Rosh Hashanah Chiddushim

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay we all know that during assassin we make certain additions to the schweinsteiger most importantly we say instead of hakeel so ultimately you don't have to uh you don't have to repeat this one answer but we all know that if someone did not say they need to repeat the shrine answering that's the only one so i just said um now what's oh you would think that since it's a suffix so something's cool but the answer is it's not a suffic if you're misopic if you say it we assume you didn't say it because you say shigura delicious you presumably said what you're accustomed to saying which is and therefore we assume you said now what about if the night of rosh hashanah you're dabbling from a master and you said the same thing right the whole thing and then after you're dabbing for the master you say to yourself one second did i say or did i say so normally we say if you're misopic what you said well we'll assume that you said the regular weekday dabbing but the night of rosh hashanah you're dabbing from the masa you said the rest of the nusa properly presumably if you said the same the same thing and you said presumably you did say here's the question the question is the following what if the night of rosh hashanah you said everything of alder the same thing you said everything wonderful the only thing is you end it off so we would say of course you have to go back and namaste again and yet the kaye odom brings down the sack of rabbi veli fosviller that if the night of rosh hashanah you definitely did not say you don't have to repeat from yesterday huh like this number one bracha gimmel nick raised kedusha hashem the third bra if during an ordinary day of the year instead of saying she said if you don't go back if you remember within the amount of time it takes to say so last of the rush of the rush so you say well maybe i'll do a trick i'll say 90 times this way in case i'm in doubt i can assume i said it correctly right we have a trick like that from ashraf maragosa for the st can i have a trick like that for america no no no because what are you going to say hashem's name can't say god's name 90 times you don't have to go back why how could that be you said americans what you should say if you definitely did not say says you do not have to go back the night of rosh hashanah you know why he says like this is what elliot was saying because what's the halal of a person for guy yalaviya the night of rosh hales the night any night any night any night what's the luck of you forgot y'all will be having the night of verse you don't go back why not because then is not massage so even though technically it's to say out of the odd foreign but if you didn't we'll let it fly so too the night of rosh hashanah it's rosh hashanah but bedding is not until the day so therefore it's at the night of rosh hashanah instead of saying but during the night the same way the other if you miss during the day you don't go you go back but during the night you don't go back so too if you forget during the day you go back if you forget it at least the first night of rosh hashanah we will see you don't go back does the mishna brewer pass that let's see the second i will grab phosphor would say on the second night let's see okay hey no laughs because we do not sanctify the month and night in kane down below rosh hashanah if so the night of rosh hashanah should be the same thing shay and sarathlasar that you don't have to go back okay very interesting very interesting sock not so well known everyone is all in tamalka cuddlers right everybody knows if you miss it you have to stay over this one i say no not so fast not the first night of rosh hashanah says the audam in the name of brother availi fast feller you don't have to go back the same way you don't go back if you miss the olivia at night you don't go back if you missed made a mistake and you were gathering the transfer from coal i mean and you didn't die from an asteroid so there if you said cargo you want to know what if you dive in the vacation we will see okay comes along you know that you're dying this morning and you forgot it's one thing but if you and said the wrong transformation for that okay we'll see comes along the shiloh he said i don't get what the man is talking about that's not exactly how he says it but then if lacy it's a wonder well the vaguely fast speller forgot the words of an open risha and prepared let's so let's read it in ravino yana himself at number three right isla matharshi oh every what's the halakha if the night of yomtif let's say pesach night you dive in the weekdays my master do you have to repeat this way of course what about the night of sukkas you've said a weekday shimano essay do you have to repeat yeah what do you mean but if you forgot y'all of yoga then you don't have to go back so why do you have to go back if you didn't dive in the yumpth of the kashmir ashrae but i thought the best thing is not makadesh until the day why are they two different things okay the answer is there's a big difference between yamtif and rosh haidash what is that dash is telling only in kids [Music] two weeks ago yeah but it doesn't kick in until in the