Review the Weekly Daf Yomi Baba Basra Pages 116 to 123 Weekly Shiur at Scheiner's Shul

okay good morning everybody we are going to pick up from the Mish we're going to try to get all the way till this week we're going to be discussing a lot about and so let's jump right into the mishna the daughters of they ended up getting three different we're going to see there's even more than that there's four some say five but the what did they get we're going to see that the m is going like the T of holes is the people that left another they got now's father was now died we're going to see that the wereing to they should get the from they learn it from they said there would have been now that there's no so that was their end up getting the three the first was the because he left another was was the therefore he's going to get so our Mish is telling us in every piece the is going to say that there was an uncle that the B also were and the reason why our told us these three things is to bring three one is another is a daughter of a son has the same as a son therefore they get Y and the brothers and the third is even though he doesn't get was considered therefore they got P now the whole reason why we even mention says because we learned comes before the brothers therefore this is that wanted to come before the brothers to get their fathers let's jump right into going how do we know this since it says in the after the sensus of say we should give it to these people that left what does it say the over there it says little ear says just like when you see when you go through the if you look through the Sens the only people that we mentioned in the T that we counted was only soone 20 and above so too to tell us that in this scenario that if you were you were 20 years old that's when you get a that's when you get a otherwise you no in the land that is the second is the people they're the ones who got the clearly that the people and right after the sentence right after it says that that were th000 Etc that's when it says okay do say why does it say that in the this is different than any other in the every the the way it works is is's father when he's so is however here work over here the people that were nft there were says he explains for example yeah let's say Ruben and shim left the land one Ruben had 10 Sons shim had one son now they got they both got so they both got so one family got 10 the family with 10 Sons got each son got a portion and the other one got one however what happened is since the other P comes to tell us that you go back up the so the Z is aish the Father's aish now that the father's AA comes back down as a yusha so what happens is you end up taking all the pieces of the pie throwing it back to the father and then coming right back in return however the pie ended up getting split from 10 pieces in one from 11 it comes out the son that had one is going to get five and a half and the 10 sons are going to split they have to split all the other five and a half and I'll give you an example so it's very interesting that says they made a so you have to know there no he brings from the that we going to say this why because we have therefore we're gonna have to say that that's the have two brothers one is one son one has two sons they go to pick up the however but since he sent them and there was a t that they're going to split it what do they do you look at the the grandfathers now we're have a third and he's not handing has nothing to do with rather they both whether you left then you got whether you came now so comes that there's another she with and that's why if you look with this that's why if you started the says not that like our could also go as long as you have a as long as you hold if you left again you have to be 20 years old let's say not practical really to say that you were survived the midbar and you were that old cuz most most of them died does bring up shot that you could be talking about someone who's older than 60 he says doesn't like that rather is he want to say that for example Ruben had a s that he was 20 years old when he left MIT and he was a Ben he was 20 years old when he left has and then in the midbar he had kids and then he was n so the kids in the midbar father as that's one one and they themselves now that they already over 20 years old when they they're going to also get a regarding the mirag even though they had sons that came at they all died the Mir we all know however their sons did not get the of theim rather what happened with there yeshu with the last two spies they were the ones who ended up getting the what about theing them the people that complain the people that 250 with people that with rather their sons only their father's father their maternal grandfather now again this m going like what like the now that we have the we could be going like that says when it says in the maybe it's going you know what me nothing to do with how know we're talking about on that says in which is a which is this is in the beginning of promis they to get so it's clear we have a that are going to get in the land s we have a Simon we're going to see six different there is going to ask we have we're going to see with also the that complain the first according to or you could say could say then we understand is going to be in a case for example the person left with 10 sons and then by time he got into he only had five so comes out he left with five so each son got a piece and then they ended up with other way sorry they left with 10 they end up with 10 portions they only end up with five coming into they divided the 10 portions into five which ended up being much higher then we can understand you left when you were five you only got five portions but by the time you pulled up the so the you had what you had 10 you ended up having to split it that's what it means we don't know how to explain it this P now you can't tell us that maybe it's going to be telling us in a scenario we could have we explained on where