0:00 / 0:00
Seuda On Shushan Purim Katan? - The Amazing Analysis of the Minchas Yitzchak
86 views
Subscribe and hit the bell for more great content! :) • Visit Rabbi Glatstein's site: https://www.rabbidg.com • Support & Sponsor: https://www.rabbidg.com/donate • Contact Rabbi Glatstein: https://www.rabbidg.com/contact • Order Rabbi Glatstein's Books: https://www.rabbidg.com/rabbi-glatstein-books Become a member of this channel to support Rabbi Glatstein and to get access to perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6MKyWBtQJme09iks2FksrQ/join #Rabbi #TorahClass #Shiur #LearnTorah #TorahStudy #Judaism #Jewish #Torah #RabbiDG #RabbiGlatstein #MachonMaggidHarakiah #Chumash #Parasha #Parsha #Parashat #Gemara #MishnaBerura #Mussar #Tefilla #Prayer
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this torah class is brought to you by
torahanytime.com
african
puram kathan so the question is is there
are there any ramifications of the 15th
of
adar alef
it's a very important rama ramon the
last semen in our hayim
he brings that there's the yeshua room
that one is
on the fourteenth of ada we shine
there almost says we're not knowing this
way but rama concludes the arabic sas
pasuda the whole discussion of rama is
only the fourteenth of adar aleph drama
doesn't say one word about the fifteenth
and the beheative is madaik
quoting the basic clearly the rama holds
avaloi bethesva not on the 15th there
according to rama there seems to be no
indian to celebrate the 15th
now the question is you could claire in
the rama when the ramos says that davika
the 14th and not the 15th does rama mean
because uh most cities that rama is
referring to are banayas so for the
banaya yaraois there's no indian of
celebrating the 15th even though duramas
said earlier that when it comes to sudas
purim
that there's a key of tui
and simon tuffrey sadike and sif based
ramos says
that the banaya archive
so it's interesting things uh important
to point out there's actually a he of
sudah on shushan purim for the banaya
all right
so is the ramos saying
that for the year is there is only a
khiev on
purim katan but not shusham
but maybe the kraken let's say
yerushalayim maybe
there would be shushan purim khattan for
the banay kraken in other words why does
ramadaku say a dalit is that because
that's a typical case but in fact for
the banay krachem they would celebrate
the 15th of other aleph or do the banay
krachim also not celebrate purim um
not celebrate the fifteenth of other
aleph so the mishabura quotes the prima
godim that says an even bigger the
mishabura in cemetery
quotes the prima goddamn that affleck
they do not celebrate the 15th of
of adar reshan now the prima godim is a
very big kiddush because technically you
could have said
um as the base yosef says that perhaps
where does the macarthur come from that
we don't celebrate the 15th of adar
reshan makar comes
so that implies the gemara is saying
that the um
in that there are certain
ramifications of
dalit
but the gemara doesn't discuss tesla so
apparently
other aleph is not recognized at all but
then the base joseph says maybe because
uh most most cases you're celebrating
the fourteenth so the basilisk himself
has the possibility that it could be for
the banay krachim uh they would
celebrate the 15th of other aleph and
yet the prema goddam is mahadesh that
the dinner of the rama that we we only
celebrate
aleph is for everybody including the
banay krachem so it comes out according
to the prima godim
points out that according to
the rama
it will come at a very big
because
typically
we know the bine kraken
uh let's say somebody in you shalom
doesn't celebrate either uh doesn't
celebrate your dalit right uh somebody
who lives in new shalom celebrates tesla
doesn't celebrate you dalit but that's
another shaini in adar alef there's only
one purim qatar on yoda there are no two
purim catan
in other words the vinaya shallam that
don't celebrate yadal other base they
will only celebrate y'dalid adar alef
that's the
summary of the minhasitrak however the
minh khasit brings a little wash
and has a very interesting khakira and
al-bush because the the language of the
reverse
in cemetery
is regarding um he's discussing
yo dalit and tasman
and he says
to increase in them what's bahem
so the aoraba is madayak that the bush
holds there's a mitzvah not only to be
marbesuda on yadal there's a mitzvah
so here for the first time we have a we
have a dissenting view to the
grandmother holds that test of is
nothing according to the prima goddamn
even for the money
and the says no it's a mitsubishi
including tesla now you could clara in
the bush when lavish says there's a
mitzvah to the imam but does he mean
for the kraken there's a mitzvah the
tesla but not for the ayaa rice
i would say uh the who doesn't qualify
and the bush is talking
to all of historians he doesn't specify
he means to everyone there's a
mitsubishi bohem to everyone dalia
rabbah adds it could be
that rama agrees
that it's a myth
even on test
rama only says you dalit dalia rabba
says that's the kavanagh of why the rama
adds the toy blade mishta tamid he's
being marbe tesvav even for the ayaris
but according to the baseline
in the world of bush you could declare
based on the following lavish says it's
a mitsubishi maharaban test above what
does all of us mean
see he's arguing on the rama so if
saddam rama
is the way the prima goddamn learns the
rama that the rama is saying there's no
indian of tesla other alif at all even
for the banay krachim then it could be
the bushes just adding there's an indian
on of teslav for the banay kraken but if
one would learn the
rama not like the mission bureau more
the way the basis seem to clear that
that maybe all the rama means is there's
no indian of teslav for the ayaroys but
of course there would be lebanese
then what the bush would be adding is
that there's an indian of teslav even
for the iris so
the the upshot is as follows
that for your dalit yo dalit aleph there
is an indian for everyone to celebrate
both
that's uh how the min has understands
the mishnah when it comes to tasva
the shita of the rama
according to the mission of is even the
bane kraken do not celebrate tesla
however according to la bush there might
be an indian even for the banayaras to
celebrate
teslav so maybe we could just add that
based on the cipher and the merchant
quotes of some software as well
that it could be making azekhara on
purim is adindo erasa so maybe we could
apply the rule suffix alohumra
and uh therefore the rama ends off lay
alive
and according to that line of reasoning
then there would be an indian at least
the harvest sas basuda even on tesla of
adar
wishing everyone afraid
you've just experienced another torah
class brought to you by torahanytime.com