Seforim and Peirushim on Maseches Moed Katan 1

[Music] although manipulated and we have people who have reached out to us where is the discussion about the cut down so here we are let's discuss today the name of the message we find in russian who call it by another name we're going to discuss about rashi if you have the new israelite gomorrah you see there's a ration which to me has been very helpful we're going to discuss with him we're going to have a discussion today about macon harry official we're also going to discuss however very important the discussions about this foreign availables and whether the the discussion out there about people who are fake fake and learning about kotlin because it's available talks about misa that's a message i'm going to be a separate discussion which we hope to be able to provide in the next week or two everybody brought how are you today okay so let's get going with the name of the message okay so first we have most people know them as its name marikata however we find that some people refer to it as messages okay now so first one romanticist shown points to rambam that refers to it as i think he calls it says the rambam refers to in some places as musa smashkin but the ali tamar from from which i've quoted in the past on um he has a piece where he shows that it's possible some people actually called it even mayad um not as bad not as mushkin okay however the question is i'm mentioning that people call it mashken who calls a mashken and um what is the even the significance of calling amashkan so as interesting as it is as boring as it is it might sound a fellow um yaakov spiegel wrote a book wrote many books actually but one of his books is called amudin batalda safer just to see it it's it's it looks like this and in one of the volumes he has a whole a bunch of pages where he literally checked how numerous numerous we shine and refer to the masata and he comes to the conclusion that ashkenazi many of them call it my cotton um provence richard and call my cotton swag we shine them some call my cotton sometimes you'll find that they do call it mashken as i mentioned earlier with mata starchon points to some rambams and then he says that the people we do find for example we shine them in italy they many times refer to it as mashken okay you'll ask me why in the world is this important i'll just mention very briefly sometimes especially in more recent years you want to uncover we find a manuscript and we don't know who it is doesn't have any and but it's believed to be a reason we don't know we we simply don't it does it doesn't say on the manuscript who it was or who wrote it so they so people who try to figure this out they try to look for all types of clues to identify the author sometimes these type of clues could help narrow down the search for example if let's say we see that the whole time he's referring to mike cotton as moshkin it might help to look oh he might be an italian region um and then somehow through that it might narrow down the searches to figure it out but okay this is just a side point um just to begin the discussion of today about my cut okay excellent so now let's get to rashi you know we had a discussion about rashi when we were discussing massages tightness but i think it might cut the discussion is a little more in depth and more wide ranging correct correct so to say at the outset i am definitely not going to spend the next two hours to speak and mention all the different possibilities in the back and forth about it but i will try in the next few minutes to briefly mention some of the highlights of the discussions about this um fascinating question okay so what's the first thing to mention is that as opposed to any other massage there are other massages we discussed tightness earlier that there's discussions about it but this my cotton has the most discussion about it with different possibilities about it um what who it could be what you'll see right now and not only that um many people feel that they actually did find the right rashi on might cut them whereas let's say some other massacres where once it became proven that it's not necessarily rashi they never found the rashi on the massacre which could mean that he didn't write it on those mistakes anyway um here are the basic ideas about about this topic number one the printing press was first invented in the 1440s the first talmud was printed pretty much as a whole talmud was by sensino in the 1480s then the next time the whole gemara is printed is by bramberg in the 1520s and small cotton is printed in 1521 or 1522. okay right away both of these chassis that existed they included rasheed where did they get rashi from okay so there were existing manuscripts that were out there that they made sure to get to use when they were printing their various talmuds now for already now for hundreds of years no one said boo about rashi so far the earliest that i'm able to discover that someone even says anything about it that it's problematic it might not be him is the radao the radao redeveloped in his peripheral a a few different academics in the middle of a discussion he says rashi on the riff is the real rashi of cotton and what's on the gemara is not rashi but it's a it's a early it's a different parish from an ashkenazi region that's what he says he does not explain why he says that in my notes i might cut and i explain more about it but sadly we don't have his notes on my cutting okay now the native in amit shayla also says as a as like like you should know at least two places i found he says that the rashi on my cotton is not on the side of the gemara is not rashi whereas the riff the rashi on the riff is rashi i'm going to explain it in a minute um drop more about this and so too another person um we'll discuss more about him shortly rabbi huda epstein he also caught in his safer minecraft he comes to the same conclusion then he says i came across the radal now i'm