SHABBOS DELIVERIES & OTHER AMIRA L’AKUM QUESTIONS - Rabbi Zev Smith

[Music] foreign like to welcome everyone to today from harvard smith deliveries and other emir outcome questions have the great social sponsorship called ignore 718-851-8651 over pesach we hear two interesting shy lists that come up on chavez and yamtiv someone was very much waiting for a safe in the mail and it was sent with uh book rate and it came to his house on chavez era and he wants to know if he's allowed to read it it came with an open box all would basically just open the box take out the book the safe actually i should say or else wait for three days it was a safe about jumped but he wanted to read it very much he wanted to learn it the question is the fact that it came in the mail is it also to use until after shabbos or yamtiv the question would be also if it's in the mountains you get maya on shabbos maybe it came does that complicate matters somewhat we had another question over yumped if someone ordered clothing for the children and puncture came on shabbos error pesach so i was waiting three days or using it on on yumt of itself so before we go right i want to be nice to today about deliveries and having enough from deliveries is negaya tayamthev just like the shabbos and some things yamtiv is regarding the sugi of today it's yamtav just like shabbos we say shabbos because there's more shabbos than yamcha but so the truth is in the sugi of today there are really two different points that really overlap there's one of course the issa of amir al-aqm instructing a guy to do something for you on shabbos whether it's delivering a package you could tell them to deliver a package before shabbos or bring the package with a guy he's being instructed to do something but then we have today's sugya if the guy did it is it muta to have enough from the package can you use the safer that you got in the mail or the clothing you got in the mail so one thing i think we should be very well aware of hazal or actually the toriyaka daisha put a very strong protection on the shabbos and specifically regarding amir al-aqm even though we passed [Music] but we can't lose sight of the fact that it's based on apostolic in the torah and parish's body the torah says it shouldn't be done why does they don't do so rashi says it a few words but really the makara is the michelta and the mr burn raishmi gimbal see if cotton hey quotes it the terrorist says it shouldn't be done means even if you don't do it if a guy does it because on your behalf that's like melaka being done by you in fact rashi in the sector shabbos kuffman gimmel says one of the reasons that mira akam is but what's noteworthy the rambam in the beginning of the sixth perique in the shabbos he says it's awesome for a guy to do even though the guy is not supposed to keep shabbos but dave is an ostomy they're very safe him is it's to protect could do shabbos shabbos shouldn't become just like another day and the embers if you think about it it will be very obvious understand why amir laakum protects shabbos imagine for a moment if we'd be allowed to ask the guy to do all mulakas on our behalf the guy could wash the dishes the guy could vacuum the guy could put on the recording of the daffy mission he'll do everything and anything there won't be a trace of shabbos the guy could cook when it's not bishop there won't be any remnant of kadusa shabbos and that's why it's so important to understand that amir allah is protecting should not become caliban i always thought that's maybe the shot in a chuva minas shamayim if you do want to resign him one of the ballet tyson yankov wrote shilos to shamayim and he received responses so in simendala he asked the question about asking a guy to move muktsa which is typically a schwester schwartz which is not so bad but the response was very serious don't play around with amir al-aqm colin again the lesson of the ministry which of course speaks volumes of the climber or the severity of mir allah but i think when i have the heritage why does he use the lotion that amir lachim the pupil of the burslam's eyes because really amir al-aqm is the protection of kadusa shabbos if a guy could do what whatever he wants to do or whatever we want him to do they won't be azekah of shabbos it has to be the banisher islam shambhas and that's why there's a lot to say but suffice to say that this is the bhavas now rob once told me that people think that amir al-aqm is not only a hatter but it's a way of life and halacha says it's not a hatter and it can't be a way of life because that's really the also physically but as far as we're concerned we have to learn a gemara in bayek of dalaran again talking about yamcha but yamdev and shabbas are very much similar and this introduces us to one to the aspect of to the icca point of today's suggest a guy brought a gift for the eid the kid didn't ask him the guy in his own brought a gift and dr kimura if you could assume that the guy did malacha he had to cut off the apples to bring you the apples it's osa for the year to enjoy the the apples on shabbos oyamtiv in fact not only you can't have enough on shabbos but you have to wait the time that it would take for the guy to do malacha and wait that time on matsuri muscle if the girl had to travel to the orchard and cut off the apples you have to calculate how long did it take to the guy to do malacha and that time you have to wait on shabbos omitsuyam not only you can have a non-shabbos but you have to wait the time that it took to do malacha and that time you have to wait a minute this is what's referred to as the kadeshayasa which means to do the time that it takes to do now this is a albatsar but you look in the sukhana it's beforeish in tough tests heathcott it's come out in the first in the gemara even if you're not sure he did even if it's only a suffix did he do moloko or not i'll suffolk you have to wait until matsuri shabbat but the price can say because we don't want you to come to malacca by yourself even the suffolk amir allah is also in this context so here we see an introduction to the iss of having enough molechas it's awesome even of a sufficient what's tucker the reason for the israel so rashi and bayer says we shouldn't have an offer the guy cut off apples off a tree that's so you can't have enough in toy swiss has a problem with rashi shita and this has a different reason which is probably the icky site the guy did for you today on his own initiative you didn't tell him today