0:00 / 0:00
Review the weekly Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Pages 40 to 46 with Rabbi Yehuda Spitz
17 views
Video from the weekly Daf Yomi Review Shiur at Scheiner's Shul on Sunday mornings.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning everybody we're going
to pick up from the top
of I'm going to try to get all the way
till the end
of let's jump right into it's a brand
new par of
par we're talking about the we finished
up last par how we threatened them but
now we're going to the itself so we're
going to have seven which
is
which of the every is seven which is it
sh in
thees which month
and how much in the month which day and
the six is what time of the day which is
all these are very crucial for because
if a person says that such a m happened
in the lake would an able to say happen
in he was
in it's going to be all for however
argues says no you do not need all these
seven rather there are three crucial
questions which are
what which day was it which time of the
day
which place it was those three is enough
for you do not need B you do not need
anything more than that and then we ask
we tell
them do you know the victim what's the
question rash's maybe it's a if it's a
GU not if you murdered him so do you
know we all know you have to and the
same thing would
happen we
asked do you know what type of did
how did he do that there multiple
options to
be and the M continues and
says the more you can do the better it
is like that we avoid we get rid of all
the people that are that
not we're GNA see who this
is that the was that a murder happened
under F tree and they asked aen how thin
or thick were the stems of these figs
what's the difference betweenus and soak
we know it's either Seven important
questions according to three important
questions what's the difference between
it sounds like we're learning that the
last case of the safe of the Mish of and
all those
are arguing that what's the difference
between and that the says
regarding the second one of the say he
does not know the answer to this
question
Al because we're GNA see you can't do
and any that is no is not an however
does not
know even if both Witnesses say I don't
know the answer to this
question however the says it doesn't
make a difference regarding
it's one witness says was a black tree
the other one says it was a red tree
automatically they
is continues they ask what day of the
month was it so one R says happened the
second day of the
month
says and we're going to explain why
why which means to say is very possible
the last month like even last week
Thursday we know was it was a month of
it was only one day it's very possible
in a month that there would be a one of
the did not know that so he's off track
by how much by one day
however when it's ready a two day
discrepancy
then we're going to explain why is it
one day vers two days what makes the
difference question is what time of the
day guy says it was 9
o' guy says it was 10
o' however
again if there's a discrepancy of two
hours one says nine and one says 11 then
we're going to say it's a bad AIS
however AR says we're going to see why
that it's more of a how much would a
person make a mistake how long can you
make a mistake in the day in those days
we didn't have what we have today clocks
was more based on the son therefore he
goes a little more
M however five and
seven and the reason is
by the
5:00 the sun is in the
East and it's in the west so therefore
everyone agrees such an error is
probably not a not a true
AIS okay after all this happened we
bring in so all this even though it said
the L of a plural of is only eight but
now we're really now we all those
questions were to who to eight now we're
going to bring in the second eight and
see if he aligns with
everything so
we bring in the
second if it's they're line again it
doesn't have to be exactly
100% we open up the like we learned in
the last
par we know
the we learned
this like we learned that was three rows
of 23 each
they however he says
we bring him
up he would not get
removed again if he has some substance
he's making sense we're going to listen
to him even if he says that who's who
the victim himself the person who's
going to get executed
says as long as again there to
it and again they
find they have to debate it
overnight and what do they
do all the they go in Pier they go home
they go and they what do they do they
wouldn't eat too
much they don't drink they have they
have a very clear
head they discuss and debate what should
we do with this person should we kill
him or
not and the following
morning we the all the come back
I'm staying with what I
said we learned you could retract in
what you
said again during the deliberations you
cannot go back and change your mind
however when it comes to the vote itself
when it comes to the minion then a we
said he has no choice but to vote the
right
vote what
happens made a mistake so we remembered
we had these two
they pull out the Ledger and they and
they show him how he said something
else if they
find they do the final tally the final
vote remember it's 23 so 12 say
he because you need to have a majority
of two in order to
be
have then you have 11
again even if it's 11
so it's 111 and you're stuck with the
23rd guy
says even you have
22 one of the says he doesn't
know how much do you bring on how many
do you bring
on we learned this they keep them
bringing them up again if it's a split
decision continue continue Till There 71
it's
3635 what
is
36 you don't have a majority of
two you got to sit and deliberate and
deliberate until
when and thear is going to explain
what's the point If eventually we're
going to see that either way we're going
to free him if they can't get the
decision is going to say they we don't
want it to look like a Bez that's very
confused
we know that you do seven all these you
do
seven
says which is number we're learning from
this
one which is two we're putting together
is three then we have another later on
in
number again is another two so we're
ready up to five how do we know seven
the last one
is we're learning from and another two
from here we see seven so what are we
talking about we're talking about three
one is the and then we have
the and then we have so to clarify the
first and
then and the third one is by sorry the
second one is by and the third
one is by okay we have
seven maybe each one again like we
saying
there's and maybe each one should have
for
example only have three
questions should only have
two put all seven we're coming to learn
seven questions so put all seven and one
p you'll learn that from each other
all together we're learning out from
each other it's not a problem therefore
we put the 3 plus 2 plus two is seven to
tell us all seven are going to have the
same that we do
seven it's not true you can't
compare why not so we're going to bring
a we're going to see the difference
between and everything else what
why we know we burn all the possessions
of the city so I'll tell you over there
maybe over there you
have maybe even