not sure what it is that because none of them elaborate why and why is it that no one up till this period of time of the 1850s said anything about it so much so that even a drop earlier than the 1850s um a work that only came to print in the in the early 1900s but it was written by someone that was a haver of the pastor and he made he was an artistral with the pastor that would date him that this work seemed to have been written in the 1830s and he talks about a topic which will also emerson discuss later on today about shaving in the middle of his cut the beginning of his right way in the beginning of his conversation where he wrote this small little hebrew on the topic he says he starts talking about rashi on my content and he says rashi you have to be medic in every single word every letter of rashi because we know there's nothing extra in rashi and it's over say how deep it is so it's ironic that he says those words on rashford so it seems no one really knew before the 1850s anything about the um that there's problems with rashi now another interesting source is the karen ira who also wrote a very important work on my cotton he's talking about arashi and he says maybe it's a thai cipher and then he says um he says maybe you could fix the thai cipher and then he says i ain't mashing the riff and he doesn't explain anything like what's up why is he showing you the rash in the rift now just now to elaborate or drop more in general we know everyone opens up your gemara and you see then the back there's rashi on the rift now everyone recently someone even asked me what is rashi on the riff so for most massachusetts it's not considered rasheed rashid didn't write on the riff it seems that in most moses that at some at some point in time in the late shining period of time riff became more used than gemara people were learning riff nakamura sometimes some people attributed to the fact that there were burnings of talmud and rift was allowed to be around so they adapted a pair so they took rashi and they wrote they didn't bring all of rashi but they took parts of actually relating to the riff and they and some people we don't even know who they are and they put it around the riff but in general it's a question if we could if we rely on it how reliable is it is it was a completely tampered but for some reason my cotton as i already i'm telling you the radar native they say rashi on the rifle is real rashi now i don't know how they know that but that's what they say okay um another interesting point is that which will also play out soon is the maritzkais who he said by themselves the first person to say that tightness might not be rashy he says that if you look in the inyankv also you'll see a lot of pieces of rashi that he does not find in the rashi and the printed chasse vilna when actually he didn't use the chassis as before but it's not there what's going on so he's also pointing out that there's that there's different rashes that the printed one on the side of your gemara that that i'm saying is already from the first printings of censino and bamberg and they're not they're in the inianctive are in the name of rashid because the yank of when he wrote his perish he put on the side rashi but he doesn't but he a lot of his rashes that he has is not going to be found in your standard rashi okay he just points it out he doesn't know what's happened okay fast forward two years later after the radar we said is 1852 a fellow named jacob reifman writes a whole article in german and he says that rashi ahmad khattan is not rashi who does he say it is the famous rabbena gashima aguila on the daily daily earlier shine him and he lists out his his proofs in this article written in german and that's 1854. okay a few years go by and a fellow named bear tsember who was a talmud of the arkhanair writes a small booklet where he discusses rashi on the dharam and american he comes out against this reichman and he concludes that rashi on the riff on this masset is the real rashi but he says the ratchet on the side of the gemara is also real rashi it's just an earlier version so all the problems that might come up it's not such a big deal rashi updated his perish that's the one on the riff so the riff when you open up your gemara and you use the riff rashi that's the most updated rashi whereas the one on the side of yagamara that's rashi but it's earlier edition okay this is going with an assumption that that many people have that rashi wrote various additions to his parish okay um now this is i said is in 1867 ramnas and david rabbinovich put out his work of dictu from on of baya and then around then he also did my cotton in the introduction he he says as a matter of like he doesn't say why but he says by the way rashi what do i use for rashi on this massage [Music] and he was a perish of robin garcia that i have and sorry he uses a manuscript and he also says that what we have on the side is not um rashi in the standard versions of your of your regular gemara that is written by who rabbenu garsham this is a similar conclusion to what i said earlier from yakov reifman but he says this himself okay comes along this dove bear december and he writes a whole book a small book and he's very sharp against um nelson dover rabinov they don't just write a claim they literally go through all the rashes on the massachusetts pointing out all different problems and he's very upset and he says i don't understand first of all it's not true it's really rashy and then he's also upset that the seven doesn't even bother to mention his work he says you know me and whatever okay the the dookie siphon writes back about it and he ends up writing also small work about this subject to prove his his method and he says that anyone who reads rasheem al-khattun it's a matter of a feel if you're familiar with rashi you will be able to pick up it's not the same language as russia and ganshas obviously not everyone is able to do that