next shabbos or next yom div you'll ask them straight out say good luck in the gesheft he did it for you you're allowed to have enough next time you'll be asking yourself so basically since amir al-aqm is so easy to do and it's so enticing and some people think it's a way of life hazal not to say no no no we have to put on a protection a deterrent that a person should not be inclined to ask the guy to do mullah because even if the guy did malachi it's awesome so we have to remove the incentive of the great malacca for the eid so we see this double esther of hanoi and even kadeshias now the embassies you look in the mr burn beginning of tough test he discusses rashi entices the various nafcaminas but we have a big agenda but i will say one thing it comes out from twice this that even on a three-day umptive if the guy did malachi on the anchavis you can't have enough not shabbos another two days yomtiv now one thing needs explanation is so that's a suggestion that's called my shabbos and though you could have so the question is are you talking if a year did malach a real shabbos there's no kadeshi you have to wake up sucked the pie skin and mr bird quotes it it's very positive because no one will ever ask a year to do mulaka for him he's pained by the idea of so there's no reason to make a day shiyasa but amir al-akham again since people believe it's a way of life we need some strong protection so not only matsuri shabbos but so adorable because it's looked at lightly hazal had to go to the other extreme so this is why the mahabhara gives a muscle and reisha involves if aleph a guy puts on a light or lights a candle for a yid it's awesome for the year to have allah from the candle until my toe is but what's possible is let's say the guy didn't you didn't tell the guy anything here's a common scenario the guy knocks on your door shop friday night i see you're sitting in the darkness the light's not on i know what happened probably the light was uh you didn't set the light or the timer went off i'm a experienced shabbos guy i know all about this stuff just let me put the lights on and you could sit in the light you don't have to tell me anything so that's the that's the mystibura that even if he does it on his own you have to be if he doesn't want to listen chase him out of the house after mr burun because the guy can't do malachi free eat that's why it's possible that what people think okay i can't tell they're going to do a lot of me but i'm allowed to hint to him now what they hint it's in it's almost the comical they call the guy into the house they point up to the light and they start begging and pleading but they don't say a word that's not a hint but even had it been a hint how do you say oh it's dark in my house i didn't mention malacha but you can't have the guy put on the light because maddox without a deeper at all as mr burroughs says he comes on his own you can't allow him so why should rem has been with them teres remiss is not muthu if the guy does it for a year you can't have hannah from the this is the isa mir and the israelite the only possible header of having on rem is is mutter if it's an indirect hand when most of the lights are on in the bedroom you can't sleep so you tell the guy i can't sleep the lights are on and the guy closes it that's considered an indirect hand not twice this is lusting and shabbos is he's he takes away anezek but you're sleeping because you're tired not because you closed the light the light would have disturbed your sleep that's an indirect tenno and that's muta to wrap the mimiramis to the guy close the light close the oven indirect handle that's why if for whatever reason that you forgot to put on the urn or the crackpot or any of the oven to call a guy tell the guy to do malachi it would be an isa hammer of amir al-aqm even by malcolm x but now let us approach our question the guy delivered a package the mailman or ups whatever it is a package in the mail can i enjoy that package so we have to clarify what it means the iss of hanoi so let me explain it it's sometimes common a person goes to a hospital nursing home and there's automatic doors you can't walk in because you're gonna open the door so what's the oldest trick wait for a guy to go by the stand by the door when the guy walks in the door opens going with him did you ever wonder the following question how could you go into the door that was just opened by the guy it's akum the guy opened the door so how could you go into that hospital so it sounds foolish but what's the answer the terror it says wait a minute you can't have enough from a melaka that was done by issa anshabas here the guy is supposed to be mahalo so the it's not han oh so far so good right so if the guy the muscle puts on the light in the basement because the guy is cleaning the basement you could tell him oh don't close it ah you put it on on shabbos he did it for his own purpose so that's fine so we have one qualification of the isa it has to be done by issa but now let's go a step further and that is let's say you need your car repaired and you bring it into the mechanic friday morning say listen no rush i need a monday afternoon i have a wedding monday night i need a one day monday afternoon or you need a suit in the cleaners a shoemaker taylor all these case where people are doing work on your behalf so we all know that if you give him enough time to do before or after shabbos so even though he tells you oh rabbi i'm going to do it saturday morning it's ready saturday 11 o'clock it's fun why is it mutter why attack is a mutt he's doing it on shabbos how about if you walk by the mechanic and say hey this is your car work on it now in two hours you won't recognize it it could be like brand new do you have to be michael you have to stop him why not i he's doing it for you on shabbos so this is the well-known heter of adaita dana sheikh which means it is akam bishabis he's doing it for you it's not like the automatic door is doing it for himself he's fixing your car for you but here's the catch it's not a melechus shabbos per se he could do it on friday he could do it on sunday or monday so he chose shabbos for his own convenience that's the heath of the makkar is the gemara in shabbos and rashi explains why the fact that it's done on shabbos is his decision for his benefit so now we are pretty much defining more accurately what it is the islam the isa is [Music] if it's not the isa there's no problem if it's not malachi shabbos because you