you have we gave this exact case that it goes up and then it comes back down so it could have the says you can't you don't need that already says no need a to tell us that second that's why the daughters of had it makes sense the father left what what no never never so what is the he didn't get so how do we understand it talking about you're going to tell us the cas you could explain that the is which is the the grandfather he had a and then what it went down left let's just give an example let's say had 10 Sons had eight Sons five Sons six Sons whatever the number is he left with a certain amount of sons now the sons was we're going to see there was also uncles that died but was the other Sons let's say five Sons entered those five sons that entered they all got a piece of but since we hold thear those five Sons ends up bringing it to who the now has those five pieces those five portions let and therefore that was the of the what happened to they ended up growing very quickly their shave it the beginning they were when they left there were 32,200 and they all the way climbed all the way to 52,700 if you look at theim it's a very high percentage of that they ended up going much higher much more people they were complaining they said we should get a bigger piece it say why are you giving us such a piece like everybody else why they why they complaining if anything right now they're much more than everybody else and each one that enters the land is going to get a piece k answers very nice when every population grows there those of people that are not 20 years old and they didn't have a father therefore that was the of the here learn there was no one that didn't get a portion if there was T who didn't get a por should have complained going to tell me maybe there was a that someone complain we see where they ended up ended up listening to them that's what it writes in it can be complain and there the mentions it so you see even though a person didn't get anything out of it the T still mentions it there was no one that could complain says no the reason why it says because there was Yeshua answered him Yeshua said I can't give you more I'm not going to steal from the other I can't do that however I can give you give should be careful from go hide yourself in the forest go sent to on a basic side we learned in we wanted to say the reason why what's so bad about can't give somebody while it's causing so on that we see that it was only that he told them shouldn't have so what did they answer answered we are from that doesn't have like it says in the the Charming son rather they go above the and therefore the the is not in them says in the we all know by like there's no control again that they don't have we said ear in the what happened with the not that the sons didn't get it rather IM how do we know this maybe you're right maybe they the sons didn't get it but it got split it got divided into the pool of rest all you know what the say instead of going into the pool of rather K ended up getting K and the what yes ended up getting the the brce mentioned earlier when it said early we understood the what very simple and left and went into the pool of here it's saying very clearly if you hold you make a just like the person doesn't make a he into the pool of what happened this is what learning what is this is these are the people when it says one wants to say since it's all the same therefore you can make a what the he from the misl of just like the got it explains doesn't say therefore they didn't make the people that hold going to tell me that all the ended up going to everyone's brings a case whole ended up being certain degree so what a mean we know didn't get such a big in in the land when I said I didn't mean the the 250 people that were with it's interesting that we bring it down we're going back to the now we're going back it says it says ended up with 10 what's the T the if you look at the it says in the very clearly there was six families which is the B so there six and the four we know the three in the Mna we're going to see an uncle you only have eight because you don't have you only have we only have the which is three three plus the six by the office tell me there was there was an uncle we didn't mention it we said with the reason why we didn't mention because there's nothing to do with the that we're learning I'll tell you that there was two uncles like it says in the what said to do however and the one who holds those two unes they learned it says it could have just said however the does say that the didn't want to learn he just learned it's not you don't he wasn't which is the six Simon that we had what is the P talking about when we're saying it says that all the brothers got it what are we handling if we're counting everybody even the is much more and why are we mentioning why are we mentionings we know there's only six we're talking about and the reason why we're mentioning we telling us to learn from there that what like we said in the from the second they left even though they never had it we said earlier that we're talking about the son you have to learn got it only because of the grandfathers that's what it means that they got their own go depends the only way you were able to get it is by going with the and we could say this just to bring out that when it says even though you can say from the ra we're going to learn that it says earlier we could say it's G like with both okay we said he was got talking going to learn so how in the world did they get it we're talking about not talking about they got it that's the point because says the reason why he said he say this which is a Pex for the tents everyone had tents therefore they mention it it says we all know we always measure with he should have used the different ones in the winter the summer the reason is when it says the second we gave the it's like we already have it and therefore you have a we're going to see the Kash is really old at the end of the BR Bas we're