but let's say something like the duke of safrim and others they had this hush they're able to pick up it's not rashi nothing more to discuss it's not rashi is it someone close to rashi maybe yeah but it's not rashi rashi had a certain amazing siva that no one was able to mimic they they even say this old messiah everyone heard growing up this i'm sure that they say um that rasheed's said that we could mimic i think rabbinical said it or not one of them said to mimic rashi's perish on humish we could but actually on chas impossible um i think but maybe i'm mixing it up but anyway the point is that rashi's purse on shas is impassable it's written and it's a unique thing no region was ever able to come to write such a um such a unique parish with such a part of the uniqueness is also with the such a small amount of words to the exact points anyway the duplicate from says sorry i disagree with you and then he apologizes to him for not mentioning his work and he okay that's uh beyond the scope of this thing but um fine so that so so far we we've reached to at this point we're holding in 1869 and we have a few different opinions out to what's going on fine fast forward the question is what in the world is the dukey siphon referring to when he says it's verbena garcia gayla what's going on over here so if you open up your shots vilna you'll see in various massachusetts they have on the side a perish called urbana garcia miraguela what happened is the vilna when they were printing the shasta they want to get you to buy their shafts so they went and they hunted down purusham of all types we shine them in them that they can find in various places in various collections they put on the side and so too rabbinical they tracked it down and they put it on certain sections on the side this is in the 1880s comes along 1896 and a fellow very learned person of ram epstein he writes an in-depth article in german where he says it's not rabbinagashima gayla um and who is it it's uh he calls it perish magenta which basically means of this of of the of rabbinica but it's not roman gosham he outlines this a very in-depth article luckily i don't read german but it was print it was translated into uh hebrew a few years back and you can read it easily in in this hebrew version it was printed in a journal called okay now his his findings were accepted today that perusian that are under the name rabbini gershomer are really perish magenta it's called okay but they're it's not far away from rashid this is basically a generation before rashi people that rashi ended up couldn't even met some of them um are people that are writing these purusha among some of them and one such muslim what we have on the side of aragon okay some people throw out i it could be from epstein throws this out as a possibility others run with this later later on some people go with this it might really be rebel yakum others say maybe rebecca was involved with the parish but it's not strictly or beyonce it's a bunch of people writing it whatever it is okay but it's not remain but the point is at this point we're holding that in 1896 the conclusion is it's not ravina garcia margaila but it's somewhat it's a ashkenaz parish that is a little before rashi okay fine fast forward to 1939 a a great time with him name remarkable he prints a parish and he calls it perish which is we already mentioned the name of one of the reshainam and then he writes in his i now found this is the real rashiyama okay and each and he proves it based on various proofs of introduction like people do in their introduction comes along with schlemmy is evan in his book reviews that came out um i believe two years later 19th um around that time and he writes that it's a great parish it ain't he's not buying into the fact that it's rashi you don't have enough proof that it's rashi he's malama it's course maybe it is rashi if you go with the rashi wrote many maduros maybe it's a maduro rashi but he's not he's not going with that okay fine great so now we're holding 1939 another possibility has been thrown out there thought fast forward to 1961 1961 a fellow a talmud of the talmud of vermeil rick but then he um to put a mildly went different ways um world war ii tragedies also got involved with that his name was his name was afraid kufifer a tremendous tremendous talmud who was prolific wrote a lot in polish about judicial history jewish history and also in hebrew printed tons of manuscripts he discovered in 1961 what he claimed to be the rashi he found this based on a manuscript in that that he worked in the manuscript room in hebrew universally and he proves bhararikos in his adama based on various things such as many quotes of roshanim in the name of rashi on the masefta that are not found in the rashi on the side of the are found in this manuscript and he has other proofs and he comes to the conclusion in 1961 i found rashi to to um now this rashi for example so it's not only an academic this academic um frank holds like this hillman who's a famous was a famous person legendary um tamukham that was a kanoi but he was prolific also he's one of the people that worked on various projects such as the shapzi franco rambam the maftahis and the text it was a big bucky and all different things tremendous time put out many russian he went through very carefully the rashi marcotte and he says rashford cotton is not arashi he comes a conclusion it's vice he says it might even be uh moritz was the one who worked on it because there's too many theorists you say the final editor let me say could be this really that some parish is not a problem but someone tampered with it a lot and that person um he says but what is the rashi this edition from the sufframe kuffer is the real rashi and he just understand even though he was uh uh but he had this ability of of picking up all these types of things he he's he's legendary in various aspects that he he had this type of question he says