could do it friday or monday so that's the enragement zion it's also in regional bays it's called the coupling basically that he could do it at any time that he wants friday or sunday so it's not shabbos related work it's job related the job could be done at a discretion so that's a better definition of amir laakum in contrast to what people might make a mistake but it's really a very obvious hylic why can i allow my the waiter or the or my housemaid or a worker the janitor superintendent of the building why can't i round to mulaka on shabbos i'm paying for this he's not doing it for me he's doing it to get paid that's his panasonic the answer is you're right he's not doing it which i'm sure that's for sure he's doing it for the money but his job is to work for you your higher waiter for the slim he's working for you and the sim his shop is not monday so the fact that he's doing to get paid doesn't mitigate the issue the mechanic it's not shabbos related but a maid a waiter a superintendent that has to do work on shabbos it is shabbos related the fact that he's doing to get paid is like my level i might but when it had enough say that's a very broad hat says even though the yid gains from the guy working and he gains in a financial way it's because it's a die to the why don't you mention the gemara the gemara says even though the year has no god if it had to day okay now we have a better understanding let us apply it and let us try to see how much we could do with this simple case let me start with the maisie shahi the true story and the camper i go to someone had a standard and it had seen better days and needed some repair so he went over to one of the guy issue workers and he said i'm gonna i'm gonna pay you fix my standard he gave it to friday i i need it by sunday afternoon do whenever you want okay the guy walks in shabbos morning after davening proudly here heart of the press fresh off the press here i just fixed it now enjoy the standard so there's no doubt about it this is a goblin he got paid for the job advice the question is can the id use the standard on shabbos so you're wondering why not if there's no issa of doing it if it's a real idea to the say so i can enjoy it and indeed the shogunate and raj noon bay steve dallas says why not if there's no issa of mirala he didn't do anything wrong by commission the guy to do it why can't he enjoy the standard now of course if the guy put on the light for you on shabbos you can't enjoy the light because there you needed it on shabbos but here you stipulated for me if monday is good so we could say according to the makhaba if the great put on the light you can't have a no but the standard is perfectly mutha however the ramo on that sith of the mahabharata called sanago is austria amaril that it's us to enjoy the standard on shabbos why it had to say says the mr bruins but the guy did it for you on shabbos now this has to be explained but what mr was saying very positive there are two independent focuses in this suggyu number one is amir laakum you can't have miraculous but even if it's not a miracle because you gave him leeway till monday but if the guy did moloch for you on shabbos and you enjoy it on shabbos you might come to tell next week to do it on shabbos it's the same problem and that's why the ramos says unless it's you should not have hannah that was done on shabbos now you should know that it's interesting you cannot never have this in real life because the the cleaner suit or the suit for the tailor or the mechanic all those cases you don't pick up the car on jabba's it's usually pick it up after shabbos so it's usually not negaya it's only a a rare case that was standard at the guy fixed in the mountains then you could have a north of shabbos and taka the rama says don't have i know until this predation now le misa i'll tell you another shot okay but here's the beauty of the circuit because it just goes from the same aside just holding hajj bin of where we're going also a true story someone was making a shabbat people send things for the simha cake and everything so arab shabbos he was overwhelmed with various uh autonomous for the kiddish shabbos morning the doorbell rings his problem who's there bringing a balance job is a delivery service we have to apologize we really feel bad we're supposed to bring this yesterday afternoon we misplaced it but we decided we're gonna bring it here it is enjoy mazel type and they walk out a guy drove brought food on shabbos just for the eat now this seems like a real isa no because it's definitely they did it for the eid and adaita did not say it's not they have to bring it now and according to the rama even if it died to the nazis should be awesome yet there is a pillar and a very very important aside the rajva in the chuvis and base yosef and the end of tough cuff tesla quotes to lush and verbatim has this very shiloh ayid sent a gift to another yidd and and he he hired a guyish messenger service that was delayed and brought it on shabbos that he's allowed the years allowed to enjoy the food on chaba so yamtiv i was brought on shabbos but here the raj is a beautiful usaid what's the problem with with enjoying it on shabbos the year that sent it sent it on friday there was enough time to do it you received that you didn't do any issa the terret says that's what the raspberry means it's based on this if you enjoy it today you might have to go next week to do it in this case it doesn't make sense the guy is not a mess you're a messenger the guy didn't bring you a gift he did it this week he'll do it next week it's a messenger service of a yid but it's not you there's no khashoggi you're going to ask this guy to do mulaka for you because he didn't bring you a gift he's working for someone else so what the raj was saying is if there's no if you have no shaikhs to that guy that brought it there's no she'll be asking for next week that's the lesson of the ram the rajva the kobay says the same thing and the mr brewer in tough tests of cotton quotes that's even more specific you have no shaikhis to the galician messenger service so i'm not gonna do something next week where was the case of waiting pradesh yasa if the guy who you know brings you a gift this weekend and ask him next week he will ask him because you have a child because you have an ongoing relationship but a guy out of nowhere coming working with someone else there's no khashoggi you might do mulaka for you so you let it take the an item and have enough