Review the weekly Daf Yomi Pages 123-131 Baba Basra Shiur at Scheiner's Shul

everybody we're going to pick off from the bottom of the we're going to try to get all the way to on top of the on top of the we learned last week we had a br that says if someone left to their children a par that's either least or rented or you have an animal that's in the wet lands and they gave birth get double even though it's not considered when the over here is going to tell us that it's not considered right even though in the case where it's in the wetlands and N of the wetlands where we're saying that it's leased or rented it's not of theour of the owner is that he gets then why in the world do you need to tell us even when it's in the Wetland and that answers just like when this animals in the Wetland it's going on its own it's gonna get its own you don't need to feed it so too in such a case the is that we consider and more than that asks a question he says why don't you just say will know and that says because in a case there is a no one needs to give him where it's leased out there's still somebody that's feeding the masus and the kamash is that since the themselves are not doing anything we consider it the and therefore is the is going to be who is this it's re when we're saying earlier this BR that we learned that is when it's when it's automatically who is this this is re the says clearly says that is not I do say however that however if had to go and be then they do not get then the is not going to get double says the that says that owed to the father money and same thing with and this is talking about after the where came out that the father owed money and since he originally took double money therefore he has to pay back double however he says before the rash a person he has a to go over and say I do not want to take double then to do that and they both throw in cases where it works to the benefit of the assment by saying I do not want to take double says for example the brothers left to Med in such a case it's for the say you know what I'm not going to take double because he's is the only defendant over here brings down what happen when the is a so it works out to the advantage of thear and his brothers to say I do not want to take a double portion what is that say even by automatic you do not [Applause] get on that explains it says in the the way we look at this extra portion that is is just like a until it gets into your hands that's when you can receive it and more than that so if it's not in your hands you have no to do anything about it until you receive it fully until then you're not going to get any double portion the however that argues and says by you will get it says in the and and it says in the says it could have said in the just you get extra portion why do we put them together as a double portion what's the coming to tell us we should have a just like by that is even before the receives it every son regarding considered in his hands however what is going to do with this's right that it says and it doesn't just say they should get extra portion it's a good on that answers it's coming to tell us that the has a what is when there are three Fields so the he wants to say I want to take the Middle Field like that the is going to have to take the field on the right and the field on the left and it's beneficial for the P that he has the brother with two fields and he's in the middle like that it's it's cheaper he has more better and that the is that thear according to he says from Bish that thear has a that he wants to get two fields that are next to each other and and more than that however Rab's also going to learn understands this from he understands it together M to tell us that is a that even though it's not in his hands it's considered rece receivership over there also says it's coming to tell us that if he doesn't want to take it he has not to accept the extra you have a small little palm tree and a got stronger eventually you have a land that eventually on its own the the point is that the way it turned into a better field is that it happened on its own there the then it's not that he's going whether it's RAB R he's going to get double in the portion where they argu let's see have these shoots and then it comes into ears or it turns into dates you have a palm you have a palm tree it's only blossoming and then it turns into dates is going to hold is gonna hold and therefore since it's a he's not going to get a double portion is who the the or even if he pass it's so doesn't make a difference what he did whether he was like reab we in our case we have re going against thein so the sh is we know the is RAB against the is like RAB even against since it's a suff since it's a suff therefore whether the D like RAB or the dying Pas we say it's and we leave it as it is however says in the name of now that more that if he does it why what's the therefore is clearly like however this talking about in the name however however what mean were inclined to say like who like however says if you did like we leave it the way it is however we are inclined to say like it says what's that is so the is other other whether whether it's that's what we're going to be talking about the saer says in the it's coming to tell us the is not going to get if the had to put in energy Etc in order to produce more however it's a happens automatically then he will get it who's this it's like we just learned however we have the exact opposite in a different it says the even which happens automatically the the is not going to get double we're going to start a in the name of which is going to be quite extensive so we have to hold a little cop in all theas we're going to start the [Applause] name clearly says in the name of that is not going to get the double portion when it comes to after the if you're going to tell me that what not going to get it is to us that mil which is only something that you have no ownership right right now in the standing there's no ownership whatsoever there's no whatsoever you're not going to get it's coming to tell that you do get put in energy you don't get the problem is we have a that says and clearly there's a that holds that will get double we have to be talking about however we clearly will come out so how would you understand this now it's interesting we are going to say in a moment that that RAB says a little why the brought a and did not bring the explicit of re which you're going to see momentarily and that answer and you ask you know what's different by talking about a not talking about not however since we're talking about a document and the document is you would had a very clear to say it's consider on that that you are not considered a whatsoever this