seven which is they save the M their
money we don't kill it maybe it'll be
less
questions and the same thing with what
how could you compare
we
know really depends what he's doing
however we know there's also he can
get compare the
last we
know just like by him he didn't what
he's trying to do he's not giving
there's no because he's trying to knock
out so we know so you can't compare all
these cases to each other
answers you're right however we're
learning that from what
the and
it's since all three have a similar have
a similar word of what to tell us to
connect all
three if it to be question we're showing
us that there is a difference between
all
three could have just said
you're still only
from we
understand it could have clear you no
point to
say what do he wanted to
say you have it
clear so what do he wanted by the case
of
could have just said a
double instead what do we
have a
different to tell us to learn out from
each other to make to tell us all three
of
them have
seven now that we know
this because all those cases a case of
SK and we're going to
learn which is a case
of you know what it says is coming he
has
extra which is extra four each Ms is
extra one which is four
you have
11 it's like our for those seven
questions which is 10 add another
three with one less with one the 11th
one what is doesn't need
his we had
this still the the brings it out in the
he wasn't happy with this he
says maybe why you
coming
May where's the where is
that we could ask in what time of the
hour was it 6:30 in the morning was it
6:45 or 7
o' so they give a little context there
really going on M we know what our m is
very clear T holds more than one
hour according to how much you have an
two hours however
the holds a person knows exactly the
time again it's like today it's very
easy to understand that we have clocks
in accordance to until when until a half
hour that is the L you
have says a person makes a mistake but
only a little it's like 613 to 610 you
know a few minutes off and you have up
to an hour that
is to says until two hours and you have
a little less than three hours so based
on this understanding
mayor
say over there even Accord to
person makes a little mistake we
understand theor that you could ask hey
what time was it was it 6:30 or
6:00 people don't know the exact time to
the second to the
minute you know what the question could
be is what we know it's years 49 stimes
seven so you can ask what was it was it
you know in the yil itself what what yil
was it
that type of question that's the next
question
our which year was it was it 49 years
ago or was it 200 years ago on that
gonna say to that
no a person doesn't give Aus forget
about statute limitations but it does
person doesn't give AIS about 70 years
ago it's very maybe about the Holocaust
we find such a concept it's very that a
person is going to give an ad about that
many years ago therefore it's not one of
the eight that's not one of the seven
questions we know there only three basic
questions according seven
questions according to
you yesterday he killed him you ask him
all these
questions understand so you happy you're
telling me this questions your three
basic
questions he just killed him you can to
ask him which day it was he just
said he said it was right
here even though there are plenty of
cases that you don't need such
questions we learn says we confuse Aid
we bring them to different rooms we try
to get them off their
feet is going to tell
you very possible yesterday to say he
killed
him we ask him do you recognize the
victim is he a is he a
etc what type of what was who was the
victim we ask him was we're Le he need
be and to say yes I know I'm going to
get executed from doing such a a and he
goes does
it maybe you could say forgot so has we
deeper and the same thing we
ask these are different types
of how do you do
it bunch of different types of see they
could they ask him these
questions I tell you how do you know the
person has to
give a person takes his
sister does not mean because otherwise
it's the only case we have you would
have to say ra we know but all the other
cases ra does not mean so what does
mean just because you
see that doesn't make
sense they have to give they have to
explain this is AR and the Torah forbids
this and if you do this you're going to
get and we're going to see since we're
going to give it something else
by his
sister has a different to tell us
we if a
person so the
what sounds like right now the
second it's going on as we
talk we're talking about we found him
while he was gathering the
wood again you see that was happening
while we told him it's a
present for the
reason like it says in
the we're playing with the
words why they need so many
we know that which is
kill for example
by why I need
to again like we learned
earlier say and learn everything else
says himself that he's going to
get We Know
by she gets typical gets so they now
that they got busted they could say no a
we don't want we weren't here to kill
her we just wanted to make it we just
fell that she should be like we
know that means you're trying to kill
her what's to get
killed we learned this once
that which
means the whole point
we all know regarding has which
has since they don't killed why
not she's not g to get
killed say
how could it be such a case answer is
very good case you know what the case
is when she's going for the second time
around such a when it's ready the second
time
around we could still say we're not here
to kill her we just want it for the
second person that did Tash Ru was her
Ru Tash okay so that's why the this but
the second time around the trying to
bring the second time around is a r that
what that she's here to kill him that
the ad are here to kill her Mar says no
we can SA maybe but there was a
different you know why you know why you
can't say
this any those two cases whether was the
which was either
way you're here to kill her you're not
here to make
her what I don't understand even gets
gets killed what's the
even which is what they're not even
married they
married but what they're not living
together can still say I'm here the have
a and say I wanted them to be user I
wanted this is to be user for her future
husband that they're going to live
together one says was killed with what
with the sword r with an ax it's not a
good it's a
steer what happens the guy says you know
what the were
black was white
then it's a good because it's not what
it's not to the core of what killed the
person so we look it as a side
[Music]
point to tell us
what
with so you clearly hear here we see
that what we see even kale is a Cale is
a problem Mar answers you know what the
Cale were it was T crucial to
the for example guy kills somebody with
a scarf he takes a scarf wraps it around
the guy's neck and Yanks it and that's
how he he killed him then makes a
difference what color was the
scarf exact same thing as an Axe and
a his sandals were
black question makes no difference to
the core function of what they how he
got killed it makes a