going through a lengthy Bry that's going to ask this k us on the when you look at the two things we see first you know what it's a good and let me go ask them he didn't have a sh he knew that that they're like a son okay more than that you can learn it from the second says wasn't sure he wasn't sure about not and that we said that they get if you look atash inash that they were like that they cherished that was another the it says wasn't sure of which is more than maybe she just should just write it continue to leave over your is going into your kids it's not going out that's which is which is more person rather dies than getting Stone now this is the was the what's the getting doubl answer is no that was the do we know now today only because what because asked what should we do regarding the said yeah give it from to give over and is to get which is that he already has it however we see we say this every day you will you will bring them and you will implant them theage the says say they didn't even realize that they were saying interesting that what they're not going to ever be enter the land says in the we're talking about the says in the the five girls went in front first they went to know what to say so what they continued on you have to read the no read who did they first go to they first went to the then they went to then they went to then they went to and says you know why the the says it this way because we want that's why it says even though in reality MAA was the last person that the approached that's they're all sitting together everybody so what's which is therefore they went everybody only after that no choice they went to my answer is no whenever you see when when when a rabi gives you know K he gives he let's oh ask my talid let's see what the talid has what to say so in such a case in that type of scenario you could give what do we do we said we have a br that says they were saying they were very shrewd we're going to see they knew when to speak up saying they knew how to learn and they knew exactly when to give a you look the so then they popped up and they said if we're like a son that's why our mother's not doing however if not what happened that's how we know how do we know we learned this in the beginning of the par how do we know that comes before it says says in the which is they knew that the only time the only time they're asking is because they knew this said there's no son it says we have a says you have to erase this and more than that the says very interesting says that didn't know how to explain this even if we would have had a brother would have left over a daughter we wouldn't have spoke how do we know they waited to marry the the people that were even they were able to marry other all the other still they waited till they found someone that's very them even the youngest daughter they had to wait years and years decades till they found their riper shirt if a person gets married under 20 she could give birth or child bearing or child years until we're she could give she could have children till 60 years old if she gets married once she's 20 gets married after 40 so Ella how do they how do they end up having kids I'm like since there were that they're doing the right thing was 130 years old says the we're talking about the second time around where he ended up marrying the which we know why we call if you go through the she's 130 goes by we all know was 210 years and she was born we're going to see that later she was born M the entrance of MIT Anda was how olda was 80 years old when we left so 210 minus 80 is 130 so we clearly see that she was 130 years old theas what what he say when when we had earlier we're going to see that we had a sh later where if you look at the cloud it says 70 the names however if you look at the pr it's 69 so who is this was so that's how we know clearly she was 130 years old so then we're going back so she ended up coming young again her skin became tender wrinkles went away we're talking about the second marriage when she went right back a brand new marriage he put it like what we have today by in the college here they were singing away they all Rejoice mother of the sons all Rejoice now they some want to say that the reason why they were singing they so happy if you look at the when we're talking about the marriage of you clearly see it says and it says that make sense to say that that's how were they were all was based on the age because in those days especially a person married based on age you waited till the older one got married however they that's when you go he has to be the has not just a tiny bit that's it can't just be that you're a little older than them say the why say they became to tell us that they all equal they were able to marry everyone only to do thats and then it says so it's very clearly that it says who you know why it say it's coming to us for example the bottom head however like for example clearly says you have to read it that when it says it's not going on where we coming from to say this that the this is talking about in that D only had this says in the that's also tell says the since over there it says regarding it says know they have they we're going to make just like by Forest just like over there it says here we're going to learn it so why don't we say by we don't say be we're gonna see in a second why we will know who therefore we clearly learn that it's for that door so what is the regarding it says what's the point of saying this it's good enough SS like clearly they need a not just a we're going to see later over here if it's if it's a it's even just like there's a that but he goes to the is him comes out because he never really did says a case for example person says if a white CH let's say a white CH is going to come out it's going to be hegdish comes out of the room came out of black there's a sh if it's or not says it's says it's not they learn so what is he going to do going to learn us which ising with finger he gonna do with that