Sefiras HaOmer: Is it Governed by Time?

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay we're going to discuss today uh and um the ramam tells us there's a mitsody to count seven complete weeks from the day that you bring the image says the days with the weeks in other words there are two parts of the Mitzvah first the Torah says which refers to the weeks and then the Torah says that there's a midst of the count the weeks and there's a midst of the count the days when does the Mitzvah begin you can't from the beginning of the day so therefore you have to start counting at night therefore you start counting at night on the 16th of Nissan Israel this Mitzvah every Jewish man is obligated in this Mitzvah uh it doesn't matter where even at all times even when there's no based on mikdash what about women are Potter presumably the reason why the random says women are Potter is because it's a Mitzvah says and in fact the cast of Mission arrives with phares he rise to number two Mission devices okay now we know there are many Mrs assassins that are governed by time that women do anyway women come to hear the Schaefer they shake the leviness they sit in the sukkah they're not obligated to but they do it so we're at Magilla is we're going to leave Mrs aside for now but in general there are many missus that say that a Shazam grandma that women do even though they're not obligated so the question is foreign what would women be higher than before if it's not if it's a that's also a discussion is it a Mr says my grandma maybe we'll see but the rambam tells us that clearly women are positive from the Mitzvah of of just as an aside very interesting if you look in the mission of bura by the way the zoyar says only for men interestingly the mission of Brewer brings down women says women have taken and made this Mitzvah obligatory now what does that mean we know the sukkah women sit in the sukkah but it's not a for them to send this women they Blow shuffle they come to hear the shepherd but it's not a clave what does mean they've already made it and in fact asks he has absolutely no idea what the mug and Abram is talking about when the Magan Abram says they made it how could they make it if you're not obligated in the midst of you can't make it ends off with a question what the mug in Abram means okay Mr Brewer says this is just a little bit of a tangential point the mission says seems to me in our communities women don't count that's what the mission bull writes now listen to this women should not make a bracha when they can't even if women want to count they should not make a bracha for two reasons reason number one they're not gonna go through the whole thing counting this is just a tangential Point says women should now make a brother a they're gonna make a mistake one night because they're not you know they're not traveling out to count the maxol you know they're not going to show they're making to make a mistake in the day they're not good they're not doing it but Seaboard they're definitely they don't like mistakes fill out the tire trust to them says the suffer the terror entrusted it to them seven days they could count 49 days you know 49 days women definitely they'll they will make an error that's the first thing he says and number two in most cases they don't know what the words mean and the mission River seems to conclude by the way that that no the mission Brewers saying that probably not no no not not at the very beginning but Mr Brew is saying two reasons why women should not make a bracha a they will make a mistake B they don't know what the words mean now who cares if they don't know what the words mean presumably what it means is in order to count you have to understand if you're just saying uh Uno you don't you don't you're just memorizing words but you don't know what those words mean that's not called Counting now both of these reasons you could make the case that today a women no maybe you know they'll set an alarm they'll send a message or they'll have a reminder they won't forget right and you can make the case today that you know they definitely do understand the meaning of uh the counting so perhaps maybe even the mission Brew would concede today women should count with a bracha but again our P Kabbalah the midst of sures only for men just point out but she can come without yeah according to Mr Bush's account with that in the house of the stapler the women counted with the bracha i the question is but the mission of Brewer says you know they'll forget me that's why the Statesman made in his business the every night to remind them and to instruct them how to do it okay so by the way concludes like the mug enough from that if women want to count uh they could count okay okay that's the that's the mission bro the mission Brewer brings down two smartas that women should not make a bracha but those uh Stars you have to try to uh see if they still apply now okay but that's not the point of the shirt the point of the shirt today is to look into the comments of the ramban again according to everyone if you would have asked us what type of mitzvahima we would all say it's a Mitzvah Mitch right after all you can count 49 days any time in the year right you can't start counting time you can't start counting you start to count when beginning the second the second day of pesach