difference the way you killed him was by
kicking him with the sandal so in such a
case a we have to know what color was
let's
bring which was there was a murder going
on under the fct Tre and he asked how
thick or thin who cares was what do you
care about the side effects what
regarding the Fig
Tree you know we're talking about
because so was a murder wasn't nothing
to do with
Chas you know how he killed they killed
him with the stems of the fiig tree then
you want to know how big it was that he
poked him in in his chest or whatever he
poked them
where regarding this fixure with stems
were thin and him where now thigs cannot
kill we can understand maybe a stem if
you know to Sharp it especially
prisoners will figure this out in a
heartbeat how to take any little thing
and use it as a murder
weapon you know
what you can't bring a ride
from was something else what you're GNA
see there he put them together therefore
there's no from the from to bring it to
our case of
Ben who's this
Ben could this really
be was he part of the the kill we
know was only what he lived
businessman he learned so it's only the
last 40 Years of his life that what he
was able to be part technically part
of we
know no more
they stop
doing that can't
be so we clearly see that they stopped
doing capital
punishment so how could if you look at
the Timeline it's not possible that
was how do you understand the case of
the with the if you
make was what after the then by that
time lift 120 only the last 40 Years of
his life was he giving was he part ofan
adrin and those last 40 of his life was
way past the timeline when there was
ready there was no more capital
punishment GNA have to
say would Reb really call him
Ben that
word so what he tell
me we clearly see the which was a case
of capital punishment you know how we
can fix the
timeline was a student at the
time and they called
him while he's still learning he was
called lat on his life this last 40
years you know why they call
now in his later on years they
call what's the case even if two say
that one even if say you know that even
if say we don't know it's a
good a
good even if one says I don't
know why should make any
difference going to this is what they
saying when it comes to even if one says
he doesn't who is this
like says even if there's 100 forget
about three two even there multiple
they're all in one
bubble says is
good this is what you have to read
that's not like
that which makes sense would argue would
say they were learning this they were
sitting and
learning asked him a question as
follows tell me tell me what's going on
what did you guys learn over there
what are you asking me about
the it sounds like something's bothering
you when you pull over me you Le tell me
about it
this
know so he's bothered he
says
questioning I don't
understand the
answer however
regarding so if it's what does that mean
it's so it's really totally in one point
is it that you could be M him or not
that's what it's toally on
you answer me very good you're that has
to do with the
soay since you came over that you asked
us you really wanted the truth and more
than that and you asked us you asked us
to really get a question you weren't
here to rip me up however have you been
very you know very tough with us and try
to get us
then we wouldn't have been able
answer you whatsoever we want to spoke
to
you more than
that sounds like they wouldn't have even
answered
okay we learned this if a third in the
month the fourth in the month the third
to the fifth
so till when can you say I don't know is
it the 14th or the 13th or the 12th or
the 10th but it sounds like you have a
time limit where you're expected to know
the
you know
why why don't we say that a person
didn't realize two months has already
passed you know
why eventually you get to a point where
you realize the
was answer
no have till the end of the
you could say making a mistake
however we could
say it that after you don't miss
two one okay you overslept but two is
and therefore you're
not now it's coming
up until what till the moon comes full
like a cavity till it's more or less
full how much is
that until the seventh of the month
which is basically what we know is a
half is is a half a
moon which is Moon I think we like
this both not arguing what said which
was it has to get filled
up one looks at like a boat like like an
arrow if you picture an arrow with the
bow it's half with the string going on
like a SE which is basically a round pot
which is the moon which is
full why don't we say every right now
it's the beginning of the
month's towards the end of the month
when it starts
diminishing we don't say
that so he asked him back okay every
month in the beginning say towards the
end of the month when it comes like the
17th 18th when starts diminishing say
that's what the moon is we're going to
see in a moment that's the way it's
supposed to be created we don't we don't
make such
a we Le this yesterday last
week we're learning from the tell us
we say this in
the you have to say
standing go on other people's shoulders
because they're very old so they pick
them up on other people's shoulders and
make the
West why do the men have to say it
because we know is really a for the
ladies rather has to be also for us
what's in
the this is what we say
every with his
words
with
time they don't change what they're
supposed to
do workers that are honest we know what
the the Moon
and they make the glorify
the then we have a says as
follows which means with wi C
which means all much of the produce is
comes from the of
the it has to be for example one o'clock
in the afternoon to 3 o'clock in the
afternoon you can make a
mistake imagine guy says even today n is
around 7:15 720 there's a big difference
between 6 o'clock in the morning and
8:00 in the morning right it's day and
night literally
night there you would have made a
mistake why would you make such a
mistake see the he's seeing the glow
that's coming out in the
morning really we just seen is like the
Rays the reflections
Etc that a person does not make such a
mistake we bring everybody
in we
know we're talking about this dying said
something
good he would stay over
there said
nothing have to read
it then you put them out for one
day so we we go we went through the
concept what he does the the ban goes
home with peers they think about it they
don't drink wine so why don't they drink
wine say
which means rules should not drink
anything that's
intoxicated which is the secret of
the you're dealing with the person's
life you don't drink any
wine if they
never they can't come to the decision
what do you
do what's the whole point of going
through this whole
procedure know why you know what's going
to happen if you get the split decision
it's not even split it's it's it's it's
just one majority we want it to
flip what's going to happen is it looks
very confusing M when everyone knows
they thought about it for a while and
eventually they got the point they still
can't make a decision then what we say
is okay doesn't a better name
