0:00 / 0:00
Shattering Stereotypes - Rabbi David Kaplan
1,939 views
Follow us: https://www.hidabroot.com https://www.youtube.com/@Hidabrootcom https://www.instagram.com/hidabroot_global https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbCYZjl1CYoa4ulQIK2q For more inspiring content: @Hidabrootcom
Categories:Torah
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
so the there's Gorn Yuma well-known
Gomorrah the Quarren starts out the
warrant says Totoro bono the word says
kiddie Tanya we have to soshim Lokesh
Lokesh a mere gotcha hey Shan Shan I am
me so here are your cloth they you
should be responsible that I caught his
work whose name a shame shame should
become beloved through you she hate
Karev is Shawna Amish Amish Tommy to her
calm him you should learn kamesh mishter
you should learn learn by tommy tommy
bahama so matter no Binaca Seema brios
and you should be pleasant when it comes
to people all people you have to be
treat them pleasantly mob real so morose
all of what do people say when they
encounter a bento or somebody who
represents taurah somebody who comes
across as a pleasant person ashtray Aviv
shalida Torah Ashley Rachel in doTERRA
fortunate is his father taught him to
her fortunate are the brios they had for
Tara's Rebane would his Rebbe autumn
tour oh boy I am lab Rios and then they
conclude Boylan boy is a GU Mauro word
it's not just the crafts he heard from
years ad when he was sitting down boy is
actually a word : lab real shallow
lambda Torah
woe to people who didn't eat learn Torah
tonisha lammeter abou common acid drop
of Kalamazoo cotton myself look how
pleasant he is about me Karev is
Sean and Michelle Mitch to meet her
found somebody learned it saboteur oh
they ain't my so my tone of a moon I
have the in deeper open atmospheres
Mabrey Osama solo What did he say about
somebody who represents story represents
yudish guy and does not come across the
way a Ventura should so they say oh Lola
flow nischala mater oh boy they that he
learned Torah I lo love in Chile motor
oil all the rubbish like the Torah and
so on
so forth the career tells us that people
intuitively or instinctively relate to
our behavior and they create a
connection between our behavior they
draw a connection to Torah that we've
been involved in now I was once many
years ago I live in the vehicle and it's
a little closer than male ammos but we
live in the vehicle and we're I think I
don't know where that green line is
either I'm not sure I always heard about
this green line I've been looking for it
I've never seen it you know you know
this meets all of the same I still
haven't found a green line so lines
Israel's very big on lines by the way
they have a red line in the Kinneret I
don't know if you're aware of that they
have the the red line which is the
danger line in the Kinneret just to let
you know which country you're living in
they once had on a live broadcast on the
radio there was a drought there had been
a series of years of drought and the
Kinneret level was about 5 it was about
I think 10 centimeters over the red line
they had the minister reactor culture on
a live broadcast on the radio and they
said to sir what are you going to do if
the water dips down to the red line and
he said it's not a problem we will erase
the red line and draw it lower so and
and in what happens is if you've been
living in the country long enough you
know you loose listens you just go oh
okay
all right that should take care of it
because we're used to get sort of thing
here so so I know red lines green lines
of not quite sure where they are in
anyway that was then waiting for the bus
here in the blaring stop on the way down
in the yorokobi Tesco and there was an
elderly man secular elderly man standing
to my right and he looked like you know
he'd been here since the founding of the
state one of those in north tel aviv
type people and just then a group of
Hader kids got out they were let out of
the fading I have to realize they've
been sitting in a crowded Hat cater for
about 8 to 24 hours and they got out of
the fader and immediately right next to
the fader there's a snack shop so then
they went and got sugar
and just then as they came to the bus
after a bit they were bit you know
they're buzzing and the bus was coming
down the hill and I think is the first
and only time in my life that actually
experienced prophecy don't tell anybody
I don't have to give breakfast but the
the bus was coming down the hill and I
knew exactly what was going to happen
before it happened I knew exactly was
gonna happen I remember distinctly
smiling through the entire thing cause I
was so proud of myself knowing exactly
what's going to happen and sure enough
the bus pulled up right in front of me
which I did there was the only part I
was a surprise the bus pulled up right
in front of me I immediately put my arm
against the the wall of the bus to hold
back the surge of the kids so that this
elderly man could get on and the kids