and it goes until it's a specific okay we're gonna talk about the time of the year in this year well you know I don't know if we're going to get to the fact that you don't do it during the day but it's it's specific to a time of the year and in that case we would all agree that Swiss armor should be considered a Mitzvah and grandma yet the ramban says something most startling gives us the rule that women are Potter from mississaug she has my grandma says ramban what are mississaug let me give you a few examples let me illustrate let me give you a list of the mitsu SASE many midsos that are not governed by time were left out for example Myra the keyboard right ah fear of a parent honoring a parent grandma right my grandma I'm not sure what what specific source is referring to but he's saying it did enlist everything it left out the following right Myra keyboard like he said Grandma right by the way when you do kiss do you make I share it to the channel right yeah right why do you have to say the word you say do you say you know actually what do you have to say um they're supposed to be two covers underneath you cover underneath the blood you're supposed to put underneath and on top so the baafar alludes to the second Halo to the Mitzvah there are two parts of the missile okay what else racist racist hagas right the first sharings of the of the sheep have to go to the coin matanus is which is more related connected time you can only start counting beginning from the second day of Face Off right if a guy starts counting the first day of pesach he already lost the spirit before he even started so what's wrong about talking about that is man grammar okay this is a plea dick around band or the methoshim jumped to the cause what does the ramban mean yes am I wrong bikerma the first fruits right yeah I thought that's brought on shoes okay so that's the question the question is what does the ramban mean that spirit is okay so first we come to the chubas Avenue foreign it's possible that the ramban holds the toy of this is not dependent on the time that you bring it that you should bring it on the 16th of Nissan in other words when is the time to bring the Omer is the time to bring the armor the 16th of Nisan or the day after the 15th of Nissan right you say it's the same thing right is it right here's the question is it when do you bring the nightmare on the 16th or the day after the 15th that's the same thing no it's different you start counting the Omer from the time you bring the the carbon the carbon owner triggers the midst of serious Omer right the Torah says um begins okay you're supposed to count from the beginning because you need to memorize we're not discussing they as opposed night as opposed today we're discussing the fact that it's at a certain time of the year right so that should be isak the time to count the Omer is not on the 16th of Nissan but rather the day after Shabbos which means in other words like this the time to start Sphero sorry there is Nissan it's the day after the first day of pesach what's the difference the day after the first day pays after the 16th of ah let's question how you look at it if the midst of serious image triggered by the 16th of Nissan then you'll say what the 16th of Nissan that's a time so it's a time it says nine grammar women should be Potter but if you say it's not the 16th of Nissan that triggers the Mitzvah it's the day after pesaf that triggers the mitza okay but it's still governed by time it's still the 15th of Nissan which triggers the answer is but it's a time that women are high even because anything related to pesach women are obligated in they're obligated they're obligated the midst of supreme they have to eat the mara they have to bring the current past life they can't eat hamit so there are the whole 15th of Nissan is a yamtif which is which they're obligated in and now the Torah says and start a Mitzvah the day after that day so that means this Mitzvah is dependent on that date but even though it's a date it's a date that they are completely obligated in and therefore says this would be a Mitzvah that women so let's see let's see how he says it ah so okay let's see IM Kane aims Manchester it's not the 16th day of Nissan that causes it then timer and if you're saying still you could say it's true it's not the 16th but it's pay Sach the 15th that causes it says or the midst of that Shabbos meaning of pesach nation is so too when it comes to the Mitzvah of spirit how are you going to exempt them is you can't say well the women should be Potter you know why because because they're only high of the day after pesach yeah even everything okay oh so you'll ask but what do you mean but you can't count zero during the day so that's why it should be considered as my grandma because you can only do it at night night not during the day them the opinion of many postgame is that you can Harvest and count during the day MK halila go so then you could say that Spirit indeed is governed by time because why because you can't do it during the day but the rambam sheet is you could do the exterior during the day and you could do the spirit during the day and therefore says the Avenue what the ramban May mean is you know why women are kindness because it's not the 16th of Nissan which obligates them it's the day after the 15th and the 15th is the