is clearly the name of now we're GNA have another which is the of which is they say he's the says this that says as follows does get so again ear that's a problem says so who is this Bryce refer that says so we're doing the same we did from to the first that place and he was and he gave said which sounded like quite clearly now who's is going like which you're going to see momentarily which we're going to discuss by so is and we we learned it early in they both said and said that we're both from and they're both going to hold that what when a person owes money it's considered a how do we see this the actually Chang it the changes it this G that we put first and more than that if you look atam he clearly puts ra before we're gonna go with with the is going to tell us in a scenario where there's we're talking about and there's what is the regarding does the get a double portion with this on that it depends if he got money back in return pay him back with money then he's going to get a double however if he paid him back with the he's not and the reason is giv him back the same money you asked for $100 I'm giving you right back $100 by car we're going to see that car is a little different since he has his more than that since he has his to release the car he never really had to pay him back specifically with that car we're talking about the car was however since the was never really in his hands since not that same therefore he's not going to go get double that is is says says when it's you do get and the reason is it's and we're going to explain the a little better in a moment however is since theak was m to you the whole time therefore you were considered from day one because we all know when you borrow $100 there's no half me that you have to give back the S same $100 but with the same serial number money is like it's not the same money so right away the questions you you're saying what's the difference you're telling me that by when it comes to paying back money is not going to get double you know why you tell me the because it's not the same money that the father left why if he wanted he could have easily sold it with money so one in the world what's the between money and you're the one who says that says you're the one who saying we're gonna see the scenario with of the grandmother then to say the case outside cuz we're going to see it in the bottom of the AR the's going to ask what this case is the case is that there was ruing ruven whether he was dying and he realized that no one's taking care of the sa so he had a good idea he said I want all my to go to the SAA like that everyone's going to take care of her however I don't want her y I don't want her kids to be yish her so what did he say he said after the SAA dies it should go to my daughter and the scenario was the case was that there was a daughter they had no kids and she married so and then the daughter died before the grandmother and before after and after he died we're going to see that extensively the story however we had a sh law and the husband came and the husband want after the after died the husband wanted to get the and that we're going to see that they said the husband doesn't get it really from different reasons for and we said and R over there says it makes sense that he shouldn't get it why because the husband the Safta sorry not the husband always had the opportunity to sell the car therefore you can't consider so that you're the one who says in the scenario of the then the case is so to over here then we should be able to understand in this case in this K you're telling me that what that that he's a because because one in the world that makes a difference just like by the S you tell me the daughter's not a cuz he could have sold it who did in this case by the we should say not that's why the same that we have by Mo it's not the exact same car that he left tell me by it's not the same because he should have sold it himself says in the name they went there was owed the father money went over to ruvin and took out Cara However unfortunately the father himself had also to Ley went Le Ley goes and he takes away the car that the took away and we're understanding the the only way to understand how Ley who's the second could take away the took we can understand that the K that was owed to the father originally was always a m that's why the is able to take because otherwise you cannot take away Etc will understand it's a therefore we have two kasas on whether it's we have the same type of and we have we or we see B he holds that the S is able to sell the car on that on that RAB tells no first of all it's not to Me Not only was he defending himself he was willing to defend and he says as follows we're just saying however we don't hold like that so to give we said there's two we have that clearly says is not and then we have that says you are that tells we me and we both hold like who we both hold like is that a person is never we agree to's I agreed to that 100% that's why like however in which is they're saying that does Say by you do go back me and differentiate is it referring to money or is it referring to and what's the we saw we said earlier the so I see from the the since you're able to sell it El you can't consider K is something that's a therefore by default I have no choice but to say that the is only going to be talking about money however ra says no you can't compare the the talking about a and we're talking about a something there's no going on and more than that on a real level it's much easier to understand that explains that we could say the whole time and money not because money's clear like and when a person lends you $100 that money is gone and you're hoping he pays you back he'll pay you back with different money but imagine I go over to someone I say can I borrow your can I borrow money can I borrow your phone and I say you know what I'm going to hold on to something till you pay me back and this when do I hold on to it I hold it the second I lent it to you so I'm holding on to this thing and then you come back to me five minutes later you say you know what keep it so if you ask anybody everyone will tell you when were you a you were from the second the whole time since the second you L to them you never let go that in essence is what she is very nice you had the opportunity to sell it you didn't and since you didn't holding on to it the whole entire time therefore I'm considered a so comes out it really comes out and is are we learning from the of the or not however they both hold like that you can never be however says which you're going to learn the and therefore it's really totally in the of the and that questions what is the scenario of sa we said it outside but my sa