moved to me like a nice moveth through
butter and they moved me and I pushed
into the old man and then I moved back
once they got out oh they're making a
lot of noise they get on the bus and the
I moved over the old man got on the bus
and before and I knew exactly what was
gonna be happening when I got on the bus
as soon as I got on he was already going
and it was he was yelling at these kids
he says that's what they taught you in
Heder that you should push all people
the bus and so if you stop to think
about it it's incredibly unreasonable
it's a great yes right before they were
let out of the fader the Rebbe probably
looked at them and said young galosh if
you see an old man at the bus stop take
him out right is unreasonable is is
unreasonable is as you could possibly be
he was he was yelling at them at the end
of the story was we're going back a long
time I wouldn't I wouldn't do this today
this was going back about 30 years ago
and he started young
where did you learn that kind of
behavior so I said well from the members
of the Israeli Knesset because
and the bus drivers started hollering at
me how could you talk so since that I've
been looking for the Green Line so the
the the point is if you stop to think
about data is the most unreasonable
conclusion you could come up with yes
the little kids came out of the Heder
what do you think the Rebbe in the
theorem because teaching them their
heresy see to natori and to then go and
make it association if they pushed an
old man at the bus stop is because you
learn Torah that's what you learned in
cater that's lastly we learn a paper
because I'll are telling us that when a
person represents toward a person is
Torah so then you're going to you our
gift connection is going to be made when
I was learning in cradle throws curl or
mortify activities of Connolly Drucker
he told us so when we get on a bus if
there's anybody standing on the bus no
matter what age anybody's standing on
the bus and we're sitting we should not
sit if even one secular Jew is standing
on the bus because they're gonna look
around the bus and their reaction is
going to be Y is the from guy sitting
and I'm standing just the fighters
otherwise that's the responsibility that
we carry when we represent three bones
film and we represent your bones ones
the rest of the world whether we like it
or not that's the responsibility with
privilege goes responsibility
that's responsibility that we carry so
one of the misconceptions is that the
world at large thinks that we think that
were flawless the world they're
projecting on our mindset and they think
that we think that we're perfect or
flawless or whatever it is we never made
that claim and to the contrary we see
because I'll not like that there's a
magician voracious rabbit
whether sebaceous raba pays I involve
the Meldrick says there is a mature
Anissa a Roman noblewoman who ran into
her be a sabbatical ofte
and she said Tara BOC vodka laughter you
know that story that about yo safe
exotic you know here's a
seventeen-year-old
red-blooded teenager down in the den of
iniquity called Egypt and you're trying
to sell us that story that he didn't do
anything
he ran away from mrs. Potiphar and he
didn't sin can you imagine who are you
trying to kid over here so rebus he said
back to her well let's take a look at
the Torah let's see what kind of
whitewashing we do here you have Yehuda
who was under his father's jurisdiction
you have Reuben who was under his
father's jurisdiction and yet the torah
reports both of them is doing something
which according to the plain meaning
which he didn't know the literal meaning
the literal meaning says that there was
something immoral that they did so with
Yosef was a teenager outside of his
father's jurisdiction if he would have
done something wrong we have nothing to
gain by whitewashing it we've even
talked about somebody who should know
better and we say here here's the flaw
look what Reuven did in the way the
Turner writes it in the literal level it
looks like an act of immorality here's
what you hooded is she doesn't know the
measures that the mala pushed it and
therefore it looks for here people who
should know better and we don't
whitewash for them so I laugh fest
counter the comma if we have a Yosef
who's a teenager who is outside of his
father's jurisdiction he's away at
college and he behaves in a way that's
inappropriate so we wouldn't might watch
it so if we tell you he didn't do
something wrong we're not trying to make
anything up but even more than that I
want to notice about this major issue
every single name in the Torah almost
almost every single name in the Torah
that we look at as you go through the
terrific sad almost every single name is
criticized Avram Avena said by made the
Yitzhak was deceived by ace of Yaakov
very two wives Moshe Ravana got angry
Aaron with the anger with the eagle and
Annan and Miriam with Russian hora you
look at every name when they stepped out