in why do we have to come and we have 23
that what we eventually get it to 71
just stop over there and you have 23 and
that's it
for
23 right so m is we're going to clarify
what is this words of old what is
exactly
someone say means it's very difficult
it's a
very why in the world by anything by
make sense you have to know what you're
talking about in order to kill the
person know
means wisely decided it wasn't like one
two three decision they came to the em
and then they pass
the older D says talk the
words okay it's a wise
decision the chief judge comes and says
that it's a difficult it's a difficult
decision embarrassing himself why would
he talk like that my answer is in
yes it's not a problem guy gets up and
says I have XYZ weakness but you have to
get up and say your weakness is y it's
much more of
a that's why when he says it's a
difficult den and that's why he's saying
it saying it's a
good a person should get up the chief
judge and say yes we we know what we're
doing I came out to the most wonderful
wise decision says in the which is
praise when a person gets
up your mouth shouldn't talk like that
rather the zar should should give you
should give you your Praises not you
answer who talks the chief
judge okay we're going to the
next unfortunately this person is going
to get executed what do we
do we take him out to get
skila where was this scaffold where was
this place that they would give him
skila so B
Bas was outside
the and it was far away like it says in
the we're going to go through we're
going to have the Mal we're GNA have
multiple cases the power and everything
we're going to go through
everything the says you should remove
the the m m we all know got
one guy stands
in and he had like this type of flag in
his
hand and then you had a horse following
the person who's going to get
executed so picture this we're sitting
in the of the guy's by the door holding
a flag the second some says you know
what I think I have he quickly raises
the red flag whatever color was and then
the horse the guy in the horse sees the
flag he goes running towards the people
going to execute says stop wait a second
they raise the flag
he should Rashi says he they wait over
there he doesn't come back other say
they immediately bring him
back so what so what
happens he the
flag even if he himself you know what I
have actually an answer why XYZ what I
did has to be that there's T to what
he's saying otherwise we don't keep him
coming
back is this really true that it was
outside it was outside was away from the
three we have then we have which is the
second we have and outside of that is
answers yes you're right it's
after
says even for whatever reason the
outside
already you still must take the Bas of
Law and put it even further two reasons
why shouldn't look like's a bunch of
murderers like that he got convicted at
6:00 we're going to see later which is
yesterday's D the whole conviction was
literally m a few minutes the whole
thing but we want a few minutes of that
time in order to be able to save
him okay do we
know there we're
learning know
three when they burnt the part this
whether was
a or the
they burnt the the the the carcass of
they burnt it outside no one's able to
eat it we
know how do you know that by
what when it says you should move all
the how do you know again
three when it says
you burn
it I already know that you burn why is
the telling
us tell us you remove
it by the already we know why do you
have to tell us we already know where
the
burn in the
to tell us three three okay so we have
very clear very we see three to tell us
that
it's person
be
even
answers it's better to learn it out you
have an option either learn it out from
the Perman or learning out from the
that's our two options
options why we're going to going to use
these words as acronym which is one
acronym which is basically four
different
points which is two from the word L
and let's explain all these four why we
want to connect the from the power and
not learn from the first one
is now we all know by the m and the
they're both getting removed outside the
m to get killed however
it's not like that we know very clearly
if anything you don't do it outside if
you did it outside you get punished
that's number one and then if you look
in the both everywhere it says except so
you have a choice to connect the two you
bring
the to the the third thing is we're
going to go there are options what
exactly means but means by
the both and the you both need to do it
outside in order to be Max you do it out
side that's the point of doing you T you
tack up a p over
there it'ser to do it outside and the
fourth one is we know that what by the
by the
what and the same thing with the the
burning is
a it's the opposite that Itself by doing
outside if anything forget about Kap if
anything is so you have these four
things to learning out from what from
from
from St to play you have a bunch of
things I could also learn it I also have
four things why which
is so what's it mean means this follow
we all know by the tells us that what
both
cases it's the person
right and is both the person M the power
the power who are we discussing we're
talking about a carcass Ava to burn it
over there so you have a to compare it
between and compared to
the that's number
one we all
know he didn't do the didn't
do what we all
know the power the power was ready dead
and the last one that's what it means
which means
and we can have we know that doing
anything
has nothing to do
with you could do a pigle therefore you
have a choice to bring P connected to
two where going to connect it
to the most similar is what if you have
a choice there's four in one side four
in the other we rather go to the most
similar which is the like we explained
that you have to do it it's part of the
part of preparing it is outside of
the Rapa learned something elsea is not
going
is going to question this who is he only
who he
ARG
was that
means
out
then's to tell us that did it that they
listen to the
command have
this rather you have to come
from regarding the he says we bring him
out and we Stone
him what are you GNA do with
that we learn two things out of this
first of all we're going to learn that
clothing prolonged the death we don't
want to give to a person we're going to
go through this extensively in a moment
and we're going to see that even one
rock after we do the if he falls on his
head we throw one rock
Etc would
told he gets away with it you throw one
rack it doesn't kill him he gets to go
home we throw a bunch of
on we
maybe take two stones
of that we start off with one big
boulder it's the easiest way to kill him
so what's going on why is coming to say
we have a very that's coming giv us a
very maybe to learn it from Lear from
the power but we have what's a public
coming to say no I have my own opinion
who is he to argue in the says no he's
not
ARG just saying AR I'm just saying that
we have however if there wouldn't be
this is what the he has like we learned
the bottom
of and the says means
where goes extreme little he says he