it's real rashi then he says it will be a great course if someone went ahead and reprinted the shots and did it on the side with this rashi that's what he says a mother hashem that comes to the same conclusion also tremendous tam niflo is still alive rebecca and cypher he also says kuffer's edition is the real rashi so now if you want to get a hold of a copy of kufrin's edition you could go to hebrew books they have it it was printed by muhammad a different time maybe we'll talk about it okay art scroll shas anders bahadur on the side of their gemara have rashi mix of what's the the only difference is art school says that it's from kofir doesn't i don't know why not maybe early editions is how they did i'm not sure a friend of mine told me that he wrote to rachael kaniewski about about that he saw in a gemara that used kufifer's edition without thanking him and it gave our cars a tie to kankarievsky so kiwi had some type of taino to a crying can he asked him yes wrote him i have nothing to do with the decisions what goes on in the printing of the gemara but the point is that these good island these kosher people felt that rashi is is from that the kuffer edition is rashi yeah amazing wow just following the history fascinating but isn't the art school oh he's the hard they have some type of deal i don't know what the deal was yes it has to it is for myself the difference is but they write down they both write down this and they think that's the whole difference that okay anyway the the story the story we're reaching to the conclusion because of um time but i just i just want to ask three three four more points about it um so you would think 1961 this guy proves it he proves it very well and cipher deals with it and and what's his name emma davidson you think you'll be finished the story is over no story's not over of course various people who um check and death at least three four different academics went through this billion and they came to the conclusions it's not and they okay fine then then a work came out namish in in this is in 2007 a fellow from barryland went and he went through this sugiya of rashiya marikatambil mamish every tag shipper tag of rashi and the manuscripts he comes to the conclusion this kuffer is 100 right but he proves it and uh obviously time will not allow to go through it his name is jaco fuchs um excellent job proving beyond the shadow of the doubt that rashi on the side which the staff if you're using art school or his brother called or you could go to hebrew books and get the actual thing kofifer it is the real rashi and he deals with all the issues that were raised over the time about rashi on the sector just to mention um two last points one that he deals with is as follows they made someone found in the in the late 70s a major discovery of people always want to know how the talmud was printed and when was the first printed so i mentioned to you the dates that i mentioned was 1480s and then the 1520s was there any other editions so it seemed this was called a bibliographical mystery they didn't know and then suddenly in 1970 they knew something but they weren't sure and then amazing discovery was discovered of a bunch of fragment pieces of pieces of gemara that printed in places in spanish countries in spanish places that were not known up till now what was interesting is that these this is in the 1480s and it might even been the earliest printing of the talmud um just we didn't know about it because the mama sure almost all destroyed because right then these hidden in portugal and everything they had to they were chased out of their lands so so almost everything was destroyed miraculously they discovered stuff what happened is these gemara pieces that they have some of them have rashi on the side and it turns out it's very dima to the kuffer rashi so you say there was there's further evidence that this rashi existed and the the italian the italian printers the heiner sensino and bramberg when they printed it in the 1480s and 1520s they didn't know about this rashi for some reason but anyway okay this was a discovery based on works of uh of a fellow heimdae mitrovsky and this yaka fox deals with it at length now just to end this thing um this part of the discussion there's a fellow joseph keller he put out arashi on my cotton also based on kufr and more it's also available in hebrew books um and his rashi and the last step the last point of arashi to conclude with this because it's just very interesting i read i reached out to there's some academics in bariland that have made some incredible i called science fiction programs that they are able to identify based it has to meet certain criteria but they're able to identify works sometimes they're not sure if it's a certain work sometimes a truth of the rash but could really be the ramban they have a whole sophisticated computer program and has to meet specific um criteria as i said but they to identify if it really might be the raja it might be the ramban and they through this tools they have been able to identify some things not everything are they able to um so i sent them i asked them could you check and what's the story russia might cut on so they spent a lot of time trying to based on what they have because they didn't have in the computers in their in in word and in their computer system they didn't have the kuffar edition and they don't have all the things but they but they did conclude that it's it's it's very it's it's uncle it's not conclusive rashi on tinus if you compare it to other massacres but there are certain things certain characteristics that only appear in rashi mode qatar and stuff like that um this is a fellow maisha koppel and avi schmidtman they were very kind enough to to run this through their programs and hashem eventually taking all these tools that are out there and the conclusions of of about rashi such as let's say this fuchs fellow and others eventually we probably