of line with FEMA dragged us somewhere
obviously at their level but the Torah
itself tells us that they were behaving
in a way that there was a flaw in their
character laughs Emad Ragusa why do I do
that
if cuz I'll say that anybody says dama
de Mello sin is making a mistake why
should we what why should we wait watch
it we don't watch anything besides the
proof that Michelle comes from him so
obviously it wasn't what people what it
looks like on the literal level so if a
person takes a look at the Torah is
you think you're perfect you from Jews
you you project yourself we don't think
we're perfect at all even the greatest
in history says openly that they had
flaws so we never claimed that we are
that we're perfect are we better than
the rest of society individually and as
a group so then we have to take a look
at the evidence and see what happens in
a total world which we'll see in a
moment but the first step in dealing
with people and when I say dealing with
people I would like to just make a
something clear from the outset because
this is one of the standard mistakes
that's made any time people ask or
challenge us you always have to
determine from the outset whether the
person is asking a question or is making
a statement and that means that
sometimes the person could ask in quite
a firm for example the husband who you
know wife says the husband why did you
just watch a walk across the floor I
just watched it and the husband says
well I had to get to the refrigerator to
get an Apple wrong wrong broad because
that's not that that's not the that's
that would be why is it wrong why is it
wrong anybody isn't married any great
length of time like about 10 minutes
understands that because she didn't ask
a question as she made a statement when
she said why did you walk across the
floor so says Rashi she was saying you
are an inconsiderate war right and when
somebody says that to you that usually
the next response should be I apologized
right it was inconsiderate of the I am
worse than the goat on Yom Kippur you
know off the cliff you know that is
really the response she's looking for so
person has to know was that a question
was a statement so particularly know why
don't create him go to the army so you
know was that a question or was that a
statement in question for him if it's a
attack my policy and I would suggest
your president for a text we don't
respond because the verse is not
listening to you there are a lot of
sharp rejoinders people always say what
do you say to somebody who asks you why
you this said there are a lot of sharp
cute rejoinders that you come up with
but they accomplish very very little if
a person asks you a question
respectfully they're curious a person
says to you why is it the creative don't
go to the
why is it that you're not allowed to
turn lights on on Shabbos why is it that
women sit in the back of the bus if it's
a respectful question they're entitled
to an answer the way I approach the
answer and I suggest you do the same is
they ask the person do you want an
answer based on secular values or based
on Torah values the secular values
secular values the reason we do anything
based on secular values is because we
feel like it because that's the ultimate
secular value secular values as you do
it because you feel like it and if you
don't do it it's because you haven't got
the energy to do it or because you don't
feel like it
no no no I mean by Torah values Torah
values ok now you're on my turf so then
I will explain to you and we tell the
DMS that's what you say the truth and
say why we don't go to the army or what
is we have against an unfiltered
internet and so on and so for just tell
the truth if a person at some point says
here but I don't agree with that we
weren't talking about you we weren't
talk about your value system I had a
friend once in when I was in college
yeah I was a Catholic and I asked him
something I was intrigued by it hurt all
my life I didn't know was true or not I
said them you know in your religion the
wafers and wine in the religious service
actually believed that that's part of
something about being part of his flesh
and blood that it's actually been some
day a fancy word that it's actually his
his flesh and blood that's got
transformed into there in a I was
curious I said you actually believe that
he said to me you know I've always had
trouble with that one all right I was
gonna say to me I'm me too especially
since on the back of the package says
Hodari on the wafer back in our house
they fit him into the box I don't know
what yeah and it's kind of big but
whatever it was me asking what we call
him or learn English she talks a lot
Lycia tusla I don't agree with it but
Liz she tossed out how do you how do you
account for this and therefore it's
something it's like you want to know why
we don't go to the army why you know why
I know why we do Shabbos sir how we with
the segregation of the genders you want
to know why she just say I'll explain to