morning it kicks in it kicks in the asymmetra kicks in look that's only other yamatoma ava beyonce rosh hashanah but the amp of rosh hashanah and shitaliburush since rosh hashanah is dependent on rashford if you don't we're a bitter youngest thing there are some that say if you say a weekday pesach night you go back circus night you go back shivers night you go back but not rosh hashanah because rosh hashanah is like just like rosh there's a difference between rosh let me clarify for a moment everyone agrees if you miss the night of verse you don't have to say it over because the dish is not makudus until the morning but everyone agrees that yamtif yomthi if it's already makuta from the night because reshridish was already settled 14 days earlier or seven days earlier so everyone agrees yomtif kicks in immediately nothing to do with this because we know right the question is how are we going to treat rosh hashanah are we going to say well rosh hashanah is that means it doesn't really kick in during until the day or do we say no no the israelite ready begins from the evening and since it is the evening you need to have darwin from the evening it's different than rashford how does it conclude ravenous concludes that on rosh hashanah you must say the ant of dikka davening because it's the because since the israel begins at night you better have dive in the young people davening from the nighttime says the shasta chivas mayan fayem if ryona concludes that rosh hashanah is not like rosh hardash because what rosh does not have israel and rosh hashanah has this so then rabindrayana is saying very clearly if you don't say the young the night of rosh hashanah you need to go back so it would come out then if you don't say the night of rosh hashanah you should have to go back so what's rava bailey fast fellow talking about that well hamel kakadu should be like gala but no there's a major difference between amnas is dependent on rosh christ doesn't kick in really 100 till the day but dependent on the umptif and the yumpta ferretti kicks in at night with the issa malacha what does uh rabbi bailey say about this i mean they definitely don't he doesn't hold it that's enough to make a difference it almost sounds like he holds like the students of ravenoyana who ravino rejected that the students of albany say that rosh hashanah is like despite the fact that there's an israel malacca but nevertheless since it's the first day of the month we don't know that it's yant of yad until the day then retroactively there was a nissan malacha from the evening but look what the mass look at number two two lines from the end right it is clear not like rabaveli foster again the soccer verb availability foster was if you dive into rosh hashanah and all you forgot was you don't go back just like was the analogy the analogy was to yala village the night of verse but he would say more but we see not like him because ravenous says clearly that the schweinsteiger rosh hashanah is not like galavia the night of verse which is only done during the the day but the esri of yamtif is dependent on issa melaka which begins at the night already [Music] but for some reason that far he doesn't go okay you're asking very good but but right now all as far as he's gone is he didn't say you could that if you dive in the weak stage vanessa you don't have to go back he just said if you're down in the yom and he said you don't have to go back but we're saying rabino yona goes so far as to say ravenous it says not like that why because if you dive in the weekdays so you're not you'd say but as of now what's the distinction yeah right i'll ask additionally what would they both say if you dive what about on a regular tuesday if you say let's say today instead of saying hakala colors you say america you have to repeat you don't go back okay so question number one that's being asked is what that he's not like because says if you died which is during the day but yamtif is dependent on israel look in the base halevi this is not the best this is the basal levy on the shouse of chuba special lady i have a better question for you forget about the fact that he's against it doesn't make any sense what the guy is doing tada and a half of why because at least you know you in your mind you think it's still a weekday but here's the guy what's the guy doing the guy's diving half of rosh hashana and then he's concluding with the weekday conclusion that doesn't make any sense da this foreign because what are you going to say right you want to come on to the swara well bazdin wasn't the kaddish yet well doesn't wasn't kind of so what the world were you doing saying you know the same thing practical the same thing right there you can you can have it both ways don't try to pull out the card the desert wasn't the kadus yet what were you doing the last half hour what does the mission of brewer say about rabbi bailey fast follower absolutely yeah in the shaharat the mission of bhura first of all he quotes the ravely fast fellow and then he says on the second night line a hero because you could only he asked the same kasha of the basal levy you could only pull out the card the peasant wasn't the kaddish the if you want to say the guy died in the weekday