat before and uh he goes back and forth and he said [snorts] he he wants it. He wants to say it's like just like he's allowed to eat. If a person's sick, he's allowed to eat the sha because he's not eating. That's not her. He's eating to save a person from going away without he is >> nice if somebody says I'm not eating maybe I'll eat are you allowed to eat >> that's a big sh >> can one make a oh he did I'm sorry. Can one allow a cotton to say the the name of hem when he's practicing? Can he say multiple times just because he's practicing when he'll get aliyah? And similar can he practice the answer. So says like this is teaching he's not even though it's the name of the prophet to themselves. So explains it says when the Reb is teaching them so things [clears throat] what does it mean he's teaching them the it's not the not when not when it's not the time to make the teaching whatever That's what he says. So you're allowed to make the with them and they're allowed to say the that's so so that when you teach the child you learn to teach him with a shame and everything is what's the what's the it's talking about a kid that he just started learning to make products you're going to start teaching him with the word hashem will never learn how to make. Here we're talking about who who do you teach the how old is the child when he at least 12 he's 12 he never [clears throat] made before in his lifetime he he knows all the he knows you say he knows so so he he's knows that when he makes when he gets to that he has to say the so he might make a mistake again but I'm saying that's not the So there's a he's talking about when you learn the gamar if you let us say the you say thee says that even the he says [clears throat] saying near a cloud Dr. Sh says that we have to know They keep on teaching over and over. So then they're going to get used to it. They're going to say it the wrong way. That's what is talking about says even start with Islam you have to teach you to teach him over and over again with thee because if you're going to teach him without he's going to get so used to saying and he makes the he'll say the same thing why it says which doesn't know it says said but says in the prophets in the he says how often does a person learn over the so many times that he gets used to saying it with that get and how often do the come back is black and white and a person that over and over you teach him the so that he's going to get used to saying that they have right that he shouldn't You have a right to teach him without but I think is no for >> what he say >> I can't >> he says they're teaching him the tune not necessarily a lot of times they get nervous so they they want them >> they teach him the rockets also as But so no but I think it's all right for because talking about the teaching present prophet might all these things keep on teaching. So he's getting used to that. So then when he's going to make the bras, nobody's around. He's making the he just get out of even though in the central he knows he's supposed to say but he's going to do what and not everybody makes so much and nobody's around to correct it. would that's not [clears throat] what's the the kid's going to get up and say the and he's going to start saying is he going to go very well or no right away everybody's going to screaming so right away he'll catch himself so so he's not going to end up he's going to make a known as wrong brother he's going to make the right bra so so what's what do is that he's going to say here. There's no way because he'll fix him up. So there's no what's the only get a little embarrassed and his father will get embarrassed and the grandfather will get embarrassed [snorts] and his family will get embarrassed. That's that's nothing to do with rem that's what I would think. >> The rule of the sh is no one's allowed to correct. Only the rabbi's allowed to correct. >> You should go to a different sh [laughter] >> but that's assuming that the sh is going to correct him. >> I think uh so I found afterwards I looked around. That's why I felt when we start it's like a liqu and he brings from that you can't teach the kid and the thing and I once he said the same thing I didn't ask him the reason but he said also but the interesting thing that he brings from it's a kid that stutters at your lab. That's what he said because when he stutters he's going to make a mistake and you start fixing him the whole he's you mess him up with the whole he's going to keep on studying the whole thing and it's going to get embarrassed it's not embarrassed >> it's not it's every sec every second word he's stud somebody wants somebody tell me a had the England and Vice England he had his son was getting mitzvah and he had they had a shy writing shing it's complicated but this person was a his own right yeah the person's left he came out but it was very close to his family was concerned. Uh told him you know my son [clears throat] can and then he asked him the shila. So she said you hear the shila tell me they told them all the back and forth and I said I had the shila I have to think about it. I have to think about it. I'll get back to you. He says no was he called him up first answer right away. So anyway, few minutes before left tension, he gets a call, he should put it on his left leg because he arriving. >> He's arriving. Well, it was a little he didn't come out. It was a few minutes before left. He's not going to start arguing, right? Okay. Then it was Shabas and then it was Sunday. So