what is this incident that we're talking about with this grandmother and that says there's a person that tells his family I wanted to go to the grandmother I'm planning giving her all however after she dies wanted to go and not to her Y and again it makes sense if you really think about what the whole incident sounds like that he wants to take care of the grandmother because the children weren't taking care of the grandmother her own kids so makes sense that he doesn't want to give over theha to her kids therefore he wanted to give it to his kids now only had one daughter says it was one she was married let's she died this this call her the daughter died before the husband and before the grandmother now that the grandmother died came ring the husband of ra he wants to get the so raun wants to sayun and RA are going to make Theus What did the what did this person when he said that should go to the sa to the Yim did he mean d one generation Yim but shouldn't continue or not so when the person said the point was I wanted to go to my daughter instead of going the direction of the of the southest kids I wanted to go to my kids however that Che said said you're willing to give it to your daughter but you weren't willing to continue the generations they sent for Mar is not going to get the however that's clearly so we agree to that however according to would come out if this had a daughter and then died a fear of that this person when he said he was only willing to give one generation he was not willing to go a second generation however that's not true we hold was a son from this ra it would go to the son so what this R the husband of is not know like we all know went through this extensively a husband is never only when it's perspective it has to be a saw you're telling me says you are but that can't be everyone agrees a husband is never was being a little him he says it was open with I'm gonna end it myself I'm gonna explain to you what's going on wants to say when this person says I want to go to my daughter you know in essence what he was trying to say he's saying in reality I want myir to go out to my daughter however since no one's taking care of the grandmother I want the grandmother to have the to utilize the property till when till she dies I'm giving her and that that RAB says no sounds like I'm not willing to go like while prove Pro it to you it's not here it's a later in such a scenario the grandmother has sell it so how could you try to tell me that it's only you only have a to utilize the property that can't be the grandmother this is what we brought down he's comparing it to the case of the we all know and more than that here is coming to tell us that we had we said what is when you have a blossom and it turns into dates we saw the and that he wants to say that's by a however in a case of a day Tre where it turns into dates there everyone agrees the husband it's going to be considered a regarding the tree and you're going to get it Republic continues and gives is coming to us that we look at it in the scenario of however he will agree is not gonna get which is we all know this is however what is the when Ru who's a son of shim Ru lent his own father money now shim the question is how do we look at that extra portion and is the suff really is maybe the B was willing to give a extra she she knows he's a smart guy he knows that if I lend my father with the extra strength it's going to come at the father he's going to be able to get it double portion going to look at as a so therefore since it's going to help his own benefit that's the suff a person is willing to give it with extra that's the sh do we say maybe not there's no difference and therefore it's mama and we are going to split it wants to say the name you're right is not however in a case of however always has a right to say you know what I don't want to wait till you guys improve the property I rather split it today and I'll I'll harm my own people it's could be make it can make a lot of sense in this scenario where the let's say he's a builder or he owns a company that helps him that he doesn't want to split it doesn't want to wait till you to improve the property and like that you're going to end up not getting double on the on that has a right to protest and say I want to split it today like that the is going to be considered a because I'm the one who's going to be improving it and if they don't listen to him it's considered a and he's going to get a double portion even on the when you have grapes it's arm you cut it off you harvest them you smash them how do you smash them by stepping on them the way to make oil and wine Etc and we're understanding the Hava is the reason why you're not the reason why the even though he didn't listen to him he's not going to get a double portion says because the regular him you were supposed to split the property you went and took the olives and you we're talking about the who's not he was and therefore we all know even if he went and he did such a case the is not the is still going to get a double portion why we all know so why in the world should the get a double portion on that we're gonna see in a moment I'm not coming to tell that that I agree with to you that he's not going to get the the is not going to get a double portion however in a scenario where they cause a in such a case the and more than that just to bring up one point with even if the P didn't listen to there's no question about it we're not going to clash the and say okay you're going to have to lose whatever profits that the bakar got that he either way would have had to pay that to he would have to give it to his brothers where do we have this even if he went and turned into oil and wi we're talking about again that's the case where clearly says the for the splinting up the properties Ru who's the tells the other brothers you know what I don't need a double portion I'm willing to take only like a so clearly is no question about it you can't retract in that then you however now the question really becomes is what happens when there are other properties that the the are going to split do we say you're and all the other properties or maybe not however you're clearly clearly all other so what explains all the way we look at it it's not like a the second the father dies the and the they already have in the it's theirs you don't need to do a physical you didn't do any M Etc in order to be considered that it's your property you're yish however therefore whatever's dividing today we're dividing this field however the rest of the properties no everything why the that the even the extra portion is considered a of it's considered like a and therefore since he gets it immediately therefore he has and