breaks out the the two
that g to tell
you we're gonna
see you're splitting up the into what
are you going do with you're going to
have to split it up how you going to
learn it over there my what is thees
over there answers
whether it's the stone that's going to
kill him we're going to see the beam
that he gets hanged on we kill him with
the
sword the has to pay for it why my we
don't say go to the store and buy
yourself a gun to that we're going to go
shoot
you that that makes that makes no sense
however we learned to the we have a flag
and a horse to save
him the this flag
we
have it's for your sake to save you so
you got to pay for
it we have to make sure to protect it
all course as long as it's possible do
we have to pay for
it we know when a person gets
killed G this grain of with
wine like a person he shouldn't fight
his death like that it's going to
prolong it like that I guess he's very
high we give some drugs today we would
give him and that's said he's gone he's
happy to
die you give we're going to learn from
this which is something intoxicated to
the person that's
L the bitter
souls and what happened
was they would bring this
wine
however who brings
it that we give it
the guy gets up and says I have next
thing you know comes
mute blows his hand like saying this is
you're not making sense he he says I
don't
understand once you go in this m what
because the guy said he has something
maybe there's someone in the other side
of the world will also give you a ter
and say that he's he's free we don't
think like that says oh calm down
awesome like a guy gets up and says he
has something
to
something answer is no
again again I know if a guy say and the
guy dies overnight we we use it as good
vote we're back to the question gets up
he says he has something smart to say he
sees his maybe the point is we wanted to
bring another bz the point of bring
another B what's the sh the sh is maybe
we should bring it to another B like
that new fresh set of minds and there's
a bigger chance that he will be
acquitted we said even if the victim
itself says I have his we bring him
back even the first two times
around we said it has to be that he
has underline this word even if there's
no
only after the third and
on only from the third time and on you
have to
have so how do you know if a person
has we bring
a they first listen they have to prove
it something
smart I don't understand why don't we
bring these two peers immediately by the
first two no matter what we come back
Mar answerers you know
why the first two times a person's so
worried about getting executed he can't
think straight he's T not going to say
anything with M even though he has
something smart to
say if
we we get him he goes
home going to
get we give a proclamation we say as
follows
is getting killed for doing such and
such the reason why I mention and
everything is in order to bring out the
higher the chances if it's if it's not
true we'll be able to
find have to say
when again to bring out the strength of
har the chances of
only now not before it's very
fascinating the stops and we're missing
if you go through the go through it's a
question and it's missing a lot of print
in
the we're GNA go through little who
Slaughters
it there's
two it
says a broken
Spirit it
says someone who's broken and
crushed not
brother okay we're going to continue the
scenario of how we
do he's around 10 away now we tell him
do we don't want to do like that his
mind is already first we're going to
give him something to drink but it's to
not be to think
straight we're going to discuss
throughout
the tells him my
son we're going to see what happened
that he did a and he says I want you to
give me I just admit what happened that
you stole
you how we know that it was
good what why have you ruined
us was going to ruin you da today she's
going to get me and make
a person doesn't
remember the guy knows he was Fram what
should he
do a person we're going to see why we
don't want this to happen but every
person going to start saying you know
what I was fr even though he wasn't and
we're going to see the issue with that
later on
the we see that yes begged to give to
give we know
only am I am I gonna
snitch understand this a little deeper
rather go make yourself a
so yes
comes tells yes come on you're not
making sense if I make
a the whole C Lottery is the someone's
going to be the winner that's how the
brain plays I have the chance right so
he's basically saying you're going to
tell me I did a a Bas and a girl I could
flip it around make and one of them is
automatically going to say it was him
we learned
this
so he actually fooled him he convinced
him he told him give a just give a and
you'll get away with it and then he
found out he's going to get executed you
have to know how he did it because of so
so important
M was able to trick him and light
him you just everything's going be fine
immediately from three misappropriations
why is another one which is the
third was
and he got
killed what only now did get killed why
did he get punished
now this this concept because this if
you look inside the it
says if you look inside the clearly the
last
it
says if you look inside the there's
clearly dots on
the why do we have these
dot exactly where do you see from the
dot that it's a time that's from now
sounds like only until only now and on
that's when the hidden sins which is
we're talking about that's we going to
get punished
it says until
forever why did he get punished why what
changing
suddenly you know why it already became
a once his wife and children know it's
ready a r knew about it and it's not
considered says in
the famous
song what
is even if a mytle between the
Willows even if a
person even we're doing we still
stand it's the same over
there they put it in the
if you look inside the it says five
times why do you have to say that to
tell us this
point we know he didn't but he tried he
tried hiding it he was a big
r we know
means what's the big
deal he already did it why you going and
trying to hide your bris
such a Russ even tried to go back and
rash's that eventually by pulling the
arw by
pulling eventually Tak was
covered that she
did what's a big deal we know he's a
Russ such a case of it's
it's you're embarrassing the family and
you're being on
the didn't
care just
saying just learning that was commanded
to get killed that was his punishment
but himself he
wasn't he took the silver the garments
the
of then if you look inside the it
clearly
says that's what we're trying to pull
out you should underline
that what did they do
wrong show us what's going to happen
look say look what's happening so to we
brought the the reason why I brought the
family because they were involved a
little more it says in
the you burn him and
didn't whatever the possessions clothing
for example own clothing can
burn the animals that got says in
the and they saw The Spoils of what
which means like a lovely
garment was good
Sil you know what this lovely means it's
it's fine wool and rash that the second