of it but wait a second what about the reason of rashi you know in the golden of earth means you couldn't enjoy this without the guy the guy plucked it off the tree the guy cooked it he baked it he fished it up but he brought you a finished product that's not a han no i the carrying but that's not considered a direct hana and there's no issue having her no so like rashi and tyson's there's no problem i'm using a delayed slichos a delayed but the guy brought on your behalf but wait this is so quite rashi and twice is a problem there's no problem and that's why the poise can say that basically you could enjoy the food but the truth is it's the only issue that might be here is if it came from chris so now you could keep it in your house and move it around the house but you can't go out of your resources out of your dollaramas so that's somewhat of an issue but basically the point here is that if the guy brought it because of someone else it's motivated to have a no and that's the way the passing in the end of tough curve tesla next question and that is a very simple question that people want to know i supposed to mail something i was asked to mail something on sunday i put in my pocket now i'm cleaning my pocket look you know to see them before shabbos the mail's still can i mail that as arab shabbos right before this month put it into the mailbox so the embassy is that if you put in the mailbox friday afternoon they're gonna the guy used to work is gonna pick it up shop this morning or whatever the pickup is however the pace can say that because in our time the tough shampoo if it's muted letters on shabbos says you shouldn't mail it arab shabbos because there might be a fryer yid that works in the postal service and and tackle her moisture about the tube it was very common to have irreligious jews working in the mail in the postal uh service but i've i heard this that herbelsky has achieved in cinderella and he says also that today there's not it's not any hidden working in the postal service so a lot of mail letters on friday but the question is wait a minute okay there's olaf neither of you worker but what about the fact that that the guy is going to process the mail he's going to pick it up on shabbos and bring it to the to the base the station so the turret says that really this is a new example of a daita denaxi when you put a letter with your stamp first class albeit you have rights that it should be mailed in a timely fashion if the guy used to work who decides that he wants to take a day off and not pick up the mail on shabbos you have no claim in other words mail is at their convenience like we all know sometimes you get the mail a week later if they don't pick it up on shabbos they wait till sunday or monday you have no claim you have no legal claim you have rights they will eventually mail you a letter so the police can say that if when you mail something on friday and they decide to come on shabbos instead of sunday or shop instead of maturity shabbos they could have done it before or after shabbos so that's why the praise can say a mailing letter today is not a problem it's a new expression of a goblin that the guys paid for the job which could be done before after shabbos now of course if your muzzle you have a a you know there's a yid working on the route that you want to when you want to mail the letters of course don't do it that's with naiva there's no head that dayton didn't have say when it comes to a yid show that's a a real left naval now the embassies i want to mention i'm surprised i didn't see any police can point this out but i think it's quite mistavra could be mailing letters is mutter for a totally different reason the prima goddamn and mish raishman gimmel the end of cotton gimbal speaks about in his times a few hundred years ago he says the whole badaya the whole mail system today in his times he's not working for the one that's mailing the letters he's working for the government the government wants to have a mail service to deliver their mail that's why he says it and i guess well to make it more beneficial financially rewarding they make mail for the whole area but the mail service is really the workers are working for the government not for the individual now this might sound like a head if you think about it it's very positive i'll give you a perfect illustration did you ever imagine someone will say you know i have thousands of employees goes oh really wow what do you do nothing i'm unemployed so i have thousands of employees i have hundreds of policemen working for me hundreds of firemen postal service garbage men sanitation department they're all working for me is he right maybe you know the garbage man once tells you before the holiday don't forget i'm working for you don't forget me i don't forget you right but noah will say the garbage man is my worker if you say he is let me ask you a question in in many neighborhoods punk the mazel is that garbage collection is shabbos so what do people do they bring out the garbage friday what's the hecta he's taking your garbage on chavez territory he's not working for you okay you're a tempter of his panosa he's working for the government his job is to take your guard but he's not working for you so the premier got them seems to be saying that that's the way the mail service also is you put your letter in the box you pay money for it 55 with the stamp whatever it may be but he's not working for you now the marzella yo similar with science if cotton zion says this you saw it that maybe the whole postal service and the sanitation department it's not a um it's not working for the eid it's working for the government if you don't put in a box if you don't so he won't take your letter but he's not working directly for you and the truth is this is mukha otherwise i told you you have a problem with the garbage disposal how can you leave the garbage by the curb the terror it says that it's really working for the government and it's not your amir al-akhm why i said this is because i guess it's tsunami people go up to the mountains and in the mountains we have a new interesting twist of this island and that is a people in front of their bungalow or private home or colony whatever it is they have a private mailbox and you put your mail in and if you want the mail person to stop by your house you pick up the red flag and they stop otherwise they drive right by so the question is can i put my mail arab shabs into my private mailbox and lift up the