will be able to come to a more accurate based on computers also of various massages if it's rashy or not okay on the um as they say just a very big sir i apologize very um so short about rashi on the museum beautiful really really fascinating okay so let's move right along to the reshinem i'm sure there are some of the classic we should learn not that many we shine them i might cut them so what could you add okay so first i'm gonna i'm gonna throw out there very fast we'll go through this very quickly number one a lost region that seems to have played a major role in the reshanam this was brought to attend to my attention by my uncle rabbi spitz is the rivet it's a lost region and you check into it you'll see the derivative appears to have written on my cotton and richey had had it and used it a lot just not which is not so we say that we're shining that normally quote derivative quoted as one thing that you'll find even in this massage but you'll find even the taisis rush quotes derivate something like 75 times in this massacre which is unusual but we don't have derivative got lost over time why that is is a different story okay um we'll discuss some some of the reshame we'll discuss in part two when we talk about availus but let's i referred to last time has a list of what's there and he listened from the sectors which we shine him he lists you one region okay now the rifle wasn't so common already i found that the heimik shayla is miyashiv that uh someone asks akasha the baja sakashana smack and he says if he would have had the ritz for he would have realized it's not akasha but even the ritzman wasn't so common um also interestingly is there's a tisis rid which is printed in the 1860s um with us comma the shalamatia with harass and but um even though the hida uses the writ a lot i don't know why he didn't mention it on this massacre okay so at this point if we're going and we're focusing on the 1860s already up to the 1860s there's literally almost no reshayman what changes what changes is in the 1930s something happens and a bunch of swarms suddenly come to print in the 19 in 1937 i believe what happened so many people have heard you know there's different majors today everyone here is maestro of ko kamakonyu an early macomb which still exists and does still put out stuff once in a while it's called machon harry fishel so this harry official he was a veer he supported a lot of institutions in the 1920s he came to scroll and he funds a building of a beautiful house and this magistrate of cook which still exists till today in the 19 1927 he realizes he only has daughters there's not going to be a shame his name is not going to have a future he wants to have us a hume of his name for the future he has a meeting with cook in the ninth this is 1927 they come to the conclusion they should open up an institute for tyra um to train people that they'll put it they'll also put out works etc etc okay if cook heads this organization um they they build it they have a bunch of different um people coming from all over to george to try to join they pick out their um their they pick out from i think it was 50 different people that um try to apply they pick out um after extensive testing oral and written oh sorry there was 102 applicants 52 came back for the oral this is this harry official wrote a um they brought a part of an autobiography and mckitzer eight at the end 18 people pass these people um end up working in the macomb and fine he discusses that length about it okay now 1935 so this macho is going on for a few years 1935 of cook is very very sick it's right before he dies he realizes that they're going to need um someone to run the machon so they hire the very well-known person rashol lieberman and rachel lieberman becomes the head of the macon and he's the person in charge and they start working on they continue working on different projects because roof cook was not able to he was very sick right at the time now when we've cooked we know already from the few years before with cook when he created this macan they they had outlined a bunch of projects and there's even a safer hayover that came out one of harry officials visits discussing all the projects that cook was working on and others are working on um until rivercook died okay we've cooked eyes they decide to put out slurm i might cut them from manuscript that didn't exist until now the first perish that they put out is amiri it was never printed on my content before they put out the hindus they put out a texas rush and then they put out a safer called they call it the shita the talmud okay so basically what happens is in one period of time the people of this macon funded by harry fishel the the in the year they were cooking if they're footnoted and everything um they put out these for we shine them they're all available on hebrew books um and they've been reprinted a few times with footnotes done properly based on the manuscripts so already in one quick year you got four we showing them knocked off okay 1957. um um a fellow rabbi mercy puts out a remi nil another region also america so you already got already a few more you so so far in the 50s you're able to learn you're already able to learn more okay we fast forward to 1966 israeli puts out a bunch of ishain in my mind cotton it's they put out just to list them they put out a rabbina garcia mara gala turns out this robin america relating tower discussion earlier with rashi that's going to fit into that whole story we won't get into it they put out the this read based on manuscripts so although i mentioned high school was printed but they redo it they put out a lee kutum of a seifernair a talmud of a possibly automatic rajma and some other material on a nice fat volume on the massage i think it actually might still be available for purchase so basically the world of reciting suddenly in the 60s explodes and one but one last thing just to mention as far as and um 21 the