once he's this he's everything now just to bring out one point it doesn't sound like there's a that is everything it sounds like he's will to be Mel everything the question is really the m rapi and rap is is can he be everything he wants to be everything rather say can he be anything and that's how do we look at the extra is it a yha or is it like a mat and therefore we all know about mat you have no to go and give it up before it gets it into your hands that was saying the both saying in the name of not heard this from they heard it from well the went Ruben was he went and sold a property of a DI without asking his brother says he was planning and paying his brother he wasn't looking to be a golin he was just willing to go and help and sell the properties however died the died they wanted to go eat their dates cuz they H that the father would never would have sold it what happened says they started hitting the so C the C the got up and they told the it's not a it's not enough that you you bought the whole entire property illegally the was not involved in the sale you're also going and going to start hitting them what is going on so the they started to go in front of says the did not do anything why because he had noell the he had no toell therefore he didn't do anything he did have a his own there's no problem selling it even since they never split up the property officially he had no right to sell the property before therefore want to say this is the that we learned that's what he's saying that the has no in the portion before and therefore a cannot be on all that was he was a and he went and he split up he had a basket full of peppers and he split it up he didn't take extra portion [Applause] sounds like that like we just said that the and therefore you went by splitting up this basket of peppers your and everything we're talking about that says he wants to say he's not going to get a double portion or another case he says I want one of my sons shouldn't get any since he's using and the clearly we have a say the tells us that all the brothers have to get the father's portion you have no right to go against the however again we're talking about that he doesn't need a because he he says I want Ru to get 80% of the and I want Chim to get 20% and Le I feel bad I'm not willing he's not going to have anything left or he says the is gonna end up only getting 50% and the reason why is that he's not going against the ti the has and you want to know if he's going to beish the kids unfortunately there's nothing left to beish because it's like a person going and gives right before his death that's that's what we do today when people PR people in the rights when they have daughters Etc they make sure we do it today we make sure that we give it a Matana a second before he dies Etc the point being that the kids are there's nothing left to be however again because he's going against the whether the way he words it as long as he puts in a the word of mat that he's given us mat and the is going to explain what the case is clearly it's not be like why we know a person has a right as long as it's m involved regarding money has a right to go against we're going to see regarding K to go against what the says if a person walks over to is and he says which is that he has to give what he has to give clothing and the clearly says that a husband has to give these three things therefore it's not going to be he still has to give it however clearly see regarding the a person has has a to throws in regarding the which that she's not but regarding the money we seey that's we're discussing which is money so and our understanding is if so cannot be like and more than that we know we like so that says you could say like why you're right here we're talking about the is you're approaching asking you know what I'm willing to get married but I don't want to give you so that she's will to be she has a choice and with know she wants to marry him she's willing to be M does that make sense here you think that you think the father asked the son are you willing to be your portion not there's no chance in the world that the son says I don't want to get to so therefore you can't compare the case of Kad to our scenario where the son is not willing to be m person gets up and he says a person gets up and he says is the and therefore he's going to get double portion what happens if he says is pling just the words now to clarify it's very possible even today you see it with second marriages Etc that there's a very s simple concept of a person being the to who just to the mother if the father was married before and had a daughter or had a son doesn't make a difference and then gets remarried to a A pulo or someone who never had children the first kid as long as it's going to be a b however it's only but not to the father and then is clearly is to get or not so however he just says my son this person is the very coming out of him saying that it's a himself says I know guy comes says I know that this person is I guess hand he want to know if he gets a double portion how do you know that he's he says the father would go and say maybe means from the mother why the reason is theone from a mother we only we call it we call it the now not a of crazy rather of uncomplete and says we have a similar concept is not complete missing stuff not let's be real only from the mother is that complete is from the mother from the father therefore he's saying to tell you you're Complete because you're only a from the mother not from the father know he's how do you know do you know how I know when show up to the father what happened was people had issues with their eyes when you see something fascinating he would say go to my son now it's interesting we brings down we saw himself had a son and he died why the cuts he cuts he cut a tree before it time and he died we learned that in the bottom however it's not the same son someone else there was a person he would say go to my son he's the let him put a saliva in your eyes and it's going to heal him so the more question how do you know he's from the father just by saying go put it in your eyes answers we have a tradition which means to say something fascinating it may be a little hard to understand we have a tradition that the saliva only from the B of A father could heal um issues with the eyes Okay quite fascinating however if a bear from the mother cannot heal on this issue we're going to go through we're going to go through a quite extensive Su of t t dragonus tum is something is is a person that's born B we don't know if it's a a c because the is in the G and it was never was never yet so what's no knew and the came out now there's no there's no in the world that it's it's a now