you explain to you why but that's I've
taken you in if it's according to the
secular value system but let's not
confuse the issue I'm not talking about
this
because we're not secular and this is
the secular value if it is a secular
Valley the answer is a value only
because somebody decided that that's
what they feel like doing in their time
so that's just as a heck dumber so when
a person says you know how could a
parade eju behave a certain way what's
the MS the answer the truth
Lycia to say - not according to secular
perspective because the second
perspective you think that we think
we're perfect from a Torah perspective
the reason a person can behave that way
is because the Torah was given to us as
human beings were not my walk in we have
a eight Sahara and once in a while once
in a while we we lose ourself what's
wrong again I remember myself I think 12
years ago I spoke loshon Hara it happens
so there's a there there is a certain
amount of there's certain about we don't
were human beings that human as human
beings we have shortcomings in and
failings now what they want to know
about a Torah society so at our society
people are as curious okay what's in it
for me to become a tour a Jew I mean you
look like you are a bunch of black
headed restricted in unaware that's
always one of the favorite one of the
favorite canards that they hurl at us is
we are unaware so at one time in class
you know I once said to the guys in
class
okay we're unaware can anybody here name
the premier of China silence so at first
so I don't know if it's a premier of
precedence is this and I'm not sure
which one it is not one guy in the class
said honestly you guys are so unaware
you got the biggest country in the world
that they're about a 1.5 billion by now
its 1.6 and now it's 1.7 I know exactly
exactly how many there are you got the
biggest country in the world and you
can't even tell me who the president of
the country to get those little who's a
leader in a country so you're unaware
right you're unaware so they think that
we're in a will speak about awareness
and on awareness we just realized how
they're looking at us as somewhere
hidden be hinted by this we are turtles
in a shell and we're unaware of what's
going on in the world and we are living
in some sort of cloistered society which
keeps us closed off from anything that's
going on in the world so first of all
one of the things we want to point out
is that
torez society when you compare the two
societies so cuz I'll say meatloaf you
knew some etosha mushy funny we need
here the criticism of the person the
criticism of the person tells you what
level the person is I I remember one of
my fondest memories growing up my older
brother who was the family scholastic
star and you know I graduated high
school when he was about 16 and he was
always getting eighth
I remember once his grades started
slipping and my parents had a meeting
with him because he came home I think he
had a 92 on a test you know I was so
happy right but they would they were you
know like what's happening over here
he's not studying enough I had a 77 we
went out the restaurant that night you
know so you do so not touch it man you
found if they're if he's being
criticized for getting a 92 that tells
you who the person is so in a torah
society if a Torah Jew does ever steps
out of line that makes the front page of
the newspaper if a turret I tried to
tell be by the son learning in a mere
Brachfeld mere Brachfeld is faced 700
tell me debate hundred told me to
whatever it is he's in the achiever for
five years in that once in five years
was he or any Talmud in the Sheva
involved in a fistfight
could you imagine 600 males between the
ages of 18 and 22 in one dormitory in
that one fistfight in five years could
you imagine now let's substitute any
other nationality it was Italians okay
at least I only say all right it was
Irish could you could you imagine what
would happen how many we think wouldn't
take 800 it would take three of them
right in a course of 10 minutes so when
you're looking at the society let's take
a look so one time you saw to juice
fighting intro that people say Jews are
always fighting it's not sure there's a
choice fighting which is almost never
fight the two raises is a nice call to
Russia shoes may argue and they may
bicker about whether or not we sail on
that say I found the day after he's and
it's true you know cuz it's really
bad stuff but at the end of the day Jews
aren't always fighting Jews aren't
always like
you know we talk we like that we like to
express our opinions let's take a look
at the criticism and from the criticism
then you see when I first started
learning coal I said that was my career
so my career was a public school guy
everybody school a what they call an FSB
which stands for either from from birth
or fractured from birth as the case may
be and I was you know I was a day school
kid and I went to a yeshiva high school