they put it on. He put it on his left hand and that says few years later. He was pirate. He was talking to about something. Then he started putting out the tone and he reminded himself of he says you know he said I know your kid because you always used to bring him. I see he had a problem with stuttering. Had a problem with stuttering. I was afraid that since he has a problem of stuttering that he's going to also put his tongue on his right the right hand like different he's going to be different two things from somebody else he's going to be [snorts] very self-conscious and make it feel weird it's not good for the kid it's not good for the kid so I had to be maf with all the stubb and everything maybe he should put on his right but I knew you going to call tell you right away I'll call you back you're going to start arguing and everything. So I make sure to call you back a few weeks at this. So he said to him anyway he went home to this kind 16 I don't know how old said now let me ask you something remember that we asked [snorts] them we knew about which you should put it on he said what what were you expecting [snorts and clears throat] he says I don't know t one thing I tell you I dominating with all my heart that should say I should put on left hand because I don't want to be different than some people. >> Wow. So not the money it's some interesting thing they got covered up that baby said that if the kids start you know there's different shas about cover that you can make a brother this is let's say the lady had a baby before she got married and she never told her husband and now she gets married she never she it's a happy marriage now she find they had their first baby point. So if the husband finds out she hadn't shown before, it's a big sh This is what I'm talking about. Maybe she doesn't have the tab and maybe there's covered up maybe covered up. So a very interesting thing [clears throat] he had a different case there had a case that the couple they had a miscarriage and they didn't want to tell their parents parents are different people very worrisome people and everything they they they wouldn't feel good and so they didn't tell their parents and then after that the first baby was a baby boy first making this a baby boy. They're not going to make a pigeon out of bed. So the parents going to say, "Why didn't you make a pigeon then?" You say, "Well, we're scared." What? And you didn't tell us. You didn't What? How could you? They hid it from us. What's wrong with being a very big problem? So, what's going to be with the C-section? >> What? >> Oh, it's a C-section. [cough and clears throat] Awesome. Thank you. >> For sure. It's even worse. Anyway, that was a sh. So, so he interesting thing. He is not a shadow. It's just a shing that he gave very interesting. One thing he says, "Have a cotton bear." That's he brings down. Have a cotton beer and tell the cotton you want to be. That's one other says also interesting. He says, "Make the pigeon pen and have in mind that you're being played at the oldest cayenne in the world that never had a pigeon pen. He played two. Why? Take a different he two. He played on a child. >> I don't understand. >> Take take a child that same dance. Have a mind this thing. >> But they want to do their own. >> The first answer. >> What? Okay, I guess I'll finish it off. Anyway, that's his two answers. I mean, there was a big turmo everybody agreed with the cases. >> What about practicing the ladies? No traffic says show that the tire should be sad. Even if you don't know what they say if somebody This is a new Shiloh. Didn't happen 10 years ago. We didn't have these sh if somebody ordered a Uber driver to come from so he can leave to the airport this run to the catch the flight this year. So they ordered the Uber driver they come he came by Shabas and they and it turned out that this Uber driver was a Eid and for when he came he drove on Shabas what what's what should they do the question is an assumption that if it would be a no problem the truth is even a guy is a Um, so the guy the guy with Julian's driving on Shabas that you should he should be there after 72. You're making a guy drive on Shabas. >> The guy could have drove me a Friday. >> Oh, so you're saying the gaz that you're making the guy drive for you on Shabas. The guy could have drove out of Shabas, parked his car right out of your house and sleep in the car. That's like you're making it do it for you. Um I have a book and he talks about this sha and he says that he's going to come there shabas. He's not going to spend all chabas there. He's going to lose it till day work. He says, [clears throat] "So that's not cool." The only time you say is some some way within maybe it's hard for the person, but it has to be something normal. It's not normal. That's not a >> could drop off the car and walk this house. I mean, it's not my chef how he >> he wants to work the whole shop. >> That's his problem. >> I guess so. It's not the mom. So, you know what they say? Let's say you have a a carriage with a with a baby in the carriage and and you you you came to the hotel that's on 15th floor. So you slept up the carriage with the baby 15 miles in Michigan but there's a guy there. So you make up with them before you say you know what I'll give you $15 every time I want to go to my apartment. You have a choice. Either you carry the carriage up to 15 times. I'm just paying you $15 now. Either you carry the carriage up to 15 times or if you want you go to the