we're talking about we're talking about a the case talking about a now this T when he gets old and the father dies he's saying I want to get double portion he doesn't get it why says since it says in the we're learning from the which is extra until when it was born we had to know for 100% certainty that this was a is gonna apply which is a for this notna have we all know he ends up doing he doesn't listen to his father Etc we kill him so to over here he's not going to have we're learning that is the second we have another we're not regarding the's portion we're not going to consider this as a person explains for example let's say you have $900 so how you going to split it the is we're going to put the T aside regarding the portion of the therefore thear is going to get $300 just like a typical when it's only ruen a shim at of $900 is's going to get 300 for the we're left with what we're left with $600 that $600 we split it with the tum he comes back in therefore comes at 200 so he's going to come out that thear in such a scenario he's going to end up with $500 out of the 900 what's the difference if let's just make the if we would count the so you would have to go what you'd have to take 900 divide into which is 225 it comes out the b is going to get 450 and everyone's going to get 225 so is really in such a case 900 is $50 let's say in the case is going to get 450 instead of 500 he's going to get 500 such a case again why since it says in the again we're learning we have another now on my ready the fourth concept of we all know we all know we do a br it doesn't make a difference even if it comes in again we're playing with the this is the fourth which is the fth then he has 33 days and the is the opposite there's a that 14 days however has a of 66 days however he wants to say he's not going to have because it's a we don't know what he had was it a you can't tell me yes was it you can't tell me yes therefore doesn't have Tas later we're going to see in a moment what what he might have a certain t we might go again we clearly say someone who has a miscarriage or is that it's that has both in such a case it says clearly that has not only has a we have to go we had to say that you have to 14 days and you only like a so if you make the it's going to come out 40 days minus 14 that it was because you're going the you can end up with only 26 days of K opposed to either 33 or 66 says regarding no we had a between you're right so regarding you're gonna tell me you're G to do that's why we don't do the bris same thing with and we go however said clearly that he doesn't have a what happened to maybe wasn't a real if wasn't a what is she she's you're right and the reason why we don't say it's a why because you could change it and say Yes throw in the word you could put it in we're going to show us a RI of that told us that is not going to get a double portion since it says Ben not a and it can be a we just understand who you coming to tell us otherwise that says you know why it's coming you have two ladies in a cave in a cave and now you don't know they both had kids they're both coming from the same husband the sh is who's the so the is which means to say is you had Ru you had ra and they both had they both had a kid now and then the later on gener later on they had more kids so the two brothers all the other brothers ganged up against the two brothers and said you guys none of you are the B you have to go prove it and therefore we're going to take that extra portion and split it with everyone and there these the sh is whether it's Ru or shim it's only those two that have so you know what you should do for yourself you two gang up you two write our which is if I'm then give me you're gonna tell me I'm not the the brother's the but the brother wrote me that he's G me a to be for him like that they both they should so that we're coming to exclude to tell us in such a case you cannot do that since no who the is I have an issue with what you're saying why only when there was a time where R we all knew at the time the ru was and then it got confusing however your case he wasn't he wasn't putting his you know anything he the one who repeats what he says and he says I made a mistake I apologize is not like what I said however why however they did say however it's was the scenario I said early you could it's not true what is we all know that he was the now says what's it mean and they were there they know he's there's no sh about it rather like we said that he called him my son the later on the father side he says no not R Rather somebody else he believe the father what against so he s him back he says what the what they should do in such a case is stay out of it and that's why we're going to see these two what he holds like then hold like he wasn't sure to say therefore he said right what is we say the says the says why does it say in theah which is extra that the father has and to say this is not the Rather somebody else and more than that there says it could come out that he's even mighty he's even saying for example to make it easy to understand what happens you have a family of five five boys there's no shil about it the oldest is 30 years old and the youngest is four years old imagine the father pulls up to the house when they says I hate to break it to you you know who the B is my B the youngest his Essence he's saying that b is M he's not only that he's saying all the older brothers are M that's what is coming out in such a cas he's able to say he married his wife after they got divorced and therefore my kids are however this was wasn't sure we understand that's why we to tell us that he's believed that's answer says for example they pull up the town no one knows who's the no one knows anything the father's Bel they say we're not against when who is so why do we need you need to come tell you that he's to tell us that he get dou why should he be different than anybody a he easily could have said I wanted him to get a double I want to give whoever I want to give it to so what is the case my answerers like we're talking about that fell after he said he's so therefore a person that's why ACC it should work then why need we back to square one and says talking about and is what even that says is only if he's able to do it a person that cannot do it physically then what is we know he's not comes at the like what is person gets up and he says this is my son this person is my son and then later on he retracts says no wasn't my son is gonna explain however if he said it the opposite first he says this is my slave this is my son then he is why I meant to say my I meant to say is he's such a good son you would think he's a slave he Mish takes care of me like an EV however it's the exact