and I told him I had a memory if there's
one moment in my life I'd like to do
over it was in eighth grade when we came
in from recess so we were all hot and
sweaty from playing baseball and we're
all standing in line by the drinking
fountain there's long line and one guy
at the back of the line today is a
lawyer at the back of the line this guy
just his last guy's line and he just
goes out loud Brooklyn I got a bum chef
Cole near Beaver oh it's so like about
you know we all just you know what are
we gonna do in a brothel that's all so
so being a bunch of little goobers we
got out of the way and we now that's a
moment that like to have back I would
like because I was thinking myself what
should I have done and I know what I
should or what I should have done and I
should have turned around and said oh
only Bieber oh now what and we
should all have done it together that
was it so I said this about Jerusalem
first was much older is a New York
public school kid he said to me Ashraf
uh that that's the trouble that went on
in your school he said I went to public
school there was an ex-boxer who
patrolled the lunchroom in order to
maintain discipline in every single day
somebody got beaten up by him he said
that's the difference we did their world
in our world and therefore we're trying
to show you know but what is a Torah
world for people who have no idea people
are looking in from the outside what
happens in the Torah world what is the
what is the milah of it or well let's
compare the society do we have flaws yes
we have flaws and if a Jewish man is
caught embezzling and it makes the front
page of the newspaper
we're embarrassed we're ashamed and if
somebody says how could he do such a
thing
the answer is that the Torah at scene I
was given to FFPs
it was given to Dorthea the people on
the highest level
and that same Torah says llosir soft
loose enough that Torah says don't do
the things that a human being is capable
of doing we never said were flawless we
never said we're not capable he has a
society we're doing pretty well when
compared to the rest of the society
for the rest of the world but we never
made the claim that you think we made
that we are beyond any sort of
temptations in any sort of mischief or
misbehavior the the Benny o yoga says a
famous muscle the Vinod against there's
the mother lion and the mother lion has
her little Cubs yes and from Chicago and
the mother lion says other lion says to
her cubs
listen I'm tired of feeding you and I'm
tired of cooking and cleaning for you
you guys have to go out and fend for
yourself it's time to go out and do your
own hunting so they say to the mother
lion okay where can we go is listen the
Lions are the kings
we're the kings of the forest kings of
the jungle you can go anywhere you want
without restrictions any town any city
you could go and gobble up anybody want
anywhere you want so they go scampering
off happily he had to get to the first
town and as they approached the first
town they see a billboard a giant an
enormous billboard and on this billboard
there's a huge picture of Shimshon
ripping apart a lion so it's the first
thing they see I'm the first day out on
the hunt so they immediately turn around
they run home they say mom no way you
know you told us that we could go
anywhere we want the first thing we see
there's a giant billboard ship shows
ripping apart a lion most of them hug
goof Araya that's exactly what I was
telling you if it would be the daily
occurrence they would never put that up
on a billboard that's the one time in
history that had happened and therefore
they made a big deal out of it let me
talk you know so not such a massive
fight from the fact that they're making
an issue out of it that's proof that it
doesn't happen and therefore when a 480
Jew is arrested in Israel 480 Jews if
you remember years ago we're going back
a long time when the green line was
still blue the 480 Jews were in Israel
and they had were arrested for what he
called for breaking apart a bus there
were bus stops that were being
vandalized in Israel
do you remember that that made
international moves could you imagine on
the front
New York Times that they arrested some
thug because he broke apart a bus stop
or he vandalized the subway
yeah missing that nobody would even make
it into the cartoons did you imagine her
ad Joo is vandalizing bus that tells you
vote for it and by the way turned out it
wasn't even true
it was a gut it was it was a bunch of
hooligans who are trying to frame the
her eighties so they dressed up as
fairies and they've analyzed the bus
that wasn't even her eighties doing it
we weren't that didn't make the front
notice the friendly front front to the
front page certainly not in English that
didn't make it but when it's criticized
that shows you what's really going on in
our society the idea of lush at Hara
which I mentioned earlier
could you imagine in the society at
large in a torah world once in a while
we people are taught speaking loshon