red flag so the guy will drive by and oh there's mail and we'll take the mail so it sounds more intimidating because the guy is coming specially to your house to take your mail and if you don't pick up the red flag he won't stop and attack us on a wonderful new site hitachi says that the flag is worse because now it's almost certain they will come to your house but the embassies it taught me to understand that because at the end of the day it's the same identity if that male person drives right by you you can't sue them they will come at their convenience especially like the prima goddamn setup it's the same you saw it with a flag without a flag they're working for the government you're the temps of their panasonic and again the the rally would be from the the garbage men that come on shabbos because you left the garbage if you don't need the garbage they won't take it so that's why it seems that this is the same hectare of amir al-aqm but it's not really amir al-aqm otherwise i have another problem let's say you live in a one family house so typically the male person that delivers the male brings the male to your house why are you allowed to do that he's walking from him there's just a yokid delivering your mail if you live in a big apartment building with a lot of guy and you could say it's rebi basil room but he's coming right to your house and he's bringing you a mail he's carrying for you what's the hector the turret has to be the same your site he could leave it in his wagon and do it on monday or he's working for the government but it's the same i died to the nazi so lifting up the flag is not any more than just putting mail in the box or putting garbage on the curb now the mr brewer does say when you give it to the mechanic don't say do it on shabbos because then but i don't think lifting a flag is like an amir it's an indication the mail is here do what you want so we would come out that it would be even to put the mail in the private box and lift up the red flag the only thing is and this is our palms he had this problem he had a yiddish mailman that brought the mail to his house every day the person that delivered to the homes was a year the friar and his mom was horrified so he asked them very nicely please don't come to my house on shabbos and because he said it nicely the guy said the yid said fine and for years he didn't get received mail on shabbos that's not a humor that's make it a dinner if the year is coming just because of you this naive there's no is nowhere to then after but we're talking about if it's ego issue workers so we have this hetero of adayte next question you received mail and let's say you received a a printed div entire publication comes from the yeshiva every friday night moves our torah it comes in an open envelope so you don't have to open it you get it on shabbos well you get it on friday you read it on shabbos this week the mail was delayed it came on shabbos morning can you open the envelope you don't have to tear it just open up the manila envelope take out the debater and read it on shabbos so let me be very clear i'm not talking about reading material that's also to read on shabbos i'm not talking about any malachi being done it's a torah publication that's there's no malachi involved other than just enjoying the mail that came to your house on shabbos so the embassy you might say well the mailman brought it to your house on shabbos i died to the nafta you could do it on monday but we said according to the rambo it's awesome to have a no even if hadith enough say racial invasive so what's the heck that have enough in the mail even if that i didn't say but you can't have a no oh but for us or boise it's mostly with us because here we have the head of the rajva is coming not because of you he was sent by the yeshiva whoever sent the dhara torah so you can't ask to do it for you because he didn't come because of you so this case of mail that you're allowed to read on chavez is like the case of tough tesla's test where the messenger service was working with someone else and indeed you could have hannah from the mail on shabbos goofer especially like the premier garden he's not he's not a sphere for anybody he's working with the government so the case of a tour that came on shabbos is just as kosher quote unquote like the kiddish cake that came on shabbos morning you could have had no if you came across the trumps you have to figure out you know if it came from then you have a problem of how far you could take this now typically regular mail is much i must tell you most mail today especially is bills now bills is much either as a bottle stopper but the ammo is says today we don't use mail or any paper as a bottle stopper today we have different types of bottles of all stated that today the mail the bills and all the business related mail is goofy so mail is muktsa now of course a newspaper that comes on shabbos a secular paper has its own problems first of all the fact that you ordered it to come on weekends also that means you paying for a messenger service to deliver the mail on shabbos to your house this is not the post office this is not the nafta you're paying specifically for the weekend delivery weekend as in shabbos weekend is not sunday weekend is shabbos so this delivery service is a problem sometimes the newspaper was printed on shabbos and often the paper itself shouldn't be read on shabbos it's it's it's material that you can't read on shabbos whether it's business or advertisements or or worse so i'm not talking about newspapers that shouldn't that that have the problem of delivery and of the printing i'm talking about a person gets mailed that is allowed to read on shabbos so the fact that it came to his house on shabbos doesn't at all present the shiloh next question is i think we borrowed some did all about mail now we're talking about private deliveries la muscle someone is in business and he gets a order on friday that the person one say hey shipment he wants it right away so it should be posted that for the seller the the industry merchant to send something overnight delivery is a problem why i the receiver is a guy not often there's no yield in alice and eve it's a guy true the problem is not for the guy is the receiver the problem is for the sender but overnight means you're paying extra that it should go on friday and get there on shabbos that is not a dieter than say that is commissioning a guy eastern messenger service to bring the mail to bring the