day they're entirely High then and therefore women would be fine you could ask is that really what the ramban means according to the Avenue is man grandma yes it is nine grammar it's just it's this man grandma that women are high even but that's not what the ramban says ramban says I'm listening to you Mrs Right that's what you want to ask that's so it doesn't fit in so well into the wrong band The ramban is not saying I'm listening to your midst of women he's saying I'm listening to you Mitchell's not governed by time it is governed by time it's just it's a time that women are having that means they're not governed by time right that women are women women are high even I understand like the first state like the 16th going all the way it's all tied in with the foot with face once pesach triggers it so this is like a pesach induced Mitzvah and whatever women anything to do with pesach women are right there right NASA Mara comments are seriously so this Mitzvah says that is okay it just ends off that is all those around bands seems to say women are thriving tourism okay yeah if 16 came out on Shabbos is is it so that's uh that's a big question right um that's what the sudoken said right I I didn't mention anything about the doctor yeah you had to bring it over right nobody said maybe she don't bring your number am I correct correct yeah would be the 16th came out on Shabbos which is special Friday it's the first day of Payson is Friday he's saying in time that the basement if pesach would come out on a Friday and the second episode was Shabbos would you bring the Amer even if Shabbos they they go and they make the kitchen okay the tire gives her the tires what's out of her but from Mitzvah it's given to her name is [Music] okay okay you're saying maybe we'll maybe we'll see about that a little bit what his answer is his answer is he's trying to give a spiral why women should be having spiritual honor what's this pharah this Farah is that if the mitza was triggered by the 16th of Nissan then you'll say women's because it's triggered by time but it's triggered not by the 16th but the day after pesach which means pesach is what's causing the Mitzvah so you're still still caused by time but since pesach has a date that women archive in everything regarding that date any Mitzvah that's connected to pesach women and then the Torah says start counting the day after pesacher says if this Mitzvah is the midst of counting from the day after pesos as well even though it's Guzman grama but it's it's the man it says man which is in other words so you give it different tattoos like uh like like something like this so you're saying it doesn't really fit into the Man Band because ramban is saying a list of Mr Shane as man Grandma okay that's what you know we're bothered by it doesn't really fit into what the ramban is saying yeah [Music] no you can make the case that pesach induces the days of the second day offensive it's not really counting I mean you're counting to shavus but the way the Torah says is it you're counting from pesach and once you finish camping now now shavuas in other words it's not that you you mark on your calendars and you count 49 days if you count the end of the count you so why the college travel out if this is the case what is the name because of the blood it doesn't say Natasha why the name of the world on the set on the four weeks of vote foreign so our college rules that's a question but uh the Torah doesn't call it for us but that's not what the Torah says yeah exactly so in other words is induced by pesach as opposed to shavua's causing the count pesach causes the count once the count is over [Applause] through the count the counters were created okay this is round fine yeah yeah okay if you say that if I if I forget one today okay he didn't say each day isn't it sir is a Mitzvah it could be one long Mitzvah then the mix was over for you well if you forget one day then then the principle goes it doesn't well that's the the bahag says if you miss one day your whole count is over by the way you would find no the ramban uh presumably does not hold like that by the way basically no reshine and agree to the bahag it's a very big finish right we've everybody knows the famous if you miss one day of Spiro you're out look in the rambam it doesn't hold like that look in the Riff doesn't hold like that look at the rush doesn't hold like this you don't make a brother according to the according to the bahag the Mitzvah is over what is the according to the rambam what was the rambam say if you missed one day should you make a bracha the other days absolutely what would the rush say make a bracha absolutely what would the riffs say absolutely who says not only the bahag it's very interesting that you know the basically safety right it's in his Chloe that he'll take the three big uh he'll take the rush the Riff and the rambam he'll take two out of three in this case he takes zero out of three he sides with the bahag he's close if you miss one day you lose the hole you lose the breath how come it's a big Kasha by the way it's a big conscience without nature is saying that since we say this that he has is foreign that's one of the one of the few one of the ones it's mostly it was my grandma's as a man just like nobody he's listening yeah you asked Akash why according to what he's saying