kivitz you should say you someone prints an article based on manuscripts of rabbihilmi parizam i had just mentioned that israeli printed something from hillary there is this is another parish this might be actually him that might be a talmud but they're from the same school anyway bottom line is shining there's more shining we're just mentioning some about them that's their story for shining for right now eleazar after you finish giving these historical backgrounds and all the proliferation of resigning them i feel like lafayette mothers are gonna need more time in their day to start learning that's the idea that's ideal okay fine so now that we're going to have more on our day to learn we shine them maybe we'll find a few more minutes to learn them what am i there what are the modern days for him okay so we'll do this very fast so first we we've already discussed on on on tinus that there's a safer hush of a safer a good one in the karan ira so he also has a very thorough safer on my cotton another safer that's written really on shasta but he has a nice amount of my cotton also worth mentioning is a he was a he was his name's epstein he wrote called minecraft to learn [Music] he was rich and he was also at some point he learned which is a remarkable thing this is fascinating on many different fronts but what's what's important for us is it talks about my cotton i believe it's available on hebrew books also another literature safer not much is known about the author is that safer called isis aaron it's also available in hebrew books very unique safer has very hush of of lit fishing contemporaries of his and the safer is unique because he also talks he also he was also into kabbalah and he also um had great havana in areas relating to astronomy he also has a little bit of rosh hashanah he talks about anyway he has a nice amount of cotton a nice saver to check out and then there's two last two acronym of of uh layer of before we get to more contemporary number one is a safer called sinus passum sinus passim was written by a great guy also a valajoner talmud um and this great guy his name was rabyakov and he um he was prolific it was a talmud uh talmud of rakhine villager and he wrote on the yosef because it's not it's actually it's on in the back with the riff so some people say it's actually iran and a lot of massachusetts is always a big problem is that iran is lucky isaf and that's its own big discussion from mike cotton he says as a dover pashut um he wrote a whole safer on mary's massachusetts [Music] and um and that's also available also on hebrew books now just to mention with him a fascinating uh a story i i recently came i recently put to put together like this there's a book um a incredible book growing up in yeshiva my russian shiva rebellion epstein was very fond of quoting this book it's called haggadah me minsk this is how it looks it's a book about the argonaut the minsk now what's significant about this book it's not like most cadillac books it's is that the author was a talmud that knew his subject the minsk again well he lived in his house for a few years he was the malamid of the minsker goddess he was the malama of the minsker goddess children for a few years some of them and they're becoming tremendous and the book is full of unbelievable insight and stories about little and other things and here he has a story about dominska goddard when he's very young and he's a tremendous balcony and he's learning his shoes he was learning in the various schools and he was very let down um he felt he was let's say 10 12 years old and he felt that the lima that people were learning they were learning but he didn't like it and just wasn't talking to him people were breaking their heads spending full days learning the martial um and then a line in a tyson or something and he just he didn't he didn't go for it his father was nervous his father wasn't his father was very nervous so he brought him to this side this author of sinus possum um and he brought his son to and he had a whole conversation with him and he said to and the minster goddard in this book it records this whole back and forth that he had with the sun is past him and the minuscule goddess says that sometimes you can have a conversation with someone that's a game changer for the rest of your life this conversation that he had with this goddamn excitous possum was changed him and what what he said was in short it's written very well as a side besides the book being um an excellent book and reliable it's extremely well written it's so well written that the author was a tremendous talent song is very hard to understand his language because he the author was a murderer bucky in the hebrew language there's tons and tons of footnotes they have to give it out to tremendous tamil to figure out what it meant anyway make a long story short what was the story what does he tell this young minska goddard was no says that sometimes it's true you shouldn't break your head the whole day learning but it's still important to learn some just that's how you open up your mind so to speak you have to spend some time on let's marshall as an example because after you get familiar breaking your head with the lash and then later on will be much easier to learn it and then and and then and there are many important ones but so there has to be some middle ground but you have to spend time on it and he says let me show you an example he pulls them out and he says look at this piece in the mookie yosef and then so the message says and he says no it's not true he says there's a good shot but if you understand the signone the lushen of the nimuki yosef which i'm now telling you is exciting he was the author of the work on the nucleus of course possum you'll understand not and he shows him into a government and he convinces me to gobble and then whatever okay that rest is as they say is history okay one last work amazing is a safer call this work