package to deliver the package on shabbos you know mail is mutter but you know i once saw many years ago a big truck and alan a but big letter three letters g-o-d so i was surprised oh they're being mephistimated they could spoil them but then i realized no it's guaranteed overnight delivery nothing to do with the initial item hiring the god is awesome because if you hire them a friday afternoon and it takes a few hours to get there you can't do it on friday and they have to be on shabbos that's considered commissioning a guy to do so overnight delivery or whatever it is if it can't be done before or after shabbos then it is us as the the fact that you're hiring a messenger service now if the merchant sends it with typical eight-day service within eight days and they decide to to ship it right away that's perfectly okay i'd like to then option but they may have to keep in mind when you have a private delivery service we don't have the hecta of premier got them of the postal service this already is a private business now the same question is would also be nigeria with when a yid receives an order from a guy's company and they send it he called it on friday and they said they what they said oh what would you like so obviously it's possible that if you say i want it within 24 hours that's awesome i the grayish company is sending it but part of the payment that you're paying for this item is the quick delivery so to order something that has to be as soon as possible even though the guy is hiring the messenger service but you're paying for that so it's basically amir al-aqm so that's why you have to really understand you know today it's a very popular business amazon amazon prime but basically prime amazon prime is a person pays extra for immediate service prime the way it works is they they figure out what you want where it's in which warehouse it is how long it will take it might even be out of state or might be out of country but they work as quick as possible say this item you could have it in two days or two hours depending on where it is if a person orders something on thursday and they say the quickest you could get it is two days in other words part of delivery has to be done on shabbos even if you order it on thursday it's still awesome if it's in unfeasible to send it without involving shabbos it's the same amir al-aqm so basically ordering on prime you have to realize it has to be done without hello shabbos okay i always mentioned prime you know there's a lot today people are talking about it's a good thing to mention you know we have to give panasonic to yiddish merchants you know i i see so many prime trucks in our neighborhood i'm pretty confident that the owner of amazon is making panasonic and that's putting it very mildly but you know it's taking away from the initial merchants so economy aramis is definitely a big big mitzvah but if someone does order with prime it has to be done within reason there shouldn't be a concern of amir al-aqm a person that orders something on again on wednesday and they say it could take you know up to eight days of course that's mother friday he says you know what send it at your convenience and punkt it comes on shabbos so again it's the same thing i'm like then i've said there's no problem having hannah would be totally in the region and base sieved the question that we began with i i received an order that was delayed a safer clothing so again no doubt about it that the it came to your house on shabbos done just for you but here since you wasn't it was not sent by issa you ordered it way in advance it was delayed we have mamish the case of the rajba the fact is that you ordered in advance the fact that it was delayed so this would be a real case of adaita the nafshay and legoyara but it still came on shabbos for that we have the rajba that you're not calling the shots it came from where it came from you also have the mirrors you side that the fact that you have no you have no connection to the delivery service it's a guy from out of nowhere so basically if you got a safe in the mail or got clothing in the mail and there's no problem as far as opening the package whatever i'm not getting into the locker aspect of it but they have enough from the item again the only issue you have to keep in mind is if the item came from on shabbos or so then you could use it in your house or in the uh city yesterday with which includes your house or your dollaramas but basically as far as the actual delivery we have the hete of the rajvum and we also have the hete of the rama of the magnaframe in the worst scenario da no is not a direct handout the guy did something other than delivering it's only the hannah from and the magnum says that i also want to mention a directive in the end of tough test says if it came from that's not an issue for you because the iss is for who that was brought bishvila here it was brought the the messenger of the the not the receiver so the is the problem of the misalight also i should mention the fact is that he didn't bring it good to have a no on shabbos supposed to bring it way in advance so there's no really and that would be okay now if you now you could appreciate that kadai to look into when you have a chance in the shinzai and seafood says that mail that a package something came to your house on shabbos you could have hando and the mr bureau could darken a few words but he captured the whole suga in a few words it's amazing i came from hospital it came from a guy he did it but he says first of all you have the hetero of the rajva and you have the head of the mother navram it's only caring it's not a direct tano so basically whatever came from you could enjoy it in your house for sure a book or clothing just don't go out of your dalaramis which could be your house or even within the ayriv if mail comes or a package comes that's muktsa whatever the reason but let's say it's muktsa so people have been asking this week's me because they throw they especially today because of cover they just dropped the mail and run and it's blocking the door people are going to trip so in the worst scenario if the mail or the package is muktsa so you can't pick it up can't move it so the simple eights are based on shiny and all of c tilted if you move it with any part of your body except your hands is mutha even the for no had to dick a reason so kick the male or move the male you have to kick it you can move it to the side with your foot and that would be tilted the