Sanhedrin Daf Yomi Weekly Review Pages 54 to 60 with Rabbi Yehuda Spitz at Scheiner's Shul

every body today we're going to pick up from the top of we're going to try to get all the way till the end of let's jump right into top of the last week we ended off saying the re learns let's to this he's bringing it it says as follows says from can whether it's your father's wife that's your mother however when it's your mother that's not your father's wife where do you know that it's if you look inside very clearly it says that's it's and we're going to make a when you look inside the right afterwards it says to tell us what you get the punishment is maybe in such a case it's considered one of the misas that I mentioned the answer is and just like over there you get it over here you're going to get it we clearly know but know they have we learning your father's wife maybe mean someone who does with his own father regarding the first which mention the top of just like over there it's through marriage it's very clearly whether it's your father's wife that's your mother however mother which means to say is that the t is saying which is not your father's wife but your mother going to make it just like in a case of your father's wife in such a case where your mother was not your father's wife regarding we're going to see regarding what does it say over there regarding the sorry says over there we're going to say the same thing the is making like like a mother and the continues the says so we're learning from them this is who this is very clearly it's learning same thing with what's the difference of let's be clear if you're telling me the guy's doing Tash with his father why is he different than any Z and that it clearly says in the that a person cannot do withw person with his father the same thing because he's learning it from what that tell you that so very clearly learning from both you know we're talking he didn't know that you know why I'm saying this what is that gets gets killed betray going to kill him twice means was from what you're learning that from the father's brother which is and you can make a where do they know for father's wife learning from what gonna learn this from what gonna say with this he's learn know who born his father's wife doesn't argue my answer is no you're making a mistake no AR of father's wife what's the coming what is g to learn it continues Accord us so let's make a quick very clearly we have three really three it's it's really so it says clearly in the follows the what it's and according to what are they learning that's where we started with and then we had so there there's no argument what's it coming to tell us in the case of a mother that it's not his father's wife and then when it says that and according to they're going to tell us that that it's an in such a case and not that's the of what about the which according beginning and according to to tell us a scenario what about the next the where it finish and it says on that of again and is going to tell us in a case of for the father and then the end of the and then when it says what are we learn now from that case of according to ACC to again this the end of this is for the very for his son's wife to tell us and everything that brings H what is the punishment why would you kill the why we killing the animal two reasons this this caused the to do what to do with it look at this sh this caused Ru to die because he did says says says clearly we all know it comes out telling us very clear is coming to tell us but this is coming to tell us that even even why comes to tell us we don't need a because very clearly that is only one why coming to tell us and then it says in the may maybe that's end we're going to learn with this regarding over there it's clearly that is no question about it says so it's very clearly the regarding for the the person who's the receiving we all know over here is very clear it means it's very clearly different May it's coming to tell us that over there that's why they got punished for doing all the which was clearly says you know how is going to learn it don't let yourself be submitted to what to get and it's going to make very practical which we're going to see in a moment is is coming to tell us it says doesn't make a difference doesn't make a difference that the animals you're still that's what it says again it says the end of the this is a person who's instigating you got to kill [Music] says the earli don't let yourself be in a position to be the same time we're bringing or we're just larning theing a little different what why because it's coming from two different however it's the same whenever it says we're talking about this between a man to a male to a female or males or or people however that right what are youna do with this already have we already know this that's the point what is why it's all the same thing no whole enough between what when a person brings a on himself according to the which and according to you have the so comes out three things we all know those are the three that regarding we're talking about the we're talking about the person who's the recipient we're going to see what this means that a is not like a doesn't make a difference now means we're going to see the measurements n years old we see we know this is we under we don't consider but you don't need to be does it doesn't make a difference how old he is what's the mean 13 what's these measurements him that he needs to be what he needs to be N9 years old otherwise we're going to see why whyi is the recipient who cares that if he would do it it won't be considered he says the recipient we're gon to see like the we all know that is three years old regarding was considered whatever if you as the recipient would be giving the Tash how old you need to be you need to be nine so too as a as the reent you need to be n is we all know it's three years old let's bring a to because it says clearly underline this so you clearly see over there that it's n years old the doesn't make a difference that brings an animal onto her however regarding I'll tell only go to do whether any type of the point is doesn't make a differ look why because it says what does it say clearly says that what what is isn't or is it somewhat which is but more than that it's ready consider but any of those points the point that someone who does do we say what do you mean just like we all know regarding why would I think is different regarding the it clearly says in the as follows underline that this whole is why know this so what are you going to do with this why you mentioning if you think about we all know so why are we bringing it from the to the that's where you're learning out from that's where the puts it the whole entire is learn from which means to say is a person he's able to take his a and be into his own you're annoying how's this really possible if it's a that's that's not possible the only way it's going to be possible if it's a when the a maybe it's possible he said so what's the in our mission we clearly Learned From the Bottom by there's two points one is that it caused the to do number one point number two is that everyone walks and says Ah this beh this beh caused Ru to get killed now regarding a we're going to see that there's only one maybe will be maybe it's only degrading it's embarrassing we can't call it do we say which means the grading everyone's say this regarding you can't tell me there's really embarrassment that's what thinking now that go does it it's dark not embarrassed and therefore you would kill the animal think about the Tre no feelings doesn't eat doesn't drink doesn't all know you destroy we know it's not true and that answers can be regarding anim to with an animal talking that if the animal that had a know from this got to get killed we destroyed and there's no we're going to bring a that what it's good enough deg grading is good [Music] enough I'll tell and the case would be where but there's no my answers no but it's degrading what's the case and we're gonna look at not the great you went and did with I don't care what the says person does it everyone