animal was born they covered it you put
like a nice covering like that it was
pristine was beautiful
fine it was died with what withum rash
says I think is also an English word
which is a certain type of
chemical says in the
Heff for this for what did he took
something says in
the 30 people got k
one thing if you say around the 100
people around is a good number what is
36in he's considered like a of 71 36 in
majority what is the
saying that's
whenever he answers with full
of were playing with this
saying was very
tough he spread in front he started
saying this what's going
on we find this with 24,000 people got
killed and we know
with Right comes by the and he pulls up
and he he does with the and it
says was stop 24,000
like more of the
Judgment did with
put we
know we also find this by rather we see
yes yesu
says why do we move this entire nation
and they shouldn't to listen and say
spoke like
this why is this na so
evil yesu
says if only would have chosen not to
cruise not to cross over the yard would
were would have been better
off go raise
yourself it's really your fault why
I said
what they're supposed to write in the
mames the on the stones what did you
do you do the 60 Mill we this is this is
what wanted to say after says he puts a
to speak and give
over so what are you talking about
didn't listen to he put the T 60 mil
away in
he
saying was really your
fault this what he's
saying
rather you shouldn't have this issue
what it say
the lifts his
eyes he sees a person standing over
there and what happened
was and he says who are you and he says
what do you mean
I'm so what did
do how could he bow n because he said
rash's
says says in the rain you coming to stay
overnight sounds like it was D if it was
a night cuz if it was in the day he
would have realized if he was a or if he
was a of
the
down maybe
it's he
says maybe he's lying very nice to say
that he's not that he's that he's coming
from answer we know we have a
tradition is not
the therefore he was able to bow
down that's where I'm
coming which he come for
the now
for what does it say the
immediately started
learning how do we
know which what are you g to do with
this what's the says in the as
follows don't get yourself into fight
very
quickly what's going to happen after for
example you walk into the show you start
screaming at a guy after you embarrass
him he said say XYZ wasn't if guy says
why do you block my car and then the guy
answers I don't talking about I don't
even drive right and then you get all
embarrassed what you want to fight your
friend before you fight before you make
sure we know we're doing find out
everything you have to understand this
talking talk like this
embarrass
them right away wow how could talk like
this
to to talk like that
say three names
has able to
talk shut
down can't stop us forget about it we're
in
trouble says in the p
this is talking as he's basically saying
his friends were telling did you D him
before this tragedy happens look at you
now but did you D him before
happened nothing would have been
left anyone Str
with he has no enemies up there
enemies on
top we know that had a good after he did
the he
died
got it says in
the we're gonna see in a
moment say
all like
what so what is his
name that what he's like a snake is a
snake that he went around us and put all
on
us what should he do he should say I
should if he doesn't if he doesn't
remember he should say and
everything that what if a person got
framed he should say accept this a and
then we said everyone's going to do it
so let everybody do it the guy's dying
either way so what let them get them let
them make believe that it wasn't there
either way dying my answer
is imagine every time in we see such
it's a big L
okay a person was on the way to get
executed
says if this is I don't
want for of
my however I'm
tell however I'm just letting you know
you guys you you guys are fine however
never be for framing
me they got very scared they
said what do he want the says we must
kill him
he has to get
killed who the
responsibility what do you mean this is
what the T tells
us this guy's goingon to want to get
away with him says no
even that they
lie the says we don't believe you have
to remember a person starts getting cold
feet when the guys about to get executed
my answer is
even when he's given a
reasoning what's the case of rash goes
very long Rashi takes over the whole
quickly through it with this case this
person was a tax collector and he was a
big russer and he died the same day God
died they make a bit beautiful L during
the came list everyone running besides
the there was a hiding and they went
they flipped the meas and it was very
embarrassing the Russia got a beautiful
L got a terrible L his T was distraught
he fell asleep that night he has a dream
this comes over him says Ah look at me
I'm doing great you know what he says
what thisi happen he says it was one
time people in never answered so why did
he get this Russia this tax collector
got himself a beautiful the answer was
because one time set up a whole
beautiful banquet for the S to come he
never had them showing up he cancel he
gave the food to the that's why he got a
beautiful you go look at him right now
you know where he is he's burning a g he
says wow wow wow okay I see what's going
on he says well for how long is going to
stay there he says you know until when
until
shim right it
says and he's going to come and replace
him he says why why get such a
punishment he says because it's a
terrible time of and there are 80 80
Ladies as we speak doing multiple types
of and they're in Ash and he says and
he's not doing anything about it the
wakes up in the morning goes running to
he tells him what's going
on says I have a beautiful poent now the
second you're off the ground you have no
control he says it was a rainy day he
quickly brought
80 they put in a pot these beautiful dry
coats he pulls up to this little castle
he walks right in they're about he says
I'm also Mas what's going on I'll prove
it to you that Mas you see outside it's
pouring rain I could go outside in a
second come back with 80 people wearing
dry coats for Kava they come in they got
very shocked the second they were
shocked each one picked the the the lady
up once the ladies off the ground
there's no K takes them outside they did
skila and then they hung them kind of
and what happened was and then it
continues one of the CRA of this were
very upset they made up a about the son
the was about to get executed on the way
to get
executed and said you know what yes
we're really relatives of these ladies
and that's why BDA and taka believe the
story that's why we're trying to compare
this over here to this type of thing the
reason why we want to go through this
see on we're going to the
no so it's it's interesting rash says I
was also wondering but if you look
inside also throughout the the that
nothing prevented him
and because how do you understand if you
think about it we brought this in how do
you understand it clearly
sounds it's not so simple if you read it