Hara okay it happens could you imagine
in the world at large who were largest
built on luncheon are the TV shows the
dramas the sitcoms the the wedding
coffee it's all ocean art and that's
only the first stage and then there's
actual violence and there's actual
murder in a total world
you're not even odd to think bad about
people you certainly don't hit people
and once in a while you slip up and you
say something once in a while you say
something negative and even then you
feel guilty about it so when you compare
and contrast our society to the other
society than the person looking in from
the outside says to you what are the
benefits of bigoted or a Jew what have
you got to sell where is your society
what is your society about we can show
the person look at her take a look at
our society our society is moral to the
degree more to greater extent than any
other society can think of in the world
people ask us about my pizza all the
time why do you have a limit Itza right
the answer is listen because we
recognize human weakness we're not on
the same high level as the conservative
in the Reform and therefore we
understand that unless we ever met he'd
say in our shoals then were you know
we're we're understand what the humans
have tell you what human nature is it's
even more than that though because the
real secret of the mashita is that women
and men are not allowed to dive in
together in a show that's a halakhah and
what we do is we bend over backwards
make an effort a Makita doesn't separate
and drive the women further away to the
contrary the Meeteetse actually draws
them closer because with automata say
they wouldn't be allowed on the shoulder
at all so the Meeteetse is something
that allows them into the shoals that's
up there pushes them out of the show and
it's not something pushing them away
it depends what your starting point is
if you're given is everybody should be
together and you're given is that
immorality doesn't matter so then you're
right but if you're looking at from a
turret perspective the given is we care
about immorality we care about a rice we
care about human behavior and therefore
the halacha says they can't be together
in on place so then we put up a mecha
that helps them out and allows them into
the show doesn't distance that now I
want to go back a little bit to the
perception that we're unaware
so the first thing in any interaction
with a with a secular Jew if you are
involved it's a very very delicate line
because on the one hand because we
represent Torah there are certain lines
that we're not willing to cross and one
of the flaws that a person or one of the
pitfalls that a person could encounter
in the world of Kiros specifically is
abiding or buying into a hush toughie
that says we have to lower ourselves and
go down into their world and our
approach has always been fast to show
and we don't do that the Torah
approaches we pull them up into our
world and if there's any danger to any
tough fate that he will get pulled down
because of involvement in that world he
FA si si speak to his rug and find out
and get guidance what's a lot what's not
allowed and whether or not he himself is
involved in the correct endeavor at that
point in his life but we never get
involved if it means bringing people
into our homes obviously we have to
bring them in their own so personally
that's to make a sheep Oh what about the
influence of our children what's this
going to do to our children what are
they going to hear what kind of failures
our kind of language what kind of
demonstration of behavior are they going
to see when they enter our homes how is
this going to be what's effect is this
going to have of my children they're all
very serious child's they have to be
asked however we do and we
have been involved and we have an
obligation to do bonus column to try to
show people the beauty of Torah and the
beauty of a Torah life so a person has
to remember a few principles when
they're doing this number one that we
don't sink down to their level in any
way shape or form
there's no rough language and there's no
behavior that's unbecoming for above a
Ben Torah to the contrary they lose
respect what a person maintains his
Judaism to the degree that a person
shows loyalty to his religion is the
degree people respect them there's so
many people who have never taken off
their yarmulke and whether in school or
at work and the people around them
non-jews certainly respect of our Jews
may have an issue with them but the
non-jews will respect them for the
consistency and the loyalty to their
principles number one number two if you
are involved you can show a secular Jew
that you have a certain amount of
secular knowledge you could relate right
this world if you don't think about
music you could anything about sports
you know anything about politics
whatever it is you could show them to
try to shatter that stereotype that we
are completely victims of tunnel vision
