Rebbi Akiva Eiger's Contradiction Between Tefillin & Tallis: Siman 25 Seif 12; MB DH Special

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay good morning everyone we're continuing yesterday at the end of this year Mandy asked me a really great question and I'm actually proud that the that we're learning it well enough that somebody could ask a question like this and there seems to be a certain inconsistency between so let's review briefly yesterday what we learned in civil base the Macabre said that if you put on fill in many times a day you have to make a bracha every time the Mishra said that is even if when you took it off you had a mind to put it right back on taking it off is a half SEC that's a the Macabre also says if it slips off its place and you move it back you have to make another bracha if you move it out of its place to put it right back you have to make another bracha um however the ramad brings the game that if you move it out of its place you don't have to make another bracha and that's the um that's the Min hug the ram the mission bro explained since you moved it to put it right back on you have to make another bracha as opposed to if it slips off that slips off the Bro the Mitzvah is gone that's why the ramad does not comment on what the Macabre said when it slips off now if you took it off completely to put it on the Rama would also be lenient even if you change the locations however in Mr Bruce um the mission Brewer brings on the halacha that if you're fill in slip off again if you turn slip off even the Ramo would agree that you have to make another bracha the mission Brewer brought the opinion of the shla that it's not our custom nowadays to make abrahawanda twill and slip off why because since it's during davening mrma your name is and it's like taking it off to put it back on again thank you now okay the the Mr Brewer brings the shita of the shla listen very carefully the shita is that even though when it slips off we're even the Rama's opinion is that you make a bracha when you put it back but if it slips off during davening it's like you're not miss and it's like you took it off to put it back again that's what we have by Hillcrest villain let's see if that's consistent with this now it happened to be I was crossing the mission Brewer with somebody yesterday and um we happen to be up to there so it actually worked out for me um so in Simon press Sif you're dalid the Macabre says if you took off your Talus with the mind to put it back again you have to make another bracha that's exactly the makabashita by philan by Phil and the Macabre says if you take it off to put it on again or if you move it to put it back you have to make a bracha that's what the Macabre holds by by thrilling the Macabre is very consistent with what he says you don't make a bracha if you had in mind to put it back on on again that drama is consistent with what he says by Jose yeah if you had a mind to put it on again but then the Rama brings an opinion that we're only lenient when the talus Katan remains on you and the Rama says that's what we follow says the mission bura basically we hold as follows um that holds that were only lenient when you have the tallest cut down that's if you're dyton bestama that's if you didn't think anything so then we say if you have the talus katanan you don't have to make a bracha when you take off the talus Gada however if you had in Das explicitly to put it on again you don't um have to make another bracha so it seems then that the Rama is consistent with what he says that if you have in mind explicitly to put it on again then you don't have to make another bracha likewise that if you explicitly have in mind to put it on again you don't have to make another it's just that if you don't have anything in mind and you're wearing a Talus Katan then you also don't have to make a bracha what about when the talus falls off that if your Talus falls off unintentionally and you put it on you have to make another bracha now I would have said that if you're based on the shla and this was Mendy's Kashi yesterday I would have said based on the shla that if you're a middle of davening we should say it's like you took it off to put it back on the same way the mission of bura brings by Hillcrest fill in that if you if you're filling slip off in the middle of davening you don't have to make another bracha because it's like you took it off to put it on again I would have said by Talus that if you your towels falls off the middle of the ovening then you do not have to make a bracha because it's like you took it off to put it on again and yet we don't find anything of the sort the macabre um says if your house falls off unintentionally and you put it on again you gotta make a bracha the mission Brewer doesn't comment the Mr Brewer asks I but you know if you remove a Talus to put on again in why do you make Abraham here no here at full fell off Beloit the Mitzvah is gone and even if the tiles cotton is on it doesn't help and the Mr Brewer says pashat so I think this is Mommy it's a full-fledged era Why by Hillcrest villain do we say well if your filling moves off your place by the way I apologize for this we'll probably we'll we'll start today's limit in a second just I think it's kadai to get this clear but why buy Hillcrest Thomas do we say if your Talus falls off even in the middle of davening you have to make another bracha and when it comes to filling the mishabura says that if you're still in full off you don't have to make a bracha why would villain be more lenient than Talus and I see the dirt shoe just points out that by the way you should know by doesn't say that there's a difference whether you're middle of the Avenue or not and just okay you want to say what I mean uh I would have thought I would not have necessarily uh thought that right um foreign so I believe I found yesterday I think this is Rubik Vegas Kasha we have Kevin Simmons um in on Sith foreign you put it on again you have to make another bracha um the Muggin of rum comments um foreign so I think it seems like I don't know why the mission of Brewer did not mention this because it seems like rubikivago would say you know what why should Phil Talus be any different than filling and um by Phil and also I think it's not posture that if you're feeling if your Talus falls off you're gonna make another bracha okay so that's what I have for you on yesterday's learning you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com