we're learning that we did die couldn't
prevent it
he's away four away from the's T four
what do we
do we remove his clothing and the reason
we on the understand remove his clothing
like that he could have a quicker
death we block his we put a little
cloth back also
consider of a lady getting hung
brings either means we just carve a
little or means a little
cloth
why don't do
this Stone
him we know
regarding get killed
he's not going to have
clothing however
regarding like we all
know and therefore you don't have an
extra
meat right away remember what's your
problem we're worri that this lady's
dying and she's she's hanging on a tree
and people are going to have
he we find this by what by the
sight he holds on to right when he's
given
water if even a bunch of TS doesn't make
a
difference until you see her
chest she's a beautiful
woman because of what because of her so
here we see does care about so why by
the case of SK we say we do hang them
hanger you know what's the problem by by
she's not for sure going to get killed
the young going have a t for her and
they're going to end up going
after she's dead she's dying that's what
the whole point is they're
executing maybe have
a she's gonna have a that's where
there's a problem by sight she comes out
innocent you have to remember she's not
so innocent
answer here
whated the problem here
ISS says in
the which means say is you repr all the
woman it's not a
problem you should not make her like
we're trying to bring out over there yes
we wanted to learn after the we she did
a terrible a let's not fool our she was
after the husband told her not to do let
us but let us learn from it so what's
the problem over here here she's ready
getting executed
she's getting
killed every so what's the if you she
should wear clothing when she's getting
executed
not it's very simple a person the guy's
getting he's dying in five minutes yeah
not here but you rather prolong your
death by a few minutes last
while you're dying or what if a person
says I'm either way dying I don't care
about B I want it to be one two three
nice and
quick throw on his
hips if he fell face You' flip him
around but if he dies from the full the
second a goes so first pushed them the
second one what takes a big
Stone throws on his heart and you hope
he dies
whoever was there would start stoning
him till he would
die he was standing so if you count his
height which is another six another
three and therefore it's really three
stories
high need such a long such such a high
in order to kill
somebody we know this
we're
compar
with if you put a person in a bar that's
only 10 yes he's going to die it's a
very high chance but we know with the
chance of dying is quite very it's more
than that it's very high so put him very
high like that'll be one two three
answers the N his body's going to
Splatter we brought in the another issue
the high are you
the more the more s while he's flying in
the Earth the pain of knowing that he's
dying that's what we were wondering
okay they
push how do we know that we
do
says it
say know even if you pushed him and he
dies Le
from this is talking about if you know
the right the p is clearly talking
about know this is even the future not
just to tell us even for the
future is it really true do you really
understand that this second AG just goes
and picks up the Rock heaven was so
heavy and it
was the two people had to pick it
up which means to say you're right the
stone is very heavy so you need two
people to pick it up however imagine two
people you'd have to go one two three
throw it's much easier now that it's
ready in the ear to pick up one guy and
throw it it's comes down in a much
stronger and therefore like again we
wanted to K we want it to die at a in a
very quick
Pace the
stones it never happened in in
throughout history that such a thing
happened never said it the P never says
You must do it the p is saying for
whatever reason ends up coming such a
thing that he doesn't die after this
whole procedure clo goes and throws the
stones whoever surrounding them by the
best
this stone that they threw we're going
to see you bury it that to sound like
there was always a stone men for
execution whether the be that we got you
hang
on so what's it mean that there was an
EV over
there there was an EV but once he used
it you bury it and replace it with
another
one we says you don't get buried Pap my
I don't mean
that that itself is considered what
we're saying
aeral what happens and then time it
comes to execution one of the lost his
hand so he can't push him
off Le the
lally doesn't have
hand people that don't have hands they
were missing hands they were born like
that the tell us that if he had
if you never had a hand more than that
the way we look at the stump is a hand
that's how you look at a person who
never had a
hand what happens if we say what happens
happen L decided to execute him and he
ran over
here so you clearly see it's not the
same my answer is
no this is the same that we said we were
lakeid it is a little it says sounds
like that they're coming to say about
other being do you really
need guys's running away the only way to
kill him is to shoot a gun that's
deserve how do we know we do
this says
you don't need the
literally like we just
learned and so what's the case
of how do we know the best put it on
says in the
anybody is this really true you don't
need a literally we know this by the If
the parents were what one of the
parents missing he's mute or if he's
lame or if he's blind or if he can't
hear if you go through the
case that means they have to be able to
grab him they can't grab him he does in
the hand they what
the clearly
says to tell us he can't be
L and it
says be and they say that means they
have to see
him doesn't listen means they can't be
deatha isn't it because you see you do
have to go like what like the has to be
literally answer is
no
the that the parents need to be again
not lame not mute not deaf etc
etc let's try
bring we all know by the we burn
everything in the in the Town Square if
there's no Town
Square so what do you see
clear everyone agrees that what you need
to make a
you what do you have to do you have to
make a Town Square my answer is
regarding if this doesn't have a which
is a
thumb which is a big toe and right
ear says he have to put it he puts his
finger on
it what's more crucial is it even if
there's no ear maybe you just put it the
different ear but the point is we see
clearly other what do you do in such a
case of does he have or not okay very
where towards the bottom over
there
anybody want to say the only people that
get killed the people that what are
which
is the whole nation sees
him they put her face towards the
be
don't we just went through this
whole He we know he just hung 80 ladies
after he ston
them he hung 80 ladies and we
know he couldn't even kill more than
once you cannot bring you cannot bring
going to
learn Etc
says in
the says in the that what you clearly
should you you kill him and then you
hang him you would think maybe everybody