but if the guy in middle switched and for the last half hour he was down in rosh hashanah you can't tell me whoa dawg what do you want me to say you want me to say it's fashion isn't that rosh hashanah didn't do anything yet. and that is why the stephen writes not like you got to go back and i even have a safer from one of the big pikes game in lakewood today rav shmuels elder he says do not agree to this kurdish of rabbi fast farm like the says and like the misha brewer disagrees that he concludes that the first night of rosh hashanah if you don't say you got to go back raboy side not so fast not so fast he said no he says right about when him say you got to go back comes along the binyan shlaimai and he says an amazing thing an amazing swara and this swara is also given by hagan rav maisha feinstein and the igor ismaisha and they both explained rubber bailey fast valor knew exactly what it is rabbit by the way he was a descendant of the sheikh salman so he says like this the analogy between excuse me is perfect why what do you mean rabbenu yaina said what's what what does roberto you want to say about a guy who darwin's a wheat ishmael on rosh hashanah yesterday you got to repeat why because because the that's question number one question number two was it's a tahati the sasari make up your mind is it rosh hashanah says the binyan says ravmasha feinstein we don't say it's because of the kedusha's yamthis the reason why we say hamelka kaddish instead of metallic others is because now we have the holiness of yamtif it's nothing to do with kadusa and i'll add we say it during the asterisk he made shiva it's not young to sin so why do we say it we say it because this is the time that god is judging us it has nothing to do with the um there's nothing to do with kadusa we say it because god is sitting on his throne his throne of malchus on this throne now let me ask you a question when does god start to sit on his throne of mishpot when does the judgment start the gemara says in rosh hashanah look at number nine israel who god does not begin to judge until besan shamatha sanctifies the new moon when does doesn't sanctify the moon from that obviously when does it when does it one second good question when is sanctifies the moon in the day so therefore let me ask you a question the addition of is it dependent on kedusha which begins at the night or is it dependent on when the judgment begins why don't we start saying chakras why are we saying good stamina it's rosh hashanah and it's a time of it's the general time frame of but yeah the announce but i'll prove that i'll prove it i'll prove to you you can have it both ways you know what's the proof yeah why do you say y'all of y'all very the night of rashford but i thought that's not specifically until they said the answer is the answer is because it's in judaism we begin with the night and even though it's technically not not being enacted until the morning but we begin saying this and you're supposed to say and if you don't say you're doing something wrong but nevertheless if you miss y'all of you at night you don't go back because since technically it doesn't begin till the next day you don't go back the same thing with him specifically is dependent on begins when there's a says if you dive the night of rosh hashanah what do you have to do you have to go back but when it comes to conduct is exactly analogous to yala the other why better you understood if you live in the weekday it's dependent on the din and the din does not begin until besides that is the defense of rav available given by the vineyard and given by rav maisha well i'm going to ask so why if we now say that an avocado she's uniquely tied to when a cottage burger will start to sit in pink yeah during the year she made sure the cottage is still sitting in dim the same way he's sitting on rosh hashanah we know that the din is determined now you might we had a whole shear about here where then you shouldn't say about one combo you should say say it again maybe [Music] he's not signing but he is on the kise but he's on the throne of judgment his role is and he's the judge right now just because the judge the judge has certain times that he records that he writes that he seals but as long as he's in that room donning that the the garb the robe of judgment now what we're saying is the robe of judgment god does not die until the morning so even though technically we supposed to say that night already but if you didn't say it you don't have now take a look look at number eight look on the last paragraph number eight the um available possible vikayaman what does that mean well shari right we saying right they should not be uphold so he's he's upholding the words of it um they illuminate like the sun they ain't no indian clouds foreign what emerges here is the in the vesden what emerges from this instead of mila mala is that the desden does not begin to adjudicate until the day so you don't bring me the words of rabbi what's up got to do with this saying if you don't say the young got to go back of course because the anthem starts at night the israel starts at night you better say that but in terms of the din aspect din is not dependent on yamthev din is dependent on