it's not it's not it's it's it's he's listening it fits with that lotion is that this little girl it's the yantra and since I don't understand according to the Avenue terms is only on the 15th they are not allowed he's not obligated to eat marrow on the 16th you know it's also but this Mitzvah is the day after pesos but it's connected to peace in other words the guy the guy in other words this is the mitza pesach that you start doing the myth so when pesach is over all the other Mrs correct all the others all the other missiles are only on piss off proper this Mitzvah is the day after because Atara says when do you start doing the mitza when pesaches over let's let's move on a little bit okay now so that we're going to try to explain what does the ramban mean again that it's a mysterious you feel that it could fit in yeah maybe okay the following question we know the opinion of the rambam and the opinion of the bahag is that every Mitzvah durabanan is really a mitsody why because there's a passing third like saucer right yeah right the Torah says don't be a right or left from whatever that could come and tell you now how many missiles are there they're officially seven they're officially seven to tell him and araven okay they're officially seven foreign were the ones who told you to say hello now the Torah says told you to say hello now we tell you to say hello in other words is the Torah coming on every specific Mitzvah that there and say and backing it up and saying oh told you to do this we we Torah Hashem I also tell you to do this no or is it just that Hashem says whatever they tell you if you're not gonna listen to that you're going to be over the general category of laissezma I give you a Masha right why is Kubota aim only one Mitzvah there should be it should be a thousand Mythos there should be a missile of feeding your father giving him a drink taking off his shoes putting his coat on his right arm putting his coat on his left arm turning on the air conditioner turning on the heat turning off the air conditioner right are these all different mitzvahs excellent in other words is it when you bring your father a drink or you put on the air conditioner those two different missiles or it's the exact same Mitzvah it's fulfilling the will of your father whatever his will may be at that time it's not that Hashem says oh because your father asked you to get him a cup of water so now I am telling you to get that cup no your father expressed his will that he wants a cup of water so if you're not gonna get it you're not going to be fulfilling his his uh will and therefore you're not you're not fulfilling the taxes of that Mitzvah if you don't do it you over by two or one in other words hey I'll give you the following uh illustration let's say your father says every night at 7 pm I want you to get me a cup of water so now women should be popular from the mitzvah because it's a mystery as my grandma right I have a question right if a father says every morning at 6 30 bring me my coat are women Hive in that Mitzvah no but this is already based on the kibuda friend [Music] to get the code at 6 30. the mystery is to do the will of your father now whatever you're the will of your father happens to me that's like subjective so the same thing with Mrs ravanan is it that Hashem says said say hello you have to say Hollow now no I'm not saying you have to say hello now whatever subjective placed upon us we have to do yeah you'll be over too sorry but the nafka Mina is the rambam writes that even though all the Mr abandon are Amit so direisa they're all counted as one myth so in other words on the rambam in his when he counts the 613 Mythos all seven are all counted as one the bahag counts the shepherd Mrs as seven different missiles there's a Mitzvah Dai rice of saying hello there's a Mitzvah Raisa of natio in other words the random learns that there's a general Mitzvah to listen to the whatever they happen to tell you that is what the Torah is telling you specifically okay who cares what's in Africa enough coming is are they seven of the 613 missiles or is it just one another naftamina would be is Israel if you're gonna say like the bahag that whatever the say the Torah says you have to do that so then so then say you have to start counting Spirits from the second day of pesach so then the Torah is saying you have to start counting so summer from the secondary pace so then it says man Grandma the Taurus whatever guidelines gave those are the Torah guidelines however if you just say that whatever will the express that's just their subjectiveness so that they give and by fulfilling it you're not specifically refer fulfilling the midst of the Torah you're just in general fulfilling the will of the Torah to listen to the it would be no different than if a father said I want you to uh to bring me cold water 7 15 a.m every single morning would anybody ever say that Grandma of course not the Mitzvah the torah's will is not to do that specific thing the Taurus was to fulfill in general the will of the Father by the way this hakira about Mr abundant in general whether according to the ramam in the bahag there's a specific Mitzi director to listen to that and it's or is it just a general umbrella don't Veer off from whatever they tell you we have Victor Amia who has I believe the chief Rabbi of Tel