which means this say is the betweenin and a husband is that a bzden what they do is when a person says a NE we have to say if you would have known XYZ what do you mean that he says no way that's what we're doing is we're making it permitted however has a right to just nullify her his wife's NE so the difference is he has to be that we're playing with the words that the B has to make sure to say and not and again if the says it's not going to work it has to be how deeper has to be a perfect deeper how does he [Applause] know so we're going to see we're going to explain this right now couldn't explain it he went to go look for couldn't find's what are we saying and that answered regarding those days we didn't have a calendar set calendar so the only way to make Y is relying on K however shabas shabas is the seventh day of the week automatically that it's automatic the next this is the we we're talking about when it says it's good enough if he aome we have a that says they it like says even if someone had he made sure to borrow like that no be embarrassed you can understand it's a holy day and therefore they went out try to get married what's the that was the day was the day that we said that that's it that the the that was the day that we said that when we had the why my that happened on now we're going to give a different all different and says that each one had other other things that they learned also happen after no one's going to give their wies the daughters so what do they learn how do they know then men knew however knew so therefore they said it was that did that had stopped it was two B that that was it and they were able to continue going Mars from that every Tish they would all dig a Cav that all go in and every year 15,000 didn't wake up and one Year everyone got up they said oh maybe we're making a wrong they waited until the moon was so and that was the day they realized they were R in the track and it was M however he did he was able to says if he needed to speak he would speak through the and it should have said wants to say that solders blocking so that day was too they stopped it we say theth bodies was a miracle that happened ready gets the summer we stop cutting comes in the son becomes weak you need a strong son to dry out the day that the ax breaks now that the nights are getting long a person should learn now that the nights long we should take the opportunity to learn wow mother's G to bury him soone who takes these winter nights St to do scary stuff is says his mother's going to bury him and he was that they were from that's when they went to do what's say6 people now 36 is somewhat R the it's not a roundabout number we all know need at least [Applause] 36 Like We Know by so on the 20 so over the 60 even though the does say they didn't have the exact same shot but since they were different than 20 to 60 we made now we're have a when we said how is divided was was divided to 12 was it divided every shave got their own doesn't make a difference how big or small the shave it was every person got a little in the land it says in the we're saying now if you're G to tell me that every single person got a what's what's if it goes by we bigger than others so clearly says and therefore we answer the question does throw in why do we need to say this learn we're say because you could learn defitely we're going to see in a moment first the beginning was only we're going to see with money we're going to see a little more exactly how the had a had to pay the difference for example you got the person that got ID had to pay the difference because every wants ID like it say that's how you see is different and the way it's always div so how they div and they had these boxes that a box with all the names of it had to be very important point it had to be D two boxes one and why can't you say oh I'm ruven now it's ruven's turn so let's see where ruven's gonna get it the answer is and then will be says you have to do every single of dividing needs to be a girl so even saying who are we going to decide now is the girl shim so and what's okay so what happened was is gonna come now you grab the box went through this and that each one's going to have himself is going to be the one who's going to give out the portions now what's it clearly say this we're bringing this whole L we clearly see that it was who's going to get that extra go which is the he's the this is what it's saying that the is gonna get maybe just got workers besides you're going to tell me poor poor and good quality portions we're not talking about silly people what you're going to take I'm take ID I also want ID rather whoever was further away from the land from whoever was further away he had to pay with money depends how they PID give more land or pain they didn't have to get it with a girl didn't get it we learned ear they got us know so now that we mention the word sah the before came was M dry it was very bad was delicious in a way in a good way that was juicy and therefore get eventually spoiled you're able to store it for a very long time says was and if was shave we're talking about which means outside the city for his legacy whether a son and a daughter both got we're gonna explain the very Wella what it mean and then however he doesn't get his mother however don't get anything but they get from however they don't get if the mother dies the girls until they get their certain age they're not going to get if you're going to tell me that what if you want to tell me that they're equal this is what we started the per with that is so what in the world are we talking about when the says so the to see all different for all the different names this is what the say whether a son or a daughter night with his no sons and the miss going to be tell us that even even a girl she's also G to get she's also GNA get a likeor we learn so we started with he clearly see even in a case where there's no Sons the daughters Y is just like that that's we started the M with what and