is the exact opposite by why if it's an evid you have to pay taxes if it's a son you don't pay taxes so imagine a person pulls up to the taxes and he says this is my EV and it's really a son you got to be crazy to do that now you have to pay taxes it's very possible that he's your evid really is your evid and the reason why he calling him is a son to evade taxes that's why however you say you gotta be crazy then ask person m is treating like a son doing all the stuff son so this is not fair the is right here says a person question is we just said moments ago in such a says there it's different this case we this he calls him an that's like a boundaries of what's he say when a person says this guy is worth to me only like a 100 bucks by talking such a by putting a number that a person will never do for his son a son doesn't have a number was really is EV is going to send seven different and the reason why we're mentioning this is says because one of them which is going to be the fifth case which is we it's going to be coming for that she to tell us therefore is going to send seven different let's jump right into let's go through the first one a person tells his friend you stole my slave I didn't steal I don't know what you're talking about he says what's it doing by you so he answers him back you sold it to me or another option he says is you gave this to me as a even though we all know we learned in the beginning of animals in do not have the reason is because they can move gives two options either that we said over there either we're talking about we're not talking about Al he already doesn't we're talking about which does have that's option A or talking about a newborn which cannot move in the was ready over there since ever that's a newborn cannot move that's a baby that has a so in such a case there's no about it he's however he was you know what he tells this this person who 's saying if you want if you want go make a now more than that first of all you don't make a evidence and now that whenever a person does make a the makes the here he gave him a double he says make a sure if you would like now make a after the guy makes even before a person is not allowed to say no I was kidding around with you no such a thing the second you gave up your able to make's able to give up we have this now father is not to be a but he says I want my father your father in the in the case I trust him we all know shepher and therefore they're not in but he says you know what let's bring them in very nice we clearly see like so what iss there's a big difference the case over there in our case the case over there what is he doing he just being he's saying you know what I could have a that he's a and since he's there for the apostles I'm giving up I'm giving up over here in our he's willing to tell the he's he's telling him not only am not not only you don't you don't have to not only you don't make a to give you to make and you'll do that's even in such a scenar could work and is like that is the first case thata sent let's go through the second case what is can can a person take away now the reason the is that a person wants to say the is going to say and just like you could take away says come on it could be from today till tomorrow what is the concept of the reason why knows he can take a property what's the M Property cuz doesn't move and evid you could go to any country and you want and sell it get rid of it therefore it's not going to work we're going to see later on that thear is going to say since we all know we're going to change this gear this second case we're going to get back to it that no one holds of the [Applause] third is to make it easier to make it very clear to understand it's a first cousin once removed very simple you have three generations so you're ready if you put ruen shim and then you go down three generations you're really in essence a second cousin a Shen would be a a first cousin once removed and then another generation will be a great uncle and then when you come to your side it's grandfather father and you so here we're talking about means a a first cousin once removed even going up which is what a great uncle was he would even say a grandfather however we all know is not like why that that a person is never never why can never be made therefore and we're going to see this very clearly we're going to go back to this this case next case on the fourth case person knows regarding a testimony before he became blind and now he's why because you cannot give testimony argues right that he's blind today but when he saw the when he saw the AIS that he wants to test he's going back in his memory and therefore he could use landmarks Etc he might when it comes to clothing you're able to tell exactly the length and the width of a suit that take speciala you can't say he would have know it without seeing it aasa regarding a gold or silver bar Li because that's normal normal papa says no imagine a person comes and says this bar is 1.83 grams am I you no you were there at the time you put on a scale we're going to ask say that is even though you're today you could go back since you saw it at the time a person who became a sonla a person was normal became right here ready let's see the however he became a son of law so now he's POS before he was a son of law he was not POS now he's P now he's not there's no kids let say to make it easier or the point is you had a three you were blind you were normal you became a came back to normal you were able to see you became blind you're back to see the point is there's a middle before the before there's a period in your life where you would be pu all those cases or why the point is right now today doesn't make a difference if you had what we call a bad stage in your life today you're good then you were good everything's fine it's a bomb anybody all they all said in such a how could that be we clearly says over here in such a case we're at the fifth case of and this is why we brought this whole just for this case is gonna explain what is he saying regarding this what is he saying I want to give him who is that we're going to see the that holds a person's able to say son has nothing to do with has zero to do with nothing do could he do it or not's like we just saw earlier he learns that from where from Yak the yak tells me he's able to do that even against we said even saying the brothers we brought all these cases however didn't stop he brought another two cases I want my wife to get like one of the sons since he's given be has today there also going to be a for the wife why because what is if the wife has more has more kids so since the B let's say whenever there's only two kids and you're splitting it up there's much more