Aviv he brings down this kakira in a very interesting safer Hamida is who lists the seven mitsos he learns anything that say the Torah is saying we want you to do that specific thing that's why each one of the design myths also be a separate Mystery Machine Kane in other words whatever the have decided to tell you you if you don't fulfill it you're violating the general rule of Lai salsa but it's not that Loy sassa is backing specifically each individual mitza so according and that's why the ramam lists it as one General Mitzvah So based on this hakira that a Warman wants to suggest and number five that if you say like the bahag if you say excuse me if you say like the rambam and a smile is not a specific Mitzvah upholding every mitza drabana it's a general Mitzvah whatever the name tell you fulfill that because if you don't you're going to be violating the general rule of Leicester young and a smile so then you can make a very strong case that sphere is man grandma what do you mean but you have to do it at a specific time at a specific time is like a father who tells his son to honor him at a specific time that doesn't make the Mitzvah his man grandma that just create the format of how to fulfill that Mitzvah but it's still not a missus in other words keep it of aim what's the midst of if the Mrs what's the tacos listening to your father so listening to your father is not governed by time it happens to be that in this instance his will is is governed by a time constraint but the the Fulfillment of the Mitzvah is to fulfill his right Zone it's not controlled by time so the same thing with Mrs if the tackles of amitabanan is only to fulfill the will of the so you're right and this specific instance their will was governed by time but the Mitzvah itself is not a missile that's government my time so which one would be which one will be no none of them according to according to what we're saying and according to that approach to the rambam [Applause] [Music] you have to wash whenever you eat whatever you eat you have to eat you're dying as is among Rome okay the general mix of nutellaim yeah I don't know I don't know that that um see there's a general mystery then which is not governed by time so now you have a yamta for a Shabbos and the Shabbos wants to co-op that mid side I don't know if it's gonna make transform the admits for that in general for example it depends yeah but the Torah did tell us in the Towering offers our Shabbos tells us when to do it it's a democracy why can't the women why can't they be a Mrs the time is written so we're saying that the same way if a father would say get me a glass of water every day at six o'clock it doesn't become a Mississippi as man grandma because the Mitzvah is not getting that glass of water the midsole is fulfilling the will of your father which subjectively in this case happens to be at a certain time so too with the mitza dravanan the Torah doesn't say whatever say you do that specific thing the Torah says you have to fulfill their will their will happens to be in this case to do a Mitzvah afternoon whatever it is whatever it happens to be if we had a car boot today yeah but we don't let's say we did let's say we would face a big dish when would not have to sell spear because then it becomes a mixed Association then it's yeah then around that then they're on bands yeah correct correct when the wrong phone is saying is talking about meteorizer because because all ah it's just that the general umbrella of Leicester makes it that it's a general category and the fact that they're dismissal happens to be governed by time does not transform them yeah okay so again but the problem with this approach really is we're basically saying that the reason why they're on bands says is basically because all Mythos can be considered in asman grammar because makes it that the Mitzvah is not to do that specifically it's a general category so yes while we're doing a band specifically mentioned okay so let's move on maybe we could come up with another answer for the ramban okay kinesh Lavana are women no anybody here ever see any women do kill Savannah no no yeah okay so the mission of writes in the name of the mug in avram paturas I said very nice they're also Potter from Schaefer do it says the mug and have Ram so why don't they do killer slovana says I'll tell you why they don't kill Savannah because the moon became small whose fault is it it's her fault and therefore even though when it comes to other Mr chasma and Grandma women are allowed to do it is so I looked up the schla how come it's her fault right I looked up last night with um so that was that made the moon small the problem with that is the problem with that is what that the moon was made slow by yes that was the fourth day of creation two days before kava ever came down to this world two days later she sinned and we're blaming this on her also right she doesn't know so by the way the uh one of the reasons there's a perish on well because it's that she was puging yeah she was bugging him in the levana and he brings down this car show what's the saying that it's her fault that she was playing by levana she wasn't even around he leaves it off in the footnotes on the Yad Rama he says we'll leave it at that pen that's why women have emitter again that's what the mug in that room writes says women