then we jump we're talking about a son and daughter what does it mean a scenario where there's no which means a we already learned this you how how you defining ear third going to try to say now what if you have a son or a daughter you have a bunch of sons we're going to learn that if a person wants he could say I want this son to get all my we're going to see a certain that it's going to work like the has be you can't say random neighbor is gonna [Applause] be to tell us oh our that can't be we're going to learn this later then why in the world would I say which is the fin they're both regarding [Applause] regarding we all know it says in the gets double which means to say is when you have with two brothers there's no sh he's going to end up with what 2/3 of the whole CU it's two out of three there only two boys maybe even a scenario where there's five brothers first gets two-thirds in every scenario he's always going to get double of everybody else altogether the same one that what just like he's going to get double he's going to get he's going to end up with two3 get two3 says no go the opposite argument sorry the first is to say just like over there he only gets an extra portion so to this five brothers Letting Go only extra portion and we're saying to say the opposite argument when it's hey he's going to get two3 says in the this why tell us that they also have and therefore it's only G to get one extra portion is going to question why we need more because he was his father's B I'm going to give you one extra portion your brother with the sword with the bone trust I don't rely on my b my sword is not going to help me if we look we brought multiple why do we need gonna tell me that a person could tell us oh I want this everything we're learning from tell us you can't learn it's a different tell us there's no difference says he only got one extra portion maybe just got one little p one little they're going to be against very clear that they got two complete separate portions gonna say very famous what that he gave away says in the his father's bed why did he give it to and says tries to give an answer person person brings an orphan to his house later on in life the comes very wealthy gives all he wants let enjoy him enjoy enjoy the pis of him wouldn't give him anything the knew it's very easy to give someone a present imagine person gives over you comes over you and gives you a nice sh you take you give it to someone you want to give him a little now you're going to give him a little present you're not going to go on your own and go buy him something [Applause] special which is we all know this is one of the most famous so what it me it says in the that the eyes of Le were were soft were tender we all know very famous only the adds another five another eight letters really to tell us doesn't say the words to which is only five that presence were long the continued Generations even though we know by was a king but it never continued don't learn it as by the cross Crossroads in here there's this was the the that is gonna end up with because he's the and Le is gonna end up with after she heard this ha she would ask what's going to be with my future they would answer is's an evil person what about started crying now from the tears and tears that were coming out all the eyebrows fell out what that doesn't make sense what happened that was that he's his father's brother he's the son of the the father sister asked going to marry me however you should be very careful my father my father's a Big R he's not going to let you because the was what's the what's the all say I also know how to deal with such people right away start deceiving people says a person's honest be honest with him stumble knock him down so what did when he married he's going to ask for this and he she not going to know it so she gave over the only in the morning he had to say that maybe the voices were similar enough that when he gave the he was quite confident oh he was relying on the in his head okay was quite confident that it's from a place if you look in the it clearly says it clearly says 70 however if you go through the names s we're learning from the S to tell us had a really he knew he was going to really ask him that he wanted to you know sharpen his brain a little who is this therefore it's not counted why because she wasn't in the VA yet like it says in the when had then what that's when he wanted to go back only then he wanted to go back want to go back then he wanted to go back to be a fire be a flame is going to destroy him like stra says in the we're talking about it says in the as follows from the till the next day and there we're clearly talking about was what so what do we tell what is going to be with we see was with who with with whoever didn't teach says from says again clearly says says from there shim from the sons of shim so you clearly see only then when they had only then they were able to interesting you don't really find such a PK they bring it down over here on the side that there is no such a PK of gets double we all know this we have a with the for leg the jaw the system the jstem that they split the pot I sign it to you con sign it basically you go and make profits and we split it to because they didn't want to do anything everything's automatically so we consider they they bu what's the case of the father already has we're talking about father answer we're talking about his friends always pledged always give it to him when they did it they said I'm giving it to you and he was alive then he died he had a heart attack even though it wasn't separated yet so that's how we understand this what about it's not his my answer is we're talking about we're not we're talking about something like there we're gonna see in a second that it's it's alive when a person in such a case we're talking about which is the scenario is talking about that case that's why it's considered a we're going to continue to pick off from the bottom next week of Base