goofy and that's muta in this situation so if the male is muksa move it to the side no one has to trip over it and you avoid that problem the mug the mr brewer and shinzai and sifka noon hey and the rav says it and see and point out let's say that you see the mailman's coming and he's bringing you a long-awaited uh book safer or torah publication it's not muktsam so in your haste you want to take it from him and why not you're in your house says mr brewer but be careful because if the guy if you take it out of the guy's hand you're making the hanako even though you're in your house and it's not mukchen is that awesome so don't be too quick to take the mail out of his hand that might be the completion of the sob and you don't want to do that on shabbos so of course don't do that listen to an exciting question i heard this a few times a few times has happened someone landed on arab shabbos from a flight and it was plenty of time to get back for shabbos so everything was going perfectly on schedule he went to find his luggage nowhere to be found he calls this person this personnel they come back with the wonderful news your luggage is in tokyo we'll have it in a very timely way please be patient we will give you plenty of free mileage and don't sue us you know they say it a nice way but it was misplaced it ended up somewhere else you'll get it don't worry the kid's uh he's not waiting around the tear of shabbos he goes home he has no choice shabbos morning shop is the afternoon doorbell rings who's there and he goes down who's there a delivery service something from the air airport here here's your luggage they brought it out of the marathon it was flown in whatever plenty melakas were done just for you this sounds frightening a guy did malacha just for you it's not a dieter the nafshi lahira they're coming that's gone jobs they were sent on shabbos but here we come to an extremely important el yoraba in rage i involve see cutting your tests has the following he writes her nishalti somebody asked me asylum a yin had a candle burning and everything was going great the guy the graisha made decided to be helpful and there was a little part of the the wick that was this that wasn't letting the fire burn brightly so they decided to take off the burnt wick you know that's like shamayata and but they they messed it up and the candle went out so they put out the initial candle so the guy decided to put on the candle now you have a problem narusha hitler akum you can't ever know your abnormal why because what the rabbi is saying is that this is a case of adai to deny the guy put out your candle and of course wants to re-light it because she doesn't want to get angry at her that's not a dieter the israel i die to the nazi and then he says an even bigger he says look at tyson's and the arab is very big it's a kadarkay but you know what he means to say the whole problem you can't have enough malachi's akuma is because if you have a not today next week you'll ask the guy to do it you are very far from asia and go to malacca for you i did everything before shout i lit my candles who asked the guy to put out my candles i'm not being bizarre i'm not talking to a guy so there's no khashoggi that almighty has to go into the malacca there's no problem of having handle aleph and the end of quotes now of course i would add why is it different if the guy lights the candle for me on his own on friday night or the guy puts on the lights for me friday night why is it different that says it's so different it's positive because if i have no light and the guy put on lights is doing it for me here it's doing it then after or there's no there's no hash that he will do it again but here the guy is doing it just for me to put on the lights i'd rather that's awesome so this is why there's a hetero when referred to as a hetero of tikkun toss if the guy messed it up the guy could rectify the situation in fact i saw the arkhasha because an amber tough son of says not only is the muta a no you could point out to the guy in a nice way excuse me you know you try to help me but you know the candle is out go see oh really and the girl put it on that's also motto because since at the end of the day when the guy re-lights the candle it's considered picking toys there's no problem now you can't directly say put on the candle that's a miracle that's dabber dover but just to say hey you know you tried but you you failed look the candle is out that's fine the point is that this is a hetero of tick and toys that there is no issue of having hanoi no now i ask you would this apply to the case of the lost luggage i got on a plane with my luggage they messed it up they sent it to tokyo where they get better and i saw most of the hindsight ice cream a number place can say you're right it's an economy now if it came from hustle trumps you have the restrictions of trump but beyond that there's no problem having enough from the luggage the orchestra is an umber tough meme test he says interesting insight you didn't have the luggage and they took it out of your hands they sent it the wrong place they all the case of tickets is you had it and they stopped your hand here they put it onto the plane in the bottom of the plane instead of going there it went elsewhere so maybe that's not the regular tikkun toys now it's true it's not the regular chicken toys what i think is according to the way they are your opposite the main hectare is that you are not looking for trouble you did everything the fact that the guy messed up you know what you're going to do in the future the second shot of the rabbit is i'm mapping this out in shabbos the guy came along and put out my candle why can't i have nobody put it on here also i'm an er i made my flight early friday morning to arrive safely and they send it to tokyo so there's no kashash of a future concern so i definitely think we could be making with the lost luggage again make sure you keep in mind where it came from if it's just home or not now of course if the airport for some reason we refuse to help you you can hire your private delivery service to bring their luggage because that's a regular miula akam but if they're doing it it's their slightest now let me ask you an interesting shower and this is extremely negay and it's come out of mitsubishi a person has a catering hall and a show whatever and he tells the guys to work having a party tonight friday night put on the lights you can even put it on friday morning i don't care just