are Potter from kiddish levana because it's amitsa SASE women always do Mr Sensations this is different because it's her fault comes and he says I don't know what the mug in avram is talking about why is kinesh Lavana is not Grandma she said of course it's my grandma it's only at the beginning of the month says yes yes what do you mean it's my grandma it's only the it's only what the season of the fruit it's only the the beginning of this the fact that you only do it at the beginning of this year next year that's because you have to make Abraham a new fruit and it's not new until next year in other words like this the definition of is you have a Mitzvah let's say it's filling Palace technically what's the Mitzvah the Mitzvah is to wrap the boxes on your arm and to wrap it on your head okay Technically when could you do that Mitzvah any time day whenever you want technically if Hashem would have said put on fill in so we would put on fill and take it off put on all year long ah now after the missile was given Hashem imposed a time constraint not only during the day only during the weekday not on Shabbos not night the Mitzvah is to put on fill in and the time comes and constrains the mitzvah when it comes to kilish Savannah what's the Mitzvah to stand outside and look at the moon no the Mitzvah is to make a broken a new moon so the you're gonna tell me it's not grandma because it's only at the beginning of the month yeah it's only on the beginning of the month because that's the only opportunity that there's a new Moon the Moon only exists at the beginning of the month in other words the fact that Kenny Saban is only at the beginning of the month it's not a time constraint it's the mitzios the new moon only exists in the world at the beginning of the month the same way women are definitely obligated to make on a new fruit what do you mean because the new fruit is only here once a year so you're gonna say oh it's my grandma because it's only here once a year no is the Matthias of the item is that the item only exists once a year so too the moon only is apparent once a month two days later the Moon is no longer anymore and right the 15th of the month the moon it's a full moon it's not so you can say this world I disagree with them again you want to say women shouldn't do the Mitzvah because ones who messed up fine but to say women are positive because it's non-grama says of some Kluger killer Savannah is not this man grandma still in his mind grammar because technically you could put on to fill in 365 days a year 24 hours a day Hashem came and said don't put it on during the night time don't put it on on Shabbos but what do you want to say Kish Savannah is governed by time it's not governed by time what's the mid side to make a Brach on a new moon the new moon only Islam once a month from a certain period of time whatever it is on the third day of the month to whatever whatever however many days after the molad but it's not governed by time the existence of the item that allows for the Mitzvah is only presents itself at certain opportunities the same way women definitely have to make a bracha on a new fruit because the new fruit only exists once a year in the beginning okay that's what if someone no he's just saying that the reason of the mug and have Ram to exempt them he doesn't agree with to sit in the booth so that you could sit in the booth the whole year so and then Hashem comes and says no only now so that's my grandma right there the opportunity to do the Mitzvah is always dementios is always possible Hashem can find it the mythius of the Moon being there is no it's not the whole year so in other words the time is not governing the Mitzvah the time is governing the mitzias but maybe Hashem made the moon because of the Mitzvah he did it like this that you should be once a month that will be in the beginning of the month maybe but it's still we still have no right to say that women should be Potter because it's not you can't say it's governed by time right just like women are definitely Hive in a new fruit what do you mean you could only do it once a year yeah but the reason why you could do it only once here is not because the halacha says there's a certain time to do it it's because the the inherent definition of making the shakiano is make the shakyanu on a new fruit and the new fruit only is in the world once a year so to the midst of Kil Saban is to make the bracha on the new moon the new moon is only in the sky once a month okay so what does this have to do with me so very interesting in the heduce Weinberg the three-day age three days he says like this he wants to say that it's true that you could only start counting from the second day of pesach so pashup shot is certainly it's my grandma because you can only start counting the iMac from the 16th day of Nissan what's the mitzvah a serious animal can we say serious harm is like villain right we said it's villain technically you could put on 365 days a year and Hashem comes and says only do it at this time so we'll say the same thing as there's a midsole to count 49 days and Hashem came along and said ah you know which 49 days I want you to count these that's not what happened when you start to harvest the wheat uh she said oh it's covered my time it's not going to my time the Matthias of the world presents itself in a way