the desert shamaw how could yeah you want to say that it's not yamcha yet so what were you doing for last hour it's not a tactic assassin i never said it's not yamcha of course i hold its young fifth that's why i diamond the russian shannon no no no no no no no listen carefully i hope it's a hundred percent yamcha and that's why i dominated the yum tips it's dependent on the din and the dim doesn't begin until the day don't say that whole paragraph that's not because of the din that's because of yomtif and avada yamcha begins on the night because of the israel they were asking it's a it's a self-contradiction either it's yumpty for it's not young tiff no not a tarty disaster it's not young tiff okay he says like this the hyoids what emerges [Music] right no no no no no no they're in the words of this okay but those words are not active no no exactly now what would you say about the second day of rosh hashanah let's say the second night the same thing same thing now what's the halacha if someone forgot the second night of her story you don't have to go back don't go back so you would say the same thing by rosh hashanah right that what i says and regarding the second day right where they're only makadesh beyond so you shouldn't have to say it you shouldn't have to go back or do we say this is not like not listen to this now again but israel has nothing to do with him but what's the difference is it beautiful yeah of course the second neighbor is you don't yesterday might have been very dish or today might be rosh hades yesterday was maybe yesterday was aleph and if it was today's right but rosh hashanah is different because the first day of rosh hashanah is aleph the second day is base it's not la merello alex it's elephant base so regarding beings there's no question that the bazin was already in the kadesh so perhaps therefore he says definitely you would go back so that's the suffix he has is it analogous to or do we say no and this is saved why do we say that well maybe one day rosh hashanah look in the paragraph the first paragraph in the second column dependent on the din and the din does not begin until god sits on his throne in the morning in the morning rav maisha says what would you do the second night the mother says mustaber that you should say it again why because how could the second night of rosh hashanah be worse than one of the days of assassination yeah but the dream is not effective ah you'll say but if you were gonna say you have to do it again isn't that a bizayan two if you say it at night you shouldn't have to go back because nobody's sitting in bed at night if it's related to din the whole story here that they nobody says he doesn't sit at night he doesn't begin until the day i thought dean is only doing it no no no no no no no no no god does not sit and din until the best one he's on 24th yeah then he's on 24 7. then he's on 24 7. but but you could say the rabbi said the second night of rosh hashanah already it might be the first night and if it might be the first time god may not have started yet but no it's mustaber he says that it's not worse than the ancestor that you have to go back the only thing is if you're going to go back that's almost like saying today is a weak day it's azusa for yomtovshani so he says like this since it's not so common that someone's going to say the young detective therefore therefore you have to go back there's also like this the spar that we're saying you have to go back is even though technically maybe god has not started judging yet but how could the second day of rosh hashanah be any worse than the fifth day of the assassination fifth day of assassination you have to go back so you're gonna say the second night of rosh hashanah you don't have to go back why why the first night is worse than the other because probably the first day was rosh hashanah the second day is only is only uh when the uh the first day of the year ah now russia says that the din of rav available is by both days that just like the first night you don't go back the second night you do go back so much i'll argue on him regarding that point so it comes out if someone wakes up early rosh hashanah morning before nate sahama listen to this you're davening chakras before nates and you dive in the yum yesterday right and you forgot right then you could say now when does the courtroom convene when does the courtroom convene but the evid if they got up earlier it works so moisture says like this you need to do it and they never used to do it before like why would they wake up early therefore mama best in shamala has not gathered yet when does hashem do things so he doesn't start the morning therefore it comes out of a tremendous if someone divins early wakes up very early rosh hashanah morning to dhaban and he forgot about you don't have to repeat it so i would say even though repfelder says roy vacroinium do not agree to the skidus look grant but ramosha ramosha upholds it so uh you know suffolk brothels you could say but you know you don't want to get into trouble the first night of rosh hashanah so the first night use your master and don't you know don't say anything with your eyes closed you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com