elevator. Whatever. What's easier [laughter] to say that's not that has to be that has choice that makes it might be harder for him. But I think that no normal person would do that's not enough. So that was saying the same thing. It's not a D that he should stay there the whole shots and lose a day's work because let's say he says it's possible. >> But I think it could be but Uber driver is a little bit different because the way Uber drivers work if a Uber driver is in the neighborhood >> let's say he's in the neighborhood they tag him to go. >> It's not like they order a driver from Friday and say your house is 72. That's >> okay. >> Okay. If it was right in front of your house from the also the same thing that that make up with the driver that he should be there [clears throat] and he's going to come you have to be there on drive. Now it's interesting here that they bring down from two cases. First of all, you have a car that you want to go suffer right after. So he says it and they have another thing they said from you have a cleaning lady. You made a sa you want to clean a lady [clears throat] start right after shamas. So you make up right after shamish. So they bring down both cases. It's part both cases the same thing. I once answered the demon silent myself as a person. I asked him not and I asked him the cleaning lady. Could you do with the farm? He said no because he has to come and sh and I asked him what's with the cleaning lady. He said yeah no problem. So he said what isn't it the same thing? What's the difference? So he said no difference. He said buy the car. He you want him to bring a car. Bringing a car is so telling him have the car there 72 minutes a minute 72. You were telling him to do a mah bringing a car in. He said cleaning lady there's no you're not telling the cleaning lady to do you clean the lady bring yourself there. She wants to bring with the car or something. ask him again. But you're not you're not telling the guy to do any. You're saying to yourself that's what he >> So if we tweak the shot a little bit then we say they told him to come right after this man and there's enough minutes that he could come that it's possible for the Uber driver to come when he's 3 miles away or whatever. One second. If it's a not that's if it's and is a few minutes away then it's not a but that's the shi but now the sh is let's say let's say not say it's the y not you didn't even know you see you go outside and you see a taxi and there and he was a y and he came from a half an hour away and everything So are you allowed to have are you allowed to use the taxi or you have active wage? So, so [clears throat] there's a law like this that does something for you on Shabas because for you not only you never tell him but you can't have either afraid you're going to tell him so because you might tell so what's the right two reasons first of Well, you're not going to tell him it's another reason because even if you tell him he's a he's not going to listen to you. So there's no desire. So that's why doesn't he can't have a but you could have aid doesn't you could have there's no but what's with the what's you could say as a did like a guy. But a person that's not like a maybe there is a doesn't go into the shelving of that person won't be [cough] only so that something like you can't set up that he should come even and if he does you always have to wait >> as could you make up for the guy to drive your car. >> Come to my house at 72 and drive my car. >> That would be nicer. >> That would be nice. But you still don't want to mean by a good company and drive my car to the airport. >> You're saying good. >> Okay. >> You should when you advertise this right there, put it in the paper together. >> Yeah. say loud enough for us in the recordings. >> Well, you should say just brought the >> What's the deal between said that the elevators have it's so complicated. >> Can one use frozen forn? And if yes, what happens if the frozen kal is in the freezer and it's mixed with other frozen stuff and to get to it, you have to do a little bit digging. There's a primal talks about you don't eat and the only other bread you have is use that for. So handles it and he handles this thing but there's certain cases I'll say he handles the don't have anything else but the sh is this frozen the same as he brings them from that per that he brings down that it's that if it's so frozen that won't be able to eat it that so you can't use it for [clears throat] so he says but unless that he's going to planning on lending his so that by the time she's still before benching it'll be defrosted then he can use it says if not the lady also has a glove He says that you have to be even if you don't have to be has to be he says it's going to defrost but that he's eating it won't be defrosted it's not called so he says should be not he wants to say that that since you could even though you're not leaving that's That's good enough. That is considered it's right and also says to you says you could put it next to the heat and everything. So it'll be right. Some say you could cut it even if it's frozen. you could cut it up and so maybe it seems it's this thing frozen in the case that you're not leaning on. It's I guess so that's the only you have you can do it. You want another royal say I could cut it off. I can come up all these >> and that's a you're saying you know I would have also thought like that it was it was to me that so I guess it's a person should be >> I don't think he let's say