make sure you don't forget we need lights for the party guys no problem famous last words friday night it's christian there's no lights can the guy be allowed to put on the lights or if he didn't ask questions and put on the lights can you have enough on the nair so we are quick to say that that lachoira is ticking toys but that's not true it's not ticking toys there was never lights on that he closed he was supposed to put on the lights okay that's his mistake but he didn't put out life that you had so in this case this is not chicken toys this is mama's rage i involve seaf alive the it can have a no in fact even the guests can have a note because it's an it's a for all people as mr brewer says in shindra face if you've got an i in dalit now even though even though by the case of luggage is mutter because i had the luggage and they sent it elsewhere but here i never had the lights so that's why it's a problem there's no head of tikkun toys now the mr the himself says you know i'm going to leave your house because the guy put on the lights so that's a different issue if you if you're allowed to use the hall but there's no doubt about it this is not a typical conventional ticking toys now someone says he's doing it for himself to protect himself but that's not the regular chicken that's not the regular chicken toys chicken toys when he he you had that law and they prevented it and the orchestra is on the tough iron base right for the apostles there's no head to of chicken toys but what must be mentioned is why isn't this a regular diet to deny you told them do it friday morning so the fact they did it on shabbos they could do that on a friday morning but the emma says this is not true and this is important to mention first of all if even if it's only a dieter then after you think you still can have enough according to the ramble because even adapted absolutely you can have unknown but then you could say maybe this is let's say but there's a more fundamental problem and everybody said listen to this every case of a dieter the naf say is the guy you could do it left now julia the guy could fix the car friday or sunday the cleaners all the cases the fact that the guy chose to do a job this morning it's still a dated enough say until after shabbos says they could have done after shoppers here you have an unusual case that the guy didn't do it on friday now it's shabbos or never they can't do it on sunday for the first time friday night simcha the only time the guy could do it is on shabbos says rafael is in that safe possible is a beautiful chuva and if you learn the ian you'll appreciate it and i'm a china involved he says this is a mistake he doesn't have people it crept into people's mindset that if you could do it before shabbos and they do it on job as a right to the officer it's not true if chavez came they didn't yet do it now he wants to do it why are you allowed to do it or die to the nazi excuse me what's your other option turning back the clock during the friday it's not working do it on sunday for forever all the cases say is you could do it and he has araya and perhaps israel also the case of the the end of tough tests about delivery came on shabbos we have three reasons why it's muted we have the reason of the rajpur and the magnafram and and the what do you have to have reasons for say push it he could have done it he both do it on friday the parent said he's supposed to do it on friday true but he didn't now it's shabbos or what so once it's only shabbos to do it that's not a dieter the nazi he has other eyes and that's why he concludes emphatically there's an issa border that's not adaited enough all the cases the mailing all the case of derek vitishka it's only because he has the option of doing it after shabbos and the shabbos and on the tough summer bays tough iron base has the exact same shiloh you told them do it friday they forgot to do it on shabbos is not a dieter the navi and it's very bistavra because it's basically missing the ikaheta of now la mesa the with this comes up on a practical level is you tell the guy you should work because this is unfortunately common don't forget cut the plastic table across the shoulder show this for the kiddush before shabbos because you're not cutting tablecloths right falcon that schubert says could involve possibly three different melakas lockers you tell them dude before shabbat for shabbos and they forget so oh tied to the nav it's not true if it's only shabbos or nothing then it's nothing because that's no longer die to the nazi so people say no i could live without it i could eat on a on a wooden table okay so eat without it go without it but you're not gonna do that so that's not an idea i don't need it it's not no so it's something that's it's kadai especially in the shul the raven you see karimtay because it's mama so this is basically what he says and it's again a very deep understanding of and let me leave you with a treat or a bosnia has this shia la maison bays a person ate out friday night the suda by his children but he wanted to learn in his study whatever dining room so he set the light to go on 11 o'clock with a timer the guy is she made saw it's quarter to 11 and there's no lights so the greyish mate didn't ask questions but very helpful pulled out the timer and plugged in the light directly put on the light so now the light was burning the yid came home a quarter to eleven and go why the lights on because oh thank you to me because i saw it wasn't on so i wanted to go on so you didn't know about the timer because what you do now you put on light i can't have enough from the lights all shabbos somebody said wasn't this shirley so the person said this is ticking toys i had a light the guy you tamper with it so vosna with his tremendous analytical mindset is not it's not perfectly pick on toys because in this case in a regular chicken toys the guy put out the candle and re-lit it here the guy put it out and re-lit it just for the yid the guy put on took up the time and put on the light just for the tic heat thai is the guy did it for his own purpose did that but here it's gone for the eid but says ravasana but what what is the hector and you could be saying that is the second swar of the al-ghuraba this seed is an er that did everything before shabbos the fact that the guy came along and did something there's no further of mixo and you could have unknown i couldn't talk to you [Music] eight five one eight six five one email foreign [Music] um