money if you splitting it up with 10 kids and she's considered only one portion she's going to get much less the kids die the last person says ow1 never got anything back so right here typically a regular scenario of what we all know however the problem over here is what gets a little sticky is there's however from could only get you could only get from We're relying therefore you can get half and only so let's just give a little context to understand what's going on is a person's walking in over here walking in in chers and he finds a wallet and the is he picks it up he sees a license he gives it back and the guy says what's going on I had $1,000 I only see 500 is he's part even though in essence he's might there that he took it and he's only paying back 500 the reason is Tak we said we want people to return therefore he's not that is the however more than that we have is as follows what is when two people are holding it's the beginning of a person has a now it says in thear a plural now the minimum of plural is two so in essence he's really holding on to AAR that says you owe me $2 now the the Mal says you owe me5 which the just says plural doesn't say anything now the could have stayed quiet and he would have been only two because that's what thear says however he says three so the sh comes how do we look at that extra dollar is he a because he could have stayed quiet or no he's a regular so over there and says you like argues and says no therefore you are even like over there that says the beginning that's there's no are just testifying on the bottom they're not really they're not really giving knew the was that there involved now the the B say they subpena them to come now the B the Mal B the Le no one really knew who the a going to go with are they going to defend the Le or they going to defend the Mal so since this guy's getting scared he's saying wait a second there's aam invol maybe the a are going to go against me therefore he said three that's why or that's why he said half and that's why he's that says there's no whatsoever here's understanding not like this he's not saying he's not saying we're not we're not we weren't worried that he's going to come against all these seven is like what I have a problem with the second case we saw the second case was regarding if you could be that in reality let's be real it says no the problem is he tell me like how could that be we you have to say there is you read it that there's no in that second case rather everyone holds you're not and the reason why you're not is why is because let's be real a person does not think that he's going to get the from the ever because the guy could just disappear with it and you read it also agrees to that so you come to tell us is like like who why would you think otherwise so if you're coming to tell us which was which was the case of the which was the third case that we said that the first cousin once removed ra went extreme ra said even a great uncle we saw says even a grandfather maybe just he's not arguing maybe himself would be might that he could testify by a great uncle the reason why he says um first cousin want your can come tell me says a grandfather that we already said over there so your third case is out gon to come try to tell me the fourth case which we said all the three cases in a scenario where there was a time right now you're blind We Ready Set there we knocked it out clearly in the top of the top of going to come at the fifth case that we had the fifth case that we saw which was what you wanted to tell us that is like who like dismiss was Tiny saying maybe a scared maybe not scared that we saying a person is not a Persona is scared that's why there's no of okay the two dos us clearly said in such a case as long as it's not a and as long as you put it's gonna win and it doesn't make a difference so right away more questions now it's a little we have to H Cup a little because me three different she really four but we're gonna have name we're gonna have and then we're GNA have in the name then we're G have so let's hold over here this is when a person says again I'm saying I want to give and he should be I want to be to and I want give it and give it them he says I want to be to in this field and give it them and however hold when it's one person it's regarding one F let's say I want to use a differentness with two different fields or one field but ruing half the field you get as a present and the other half I so again is very very one person one field even two Fields as long as it's one person or or it's one field even those two people that is it's going to work two separate cases M two fields and now when came to B and he said was went extreme he says it's he says if a person says I want to give this F so this is a case of let's be clear this is a case of even that's that's however in such a case according to he learned this context of so according to is the most he even it's going to work you made one thing easy one thing why I could get out of it very quickly talking about however this in the second case which is and that he clearly says the problem is more than that double because over there is the one that's going to the opposite extreme according to answers on how extreme those they're opposites according to is the most according to is the most M now we have the which a person not we're talking about the only time it could work when it's this is what he's saying so it's already throws in this field the only time it could work when he puts two L of yusha and two L of mat like that we can connect it to since they're separate the only way it could work is a r and and have nothing to do with each other therefore the only work with twice however if you only have for example you say and then you only say what's goingon to happen is we're going to say the is we're gonna only say the case is going to be that is going to get therefore the only way to be kind of is in a scenario where you say I want it to be field that I gave them which is the is going on one foru and one therefore you using for both for and which is a that's why it's going to work however if you say and you should give should be in such a case it's not going to work since it's two separate people two separate in such a case it's not going to work we already have see with the which is it's gonna work extreme which is who is is it's going to work which isas according to again this is quite complex toas again this is only a on Friday we did this quite quite extensively the three Shas because it's quite confusing it's really fouras again you have we have but that itself is and again according to is the most then we have according to which is is somewhere in between 21 is going to work however 22 is