he's going to be digging already in the freezer if he has can he go digging in the freezer sh let's say let's They don't have a different you can use it. You can descend. It's a sh now we're taking it out of the freezer. You have to worry about anything when you take it out of the freezer. So there could be two possible problems. One of the player because there's a whole mixture. So the is [clears throat] if it's so if you're doing it for so let's say you want to take it out 3 hours before remember so then that's one you have to make sure >> that's called >> that's called if you're not going to eat it >> it's time to be frozen >> it's a If if if it takes let's say a half an hour to do everybody basically is money you have to take it out a half an hour but let's say it takes a half an hour to fill and you didn't you're not going to be around you're going to so you want to take it out two hours before because you're not going to have time that this not >> it takes two hours to >> doesn't it takes two hours before that but it takes an hour to you want to take it out in the middle of the day that's one thing you have to worry about coming you have to Make sure there's nothing. And then there's a different shing away. >> You're not taking a break. Moving away is not just that. So then you have to figure out what things are. absolutely >> if somebody wants to use concentrated made pers in order to make misinus roll the way is concentrate made pers works he has 20% real apple juice and the rest 80% is water and he uses that to make mazernus rolls can he do that >> so I think to answer this question first we have to go about what what the Indian Z is the yellow to this. Now, now we know that if you want a penny, you want to buy any bread that's made by the even though you look high and low, you won't find bread that's beside this bread. I'm not talking about of course you won't find that I'm talking about the bread that's made from you won't find [clears throat] the sea is by the time you don't have so hard to figure out how can only figure it out such a discovery [clears throat] >> just figure out things that go figure out that >> the answer is that it was a bris and whoever want the answer is because if a guy wants to eat cake if he wants to eat bread what's he need bread that has too much so so what's in [clears throat] discover is because a person a lot of times he doesn't want to wash bench takes time to wash bench and everything so so what are you going to do you want to have a good breakfast I don't want to eat cake for breakfast it's not healthy so what do you do you want to have a good breakfast but bread and eggs and everything and you don't want to eat cake and you want to wash and and you don't want to wash and you don't want to bench. So, so you're stuck. You're stunned. So, they made an invention at you could have [clears throat] your bread for breakfast, healthy breakfast and still you don't have to wash your ve how can you do such a thing? Oh, that's invention. It's maz. But what what is why what makes it misus? What makes Oh, you say what maz is? was it's not the death of the but they're using instead of bread it's not so so is based on the [clears throat] [cough] he handles what's the pass of the why don't you have to make a pass of the he say the first he wants to say that Since bread has to have water. So bread without water doesn't have a sh only it only has a shas if it has water and then they say it goes more even if it's right may payers and meat water is bottled in the right payers. So it doesn't have water. So bread without even rightly pairs is is not impossible because the people they don't these type of things it's too sweet and everything that's wants to say even though has another but he never back up from his first it's right make pis that can't be pass needs water right make pis so he never backs up so that's that's kind of sense so if you have a bread that's right make pears even though it tastes tastes like bread doesn't matter it's not bread that's now brings out and he doesn't speak up but he brings out and when he say he says And what's the [clears throat] taste of it from many many [clears throat] has to be and so if a person goes with the no nothing to talk about you don't of this environment. But what's the factory? The factory says, okay, it's true. But nice does say such a thing. It's a [clears throat] time to bench. They don't have time to wash. What are they going to do? So you could be a right to be last night was very big. That's that's >> I'm sorry. >> No, even when if you eat suda. >> So then even if you eat chocolate cake that doesn't help that talking about making suda that's don't okay that's not done. Now, now the talk about that even if you want to be deal with this is two problems with the Zitus practice rolls. First problem is that the way they do it today is not like that and it was you have 100% what they take is concentrate because they ship from other places the Jews they're not shipped. So they take out the water, they ship their concentrate and then you wear the company has the water. So, so you can't tell me that it's rain payers if 80% is water and 20% is concentrate and this says like and says that even according to not have the not my parents that's the second thing I'm talking about that even if you're going to say that you make it pure but the holy is if you're not but the bread in the world people they put they make a meal out of it it's like regular bread so even the last time would be