agrees it's you could think it's very good now we're gonna bring a very interesting from the we're gonna bring it from G and we're gonna bring it from but it's gonna be the exact same so let's see girl we all know as long as she's three years old the brother's wife she's three years old if the father then some went and be with her it's considered and therefore which is talking about means we all know that if a person is Bor when as long as as long as she's under if she's under three if she's under three's not that that he's in such a case this is what we're getting to the point underline this however even this is you can't call the we all know clearly see a b as long as you can't tell me there's no we're not going to punish her the animal doesn't care let's bring another very similar theal Reve can't bring keep the says in the tell answer is what's the case is the sh that what is very clearly you need one the question is which one is the most're going to say it's not considered a problem and you'll kill it even without one of them is it's good enough Etc all those type of things so he has to say the name he can't say said oh Bas on what you said I want to be that's not going to work you have to say it yourself as long as whenever we're having the person was Ma so whenever we bring the and we want to go through the case we're not's they're not going to keep in saying the name we're going to see in a moment what's going to happen in a second but rather we quote it we're going to call it y we're gonna see it's four letters someone to say it's 86 grias but the point is however when it comes to kill the person rather so what do you do you tell everybody got to go the bigger the one who's more and we need to hear exactly what you're telling us the r saids the name get up see just like today we all know someone's someone someone's n they RI their the jacket you see it and they rip and they're never allowed to reap rep it you never allow to rep it the second we're going to see doesn't need to say the sh she just says and I agree with what he said we're going to see this is going to come tell us who is this for like now very clearly we're gonna see that's that he has a choice rather there's no and therefore he has no choice and he's just to quote it but it's to say because we're going to see while we're coming to this what do you know that you need to say twice you basically have to say how do know in it so we're gonna see go through it says the and over here we're going to see learning how do you know if anything means which means like it says says in the how can I curse is not curs know regarding maybe means if you think about it is piercing like taking a knife and stabbing it in it says in the on the lid is what we're talking about Idol is no is impossible to do with a piercing a shame and a shame regarding a CL you could say maybe you have two sa let's say you take a knife and you stab it what you really doing is piercing both but it's not the one going to the other maybe have engraved and you stab it it's really the night there's a nice engraving but it's not the name that's doing it maybe it means to say it not the way it's vocalized the way we say it rather the way it would be pronounced the real right is not the way we say it saysf the Nam it's not possible in the and over here we saying it's pronounced in curs remember mearly says so we're going to see that says regarding the CL double just like they in how do they get killed they get killed besid we learned this regarding very clearly we're gonna see this later to tell us for example all those typ of says we started stop with how do you know according says in the why is it saying this you know what this comes to tell us is gonna get what is gonna get what [Applause] now we're g to go through all the one is we all know that they have civil courts this is the we're GNA see everything except they don't have this regarding we're going to see this which is number six the a is going to also learn this we're going to go through everything later even and even regarding doing whatever is regarding the because it says the so what is all these types of things in the and a person does all these divinations is the light of hand we call Magic what people think it's magic o someone to say he wants to be he wants to know when he's going to go and he's based on certain he's making his decisions based on certain OMS who does he's able to make do charms we all know he does Spirits with that people with his armpit and puts a bone of an animal makes voices in his mouth he sleeps in the base of to come with all the spirits of the clear you clearly see were part of the I'm going to see d means grafting and animals two different animals to Pro them the SE is going to be doing our the two animals which isft know so let's go right ins that's the surely we're going to break down this they tell us that what they have civil courts like it says in the underline the word is and it says in the so sorry what do we learn from this is the you saw earlier clearly says sayar we're learning the what did we learn from that we're seeing lar the concept of introducing oh the concept of marriage what are we learning we know says the this is regarding the the so you clearly see that crushed he went after what the people that were telling them to do but he didn't he didn't worship It Go we know if we don't have a of execution ay goes over there he Embraces it he kisses it what's the case of that's the way to regarding civil courts is this really true that the commanded to do civil cour so whatever the means it's not part of and what it say get ready for this clearly says it says in the it say the you should put over there very clearly that they meet statues and law so what is going on how you tell me it's part of the we know that what we all know they need to have 23 [Music] every province in every city what is's going to change the and he's going to flip it to what to which is the and is four get ready is number six is number seven that you shouldn't do anything else go do other he's learning from that what shouldn't curse it like it says in the you're learning out from the who says all three very simple if you're learning the rest of the learn it let's go through and if they got punished on it they were commanded this is this is talking about what talking about they got punished for what for we're going to see in a second for we're that's not learning it out why don't you see no you know how they you know how they got punished that's why they got punished but where do you know from you know it from I'll tell you that's you know how they're getting killed with that's the point like it says in which is what which is we're going to see that is going to be until now now like you're just like everything else that even the it says in the we're gonna even see this more extensively to tell us that even theim is going to see it might be permitted that means not tell you want companionship the animals want to be with the same type of men what is that is gonna be this number one okay we can understand we learned clearly over there tell me because over there very clearly they all have regarding if you look in the is this really true we see clearly that's how they get K he's going to get killed says in the this is regarding these are regarding going to discuss this what it mean so if it's a it's also to do all this however is able to do this we're gonna see what this means you tell me that what why does it say answer you know we want to use this really true whatever very explicitly under I'll put them in the and I'll take out of the to kill them no choice of there what's someone who's eating a worker is able to eat what's the case able to eat the grapes while you're pulling out the grapes your regular Goin tell us in a case when you stole that why we why is a to take for because the person doesn't care I give the musle for example a guy has a scratched up car would you go over him and say can I scratch another can I do a little scratch a father you say no but if you if you did it already and you scratch she goes no no I have I'm ready old