we don't know what's going on outside us
you can show them and demonstrate a
little bit just keep it within the
parameters of proper behavior that it
shouldn't be something that you end up
becomes the means in and of itself it
gives the Gulf person gets absorbed into
it and the person forgets why he was
doing it to really get so caught up in
it that he himself starts to pursue that
interest and that's always that's always
the danger that's something that we have
to watch for now one of the one of the
areas that people have a lot of trouble
with this is almost unique to Aaron sea
shell but I'd say that this applies in
other areas here in Eretz Israel is the
question in the United States also but
specifically over here is a question of
colo learning people are wondering you
know you've seen the various insults
that have been hurled at the from
community that we're a bunch of
parasites and so on and so forth and
people are very curious you know here
you are you have a male population I
remember
driving once past a certain city here in
Eretz Israel some Indian car said yes
and their great job opportunities here
too and I was little I was surprised
because most of the people in this
community we're learning in coal and I
said their great job opportunities here
he says I'm talking about for the women
right because you know the wives need
the job opportunity so that the men be
continued learning in coal oh so it's
something that the world is baffled by
because the world sees usually secular
education as a means of then getting a
job and most people have been to college
the purpose of colleges to get grades at
a prestigious college if possible
because the better the grades and more
procedures the university the better the
job the more money you're going to make
which we all know that's the goal of
life and therefore if a person
understands that well that's the goal in
that's education has the limit now why
are a bunch of grown men with families
still studying if they're not studying
full-time they're studying part-time
earners studying every minute that they
could they have a book open I mean did
you graduate already why are you still
why are you still learning and the
answer to the approach to Colo I think
is something also that we have to know
because if something were confronted and
again I'm talking about somebody who is
a somebody who is a who is asking not
somebody who's attacking my first year
in Colo when we're living here in Israel
for zeros married so I broke my foot I
was playing basketball trying to shatter
the room stereotype with some secular
guys so I broke my foot and of course in
Israel at the time it was during the
doctors strike which is a really bad
time to break a foot so they put a cast
on me in the hospital then two weeks
later I have the cast change and I went
into the doctor doctor was a secular Jew
who happened to also be from Chicago so
we hit it off right away and he was
examining my foot and at a certain point
he said to me so what do you do I said I
study in coal he said well what supports
you so I said well my wife works say
gave like a snicker goes I guess
somebody has to do huh so I think myself
you know I I'm not nice thing had
fluttered through my mind and I didn't
say because he had my broken foot in his
hand but
I was thinking myself you know look at
you
you went to medical school who put you
through Medical School either you got a
loan from the United States government
or your father lent you the money or
paid for it or your wife worked who I
went through Medical School but to you
it was the value and because it was a
value to you you were willing to invest
in that Valley and even take money in
order to pursue their value because
becoming a doctor study medicine that
was a value to you to us tourists study
is a value and if my wife is happy to be
able to work to support me or my father
or father-in-law or the Rocha Kolo are
willing to fundraise for me so that I
could study in color I didn't ask you
for any money I'm not imposing on you in
any way shape or form I didn't ask for
your opinion none of which I said there
but that's what I would have said that's
the second moment I'd like to do over in
my life wrench my foot out of his grip
and then say so a person understands
that when we asked the question the
answer that we give has to be the true
answer people say all the time what do
you say to somebody who asks and the
answer is we tell them the truth if
somebody else how do we know Torres from
Cena what do you say to some of us how
do we know for a certain scene I the
answer is we tell them the truth and
done usually a person see which is what
I say okay
is that what we tell somebody else I
said what how do we know that Torres
Lucy Knight whatever the MS happens to
be on a subject somebody who's asking a
question they deserve they are entitled
it is only respectful to give them an
answer which is a it has to be I must be
they're entitled for the answer but you