not going to work and then we have R in the name of which is the that's going to be a double two two is going to work again for who and then we have which is quite complex that you need to have two of and two of mat for both of them in a case which it's a two two in order to work I know work we have a say person says I want to give my doesn't mean rather for a week he wants to give his kid a dollar a week to live on today it's inflation no chance you're living on this is he needs double you have to give them double however don't give them more than a dollar and that we only give a says we don't hold like this do we give them what they need to live the reason why he's being tough was tough love he want them go out to work go go hustle a little go make your own money however so now let's be clear in this case what is he really doing he's giving him he's giving over here where he's giv to his sons and then he's giving to somebody else it's m which is also to be a to is so you know what we're talking about the reason why he's saying to myself but I don't want my my of having a you're not going to ask him answer you we're talking not because of the reason why it works is because they were and like who which you all know now we're gonna bring a if a person says which I'm give you the so in this case is because again you're giving the first person the second person and it's two different fields and it clearly says you are going to tell me like what we tried saying earlier there himself self defended his friends me that can't be in this case why why is when when the second person dies the third person gets it that can't be this Cas is not goingon to stop you can't tell me the case is Roy we have walk with like who like be says that can be explains this is one of the cases answer three or four words the point is if it's however it's going to come out whenever person is from his mouth two things we don't say that he retracted what he said rather it's like we say that he meant both and whatever sticks sticks so therefore if a person says a person says we split it because we could say to both of them now what happens one of them could be tyus one of them cannot be tyus for example when a person says which is notus is we're going to go with and what happens if it's a we already learned to B do we say however if a person's very clear and he says I'm retracting what I said that's not a that everyone holds however what was saying there are two scenarios we don't say that my person when he says I want this tree to be to and then immediately retracts even though we say has a tells us even should be we say we say it is going to be pule and a person goes over goes says I want to marry you XYZ I'm going to give you this he says you know what I'm is since we're talking about we're worried that there's going to be lies on the kids they're going to say that was really married therefore because of that we say she has only that she needs to go over to the person that said this and get a get the last the Miss on the top person gets up and he says I want I want my brother to be Irish I don't want my daughters to be Irish or [Applause] however that's the stand so right away the questions you tell me my brother instead of his daughter a son with all the sons or daughter with all the daughters so that that's basically which is so how you understand the what is the difference between would hold even a brother instead of a daughter that can be says with the words what do they really so again we're back to square one what is is arguing they areu even in such a case the way to easy the easy way out to really understand the this is how you read the I want my brother to be in the sne with his daughters or a daughter with all the other daughters why is this so that's the easy way out that comes out that the and then we have really another we saw earlier able to go over and say I want to be everything and us that says in the now we already saw the says you have a power to be to give somebody else now the should have easily just said as said the day that the son why does it put it with the father says we already learned this that says that you can't give the to somebody else however the you could give you can give it says is it say he says you would have said like we know we all know what's the between a and a is that a is even so therefore should be able to give up the why I need the second you make so comes out there we needed both why because tells me cannot give over the why would I think otherwise because I can give over the why could I give over the I can't go on that since we have come to tell us both things that you're able to do that regarding the you cannot regarding a p you could even though you would have a h enough to think otherwise since the p has extra Milo he's saying that so what's it mean one says one says so what's the difference between the one says is better when a person says I saw it's much better is better now what's the the and there mil and there are to the mil of AA is that when when it comes we all say when it comesa when a lot of times someone tries to ask a the second he hears it's hypothetical he doesn't want to give an answer when it'sa you're going so that's a then there then there's a because it's very possible that the reason why the ra pasin that this mice is good is very possible you didn't know the entire story it's very possible let's say now that he really used somewhere and you didn't understand that you didn't realize that so each one has a love either either by or that's the which one do we say until you hear the words what you could go do the so what's the whole entire is what this we learn from each other is a very important point that you can't say is very possible where you see where you could say that there's a wound over there be in a different animal different place even though it's the same place you can say why I'll prove it to you exactly where would be should we do it don't do it I and he tells him as follows when when something comes up that says I pass XYZ and you want to argue you want to say no I don't like how you pass don't rip it up go I'll come [Music] if I have a why I like that I'll tell you I don't have a problem I don't have a problem saying I made a mistake however after I die don't rip it up you can't learn from it why you can't rip it up have said something to you and don't learn from there the says for example where a person comes with the don't start saying if and and the person came with a few days later where the dime was already yish was already dry don't start coming the D can't start making oh if the person would have came with this immediately and it would have been I would have therefore I'm going to continue next week with