um is also by luffy chicago um this literature gobbler wrote many swarm on them [Music] prolific he also wrote a safer on the rectanti and detachments in manuscripts he left behind the safer under paradise which only a few years ago came out vi um they finally printed it now the maseratis maisha was printed after he died his son printed it it was printed in 1924. just one fascinating piece of information that the son writes in this dhamma says my father was a very gifted it seems he was a very big smart balchistrian and it seems that in the town where he was the masculine got them and he was being and they he was learning with them already and he maybe had he had um and it seems they almost got him mean to say and they i guess they told him he's going to be a great professor something happened and barack hashem he left and he ended up going to valerian he ends up learning a village and he ends up having to do rivets well hollander becomes a great he gets a stellar becomes a great love and a prolific writer and what's interesting you always hear about certain people they say about different people oh they had some type of story they have some type of story with um with what's his name with a scholar here's one that his son is writing about him and he successfully won and he became the great gain and prolific writer okay now just to conclude very fast is that mercedes-benz people is complaining not we don't have content i don't mention contemporary sperm so let's just mention first there's a safer arizona very very good there's also a safer of rebellion [Music] very useful um another safer is magnetim i happen to enjoy this after a lot but amit hashem will discuss him more when we get to massachusetts and now to conclude the contemporary topics of the music so the eerie already writes that uh which people know very well musa deals with khal made and availas and then svice gets mixed in so for halloween just to mention not to go into just to mention it i i don't want to get shot over here number one the safer on the massachusetts which i believe article recently reprinted it but it was printed in the 70s um in the early 70s or in 1981 frame of david zucker and ramaisha francis called khalamoid article reissued it it has tons of it's it was always considered the safer on the massachusetts not to say from the sector and the safe route [Music] okay that's one contemporary say for on sorry on the topic of khal maid another safe is the kute allah um also another important safer another safer to mention is you casio farcas [Music] and there are many others not to take away from them i just can't list them all and then as khalil made and related there's controversies like everything else in allah so just to point out one tooth farm on that one is shaving on halamite everyone knows a big tumble about it so there's a beautiful safer from mayor benio called one last safer relating to halamide is a massive safer it was seen as believing so they say it's this fact it is um it's called charsham in ashkenaz what is it about it is 916 pages about the topic of wearing chillin on halloween fascinating fascinating topic um also relating it also relates to the right sum of the rise okay fine now that is the the swarm relating to halo night i'd just like to conclude because it gets in there and because we're in the year of shemitah i'm not going to speak about rico's i just have i feel we have to listen list them some of them basically a few meters ago i walked into those farms to stroller i said what's happy farmer there and shmita said they just began we have over 75 and this was not even a big sperm store today if you're going to anywhere in arts israel sperm come out every other day about shmita still and they're still coming out i don't i'm not aware of any recent bibliographies collecting all this just to mention because it relates a little bit over here so for me i'm an artist i'm just going to spend one minute listing some names number one one of the best essays is an essay from roseville just gives you a background from the classical sperm of cooks the pasta had there's an addition that has the red basil very important of course we can't go without mentioning the madame [Music] incredible incredible safer of course at one point it was printed to change it a little bit and then it was the to kilo casher it up and then later on it was more released than the proper edition fine there are camouflaged it's being learned here yaya valaila everyone and it's an incredible work you have the works of kamakahana we have the famous safer shemitah from rav to kashinsky of course it goes on and on and on contemporary and new works keep on coming out they put out they just recently put out a reviews of engel safer they reissued with the heart's fee from two pieces of frank's material robert yosef they made a new edition of wolves pirates on schmitta a friend of mine rebellio greenswag they also just collected his essays on shmita and to conclude that history um i'm sorry about in a week about about a week a new safer that um somehow it has some connection to me is supposed to cut supposed to be coming out from a manuscript of a rhinos on schmitta from met that was never printed before and just to conclude with history the excellent safer two volumes so far from mubarak's hutner called looks like this it's a fascinating two fat volumes on the topics of shmita and also there's the essays it could be found online of eitan on the topics of shemitah available to read and get some information about it that ad can part one on the uh well amazing and you're not going to mention any schmidt controversies we don't know we're out of time no we're out of time so i already already stuck it in the loophole so to go into that so if i let's look forward in the next week or two on the edition specifically on avelos everybody continue learning my content don't stop and we'll hear what rebellion has to say unavailable [Music]