that gets
killed it says in
the learning
from anybody
when you
have however over here it's a little
different
says so if you stop right here you would
say nothing
more
however the top
of now that if you look inside the it's
separated two to tell us to
what say Okay
anybody you know what the that separated
you tell us everything that's similar to
the which is anybody that has
we don't hanger says
in to tell
us
us without clothing like we learned
ear right we have no choice but to come
from different more questions what going
to say says in the in the beginning of
the
us we don't look at we look at him as a
kid we don't look at him
as he does get
H even though he's a we're still gonna
kill
him so why do you
have
us one of the fascinating things that we
kill him for no for the
future for
example and now the whole concept just
to get a little context the reason why
we're so worried is the BDA needs to be
100% focused on doing the right thing so
the second there's a bunch of Mis we're
worried that b is going to lose their
Clarity their focus and end up making a
mistake
they all
getting we can't learn out from
him they were doing different the so
once the it's different a again B is
gonna have to go through every a very
and once there two a is going on we
don't do that
it's exact same exact same
everything we all know she
gets
or which means three pairs of which is
the first
pair's going to get comes the second
pair of says the first are liyar
therefore they're going to get either
skw
or pardon they're going to get the first
pair
of either or they G
get comes the third of and says what
that the second PA of Al so the second
of G to get what the first Pier would
have got what would the first peer would
have got either or SK but what's the is
now that the first of the EM the first
Pier is going to punish her Whata so she
got and the second Pier is going to get
or
even to make it like a fence to make
sure we're
protected now riding a horse is
only and there's nowhere in the T says
you can't do
it was terrible was going on a lot of
pre was going on in the V how do we how
do we hang
him we take a beam we stick it into the
ground it can be has to be quite thick
to hold his body right we put it
vertically in we have a piece of wood
that's
protruding we take his hands we tie him
and we put him on top of this beam and
he hangs there we're going to see for a
very short
time argues we're going to see why he's
coming from
was against the wall we didn't put it
anywhere into the
ground with the
Rope immediately we would release him
however we keep a body
overnight if you look inside the it
says you know why he
say we're going to learn a little more
that in pain when he sees
hanging you know what
says which means I burden with on my
head my
arm
think even you leave it
overnight
however for his own for example
immediately they wouldn't put him in his
regular
C two
cemeteries after a while when turn the
bones the worms ate it
up then they would put it in its
original
C would say we're still friends we know
you did what wanted us to do
what could you do when it comes to grief
that's your
control you first hang him and then you
Stone that's what do
first when when do we you know when we
killed him we would wait few minutes
the second we say you deserve to get
executed we bring in there we do the
whole very
quickly which means
say do for a second one guy ties it one
guy loosens it
done that's why it's fascinating even
though it's Mish for seconds we're still
busy which direction he faces if you
think about it
okay eight says in
the makes no difference if it's a
regular tree
bu imagine you put him on a big tree you
would have to uproot the tree call a
truck
Etc the reason why he says it has to be
against just against a wall you can't
even put it into the ground because by
putting into the ground has to be quite
deep to hold the body that's a problem R
is g to say just pulling out of the
ground
IM you have two twins you have
twins one's the king one
be the says you got to get he hangs
him look the's
hanging same thing with the Y where the
Y's hanging what do we see we see all
together just like the King's
Twin where is he coming from it says in
the where says that is saying that he's
very what me
they're not really arguing what means
which he means he's
heavy which is light less which I'm not
basically I'm
heavy just say if you're going to
tell a lot of times when you want to see
Heavy use I am light
you
need why
change maybe that's
us us what
us know a person he
Lees right the beginning of the says
from here we
see okay now we're going to see a
fascinating incident with
the didn't
answer was very
upset look where the world is you know
we gave the world too we gave it to to
for not answering
it what do you mean we're just going
through our Miss cover you bury no no no
he know he didn't answer I'll tell you
you put him in a box that's what he
means burying
him
says it's not a he's not he wasn't going
to accept it that's why he didn't say
that we know the got
buried just a
minute this is by a was getting
basically his whole family was getting
him his whole family is going to get
killed
but the says that he is going to have a
good me he's going to die but he's gonna
have a good husand he's goingon to get
buried okay and then it
says this is the town
of says they're not
have be like they're gonna lay on the on
the ground all the birds are going to
eat
them it's not with
is it because it's a for the
person I don't want to get talking about
himself third person I don't want this
person to get
buried family is going to get
embarrassed I don't want a
so we know that the got
buried the need
aers yes in
let's
bring the rest of his
family also got
buried
ansers he deserve
the says in the
this is regarding the town of
anus there were such that did not
deserve who's the COV for when you give
them is it for the the mace or for the
family says I don't want to when I
die if it's about him the he could force
the to pay it to give us if it's for
them they can say we don't want to spend
money on us
SP we know
came running from
the does that make sense just because
of s should sit there and wait my answer
is yeah s herself would have been happy
if for for ab to get
Co to
the is this his family that's why you
should give him a SP my answer is
yes at least his family should get
some learn from from the town of an it
says
the that his family the family didn't
even want to hear anything regarding
anything to do with the town
of this is a
of this a in
sorry says in
the Thomas this
is he says you're going to
die the way they killed the Kings they
killed all the possession more of a
covet whatever the king had they burnt
it as a covet are
shine they're going to call you a master
when you die when they give you a
SP what type of what type of is this he
doesn't even care you know the my answer
this is what they're saying
your memory is going to be in honor
for just like the earlier Kings was a
covered for them next week we're going
to pick up from the top of