mas that's a ta years ago maybe from 30 40 years ago when I look into the sha so I called up the mashia at this factory I don't remember factory he was. I don't remember name. I called him up. I said, "You give the on the road." He says, "Yeah." I said, "I don't understand you." I said, "But I understand. First of all, they make it from concentrate today." I said, will say if it's from concentrated has no that's the first thing and the second thing I said well it's bread in the thing people are they use it for so has nothing less tire that's the two question I guess so the first thing he must have been a very old man because he says look handc. So he told me when he became a thing he said he had the shadow because they made it from concentrate. He said he is the satisenstein the sail the puppy fire and they all told me he hugely no concentrate is the same thing as pure because concentrate makes it back so they know so he says so to me. >> So then I said, "Okay, [clears throat] so how could he say if a person eats it for he has to make?" So I said, "Well, how can you write on?" He says, "No, if you eat it like a piece of cake, you take it with a coffee." So we have a rag right if you take short cake also after it. So what's what's the problem? That was his answer. The first answer says anyway [clears throat] that's that's the story and it's not it's like a very but I just want to say um I saw him he has a troop but they person that how could give a hinus on the roles that they give in the airplane that if you make for it's not uh it's not so so he said the rolls on the shita is the rolls on the plane it's a tiny little row and the main meal is the other thing it's not called it's not called so if you that the whole is a hold on the plane is not a lemon if the person makes sandwiches and all these things for the mos I might say >> and the rules are concentrated from the >> I did not think basically and I did not make sense. You could say you could argue that of course you can argue okay but [snorts] that's that's the short of the story. So I don't think it's correct this time >> but I just want to say >> should not make a person can make a misin and everybody payers. No, only the factory that made bread. They make both bread and bread. But [clears throat] it was kind of mixed up. Kind mixed up. So they said they have no way of knowing the difference. They say not you don't taste the difference. I just want to say but but but the whole sh of and everything is based on what the person is a shak that was a shak that she didn't have to bench a person has to understand that the you need a not that you shouldn't have to bench but you should have a that you should be able to bench And it says says everybody knows says that it's a person benches and [cough] person buys insurance all different things and he can buy insurance for free by pening and [clears throat] he doesn't do it if it's very hard to understand a person that doesn't I know a person that he told me his mother she washed is three times a day to be able to bench three times a day benching all the everything's benching that's sit down when he was getting he got some shish from so he called said that he could sit in he could sit in so he sat all day and anybody that had a problem whatever problems kids any anything you think of sickness the answer was bench from a bench bench from a bench that was something and once he said rasha came with his wife and he had a problem I do not remember what the problem was and said bench bench so the rasha looked at him like me telling intervention you know so my kid said was a big guy he had a problem of memory and the health story and he says the pen that's one second I know somebody he's not around anymore but but years ago somebody from Lakewood years ago his wife he he he got sick he got sick because he got sick he get couldn't work anymore and then this kid started going up and there so it's three things he didn't know what to do so he made a special decide he's going to they ask him what should he do what should he do so made a special thing special what should he do he told the whole thing and said I said to you pen the pen. He was very disappointed. He thought tell him such that that's what he came to tell him to penetrate. He was very disappointed. He decided he's going to go to he went he didn't tell that he went to he went to he told the whole thing says what what does want with me what said yeah what's bench bench then third thing I know this my society told me that his wife got sick and everything and she went to doctors with serious sickness doctors said they'll do treatments and everything they don't know if she's going to be successful but she'll never have children anymore and then again so they went through Kineski said she should [clears throat] start washing and bench from the bench and bench from the bench I think the husband also should do it I don't know so anyway way they did it and were confident they did it nice and successful. They have last I know they had four kids maybe I got more but everybody should have a good time to say that they make them with Zus bread people like Rwab can't split the meal because we can't like anybody want copies of available soon you I don't have a flashback. >> Oh, you have a sh Um, yeah. I'm going to try to get it off the the machine. >> Any any shaking? >> No, no, no, no. It's fine. Don't worry. >> I didn't see you shaking, but your foot was next. >> Worried that you might shake. You ever been great?