ROSH CHODESH AV FALLING ON SHABBOS - OPPOSING OPINIONS ON THIS WEEK'S HAFTORAH

I would like to begin tonight's with giving a graci for we reflect back for arranging guest speakers inviter just on the note of I want also he said about a shout out I want to say I'm grateful that my son he has he started today so he joined the kabur as well this year I don't know if the remembers he was so much happened we went through a war in Nissim but this year was an interesting year on the calendar a unique year I don't remember it's not going to happen for another 20 years the still some interesting let's call it that are being from the calendar the setup of this week shabas it's something that only happens when pes falls on chabas such a occurrence is not going to happen for another 20 years and what we're going to discuss tonight is legal Tyra. >> The half Tyra. What' you say? >> Oh, very good. Very good. Very fine. Said was very busy saying that the next is in 20 years. So people were saying we should be that it should be sooner than 20 years. If it could happen could happen next year. Which do we shabases? So what's the shil? Let's break it down. Let's start from the beginning. In general though it's the gumar already brings about ha most of the ha that we l that we say are not in the garra. It's minhogim. As a matter of fact, you look mimic the start earlier, they say later. Some even have a different a lot of different very few are in the Gomorrah. One of the one of the few is Shabases. The Gomorrah says when it's shabases that we lay in Shabases when you have lay and then a second of you read it starts the Gmorra calls at the end of the as explains Every haftra that we l is connected to the para when there was the zer that we kept we couldn't have katyra we lyra that was connected reminded us of the para and what's the connection to the so that's what the shy very simple however not a gor not a gor but it's a tyus bring this brings a that even though every week we read what's connected to the para for the next 10 weeks says the next 12 weeks we don't read what's connected to the para but now gibble the pironius the three weeks the hyra shabas of For 3 weeks we read the gimmel the pironius and then the seven weeks afterwards for seven weeks and then two weeks of chuva. So really to l this week is not a steer to because talking about when it's not shabases or to lane the gimmel the peronius which is which is shimu is also not a because the gammor says you shabases on a regular shabases but just like the the gimmel the piranus is the parer So which of the do you shabas? Which of the do you oftes or the >> what' he say? >> Good. So over here the reason for that is very good. You're asking very good over there. The answer is is because you always end off. So you take out the last why because it's lesser. So is connected. Very good. But here this shabas is shabas. That's one. The second is Ka is so mitad what's connected to the ka would be however the says that these three weeks we don't we don't read that's connected to the para or but rather connected to the more rather yeah the em is that really these are mafur these are mafur What you doing such a shabas says you know what it's a gammorra it's a gor so we're claring tooth the piranus the garra says says even though it's a gam to read this shabas not like that is always the shabas beforeus explains that it's not we're knowing against The gar the garamar is going with that from but we it's only so that's why is the shabas before this year the we're going to l is not but he's not but it's here is Sunday but we're not like the we're not So we don't lazy. What do we lame? Do we do over there for says you lane shimu? Shimu is gimlius before shimu. is in the all say that you you read the ha of shimu of gimmel the piranius Shabas says, "You know why you're laying this shabases?" Actually says, "Not like that." But also the minist that says that the is the true and he says you know why because it's either in general is or is also more than to be shabas there's yet a third cheetah The ram says like the says that this wonder if anybody's knowing the says we have three either or shimu which is the ka of the three weeks or the maril brings lan And the says the reason why to shim. Why would they shim the says in these the words and how explains it's referring to. So even in the three weeks it speaks about so with you could also call it cash and have the it could be everybody agrees that we want to lay for the reason of the mal says we want to l you know you know why we should lashes up you can't not on if you're not going to lay ones everybody Everybody agrees is Shimu the three weeks after Marel is also and even the Rambam that says the Gomorra. It's very interesting. The Rambam the Rambam lists out every single of and then the Rambam says in the three weeks which of you he goes through and the Rambam says that in the three weeks however when it's shabas he doesn't call it the raom calls it interesting the raom in the three weeks when he says to read he says But when connected to we have so what's choice to choose a positive or negative >> she should go toesh So the says it's not clear and the rail already brings it's not the and the brings that it's either or which is the three weeks. However, the ishoreshik whatever we're going to speak about is a medic though it's very interesting because if you take a look in the dark the raish actually says shimu the says the mo the pna was says the closen brings a very but he says if you look in he says on the para and he also says and if you take a look in this week's para he says on the like what he says in he says the safe one we learned who says shimu the the the gimble Pranusa the B though the B and the he doesn't speak about it but the B himself says to say and the reason why to say is because like we mentioned earlier says and is in different places he says it also from the was to listen that the Prague was shimu. He says the medusim says shimu the says shimu like theisilla [Music] says is a mistake to like the So we have over here it's a little hard to narrow it down what the mig is. We spoke about this previously. It's brought in the taz that something that's not you can't say mik. You can't say mics. Even though taka happened four years ago, I don't know if anybody remembers from four years ago, but let alone if the next time is 20 years to remember >> say because people forget. Why do they say >> what? Say >> why do they say you can't say a minute? Because people forget. >> People forget. People don't remember. People don't remember certain times you even see in the same place they changed. It's not to go in now, but it's not if you're very organized and you record just to go a little bit shimish Lakewood. would you have l >> Oh, very good. We're going to get to that mama in a minute and with that we're almost going to conclude. It's interesting the cha says not a but he says like this if somebody's speaks about these call it but somebody that's should say and if not the gimmel the producer Very good. You asked why can't you do both? Very good. Why can't you do both? >> So the m what say >> why can't you why can't you say both? What >> do >> so the em is the em says we don't do two what we do is a good shila this is not the first time where it's neg to do two >> what say so the iss it happens this shil happens more than once when it's if you Shabas and Sunday not like this year this Shabas and Sunday. So Shabas and Sunday have two of you tomorrow. So which so the the says that when it's and Sunday you do both you don't do both tuk I don't know if you would do both here also which tuk of what because there you do of you do you you do both says you do not do both because you don't go to two different places so I'll if all over. So he rules. So we don't do both. >> Which one is a shi? >> Good. That's a that's a always and the embassies that even even those that go with there are still those that actually do say it's a smoo for itself. But it's in about tonight's of the two. But it's a good sh your shil is more national shil not just for tonight of the two of what what we're gonna do >> what says >> what for this week very good very good he says do the first one in the world the says the says by every that shabas on Sunday you do toup suck from the other half of Tyra. So here also yeah it's not the >> lisa lisa is like this mid shiners is where diamond is from it's whoever is going to lane laer >> not not twice for sure no not twice >> one thing I could say is you'll come to shul and whatever they're going to lane or if they don't know you'll be educated I'll these two stan what's l I don't know and hog lan One more pointer and with this I conclude if you're going to lane this shabases there are those that were that last week it's too late already but last week you should have lain two of s the first of gimmel the prusa paras and also this week and you have no of two you're looking at me two it's right next to each other it's one after the other so you just do both somewhat you should there are those that said no it's first of all it's a but that's really when you when you if you miss it is speaking about here last week you never missed this week so void they say we should be So last week you should l to bring on more also we have if tisha falls on chabas you don't move it early move it later so push it kick it down the road soap last week some want to say some say not Prepare to be a medal.