have to understand that when we explain
it and we explain it pleasantly and we
explain it in a way that makes logical
sense then the person walks away from
the encounter with the from jus it's a
good exceeded one a good experience and
that more than the answer more than
anything you tell the person is going to
have the effect and his attitude towards
you describe the same thing goes for the
question of the women and the back of
the bus this is also one of the main
issues in the society today arts Torah
Jews male chauvinists right I mean you
even have a brother Louis on e esha I
mean
how blatant could we get so the answer
to that question is several fold first
of all and again to somebody who's
asking that attacking my first response
to the person is you know if we were
shoving us isn't it interesting that
when I got married I took on full
financial responsibility for the family
the people I say yeah but nowadays the
women work if they do it's by choice
if a man doesn't work in the old days
when base then he had the in the
old days a man who would refuse to go to
work base in hand the other I had that
he had the right to flog in he could get
monkeys if he didn't go to work a man
complicit you know what I think I'm
gonna quit you know basic says really
oh yeah you want to think about that
again an hour off he goes a woman comes
home and she says by the way I got good
news and bad news
what's the good news the good news is
you're gonna be getting is better
dinners from now I what's the bad news
I'm gonna have more time because I quit
my job I'm gonna be in the home all a
man could say ders thank you for what
you've done up until now she has
absolutely no obligation he has no legal
recourse there's nothing he could do
she's doing it willingly and therefore a
man which by the way fess I'll say that
the pain of childbirth
whatever the pain of childbirth is the
difficulty of making par Nessa is twice
as much I don't say say that to the girl
in the first meeting in a up but I
just want you to know that those are the
facts right because I'll say that the
difficulty the stress in the pressure of
making prayer NASA is twice as painful
as the pain of childbirth that's what
has I'll say so person says you're
shoving us if I'm a chauvinist why would
I make a law why would we have a law
that puts the burden of responsibility
on the husband why would I make laws if
it's man-made andr shoving us why would
it make a law that requires me to get up
an hour before my wife does so that I
could have to go to trudging out to
meaning and 7 o'clock in the morning and
a cold frigid winter morning if I was
chauvinist I'd make everybody else go I
wouldn't make myself go and therefore
our person asks that explain that we
passed the shawl there's nothing
disparaging in this religion in Yiddish
guide there's nothing disparaging aimed
at women in any way shape or form for
everything that is said about them which
could be interpreted with that way
there's something that
said in the app to disclose - even see
Kony as they got out of its right and so
on and so forth and therefore the answer
has to be accurate the answer has to be
respectful and the answer has to be true
then the person asking the question sees
that we've thought this out we know what
we're doing we're not a bunch of people
who are just what following the blind
following the blind we are we've worked
it out we're pleasant people we have a
society and we have what to offer them
I've just conclude by telling you that
many people have had the experience of
an encounter with a secular Jew and at
the end of the encounter the secular Jew
says you know what if all the freedom
would be like you would be okay right
many people have had that encounter and
obviously the reason that the secular
Jew is thinking that is because he's
inundated with the Israeli media with
the brainwashing against the Froome
community and then he meets an
individual on a one-on-one has a
one-on-one meeting which is a pleasant
meaning there are people who have opened
their home to secular Jews they're in
their home or thirty-seconds their lives
are changed because they were
face-to-face at a Shabbos meal or in a
discussion with a from Jew and they
walked away and in many cases it was the
most exhilarating experience of their
life and therefore a person when you're
in kept an encounter with a secular Jew
what your goal should be the goal should
be that if all from Jews were like you
all from Jews were like you as well from
Jews were like you the secular person
should walk away feeling if all from
Jews were like you it would be okay
they've never met and that's really our
responsibility it's Easter L assure the
fire safar the Gemara concludes Hsieh
hate Shan Shan I'm nice I have all your
talk we are the ambassador's of Torah
and it is our responsibility to see to
it that the people who meet us walk away
with a positive impression of torah deut
Torah juice and tourism
[Music]
you
[Applause]