that you only harvest the wheat once a year it's not government it's not the 16th day of Nissan it's not a calendar date it's a mitzius island the same way that says that the midst of killer Savannah is not Grandma why because the new moon is only apparent once a month you can only see it in the sky once a month so you say yeah but it's govern my time it's not governed by time governed by time means a myth so that could potentially been done at any time Hashem can find it you don't say that about three you're gonna say by svira really you could count 49 days anytime and Hashem said no I want you to do it on this date oh it's you have to count these 49 days it's not you could count any 49 days in Hashem placed it now it's me Hawkeyes okay I'll let you look um by the way let's take a look let's take a look at number seven days there is very simple to me amid such as nine grammar is a mitza that has a time constraint has man who Hamas garisha amitsa there's a Mitzvah and the time is the frame of the mitza in other words you have a picture right after you have a picture you want to put a nice frame around it but the picture exists without a frame right if anybody ever bought a piece of art even if you don't have a frame you have the art the frame is just what boxes in the picture so to the definition of this man grandma is you have a myth you have to fill in it could be done any time the time merely frames in the mitzvah 365 days a year Hashem says no the frame of the mitza is what is the time is the essential aspect elements was not to count and the days are merely the frame days of the counting are part of the Mitzvah itself the duck kiamiko look very carefully into this it's very deep but I explained the review so Weinberg in a certain way that it's similar to kiddish halavana that the same way Savannah is based on so too assignment is based on the Matthias there's another way to learn him but this is how we're gonna explain okay let's end off with the following again back to the question what is around that and this is another explanation for them um is explaining why is man grammar he's not governed by time the the um presents itself in a way at a certain time of the year let's look at the shots he was lived there in 1910. skin um of the late 19th century early 20th century even the admiram used to send many stylists to the diva very interesting uh story goes there were three sisters and uh one sister a son who's a big God of Israel she became the mother of the other sister was the mother of reviews a Victor the pardes remind him on and the third sister never you know she didn't have a son who was world famous like her other two sisters and she was her whole life she was miserable you know she wasn't so set to to have a son that met up to the standards of her other two sisters until finally her grandson grew up to be the Divine malkiel and then she said okay now I now she's ready to die um has very interesting so he says like this as my grandma you're fatoma is Taco a good question that's why I say dramban is a tall sofa there's a gift mistake in the ramban it's obviously it's obvious that with the rambanment it's his man grandma and it should be in the list of the ramban in the previous piece where he lists the Mr says in other words you know this whole Shear was uh academic because you know the printer when he when he's printing the list he mixes you know what it said it said but then the printer when he copied over mentaph right the mem you know he made it he closed it up and the tough he left a little openness okay the printers or another possible uh Hamlet's another Paso uh rationalization for this uh for this publisher but yes really the publisher didn't make two mistakes right the first chat is a publisher made two mistakes he wrote Memphis iron then he thought it was and then he thought that stood for Spirit no the publisher got it right he wrote samache ayen but does not stand for sphere it stands for avoida carbonis women archive in Carbones everybody knows that these mistakes are rampant in many of the storm or or you could say like this he says all the way at the end about seven lines on the other piece of idea you could say the following I've seen in the safer color yo the spirit Karma that in order to bring the carbon you need to cancel them excuse me someone who didn't count the srira you couldn't bring the Cabanas on chivalrous according to their mom no he's saying there's a shita you can't bring the Cabanas and show us unless you first counted the sphere so I mean of the carbon anchovus and women archive in the carbon and therefore they would be higher then okay so just basically to summarize to summarize the ramban seems to listen among the midst of Shane as man grandma so we said a number of possibilities the abnenezer says why is it inazman grama because pesach has gone in the Mitzvah and pesach has a date on the calendar that women are kind or number two we set up shot from every war Man based on the um that the Mitzvah of Life which makes every drop is not a specific Direction it's a general diary son therefore even if the drop on them specifically is governed by time it's still the die rice does not consider government my time and that would solve the problem I'd like to have a good day God bless you you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com